sentence1
stringlengths
15
1.2k
sentence2
stringlengths
46
501k
FBI and DNI Announce Increased Foreign Interference
MILES TAYLOR, CNN CONTRIBUTOR: The bad guys are back and the president and the White House have not done enough in the past few years to deter foreign adversaries from interfering in our democracy, and that's something that Elizabeth and I, when we were at the Department of Homeland Security, we raised with the White House constantly that this needed to be a priority. But because they didn't deter them, we've got more countries in the game, which of course -- it's not just the Russians now, it's the Iranians and we also know the Chinese are interfering. But as you know, the good news here is that this revelation last night shows that the U.S. government has gotten better at uncovering and monitoring these threats in real time, and that's because of enormous investment made by the intelligence community in detecting and disrupting these threats. And the last piece of good news here, of course, is that that it doesn't sound like this is necessarily a threat to election infrastructure. Americans should still feel confident their votes are going to be counted, and counted correctly. However, it is alarming that these nation-states managed to get, you know, ahold of voter registration information. We're not clear on exactly how they got ahold of that information. But at this moment, it seems like they're trying to use it for relatively low-level purposes to dissuade voters from going out rather than attacking the actual infrastructure of voting systems themselves.</s>JIM SCIUTTO, CNN ANCHOR, NEWSROOM: Miles, I'm glad you brought that up. And I want to ask you, Elizabeth, what do we know exactly, right? Because the big fear in 2016 -- beyond disinformation, right -- was that Russia was going to interfere with actual voting systems. And there was that warning from Obama directly to Putin, saying, don't even think about it. We haven't had any such similar warning -- to our knowledge -- from Trump to Putin. What is the level of concern that a Russia or a China or Iran would take that step, mess with voter registration on Election Day, attempt to interfere in counting, even in a small number of counties or districts?</s>ELIZABETH NEUMANN, FORMER ASSISTANT SECRETARY OF HOMELAND SECURITY UNDER PRESIDENT TRUMP: There is a concern there, right? And the lack of clear, forceful pushback on Russia, on Iran, on North Korea and other actors that are attempting to sow seeds of dissent and potentially manipulate the outcome of the election, it does hurt, right? If Trump had chosen to handle things differently in 2017 or 2018, we likely would be seeing a different type of game being played by our foreign adversaries. That said, the men and women in the intelligence community, in the law enforcement community, at DHS and CISA particularly are doing their darndest to try to keep everything safe. And I've spoken with people in the states where the elections are actually housed. I mean, part of what makes this difficult is that it's not just one election, it's not even just 50 elections. Elections are often run by the secretary of a state, but they are administered locally, so you are dealing with any number of various apparatuses and election capabilities, and that's where the vulnerability is. We as a nation need to do a better job of ensuring that our local communities have both the information and the resources they need to protect these elections. So I think they're doing a great job. But I think on the other side of this, there's going to be more resources and more education needed to make sure that we can keep our elections secure in the future.</s>POPPY HARLOW, CNN ANCHOR: Miles, what do you say to folks who are waking up this morning, really confused at how e-mails from a -- you know, meant to come from the Proud Boys, saying, you know, you're in harm's way if you don't vote for the president. How those are meant to damage the president and the fact that that message came from DNI Ratcliffe who, not that long ago, was a member of Congress, very partisan, a conservative who even some Republican senators had questions about confirming, at least the first time around?</s>TAYLOR: Well, I think there are big question marks still. You noted that last night, when the DNI spoke, he said that the Iranian interference was meant to harm Trump. But when the FBI director spoke, you did not hear that message again reflected. So I have a question about whether there's disagreement in the intelligence community on that assessment. But for your average voter, I think really it doesn't matter whether a foreign government's trying to harm or, you know, help Donald Trump with this interference. I think your average voter needs to listen to U.S. authorities, especially the FBI director. Elizabeth and I worked closely with Christopher Wray and his team. He's a man of integrity, and we should believe what he says. And when he says they're undertaking every effort to protect this election, that's true. So Americans should feel like, again, their votes are going to be counted, they will be counted correctly. Go exercise your democratic rights and don't let any of this disinformation fool you. Your mail-in ballot, your in-person ballot, it will be counted and it won't be disrupted by a foreign government.</s>SCIUTTO: Elizabeth, there's been a deliberate effort to equate the threat to the election from Russia and Iran and China by Ratcliffe and others in this administration. You served this administration, you've seen the intelligence. Is that a false equivalency? Who is the biggest threat as a foreign actor?</s>NEUMANN: So I'm going to answer this question based on open-source information, not based on intel that I saw. But we have heard from intelligence officials over the last year that Russia still poses the biggest or has the best capabilities and has been at this game of disinformation for so much longer than China or than Iran. So while we have seen Iran's capabilities increase, as far back as 2017, 2018, you have the cyber-security companies that have come out and assessed some of the connections to disinformation that they've spread, that they have increased their capabilities in the last few years. It still does not match what Russia can do. And on the China pieces, there was some conversation in September when Microsoft released some information about potential disinformation and hacking into campaigns, and there was this equivalency idea that China was actually trying to support Biden. And if you read through the details, what it actually seemed to be saying is that China was doing what China normally does: long-term strategic espionage, trying to understand this (ph) intents (ph) if a Biden administration were to come into play. They want to know what his intents would be towards China. So very, very different type of hacking than election interference hacking that we're seeing out of Russia and Iran.</s>SCIUTTO: Yes. Thanks for clearing it up.</s>HARLOW: Guys -- yes.</s>SCIUTTO: It's important to hear from the folks who know.</s>HARLOW: For sure. And just going to say, so good to have you both, given your previous work on this, this morning. Thanks so much and we'll be right back.
Interview with LabCorp CEO Adam Schechter
HARLOW: Welcome back. So we know the vaccine trials are moving at record speed right now, but do we know for sure how much immunity a vaccine actually gives someone? LabCorp is now launching a new antibody test designed to tell us exactly how effective these vaccines are. Adam Schechter is here, he's chairman and CEO of LabCorp. They're processing over 200,000 COVID-19 tests a day. Thanks for coming on, Adam, good to have you.</s>ADAM SCHECHTER, CHAIRMAN AND CEO, LABCORP: Good morning, Poppy, glad to be here today.</s>HARLOW: So explain how this is going to work, what you're developing that's going to tell us just how much immunity these vaccines actually give us.</s>SCHECHTER: Yes, so there are three types of tests, Poppy. The first one's a PCR test, that's seen as the gold standard to tell if you actually have the disease.</s>HARLOW: Right.</s>SCHECHTER: There's the antigen test, which are the fast-acting tests that you hear about. That also tells you if you currently have the disease. They're faster but not necessarily as accurate. And then there's antibody tests, which tells you if you've had the disease in the past and if your body is able to fight the disease in the future. There's still a lot we don't know about the antibodies. We don't know what level you need for protection, we don't know how long they last, we don't know if somebody has immunity, if that means they'll have immunity forever. So as we go through the vaccine trials, we're going to learn a lot more. And then we'll know what we need to measure exactly. But we have tests for neutralizing antibodies, for total (ph) antibodies, quantitative and qualitative analysis. What we're trying to do is develop a whole series of tests so that wherever it ends up scientifically, we'll be able to help.</s>HARLOW: You know, Adam, people were just so frustrated back in the spring and summer, that it took so long for many people to get their tests back. Our babysitter couldn't come for 14 days because that's how long it took her to get her results. And I'm not saying hers went through LabCorp, but I mean, even you have said, at one point, 14 days is not OK. Your longest wait time, I know, is about 4.5 days. The reason I'm asking is all the experts say the next six to 12 weeks are going to be the darkest period of this pandemic. Are we going to go through that testing lag again?</s>SCHECHTER: So, Poppy, we've been building capacity since the beginning. When we first started back in March, we could do two to 3,000 tests per week. Right now, we can do more than 210,000 tests per day.</s>HARLOW: So it's not going to happen again?</s>SCHECHTER: Partly, we're running (ph) --</s>HARLOW: It's not going to be as bad as it was?</s>SCHECHTER: Well currently, we're running about 125,000 tests a day, so we still have plenty of capacity. But we need people to social distance, to wear masks and to continue to wash their hands. We have to all be in this together. There is -- there are scenarios that we continue to build capacity. But in the flu season, we have to all be trying to minimize the impact of this virus together.</s>HARLOW: Why is it that the rapid tests still are not nearly as accurate as the PCR tests? And is that just a function of science that can't be changed, or is there something that is going to make them, soon, as accurate as the PCR test?</s>SCHECHTER: Yes, the PCR test is seen as the gold standard. It takes very sophisticated equipment. You're searching for the genetic material of the virus through multiple cycles. And you have to do that in a laboratory with that equipment. The point-of-care tests that you're talking about, they'll search for the virus, the protein of the virus. But it's not going through multiple cycles and it doesn't use that sophisticated equipment. So I don't --</s>HARLOW: OK.</s>SCHECHTER: -- it's going to get better, but I do think it serves a very important purpose.</s>HARLOW: Some. But as we saw at the White House with the Rose Garden event, they're not perfect and people were getting tested negative with these rapid tests, and then clearly there was COVID. What about our children? So I take, you know, my kids to the pediatrician and they get that 15-minute flu test. You guys have developed and just put out this three-test (ph). So you test for the flu, you test for RSV, you test -- you can test for COVID at the same time. How widespread and broadly used do you think that is going to be for our kids this fall and winter?</s>SCHECHTER: Yes, so it's already available through physicians' offices. And luckily right now, we're not in the flu season. So we'll have to see when the flu season starts and how bad of a flu season we face. By the way, masks, washing your hands and social distancing also stops the spread of the flu, and everybody should get flu shots if they're eligible. But at the same time, what we have to do is we have to continue to find new innovative ways to get those tests to people. So we have filed with the FDA to try to have an at-home test that you can order to your house with a simple nasal swab, take the test, Federal Express it back to us and we'll test for flu, COVID and RSV together.</s>HARLOW: I would love for you to see me attempting to put a, you know, nasal swab in my daughter's nose. I don't know how well that would go, but it could help families a lot. Final question, you have said it's not going to be another 100 years before we have another pandemic. And you've also been to the White House more than four times, you talk to Admiral Giroir all the time. What is the one thing the federal government could do right now to help you guys on the testing front, to help all of us?</s>SCHECHTER: Yes. What I would say is, the White House Task Force in general, Admiral Giroir has been terrific to work with. And when we needed help in terms of getting supplies, they've been really helpful. What we need to --</s>HARLOW: But what do you need now?</s>SCHECHTER: -- do is prepare -- well right now --</s>HARLOW: Right? Because --</s>SCHECHTER: -- we have to continue to build capacity, and we need everybody to do their part in terms of masks, social distance and washing hands. For the future, I do think we have to think about redundant supply chains. We have to think about stockpiling of materials that we need, and I think we have to continue to think about, in the future, what else would be helpful.</s>HARLOW: OK. Adam Schechter, thank you to you and your team, we appreciate it.</s>SCHECHTER: Thank you, Poppy, nice to see you.</s>HARLOW: We'll be right back.
Barack Obama Joins Campaign Trail.
BARACK OBAMA, FORMER PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: We literally left this White House a pandemic playbook that would have shown them how to respond before the virus reached our shores. They probably used it to, I don't know, prop up a wobbly table somewhere.</s>SCIUTTO: Well, he's back on the campaign trail -- unleashed, you might say -- David Axelrod, here to talk about all this. David, I'm curious, what does the timing of Barack Obama hitting the trail exactly 13 days to Election Day say to you?</s>DAVID AXELROD, CNN SENIOR POLITICAL COMMENTATOR: Well, I think the timing is actually pretty smart because what you didn't want was a long protracted surrogate battle between Barack Obama and Donald Trump when Joe Biden is the leading man on the Democratic side. And what you have now is a situation where Biden has a significant lead, and Obama is coming and adding value where it needs to be added. He's focusing on young people, he's focusing on people of color, constituencies that did not come out for Hillary Clinton, who did not come out for Hillary Clinton in sufficient numbers in 2016. And it's not just his public appearances, but he's pretty active on social media, on networks and channels that reach these voters. So he has a surgical role here that is really important to the Biden campaign.</s>SCIUTTO: With the big goal -- and I want to play another comment from him, talking about on -- already -- a Trump transition. Have a listen, I'll get your reaction.</s>OBAMA: We cannot leave any doubt in this election. Because you know he -- the president's already said if it's even close, I'm going to just make stuff up. He's already started to do it. So we can't have any doubt.</s>SCIUTTO: So in effect, gaming not just for a win but for a big win. And I wonder, you've done a lot of races, some of which haven't turned out as expected. What is your level of confidence that the public polling we're watching accurately reflects the race?</s>AXELROD: I have a high level of confidence, actually, in the polling. Remember, Jim, there's a lot of disquiet about polling in 2016 --</s>SCIUTTO: Yes.</s>AXELROD: -- but the national polls were quite accurate actually. I think the final polls had Hillary Clinton winning by a little more than three points, she won by 2.2 in the popular vote. Joe Biden has a more significant lead of, you know, eight, nine points now. She was less so at this point in the campaign four years ago. If Biden maintains anything close to this lead, it's very hard to see him lose the electoral college. But listen, we -- you know, vigilance would be the word if you were over there in Biden headquarters, because of -- we've seen what's happened. And because this is an extraordinary election, all the mail voting that is being done creates an element of uncertainty. Mail votes are disqualified at larger rates than in-person voting.</s>SCIUTTO: Yes.</s>AXELROD: So there are all these factors that you have to be concerned about. But yes, I have some confidence that Joe Biden has a significant lead right now and is in a very good position going into this debate tonight.</s>SCIUTTO: All right. Well, we'll be watching the debate, we'll be watching the final 12 days. David, I know we'll have you back on. Thanks very much.</s>AXELROD: Looking forward to it, thank you.</s>SCIUTTO: Our special coverage of tonight's final presidential debate, that starts 7:00 Eastern time, only here on</s>CNN. HARLOW: Thanks to all of you for joining us today. We'll try not to look too tired tomorrow morning after the debate. We'll see you then. I'm Poppy Harlow.</s>SCIUTTO: And I'm Jim Sciutto -- coffee works, I think, sometimes --</s>HARLOW: There you go.</s>SCIUTTO: -- NEWSROOM with John King starts right after this.
Ohio Secretary of State Frank LaRose is Interviewed about Elections.
SCIUTTO: Welcome back. More than 41 million Americans have already cast ballots in the presidential election. This shatters early voting turnout records. Joining me now to discuss, Ohio Secretary of State Frank LaRose. Mr. Larose, thanks so much for taking the time this morning.</s>FRANK LAROSE, OHIO SECRETARY OF STATE: Good morning, Jim.</s>SCIUTTO: So more than a million in just Ohio have taken advantage of early voting. I wonder, does early voting in your state favor either party?</s>LAROSE: You know, I don't think it does. But, either way, those aren't numbers I'm tracking. I'll tell you what it does favorite, it favors the democratic process, though, because we've seen double the numbers of voters that we've seen casting previously in 2016 have showed up for early voting, as well as absentee voting in Ohio. And we're just proud to see it.</s>SCIUTTO: No question. It's good news, more people vote. I want to ask you this because federal officials, of course, announced yesterday that both Iran and Russia have obtained U.S. voter information in an effort to interfere in the 2020 election. And I wonder, have you seen evidence of that in Ohio and are you concerned that that might be used to disrupt thing Election Day or in advance of Election Day?</s>LAROSE: Well, we haven't seen recent evidence of anything like that. But, of course, we're constantly vigilant. What I remind our team, and this is a -- a saying I took from the Army is that the -- the bad guys only have to be right once, the good guys and gals have to be right every single day. And that's the kind of vigilance that we bring to it. And so of course this is something that we're always on the lookout for. But, also, Ohio's really been at the tip of the spear in making sure that we're prepared for this. Really starting last year, we used our federal</s>SCIUTTO: You've asked the citizens of Ohio to do two things in advance of this election, to fight back, one, report disinformation and, two, simply to vote. I just wonder, regarding disinformation, because a great deal of its coming from outside the country, but the sad fact is some of it's coming from inside this country. And, unfortunately, the president himself has made unfounded claims about, for instance, the insecurity of mail-in ballots. I wonder, does that make your job more difficult?</s>LAROSE: Oh, sure it does. Anytime somebody's spreading unfounded information about elections, it's something that I have to push back against and speak out against. And -- and I've been very clear about doing that. In Ohio, our absentee voting system is trusted. Its's been trusted by both Republicans and Democrats for close to 20 years. It's a secure and safe way to cast your ballot. And it's -- you know, it's not responsible, no matter who does it, whether it's a foreign adversary or one of our own domestic politicians.</s>SCIUTTO: Understood. The question of poll watchers has come up reportedly. The president has asked his supporters to go out there. But CNN has learned that both Republicans and Democrats are prepared to deploy approved, you know, vetted, trained poll watchers as well to watch things on Election Day. I just wonder, as secretary of state, do you think that's necessary, right, I mean because there are concerns about voter intimidation.</s>LAROSE: Sure. You know, it's always been the right of candidates and parties to nominate elections observers. That's what we call it here in Ohio. And their job is to just observe, really, they can't do much more. It's very tightly defined in Ohio's law. They can't be uniformed. They can't be armed. They can't really interfere with what's going on at the polling location. So, of course, a party, a candidate can nominate an election's observer. That's their right. But more important than poll watchers, we need poll workers still. I mean, you know, if you really want to make a difference and make sure that our laws are being enforced uniformly, get trained and become one of those sworn election officials that actually helps us run the election on Election Day. Sign up at our website, voteohio.gov.</s>SCIUTTO: Before you go, we've had a real emphasis on this broadcast about getting the facts out about voting. Information people need. When they've got to have their mail-in ballot in. You name it. What would you say to voters who are concerned, and understandably, about foreign threats, about disinformation coming from outside the country, inside the country? Can they have confidence their vote will be counted and, two, what should they do to make sure that it is?</s>LAROSE: Well, the answer is, 100 percent, yes. We run better, more accessible, and more secure elections as we speak today in this country and here in Ohio than we ever have before. Every American, every Ohioan should feel confident casting their vote, no matter which method they choose. And, by the way, in Ohio you've got three choices, early voting, absentee voting and, of course, election day in-person voting. And the bottom line in is this, our foreign adversaries want to cause you to distrust our election. Don't let them win. Make sure you vote. That's the bottom line.</s>SCIUTTO: Frank LaRose, thank you for your time this morning. Thank you for your military service as well.</s>LAROSE: Thank you, Jim.</s>HARLOW: All right, well, tonight, President Trump and former Vice President Biden square off. It is the final debate. But will rule changes actually keep this one from going off the rails? We'll see. Our special coverage of tonight's final presidential debate begins at 7:00 Eastern right here on CNN. We'll be right back.
Obama Delivers Scathing Rebuke of Trump in Closing Days
BARACK OBAMA, FORMER PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: He hasn't shown any interest in doing the work or helping anybody but himself and his friends or treating the presidency like a reality show that he can use to get attention. And by the way, even then, his TV ratings are down. So you know that upsets him. Can you imagine if I had a secret Chinese bank account when I was running for re-election? You think FOX News might have been a little concerned about that? They would have called me Beijing Barry. I get that the president wants full credit for the economy he inherited, and zero blame for the pandemic he ignored. But you know what, the job doesn't work that way. Tweeting at the television doesn't fix things. This idea that somehow this White House has done anything but completely screw this up is just not true. Now, he did inherit the longest streak of job growth in American history. But just like everything else he inherited, he messed it up. It has been coming in two weeks for the last 10 years. Where is it? Where is this great plan to replace Obamacare? They've had 10 years to do it. There's no plan. Just like when Russia puts bounties on the heads of our soldiers in Afghanistan, the commander-in-chief can't be missing in action. And with Joe and Kamala at the helm, you're not going to have to think about the crazy things they said every day. You'll be able to go about your lives knowing that the president is not going to retweet conspiracy theories about secret cabals running the world, or that Navy SEALs didn't actually kill bin Laden.</s>KEILAR: Tim Naftali is CNN's presidential historian and a former director of the Nixon Presidential Library. The question, Tim, is will this have an impact 12 days out from the election?</s>TIM NAFTALI, CNN PRESIDENTIAL HISTORIAN: Well, with a combination -- Brianna, with a combination of humor and plain speaking, President Obama actually engaged in a bit of a role reversal with Vice President Biden. Normally, it is the number two on the ticket that launches the indictment on the opposing nominee. And in many ways, President Obama was playing the role of the scrappy vice-presidential candidate while the presidential candidate projects decency and unity. So the speech was remarkable. Its effectiveness? Well, like most everything at this moment of the pandemic election of 2020, it depends. Today, I believe we will cross the threshold of a larger number of people voting early than was the case in 2016. In 2016, by this time, with 12 days to go, about 21 million people had voted. As of the last time I checked, 46.6 million have voted. In total, 47 million Americans voted early last time. So we're about to cross that threshold. That means baked in already are about 46 million votes. I believe the president -- former president's pitch yesterday was to Democratic voters to increase turnout. I don't think he was trying to persuade many people that were on the fence. I think he was persuading people to vote, take the time to vote. It matters. Don't be apathetic. Every vote counts. I believe that was his message. And to some extent, I believe that will affect the turnout.</s>NAFTALI: Will it affect enough? I don't know. But it certainly will affect turnout.</s>KEILAR: Do you think -- I mean, look, the folks that Biden needs to win over are people in the Industrial Belt states that Trump was able to flip from Obama to when Trump ran against Hillary Clinton. Is there any damage that is done by President Obama with those supporters? Is there any vulnerability there?</s>NAFTALI: No. Because those were Obama supporters. Many of those people voted for Obama, then switched to Trump. And he did press the idea of working families. And many of those working families in the Chicago media area. There were people in Iowa who remembered Obama as a scrappy, tough, energetic Senator. I don't think it hurts with those voters. Those voters, by the way, are most attracted by the decency campaign of Vice President Biden. And those are also voters effected by the day to day reality of COVID, not simply the disease but its effect on our economy.</s>KEILAR: All right. Tim, it's great to see you. Tim Naftali, thank you</s>NAFTALI: Thank you, Brianna.</s>KEILAR: Chris Christie, who is recovering from coronavirus, says he is sorry for not wearing a mask at the White House. But he is missing something in this apology. We will roll the tape. Plus, defense say Iran and Russia are interfering in the election and they've obtained the personal information of American voters.
Trump and Biden Face Off in Final Presidential Debate Tonight; Faulty U.S. COVID-19 Response Meant 130,000 to 210,000 Avoidable Deaths; Senate Judiciary Committee Votes on Barrett's Nomination; U.S. Reports More Than 1,000 Coronavirus Deaths on Wednesday.
