Datasets:

Languages:
English
ArXiv:
Tags:
code
License:

Reported Action Score in Fig.4 mismatch the formula in the paper

#7
by Yiqin - opened

image.png
According to the formula, when SeqScore_i is 0, it does not contribute to the final result of Action Score.
In another word, the Action Score is only calculate from those matched sequence.
(Action Score + Click Penalty + Key Penalty + Write Penalty) should always equal to 100%.
Those mismatched sequence should not create any penalty.

However, is the evaluation scripts, those mismatch sequence still create penalty. The SeqScore_i > 1 condition is not applied in the code. Thus, (Action Score + Click Penalty + Key Penalty + Write Penalty) is equal to SeqScore instead of 100%, as shown in table.4.

As a result, the reported Action Score can not showcase "how well a code snippet containing the correct action", because the reported Action Score is directly influence by Sequence Score due to the mistake in evaluation scripts.

Sign up or log in to comment