JIM SCIUTTO, CNN ANCHOR: Very good Thursday morning to you. Twelve days to the election. I'm Jim Sciutto.</s>POPPY HARLOW, CNN ANCHOR: And I'm Poppy Harlow. We're glad you're here. Well, it's a big day today. A final debate tonight, a growing health crisis and a consequential Supreme Court vote today. Also fresh attacks on an election that, as Jim said, just 12 days away. We're following all of it. First, the Senate Judiciary Committee is set to gavel in at any moment and vote to advance the nomination of President Trump's high court pick, Amy Coney Barrett. Republicans pushing ahead despite Democrats' plans to boycott. We're going to take you live to Capitol Hill to see that. And then tonight the debate. A final face-off between President Trump and former vice president Joe Biden. The nation bracing for a fiery debate despite new rules meant to crack down on interruptions. See if it works. This morning early insight into the president's strategy.</s>ALYSSA FARAH, WHITE HOUSE DIRECTOR OF STRATEGIC COMMUNICATIONS: The topics themselves I'd say he's going to answer those topics, but he's also going to frankly answer the questions he wants to.</s>SCIUTTO: All right. All this 12 days before election day and we're learning that Iran and Russia are actively interfering in the 2020 election. Both countries have obtained, and this is key, U.S. voter registration information. And U.S. officials are linking Iran in particular to threatening e-mails sent to voters warning them if they don't vote for Trump they're in trouble. We have the latest on that. And this, a health crisis gripping the nation and getting worse, a new report has slammed the administration's response to the pandemic, saying that that response has led to somewhere between 130,000 and 210,000 deaths that could have been avoided. At least 31 states now seeing a rise in cases and new infections right now. We begin with CNN's Jessica Dean on tonight's final presidential debate. Tell us what the two candidates are hoping to accomplish tonight.</s>JESSICA DEAN, CNN WASHINGTON CORRESPONDENT: Well, Jim and Poppy, as you guys mentioned, there are going to be some rule changes. I'll walk you through those really quickly so we all know what to expect from that this evening. Each candidate is going to be given two minutes of what they're calling uninterrupted time to talk about the subjects at the beginning of each segment. And at that time the opposing candidate's microphone will be turned off. Now after the two-minute remarks there will be a period of what they're calling open discussion. At this point the microphones will be on so we can only imagine how that will go. The topics, again, just to remind everyone what the topics will be tonight, fighting COVID-19, American families, race in America, climate change, national security and leadership. And you can imagine that all of those topics you all just talked about, including these new reports about election interference, will likely be talked about on that debate stage behind me tonight. As for the two candidates themselves, you heard a little bit from President Trump's adviser there about what they're anticipating for tonight. We also know that his advisers have counseled him and told him that this is likely the last time that he can change people's fundamental view of his behavior, especially women and senior voters. Those are key demographics that he's losing ground to, to Biden, where Biden is really making up a lot of ground. They've also told President Trump to cool it down, to not come in as hot as we saw him at that last debate, and he's indicated he wants to do that, but will push back. As for Vice President Biden, guys, we know that he is anticipating personal attacks against himself, against his family, but we can anticipate that as we saw last time they want to be talking -- that Biden really wants to be talking directly to American voters. They want to keep bringing this back to issues. Two key issues they want to keep talking about, the coronavirus pandemic and the economy.</s>HARLOW: OK. Jess, thanks for the reporting. Big, big night ahead. So let's bring in John Avalon, CNN senior political analyst, and Susan Page, Washington bureau chief for "USA Today," who might know a thing or two about the pressure of a day like this. Susan, I bet you're happy that your evening may include sitting on the couch and watching this instead of having to moderate it, which you did a great job at. So what would you ask tonight, Susan, if you were doing this one?</s>SUSAN PAGE, WASHINGTON BUREAU CHIEF, "USA TODAY": You know, I think this is the coronavirus campaign. It is all about the health effects that we're seeing across the country, the spike in cases, the economic repercussions, and also what it tells us about presidential leadership in response to this pandemic. I think that is the issue. When we talk to voters those are the issues that they raise with us.</s>SCIUTTO: To that point, Susan and John, the former president, Barack Obama, unleashed you might say on the campaign trail yesterday and he spoke to this issue of the COVID response. I want to play that sound and get your reaction.</s>BARACK OBAMA, 44TH PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: We literally left this White House a pandemic playbook that would have shown them how to respond before the virus reached our shores. They probably used it to, I don't know, prop up a wobbly table somewhere. We don't know where that playbook went.</s>SCIUTTO: Now what he said is true, that there was a plan and largely set aside. I just wonder will Biden -- I mean, will his focus or his attempted focus be on COVID tonight?</s>JOHN AVLON, CNN SENIOR POLITICAL ANALYST: Yes. I mean, I think there's no question about that. I mean, we've got a brand-new study out this morning saying that the government's, the president's botched response led to many, many, many more deaths, which accounts for the difference we've seen between most other industrialized nations in the United States. This is a crisis that the president did not create, but he compounded through his own denial and unwillingness to rely on scientists and best practices, including that pandemic playbook. This is a problem that had been identified and focused on by the federal government going back to George W. Bush. And so, of course, Joe Biden will hammer that home and we'll see how specific he gets, but this is the issue number one, as Susan said. No question about it.</s>HARLOW: John, we know from Alyssa Farah at the White House that the president is going to find a way even if he is not asked about it to bring up China and bring up one of Joe Biden's sons, that is Hunter Biden.</s>AVLON: Yes.</s>HARLOW: And the reason I ask this is because listen to how President Obama in that speech in Philadelphia yesterday addressed the issue of China and then I want to get your reaction on the other side.</s>OBAMA: Listen, can you imagine if I had had a secret Chinese bank account when I was running for reelection? Do you think -- do you think -- do you think FOX News might have been a little concerned about that? They would have called me Beijing Barry.</s>HARLOW: So he did it with a smile and humor and I wonder if you think that's the way that Joe Biden should respond tonight.</s>AVLON: Look, you should always be a happy warrior and Biden is going to be a lot more effective at joking -- using humor as opposed to being a scold. But these are serious fundamental issues. I mean, obviously Trump is going to try to trigger him by going after his only surviving son, but he should push back by pointing out just that story because it hasn't gotten nearly enough pickup, and entirely ignored in conservative media that President Trump has got a secret Beijing bank account. And he had it during the last election. He's paid more taxes to China than to the United States. These aren't hard difficult things to point out that matter.</s>SCIUTTO: Susan, the former vice president needs to -- listen, the president is going to push the issue of Hunter Biden attempted business deals in China, e-mails, et cetera. The president is going to push it probably more than once. I know there's been some debate in the Biden camp as to how to respond to that. I imagine they have to. And what should that answer be?</s>PAGE: We know that they've been talking about really not just in connection with this last debate, about how to respond to the accusations about Hunter Biden and this is, I think, the issue that Joe Biden has struggled the most to address because it does get under his skin. The issue of his family. It's not one that you can handle with humor. What he has declined to do, which some of his supporters wish he would do, is turn it around and talk about the president's children and their business interest. He's been unwilling to do that. It's a test for Biden. Can President Trump get him off his stride by raising the issue of his son and that is something we certainly should be looking for tonight.</s>AVLON: Yes, and look, we got a preview of that in the last debate and what Joe Biden did was talk about his love for his son and his struggles with addiction, which was kind of a judo move that was very empathetic and relatable. You know, Lyndon Johnson, I think, is credited with an old line that said, you know, the problem with a pig is that you get dirty and the pig likes it. And that's always the danger of getting in the dirt with some of these debates.</s>HARLOW: Hey, guys, interesting that Joe Biden appears to trying to put the question of court packing and whether he'd support it or not if elected to bed in the "60 Minutes" interview. He doesn't totally directly address court packing, it's more about Supreme Court reform, but listen to this.</s>JOE BIDEN (D), PRESIDENTIAL NOMINEE: If elected, what I will do is I will put together a national commission of bipartisan commission of scholars, constitutional scholars, Democrats and Republicans, liberal, conservative. And I will ask them to over 180 days come back to me with recommendations as to how to reform the court system because it's getting out of whack.</s>HARLOW: Does he put it to bed, Susan Page, or if, again, you were the debate moderator, would you say, can you clarify if that means you would support packing the court?</s>PAGE: You know, it's clear that Joe Biden's instinct is not to expand the size of the Supreme Court. He has said that.</s>HARLOW: Yes.</s>PAGE: He said that as recently as the last couple of days, but that's not good with his progressive supporters who very much are angry about what's happened with the membership on the Supreme Court and want to take some action. But a commission? Really? A bipartisan commission over 180 days is the way to avoid coming down with a conclusion, not to get to one.</s>AVLON: Certainly that's been the Washington experience and I give Susan all the reasons in the world to be cynical about that, but I think the keyword is bipartisan and the fact he doesn't talk just about the Supreme Court. He's trying to deal with the politicization of our courts in a way that doesn't compound the problem. And I think that's significance he was saying.</s>SCIUTTO: No question. Listen, we'll be watching tonight. There are a lot of unanswered questions that need to be answered. That's why we have debates. Susan Page, John Avlon, thanks very much.</s>AVLON: Thank you, guys.</s>HARLOW: Well, this morning a damning new report. It takes aim at the Trump administration's response to the COVID pandemic and here is what it says. Up to 210,000 lives could have been spared in the United States if -- globally, rather, if officials had acted sooner. Today the FDA is holding a meeting with vaccine advisers as the director of the National Institutes of Health says a vaccine could be available in the next few months. Also right now only one state is seeing a drop in new cases in the U.S. 62,000 new infections were recorded in this country yesterday and at least 1100 Americans died. We are so glad on these headlines that Mike Osterholm is here, director of the Center for Infectious Disease Research and Policy at the University of Minnesota. Good morning to you. It's very good to have you here. That report, let's just start there --</s>DR. MICHAEL OSTERHOLM, DIRECTOR, CENTER FOR INFECTIOUS DISEASE POLICY, UNIVERSITY OF MINNESOTA: Good morning, Poppy.</s>HARLOW: -- if we could. The report that I just mentioned about up to 210,000 additional deaths that could have been prevented, it comes from Columbia University. And I know we can't move back, but given that you've said the next six to 12 weeks could be the darkest of this pandemic, what should we as a nation and our these leaders in power in this take from this report and try to change in the next three months?</s>OSTERHOLM: Well, you've really hit the question right on the head. This is what we need to look forward to and say, OK, what we've done so far has not been all that successful and we will see this big surge of cases. We know how to reduce the risk of this virus transmission. Just look at the Asian countries that basically have it largely under control and whose economies are coming back, but it takes inspired leadership. We need to do is explain to people why we don't want them to go to bars and restaurants right now, why we don't want them going to public spaces --</s>HARLOW: Michael --</s>OSTERHOLM: Yes.</s>HARLOW: I'm sorry to interrupt. Stand by. I'm going to take everyone to Capitol Hill. What you're seeing play out here on the floor of the Senate is a consequential moment. It is the Senate Judiciary Committee voting on the nomination of Supreme Court -- soon to be Supreme Court justice, Amy Coney Barrett, which we believe none of the Democrats have showed up for this. Let's listen in.</s>SEN. LINDSEY GRAHAM (R-SC): Senator Cornyn.</s>SEN. JOHN CORNYN (R-TX): Mr. Chairman, I'll just take a couple of minutes. I just find this to be a surreal environment we're in where our Democratic colleagues announced yesterday they're going to boycott one of the most important votes this committee will have probably during our entire Senatorial tenure, and that is a vote to confirm, provide advice and consent to a nominee for the Supreme Court of the United States. But I just want to comment on the pictures that are in their chairs like this is some sort of sporting event during COVID-19, and rather than show up and do their job, they choose to continue the theater that was part of the hearing. And of course, this is all pretextual. Their argument as I understand it is somehow Amy Coney Barrett will violate her oath of office, contrary to everything she has done and who she is, and somehow that the Affordable Care Act is in jeopardy. She explained, I think, with great skill, the issue before the Supreme Court, it's really one of severability, which is a very technical doctrine. It doesn't have anything to do with the merits of the Affordable Care Act. It has to do whether you can sever the --</s>HARLOW: OK. So let me bring in our expert on this, Sunlen Serfaty, who joins us on the Hill. Sunlen, can you explain to our viewers what's happening right now? Sunlen, can you hear me? OK, Sunlen --</s>SCIUTTO: As we wait for Sunlen, just a note about the photos that you see there and that Senator Cornyn was referring to. Those are pictures of people who -- Democratic members of the Judiciary Committee say are affected by the Affordable Care Act, Obamacare. Of course, their focus in these hearings has been if you confirm Judge Barrett that she will be the swing vote that might overturn Obamacare. And that's the origin of those pictures that they put up in their seats. Senator Cornyn said it was like a sporting match, but that's the back story as to why those --</s>HARLOW: Yes --</s>SCIUTTO: Photos are there.</s>HARLOW: Though, it's very important, I know -- and Jim, as you rightly -- no, I mean, they're going to hear that case on November 10th, so really soon. We now have Sunlen Serfaty with us. Sunlen, there is a rule that says you need at least two members of the minority party to make this vote happen --</s>SCIUTTO: Yes --</s>HARLOW: Rule 26, something like that, but there is no member -- there are no Democratic members of Judiciary there right now, but the vote is still going to go through?</s>SUNLEN SERFATY, CNN CORRESPONDENT: The vote is going to go through, Poppy. A little complex procedure, first and foremost. The committee rules do say that two minority members, two Democrats on the committee must be present in addition to nine other members on the committee in order to -- for this to move forward. That is what Democrats are arguing that they need two members, two Democrats, to push this forward. But there is a Senate rule, it's called Rule 26, and that Republicans argue supersedes the committee rule.</s>SCIUTTO: Right --</s>SERFATY: And that rule says that you just need to have a majority of committee members. So here, that's what Republicans are saying. Now, we have 12 people here, we have a majority here, and that's why they are pushing this through today --</s>SCIUTTO: Right --</s>SERFATY: Advancing her nomination, advancing it to the full Senate floor. And I just want to take a step back --</s>SCIUTTO: And, Sunlen --</s>SERFATY: Of course, and note that --</s>SCIUTTO: Just a --</s>SERFATY: You know --</s>SCIUTTO: Just a brief note, Sunlen, because, you may not know this, but they have advanced her nomination --</s>SERFATY: Right --</s>SCIUTTO: In a vote of 12-0 here --</s>SERFATY: Twelve-to-zero --</s>SCIUTTO: All Republicans of course. So Judge Amy Coney Barrett, the nominee for the Supreme Court, she has now --her nomination has now advanced to the full Senate. Sorry to interrupt you, but I just wanted to give that update.</s>SERFATY: Absolutely. An important advancement here of course, and Senate Majority leader Mitch McConnell has already set up a Monday vote for her final confirmation, and she is expected to be confirmed in front of the full Senate on Monday, by next week. And importantly, as Republicans' goal before the election day. And I just want to again take a moment to step back and say this wide shot of the room, that's the image that Democrats wanted of this morning. In effect their last protest, this boycott of the committee room, seeing these large posters, 2 feet by 3 feet approximately across --</s>SCIUTTO: Yes --</s>SERFATY: Of people who had been affected by the ACA, men, women and children. This is what they have made these committee hearings about. The Affordable Care Act, what would happen if Amy Coney Barrett becomes the next Supreme Court justice, what that means for your healthcare. And this is the picture the Democrats wanted. Now, I should say the other side of that strategy is the fact that they let the chairman of the committee, Lindsey Graham, of course, lead off this hearing, speak for I think it was 13 minutes before they voted through 12-0, her confirmation, voted through to the Senate floor. And in that -- right off the bat, he talked about the fact that Democrats had decided to do this boycott. He said this was their choice, I'm not going to allow them to take over the committee, they made the choice today not to participate.</s>SCIUTTO: Yes --</s>SERFATY: So Democrats will be holding a press conference later on Capitol Hill, but again, not showing up for the committee today --</s>HARLOW: Yes --</s>SCIUTTO: Well, we should note that Lindsey Graham did say a number of months ago, he would not bring up a nominee so close to an election if he were chairman, of course --</s>HARLOW: Yes --</s>SCIUTTO: He did, and of course going back to 2016, that didn't happen when a Democrat was the president. Just to remember the history here, the recent history as we follow this.</s>HARLOW: Yes, I'm smiling because that was then and this is now, right, Jim?</s>SCIUTTO: Yes --</s>HARLOW: And he's also in the middle of a really tough race to hold on to his seat. And I would just note for our viewers before we move on. Remember that this judge will fill as a justice the seat of Ruth Bader Ginsburg, the late Justice Ginsburg, who was confirmed almost unanimously, right, and those were very different times. Thank you, Sunlen, for explaining it all. So, we're going to get back to Michael Osterholm on COVID right after the break. Jim.</s>SCIUTTO: Also this hour, the nation's top national security officials say that Russia and Iran are interfering in the 2020 election. How are they doing it? How far does it go? We're going to speak to someone who has been briefed on the intelligence.
U.S. Officials Link Iran To Threatening E-mails Sent To Voters
JOHN KING, CNN HOST: The latest now on a remarkable new wrinkle in foreign election interference. The head of the FBI and the director of National Intelligence holding a rare evening news conference last night to say they have evidence that Iran is now mimicking Russia and sending e-mails to American voters trying to interfere in the 2020 election. These efforts include collecting voter registration information and other attempted voter intimidation. Let's get the latest from our CNN congressional reporter Lauren Fox. She's on Capitol Hill and CNN business reporter Donie O'Sullivan who is in New York. Lauren, let me start with you. Obviously, Congress promised it would do a better job watching this, a big development announcement last night from the FBI director and the director of National Intelligence. What's happening on Capitol Hill?</s>LAUREN FOX, CNN CONGRESSIONAL REPORTER: Well, we just got a statement just moments ago, John, from the chairman of the Intelligence Committee and the top Democrat on that Committee, Marco Rubio and Mark Warner saying in this statement, quote, it is clear that Iran is now actively seeking to sow dissent and divide us, much like Russia did in 2016 and continues to do today. Republicans and Democrats are united when we say that continued attempts to sow dissent, cast doubt on election results, or disrupt our election systems and infrastructure will necessitate a severe response. Now, I will tell you that on Capitol Hill, there's some concerns about how this press conference came about. There's distrust in John Ratcliffe, the DNI essentially concerns that he's trying to equate Iran and what Russia has been doing over the last four years, John. You can hear from some Democrats, that they're a little frustrated that Ratcliffe got into the fact that he believes that this was intended to hurt President Trump. They argue, you know, this is bigger than hurting one candidate. This is about the integrity of our elections. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi spoke to that point, just a few minutes ago at her press conference, saying essentially, this is about protecting the sacred election in the United States. This is far bigger than any one candidate. John?</s>KING: Lauren Fox, appreciate that. And to go back to what the FBI director said last night, at this time of confusion, trust your local election officials, don't trust things you might get in your inbox or see on Twitter. And to that point, let's bring in Donie O'Sullivan, who spends a great deal of time reporting on the internet and these websites and the like. So Donie let's get to the basics here. How many Americans receive these e-mails allegedly from Iran?</s>DONIE O'SULLIVAN, CNN BUSINESS REPORTER: Yes, John, thousands of Americans, I mean, this was by no mean a sort of small effort that, you know, might have only hit a few dozens of people, this was thousands of people. Google came out last night, they of course, run Gmail, one of the world's most popular e-mail clients. And they said that through their system, 25,000 messages had been sent. Now their spam filters caught 90 percent of those messages. But what that means is that potentially about two and a half thousand Americans, possibly American voters received these very threatening messages just on Gmail. And remember, of course, there are many different sort of e-mail providers, including Microsoft, and Yahoo as well. We have reached out to those companies to try to get some numbers. These are very scary e-mails, John. I mean, you know, you imagine opening one of these e-mails and in black and white, it says we know where you live. And it says, in some cases, it actually included people's home addresses, their names, and they falsi (ph), of course, also claim they said, we will know if you don't vote for Trump. And if you don't vote for Trump, we're going to come for you. Of course, that is absolutely inaccurate, because the ballots here in the United States is secret but nonetheless, a really chilling e-mail for a lot of Americans to get. And one important point as well, is that we don't know precisely where around might have got this information. You know, they might not necessarily have had to hack anything to get this a lot of these voting records, a lot of the information, including people's home addresses are available through open voter databases that are open to the public. But all that being said, of course for the voter who gets these messages to see that black and white -- in black and white on their screen is a really disturbing thing, John.</s>KING: It sure is. It's a direct threat intimidation. I will stay on top of this. And we're grateful, Donie O'Sullivan to have your help constantly on this important story. Donie, thank you very much. Coming up for us, Barack Obama back on the campaign trail, the former president delivering a scathing indictment of his successor, how common is that? We'll take a historical look, just a moment.
Moderna Reaches Target Of Enrolling 30,000 Participants For Phase 3 Of U.S. Vaccine trial.
KING: Important news this morning in the quest for COVID-19 vaccine, the pharmaceutical company Moderna hitting a milestone by finishing enrolling all of its trial, phase three trial participants. CNN senior medical correspondent Elizabeth Cohen joins us with more. Elizabeth, how significant?</s>ELIZABETH COHEN, CNN SENIOR MEDICAL CORRESPONDENT: John, it's significant before Moderna had been said that they would be ready or possibly ready to apply to the FDA for authorization to put this on the market. In December, I spoke with the president of the company Dr. Stephen Hoge. And he told me early December, so they're even more optimistic than they were before. Let's take a look at what's going to happen here. So 30,000 participants enrolled in the trial, they've all gotten their first shots, and most of them have gotten the booster shot that happens about a month later. Now remember, half of these people got the vaccine and half got the placebo and no one knows right now who got what. When 53 participants get sick with COVID-19 an analysis will be done, who the people who got sick, did they get the vaccine or the placebo? If at least 40 received the placebo, in other words, 75 percent, that means that Moderna will apply to the FDA for authorization. Now let's take a look at where all of these trials stand. As I said, Moderna says they could apply to the FDA in early December. Pfizer says they could apply to the FDA for emergency use authorization in late November AstraZeneca and Johnson & Johnson, John, those trials are both on hold. Participants one in each trial got sick. And so they've paused to see if they are going to go back or not. So those are both on pause right now. John?</s>KING: Elizabeth Cohen, grateful for that very important update. We'll stay on top of that. Coming up for us next, the race for the presidency, the battle for the control of the Senate, you want to look at one state to watch, how about North Carolina.
Path to 270: Electoral Map "Death Match" Scenario; Obama Delivers Scathing Rebuke of Trump in Closing Days; Biden & Trump Face Off Tonight in Final Debate Before Election
KEILAR: We are 12 days out from Election Day. And more than 40 million Americans have already cast their votes. The polls are furiously tracking which presidential candidate may have the easiest path right now to 270 electoral votes. But as 2016 proved, things are not always what they seem. CNN's John King shows us the potential death-match scenarios.</s>JOHN KING, CNN CHIEF NATIONAL CORRESPONDENT: There are many different ways to look at this map. The one thing that's unmistakable is Joe Biden has a significant lead right now. We have him at 290 electoral votes. It takes 270 to win. The president is at 163. Meaning he has a long way to go. Some Democrats look at this map and say, OK, look at these toss-up states. All of them carried by President Trump last time. Look right now, Biden -- we lean Pennsylvania, Michigan and Wisconsin to Biden. Some Democrats remember 2016 and they say, well, what if this happens. Right? What is this happens? What if the president winds all of the toss-up states and these come back into play? Then you're in a death match, right? Then you're in a death match. The same three states that made Donald Trump president are fighting again. But other Democrats come back to this map where we are right now and they say, you know what, look at this. Look at this. Look at the spending. Joe Biden and outside groups, $645 million since September 1st to $388 million. The Democrats are outspending the Republicans. Look at these battleground states polls. Joe Biden is in play everywhere. Leading in Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, Michigan. A slight lead in Arizona, a slight lead in Florida, slight lead in North Carolina, slight lead in Georgia, Iowa, Ohio. Texas down four. That's in play, right? So some Democrats look at this and they say, wait a minute, what if we have a landslide. What if Joe Biden could do this? Including Maine's second congressional district. What if Joe Biden ran the board? If Joe Biden ran the board, you get a blowout. Is that going to happen? Probably not. Right? We've all lived through American politics. But because of the money, it is a possibility that Biden could win some of these states. Some Democrats say, you know what, we can get Texas. Why is it important to compete? Not just for the presidency. Senate races. Senate races. Senate races. So Democrats are looking at this map and saying it's possible, it's possible. We could have a very big win.</s>KEILAR: Democrats are hoping to turn the electoral map blue, in part, by deploying one of their big weapons -- the former president, Barack. He made his first appearance on the campaign trail last night in Philadelphia and he showed no mercy to his successor in the White House.</s>OBAMA: Just yesterday, when asked if he would do anything differently, Trump said, not much. Really? Not much? Nothing you can think of that could have helped some people keep their loved ones alive? And with Joe and Kamala at the helm, you're not going to have to think about the crazy things they said every day. And that's worth a lot. You might be able to have a Thanksgiving dinner without having an argument. You'll be able to go about your lives, knowing that the president is not going to retweet conspiracy theories. We're not going to have a president that goes out of his way to insult anybody who doesn't support him or threaten them with jail.</s>KEILAR: I want to bring in CNN political commentator, Errol Louis, who is the host of the podcast, "You Decide." Errol, it is wonderful to see you. We are so close to this election, less than two weeks out. What do you make of the former president's decision to stay off the trail until now?</s>ERROL LOUIS, CNN POLITICAL COMMENTATOR: Well, he tends to bide his time. We know that Obama is a careful strategist. In 2016, he did the same thing. He tries to husband and hoard his political capital and deploy it at the last minute. There's a lot of people who wish he would get out earlier, but that's been throughout his presidency, throughout his political career. Now that he's out, though, he's occupying an interesting sweet spot between the Bernie Sanders wing of the party that says the whole system has to change, and the careful Joe Biden argument that's designed to try to reach across the aisle. You have this sweet spot in the middle for people who are partisan Democrats. They don't like to vote Republican. But they also don't necessarily want to blow up the whole system. That's where Barack Obama, I think, is at his most effective. I heard kind of that walking down the middle of that Democrat coalition is yesterday's speech -- Brianna?</s>KEILAR: So maybe some more traditional Democrats he's appealing to in this final push here. Donald Trump has tweeted out about this, saying this works to his favor, that President Obama being out there is something that benefits him. What do you think about that?</s>LOUIS: Well, look, Donald Trump's strategy has been to mobilize, energize, aggravate, and enrage his base. Nothing enrages them like the sight of Barack Obama. So to a limited extent, that's true. And it probably makes him crazy, makes his base crazy, and might even bring out more Donald Trump voters than before. The only problem with the strategy, Brianna, is that that's what he's been doing all along and the polls suggest it's not working. That there are people, however much they might want to hate on Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama and everything else. But they also have to deal with real-world problems, like record high unemployment, like mass hunger in many, many states, long, long lines of people waiting to get food, and the ever-present danger of the COVID. You know, we've got a reality show president trying to return this into a reality show showdown. But I don't know if he's got most people on his side. Of course, we'll know that in a couple of weeks from now.</s>KEILAR: So what do you think about tonight? For me, I'm wondering, will this be as nuts as it was last time? What are you wondering about the debate tonight?</s>LOUIS: I only thing I wonder is if he'll interrupt the way he interrupted the "60 Minutes" debate and just walk out. That is a district possibility, honestly. Because really, Brianna, he's not just running against Joe Biden. Donald Trump is also running against reality. When everybody gets to see the "60 Minutes" excerpts floating around the web, thanks to the White House, you can see he's got an answer for everything. It's just a careful distribution of fault to absolutely everyone else. The handling of the coronavirus not his fault. Its entry into the United States not his fault. The failure to come up with protective equipment not his fault. The rising statistics -- we're closing in on a quarter million people dead -- not his fault. He just goes on and on and on. The economy not his fault. He has a way to blame everybody. But after a while, he gets visibly angry in that interview. When reality starts to set in, and if Joe Biden is a competent debater tonight, he'll bring home this point. The president states to get very aggravated. He thinks we should all by talking about Hunter Biden and some stolen laptop when we're closing in on a quarter of a million dead and an economy that's still in tatters. And a lot of people who are scared and wondering what the future of this country is going to be. Donald Trump doesn't seem to have any answers for those people.</s>KEILAR: Yes. Errol, I know you'll be watching with keen interest, as will I. Errol Louis, thank you.</s>LOUIS: Thanks.</s>KEILAR: Next, Mississippi's top health officer will join me live. He says white people refusing to wear masks are to blame for the increase in COVID cases in his state. Plus, Southwest is going to start selling every seat in its flights. No more empty middle seats. As airlines report staggering losses.
Updates on Coronavirus Responses Across the Country; Dr. Thomas Dobbs, Mississippi State Health Officer, Discusses His Blaming Maskless White People for Rising Cases
KEILAR: The U.S. Airline industry posting record losses and pleading with the Trump administration for a coronavirus testing strategy. Airline trade groups and unions are telling the federal government that travelers need a way around pandemic quarantines that are, quote, "decimating the industries." That's where we begin our look at coronavirus headlines across the country.</s>PETE MUNTEAN, CNN AVIATION CORRESPONDENT: I'm Pete Muntean in Washington. Southwest Airlines says it's done with the policy it put in place because of the pandemic. It will soon start selling every seat on board its flights. Southwest just posted record financial losses. It says it is done capping capacity onboard its flights starting December 1st. And it insists that science is on its side. That makes Delta Airlines the last of the big four airlines still not selling every seat.</s>ADRIENNE BROADDUS, CNN CORRESPONDENT: I'm Adrienne Broaddus in Chicago. Illinois is among the states leading the nation in a seven-day average of news cases. Starting Friday, parts of Illinois will look a lot different. Gatherings will be limited to 25 people or less. Indoor dining and bar service will also be banned. The governor has given the green light to the Illinois State Police. The state police have the ability to issue citations if people aren't following the guidelines. Also, the state has the authority to pull someone's liquor license if they aren't following the rules.</s>DAN SIMON, CNN CORRESPONDENT: I'm Dan Simon in San Francisco. After a wave of infections at California's San Quentin Prison, a state appeals court has ruled that the prime must release or transfer half of its inmates to stop the spread of the virus. That would reduce the numbers from approximately 3,500 inmates to 1,750. San Quentin is the state's oldest prison. It also houses the state's death row for male inmates. The ruling comes after approximately 75 percent of the inmates contradicted COVID-19 resulting in 28 deaths. The court said that the state's failure to take adequate protections was, quote, "morally indefensible." State officials that managed the prison system say they disagree with the ruling and will determine the next steps.</s>KEILAR: Thank you, everyone, for those reports. In the beginning, coronavirus hot spots in this country were big populous city centers. Seven months in, coronavirus is now devastating more rural areas. The top health officer in Mississippi says that while more people of color fell ill over the summer, it's white maskless residents who are to blame for the uptick they've seen there since September. And infections in that demographic are very much on the rise right now. I want to talk now with that top Mississippi health officer, Dr. Thomas Dobbs. Thank you so much for being with us. Because you're seeing some patterns certainty worth talking about here. We know that people of color were disproportionally hit when it comes to COVID deaths. They also disproportionally represent essential workers and they bore the brunt of the virus up front. But now you're seeing white Mississippians catch up. Explain this to us, why these deaths are now equally divided and the changes you're seen over time.</s>DR. THOMAS DOBBS, MISSISSIPPI STATE HEALTH OFFICER: Yes. We've seen a pretty remarkable shift early on. African-Americans accounted for basically two-thirds, or 60 percent or more of cases and deaths. Over the summer and into the fall, we've seen that shift basically upside down. Now it's over 60 percent of new cases are in Caucasians. And the deaths are mirroring that also. It's really something we've got to watch closely because we've been working hard to try to work on social distancing and masking. It may well be we found a pretty receptive audience in the African- American community, maybe because they were hit so hard and have personal experience. But we're not having the same success we've seen with other segments of the population.</s>KEILAR: Explain to us this disparity when it comes to behavior that you're seeing between these racial groups. How are they differing right now?</s>DOBBS: You know, anecdotally, and also looking how the schools are operating, we are seeing a lot more enthusiastic compliance with our recommendations as far as masking and public social distancing, small groups. Nothing is perfect, but the message seems to have hit more fertile ground right now in the black community. We have other areas, Hispanics and Native Americans, who were hit really hard. And certainly, we've invested a lot of our efforts in those areas. And hopefully -- in a way, though it's true there's still a lot of vulnerability. But you know, coronavirus affects anybody. It doesn't matter. If we let our guard down for any reason, if we're reluctant to follow guidelines, and if we're at social events -- social events are what are giving us a terribly hard time. Those are scenarios that can't be safe right now, unfortunately. That's where we're seeing a lot of it. And a lot of this is, frankly, more seen within certain subsets of the white population.</s>KEILAR: So when you're talking about social events, are you seeing weddings, for instance? That's something we've seen across the country where we wonder, why are people, dozens of people, sometimes more than a hundred people getting together and having a wedding. Are those the social events you're talking about that seem more likely for white folks to be engaged in rather than black folks?</s>DOBBS: Not weddings so much. But that certainly is something. But a lot of it is youth-based. We've seen a lot of stuff that are parent-sponsored youth events, dances, parties, things of that nature that have really undermined a lot of our efforts to keep the schools open. It might even be smaller stuff. It might be small get togethers, people in bars and that sort of thing. So it kind of crosses the entire spectrum of high-risk activities. We know what we can do to prevent transmission of coronavirus. It's a little bit maddening that we kind of find ourselves caught between the severe dichotomy of it's either shut down or open up. But really, in the middle, there's a nice place where, if we do some simple stuff, if we stick -- mostly nuclear families, your household contacts, and wear a mask in public. Then if you're going to have a social gathering, do it in small groups and outdoors. It's that last piece that's really hard for us to get past. In addition to the mask thing, I think the combination of those these are really driving -- are really significant in the increase in cases and hospitalizations over the last couple of weeks.</s>KEILAR: I think it's so important in your patterns. It's something people all over the country can gain some knowledge from. Sir, thank you for being with us.</s>DOBBS: Thanks for having me.</s>KEILAR: Russia was the first country to approve a COVID vaccine but there's no evidence the Kremlin is actually way behind other countries in their vaccine development despite skipping several steps in the safety process.
Only 6,000 Participants Received Both Doses in Russia's Vaccine Trial.
KEILAR: A major development in the race for a coronavirus vaccine. The pharmaceutical company, Moderna, says it's now hit its target of 30,000 participants for its phase three vaccine trial. The company says all of those in rolled have received their first vaccine shot and most have also received the required second shot. Moderna's president said, if all the stars align, his company is now on track to apply to the FDA for authorization to put the vaccine on the market in early December. Now a CNN exclusive on Russia's push to develop a coronavirus vaccine. The developers of Russia's touted Sputnik-V coronavirus vaccine revealing to CNN the vaccine has not undergone the same rigorous testing required in other global trials. CNN's Fred Pleitgen is reporting from Moscow with exclusive details.</s>FRED PLEITGEN, CNN SENIOR INTERNATIONAL CORRESPONDENT: Hi there, Brianna. In August, the Russians approved their vaccine Sputnik-V without going through the main phase three trials for efficacy and for safety of the vaccine. However, the Russians kept on saying that they were going to conduct trials quickly. Last week, they said they'd already vaccinated 13,000 people. This week, they were saying 17,000 people. When we exclusively spoke to the head of the Gamaleya Institute, which is responsible for the Sputnik-V vaccine, the head of that institute told us, so far, only around 6,000 of those participants have actually received both doses of the vaccine. Which, of course, are key to achieving immunization and then for the scientists to be able to collect data from those trial participants. Now, another thing we've also learned is this vaccine, the institute says, is suitable for people between the ages of 18 and 60, and also not suitable for people who have various illnesses and also allergies as well. However, the head of the Gamaleya Institute says he believes it's still fine to also give the vaccine to older people and also to people with most illnesses. Of course, many prominent Russians have already taken the vaccine but one notable exception remains the Russian President Vladimir Putin, who, for months, has remained in isolation essentially inside a bubble -- Brianna?
Debate Night Offers Trump Final Chance To Reset Campaign; Biden Says He Would Have Bipartisan Commission Of Scholars Look Into Possible Supreme Court Reforms If He's Elected; Biden Looks To Protect Lead Entering Debate With Trump; Trump's Interruptions Frustrated Biden In First Debate
JOHN KING, CNN HOST: Hello to our viewers in the United States and around the world. I'm John King in Washington. Thank you for sharing a very busy consequential news day with us. It is debate night in America. The final time President Trump and Joe Biden will share a stage. Here's a live look at the debate hall in Nashville, Tennessee. What happens tonight could very well determine the November election outcome? But president is losing as he was when he walked on stage for his final debate four years ago. Tonight, his last big stage to change the 2020 campaign dynamic, 45 plus million Americans have already voted. And today, there are new concerns about election integrity. The FBI Director, the Director of National Intelligence last night warning Iran is mimicking Russia, trying to meddle in the 2020 election. National security is a debate topic tonight, so, too, is the Coronavirus. The country right now facing growing trouble again and so, it is safe to say the president is on defense when it comes to the virus. You see the map there, the numbers. Cases, positivity, all signal a third crippling COVID peak is here. 31 states, that's the red and the orange on that map, recording more COVID-19 cases now than a week ago. Wednesday, nearly 64,000 new cases, the positivity rate now above 10 percent in 14 states. And most troubling, the death toll on Wednesday climbing above 1,000 Americans dying of the Coronavirus above 1,000 for the first time since last month. Just yesterday, the president said not much when asked what he would change if he could go back and redo his pandemic response? That attitude is the biggest of several big reasons the president is losing. And advisers hope he is more humble tonight. One of those advisers this morning saying the president will answer the questions he wants to answer. That adviser also promising Joe Biden's son Hunter will be a big topic. The final debate ten days to Election Day, let's take a look at where the race stands right now? Joe Biden has an advantage. His job tonight is to protect his lead. We now have him 290 electoral votes, 163 for the president. Dark blue, safe for Biden, light blue, leans Biden. The dynamic of the race right now trending in Biden's direction, one thing the president wants, the president wants a really strong debate. You see these yellow states. These are all toss up states plus Maine, second congressional district. Maine awards electoral votes by congressional district, Iowa, Ohio, North Carolina, Georgia and Florida. The president won them all four years ago. He is hoping for a really strong debate to get him back in the game. If he can put those states back in his column, then he would look to Arizona which he won four years ago, and then we would come down to the three most spoken words recently in presidential politics, Pennsylvania, Michigan and Wisconsin. That is the president's hope. If you are Joe Biden, you go into the debate not only looking strong now, but even look at these toss up states. And let's take a look at the state of the race. If you bring up the state of the race right now, if you're Joe Biden, if you can come out of tonight's debate looking anything like this, you're in great shape. Because not only is he leading nationally, leading in Michigan, leading in Pennsylvania, leading in Wisconsin by pretty healthy margins, leading in Florida. That's competitive. But you're in play in a state the president won four years ago. You're in play, a little behind, but in play in Texas, state Republicans have won forever. You're leading a little bit or at least in play in North Carolina, same as Ohio, Georgia, Iowa, Arizona. Right now the map gives Joe Biden many options. He's looking at a very long menu how do I get to 270? If you're the president, your options are much smaller. You need a big debate tonight. The president's job try to trip up Joe Biden. One issue likely to come up, the president's Supreme Court pick is about to be confirmed. Joe Biden is mad about that. Democrats are mad about that. Many progressives want Joe Biden to commit. If I am elected and we take the Senate back, we'll add new justices to the Supreme Court. The president says Biden should give a crystal-clear answer. Biden says I'll name a commission; we'll study it for a while.</s>JOE BIDEN, (D) PRESIDENTIAL NOMINEE: I'll put together a national commission of, bipartisan commission of scholars, constitutional scholars. I will ask them do over 180 days come back to me with recommendations as to how to reform the court system because it is getting out of whack. There are a number of alternatives that are well beyond packing.</s>UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: This is a live ball.</s>BIDEN: It is a live ball. It is a live ball. We're going to have to do that.</s>KING: Joining our conversation right now is the National Co-Chair of the Biden Campaign, the Democratic Congressman from Louisiana, Cedric Richmond. Congressman, it's great to see you. It's a very important day for your candidate and for the country. Lot of pressure on Joe Biden going into this debate, he is in the driver's seat right now. This is a campaign that many Democrats think has the opportunity to be a wave election. What is worry number one for you as Joe Biden goes to Nashville?</s>REP. CEDRIC RICHMOND (D-LA): Well, I'm not worried about Nashville tonight. Joe Biden will articulate his vision for the American people. He will let them know that this race is not about Joe Biden, it's about them, it's about their families, and it's about their communities.</s>RICHMOND: And that he will do what a president should do which is unite the country, listen to the science, and make sure that we put everybody's economic recovery and physical recovery at the top of the to do list. And we will not rob the American people of the power to make their own decisions like Donald Trump did when he did not be forthright with the American people about how dangerous COVID was. He compared it to the flu. And so, we're going to make sure that we empower people to make good decisions.</s>KING: As you know, Democrats have every reason to be optimistic right now, a double digit national lead for Joe Biden as I just went through in the battleground states, fairly healthy leads in places like Pennsylvania, Wisconsin and Michigan, which were the big headaches for Democrats four years ago. In play in states that Democrats can only dream really most years of competing in. One of the questions is will Democrats have a unified approach? Will centrists, progressives, independents and republicans vote for Biden? You just heard his answer to Norah O'Donnell of "60 Minutes" on the Supreme Court issue. You know many progressives want Joe Biden to say, I will add two or three justices to the Supreme Court, because we are mad, Amy Coney Barrett is going to get that seat. Will his answer take three months; we'll have a study commission? Might that take the air out of progressive turnout?</s>RICHMOND: No, I don't think it will. And look, that's who Joe Biden is. He is thoughtful and he is thorough. And so, yes, I'm mad about Amy Barrett being confirmed. But I think what you see is someone being not emotional about it, but very thoughtful because as he says, presidents come and go. Supreme Court Justices last a lifetime and the Supreme Court shouldn't be at the whim of a president. But what the Republicans have done in stealing two Supreme Court seats has tipped the balance of power. And that balance of power could be tipped for a lifetime. So, I think that he wants to take a real thoughtful look at it and then make a decision based on what's best for the country and that's having a balanced Supreme Court. And I think that people who hear that answer understand it and realize that they're getting a thoughtful president.</s>KING: We never know which President Trump is going to show up. We saw in the first debate, the constant interruptions and bullying behavior frankly that led the Debate Commission to decide they're going to use a mute button so that each candidate actually gets the two minutes they're allotted. One thing we're told from Trump advisers is that, he wants to make a full throated attack on Hunter Biden, to try to suggest that Joe Biden is unethical because of the business dealings of his son. How will the former vice president answer that, and one of the tricks the president is up to Congressman Richmond is he knows that Joe Biden sometimes I call it getting his Irish up, he gets mad, when people go after his family and the president is trying to trigger him. What should the answer be?</s>RICHMOND: Look, I think the vice president will look straight past Donald Trump and his theatrics. Donald Trump is a known con man in many New York circles. But we know he is very dramatic, and he is all about the aid and he doesn't let the facts getting his way. Every credible news station has debunked the story about Vice President Biden doing anything wrong. I sit on judiciary. I watched the impeachment hearings. And it was crystal clear, even the president's administration when they came before judiciary, it said Joe Biden is an honorable man, he acted consistent with U.S. policy and he did nothing wrong. We believe in Joe Biden. And that's from his administration. So, I think Joe Biden is going to look completely beyond that. What he won't do is get in the mud and start talking about the president's kids, which by the way, if I had a big bully like Donald Trump who wants to play the dozens and talk about family, I'd have a field day on Eric Trump, Don Jr. and the rest of his family. I mean, it's nepotism at its highest. But I don't think you'll see that from Joe Biden. That's not who he is. He is so much better than getting in the mud. I think he's going to keep it focused on the American people.</s>KING: Help me to understand, Congressman, the mind set among Democrats especially Democrats like yourself who also hold senior positions in the Biden Campaign. If you look at the numbers, you go through the battleground polls, you look at the trend lines, and you look at the - even go away from polling, and look at the Americans that think the country is off on the wrong track, there are all the seeds of a wave election. And yet there's 2016 Deja vu. When Donald Trump walked on to the stage for the final debate four years ago, he was trailing Hillary Clinton. He still lost the popular vote, but those three words, Pennsylvania, Michigan, and Wisconsin allowed him to be President of the United States. What is your sense, is it nervous, is it anxious? What's the right word right now for Democrats at this moment?</s>RICHMOND: I think the word is focused. You saw Former President Obama in Pennsylvania yesterday. You see a conservative effort by the campaign to make sure that we have our principals in Wisconsin, Michigan, Pennsylvania, in North Carolina, in Arizona, in Iowa, making sure that we're going to all of those places.</s>RICHMOND: But more important, we're making Trump defend places he didn't have to defend four years ago.</s>KING: Forgive me for interrupting. But you mention other states? Do you want the vice president to be bold and to go to Texas, to go to Iowa or do you think let's just win and spend your time in Wisconsin, Pennsylvania, and Michigan?</s>RICHMOND: Well look, I will tell you, I am focused on winning this election, and whatever it takes to win. And so, we're going to see a robust focus on of course the trifecta states, but you'll see focus on Iowa and Arizona and North Carolina, because you have to have a backup plan. We're not going to throw Florida away which we are winning. And so, the strategy is we don't want to concede anywhere. We don't want to concede Texas. It's just a very expensive place to compete. But we feel good about where we are. And I think the people in Texas will look at things like the debate tonight and get a feel for who they want to trust with their future. So I still feel good about Texas also.</s>KING: Congressman Richmond grateful for your time on this important day. Thank you, sir.</s>RICHMOND: Thank you for having me, John.</s>KING: Thank you sir. For more insights on tonight's expectations, let's bring in Lisa Lerer of "The New York Times." Lisa, I'm trying to get the Congressman, I get it completely. But Democrats see this opportunity, they see a map that look something like 2008 where Barack Obama flipped so many states that George W. Bush had carried, flipped Indiana, flipped North Carolina, flipped Colorado and Nevada which have since become more Democratic leaning states. So the opportunity is there, but so is the recent history, meaning 2016 when Trump was losing, headed into the last debate. And again, he still lost the popular vote, but he won the election. What is the Democratic mood right now in terms of Joe Biden must do what tonight?</s>LISA LERER, CNN POLITICAL ANALYST: Well, I think that a lot of Democrats see this as Joe Biden's debate really to lose in a way; he is in a commanding position in this race as he has been fairly for several weeks if not months. And if he can just stay the course, Democrats believe if he can deliver the message he has been delivering, that he is the best physician to pull the country out of the pandemic, out of the economic downturn and that he can impose some kind of civility, maybe bring the country back together in some way. They believe that he will have a very good night. The question is going to be how he deals with attacks on his family, which many Democrats and Republicans expect to come from the president.</s>KING: And one thing we won't have to deal with is what we saw in the first debate, which was a president who wanted the floor. Listen.</s>KING: So, we will have the mute button, so they will actually get the two-minute answers. I asked you the stakes for Biden, in terms of the president, is this it when you look at the polls, OK, we're all skeptical, because we lived through 2016. But deep into the bones of the polls is very different than 2016, plus Biden has a cash advantage heading into the final weeks. He is not Hillary Clinton, I don't mean that to be critical, just if you look at the polls, his gender gap is bigger than Hillary Clinton; his support among Trump base, white blue collar workers is bigger than Hillary Clinton's. So for the president, is this it? Does he have to change the tide tonight or is there some other Trump magic we're not thinking about?</s>LERER: I think you raised a really good point, which is that President Trump is losing this race and all leads are not the same. Sure, Hillary Clinton was leading when we went into that third debate in 2016. But Biden's lead is different; he is cutting into key portions of the coalition that elected President Trump four years ago. I think the stakes for the president are extraordinarily high. He needs to find a way to change the dynamics of this race. And there's a real question about whether it's even too late given the outpouring of Democratic mail ballots that are already locked into the system. He needs to prompt this red wave that he loves to talk about his rallies, and get enough republicans out to the polls, largely on Election Day, to overcome that democratic advantage. That will require extraordinary discipline from the president. His aides have urged him to take a much more restrained approach to prevent an affirmative vision for the country. That's just not something we've seen from him. It's not something we've seen in his rallies, it's not something we've seen on his twitter account. And I am hard pressed to imagine that we see it tonight, but who knows. We live in extraordinary times, John, right?</s>KING: We certainly do, and we have an extraordinary election behind us, and we're in the middle of one right now, the final days. Lisa Lerer grateful for the reporting and the insights. It is a big night, and you should spend it with us. Our special coverage of tonight's final presidential debate starts at 7:00 pm eastern right here on CNN. Come join us. Up next, the CDC changes its definition of what it calls close contact with someone infected by Coronavirus.
Dr. Robert Redfield: Studies Will Determine Whether 14-Day Quarantine Period Can Be Shortened.
KING: We know the Coronavirus pandemic will be a big debate topic tonight. We also know that it is increasingly more and more and more of a concern almost depending on wherever you live. Let's take a look at the state map right now. You see the red and the orange. Those of you familiar with this know red and orange means wrong direction. 31 states right now trending up, more new Coronavirus infections now than a week ago 31 states trending in the wrong direction. One of them is New Mexico, more than 50 percent new cases now compared to a week ago. 18 states that's the Beige holding steady only one state, Hawaii are trending down at the moment. So this is a bad trajectory for the country. More than 60,000 new infections reported nationally yesterday. You see 31 states going in the wrong direction. So, too, the death trend 25 states, half of the United States reporting more deaths this week than last week, and you see it's a little bit of everywhere. But a lot of it across the northern part of the country. That was the warning for months. As it gets cooler and colder, cases will rise, and death will follow.</s>KING: You see here in the Midwest, you see the deep red that's 50 percent, 50 percent more deaths this week than a week ago is the deep red. And you see that cluster here; you see more of it out here in the plains as well. The CDC forecast now because of the rising cases is that 247,000 Americans will die of Coronavirus by November 14th. You see the numbers on the screen, 222,000 now so 25,000 more Americans projected to die in just the next few weeks because of Coronavirus. If you look at the positivity map, this helps you understand. More cases today, more infections in these places, and more likely spread because the rates are so high. See double digits here, Florida, Alabama, and Mississippi, 12, 14 and 18 respectively. But then look out here. Look out here, Nevada, 21, Idaho, 32, Montana, 13, South Dakota 35 percent, Iowa 51, Kansas, 21. Imagine that 51 percent positivity. 35 percent positivity that means a third of your people who get a test are coming back positive much more likely to spread the disease when the positivity is that high. South Dakota are 35 percent positivity, well then what happens? When you have such high positivity, guess what? Your case count goes up. That's pretty simple math, how it works. More people positive, more spread, case count goes up. You might think with a case trend line that way, 35 percent positivity rate that the governor of that state might feel some pressure right now? No. Republican Governor Kristi Noem says she believes that people in her state feel quite good with the direction.</s>GOV. KRISTI NOEM (R-SD): My people are happy. They appreciated the fact that we didn't shut down their businesses, we allowed them to be flexible, take care of health and protect the public, while still taking care of their customers and their employees as well. So we're doing really good in South Dakota. We're managing COVID-19, but also our economy is thriving. I think people are really recognizing that leadership has consequences and what we're doing in South Dakota is Republican leadership.</s>KING: Joining me now to discuss is Former CDC official Dr. Cyrus Shahpar. Doctor, it's good to see you again. Reminder we were listening to Governor Noem, whether you agree or disagree with her? Whether people out in the country watching around the world agree or disagree with her? It is a reminder that one of the complexities of the national challenge here is that this is a republic. You have 50 states; you have 50 Governors who make decisions in their own states. She has decided we're not going to have a mask mandate. We're going to leave businesses open. And yes, we'll take body blows every now and then, but she thinks her approach is the right approach.</s>DR. CYRUS SHAHPAR, FORMER CDC OFFICIAL: Yes, I heard the same thing from Texas, Florida and Arizona early on, and then when hospitalizations and deaths rose, they had to react. So I think it's a bit of a recurring nightmare that we're seeing in her state.</s>KING: You say a bit of a recurring nightmare, you so see the trend lines, 60,000 new infections yesterday. Again, we started from a baseline of 40,000 up this third peak. The question is how high do we go? And as we climb again, the CDC is updating its guidance about what it considers close contact. This is what the CDC says now. Someone who was within six feet of an infected person for a cumulative total of 15 minutes or more, over 24-hour period, starting from two days before illness onset at the time the patient is isolated. It's the word cumulative that is new there. The idea being that if we go back a couple weeks, people thought you had to be let's say around that person for the entire 15 minutes. They saw Vermont prison study, where the guards were going back and back and back only for short doses. But they think the repetitive; the cumulative is what caused it. How significant is that?</s>SHAHPAR: I think it's just the reminder that risk is continuing. There's nothing magic or special about 15 minutes and 14 minutes is not safe just because it is less than 15 minutes. So, I think it's important to stress that we need to wear masks and socially distance at all times, even if it is less than 15 minutes.</s>KING: We are learning all the time. And so, we have people not familiar with terms like quarantine, like isolation, like positivity rate. Dr. Redfield, the Head of the CDC says they're trying to reassess whether or not it should be 14 days, 10 days, and 7 days. Listen to him here talking about the question, if you think you've been exposed, how long should you quarantine?</s>DR. ROBERT REDFIELD, DIRECTOR, CENTERS FOR DISEASE CONTROL AND PREVENTION: There's a series of studies gathering data that are trying to determine, can you use testing during the quarantine to determine if you could shorten the quarantine from 14 days to 10 days or 7 days.</s>KING: So the idea I assume, help me if I'm wrong is that, do you have testing that you trust enough to after two or three days test a person and then what think OK, they must be OK, they're on a better track, test them again at 7, still negative, you can clear them? Is that the idea?</s>SHAHPAR: Yes, the idea is to look at minimizing the burden of quarantine, while still getting the public health impact of quarantine. So is there a sweet spot, maybe it's a little shorter than 14 days, maybe it's 10 days, maybe it's 7 days where we can test at the end of quarantine, so that we reduce the overall time, and have more people quarantined because we've seen difficulty adhering to quarantine of 14 days. And this has been done in Europe.</s>KING: Dr. Shahpar, grateful as always for your expertise and your insights, especially at this moment where the case count is getting quite troubling. We'll continue this conversation. Up next for us though, we turn back to the campaign and this remarkable news conference last night. The Director of National Intelligence, the FBI Director saying, it's not just Russia interfering this year, Iran also meddling.
Final Presidential Debate Tonight Has New Rules; CDC Revises COVID-19 Close Contact Definition
BRIANNA KEILAR, CNN HOST: It is the top of the hour, I'm Brianna Keilar. And in just hours, President Trump and Democratic presidential nominee, former Vice President Joe Biden, will share a stage one last time in these closing days of the election, and the stakes couldn't be higher for both men. The president needs to convince Americans that he deserves another four years in the Oval Office. Biden needs to maintain his campaign's momentum going into these final 12 days. The Presidential Debate Commission is desperately trying to turn the page from the first match-up, with new rules in place including a mute button for opening remarks. CNN's Arlette Saenz is in Nashville ahead of tonight's debate. And you know, Arlette, we're wondering what we can expect from each candidate when they take the stage, and if things are going to be different from the first debate.</s>ARLETTE SAENZ, CNN POLITICAL CORRESPONDENT: Well, Brianna, the moderator and the Debate Commission are certainly hoping that the debate might play out a little bit less chaotically than that first debate. But for President Trump, he is hoping that this debate can help him change the trajectory of the race, while Joe Biden is simply trying to protect his lead against President Trump. Now, for the format of this debate, the Debate Commission changed the way that the microphones are working at the start of each segment. The candidates will each have two minutes where they can speak without the other candidate's microphone on. This is to try to help avoid some of those interruptions that we saw play out in Cleveland just a few weeks ago. After each of the candidates gets their opening segment during those -- two-minute segment during each section, then they can move on to an open period of discussion, where they can both have their microphones on and proceed with their talking. Now, there will be six segments over the course of this debate. I want to run you through those topics. It's fighting COVID-19, American families, race in America, climate change, national security and leadership. This will be a 90-minute debate covering those six different topics. Now, something that will be different from that first debate is that there will be plexiglass barriers erected between the two candidates on stage. That's something that we saw during the vice presidential debate between Kamala Harris and Mike Pence, but today they are instituting that once again here at the presidential debate, after the Debate Commission consulted with their medical advisors. Now, we've learned that Joe Biden tested negative for coronavirus this morning. We haven't heard if President Trump has undergone a similar test before he proceeds to this debate. But this debate is essentially going to be voters' last chance to size up the two candidates on that stage, one on one, face to face together. We're just 12 days out and there's still a number of undecided voters who will be tuning into this debate to see if it can help them make up their minds about who should be the nest president -- Brianna.</s>KEILAR: All right, we'll be watching with you, Arlette Saenz, thank you so much, live for us from Nashville. And ahead of tonight's match-up, we are seeing the president return to one of his go-to lies.</s>LESLIE STAHL, CBS HOST, "60 MINUTES": Let me ask you what you think your -- the biggest domestic priority is for you right now or next year?</s>DONALD TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: Well, ultimately, let me -- and I'll tell you, it was happening, we created the greatest economy in the history of our country, and the other side was coming in --</s>STAHL: You know that's not true.</s>TRUMP: It is totally true.</s>STAHL: No.</s>KEILAR: That is not true. One topic that Biden will likely answer for is expanding the Supreme Court. Here's how Biden is now addressing that question.</s>JOE BIDEN (D), PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATE: If elected, what I will do is I'll put together a national commission -- bipartisan commission -- of scholars, constitutional scholars, Democrats, Republicans, liberal conservative. And I will ask them to, over 180 days, come back to me with recommendations as to how to reform the court system, because it's getting out of whack, the way in which it's being handled. And it's not about court-packing, there's a number of other things that our constitutional scholars have debated, and I'd look to see what recommendations that commission might make.</s>KEILAR: CNN political director David Chalian is joining me now to discuss. All right, I mean, this is the last match-up. What are you watching for going into tonight, David?</s>DAVIS CHALIAN, CNN POLITICAL DIRECTOR: Yes, the second and final match-up. Well, the first thing I'm looking for is Donald Trump's approach tonight. Now, we know, Brianna, we've observed him long enough, we don't expect Donald Trump to change all of a sudden and be someone he isn't, but what version of himself does he bring to this debate stage tonight? Is it much like the first performance where he was constantly interrupting and creating chaos on the stage? None of his advisors want it to be that because that did not go very well for him. In a remarkably stable race, Brianna, there is a noticeable dip for Trump after that first debate, so they don't want him to re-create that. And yet some signals are that may be exactly the road that he is going down here. Or does he lean into more his advantages in this race on the economy, where voters see him better than they see Joe Biden on that score? Does he try and seize this opportunity, as Arlette was saying, to actually change the dynamic in these final 12 days? Or is it more of his grievance politics? I think that is one key thing to watch. For Biden's part, Brianna, his defense. That, I think, is going to define his performance tonight, because we know Biden would like to stay above the fray as much as possible, talk directly to the American people. Of course, like any frontrunner, do no harm. But if Donald Trump is throwing things at him about Hunter Biden, his son and his business dealings, how Joe Biden responds to that. Does he get rattled? Does it get under his skin? Is he able to simply ignore it and move ahead with his own strategy and execute on it? I think is going to be sort of the defining aspect, in many ways, to how Biden's performance is perceived tonight. And my final thing I'm watching is that muted moment, right? I mean, Arlette just took you through the rules and there's this new enforcement mechanism that they have where, at the beginning of each topic section, if you're not speaking in that first chunk where you have two minutes to address it, if you're the opponent not speaking, your microphone's muted. Is Donald Trump going to obey that or is he going to try to interrupt and speak over his muted microphone and still try to throw Joe Biden off his game? Or does it actually -- does that enforcement mechanism actually bring more order to the debate stage tonight than existed in Cleveland last month? That's the third item I'm on the lookout for tonight.</s>KEILAR: Yes, I am very curious about that mute function. We'll see how that goes. David, we'll be watching, thank you so much. David Chalian.</s>CHALIAN: Thanks, Brianna.</s>KEILAR: And in just one day, the U.S. recorded more than 1,000 coronavirus deaths, we hit that grim milestone yesterday. This is the highest daily toll that was recorded in more than a month, and the recent trends are similar to previous surges but this time, experts say the worst is yet to come. There are 31 states that are recording more COVID-19 cases this week than they did last week. There is only one, Hawaii, that is moving in the right direction. The average of new cases per day has climbed to just under 60,000, and we haven't seen that level since the first week of August. There were more than 40,000 hospitalizations reported on Wednesday, several states hitting record highs on that including Iowa, Kentucky, Ohio, Oklahoma, South Dakota as well as Utah. You can take a look at the U.S. coronavirus death toll on the right side of your screen there, more than 222,000 lives lost. A new study investigated why that number was so high, and it found that most of those deaths were avoidable. CNN's senior medical correspondent Elizabeth Cohen is joining me now. I mean, this is -- it is tragic to look at these numbers, that these analysts estimate the death toll could be somewhere between 20 and 90,000, not 222,577, if there had been an adequate government response -- Elizabeth.</s>ELIZABETH COHEN, CNN SENIOR MEDICAL CORRESPONDENT: That's right, Brianna. And just to try to describe how inadequate the government response has been is tough. We're going to try to boil it down to a couple of points, but again, the support from Columbia University, saying there could have been tens of thousands fewer deaths if different things had been done by the federal government. So let's take a look at those. They said there was insufficient testing, there was lack of national mask guidance. The Trump administration downplayed the pandemic and mocked masks. Masks save lives, so mocking them does not help. It is so bad that countries, developing countries such as Pakistan, Honduras, Malaysia, they had more successful responses. And, Brianna, to add to that list, Columbia also pointed out, look, Trump spent a lot of time advocating for solutions that didn't work. For example, hydroxychloroquine. So that also added to the death toll -- Brianna.</s>KEILAR: And tell us about this CDC revision on what is considered close contact with someone infected with coronavirus. What is the change here and why is the change?</s>COHEN: Right, so the CDC has been saying for months, a contact means -- or if you've had -- when we say you've had "close contact" with someone with COVID, we mean have you been within six feet of them for 15 minutes or more. And now, the CDC making it clear it doesn't have to be 15 minutes consecutively, like from 3:00 to 3:15. It could be five minutes here, five minutes there, five minutes later on. It can be cumulative, all put together. And one of the reasons why they did this is that the state of Vermont noticed for their corrections officers, that they were at risk for getting COVID even when they weren't within 15 minutes of someone all at one time, it could be just little bits and pieces put together. And it makes sense. It's the amount of time, put together, that you are near someone with COVID, the chances that they're going to get you sick.</s>KEILAR: No, it's a very good point, a very good change. And the CDC is also investigating ways to shorten the quarantine time for schoolkids. What are the options here?</s>COHEN: Right, this is something that they're looking into, that they haven't actually done yet. But I asked, actually, about this, I asked Dr. Robert Redfield of the CDC about this yesterday. And he said, look, we're looking at the science. This pandemic is relatively new. We were saying people need to be quarantined for 14 days if they've had close contact with someone with COVID or if they've had COVID themselves, they need to be isolated for 14 days. Maybe it doesn't need to be 14, maybe 12 is OK. There are various studies on that, and Dr. Redfield said they're looking at the studies.</s>KEILAR: All right, Elizabeth Cohen, thank you so much, great to see you.</s>COHEN: Thanks so much.</s>KEILAR: There have been nearly 300,000 more deaths than expected in the U.S. during the pandemic. The CDC reports that about two thirds of those deaths were from COVID-19, so what about the other third? CNN health reporter Jacqueline Howard has more -- Jacqueline.</s>JACQUELINE HOWARD, CNN HEALTH REPORTER: Brianna, some experts say those other deaths, which represent about 100,000 lives lost, might be deaths of despair. The term "deaths of despair" refers to deaths caused by suicide, alcohol or drug use. Here's what former FDA commissioner Dr. Scott Gottlieb has said about this, especially when it comes to younger adults. Have a listen.</s>SCOTT GOTTLIEB, FORMER FDA COMMISSIONER: I would suspect that a good portion of the deaths in that younger cohort were deaths due to despair, due to other reasons. We've seen a spike in overdose --</s>HOWARD: And one of the biggest jumps in excess deaths has been among adults ages 25 to 44 -- Brianna.</s>KEILAR: Jacqueline, thank you so much. Still ahead, we're going to hear from the top health official in Mississippi, who says the spread in his state can be traced to white people not wearing masks. First though, the FBI shares new evidence about how Iran and Russia are trying to interfere in the U.S. election including sending intimidating e-mails to voters. And one topic that should come up tonight? Health care. We will roll the tape on all the promises the president has made about his nonexistent plan to replace Obamacare.
FBI Election Interference Announcement Raises Questions.
KEILAR: With just 12 days to go until the election, we are learning from the country's top national security officials that Iran and Russia are actively interfering in the 2020 election. Director of National Intelligence John Ratcliffe says both countries have obtained U.S. voter registration information, with Iran posing as the far-right group Proud Boys and sending intimidating e-mails to voters. One of those e-mails reads in part, quote, "You will vote for Trump on Election Day, or we will come after you." And it concludes with this, "I would take this seriously if I were you." Now, the timing of this announcement has raised questions. The briefing was hastily arranged and delivered just minutes after former President Obama delivered a strong rebuke of President Trump. Anthony Ferrante is a senior law enforcement analyst, he's a former FBI special agent and he's joining us now to talk about this. And, Anthony, there was a source who told CNN that the government assesses some of the data that the Iranians obtained came from vendor and state systems. It's not just that this was publicly available voter registration information, so that's very alarming. How did they get this information and does that mean that this information is vulnerable to other attacks?</s>ANTHONY FERRANTE, CNN LAW ENFORCEMENT ANALYST: Of course, right? I think this is just the tip of the iceberg here, Brianna. I mean, let's take a step back. A month ago, no one -- many Americans hadn't even heard of the Proud Boys. As of yesterday, many Americans across the country actually received a threatening e-mail from this group, telling them they had to vote for Donald Trump or else. This is clearly escalatory behavior, and we really need to take this seriously because, I mean, as our intelligence officials briefed yesterday, Iran and Russia have now taken this bullying tactic and they brought it into the homes of Americans. This is no longer just targeting state infrastructure like they did in 2016. They have escalated the fight, they have now brought it into the kitchens of Americans across the country. And we really need to appreciate what that means.</s>KEILAR: I want to listen to something that the DNI said last night. Let's roll this.</s>JOHN RATCLIFFE, DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL INTELLIGENCE: We have already seen Iran sending spoofed e-mails designed to intimidate voters, incite social unrest and damage President Trump.</s>KEILAR: OK, what do you make of that? Because the e-mails make it clear they want people voting for President Trump. He's saying that this was a coordinated effort to hurt Trump. What do you say to that?</s>FERRANTE: Yes, Brianna, I mean, as a former FBI special agent, it's very troubling for me to see that. You know, I watched the press briefing last night, I looked on stage and I saw no special agent investigators up on stage. I saw all Trump political appointees, and it broke my heart to see them stand before the FBI seal and make that statement. Now, look, you can interpret that statement or the e-mail any way you want, really. Let's put that aside. That statement that the DNI made, it just wasn't necessary. It wasn't necessary, and it took a very important message, right? A very important message about Americans being targeted, Americans now facing this fight in their homes, in their kitchens, and it put a political spin on it, and it just wasn't necessary, right? And it's super-frustrating that it happened in the FBI building in front of an FBI seal with no investigators up on stage, just these political appointees. And there's more to be done here, right? OK, so you're saying, the e- mail is a threatening e-mail saying, you know, you must vote for Donald Trump or else. But what are we going to do about it, right? The only thing we got last night is the U.S. government telling us they're aware of this. They didn't tell us what they're going to do about it, so what's next, right? I hope we can expect more from our government, more than just a monitoring squad. I would really like to see some action come out of this.</s>KEILAR: I wonder if the DNI has clearly been co-opted here by the political apparatus of the administration. Because the DNI also offered specifics about Iranian interference, but then didn't provide the same level of detail when it came to Russian interference. What did you think of that?</s>FERRANTE: I mean, I had the same reaction to the briefing. I think there's no other way to interpret these activities other than escalatory, OK? We certainly saw them targeting the 50 states in 2016, but they were doing it at the state level, they were doing state infrastructure, right? The fact that now they pulled this data, whether they stole it illegally from compromised infrastructure, or they obtained it legally through paying for it, right? Where it's publicly available. They still took these steps, and they did in the public's eye, they did it in plain sight. They weren't secretive about it at all. It's my understanding they also used foreign infrastructure in which to launch these e-mails that landed in the homes of American citizens. And I just think that this is clearly escalatory behavior, and I would really like to see some sort of response activities coming out of this. Remember, in 2016 when this happened, it was a difficult subject, it was a very sensitive subject. Yes, the administration was slow. I am very happy to see the press briefing last night, that the administration is moving quickly to inform American citizens, right? But what are they doing about it? Christopher Wray getting on stage and saying you should have confidence in voting, that's not the problem. The problem is not the infrastructure, it's not a tactical problem, OK? We really need to help Americans understand that this is massive, real -- right? -- misinformation campaign being facilitated by nation- state actors. Russia and Iran are behind this.</s>KEILAR: Anthony, thank you so much for taking us through this. Anthony Ferrante, we appreciate it.</s>FERRANTE: Thank you.</s>KEILAR: Next, former President Obama slams President Trump for everything from COVID response to spreading conspiracy theories. But can he move the needle for Joe Biden?
Debate Night Offers Trump Final Chance to Reset Campaign; Barrett Nomination Advances Out of Committee; Trump Aide: President Plans Big Focus on Hunter Biden.
JOHN KING, CNN ANCHOR: Top of the hour. Hello, everybody. I'm John King in Washington. Thank you so much for sharing your day with us. It is debate night in America, the final time President Trump and Joe Biden will share a stage. And today is full of new developments certain to be debate flash points. Republicans on the Senate Judiciary Committee this morning ignored a Democratic boycott and advanced Judge Amy Coney Barrett Supreme Court nomination to the Senate floor. It is near certain now she will be confirmed early next week. Tilting the high court to the right, justice deals with Obamacare and 2020 election challenges. Plus, new unemployment claims are bleak again, but not quite as bad as other recent weeks. The coronavirus economy is a big debate topic. Here's a live look at the debate hall, Nashville, Tennessee perhaps we use these words too much, but the stakes tonight, are giant. The president is losing as he was when he walked on stage for that final debate four years ago. Tonight, is his last big stage to change the 2020 campaign dynamic. Goal number one for Democrat Joe Biden is protect his lead. And he knows the president is coming to attack his policies and to attack his family. As the candidates meet and millions of you vote early, there are new concerns today about election integrity. At a press conference last night, the FBI director and the director of National Intelligence warned Iran now mimicking Russia, trying to meddle in the 2020 election. The emails traced to Iran, threatened Democrats to vote - not to vote for Biden. But the intelligence chief, a Trump ally, insists, without backing it up, that the goal is to hurt the president.</s>JOHN RATCLIFFE, DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL INTELLIGENCE: We are standing before you now to give you the confidence that we are on top of this and providing you with the most powerful weapon we have to combat these efforts, the truth.</s>CHRISTOPHER WRAY, FBI DIRECTOR: We are not going to tolerate foreign interference in our elections.</s>KING: National security is a topic tonight. So too is the coronavirus. The country faces growing trouble again. So, it is safe to say the president is on defense here. The numbers, cases, death, positivity, all signal a third crippling COVID peak is right before us. 31 states, you it on the map. They're recording more COVID-19 cases this week. That's the red and orange, 31 states, more cases this week than last week. Only one, Hawaii, pushing the case curve down in the right direction. Wednesday, nearly 64,000 new infections. The positivity rate sits above 10 percent in 14 states. And most troubling on Wednesday, you see the chart there, the death toll climbing above 1,000 for the first time since last month. Just yesterday, the president said not much when asked what he would change if he could go back and redo his pandemic response. That attitude is the biggest of several big reasons he is losing. And advisers hope he is more humble tonight. One of those advisers this morning says the president will answer the questions he wants to. And that adviser promising Hunter Biden will be a big debate topic. Let's get straight to Nashville. CNN's Jessica Dean live at the debate hall. A very big night in Tennessee tonight, Jessica.</s>JESSICA DEAN, CNN CORRESPONDENT: It absolutely is, John. And I think you laid it out so succinctly. This is Donald Trump's last chance to really change the trajectory of this race. We know that his advisers have counselled him that this is really his last chance to change opinion of his behavior from last last time. With two very important demographics, women and seniors. That's where Joe Biden is making a ton of inroads and that's where President Trump really needs to shore up some support. He's also been advised to really tone it down tonight. Cool it off a little bit. Not come in as hot which he indicated he's willing to do but he also indicated he is going to push back and push back hard if he feels like he's being treated unfairly. For his part, former Vice President Joe Biden has been preparing the last several days for this debate, he and his campaign well aware and preparing for personal attacks against him and as you mentioned, his family as well. They really want to keep this about the policies. They want Joe Biden, as you remember from the last debate when he would look right into the camera, they want him talking directly to the American people, they want to be talking about the coronavirus pandemic and how he plans to get America out of the crisis it's in, surrounding that, and also how he plans to bring back the economy after it's been decimated by the coronavirus pandemic. They want to continue to go back to that again and again as much as possible. They believe when he's talking about that, that's where they really do well. Again, also, we know that this mute button is going to be in play tonight 2 minutes of uninterrupted talking time at the beginning of each segment where the opposing candidates mike will be muted, after that it is open discussion. So, it remains to be seen how that will all play out. Just a reminder for everyone out there, there are a set number of topics that have been discussed. They will be discussed tonight. I want to run through those with you. They include fighting COVID-19, American families, race in America, climate change, national security and leadership. Each of those spanning 15 minutes for a total of 90 minutes uninterrupted on that debate stage behind me. But John, as you all know, those can be the topics that we outline and that we're supposed to be talking about tonight but it will be incumbent upon those two men on the stage to drive what they're talking about and what they want to bring up and we will see how that all plays out.</s>KING: As we've learned in this campaign and others, the candidates can sometimes have their own debate outside of the lines and outside of the suggested topics. Jessica Dean, appreciate the preview there from the debate hall in Nashville. Joining our conversation now, Jackie Kucinich of "The Daily Beast," Toluse Olorunnipa of "The Washington Post." Jackie, it is hard - it is hard to understate the importance here for both man but especially the president to his trailing. You see in the list of topics, COVID-19 is first, a man who helped the president prepare for the first debate, is in his face on the day of the second debate. This is this is Chris Christie, the former governor of New Jersey, who of course got coronavirus at the White House, because he said he took his mask off and he was not careful. This is what he writes in "The Wall Street Journal" today. "Those who deny the scientific realities of the pandemic undermine conditions that allow for rapid and complete reopening. They encourage behavior that invites personal tragedy and social regulation. People need encouragement to do the right thing, not excuses not to." That could be a message to the president of the United States that is delivered on this day by the man who helped him prepare for the first debate.</s>JACKIE KUCINICH, CNN POLITICAL ANALYST: We've seen the president isn't listening to anyone when it comes -- or anyone he doesn't want to when it comes to masks and to how he's dealing with the coronavirus and COVID-19 crisis. You know when I was reading that op-ed, I had a moment and though, you know what if the president actually had something to put something like this out after his infection with the virus. And instead of doing what he's doing, which is kind of plowing through and pretending it's lifting off the country. But while -- I hope people read that Chris Christie op-ed, he's right that masks shouldn't be a political tool or political virtue signaling. But I think we're kind of past the point where the president is going to take advice on COVID-19 and mask wearing. And that's one of the reasons they want to talk about anything other than the pandemic. Which is why they're bringing in some of these other topics like Hunter Biden, like how the economy was, to really try to, you know, make people forget about the thing that is affecting most people in this country every single day.</s>KING: And we get that, Toluse, and Jackie raises a key point. One of the big questions which Trump do we get? Joe Biden is pretty steady in debates and even at times, but it is the same guy every night. President Trump can be different. We learned that it in 2016. We saw his performance in the first debate this cycle. And Jackie mentions Hunter Biden. We know that Trump's strategy. He did this with Hillary Clinton. Everybody is corrupt, hate us both but then vote for me, right? He needs to bring Joe Biden down. Again, his unfavourability ratings up. Listen to Frank Luntz, the Republican pollster who says, given the challenges right now, the COVID pandemic is accelerating again. The economy is in the tank. Frank Luntz, Republican pollster, says he's not so sure this Hunter Biden strategy is the right one.</s>FRANK LUNTZ, REPUBLICAN POLLSTER: If you've lost your job or you're afraid of losing it, what do you care about more, economic policy or Hunter Biden's laptop. If you've been sick or you know someone who's got sick from COVID. What concerns you more? If you got kids who are going to school, what matters to you most? I don't understand why the campaign is so focused on Hunter Biden when there are so many better issues that the public cares more about.</s>KING: There are a lot of Republicans, Toluse, who believe that. But we all know this president trusts his own instincts. Who will we see?</s>TOLUSE OLORUNNIPA, CNN POLITICAL ANALYST: The president is trying to recreate the magic of 2016. And we knew in 2016 Hillary Clinton did have sort of an air of scandal around her in part because the FBI was investigating her use of emails and the FBI director announced towards the end of the campaign that they were going to reopen that investigation. So, the president is trying to recreate that kind of situation where his opponent is under some kind of cloud of scandal, some kind of investigation but it just doesn't seem to be what's happening. In part because the unfavourability rating for Joe Biden is so much different than what we experienced four years ago with Hillary Clinton. People in general seem to like and trust Joe Biden. They don't think of him as sort of this corrupt Washington politician who's you know been involved in all kinds of various scandals. Instead for the most part he's well trusted. So, the president is likely going to try to attack Joe Biden on those lines, try to bring his family into this, try to make him into this image of a you know long-standing Washington corrupt politician who hasn't gotten anything done but has lined his pockets while he's been in Washington. It's an image that is very different from what the American people have seen of Joe Biden. But President Trump has been trying to push that message on the campaign trail and this is his biggest audience yet so far and his last big chance to have tens of millions of people watching him. And I would expect him to push this message pretty hard. Even with his mike muted for a good chunk of the debate. I would expect him to use the time that he has, especially that open 10 minute period to really try to challenge Joe Biden and to get him off of his game by attacking his family and trying to paint him as a corrupt Washington politician.</s>KING: And we know, Jackie, in recent days we've seen the president bristle at coronavirus questions. Ending that interview at Lesley Stahl of "60 Minutes." But we also know that Joe Biden gets his Irish up when people challenge his family and that is part of the Trump's strategy. To try to get him to lose his temper and lose his focus in a debate in which Biden clearly if he has a strong even breaks even with the president he's in the driver's seat for the race. But the president is trying to rattle him here.</s>KUCINICH: Well, that's kind of the only play they have, right? Because the Biden campaign is really emphasizing that they're just going to take the approach they have to every debate. He's prepared to talk about the issues that he's been pushing the entire campaign, things like following the science, getting the economy back, some of the things that you just mentioned and it's just going to try to brush off the president's attacks. Whether or not he's able to do it. You know when the president was attacking him during the last debate. There was this moment where Biden -- about his son, Hunter, he looked at the camera and talked about the struggles with addiction. It was one of the better moments for Biden, one of the more relatable moments for Biden in that first debate. So, in that case, that really backfired on what the president was trying to do. We'll see how they approach that tonight.</s>KING: And Toluse, one thing the president's advisers are begging him to stick to is an economic contrast. They say if you want to win back some of those suburban women who tend to vote Republican, who don't like your tweets, don't like the way you conduct yourself, if you want to win back Republican leaning independents, who like the way the economy was before the pandemic, focus more and more on the economy. Joe Biden will raise your taxes. You should prefer my approach. The president, a little bit of a test run in the "60 Minutes" interview that was on Sunday. Listen to this clip they released.</s>LESLEY STAHL, CBS NEWS HOST, "60 MINUTES": Let me ask you what you think your -- the biggest domestic priority is for you right now.</s>DONALD TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: Ultimately, I'll tell you, it was happening. We created the greatest economy in the history of our country. And the other side --</s>STAHL: You know that's not true.</s>TRUMP: It is totally true.</s>STAHL: No.</s>KING: This is the fight. The president bristles at the idea that he inherited a very strong economy from Barack Obama, which happens to be true. It also happens to be true that at least in the early days the Trump tax cuts did give that economy even more juice. Where do we expect this fight to go tonight?</s>OLORUNNIPA: Yes, I would expect the president, he has a number of talking points on the economy. They're well-rehearsed. He's talked about the first three years of his administration not necessarily focusing so much on the last year which has been plagued by this economic downturn in the middle of a pandemic. But I would expect him to try to focus on the economy. His advisers are telling him, focus on the economy, draw a contrast between yourself and Joe Biden on issues like taxes which they polled and shown that the president does poll well when it comes to taxes in comparison to Joe Biden. So, you would expect President Trump to focus on that. But if you look at the "60 Minutes" interview as a case study, yes, he talked about the economy, but he blew up the entire interview by walking out of the interview, tweeting about it. Getting all kinds of different news headlines. So, even if he give a pitch perfect answer on the economy, no one is going to be talking about it if he is creating other headlines by giving his normal Trump-style antics that overshadow the meat of the message. I wouldn't be surprised if we see that tonight as well.</s>KING: That's why we watch the entire 90 minutes. Toluse Olorunnipa, Jackie Kucinich, grateful to your reporting and insights especially on a very busy day, thank you both. Our special coverage of tonight's final presidential debate starts at 7:00 p.m. Eastern right here on CNN. Please join us. Up next, COVID-19 numbers are on the rise, case counts back above 60,000 today.
U.S. and U.N. Condemns Violence in Nigeria; Security Forces Open Fire at Peaceful Protest in Nigeria; Falz, Rapper, is Interviewed About Lagos, Nigeria Protests; 40 Million Votes Already Cast in U.S.; Joe Biden Leading in Polls; 2020 Presidential Election Final Debate; Liz Harrington, Spokeswomen, Republican National Committee, is Interviewed About 2020 Presidential Election and Trump; Interview With Melody Gardot; Interview With Author Ayad Akhtar.
CHRISTIANE AMANPOUR, CHIEF INTERNATIONAL CORRESPONDENT: Hello, everyone, and welcome to "Amanpour." Here's what's coming up.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: It was very bad. Military men shooting at protesters.</s>AMANPOUR: The Nigerian government appeals for calm amid shootings that have shocked the world and a crackdown on peaceful protests. Then --</s>BARACK OBAMA, FORMER U.S. PRESIDENT: We've got to vote like never before and leave no doubt.</s>DONALD TRUMP, U.S. PRESIDENT: You can go ahead and vote today, they say. Today. Go out and vote.</s>AMANPOUR: Twelve days to go, 40 million votes already cast. The president has a mountain to climb. Can he do it? RNC spokesman, Liz Harrington, joins me. Plus, Hari Sreenivasan talks to Pulitzer playwright and author, Ayad Akhtar, about his new novel, "Navigating the American Dream". And finally, from lockdown with love. Jazz singer, Melody Gardot, on finding inspiration in troubled times. Welcome to the program, everyone. I'm Christiane Amanpour in London. The United States and the United Nations are strongly condemning the violence that's erupted in Nigeria. And these are some of the latest images, smoke billowing into the sky amid reports of a prison in Lagos being set ablaze. It comes after security forces open fire at a peaceful demonstration protest against police brutality on Tuesday. Witnesses and Amnesty International say at least 12 demonstrators were killed in Lagos, which is Africa's most populated city. And across the country, Amnesty says, a total of 38 have been killed on Tuesday alone. But the Lagos state governor denies there were any deaths. This brutality in one of Africa's biggest cities comes amid a global uprising for justice and equal rights and powerful voices from Joe Biden to Beyonce have joined in denouncing this violence. Activist and renowned rapper, Folarin Falana, better known by his stage name, Falz, led one of the first protests two weeks ago and he's been taking part ever since, and he's joining me from Lagos. Falz, welcome to the program. We're coming to you because you've obviously got, you know, the pulse of the people. You've got 7 million Instagram followers and you have been organizing some of these protests and joining in. Can you tell me how this all started? What turned this city into violence?</s>FALZ, RAPPER: Wow. It's really crazy for everyone out here. It's a horrible, horrible time. And if this was yesterday, I probably wouldn't have been able to take this call because I was extremely distraught. It was a horrible, horrible incident. But it started probably about two weeks ago, roughly about two weeks ago. On the 8th of October, myself and another artist named Ronton (ph), we had shared on our Twitter and Instagram pages that we were going to do a walk, just a march, a peaceful protest against all forms of police brutality, all forms of police misconduct in general. And we did that with the #EndSARS. The hashtag was already in existence. You know, this is something that was already a big thing on social media but no one had actually gone ahead to do a physical protest. So, we decided to take that extra step. So, we went up on the 8th. I think it was a Tuesday. We went out and probably were expecting maybe around 50 or 100 people, but when we got around about 2,000 people or so that came out on that very day. And it was huge. You know, we did a march to a police station, which has some high-ranking officers here in Lagos and we handed in a petition just saying that the youth as a group were very, very unhappy with, you know, the way things were going, and we were really, really furious about police brutality, police harassment, police extortion. And, you know, enough is enough, basically. Everyone was standing up, you know, everyone was lending their voice to this particular cause. So, from that day up until now, back to back to back it's been a different state in the country because there are 36 states in total.</s>AMANPOUR: Right.</s>FALZ: But apart from that very one on that day, we didn't even have to call for people to come out in other states. Everyone just trooped out, you know, on their own. It's been crazy. It's been really, really crazy.</s>AMANPOUR: OK, Falz?</s>FALZ: Yes.</s>AMANPOUR: Let me just interrupt you a bit because I just want to ask you so that our viewers are clear. End SARS is the hashtag and it's the movement. SARS, for everybody to understand, is a special police unit, right, it's the Special Anti-Robbery Squad.</s>FALZ: Exactly.</s>AMANPOUR: What is it about them? And apparently, they are -- they're not in uniform, they're plainclothes, and for years you, have been protesting against them. What is it that you're actually protesting? What do they do?</s>FALZ: It's all forms of violence. It's all forms of brutality. And the offenses that they're supposed to be protecting us against is pretty much what the -- is pretty much the offense they end up committing. The SARS stands for State Anti-Robbery Squad but they're committing armed robbery because we hear about numerous cases where they stop young people just because you look fresh, just because you look -- you know, you look young and you look like you're making a lot of money, they'll stop you, they'll harass you, they'll go through your phone. And sometimes they check -- they search for messages from your bank, for example, so they could see your bank account balance. And when they do that, they drive you to an atm, get you to withdraw money and, you know, before they let you go. If they can't get money off you, they lock you up. We hear about several, several cases where they've locked people up and those people have disappeared because they were eventually killed. So, it's really, really crazy. If you're not as lucky when you encounter them, they could shoot you on the spot. It's all forms of violence. They beat people up. They, you know, torture people. They murder. They commit armed robbery. It's everything. It's everything. And there have been so many cases. And --</s>AMANPOUR: Let me just ask you a question. Let me ask you a question because you're right, this has been going on since about 2017. Now, as you know, the state governor in Lagos has denied there were any deaths, although despite video, despite Amnesty International and eyewitness, the Nigerian military or at least a wing of it, the army has said it's fake news, this -- you know, and they don't believe it. But here's what your president has said, because to an extent, he says that he's heard you and these forces should have been off the street, he says. Can we just play a little bit from his speech?</s>MUHAMMADU BUHARI, NIGERIAN PRESIDENT: The disbanding of SARS is only the first step in our commitment to extensive police reform in order to ensure that the primary duty of the police and other law enforcement agencies remains the protection of lives.</s>AMANPOUR: Falz, what do you make of that and what -- I mean, how much stock do you put in the pledges for police reform?</s>FALZ: It's infuriating. It's annoying. It's frustrating. And I think that's exactly how everyone is feeling. Because they've been reforming the police for the longest time but we've never actually seen actual action. And they said -- I was about to say, since 2017, they've been announcing that the SARS unit has been disbanded. They announced in 2017, announced in 2018, announced in 2019, now in 2020. After we started these protests, they announced again. And in the same breath, announced they were replacing that unit with a new unit called the Special Weapons and Tactics Unit. And it's just -- they just think we're stupid because you're literally just renaming this unit and expecting us to say, oh, yey, wow, that's great.</s>AMANPOUR: Can I ask you something because --</s>FALZ: It's insensitive.</s>AMANPOUR: I want to ask you what you're demanding. But first I want to ask you, because you alluded to, you know, the stressful situation and the lack of safety. There are a lot of young people who we've reached out to, a lot of people who were very upset and very -- you know, like you, but didn't want to appear on camera because they're afraid for their lives. Are you afraid for your own safety?</s>FALZ: I'm not afraid for my life. I'm not afraid for my life because where we are right now, I feel like I could easily die by anything else anyway, you know, like there's a share -- man, I don't even know where to start from. We have nonexistent health care, for example. We have a seriously high level of poverty. There's unemployment. It's in -- we're in a critical state because of how much corruption and just mismanagement of funds that we've -- you know, we continue to see on a daily basis. So, if I don't come out to sort of complain about the state of things, I could sit down and, you know, I could have an accident on my way to work or something and I could die as a result of that because of the state of the health care is nothing to write home about. We don't even have proper hospitals. Our hospitals aren't well equipped. You know, people have to travel abroad to get properly health care. And every Nigerian -- and we keep on saying this, every single Nigerian is one sickness away from passing away. So, what kind of life am I leaving anyway? Like why should I be afraid of dying? I'm going to die anyway, so what's the point?</s>AMANPOUR: Falz, let me ask you because some of the things you're saying resonate quite strongly with what's happening in the United States, certainly the racial uprising for justice, and obviously the need for equal health care and the like. And you know it's playing very heavily into the presidential election right now. I guess I want to ask you whether you feel a sense of solidarity coming from the U.S. and other places where politicians, government leaders and, you know, singers, artists, rap artists, are basically, you know, saying that they're coming -- they're supporting you. Do you feel a sense of solidarity?</s>FALZ: In a way, yes, and, you know, it's -- but I feel more -- it's more depressing to think about what we're going through because, you know, the whole Black Lives Matter movement happened in the United States and it's more -- that's a more complicated issue, you know, with racism and all that stuff. But out here, it's black people doing the same thing to their brothers. It's us. It's us on us violence. It's even more depressing to think about. So, it's a really, really terrible state that we're in right now. And there was a horrible, horrible massacre that went on Tuesday. And as a result, everywhere is up in flames. There's looting. There's shooting. There's -- it's a chaotic state right now. I don't even know where we're going from here.</s>AMANPOUR: And, Falz, I mean, you know, we always have to remind everybody, you know, you're talking about the biggest city in Africa. It's Nigeria's commercial capital. And this is a very rich country. It's had a hugely significant economy. Do you think the government will pay attention? And what precisely are you demanding to end this situation now?</s>FALZ: The government has to pay attention. All we're asking for is not to be killed. All we're asking for is not to be extorted. All we're asking for is not to be robbed by the officers that are supposed to be protecting our lives and property. All we're asking for is not to be raped. All we're asking for is not to be beaten up. I don't think it's too much to ask. There's so much evil that these officers are perpetrating, you know, under the police -- in the police uniform and all we're asking is this stops. We've continued to protest against this for about two weeks straight, and the government has just continued to drag its feet. They're not really giving any real response to what we're complaining about and it's very, very worrying to think about.</s>AMANPOUR: Falz, thank you very much, indeed. Thanks for giving us an update. And we understand, you know, the president is talking to the nation. We'll see whether he delivers on any of his promises. Falz, thanks for joining us from Lagos.</s>FALZ: Thank you so much.</s>AMANPOUR: And of course, we mentioned the United States and the election there. There's 12 days to go. And the final debate between the two contenders could signal the end of a campaign. A staggering 40 million votes have already been cast and counting. Joe Biden is leading comfortably in the polls and it seems the biggest battle the president faces is his handling of the coronavirus pandemic. Former president, Barack Obama, had a few words to say on the matter as he stumped for his vice president last night in Philadelphia.</s>BARACK OBAMA, FORMER U.S. PRESIDENT: We literally left this White House a pandemic playbook that would have shown them how to respond before the virus reached our shores. They probably used it to, I don't know, prop up a wobbly table somewhere. We don't know where that playbook went.</s>LIZ HARRINGTON, SPOKESWOMAN, REPUBLICAN NATIONAL COMMITTEE: I think we're going to see two completely different directions for the country. You couldn't get a bigger contrast in this election. Certainly, when it comes to the records of 47 years of failure with Joe Biden versus less than four years of success and history making achievements under President Trump. This was supposed to be the foreign policy debate. We wish it would come up more because President Trump has really succeeded on that. And now. we know just how corrupt Joe Biden was when he was supposed to be selling -- getting good deals for the American worker with China or Ukraine or Russia, and it seems the only good deals were people involving the Biden family, Biden Inc. and China Inc. And so, these are big issues. This election, do we want to continue with peace and prosperity under President Trump who built the greatest economy on record in 2019 which we'll even surpass that in 2021? Do we want to continue draining the swamp or do we want to fill it back up with career corrupt politicians who have never achieved anything for the American worker like Joe Biden? And I think that's a big choice for Americans and I think I know what they're going to do.</s>AMANPOUR: The choice is obviously very clear. You talk about draining the swamp. Speaking of, as you know "The New York Times" has reported that President Trump has a -- had a bank account in China. And this is quite unusual, certainly. And certainly, Former President Barack Obama brought it up last night. Just take a listen.</s>OBAMA: He's got a secret Chinese bank account. How is that possible? How is that possible? A secret Chinese bank account. Listen, can you imagine if I had a secret Chinese bank account when I was running for re-election? You think Fox News might have been a little concerned about that? They would have called me Beijing Barry.</s>AMANPOUR: Liz, he has a point, doesn't he? And let's just be clear, "The Times" is reporting the account is controlled by Trump International Hotels Management. Tax records show it paid $188,000 plus taxes in China while pursuing licensing deals there from 2013 to 2015. Now, the campaign and the White House says it's a dormant account. But that doesn't look great, does it?</s>HARRINGTON: Well, that has nothing to do with the swamp. You said 2013 to 2015. Where was Donald J. Trump? He was in Manhattan, he was building a business empire, he was living the American dream in the private sector. Where is "The New York Times" reporting on Joe Biden's dealings, big -- 10 held for H. Hunter for the big guy which we now have confirmed the big guy, according to Hunter Biden's former business associate is Joe Biden. We're talking tens of millions of dollars with associates of the Chinese communist party. Joe Biden, by his own admission, has never had a real job in his life. He said he's never cashed a paycheck. He's only ever been in the swamp. He's used his public office for personal gain. That is corruption. That's what we were running against in 2016, Hillary Clinton is the same thing. They use their power not to advance the interest of the American people and the American worker. Well, now we know, Joe Biden who never held China to account. They let China into the World Trade Organization. They've been ripping us off. They wouldn't take a hard line and they won't even blame China today for the pandemic that we're dealing with because of their cover-up. Well, now we know. Because he's completely beholden to China and there's hard, damning evidence that shows their connections and it's an absolute disgrace.</s>AMANPOUR: Liz, you actually sound like you're on a Fox News show right now. You sound a little bit like an anchor --</s>HARRINGTON: Well, unfortunately --</s>AMANPOUR: Even Fox News --</s>HARRINGTON: -- Fox News is the only news channel that's covering the real e-mails.</s>AMANPOUR: Even fox news would not touch this story that President Trump's --</s>HARRINGTON: That's not true.</s>AMANPOUR: -- personal lawyer, Rudy Giuliani, tried to dump. You know that. Even the "New York Post," the key reporter --</s>HARRINGTON: Fox News just confirmed Hunter Biden's former business associate, who identified by name, Joe Biden is the big guy, who's profiting off these shady foreign dealings.</s>AMANPOUR: Let me ask you this.</s>HARRINGTON: And it's not just China. It's Ukraine and it's $3.5 million from Moscow. There was --</s>AMANPOUR: All right. You wanted to go there. You wanted to go there.</s>HARRINGTON: There wasn't a dossier. It was real and it all had to involve the Bidens.</s>AMANPOUR: OK. You wanted to go there. You know perfectly well that the White House was warned in 2019 that Rudolf Giuliani, that is the president's personal lawyer, was "being used to feed Russian misinformation to the president. Giuliani met in December with somebody who the United States government believes is a Russian agent." You know who I'm talking about, the Ukrainian parliamentarian by the name of Andrii Derkach. Are you comfortable with the president of the United States being close to a person like Rudy Giuliani who also says also that he is not bothered whether any of the information comes from Russian hacking? What does that say?</s>HARRINGTON: Are you comfortable that CNN used Russian disinformation from a Russian asset to leak it to subvert the peaceful transfer of power? That reporting on the dossier was complete --</s>AMANPOUR: Liz, Liz --</s>HARRINGTON: -- complete verified Russian disinformation? Is it not? Is it not?</s>AMANPOUR: Liz, let's just get back to the story.</s>HARRINGTON: Was the dossier real? Was the dossier real? Oh, it's very relevant --</s>AMANPOUR: Can we get back to the current story?</s>HARRINGTON: -- because everything the Democrats accused us of doing is what they themselves did. Rudy Giuliani --</s>AMANPOUR: You know what, we always try -- we --</s>HARRINGTON: -- is not a Russian asset and we've heard the smear very well before.</s>AMANPOUR: It's the United States government who said it, not me and not CNN. The United States government has reported --</s>HARRINGTON: The FBI -- OK. You know what, also the United States government says, the FBI says, this laptop is not Russian disinformation. So, what are you talking about here, this laptop is real. It's not just a laptop. There's other e-mails, there's text messages. They are real. So, according to the U.S. government --</s>AMANPOUR: OK. I know that you're trying to move everybody to look at that but that's not what we're hearing from the</s>FBI. HARRINGTON: Why don't you want to report this? This is one of the most powerful families in Washington.</s>AMANPOUR: Liz, Liz, Liz--</s>HARRINGTON: The Biden family and you're OK, you're OK with our interests being selled out to profit --</s>AMANPOUR: Liz?</s>HARRINGTON: -- Joe Biden and his family when we're suffering during a pandemic from Communists China --</s>AMANPOUR: Yes. Absolutely, absolutely.</s>HARRINGTON: -- and he's doing shady deals --</s>AMANPOUR: Liz, as you know --</s>HARRINGTON: -- with Communist China and you're comfortable.</s>AMANPOUR: -- perfectly well, I'm a journalist and a reporter and I follow the facts. And there has never been any issues in terms of corruption. Now, let me ask you this. Yesterday, the</s>FBI -- HARRINGTON: Wait, wait, wait.</s>AMANPOUR: The</s>FBI -- HARRINGTON: How do you know that?</s>AMANPOUR: I'm talking about reporting and any evidence. I'm talking to you now --</s>HARRINGTON: I would love if you guys would start doing digging and start doing that verification.</s>AMANPOUR: Now, we're not going to do your work for you. I want to ask you a question --</s>HARRINGTON: That's a journalist's job.</s>AMANPOUR: -- contrary to what --</s>HARRINGTON: It's a journalist's job to find out if this is verified.</s>AMANPOUR: I want to ask you a question about the FBI press conference yesterday. So, the director of National Intelligence pointed to Russian and Iranian interference. Then the FBI director, CHRISTOPHER WRAY, talked about how people should be able to have faith in the American electoral system and in this country election. This is what he said.</s>CHRISTOPHER WRAY, FBI DIRECTOR: You should be confident that your vote counts. Early, unverified claims to the contrary should be viewed with a healthy dose of skepticism.</s>AMANPOUR: Are you -- does that make you feel good that actually he's saying that people should and can have faith in the election system? Because it's not what your president or your candidate is saying.</s>HARRINGTON: No, absolutely, we want a free and fair election. We want every valid vote that's cast by an eligible voter to count, of course. That's fundamental. And that's why President Trump has been sounding the alarm about sending ballots out, using inaccurate voter registration rolls. I mean, you're -- I'm in D.C., we have apartments that are getting tens of ballots of people that no longer live there to the wrong address. Is that a safe and secure election? Is that free and fair? That's what we don't like. Democrats are changing the rules. Their using inaccurate lists. They're trying to allow ballot harvesting, which is illegal in the vast majority of states. That threatens the legitimacy of our election when you have paid operatives going door to door and trafficking in-ballots. That's a joke. And we shouldn't have ballots counted for weeks after election day like they're doing in California. And that is a threat to our free and fair elections.</s>AMANPOUR: As you know, the Electoral Commission, the FBI, everybody's weighing in and saying people should not worry, there's no evidence of voter fraud, and that they should be able to go and cast their ballot. I want to ask you before we go, what about the polls? What about the polls?</s>HARRINGTON: Well, was there fraud in Patterson, New Jersey? Because four people were indicted. That is evidence.</s>AMANPOUR: Liz, your own administration had its own fraud panel after the first election, and then that had to disband for lack of evidence. So, let's just not go there. Can I ask you about the polls because that's really what I wanted to ask you? We're on the verge of the last face-to- face encounter. The polls do not look good for the president and yet, there are hope with some, you know, uptick in registration, in some of the key states. Do you believe the president has a tough hill to climb? How do you analyze what's happening right now at this moment in terms of his effort to turn this into a victory?</s>HARRINGTON: We -- I can tell you, we are in a better position today than we were four years ago. We have 2.5 million volunteers who have been working in these states, getting out, knocking on doors. The president is out there working every single day to earn American votes while Joe Biden is taking a week off, two weeks out before an election day. He clearly doesn't seem interested in actually working to earn your vote. We're getting our message to the people. Our polling indicates we're in a very strong position. And the media would be -- we've gone down that road before. We've seen what happens when they buy their own bogus polling, and that's what happened in 2016. I think they're in for another surprise in 2020.</s>AMANPOUR: Well, how about this polling? That may be as it is, but most Americans by a healthy majority want to keep Obamacare, Affordable Care Act, whatever you might want to call it. The president and the Republicans for the last 10 years have been trying to get rid of it and promising that there will be some kind of replacement. There literally hasn't been a plan. Americans need their health care, now possibly more than ever. As I said, the majority of people want to keep it, want to keep Obamacare. What do you -- I mean, it's going to come up in the Supreme Court shortly after the election. Can you imagine taking away health care at this particular point?</s>HARRINGTON: No, nobody is taking away health care. The people that are threatening to take away health care are the 180 million Americans who have private health insurance and Democrats are saying, oh, we're going to give away health care to illegal aliens, they're saying we need a public option, which was specifically designed to destroy private health insurance. Just ask Jacob Hacker who invented it. That's a real threat to health care. We'll see what the Supreme Court rules. President Trump has already been acting on this. We got rid of the individual mandate. We've lowered prescription drug prices for the first time in decades. We've opened up competition across state lines. On January -- in January 2021, we're going to have the most favored nations, new standard, which will really reduce cost. We want more choice and competition and we certainly want to protect the private health insurance industry because most -- the vast majority of Americans have private health care and they like it and they want to keep their plans. And everything the Democrats are talking about is a real threat, a DMV style health care system where government mandates who can go to a doctor and where and when. That is the real threat to health care in this country and especially, the seniors and our most vulnerable with pre-existing conditions. They will be the back of the line when you have health care rationing under a Democrat-run government plan.</s>AMANPOUR: Apparently not for two-thirds of the country. And all I was asking you is where is the plan that President Obama -- sorry, President Trump --</s>HARRINGTON: President Trump has released plans. He --</s>AMANPOUR: We've never seen it.</s>HARRINGTON: Yes, he has. Yes, he absolutely has released plans. We'll see what the Supreme Court does. But why should you have to keep this --</s>AMANPOUR: Anyway --</s>HARRINGTON: -- monstrosity of a 2,000-page bill that you have to pass it to find out what's in it when we can protect people with --</s>AMANPOUR: The two-thirds of the American people want.</s>HARRINGTON: We don't have to keep all the mandates in government that come with Obamacare. That's very unpopular by the way and --</s>AMANPOUR: Liz Harrington, thank you very much. 62 percent.</s>HARRINGTON: It is. Look at the --</s>AMANPOUR: Liz Harrington, thank you very much, indeed. I tried. I tried my best.</s>HARRINGTON: Thank you.</s>AMANPOUR: For the first time in nearly 100 years, "Time" magazine has replaced its logo. Vote, it says, it is time. Now, what it means to be American in both body and soul has been on our next guest's mind for years. Playwright, Ayad Akhtar, won the Pulitzer prize in 2013 for his candid and thought-provoking play "Disgraced" on the identity crisis among Muslims after the 9/11 terror attacks. The conversation continues in his new book "Homeland Elegies," part memoir, part novel, it looks at the immigration experience through a son's relationship with his father who happens to support the anti-immigrant Trump. Here he is discussing this fraught family dynamic with our Hari Sreenivasan.</s>HARI SREENIVASAN, CNN INTERNATIONAL CORRESPONDENT: Christiane, thanks so much. Ayad Akhtar, thanks for joining us. The narrator in this story is a Pakistani American with your name who also grew up in Milwaukee, who also happens to be a playwright, but this is definitely a novel.</s>AYAD AKHTAR, AUTHOR, "HOMELAND ELEGIES": It is, if only because I wouldn't know how to write a nonfiction memoir. I mean, I was so scared to -- you know, to get canceled like James Springer or something like that because, you know, I'm compositing and, you know, collapsing events and I'm taking things from multiple time periods and I'm putting them into a 24-hour -- you know, I'm doing what most dramatic writers do. And in the process of doing that, I kind of took so many liberties with the facts of, you know, sort of my parents and all of that stuff that I couldn't really realistically call it a memoir. And plus, I think if I wrote a memoir and tried to be true to the facts, it wouldn't be nearly as interesting as what I was able to hopefully create in a novel.</s>SREENIVASAN: Tell me what this book's about.</s>AKHTAR: I mean, I think the way I've been describing it is that I wanted to tell the story of my parents and their generation of immigrants. They came over about half a century ago, 50 years ago. And what happened to them and their kids, meaning my generation, in the 50 years that they were here. And what that says about what America was to them when they came and then maybe what it became over the course of that time as told by one of their kids, myself, or the narrator who has my name in many facts of my life and who has written about them in the past and gotten in trouble with them. So there's a little bit of there's some hijinks there.</s>SREENIVASAN: So, this is the opposite of a tweet. This is the opportunity for you to lay out everything in hundreds of pages. I want to ask. There is a certain option here for readers that -- to maybe punch through some of the noise that we're always seeing, right? You're publishing a novel like this at a time when our news cycle is so fast and furious, our alerts on our phones are always going off, and yet here you are trying to say, give me some space, give me some time.</s>AKHTAR: Yes. I mean, I think that's that's exactly what I hope the book is trying to do. It's playing by that game of sort of ensnaring the reader's attention with the breaking news obsessions and the Instagram scroll absorption, but it's doing so in order -- there's all of the prurient, sort of sensationalist attraction in the book. But it's doing so to provoke a deeper conversation, I think, ultimately about how to think about our country and what's happened to our country. And by think, I don't just mean intellectually thinking. I mean emotional thinking, because I think that literature at its best is something -- it's a kind of form of expression that is conditioned by emotional nuance, as well as intellectual precision.</s>SREENIVASAN: Yes, there's a couple of big themes, for me, at least, as a reader, or a listener in this case for your audiobook. One was identity. And I want to read a quick passage about that. And you are -- the narrator is explaining this to a billionaire friend at a bar, as we all do, of course.</s>SREENIVASAN: "We were outsiders. At least my parents were, because you know what? They came from somewhere else. That's what outsiders are. And it didn't bother them. There was a culture here. They had to learn. And they never really did, not the way those who are born into it do. "Don't get me wrong, my father loves America, loves it more than makes sense to me sometimes, frankly. He thinks he's American, but what that really means is that he still wants to be American. He still doesn't really feel like one. It's been 45 years, and he still doesn't really understand what it means, because being American is not about what they tell you, freedom and opportunity and all that horse</s>AKHTAR: Well, it's important to remember the context of that conversation. He's speaking to a billionaire. And it's a chapter which is really about the predominancy of wealth in this country, as not only the expression of willpower excellence, the making money is the expression of willpower excellence, but also the kind of valorization of being. Wealth accords us in this country not only status and legitimacy. I think it's, subliminally, the real reason that Donald Trump has any sway over the American people, is because we worship wealth in a way. But, also, wealth is the means to full citizenship. In order to really have an influence on the franchise and on the election, for example, it's not your vote that matters as much as how much money you're willing to donate. So, this is kind of a metaphor, I think, for the ways in which money has come to dominate American life in almost all ways. I mean, I think that we are increasingly customers to reality and less citizens of a republic. I think citizenship and civics have given away to consumerism. And that's not a new story. But I think that it's something that has gone so far that the consequences are now socially very widespread.</s>SREENIVASAN: So, that leads perfectly to a passage that I'd like you to read about the power of money.</s>AKHTAR: "Yes, money had always been central to notions of American vitality, but now it reigned as our supreme defining value. It was no longer just the purpose of our toil, but also our sport and our pastime. "We discuss a movie's weekend gross before its plotline, an outfielder signing bonus before his batting average. The market had seeped into our language. We sought upside and minimized our exposure and worried about the best investment of our sweat equity. Even suffrage was monetized. True political power lay not in the ballot box, but in one's capacity to write a check. "We were now customers first and foremost not citizens, and to buy was our privileged act. No longer ruled by a personified abstraction, Zeus or Yahweh, we now appeased a material one, the economy. We feared its humors. We were grateful for its dispensations. We tended to its imagined well- being with our ritual purchases. "When the economy was well, we were happy people. When the economy faltered, premonitions of doom were never far."</s>SREENIVASAN: So, what do we lose as this shift is happening?</s>AKHTAR: Economic well-being cannot become the sole metric for human flourishing. We're seeing this across universities, for example. When you have the only metric being cash flow coming into the coffers, then some of the more intangible pursuits, the humanities or philosophy, music, whatnot, begin to get cut. It's what's happening at the University of Wisconsin, a state that I know very well. But, when that happens, it's not just that we're losing -- we're losing something that we like. We're losing something essential about being human. I mean, teaching children, for example, song is not just about giving them some imprint of the national anthem or whatnot. It's about attunement to reality, to cadence, to rhythm, to being able to sing, to express openheartedly with others in a community. I mean, these are fundamental human capacities that we're developing at early ages, which, because we don't recognize their value on a spreadsheet, begin to fall by the wayside. What we're going to see, I think, if we continue to let this happen, is something fundamentally impoverished about our societies and something that will ultimately have a significant economic impact, even though we can't track it, obviously.</s>SREENIVASAN: What's also interesting is the relationship that your narrator has with his father. I don't know how much of this is true for your father in real life. But their notions of what success is when they came, so to speak, from the old country, and what they strove for, and how, in this case, the father in the story is aligned with the president to be and the president, Donald Trump.</s>AKHTAR: Well, in the first chapter, I tell the story of my father in the book, who -- my real father was also a cardiologist and a specialist of arrhythmias and world famous and sort of treated a lot of dignitaries and whatnot. And in the book, he -- in the middle of the '90s, he is Donald Trump's doctor very briefly and gets to know him a little bit then kind of becomes enamored with Donald Trump. And this is the reason why, in 2015-2016, he's a supporter of the Trump campaign, even though there's all kinds of egregious statements being made about Muslims and whatnot that should theoretically threaten his own citizenship or his own well-being in this country, but they don't seem to. And it's a way of sort of getting inside the intergenerational conflict, as well as the political conflict that has unfolded in this country, and also to try to tell a story that elucidates or brings out the kind of human dimension of an attachment to Trump.</s>SREENIVASAN: Because one of the things that you realize as you read this is that, so often, the kind of dominant narratives want to clump immigrants into a particular bucket. And that's just not the case. I mean, we're a pretty complex group of people. We are getting into a complicated relationship between a father and a son. They're disagreeing on politics. This is not one lump sum voting bloc.</s>AKHTAR: Yes. I mean, it's kind of an interesting paradox that those who would espouse the values of diversity don't always share the constituents of that diverse cohort, right, that there are lots of left-leaning, capitalist-driven, ideological -- ideologically right immigrants in this country. And in this book, my father is one of them. Yes, it's an important -- it was an important part of the story for me to tell.</s>SREENIVASAN: You use one of the characters in your book, Mike, and there's sort of conversation about how, really, in a lot of ways, the left and the Democratic Party just forgot about a huge chunk of the country that was relevant to everyone else. And he's speaking from kind of different voices. And you can pick whichever one you like. But what was the thing that you were trying to get across to the reader in that -- in kind of the use of Mike and how basically, for him, he's come to a -- well, he's come to a place where he can have pretty divergent viewpoints about certain things and still go sleep at night?</s>AKHTAR: Mike Jacobs in the book is a successful Hollywood executive who is someone who believes that bettering the life of his fellow black Americans is a top priority, and has come to the conclusion that paying taxes to a government built by whites is not something that he can countenance. And so it, paradoxically, leads to him voting for Republicans...</s>AKHTAR: ... who make -- who have endeavored to make life worse for black Americans. And that paradox is something that the narrator and him, he -- they get into quite a bit of conflict over this, because they're friends. I think Mike's perspective, which is not a totally concocted perspective -- I won't say anything more about it than that -- is something that I thought was important to include, because his analysis is very, very clear-eyed, a little cynical, but clear-eyed about -- that the ways in which race and identity inform and shape economic decisions, and that, fundamentally, somebody like Mike, who sees the picture very clearly, recognizes that it really is all about money, and where the money you have, where you're spending it, et cetera, et cetera. The Democratic Party, just to get back to the prelude of your question, moved to the right. They had to. Reagan was a transformative figure. Whether for good or whether for bad depends on your political point of view, but he was a transformative figure and changed the ideology of this country, enshrining, legislatively, as well as mythologically, the acquisition of personal wealth as a supreme American value. And so, in order to make a play for the political center, Clinton had to move to the right. And so it's meant that the Democratic Party has moved to the right. And it's also meant that Goldman Sachs, which is the sort of American global diplomatic corps when it comes to economic policy, has been in charge of economic policy, at the forefront of economic policy for two generations. So that's -- there's a through line between Reagan and Obama that's undeniable. There's lots of variation there, but there's a clear line that you can draw, and that line has moved away from the heartland, it's moved away from locality, it's moved away from the middle class, it's moved away from industrial, it's moved away from an economy that makes things, it's moved away from any meaningful, helpful form of protectionism, all of those things under the guise of international competition.</s>SREENIVASAN: Going back a little bit to "Disgraced," and that, if I can summarize your plan in 20 seconds, so we have got a Muslim man who, at a dinner party with his white wife, he's fairly successful and affluent, a conversation turns to 9/11. And he basically exposes almost a moment of pride, and that kind of leads to this -- the central tension that you throw on the audience. In this, it's not really just the tension of that defining moment for Muslim Americans or Muslims all over the world. It really seems like it's not just the towers falling. You're talking about a man struggling with his entire country falling.</s>AKHTAR: Yes. No, that's exactly right. I mean, I think the argument of the book, if you will, that begins with a kind of -- a lecture that a college professor is talking about America and its legacy as a colony, where, in a way, the country is still defined by its own plunder, by its own citizens plundering the nation. And, in the book, I'm at the time barely 20 years old, and I don't really understand what this professor is getting at. And I say that it took me 15 years to understand it, and that, even 9/11, and even the difficulties for Muslims and people in my family after 9/11 did not help me to understand better what had really happened in this country. It wasn't until I started to see the larger picture of the suffering that all of us had been going through, that I started to get a picture of actually what had happened to America.</s>SREENIVASAN: Post-9/11, post-"Disgraced," post a lot of the pushback and criticism that you have gotten in taking on these topics, in writing about how Muslim Americans may feel, what kind of kept your faith in the country, or has it been shaken so thoroughly that you are cynical now?</s>AKHTAR: No, I wouldn't call myself cynical. I mean, I think I'm hopeful about life in this country, because I'm hopeful about my experiences with others that I have here. And I think -- I come from Wisconsin, and I spent a lot of time still back in my home state. And I do love the state. I do love the community that I come from. I think, as an artist, as somebody who's an outsider, by not just because of identity, but also because of chosen vocation, it's my job to take a look at things and to sort of outline them, rather than to, I don't know, celebrate, needlessly celebrate our greatness. I think the analogy -- I often get the question, what country does it better, right? Well, why are you criticizing America? What country does it better? And when I get that question in Wisconsin, I always just turn to the Green Bay Packers, and I say, well, we have got a pretty good team. We have made it the NFC championships last year. But people had a lot of complaints about how Aaron Rodgers was calling plays and whether the head coach was dealing with Aaron Rodgers very well There were a lot of criticisms. You listen to talk radio, people had all kinds of opinions about -- criticize -- does that mean that we don't love the Green Bay Packers, or that we're not trying to make the Green Bay Packers a Super Bowl contender this year? It seems to me that the idea that somehow critiquing our country is some is -- I don't know, it's not the patriotic? I don't know. It's certainly our generation, a younger generation who has had a different experience of America maybe than our parents have. The mythologies that they grew up with were mythologies that translated to real change, real experiences for them. Their lives got better. A lot of folks who were sort of my age and were really younger than me, their lives are not getting better. And so their experience of America is very different. So it stands to reason that they would have a more critical approach to it.</s>SREENIVASAN: Ayad Akhtar. The book is called "Homeland Elegies." Thanks so much.</s>AKHTAR: Oh, thank you.</s>CHRISTIANE AMANPOUR, CNN INTERNATIONAL HOST: And, finally, whether it's public book readings, concerts, rock bands, or the opera, many of us are missing the joys of live performances. And, of course, all the artists on and off stage are suffering too, loss of jobs, livelihood and joy. But it's also sparked creative brilliance from some of the greats, like Bruce Springsteen with the E Street Band. His "Letter to You" is out tomorrow. And Paul McCartney is also getting ready to release a new lockdown solo album, "McCartney III." And the American artist Melody Gardot, who's out with a new jazz album "Sunset in the Blue." Here's a bit from one of the tracks called "Little Something," which she performed as a duet with Sting.</s>AMANPOUR: Oh, I could listen to a lot more of that, music for the soul. And Melody Gardot is joining me now from Paris. Welcome to the program. That was lovely. I want to ask you that, were you together? It looks like you guys were together. Were you together singing that? Or how did that come about?</s>MELODY GARDOT, MUSICIAN: In that particular clip, yes, we were. But the incarnation of the music, unfortunately, was deterred by the circumstances we all know so well globally around the world, meaning it was not being able to fly, not being able to come together. So it was interesting to have a piece of music done on two different continents, especially as a duet. That's not typical for me at all in the kind of music I have done. And we had to come up with a way to say, do we wait, or do we just give it a shot? And so, the first time we met was there in Tuscany about two weeks ago to three weeks, I think. But we met through music. We never spoke. We discussed. We just listened to each other's ideas on the recording and then finally met up afterwards.</s>AMANPOUR: And the whole album, how did it come together? Because, as you say, I mean, it's just completely unusual circumstances. How did you -- I think you -- I think you produced it at the Abbey Road Studios here in London. How did the whole thing come together?</s>GARDOT: Well, this was quite an ambitious move to decide to push through during this time. And I think our first feeling of, OK, we can do this was with a track that we released as a single to benefit health care workers. This was a single called "From Paris With Love," where we had orchestra musicians all around the world record themselves while quarantined. And then they sent in their performances. And we just put the music online and said, give it a shot and we will do our best to try to put it together. Those that had the most competent sonics were chosen and then also paid. And we, bizarrely, somehow managed to get that word out so quick that, within a week, we had some 50 countries around the world where people were playing. And so it was this impossible global orchestra, players I have never met, that perhaps I never would have met before, and very symbolic to the thought and the notion that we can continue to create, despite this distance. And so that gave us a bit of ammunition. And when we moved forward, the discussions were, again, do we wait until everything is back to normal? When is normal?</s>AMANPOUR: Yes.</s>GARDOT: How do we make music during this time? And Abbey Road had been closed. And we found out that there was going to be an opening. And so they spoke to us. We spoke to them. And they agreed for us to be the first session back after Abbey Road had closed for the first time since World War I, which was quite phenomenal, very symbolic, again. It's this idea of everyone coming together and giving their best effort and their best energy in a moment that kind of forces us to think that that would be impossible.</s>AMANPOUR: It is an amazing thing to think about that, that it would be -- it was closed, and you were the first to go back into it. But, also, I think you have been very cognizant of the fact that so many musicians are hurting, so many are out of work. and just the whole artistic landscape has been devastated by this, all the performers, the backstages, and everybody, as well as the actual performers. Is that -- that's kind of one of the reasons why you wanted to get something done, right, to keep people employed, working, a little bit of inspiration?</s>GARDOT: Of course. I mean, it's a trifecta, in a way, because, look, I have worked with orchestral musicians for many years, and the last two years prior to making this record, and toured with a number of beautiful players. These are the kind of people that do music because they love it. And they're not making seven-figure salaries, six-figure salaries. They're supporting their families, et cetera. So, when all the philharmonics were closing, when this was all kind of falling apart, that was my first instinct, was to look to my colleagues and say, what can we do to help? Of course, we can't help everyone, but doing something like that can inspire others, my colleagues and the people who have opportunities to create to do the same. So, that was the first. We're athletes. We're used to playing every day. So there's the physical aspect that's in danger, the financial aspect, and then just the morale, because, for some of us, in terms of music, it's arguably more important than food, in the sense that it nourishes us. And so, when you take it away, it's as if there's nothing to look forward to, and there's only so much Bach you can play before you're tired, says my friend from Armenia. We must find a way to continue to create new things and create new music and, despite this inability to physically be in the same room, use the technology we have, as I'm doing now with you to be with you...</s>GARDOT: ... and continue to move forward. And that's something I have always tried to do in my own personal life, with my own history, is that, no matter what the news feels like, when you have been handed the long list of bad things that have happened, you have to try to spin it and look at the bright side. And the bright side is a matter of how much energy you're willing to give to push through, how much you're willing to weigh that against more serious things. In this moment, I think it's quite easy, because we recognize that health is the most important for everyone. And now that we have that before us, slamming us in the face in a way, OK, broadcast, take care of yourselves. Without that, there's nothing. We can move forward and go, OK, I'm healthy, I have my body, I have my arms, I have my family. It's actually not that bad. We can continue to move forward. It's just the initial shockwave of not being able to do what you're used to that causes that stress, that pressure, that almost depression, because you have been forced to change. It's not as if you woke up and decided, I'm going to move in another way. Someone's come into your life and said, in fact, no, you mustn't do this anymore. The thing that gave you great pleasure no longer exists.</s>AMANPOUR: Yes. Yes.</s>GARDOT: And that's the problem. It's that resistance. We're creatures of habit.</s>AMANPOUR: Resistance is a good way to describe it. And music is, I guess. It really is. Thank you so much, indeed, for joining us. And that's it for now. You can always catch us online, on our podcast and across social media. And we're going to leave you now with more of the wonderful music of Melody Gardot, "From Paris With Love." END
Former Prime Minister Saad Hariri to Lead Lebanon; Feds Say Russia and Iran Have Interfered with the Presidential Election
UNIDENTIFIED MALE: Lebanon set to appoint former prime minister Saad Hariri to a new government.</s>EMMANUEL MACRON, PRESIDENT OF FRANCE (through translator): I'm ashamed for your leaders. I'm ashamed for them.</s>UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: We don't feel victorious.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: The revolution did not die.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: The regime doesn't change by protesting on the ground.</s>BEN WEDEMAN, CNN SR. INTERNATIONAL CORRESPONDENT: This is going on against the backdrop of a failing economy.</s>BECKY ANDERSON, CNN HOST: This hour, everything old, new again. At least in Lebanese politics. Saad Hariri set to become prime minister once again. But will Donald Trump get set to run America for another four years? He will collide with Joe Biden right on this stage at the final presidential debate just hours from now, with 12 days and counting before what will be a historic U.S. election. More on that in a few minutes' time. First up, though, to Lebanon. The country has a brand-new leader -- of sorts. There is nothing really new about Saad Hariri. He is not only old guard, he's been here before. He is the prime minister who called it quits nearly a year ago at the height of Lebanon's popular protests to be rid of its ruling elite. Fast forward and people are still protesting, mostly because life is even tougher now. Lebanon's economy still on its knees, only now it has a COVID surge as well to deal with. And the fallout from August's devastating blast, which ripped through the capital, Beirut, killing more than 200 people. Now the new prime minister designate is just as caught up in the tragic mess of it all as everyone else. All Lebanon really wants is change for the better. But can a four-time prime minister deliver it? And there is a question looming, where is the French president? Not long ago, it looked like Emmanuel Macron was coming to the rescue after the Beirut blast in August. Mr. Macron did come up with reforms in an initiative that Mr. Hariri has vowed to push through.</s>SAAD HARIRI, LEBANESE PRIME MINISTER DESIGNATE (through translator): I will start by forming the government quickly because the time is running out and this is our beloved country's last and only chance.</s>ANDERSON: Let's get to Beirut, where I'm joined by Bel Trew, Middle East correspondent for "The Independent." Good to have you. Hariri pledging to work to stop the collapse threatening the Lebanese economy, Lebanese society and indeed security. Time is running out, he says. This is the country's last and only chance. So what has changed to persuade anyone that, this time, Hariri is the man to turn the tide?</s>BEL TREW, "THE INDEPENDENT": In short, nothing has really changed. In fact, since he stepped down last year, the country has got progressively worse in terms of pretty much everything. The economy has completely collapsed,; according to the U.N. nearly 60 percent of the country is trapped in poverty, which is double last year's rates. The currency has lost 80 percent of its value. Food prices are doubling. The government threatened it's going to have to cut subsidies, which could see prices of things like fuel, electricity and bread quadruple in price. People are poorer. There have been people back on the streets even as recently as the weekend because they are marking the anniversary of the start of what was called the October revolution. So they don't really see it. The protesters I've been speaking to don't see how he can make any difference whatsoever. And they see him really as part of the old guard they have taken to the streets to fight against. One protester said that the whole point of the rallies was to stop this, what they called generational politics because Hariri has not only been in power himself but his father was a prime minister as well. So really people see this as rearranging the chairs on the deck of a ship that's sinking. What they want to see is key change. He has promised to form a government of nonpartisan specialists. He said it's the last opportunity and he has pledged to push ahead with this French initiative. But there's little hope here, unfortunately.</s>ANDERSON: I wonder who those members of his government will be and whether we will recognize any of the names as those evolve.</s>ANDERSON: Of course, Emmanuel Macron in the past month seemingly washing his hands of Lebanon, calling the action of the leadership there a betrayal to him and the people of Lebanon. Does Hariri have his support? Because he sure is going to need support from across the international community, isn't he?</s>TREW: Absolutely. In terms of domestic support, he only won by a slim majority of 65 votes to 120, of those who voted in favor for him was his own bloc, the future movement, the Shia movement. But notably who withheld support with the president's Michel Aoun's party, the free patriotic movement and Hezbollah. Although we understand they do implicitly support his return to politics. In terms of the international community, it's still early days. I think they're going to be slightly galled like the rest of people here in Lebanon that he's returning to politics, in that the situation is like it was before. That wasn't working. But he has vowed to push forward with reforms, which may open up access to much needed international aid.</s>ANDERSON: I spoke to the head of the IMF recently, alongside Melinda Gates. We were having a wide ranging discussion, not least about the equitable distribution of vaccines. But we did talk about Lebanon and it was an important conversation to have with the MD of the IMF. And I asked Kristalina Georgieva for her take and this is what she told me.</s>KRISTALINA GEORGIEVA, MANAGING DIRECTOR, IMF: It is so sad to see Lebanon, a country of entrepreneurial people, very smart people, very generous people, to be in such a dire situation. And why is the country there? Because of lack of political determination, unity of purpose. We are ready and very willing to help Lebanon. We need a partner.</s>ANDERSON: She said we need a reliable partner as a follow-up. Is Saad Hariri that reliable partner that the IMF and others want at this point?</s>TREW: I guess it depends who you speak to. Certainly in terms of the protesters, the answer is definitively no. And that's why they wanted him to resign last year during massive protests. If you were to speak to his supporters and people within the parliament, they would say that he is but he has got sort of cross-party support-ish. He's obviously very experienced and he has promised to push ahead. But really, just being here in Beirut, it's hard to see why no one is making any changes, why there hasn't been reform. There are millions of euros' worth of financial support that countries have pledged to help Lebanon, specifically after the devastating August blast. But it can't be unlocked until these political financial changes and reforms are made. In the interim, people are almost starving. It's impossible to see how families are able to survive. And they have the winter coming up, when there will be shortages of electricity, fuel, food and money. And it's going to be hard to see how those changes can happen in that difficult environment.</s>ANDERSON: A year ago, I spoke to the former interior minister. I asked her at the time whether Lebanon was at a dead end. Just have a listen to what she told me then.</s>RAYA HAFTAR EL HASSAN, FORMER LEBANESE INTERIOR MINISTER: No, I don't think Lebanon has reached a dead end. Obviously business cannot run as usual. So there has to be a change in the mindset of the politicians. I think, by forming a technocratic government, that's a step in the right direction. It's a different ball game. Things have to change.</s>ANDERSON: It almost seems positively naive to have asked her that back then. I mean, you know, you've talked about the word on the street. Let's just also hear from some protesters.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE (through translator): The revolution did not die. We can hold this corrupt authority to account. And the proof is that we brought down two governments. They are arguing with each other about not being able to take a decision. They were exposed in front of the international community and their corruption was exposed. They were careless about the Lebanese people and careless about the Lebanese economy. So this whole corrupt leadership was exposed.</s>ANDERSON: This as Saad Hariri is the country's "last and only chance." I wonder what you believe he means by that and, in the short term, what needs to happen next.</s>TREW: I think what he means by that is they cannot afford to have another cabinet resign. They cannot afford to have no reforms being pushed through. They cannot afford to not make changes that mean -- that unlocks the key, which is an IMF loan. How that actually happens in practice is yet to be seen. As far as I can see, as far as people here in Lebanon can see, there doesn't seem to be any willingness to actually change and push through reforms. There will be some changes, for example, the lifting of subsidies. But that's happening not because of reform but because of financial necessity. What he actually means, he's going to have to prove to the people -- because people are asking question themselves. How is there going to be any difference? How is he going to, as he failed before, make any changes whatsoever? The situation has got worse since he was last in power. This is an almost unprecedented financial crisis. Swathes (sic) of Beirut are still completely devastated. In my neighborhood, which was blown up, there is rubble everywhere, glass everywhere and, you know, buildings and homes destroyed.</s>ANDERSON: Bel Trew is on the ground for us in Beirut in Lebanon, thank you for your insight and your analysis. We stay on this story, of course, it is so important. Thank you.</s>ANDERSON: It's been what would appear to be a stunning announcement from America's top intelligence official, just days out from the presidential election there. At a last-minute news conference, pulled together on Wednesday night, the Director of National Intelligence, John Ratcliffe, alleging that both Russia and Iran got a hold of voter registration information and are now attempting to interfere in America's election. Have a listen.</s>JOHN RATCLIFFE, DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL INTELLIGENCE: We would like to alert the public that we have identified that two foreign actors, Iran and Russia, have taken specific actions to influence public opinion relating to our elections. We have already seen Iran sending spoofed emails designed to intimidate voters, incite social unrest and damage President Trump.</s>ANDERSON: Well, let me show you one of those alleged emails from Iran, saying "Vote for Trump or else." Now we don't know how many emails like this were sent out but Google tells CNN about 2,500 landed in users' inboxes. The goal of all of this, Ratcliffe claims, is to damage the president. Democrats on the House Homeland Security Committee didn't seem to be buying it, going as far as calling Ratcliffe "a partisan hack" but deleting that tweet soon after. Russia and Iran denying all these accusations. From the capitals of both the United States and Russia, we are connecting this story for you from every angle. Let's begin with Alex Marquardt, who is in Washington for you. What do you make of what we have heard and seen?</s>ALEX MARQUARDT, CNN SENIOR NATIONAL SECURITY CORRESPONDENT: You're right; it was a surprising press conference. We had not been told that this was going to happen. You look at the people, the men who were up there, these officials. These are the seniormost national security officials in charge of safeguarding this election. So what they say carries a lot of weight. This is the first time they have come out with an accusation like this, saying that voter registration data has been obtained by foreign powers, implicating, attributing these actions to Russia and to Iran. It's less about how they obtained that data; it's actually not that difficult to get that data. It's what they're doing with it. And what Iran is doing, according to the Director of National Intelligence, John Ratcliffe, in part, is sending emails to voters, intimidating emails to voters, making them look like they're coming from this pro-Trump far right group, the Proud Boys, which we have heard a lot about of late. You read one of those emails; another one we saw said, "Vote for Trump or we will come after you." Now Ratcliffe got himself into a little bit of hot water there because he said that this was done to damage President Trump. Now there is no doubt that emails like this from Iran will intimidate voters, as he said, incite social unrest, as he said. It's not as clear how those will damage President Trump. So a lot of Democrats today are voicing their skepticism because Ratcliffe has been roundly accused of partisanship in the past few weeks. He has done several things that were clearly meant to benefit President Trump politically. So he is getting criticized today by Democrats. But what he has said is in line, in fact, with what the intelligence community has assessed.</s>MARQUARDT: For more than two months now, they have said that Iran is working to undermine President Trump. And this is an example that they are giving of what they are doing. The intelligence community has also said that Russia is working to denigrate Biden; so in favor of President Trump. One thing we did not hear very much about last night, Becky, is Russia. They did mention it but they did not detail the lengths to which Russia is going to meddle in this election.</s>ANDERSON: Fascinating. Let's bring in someone who has spent years covering stories in Russia and Iran for CNN. Fred Pleitgen joining us from Moscow. Fred, what are the Russians and, indeed, the Iranians saying in response to this news?</s>FREDERIK PLEITGEN, CNN SENIOR INTERNATIONAL CORRESPONDENT: Hi, there, Becky. Alex is absolutely right. While there was some substance and details about what the U.S. is accusing Iran of with those emails, under the Proud Boys' name, the Iranians they deny. What the Russians were likely doing with that data, there was very little about that in that press statement from John Ratcliffe. Still, the Russians came out today and denied the allegations, as they usually do in situations like this. There was a call earlier today with the spokesman of the Kremlin, Dmitry Peskov. He said, "It is with regret that we can comment on these accusations," as he put it, "accusations are being poured over us every day. They are all absolutely unsubstantiated and not based on anything. More likely, it is a part of the internal political process in connection with the upcoming elections." It's one of the things that the Russians have been saying for a very long time, they believe that a lot of the -- or they say they believe --that a lot of the accusations that are levied and thrown towards Moscow, that those have more to do with internal American political matters than with Russia themselves. And then you have the Iranians. And I think one of the things that was really key in this also, Becky, is that the Iranians came out very, very quickly with an angry denial; in fact, they did so last night. It was the spokesperson for their United Nations missions, who came out with a tweet. I want to also read you part of that, because he says, "Unlike the U.S., Iran does not interfere in other countries' elections," obviously denying the allegations. "The world has been witnessing," he tweeted, "U.S.' own desperate public attempts to question the outcome of its own election at the highest level," seemingly referencing some of the things that President Trump may have been saying about the upcoming elections over the past couple of weeks. And then saying, quote, "These accusations are nothing more than another scenario to undermine voter confidence and are absurd. Iran has no interest in interfering with the U.S. election and no preference for the outcomes." That denial coming from the Iranians, quite a strong one coming from the Iranians. One of the things we have to keep in mind, Becky, relations between the Trump administration -- and we have covered this many times -- and Iran have been at absolute rock bottom for a very long time.</s>ANDERSON: Absolutely. Fred, thank you for that. Fred Pleitgen is in Moscow for you this evening, Alex was in Washington. Just ahead on CONNECT THE WORLD, here is a live look at the U.S. presidential debate center. Donald Trump and Joe Biden will make their final pleas to voters there a few hours from now. And one of the biggest talking points will be the pandemic, an issue, of course, not just in the U.S. but globally. Coming up, we get the picture from Europe, which is dealing with a surge of new cases. Plus traffickers in India take advantage of economic desperation during COVID-19 lockdowns. Calls for action amid reports that children are being sold by their own families.
Erratic Trump and Deliberate Biden Prepare for Debate
TRUMP: All you hear is COVID, COVID, COVID, COVID. COVID, COVID, COVID. That's all they put on because they want to scare the hell out of everyone.</s>ANDERSON: It's not just America, we're all thinking about COVID-19 all over the world. It's a pandemic, right? It's scary. And it's perhaps nowhere more acute than in America, where more than 40 million Americans, who have already made their choice for who will be their next president. Early and mail-in balloting shows voter interest in this election is simply off the charts. In a few hours, the final live showdown between president Donald Trump and Joe Biden -- here is a look at the debate hall in Nashville, Tennessee, where both will try to seal the deal for what few undecided voters may be left. After the sound and fury of their first debate, President Trump running behind Biden in national polls but within striking range in several of what are known as these key battleground states. There will be one new tool tonight in the debate hall, a mute button designed to muzzle at least some of the outbursts that turned the first showdown into a loud, ugly brawl. Our senior political analyst, John Avlon, is here with what is at stake. You heard, John -- and thanks for joining us -- you heard the setup there with Donald Trump, bemoaning the fact that it's all about COVID. He says it's nothing more. This is what Barack Obama had to say earlier on today. He is, of course, back on the campaign trail for Joe Biden. Have a listen.</s>BARACK OBAMA, FORMER PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: Just yesterday, when asked if he would do anything differently, Trump said, "Not much." Really? Not much? Nothing you can think of that could have helped some people keep their loved ones alive?</s>ANDERSON: If he gets asked that question tonight, do you think it's likely that he will say "Not much?"</s>JOHN AVLON, CNN SENIOR POLITICAL ANALYST: Yes. Donald Trump is not going to change. He is Captain Chaos, he lives in a Trump-centric universe and there is a 0 percent chance that he's going to change. He may try to shade certain things to be slightly less offensive to, for example, suburban women, who he needs to court -- and knows it. The mute button will be a duel, some of that reigning in for him. And of course he's already railing against it, something about the way we have never needed before in a presidential debate, because people who are running for president don't generally try to shout over each other and interrupt each other as a matter of strategy. But the clip you played at the top is important. The president is mocking a disease, a pandemic, that has killed, at this point, more than 215,000 Americans on his watch. Just this morning, Columbia University released a new study, saying that the Trump administration's response, its failed response, is attributable for many of those deaths, really the delta that leads us to have the worst death rate in the world, 4 percent of the population, 20 percent of the world's deaths to date. That's serious stuff. And the president can try to distract and deflect and even dance at rallies. But that's a reality you can't spin your way out of.</s>ANDERSON: Is that mute button going to be a game changer tonight, John?</s>AVLON: Well, it will be a game restrainer. I mean, Trump -- Trump was railing against it from jump because his strategy is to try to get Joe Biden off his center, off his base. And he intends to do that as he did in the first debate by instinct, by bullying and blustering and interrupting. And at least for the first two minutes of every question, he is going to be unable to do that because of this mute button. After that, it's, you know, all bets are off. And you can expect he will default to form. But, again, these guardrails have been accepted sort of as democratic norms.</s>AVLON: And it's a reminder that so many of our democratic norms in the Trump era have had to be reinforced by mechanisms, when previously it was just reinforced by personal decency and honor.</s>ANDERSON: I want to hear a bit more from Barack Obama. It's good, actually, to have a listen to a man we haven't seen stumping for some time, of course. It takes you back, doesn't it?</s>AVLON: Yes.</s>ANDERSON: Have a listen to this.</s>OBAMA: Look, I get that this president wants full credit for the economy he inherited and zero blame for the pandemic that he ignored. But you know what? The job doesn't work that way. Tweeting at the television doesn't fix things. Making stuff up doesn't make people's lives better. You've got to have a plan. You've got to put in the work.</s>ANDERSON: What will Donald Trump want to talk about tonight, John?</s>AVLON: He's going to want to attack Joe Biden about his son, Hunter, and a highly suspect scandal that's basically percolated solely among right-wing media because he knows that Hunter Biden, being Joe Biden's only surviving son, it's a sore spot. Again, this is about the politics of personal destruction. That's not the game Joe Biden has tried to play. One of his closing argument, speeches but also an ad that aired during the World Series the other night, "it's a morning again in America." It's a "we can all disagree but we only have to agree that we all love this country." It's a uniting message. But Trump is going to try as many low blows as he can get in because that's -- that's his arsenal. That's his instinct. Biden has to keep his cool and stay focused on folks at home and what he could do for them as president. The rhetorical equivalent of tweeting at the television is useless. It is about taking responsibility and solving other people's problems.</s>ANDERSON: I just ,wonder given that the conspiracy theories, these allegations around Hunter Biden, which so many people have put to bed, wouldn't it be more sensible in some ways for Joe Biden just to, if it comes up -- and you're suggesting it's likely to -- why doesn't he just take it on head-on and put it to bed?</s>AVLON: I think the question is, what aspect of it? We have had 80 different former intelligence officials say it has all the hallmarks of a Russian disinformation campaign. We have had the current DNI, John Ratcliffe, say the opposite. Unfortunately John Ratcliffe's credibility is compromised in fundamental ways because he said he wouldn't be political, witness at a hearing. And he's fundamentally political and partisan about this stuff. So there's always a danger of amplification (ph). You look at the different tributaries that run through it, it's like a super cut of all the conspiracy theories Trump and right-wing media have been trying to foist with very little success outside their own ecochamber (sic), ecosystem. So I think Trump's -- you always want to punch back but it's better to be a happy warrior and to focus on folks at home. Focus on how you're going to make their lives better. Politics does not need to be a race to the bottom. That's important. If you offer people a contrast between love and hate, truth and lies, hope and fear, generally, in American history, they go for the positive, not the negative.</s>ANDERSON: We have one more fascinating debate.</s>AVLON: We will.</s>ANDERSON: To get through. Fascinating for a myriad of reasons, I'm sure.</s>AVLON: Yes.</s>ANDERSON: But let's keep an eye on it. We will let our viewers know how they can watch wherever they are watching around the world. John, always a pleasure. Thank you for joining, as I know that this is a busy time for you. Coming up, the Eternal City comes under new curfew, new restrictions in Rome and other parts of Europe, as they tackle staggering rises in COVID cases. And Real Madrid are looking, well, really sad. We will have "WORLD SPORT" on later to bring us updates from the Champions League.
Europe Imposes Tougher COVID-19 Restrictions.
ANDERSON: From Manchester to Milan, people are coming under new curfews and restrictions as they try to tackle a spike in these coronavirus cases. Multiple countries reporting record daily cases, I'm afraid, including Poland, where daily deaths are four times higher than during the first wave earlier this year. The prime minister of the Czech Republic has apologized to his country for the way his government handled the outbreak, as a new lockdown begins there. France and Spain have now passed 1 million cases, while Italy has imposed curfews in the Lombardy and Rome regions. And the English county of Greater Manchester is due to move to tier 3 on Friday, which indicates a very high level of alert. For more on the situation across Europe and the U.K., let's turn now to Scott McLean who is with you -- with us for you in Berlin. We will get to where you are in a moment. But first what is the latest on Belgium's deputy prime minister, who, as I understand it, is in intensive care right now?</s>SCOTT MCLEAN, CNN CORRESPONDENT: That's right, Becky. We know that the Belgian deputy prime minister said that she had contracted the virus or tested positive for the virus over the weekend. It was just last night she was admitted to the intensive care unit. We don't have a ton of detail about her condition but her spokesperson told CNN she was conscious, stable and able to communicate with her team and her condition is, quote, "not alarming." She is not the only world leader to contract the virus. The deputy prime minister and cabinet prime minister, along with the German health minister, all tested positive this week, Becky.</s>ANDERSON: Germany, where you are now, of course, hitting new records, as is next door to you in the Czech Republic. How are people feeling about what happens next?</s>MCLEAN: Nervous for sure. We have seen this tsunami of different rules, restrictions, curfews and obviously lockdowns coming in other countries, coming back in many cases, in most cases. And perhaps it's not surprising we are seeing world leaders contracting the virus because the number of cases in Germany and across Europe continues to surge. I want to show you a graph that illustrates the issue. You can see things are especially bad in Belgium, in the Netherlands, in Czech Republic, which just reported a record high case count, smashing the previous high water mark by 40 percent. Germany has also reported a record number of cases today. But compared to the rest of Europe, you can see it there at the bottom of the graph, it's doing much, much better. Despite the surge in cases in Western Europe, most countries, they have seen the first wave of the virus been more deadly than the second wave. And you can see, you know, that's certainly the case in France, Italy and Spain and the U.K. But it's a different story in eastern Europe, where Poland recorded 168 new deaths. That's a record death toll for the second straight day. They are now seeing four times more deaths than they saw at the peak of the first wave of infection. You can see from this chart, it's a similar story in nearby countries, Croatia, Hungary and Romania to name a few. I want to show you one last graph.</s>MCLEAN: And that's to show you in comparison how much worse things are in the Czech Republic right now, compared to even its neighbors, which, again, are seeing higher death tolls on this second wave. It's really off the charts. The Czech government is right now continuing to construct a field hospital which should be able to have 500 beds in it. The health system is in such dire straits that hospitals are appealing to anyone with medical training to come forward to help. The health minister is warning, if things don't turn around soon, that the health care system could completely collapse. He gave a very specific date that he thinks that could happen; that's November 7th. The clock is certainly ticking. And you can understand why the Czech Republic has opted to go back into something that looks like a lockdown, with restrictions on movement, only essential shops and stores open today; the streets of Prague were absolutely deserted -- Becky.</s>ANDERSON: Amazing stuff. Thank you. That's a very cogent (ph) wrap on what is going on across the continent. Ireland going into level 5 restrictions overnight, making it the first country into Europe to reenter lockdown, which it will stay now for the next six weeks. CNN's Nic Robertson captures the mood of the country for us.</s>NIC ROBERTSON, CNN INTERNATIONAL DIPLOMATIC EDITOR: In the hours before a nationwide six-week lockdown, shuttering pubs, bars and Dublin's fabled drinking haunts were bustling.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: We are in the type of area there is a lot of young people out right now and we are having a few drinks before lockdown. It's a bit of a crack at the end of the day but it's a necessary move to go into lockdown.</s>ROBERTSON (voice-over): Sorrows being drowned but concerns about what next growing.</s>WILLIE AHERN, BAR OWNER: I really fear for the economy of the country and what comes with that, in terms of job losses, stress, mental health, anxiety with people.</s>ROBERTSON (voice-over): Bar owner Ahern expressing worries of many, is the government handling the pandemic well?</s>AHERN: We have had seven months now and I question, did we put the proper procedures in place, the test and trace? Did we build up our hospital beds and our ICU beds? As far as I can see, no, we didn't.</s>ROBERTSON (voice-over): The answer, according to a leading scientist, not so much. Despite good testing, decades of underinvestment crippling capacity.</s>SAMUEL MCCONKEY, ROYAL COLLEGE OF SURGEONS, IRELAND: Last weekend there were so many positive cases and so many contacts that our contact tracing system actually was unable to keep up. And they are now trying to recruit 60 or 70 people a week. My view is they probably need several hundred more people per week and to scale that up rapidly.</s>ROBERTSON (voice-over): The new lockdown to combat rocketing infection rates closes all but essential retail, demands people must work from home if they can, bans mixing of households and curbs all but essential travel to 5 kilometers. The prime minister confident, with compliance, it will work.</s>MICHEAL MARTIN, IRISH TAOISEACH: If we pull together over the next six weeks, we will have the opportunity to celebrate Christmas in a meaningful way.</s>MCCONKEY: I think it will happen that we will achieve good control of our virus again over the next five, six weeks, based on the restrictions we have adopted last night, because we did it back in March and April and May.</s>ROBERTSON (voice-over): Many others, though, yet to be convinced.</s>VINNY DONNELLY, VIP TAXIS: A lot of people at this stage are resigned to it. I think as well a lot of people feel, if we got a vaccine, they're really -- you know, it's -- on-off stuff is difficult for them.</s>ROBERTSON (voice-over): In Ireland, as everywhere, this will be a winter of worries.</s>ANDERSON: Nic Robertson reporting for you. Coming up at the top of the hour, former U.S. president Barack Obama hits the campaign trail for his former vice president and mate. Will he be the factor that puts Joe Biden over the top? We will take a look at that. And the first presidential debate was something of a street brawl, wasn't it? In a few hours, will a mute button be able to work any magic? Because we preview the candidates' playbooks for what will be the last of the presidential debates this season. That at the top of the hour.
President Donald Trump Slams Obama's Campaigning For Biden; Strong Divide Between Donald Trump And Joe Biden On Energy Policy.
ANNOUNCER: Live from CNN Abu Dhabi, this is CONNECT THE WORLD with Becky Anderson.</s>BECKY ANDERSON, CNN ANCHOR: Well, this hour what's old is new again. Lebanon a country in some ways on its knees, desperate for change, the prime minister who resigned during last year's corruption protests once again in the top job. Meanwhile, in America a former leader reminding us of less chaotic days President Barack Obama in the 2020 race spotlights. Well, it was a speech that everyone was waiting for it seemed, Former President Barack Obama hitting the campaign trail to deliver an often incredulous and blistering account of his successor's first four years in office.</s>BARACK OBAMA, FORMER PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: Look, I get that this president wants full credit for the economy he inherited and zero blame for the pandemic that he ignored. But do you know what the job doesn't work that way. Tweeting at the television doesn't fix things. Making stuff up doesn't make people's lives better. You've got to have a plan. You've got to put in the work. I never thought Donald Trump would embrace my vision or continue my policies, but I did hope for the sake of the country that he might show some interest in taking the job seriously. But it hasn't happened. He hasn't shown any interest in doing the work or helping anybody but himself and his friends or treating the presidency like a reality show that he can use to get attention.</s>ANDERSON: Well, this of course just 12 days out from an election that could send shock waves around the world. It's also ahead of tonight's final Presidential Debate in Nashville, Tennessee, where COVID-19 will likely take center stage, much to Donald Trump's dismay.</s>DONALD TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: All you hear is COVID, COVID, COVID, COVID, COVID. COVID, COVID, COVID. That's all they put on pause they want to scare the hell out of everyone.</s>ANDERSON: With all due respect, Mr. President, it should scare the hell out of everyone. More than 200,000 Americans have lost their lives to this virus. Cases in all but one U.S. state are heading in the wrong direction. A reality check Obama was quick to make.</s>OBAMA: Just yesterday when asked if he would do anything differently Trump said, not much, really? Not much? Nothing you can think of that could have helped some people keep their loved ones alive?</s>ANDERSON: Well, Obama went on to encourage young voters to get out and cast their ballots. He touted Joe Biden's message of hope and painted a picture of a calm Biden-Harris future.</s>OBAMA: And with Joe and Kamala at the helm you're not going to have to think about the crazy things they said every day. And that's worth a lot. You're not going to have to argue about them every day. It just won't be so exhausting. You might be able to have a Thanksgiving dinner without having an argument.</s>ANDERSON: Well, the former president's first stump speech was delivered in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania the state is one of the biggest prizes on the battleground map, holding 20 Electoral College votes. According to the latest CNN Poll Joe Biden is leading by 10 percentage points there. Will having Obama on the trail improve that? Here is Mr. Trump's take on the subject.</s>TRUMP: President Obama is campaigning for sleepy Joe Biden and I said, huh, that's good news or bad news? Tell me, are you saying it's good or it's bad. Well, I guess it's bad. No, it's good. There was nobody that campaigned harder for crooked Hillary Clinton than Obama, right? He was all over the place. But the only one unhappy than crooked Hillary that night was Barack Hussein Obama.</s>ANDERSON: Well, regardless the #bringbackobama is now trending. Before you ask, no, he can't run for president again. Well, my next guess says, and I quote, superman is back in the building. Van Jones is a CNN Political Commentator; he served as Special Adviser to President Obama. It's good to have you with us, sir. The Obama factor on full display last night, a scathing speech but you have to ask whether he is a little too late to this race. What impact do you believe his appearances will have?</s>VAN JONES, CNN POLITICAL COMMENTATOR: Very, very powerful. Listen, you have to understand - you have to hold Obama back until now otherwise it looks like he's overshadowing both Harris and Biden, you know, Barack Obama is a megastar. He is a star among stars. If he never gave another political speech his name alone is going to be known for 100 years. So you have to hold him back. Let Biden and let Harris establish themselves and then you bring in the bombers. We have real problems at the base of this party that we don't talk about enough. There is a section of people on the one hand that are just so disaffected. They just feel that nothing is ever going to work for them. Obama was speaking to them in the speech. He wasn't just beating up on Trump; he was also sneaking in some medicine for the base. Listen, you are not going to make it perfect by voting but you can make it better who said that over and over again. Also you have got a bunch of people on the far left who feel again that they didn't get Bernie Sanders or they didn't get Elizabeth Warren. They're not sure they should participate. He was calling them back in by saying you can't abandon all these people who are suffering right now. So he gets the attention for the incredible blistering attacks and he just took Trump to the wood shed, he just took him, just took him to the wood chopper. But he's going into places where you have some people who are holding back frankly in the black community as well and he can talk to those people and bring them back into the fold and he is doing that beautifully while also putting Trump on defensive.</s>ANDERSON: Yes, that's interesting. All right, well, I just want to play you a political ad from Utah from two Governors who are running against each other. Just have a listen to this.</s>JONES: Yep.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: And while I think you should vote for me.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: Yes, but really you should vote for me.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: There are some things we both agree on. We can debate issues without degrading each other's character. We can disagree without hating each other.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: And win or lose in Utah, we work together.</s>JONES: Beautiful.</s>ANDERSON: And there are those--</s>JONES: Beautiful.</s>ANDERSON: --who say that they wish they were seeing more of that. That Biden continuing to call for unity on the campaign trail, but America's current divide is not just exclusive to D.C., is it? Are the American people truly ready to heal the wounds that have been caused, do you think?</s>JONES: It depends on the size of the victory. If Trump squeaks by and we have four more years of Trump, I think it's going to be very, very difficult for liberals to accept that because they're going to be pointing to Russian interference, they're going to be pointing to voter suppression, they are going to be pointing to all kind of things. If Biden squeaks by I don't think you're going to see Trump just go quietly into the night, you are going to hear from him and his base saying you know the mail-in voter fraud, et cetera. But if either side scores a true landslide, if you are looking at a, you know, 400 Electoral College, you only need 270. If Biden is sitting there after all the court, you know, dust clears and everything is said and he's got 400 Electoral College votes and the Democrats have the Senate, that will be such a thorough repudiation of the worst in the Republican Party that I think you're going to see people then looking for ways to come together. But you've got to have to have a decisive win and it's very hard in such a divided country to have a decisive win. I think, if either side wins decisively then I think you may get there.</s>ANDERSON: Let's do the math, shall we? Because this is a tight race in the majority of the battleground maps that we've been looking at. At this point with 12 days to go what is your advice to the Biden Campaign? I'm not asking you to advise the Donald Trump Campaign because I know that's not something you would be willing to do, but what do you expect him to do?</s>JONES: Yes, my view of the Biden Campaign is stay disciplined. This is a turnout race at this point. You have a lot of African American, Latino, Latina forces that still need money. They need support to get the turnout to happen. Data doesn't vote, polls don't vote, human beings have to walk out the door in the middle of the pandemic, leave their kids someplace and stand in long lines. Who is bringing the pizza? Who is watching the kids? Focus on the details and the mechanics of the turnout game.</s>JONES: On the Trump side I think he's got to understand that he is scaring the zebras out of people who want to vote for him. I'm hearing from conservatives that want to vote for him, but he is not talking about the stuff they care about. He is not talking about the economy. He is not even talking about the taxes. He is talking about Fauci and picking fights with random people. So, if I were Trump has the ability to get disciplined at the end, last time he got disciplined at the end, the Comey report came out and he was able to squeak by. He's picking the wrong parts of the playbook from last time. He remembers the fire and Brimstone; he forgets he got silent near the end last time. He needs to take his own playbook seriously or he is going to have a big problem in a couple weeks.</s>ANDERSON: Well, let's just focus in, then, on tonight. I just wonder whether you believe he might take your advice in the debate. A talking point of course for many is this muted mic. It is probably unlikely to actually stop Donald Trump interrupting, but the audience of course just won't hear what he says. Biden, however, a few feet away will. Will Donald Trump use that as a tactic or do you believe at this late stage, he could actually be a lot more disciplined than we might expect him to be?</s>JONES: You never know with Donald Trump. You just never know. I tell you the moderator in this debate is living out the fantasy of about 60 to 70 million Americans to be able to mute Donald Trump. So, you know, she's got the best job in the country as far as - are concerned. But you know, honestly Trump should just let Biden talk, you know, side-by- side as much as I love Joe Biden, he's not the most compelling communicator. His heart is in the right place, but everybody knows him. That's why he's able to kind of perform. Trump is always arresting. Even if you don't like him, let Biden talk and then do your thing. The idea that you've got to run over Joe Biden and keep him from talking shows so much insecurity on the part of somebody who has been able to talk his way into and out of every situation in the world. Let the other guy talk and then do your thing. That's what Trump should do.</s>ANDERSON: Fascinating stuff. And I want our viewers to tune in tonight. We certainly will be, even though it is a terrible time here, its 3:00 am, Abu Dhabi time. I know you will be keeping a very close eye on what's going on and our viewers can, too. It is the final Presidential Debate. Thank you, van. Our coverage begins 7:00 pm Eastern on Thursday. That is 12:00 am in London and as I say a very early 3:00 am here in Abu Dhabi on Friday. But look, I mean, you know, in all seriousness, this is really important stuff. What goes on in America and I said this time and time again, doesn't stay in America. Wherever you are watching in this world, this U.S. election is important. An allegation of foreign interference just days before that election has some intelligence officials crying foul. Last minute news conference on Wednesday night Director of National Intelligence John Ratcliffe announced Russia and Iran have obtained voter registration information that could be used to influence this race. He also claimed Iran took it a step further.</s>JOHN RATCLIFFE, U.S. DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL INTELLIGENCE: We would like to alert the public that we have identified that two foreign actors, Iran and Russia, have taken specific actions to influence public opinion relating to our elections. We have already seen Iran sending spoofed emails designed to intimidate voters, insight social unrest and damage President Trump.</s>ANDERSON: Well, according to Ratcliffe the goal of this foreign interference is to hurt President Trump's chances of winning reelection, but he offered no proof of that, and he didn't take any questions. Some intelligence experts are skeptical of the claim. Democrats on the Homeland Security Committee going as far as to call Ratcliffe a partisan hack both Russia and Iran have denied all accusations of medaling well. Well, this is our country's last chance. A stark warning from Lebanon's new leader the same man who didn't exactly - the country the first number of times he ran it. Up next, Saad Hariri conjures something new to heal his tortured country? Plus, financial desperation during the pandemic has gotten so bad in parts of India; it's reportedly prompted families to sell their own kids into slavery.</s>ANDERSON: That's on our freedom report, freedom project report tonight, and that is after this.
Lebanon's New Leader Looks Familiar; CNN Speaks To Former Lebanese Prime Minister Tammam Salam
RANA KHOURY, LEBANESE ACTIVIST: Today I am the red line. My son is the red line, the women cursing the road are the red line, and the students who are rescheduling their studies here are the red lines. We are the red lines. You as a government as people empower have crushed us so many years it's just time for you to go home.</s>ANDERSON: That's right. That's an activist in Lebanon talking to me a year ago in Beirut almost a year to the day during the protest that led to the resignation of then Prime Minister Saad Hariri. Well, today he is back. Lebanon's lawmakers have asked him to lead the country once again. You see Mr. Hariri there to the right of the Lebanon's President and the Parliament Speaker. The picture could tell a thousand words this is their answer to the government's paralysis despite the Lebanese people's desperate pleas for change. Well, Saad Hariri returns to his old job to face a fall out from 12 months of growing misery, of growing poverty and a COVID surge and a deadly blast that devastated Beirut. More anti-corruption protests and it go on but he says he is ready to lead this time.</s>SAAD HARIRI, LEBANESE PRIME MINISTER-DESIGNATE: I told the Lebanese people who are facing despairing hardships, I am dedicated to my promise to them on working to stop the collapse and that is economy , society and security and to rebuild the destruction from the terrible port explosion in Beirut.</s>ANDERSON: The Former Lebanese Prime Minister Tammam Salam is one of the most respected people in Lebanese politics, and he just spoke to Mr. Hariri. Tammam Salam joins me now from Beirut. It's a pleasure to have you on. You spoke to Saad earlier today. What is his mood? Why do you believe he is the man now to get the job done?</s>TAMMAM SALAM, FORMER LEBANESE PRIME MINISTER: Well, thank you, Becky. This time in Lebanon with all the trouble that is weighing heavily on every Lebanese in every respect, we have to face reality. And yes, a heavyweight prime minister is needed. As you well know, Lebanon is represented politically by three people who represent in turn the three major congressional parties in Lebanon. You have the President of the Republic; you have the Speaker of the House and the Prime Minister. And since the President of the Republic is belongs to a major political entity in the country.</s>SALAM: And so does the Speaker of the House, it's only normal that the Prime Minister also represent a political entity. And by far Mr. Hariri is most representative of the Sunni Community in Lebanon, so it's very normal that he himself takes up the challenge and faces this dire and difficult situation.</s>ANDERSON: Right. With respect, sir, the reality is that he is part of the problem as far as so many protesters are concerned and all of them. And that means all of them was a chant that you and I heard on the streets of Beirut and we continue to hear. Now that was about getting rid of the kleptocracy as it's seen, the corruption at the very heart of Lebanese politics and Saad Hariri has promised to rebuild the country. Let's just have a listen to what he said specifically.</s>HARIRI: I will start by forming the government quickly, because the time is running out and this is our beloved countries last and only chance.</s>ANDERSON: Whether or not people on the street accept that this is the man for the job, this is who they have got for the time being. But Tammam, arguably time has already run out for Lebanon, hasn't it?</s>SALAM: Yes, very much so. And yes, that's fine. The demand of the people on the street is not an easy thing neither for Hariri nor anybody else. But unfortunately, Becky, the people on the street who were supposed to represent a big change badly needed in Lebanon were not able to consolidate their presence in a unified front to make that change happen. Therefore, they have certainly had an advanced situation which influenced all the political class, all the political establishment that has been running the country for many years now. I hope that those politicians, I hope that this establishment realizes finally that it cannot go on unless some radical, serious change takes place. And having, as you said, discussed this matter with Prime Minister Designate Hariri, I felt that he had the will to do that and he's very genuine about it and he realizes that big reform in the country is required and, therefore, he - we have to take into consideration the French initiative and President Macron's personal interest in drawing a road map, a reform road map to be implemented in the coming six months so as to regain some confidence and trust in the system and in the country. And that will require certainly the formation of a unified teamwork for the government. And that's why, yes, the main proposal in that matter is a non- politicized formation of a cabinet of the government.</s>ANDERSON: Right. So because he's tried this before, hasn't he? I mean and you're right to point out that he says he's going to have you know, a group of non-partisan technocrats. Because the last time he tried this in July of 2019 and he was trying to get this cash from the IMF, he had been asked to implement these reforms, he just couldn't get those reforms that were needed implemented. I spoke recently Tammam to the head--</s>SALAM: No, Becky, it was not--</s>ANDERSON: Go on.</s>SALAM: It was not he who tried it; it was another guy who tried it. And it was another political group in the country. Those known for being not with Hariri and not with many other political groups in the country, they tried it for a good seven, eight months with a prime minister that was not up to it to start with.</s>ANDERSON: All right.</s>SALAM: But that served their own goals and purposes. And it failed. And of course, it failed. And the technocrats or non-politicized ministers supposedly, as they had said, were not so.</s>SALAM: They were appointed by the political parties.</s>ANDERSON: OK.</s>SALAM: Backed by them and followed up by them to do what's good for the political parties, not for the good of the country necessary.</s>ANDERSON: Thank you for putting me right on that. So Saad Hariri now needs massive support, not just from the people of Lebanon but from the international community. I spoke to the Head of the IMF recently. She was alongside Melinda Gates. We were having a discussion about a number of issues. But we talked about Lebanon. I asked Kristalina Georgieva for her take on Lebanon. So this is what she said. Have a listen.</s>KRISTALINA GEORGIEVA, MANAGING DIRECTOR, INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND: It is so sad to see Lebanon, a country of entrepreneurial people, very smart people, very generous people, to be in such a dire situation. And why is the country there? Because of lack of political determination, unity of purpose. We are ready and very willing to help Lebanon. We need a partner.</s>ANDERSON: She went on to say she needs a reliable partner. Is Saad Hariri that reliable partner for the IMF? And does he have support from elsewhere? You're talking about the initiative from Emmanuel Macron, what about from the Saudis, from the UAE, for example. What's his extent of support on the international map?</s>SALAM: Well, as I said, everybody is aware as Ms. Georgieva was saying, everybody is aware and she has political experience, you know. And she is quite professional now in her job at the IMF. And she realizes that a lot of confidence and trust are required to pull out Lebanon of the big financial mess we are in. And, therefore, I say, Becky, it's for Saad Hariri who is known for his regional and national relations, to be able to form a consolidated, strong, united government, too because he by himself will not be able to do anything, he needs support from his ministers. Especially what is important is that in the financial sector, we need some experts to help us out. I'm sure we can work out something with the IMF as you well know. We also have some very competent Lebanese with the IMF who will always look like a very interesting eye to work their own country and they are there to help. So, we should not miss that opportunity, I believe. And so as much as also on other fronts, with other relations as you were mentioning, with the gulf countries, which unfortunately were alienated politically by some Lebanese political groups for a few years, and that has to be remedied. In fact, Hariri can remedy that if he is given the chance to do it.</s>ANDERSON: Lebanon and Israel currently negotiating over a maritime border regarding access to energy. I mean this is so, so important for the future of the country. Do you see that as a game-changer for the Lebanese economy?</s>SALAM: It should be so, yes, eventually as we are watching the developments in gas and oil in the Eastern Mediterranean region with the other countries surrounding us who are gathering together and working out some profitable unified solutions for their problems. Yes, we should be able to enjoy that resource which will certainly be a game-changer and will be - will have a very positive impact on our economy. And, yes, we have been handling this matter very carefully because it's a very delicate situation. I hope we can succeed and that also depends on if the other party wants seriously to reach some valid, sustainable agreement on that matter.</s>ANDERSON: Finally, what can the people of Lebanon then expect? The IMF has been exploring all possible ways to support the people of Lebanon, as the Managing Director told me.</s>ANDERSON: She says it's important to put in place meaningful, a meaningful program of reforms to turn the economy around. What do those reforms mean, and how big an impact will they have on the people of Lebanon who are struggling so badly at this point?</s>SALAM: I believe, Becky, the major and main reforms required are certainly those related to the monetary situation, to the economy, to the administrative setup in the country, and to the energy sector. And I have to stress the importance of serious reform regarding the judiciary, because there lays mainly the confidence and trust needed in the country. And that has been messed around with for some time now unfortunately. We have been relying on our judges, our good judges, but the system is not. Hello?</s>ANDERSON: Tammam Salam, oh, I think he left.</s>SALAM: I'm off the screen maybe. We have a - they must have heard me talking about the energy.</s>ANDERSON: Thank you. And you know I have spoken about that before and I really appreciate your time.</s>SALAM: Yes.</s>ANDERSON: In fact, electricity has gone.</s>SALAM: Thank you for your interest in Lebanon and keeping up with it. Thank you.</s>ANDERSON: And that is the state of Lebanon today. Look at that. That's electricity cut as we were speaking to the Former Prime Minister of Lebanon who makes an awful lot of sense. He was talking about something we were speaking about in the past, a reform of the judicial system being so important. You couldn't make it up, could you? There you go. That is the problem in Lebanon today, there is no electricity. Thank you, sir.</s>SALAM: I'm back on the screen? Thank you. Thank you, Becky.
India Sees Sharp Rise In Child Forced Labor; Melinda Gates Praises India's Investment In Women
ANDERSON: When we talk about COVID-19 lockdowns in the more developed parts of the world, a lot of times we talk about them in terms of inconveniences, not being allowed to travel or store shelves not being fully stocked. Even when we talk about the staggering number of job losses or how many are forced into poverty.</s>ANDERSON: We still can't comprehend how bad it has gotten in some parts of the world. The IMF projects that India's economy, for example, will shrink by over 10 percent this year, and that's not just some big, fancy, economic projection. It has an impact in the real world. CNN'S Ivan Watson shows us now how in some areas, families have become so desperate they are reportedly even selling their children into forced labor for as little as a few dollars.</s>IVAN WATSON, CNN REPORTER: On the streets of Jaipur, in India, one of the hidden costs of COVID-19 exposed. During this nighttime bus raid authorities discovered 19 children they say were being trafficked. Officials say it is repeating itself far more often since the virus took root here. Authorities say those children rescued during the pandemic as young as 11 years old. Under Indian law, it is illegal for children under 14 to work, but the horrible economic toll of the pandemic is forcing many children and teens to take on what sometimes amounts to slave labor. 14-year-old Mujib (ph) is one of the children rescued during the raid. He says he along with other boys were lured away from their village but a much older man who gave families 500 Rupees equivalent $7 and promised them a holiday in Jaipur about 800 miles from home. Others like 15-year-old Aman (ph) see no other choice but to sacrifice themselves for the good of their family. Bihar one of India's poorest states with a vast migrant population, sheer desperation for those like Aman who volunteer themselves and to those families no job prospects and not government insists. They see no other way to survive but to sell one of their children to feed the rest. 12-year-old Mishaud (ph), one of the boys rescued in raid on bangle factory says his parents sold him to the traffickers for 1500 rupees or $21. He was locked inside this dingy room for five months and not allowed outside, working from morning until midnight each day before he was given any food to eat to pay the debt his parents owed. And he says if he or the children couldn't keep up with the demand, they would be beaten. Nobel Laureate Kailash Satyarthi's BBA "Save the Child Movement" is one of many NGOs sounding the alarm about the rise of what amounts to childhood slavery since COVID-19 began? So Satyarthi says his group, alongside local authorities, has rescued 900 trafficked children and got 70 traffickers arrested between April and August of this year.</s>KAILASH SATYARTHI, NOBEL LAUREATE: That was just to send a strong message to all the state governments and the local governments that, look, this is happening and that is growing so we cannot simply wait and watch.</s>WATSON: Authorities in Bihar have acknowledged that they are receiving more reports about child trafficking since the pandemic began. And in response, "Have increased guidelines and advisories but have not done any field checks due to COVID-19". But Satyarthi says calls on the government to create tougher anti-trafficking laws have so far yielded few results on the ground. The message from leaders is bleak.</s>SATYARTHI: If you're not able to protect this generation, we are not going to protect all the generation to come. Children have never faced such crisis. This is not simply the health crisis or economy crisis; this is the crisis of justice. This is the crisis of humanity. This is the crisis of childhood.</s>WATSON: At this shelter, Mujib and Aman are more than a dozen rescued children waiting to go home and while Mujib is interested to get back Aman is the optimist. With no end in sight to the economic crisis caused by the outbreak of COVID-19, he will be returning to the very situation he gave up his youth to help his family escape. Ivan Watson,</s>CNN. ANDERSON: Well, my next guest has reported extensively on social justice issues in South Asia and around the world.</s>ANDERSON: Let's welcome Journalist Priyali Sur. She is the Founder of a project Azadi Project which gives skills and voice to refugee women and girls. Thank you for your time today, first of all, your reaction to Ivan's report there?</s>PRIYALI SUR, FOUNDER, THE HEAD OF AZADI PROJECT: Becky, to understand why there has been a rise in trafficking of children in India during the pandemic? And as you rightly put - saying that how much the economic impact has been? It is very important to understand how much the economic impact of the pandemic is also intertwined with the social impact. And most of the economic impact and the social impact is not held by the rich people or upper middle class people, it is actually the people who bear the brunt of it are the poorest of the poor people. The parents that cannot put food on the table for their children or children actually go to school and because the schools are shut down, cannot access that one meal a day that they would access through the school program. And as the report clearly showed that a lot of people during the pandemic have lost their jobs. Most of them are daily wage laborers. For example, when I interviewed Mujib in the story and he said that his father, who's a daily wage laborer could not send money back home and that's why they could not - they did not have any access to any food or he couldn't even go to school. It clearly shows the impact of extreme poverty on these families. Traffickers are known to exploit these situations. Traffickers thrive when there is extreme poverty. So when there is lack of government aid to these extreme poor families, for example, the Indian government put in a stimulus package earlier of the lockdown which is 2 percent of the GDP, which is far less than any other government or most other governments in the world have put in. And even if that stimulus or that package that was put through did not trickle down to the poorest of the poor people as we see in the story. Then they are left with no other option but to sending their children or as we term it sell their children into bonded labor. When the children go in the hope for a better future, they actually end up being paid nothing and being exploited.</s>ANDERSON: And you're making some very, very valid points. At a point which we are nowhere near the end of this virus, of course I spoke to Melinda Gates about poverty in relation to the Coronavirus specifically. She used India as an example of the positive measures she said that are being taken for gender equality. Have a listen.</s>MELINDA GATES, CO-FOUNDER, BILL & MELINDA GATES FOUNDATION: You invest in women's health. The other thing you do is you lift women up economically. We have great data from years and years of development that if you put money in a woman's hands, she spends it on the family and everybody else. So what did India do? They put 200 million cash transfer payments right away during this pandemic into the hands of women. They had the gender disaggregated data and they knew if you put it in the woman's hands, it will get spent properly on health, education and jobs. You do those things, those are just a few examples, we have many more you actually build this quicker road to recovery.</s>ANDERSON: She paints a good picture there, but is it enough? What is the reality on the ground?</s>SUR: Becky, I think in principle it's great to put more money and direct cash into the hands of women because women will make sure that their children are being fed and being educated. So in principle, it's great. And yes, there was a scheme of direct cash transfers started by the government in India. But even in the story, Aman's mother says who we have - Aman's mother says that she did not get the money that was supposed to reach her during the pandemic. And it's not just her. We have heard stories of many such women on the ground in the poorest of the poor states who have not had access to this money because either they are not in the rolls or they don't have the Aadhaar Card which is the key requirement, the digital identity card, to which they will get that direct money transferred. So it's a check in the box in a lot of situations. It would be unfair to say that it's not reached anybody, but I think to say that this has had a major positive impact on the ground, you know, there are two sides to it.</s>ANDERSON: yes, fascinating stuff. We'll have you back. Thank you very much indeed for joining us and the reporting ahead of that of course from Ivan Watson. Well, Europe tackling a major new surge in Coronavirus cases. Belgium is among those hardest hit. The country's Deputy Prime Minister is in the hospital with COVID-19. More on that and the wider challenges in Europe is up next.
Trump and Biden Face Off Tonight in Final Presidential Debate; Obama Returns to Campaign Trail with Blistering Rebuke of Trump; Feds: Russia, Iran Using U.S. Voter Info to Interfere in Election
CHRISTINE ROMANS, CNN ANCHOR: All right. Welcome to our viewers in the United States and around the world. This is a debate day edition of EARLY START. Good morning. I'm Christine Romans.</s>LAURA JARRETT, CNN ANCHOR: And I'm Laura Jarrett. It's Thursday, October 22nd, 5:00 a.m. here in New York. Just 12 days until the election, and today is the deadline to request an absentee ballot if you are in Indiana. So, if either presidential candidate hopes to change the course of the 2020 race, well, tonight may be their last chance. Joe Biden and Donald Trump gearing up for their final faceoff after their train wreck of a first debate. President Trump is now running behind Biden in national polls, but within striking range in several key battleground states. The debate comes after national security officials revealed the most concrete details to date about interference in the upcoming election. We'll get more on that in a moment.</s>ROMANS: A big topic tonight will be the pandemic Trump failed to bring under control, and shows dangerous signs of spiraling. More than 1,100 American lives lost yesterday, the most since September 15th. The incumbent president laying the role of underdog. His advisers hoping he'll show restraint. Our coverage begins with CNN's Jim Acosta at the debate hall in Nashville.</s>JIM ACOSTA, CNN CHIEF WHITE HOUSE CORRESPONDENT: Christine and Laura, President Trump and Democrat Joe Biden will meet later on this evening for the final presidential debate. In the meantime, President Trump is back to his old tricks of manufacturing bright, shiny objects when he is in big political trouble. The president is on the attack against a slew of targets from the media to Dr. Anthony Fauci. But the president is defending his record on the coronavirus saying there's, quote, not much he would change in terms of his handling of the pandemic.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: With COVID, is there anything you think you could do differently if you had a mulligan or a do-over on one aspect of the way you handled it, what would it be?</s>DONALD TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: Not much. Look, it's all over the world. You have a lot of great leaders. There's a lot of smart people, it's all over the world. It came out of China. China should have stopped it.</s>ACOSTA: And Trump advisers are hopeful the president will do less interrupting than he did at the last presidential debate. That's because they think that the president turned off some voters out there as they watched that unfold. They are hopeful the president will allow Democrat Joe Biden to talk more in hopes that the former vice president will have some sort of gaffe that will shake up the race -- Christine and Laura.</s>JARRETT: Jim Acosta, thank you so much for that. So, how does Joe Biden plan to counter the unpredictable president in their final debate? CNN's Arlette Saenz is with the Biden campaign.</s>ARLETTE SAENZ, CNN POLITICAL CORRESPONDENT: Laura and Christine, the former vice president spent the past three days off the campaign trail, meeting with his advisers as he prepared for this final match up. Biden's advisers say he will focus on talking about COVID-19, and his plan to build back the economy. Once again stressing that Scranton versus Park Avenue messaging that Biden has tried to frame this campaign around in these closing weeks. Now, Biden's advisers say the former vice president is preparing for President Trump to bully and deflect his way through this upcoming debate. They expect that the president will not just attack Joe Biden but also go after his family. And Biden's deputy campaign manager said that ultimately, these debates are a test of presidential temperament. Biden has said that he plans on turning this debate back to the issues at hand. What matters most to voters in these final 12 days before the election, as voters will gauge whether they're going to vote for Biden or President Trump -- Laura and Christine.</s>ROMANS: Arlette, thank you so much for that. While Biden prepped for tonight's debate, his former boss and the Democrat's top surrogate made his strongest argument yet that President Trump must go.</s>BARACK OBAMA, FORMER PRESIDENT: I get that this president wants full credit for the economy that he inherited and zero blame for the pandemic that he ignored but you know what, the job doesn't work that way. Tweeting at the television doesn't fix things.</s>ROMANS: Former President Barack Obama pulling no punches in his first in-person campaign event, in a state that would be crucial to a Joe Biden victory. CNN's Jeff Zeleny has more for us this morning from Philadelphia.</s>JEFF ZELENY, CNN SENIOR WASHINGTON CORRESPONDENT: Christine and Laura, without question it was one of the most blistering and mocking assessments former President Obama has ever delivered of his successor. In more than 30 minutes during a rally outdoors here in Philadelphia, he really ran through a litany of criticisms about President Trump, dwelling certainly on his handling of coronavirus.</s>OBAMA: And just yesterday when asked if he would do anything differently, Trump said not much. Really? Not much. Nothing you can think of that could have helped some people keep their loved ones alive? So, Joe is not going to screw up testing. He's not going to call scientists idiots. He's not going to host a super spreader event at the White House.</s>ZELENY: President Obama went well beyond that also talking about President Trump's view of the world and how the world, indeed, views him. And beyond coronavirus, President Obama also talked about President Trump's behavior in office. He talked about the exhaustion factor that Americans have. He said that indeed this November election could bring America back to a calmer and simpler time.</s>OBAMA: With Joe and Kamala at the helm, you're not going to have to think about the crazy things they said every day. And that's worth a lot. You're not going to have to argue about them every day. It just won't be so exhausting.</s>ZELENY: But there was no question the overall message from the former president was to Democrats, delivering a bit of tough medicine to them as well saying that now is not the time for complacency. He talked four years ago about how the race between Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump was tight as well. This was the first of several appearances Obama was going to make to key battleground states. He's going to be visiting places where voting is already underway, like here in Pennsylvania, also he'll be targeting Florida and other states. What the former president is trying to do is increase participation and enthusiasm among young black voters, Latino voters and younger voters overall -- Christine and Laura.</s>JARRETT: Jeff Zeleny in Philadelphia, thank you. Breaking overnight, federal officials say Russia and Iran have obtained U.S. voter registration information in an effort to interfere in the upcoming election. They say as part of that campaign, Iran has been sending menacing e-mails to voters in several states, posing as the far right Proud Boys, the group that the president refused to condemn at the last debate. Now, a source tells CNN that some of the data Iran obtained came from private vendor and state systems. This is the first time this election cycle a foreign adversary has been publicly accused of targeting specific voters.</s>JOHN RATCLIFFE, DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL INTELLIGENCE: We will not tolerate foreign interference in our elections and we will continue to work with our many partners to disrupt and to impose costs and consequences on any adversary that attempts to interfere in our democratic processes.</s>CHRISTOPHER WRAY, FBI DIRECTOR: You should be confident that your vote counts. Early, unverified claims to the contrary should be viewed with a healthy dose of skepticism.</s>ROMANS: It is not unreasonable to view some of this as a distraction. John Ratcliffe has been accused of politicizing a number of intel issues since becoming the director of national intelligence. Last night, he claimed the Iranian emails were intended to damage President Trump even though they said to vote for him or else. After the announcement, Homeland Security Democrats urged people not to listen to Ratcliffe calling him a partisan hack, in a tweet that was later deleted.</s>JARRETT: A major change from the CDC this morning. The agency is updating how to find close contact with a COVID-19 patient. It used to be thought that you needed 15 continuous minutes of exposure to somebody. But now it turns out it could be a series of multiple brief exposures, and this is coming after a Vermont prison worker appears to have been infected that way.</s>DR. PETER HOTEZ, DEAN, NATIONAL SCHOOL OF TROPICAL MEDICINE: It's a reminder that we don't have a lot of tools to fight this virus until vaccines come along next year. It's just another reminder of how easy this virus is to transmit, and if you let your guard down, unfortunately, you can get caught and get COVID-19.</s>ROMANS: The U.S. suffered nearly 63,000 cases yesterday. The 7-day average is on the verge of surpassing 60,000 for the first time since August 3rd. More than 2,000 of those cases were in New York. The first time the state has gone over 2,000 since May. Five New York City public schools added about 1,500 have been shut down for two weeks because of outbreaks. San Francisco public schools do not anticipate bringing students back into the classroom before the end of the year.</s>JARRETT: Well, still ahead, it's one of the biggest talking points you hear often from the GOP that Joe Biden will raise your taxes. We're going to separate fact from fiction, up next.
Rays Even World Series with Win Over Dodgers.
ROMANS: A northern California woman owes her life to the heroic actions of one police officer.</s>POLICE OFFICER: Ma'am, ma'am, come out this way. Come out this way. Come out. Hurry up. Get out right now, hurry. Get out.</s>ROMANS: Wow, Davis Police Corporal Fong Lee realized the only way to get a woman out of an overturned car quickly enough was to drag her by the hands. He told this woman, I was not going to fail this woman, I was going to get her out of the car no matter what. Police say she's suspected of driving under the influence.</s>JARRETT: A scary scene there. Well, the Tampa Bay Rays even up the World Series with the win against the Dodgers. Andy Scholes has this morning's "Bleacher Report". They're not giving up this fight.</s>ANDY SCHOLES, CNN SPORTS CORRESPONDENT: They are not, Laura. Good morning to you. The Rays did not want to fall behind 0-2 in this first ever neutral site World Series, and second baseman Brandon Lowe coming up big for the team. He was in a terrible slump but finally busted out of it. Lowe homering in the first inning to give the Rays the lead. Then in the 5th with a runner on, Lowe comes to the plate, homers again, he's the seventh second baseman to hit two homers in a World Series game. Rays win it 6-4 to even the series at a game apiece. Lowe crediting his teammates for never giving up on him when he was in that terrible slump.</s>BRANDON LOWE, TAMPA BAY RAYS SECOND BASEMAN: Just pure joy. I'm going into that dugout after hitting that home run. Everyone was happy, jumping up and down. You know, it's not an individual thing out there. It's everyone with the team, and you know, whatever helps the team win.</s>KEVIN CASH, TAMPA BAY RAYS MANAGER: Man, it was exciting for the first home run, the second one, you know, really ignited. I mean, we've seen, look, you've seen it. You've covered him. He can go quiet for a little while but can get as hot as anybody in baseball.</s>SCHOLES: All right. Game three of the World Series will be Friday night. The Florida Gators football team meanwhile is shutting down its facilities through Monday amid a coronavirus outbreak. An athletic department spokesperson tells CNN that there have been 26 positive cases within the program since October 13th. Head coach Dan Mullen who announced that he tested positive last week said everyone for the most part is doing fine. The outbreak prompted last week's game against LSU and this week's game against Missouri to be postponed. All right. LSU is banning Odell Beckham Jr. from the school's facilities for two years, according to "Sports Illustrated". Beckham went to LSU, and was seen on video counting, then slapping cash into the hands of LSU players after they won the national championship in January. That's, of course, against the rules. We reached out to Beckham about the ban through his agent, and the Browns, but haven't heard back. You know, Christine, the whole point of a $100 handshake is to be discrete, and that certainly was not discrete, counting it in front of all the cameras.</s>ROMANS: In front of the cameras, right.</s>SCHOLES: Yeah.</s>ROMANS: Generous and against the rules.</s>SCHOLES: Yes.</s>ROMANS: There you go. All right. Thanks so much, Andy. Joe Biden and Donald Trump face off one last time, the must watch final presidential debate. Special live coverage starts tonight at 7:00 p.m. Eastern on CNN.
Trump And Biden Face Off Tonight In Final Presidential Debate; FBI Say Russia And Iran Using U.S. Voter Information To Interfere In Election
LAURA JARRETT, CNN ANCHOR: Good morning. Welcome back to EARLY START. I'm Laura Jarrett.</s>CHRISTINE ROMANS, CNN ANCHOR: And I'm Christine Romans. It is exactly 31 minutes past the hour on this debate day. If either presidential candidate hopes to change the course of the race, tonight is the last chance. Joe Biden and Donald Trump gearing up for their final face-off after their train wreck first debate. President Trump is running behind Biden in national polls but within striking range in several key battleground states. The debate comes after national security officials reveal the most concrete details yet about interference in this election. More on that in a moment.</s>JARRETT: A big topic tonight, of course, will be the pandemic that the president failed to bring under control and shows dangerous signs of it spiraling out of control. More than 1,100 American lives lost yesterday. That's the most since September 15th. The incumbent president still playing the role of the underdog but his advisers hope he will show some signs of restraint tonight. We get more from CNN's Jim Acosta at the debate hall in Nashville.</s>JIM ACOSTA, CNN CHIEF WHITE HOUSE CORRESPONDENT: Christine and Laura, President Trump and Democrat Joe Biden will meet later on this evening for their final presidential debate. In the meantime, President Trump is back to his old tricks of manufacturing bright, shiny objects when he's in big political trouble. The president is on the attack against a slew of targets from the media to Dr. Anthony Fauci. But the president is defending his record on the coronavirus, saying there's, quote, "not much he would change" in terms of his handling of the pandemic. Here's more of what he had to say.</s>ERIC BOLLING, HOST, "AMERICA THIS WEEK": With COVID, is there anything that you think you could have done differently? If you have a mulligan or a do-over on one aspect of the way you handled it, what would it be?</s>DONALD TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: Not much. Look, it's all over the world. You have a lot of great leaders and a lot of smart people. It's all over the world. It came out of China and China should have stopped it.</s>ACOSTA: Now, Trump advisers are hopeful the president will do less interrupting than he did at the last presidential debate. That's because they think that the president turned off some voters out there as they watched all of that unfold. They also are hopeful the president will allow Democratic Joe Biden to talk more in the hopes that the former vice president will have some sort of gaffe that will shake up the race -- Christine and Laura.</s>JARRETT: All right, Jim Acosta. Thank you so much for that. So how does Joe Biden plan to counter the unpredictable President Trump in their final debate tonight? CNN's Arlette Saenz is with the Biden campaign.</s>ARLETTE SAENZ, CNN POLITICAL CORRESPONDENT: Laura and Christine, the former vice president spent the past three days off the campaign trail meeting with his advisers as he prepared for this final matchup. Biden's advisers say he will focus on talking about COVID-19 and his plan to build back the economy, once again stressing that Scranton versus Park Avenue messaging that Biden has tried to frame this campaign around in these closing weeks. Now, Biden's advisers say that the former vice president is preparing for President Trump to bully and deflect his way through this upcoming debate. They expect that the president will not just attack Joe Biden but also go after his family. And Biden's deputy campaign manager said that ultimately, these debates are a test of presidential temperament. Biden has said that he plans on turning this debate back to the issues at hand -- what matters most to voters in these final 12 days before the election as voters will gauge whether they're going to vote for Biden or President Trump -- Laura and Christine.</s>JARRETT: All right. As Arlette said, 12 days to the election. It's time for three questions in three minutes. Let's bring in CNN senior political analyst John Avlon. John, great to see you. Thanks for getting up --</s>JOHN AVLON, CNN SENIOR POLITICAL ANALYST: Good morning.</s>JARRETT: -- with us. It is debate night -- probably the last chance, one might think, for a president to change the trajectory in this race, although I'm not sure that that's true with 40 million people already having voted.</s>AVLON: It's also 2020, so kind of balance those two things, you know.</s>JARRETT: It's also 2020. There's always the chance for another October surprise.</s>AVLON: Yes.</s>JARRETT: What do you think? Can the president change anyone's mind tonight?</s>AVLON: Look, this is his last best chance. I mean, he really had a ton of self-inflicted wounds in the first debate. Second debates are where presidents tend to come back. And -- but look, he's going to be told by his folks don't be quite as aggressive. As you just heard, let Joe Biden speak for himself and the gaffes will come. The problem is Trump's going to trump. He's not going to change even those he's got his mic muted at the top of the first two minutes, his strategy is to try to get Joe Biden off base. Now, where things are going to get ugly is if he goes after his family and his son, as he almost certainly will. That's playing dangerous ball because the chance of backlash, the Trump team must know, is significant.</s>ROMANS: Yes, absolutely, and they're ready for it. I think they must be ready for it --</s>AVLON: Yes.</s>ROMANS: -- this time in this debate prep. Let's look at this map. This all about the road to 270 electoral votes. You know, not a lot of undecideds left -- only 12 days. Even if you give the president all of these states in yellow -- he won them all, by the way, in 2016 -- he still can't top Biden. What swing state can Trump bring into his column at this point?</s>AVLON: Such a great question and it's really the key question. Remember, these are state races they're trying to cobble together 270. Look, I think any southern states that are within the margin of error remain very much in Donald Trump's possibility if he doesn't have a lot of unforced errors. So, Georgia, North Carolina -- those are places he could bring them in. These are all classic swing states, by the way.</s>ROMANS: Yes.</s>AVLON: I think Arizona, he can make a real push. The Senate race has been trending Democrat but, you know, you shouldn't count Donald Trump out. Some folks will start talking about districts in -- you know, the main two in Nebraska one and Nebraska two. But he's got to -- this is a game that enters at this point. It's a cliche because it's true. But he should not -- his team can't afford to give up some particularly southern states within the margin of error. Here's the bigger problem. He's running out of money and that gives Biden a big advantage to prosecute that case with ads in the final days of the race.</s>JARRETT: Yes, they have blown through a serious amount of cash. John, finally, some odd deja vu last night. As I thought it was safe to go to sleep, we see a hastily arranged FBI news conference just two weeks before the election, once again about e-mails. Although this time it's different. National security officials are accusing Iran and also Russia of obtaining U.S. voter registration data to obviously interfere and meddle in the election. But given the role of John Ratcliffe here, the head of the -- the director of the national --</s>AVLON: Yes.</s>JARRETT: -- national intelligence, I should say, it's being viewed with skepticism I think. And this is where the erosion of trust --</s>AVLON: Yes.</s>JARRETT: -- we're seeing in government matters. So how should we receive -- how should voters receive what they learned last night?</s>AVLON: Look, you're absolutely right to point out that John Ratcliffe has a massive credibility gap because he promised to leave politics out of it during his confirmation hearings and he's been the most political DNI we've seen to date -- no surprise. Look, even the order of these two countries and how it was presented -- Iran and Russia -- wreaks of politics. That said, getting voter registration data is potentially a big deal. We know Russia was trying to do it last time around. It upon itself doesn't prove anything, but the danger of elections being thrown into chaos because of voter roll confusion or incursion is a very big deal. This administration has not taken that danger seriously enough. They've tried to deflect away from Russia repeatedly. The fact is Russia's in this game and we should not be like generals fighting the last war.</s>ROMANS: Yes.</s>AVLON: Pay attention to these swing states in these swing districts. As a former prime minister of Estonia, oddly enough, once told me -- it's not that you need to change the results of an election entirely, you need to raise doubt about key districts.</s>JARRETT: Well -- and I think Ratcliffe raised a lot of questions because he said that the effort was to hurt the president by putting out these e-mails from the Proud Boys ostensibly --</s>AVLON: Yes.</s>JARRETT: -- but he didn't quite explain it. And then an intelligence official later had to clean it up and say it's because of the relationship or the at least assumed relationship between the Proud Boys and the president that it would be seen as hurting the president. But, Ratcliffe didn't really explain that connection at the time. So I guess we'll have to see how this all plays out tonight at the debate.</s>AVLON: Let's pay eagle-eyed attention.</s>JARRETT: Yes, sure to come up.</s>ROMANS: All right.</s>JARRETT: Thanks so much, John.</s>AVLON: Thanks, guys.</s>JARRETT: Appreciate it. Nice to see you. All right. CNN has learned that both campaigns are prepared to deploy thousands of poll watchers on Election Day. Each party is training people to document, record, and pass along incidents to their respective legal teams, which could be used as evidence in future legal disputes. Forty million Americans, as we mentioned, have now voted nationwide but efforts to suppress the vote are ongoing. The Supreme Court, last night, blocked curbside voting in Alabama despite the pandemic. And in battleground Iowa, the state Supreme Court sides with the GOP, saying county officials cannot use the state's database to fill in missing information on ballot applications, as they have in prior elections. The deadline to request an absentee ballot in Iowa is on Saturday, so time to fix errors is very short right now.</s>ROMANS: In Indiana, a federal appeals court overturned a lower court order extending the state's absentee ballot deadline. Ballots are now back to being due by noon on Election Day. And, North Carolina Republicans signaling they may appeal to the Supreme Court after a lower court ruled ballots mailed by Election Day can still be counted as long as they are received by November 12th. Bottom line, check it out with your state and local election authorities and act early here, right? All right, a major change from the CDC. The agency updating how it defines a close contact with a COVID-19 patient. It used to be thought that you needed 15 continuous minutes of exposure. That's changed. Now it can also be a series of multiple brief exposures after a Vermont prison worker appears to have been infected that way.</s>DR. PETER HOTEZ, DEAN, NATIONAL SCHOOL OF TROPICAL MEDICINE: And it's a reminder that we don't have a lot of tools in our -- in our</s>JARRETT: The U.S. suffered nearly 62,000 cases yesterday. The seven- day average is on the verge of surpassing 60,000 for the first time since August third. And a volunteer in Brazil's trial of the AstraZeneca COVID vaccine has died, but authorities say that's no reason to stop the trial entirely. Thousands of people are enrolled in it and they say there's no reason to assume that it was the vaccine that killed this particular volunteer who may have received the placebo anyway. Well, a rise in coronavirus cases forcing a big city school district to rethink plans to bring students back into the classroom. CNN has the pandemic covered coast-to-coast for you.</s>BIANNA GOLODRYGA, CNN SENIOR GLOBAL AFFAIRS ANALYST: I'm Bianna Golodryga in New York. Boston Public Schools announced Wednesday that due to a rising COVId- 19 infection rate in the city, all students will shift to remote learning effective today. The city's seven-day average COVID-19 positivity test rate was reported at 5.7 percent. That's an increase from 4.5 percent last week. Students will remain in remote learning until there are two full weeks of falling infection rates.</s>PETE MUNTEAN, CNN AVIATION CORRESPONDENT: I'm Pete Muntean in Washington. International Travel is suffering because of COVID restrictions. Now, airlines are trying out a new mobile health pass app. United Airlines is trying something called CommonPass. It stores your coronavirus health status, including the results of a recent coronavirus test that you may have taken for airlines and governments to see while protecting your private health data. United Airlines passengers tried it for the first time on Wednesday -- the route from Newark to London. And the idea, United says, could be expanded soon.</s>OMAR JIMENEZ, CNN CORRESPONDENT: I'm Omar Jimenez. And in multiple states across the Midwest we have seen rising coronavirus numbers, but especially so in Wisconsin. The state set a single-day death record Wednesday of 48. The state built a field hospital just to try and keep up with the pace and Wednesday, it admitted its first patient. Now, all of this comes as the state's positivity rate has soared to more than 22 percent as early in-person voting begins for Wisconsin that has already seen people show up to the polls in the tens of thousands.</s>BRYNN GINGRAS, CNN NATIONAL CORRESPONDENT: I'm Brynn Gingras. Halloween in New York City is happening. It will be a bit different this year, of course, because of the pandemic, but the mayor of this city says that it can go on safely. So what does that mean? Well, trick-or-treaters need to stay outdoors. No trick-or-treating in those big, tall apartment buildings. Treats -- they should be placed in baskets rather than handed out, and hand sanitizer should be at the ready. The mayor is reminding trick-or-treaters also that costume masks cannot replace a proper face mask. And his blessing to celebrate Halloween comes as health officials say hotspot areas in New York City are leveling off in cases.</s>ROMANS: All right, thanks to our reporters for all of those. Now, as the pandemic drags into its eighth month now, a growing number of Americans are running out of their state unemployment benefits and shifting now to extended payments funded by the federal government. That was part of the CARES Act and that extra cushion won't last much longer. The 13-week benefit extension runs out at the end of the year and an extended benefit program triggers when state jobless rates soar. That's winding down in some states as their economies recover. All this could leave millions without a financial lifeline as the jobs recovery stalls. In one week, 372,000 people filed for special pandemic relief programs. Altogether, 25.5 million people are getting some sort of jobless assistance. These are the people who need stimulus, right? Sources say passing another deal through both chambers will most likely have to wait until the lame-duck session. We'll be right back.
Pope Francis Endorses Same-Sex Civil Unions.
ROMANS: A stunning shift at the Vatican. Pope Francis becoming the first-ever pontiff to endorse same-sex civil unions. CNN's Delia Gallagher live in Rome with the details. Tell us about the thinking. This was in a documentary that debuted. It would signal a shift, really, in church thinking.</s>DELIA GALLAGHER, CNN VATICAN CORRESPONDENT: Well, that's right, absolutely. This came out last night in a documentary that premiered here in Rome. Let's take a look at what the Pope said in that documentary, according to the Catholic News Agency. He said, "Homosexual people have a right to be in a family. They're children of God and have a right to a family. What we have to create is a civil union law. That way they are legally covered." Now, as you can imagine, this has been met with both praise and criticism by some Christine because it is a change from the position of the Pope's predecessors, John Paul II and Benedict XVI, who were against legalizing same-sex unions. However, Francis, in the past, has expressed an openness to legal protections for same-sex couples even though he's made a distinction between that and marriage, which he says should be between a man and a woman. Nonetheless, these are really important comments coming from the Pope because it's the first time he's directly supporting legalization of same-sex unions. We should mention that these were comments, of course, made in a film so we don't have yet any official document from the Pope or the Vatican on this topic. So we'll have to wait and see how this develops -- Christine.</s>ROMANS: All right, Delia Gallagher for us in Rome. Fascinating -- thanks.</s>JARRETT: All right. Senate Democrats on the Judiciary Committee plan to boycott a key hearing today expected to advance Judge Amy Coney Barrett's Supreme Court nomination. They say they'll fill the seats with pictures of people affected by Obamacare to stress that Judge Barrett would be a threat to the law. The GOP has been accused of rushing to confirm a justice who President Trump has said he hopes would help sway the election if it should end up in court. Senate Republicans are also defending Barrett against a report about her time on the board of a private Christian school system. The Associated Press reports that the school has anti-LGBTQ policies.</s>ROMANS: All right. Purdue Pharma agreeing to a kind of corporate death penalty for its role in creating the country's opioid crisis. The company, which made billions of dollars as the crisis worsened, will plead guilty to federal criminal charges and pay more than $8 billion. The company will shut down. The DEA says the devastating ripple effect of Purdue's actions left lives lost and others addicted. Purdue's assets will be used to create a non-profit trust that will continue to make OxyContin and overdose rescue drugs. The earnings will ultimately be used to combat opioid addiction.</s>JARRETT: Rare to see a company face criminal charges there. Well, archeologists in Oklahoma searching for the victims of the 1921 Tulsa massacre say they found a mass grave. They also found at least one set of human remains on-site there at the cemetery. So far, they haven't been able to confirm that the remains are actually the massacre victims but the state archaeologist says that she's confident that they're looking in the right place. Hundreds of African-Americans were killed in the massacre when a white mob looted and burned down what was then known as Black Wall Street.</s>ROMANS: All right, just about 52 minutes past the hour this Thursday morning. Losses for markets around the world. You can see Asian shares closed mixed. Europe opened lower. And on Wall Street, looking at futures -- right now, futures are leaning lower. Stocks closed down Wednesday. The Dow fell 99 points. No stimulus -- 98 points -- no stimulus deal yet and hopes fading there. Also, this report from the Federal Reserve, known as the Beige Book, found the economic recovery is slowing and said the jobs picture is confusing. On one hand, you have more layoffs by some companies, but other companies report they can't find workers because there's not child care and there are concerns about people's health. The S&P 500 and the Nasdaq also closed down. In just a few hours, we'll get another look at layoffs -- another weekly jobless claims report. Figures expected to show a small decline in claims but still well above pre-pandemic levels. Tesla thriving during the pandemic and vows to sell half a million cars this year. Tesla reported a net income of $874 million, nearly double its second-quarter profit. There were doubts, of course, Tesla could achieve its 500,000 goal given its California plant was temporarily shut down when the pandemic began. It has delivered 319,000 cars in the first three quarters of this year. Tesla's stock, by the way, continues to deliver. It's up an astonishing 405 percent this year. Much like its content, Quibi didn't last very long. The short-form video app is shutting down just six months after it launched. This was a major initiative backed by some of Hollywood's most powerful people like Jeffrey Katzenberg and Meg Whitman, but the company struggled after launching during the pandemic in a very crowded streaming market. Quibi plans to return the remaining cash to investors and look for buyers for its assets.</s>JARRETT: Well, here's an extraordinary move by a pro-sports franchise. The Seattle Storm of the WNBA is endorsing the Biden-Harris ticket. Now you don't often see sports teams endorse candidates but the Storm has sort of done this before. Over the summer, they backed a Democratic opponent of Republican Sen. Kelly Loeffler, who co-owns the WNBA's Atlanta Dream. The Storm has also supported Black Lives Matter. By contrast, NFL legend Brett Favre asked President Trump during a town hall how pro sports should promote an anti-racism position without alienating fans and losing ratings.</s>ROMANS: All right. Coming to a Sam's Club near you, robot janitors. The big-box chain deploying nearly 400 autonomous floor scrubbers to its stores during the pandemic. Hundreds are already in place at Sam's Club locations but now there will be a robot in every store nationwide. Walmart, which owns Sam's Club, is partnering with the company Brain Corp on the robot technology.</s>JARRETT: It makes you wonder what that means for the jobs there, though, right?</s>ROMANS: Absolutely, but it's -- you know, it's also about the safety of workers as well.</s>JARRETT: Yes.</s>ROMANS: You need to deploy people to do other things if you don't have them doing that. All right, enjoy the debate tonight, everybody. Thanks for joining us. I'm Christine Romans.</s>JARRETT: I'm Laura Jarrett. "NEW DAY" is next.
Source: Biden Prepped in Mock Debates for Trump Attacks, Interruptions; Trump Advisers Plead for President to Take Less Combative Approach; Awaiting Start of Final Trump-Biden Debate.
COOPER: And we are back with our coverage of the final presidential debate of 2020. It is the candidates last best chance to influence the important race for 270 electoral votes. John King is at the magic wall with more on that. John.</s>JOHN KING, CNN CHIEF NATIONAL CORRESPONDENT: Anderson, you have to say advantage Biden and significantly so as we head into the final debate and essentially the final 10 days, we're 12 days out, but 10 days really the campaign left after this. We right now have the electoral college outlook the path to 270, 290 for Joe Biden, the deep blue solid Biden, the light blue lean Biden, same dark red solid Trump, lean red look at that Texas leaning red right now that tells you about the Presidents problem. Lean Trump, 294 Joe Biden to 163 for the President, everybody knows it takes 270 to win. So if nothing changed, if Joe Biden comes out of this debate and nothing on this map change. He's the next President of the United States. What's different on this map? Number one, Pennsylvania, Michigan and Wisconsin, the three states that made Donald Trump president, the blue wall he cracked and flipped red. We lean them all for Joe Biden heading into this debate. All these toss up states, Iowa, Ohio, North Carolina, Georgia, Florida, all carried by President Trump last time. So the map is very different. The President is on defense. But, of course, he was losing heading into the last debate last time. What if the President turns in a strong debate tonight? What if he makes the case his advisors hope? Joe Biden will raise your taxes, you don't want a Democratic economic plan. Well, if the President comes out of this debate strong tonight, the Biden campaign might go into protect mode. Let's say the President has a strong debate and people come out thinking, Iowa is going to stay Republican, Ohio, North Carolina, Georgia, Florida, if they start trending the President's way, then Biden goes into protect mode in the final days, which is protect those three; Wisconsin, Michigan and Pennsylvania. Because you can imagine a scenario even with, Anderson, if the President comes out strong tonight that he would get Arizona back as well, long a Republican state. It's trending toward the Democrats, but you could see this scenario play out and if all that happened, you'd have 279-259. The President then would be back in play and it would come down to these big industrial battlegrounds or some combination if the President could somehow get Nevada and New Hampshire. But the Trump campaign would agree, this is where the fight would be if he can come out strong tonight and flip the toss up states his way. But let's try another scenario, coming into this debate, Joe Biden is in command of this race and you see that when you look, number one, at a number of things, but let's look number one at the battleground states. Imagine if Joe Biden has a strong debate tonight. Even if he breaks even with President Trump and nothing changes. Well, if nothing changes, Joe Biden goes into this final debate ahead in Michigan, ahead in Wisconsin, ahead in Pennsylvania and ahead in these other states as well. A little bit in Arizona, maybe a tiny bit in Iowa, you can call that a tie if you want. Call that Georgia tie but at least Joe Biden is in play in a state that hasn't gone red since Bill Clinton, a long time ago. Florida, slight advantage Biden right now. President Trump can't win without Florida. Look at all the menu options Joe Biden has to get not only to 270, but maybe even to try to build to 300. The President has to change this and change it dramatically. One of the challenges for the President, Anderson, is you look at this right now, TV ad spending. The Biden campaign has more money, there's a lot of super PAC money coming and a lot of money. But even there the Democrats have an advantage. This is just the Biden campaign for the last two weeks, $52 million in TV ad spending in Florida, North Carolina, Arizona, Pennsylvania. Look at that, Texas is in the top five for Joe Biden, making a play to try to bring Texas his way. The President spending much less money, $20 million less. That's a lot of money for the final week. Florida, Pennsylvania, North Carolina, Michigan and Arizona, what's common here. The President trying to get back all states he won last time. So when you look at the map right now into this debate, you have to say advantage Biden. Democrats, of course, haunted by 2016 and they know the President was losing them, but this is a different map Anderson just without a doubt, especially Wisconsin, Michigan, Pennsylvania, unless the President can have a strong economic debate tonight, start to bring those back his way. You have to say heading in it's advantage Biden. Biden's biggest goal tonight, keep things just the way they are.</s>COOPER: I will be checking with you throughout the night. President Trump had an opportunity to try to reset his campaign tonight. It's not clear if he'll change his strategy after his hyper aggressive performance in the first debate. Let's go to Abby Phillip. Abby, there are new rules tonight but the animosity we saw certainly in that first debate is still there.</s>ABBY PHILLIP, CNN WHITE HOUSE CORRESPONDENT: Oh, absolutely. And the stakes are even higher now tonight with less than two weeks before the election. After the last debate, voters were turned off by a noxious combination of constant interruptions and biting personal attacks. But with President Trump teeing up new attacks on Joe Biden's family, it's very possible we could see something very similar tonight.</s>CHRIS WALLACE, FOX NEWS HOST: Mr. President, can you let him finish, sir?</s>JOE BIDEN (D) PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATE: He doesn't know how to do that. He has ...</s>DONALD TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: You'd be surprised.</s>PHILLIP(voice over): They say politics ain't beanbag. But even by that standard, the first faceoff between President Trump and former Vice President Joe Biden was a slugfest.</s>BIDEN: Will you shut up, man?</s>PHILLIP(voice over): A 90-minute grudge match with dozens of moments like this?</s>BIDEN: You should go out and vote. You are in voting now, vote and let your senators know how strongly you feel.</s>TRUMP: Are you going to pack the court?</s>BIDEN: Because the question is ...</s>TRUMP: ... put a lot of new Supreme Court justices, radical left ...</s>BIDEN: Will you shut up, man?</s>TRUMP: Listen, who is on your list, Joe? Who's on your list?</s>BIDEN: This is ...</s>WALLACE: Gentleman, I think ...</s>BIDEN: This is so unpresidential.</s>TRUMP: He is going to pack the court.</s>BIDEN: They can in fact take care of it if he'd just stay out of the way. Look here ...</s>TRUMP: Oh, really? Oh, really?</s>PHILLIP(voice over): And the moderator struggling to keep it under control.</s>WALLACE: You have never in these four years come up with a plan, a comprehensive plan to replace Obamacare.</s>TRUMP: Yes, I have. Of course, I have.</s>WALLACE: Well, I'll give you - when I finish I'm going to give you an opportunity ...</s>TRUMP: I got rid of the individual mandate - excuse me, I got rid of the individual mandate. Well, you didn't do very well in Swine Flu. H1N1. You were a disaster. Your own chief of staff said you were a disaster.</s>BIDEN: Fourteen thousand people died, not 200,000. There was no economic recession.</s>TRUMP: A very ...</s>WALLACE: Sir, you made a ...</s>TRUMP: ... a far less lethal disease.</s>BIDEN: There was no (inaudible) ...</s>WALLACE: You made a point. Let him answer.</s>BIDEN: And there was no one - no, we didn't shut down the economy. (Inaudible) ...</s>TRUMP: He made a statement about the military, (inaudible) ... Well, first of all, I guess I'm debating you, not him. But that's OK, I'm not surprised.</s>PHILLIP(voice over): Tonight, Biden and Trump will meet again on the debate stage with new rules designed to keep order. But no mute button is likely to stop these kinds of personal attacks.</s>BIDEN: I'm going to make sure ...</s>TRUMP: You graduated last in your class not first in your class.</s>BIDEN: You're the worst president America has ever had.</s>PHILLIP(voice over): Trump interrupting Biden talking about his late son Beau Biden with this attack.</s>BIDEN: And I resent white Joe ...</s>TRUMP: Are you talking about Hunter? Are you talking about Hunter?</s>BIDEN: I'm talking of my son, Beau Biden. You're talking about (inaudible) ...</s>TRUMP: I don't know Beau. I know Hunter.</s>PHILLIP(voice over): Biden resorting to language unheard of on a presidential debate stage.</s>BIDEN: Folks, do you have any idea what this clown is doing?</s>TRUMP: And under that plan, you're going to socialize, they call it (inaudible) ...</s>PHILLIP(voice over): A historically vicious presidential debate in the middle of a global pandemic and the coronavirus may already have been literally hanging in the air.</s>TRUMP: He could be speaking 200-feet away from and he shows up with the biggest mask I've ever seen.</s>PHILLIP(voice over): Just two days later, President Trump and First Lady Melania Trump testing positive. Trump spending days in the hospital. The debate commission now scrambling to change course on tone and health precautions. First, plans to convert the second debate to a virtual format were scrapped after Trump objected. Now, for tonight's debate, a mute button. And this time anyone not wearing a mask inside the hall will be ejected. For President Trump last month's debate went over like a lead balloon with some swing voters.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: Contentious.</s>UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: Embarrassing.</s>UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: Childish.</s>UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: Train wreck.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: President Trump barely has control issues and he couldn't stop his anger.</s>PHILLIP(voice over): Tonight, a final chance for the two candidates to make an impression.</s>DOUGLAS BRINKLEY, CNN PRESIDENTIAL HISTORIAN: There's an opportunity here for each candidate to make a closing statement. It's going to be hard because of all of the angry named calling going on and how it will descend to such a low road. But it is the last time you're going to get this sort of millions of people watching and hearing your act, so they still matter.</s>PHILLIP: The changes announced by the debate commission this two- minute period where one of the candidates will be muted while the other is giving their initial answer. It's designed to make this debate more substantive, so people can actually hear what is going on. And with millions of people voting now and million of people tuning in, it'll really matter whether or not they're able to get something out of it. But of course, it will be up to Biden and President Trump to truly set the tone tonight.</s>COOPER: Yes. Abby, appreciate it. Thanks very much. Let's go to our team who are standing by who are going to be with us all evening long. David Axelrod, I mean, it seems like both men have something that they could try to improve upon from the last debate, certainly President Trump. I mean, if he looks at all the focus groups, the reaction to the last debate I guess he would try to be less obnoxious and aggressive and interrupting. And Vice President Biden was thrown off repeatedly by the President interrupting and kind of losing his train of thought, whenever the President would interrupt.</s>DAVID AXELROD, CNN SENIOR POLITICAL COMMENTATOR: Yes. No, exactly. Yes. If the President were sitting down, reading focus groups, that's what he would do. The question is, does he do that? I mean, he does have to change the trajectory of this race in this debate. He did it last time, but he sent it in the wrong trajectory with his behavior. And the question is can he correct that, can he control that here. For Joe Biden, he can't chase the rabbit down the hole. He can't let Trump throw him off his game. He scored when he was talking to America in that debate. When he turned to the camera and talked to people about their lives and their problems and his response to them, he did very, very well. When he got thrown off, he did not. And I'm sure that's a lot of what they've been working on in the last few days.</s>GLORIA BORGER, CNN CHIEF POLITICAL ANALYST: But I think the question that I really have here is about the President's behavior. Because if you look over the last few days, what is the President talking about? He's been angry. He's mad at the format. He's mad at the moderator. He's mad at 60 Minutes and Lesley Stahl. He's mad at everything. And if he walks into that debate hall and he's still angry, you're going to see the same Donald Trump. And I've spent four years listening to people say, Donald Trump is going to pivot, he's going to be different. He is not going to be different. Maybe he'll hold it in for the first answer, maybe even the second answer, but if I were a wagering person, I'd put a lot of money on the fact that he's not going to be able to go 90 minutes without reverting to form and that will not sit well.</s>COOPER: Van, I mean, they are muting mics. I don't know - again ...</s>BORGER: Yes, good luck.</s>COOPER: ... that doesn't mean the candidate is going to be muted.</s>VAN JONES, CNN POLITICAL COMMENTATOR: The moderator is going to be the most envied person in America that have the power to mute Donald Trump for an hour and a half. That's a good thing. Listen, this is the big deal. For those of us who have been watching this stuff and the details of it, the reality is the next time this is the biggest audience these guys have. The next time these guys have a big audience, one of them is going to be giving concession speech, the other is going to be giving a victory speech. That's how close we are to the end of this thing. And tonight, you got to get your base shored up and fired up and working moms need a champion tonight. When you're talking to people in the real world, they're not talking about all of these shenanigans. They got kids that can't go to school, they can't do sports, they can't go to daycare, they can't go to work. They're getting crushed. Donald Trump has already said he has no regrets looking back and no health care plan looking forward. Which means you've got a great opportunity, if you're Biden, to say I have an answer for you. Now, the trick for Biden is just not to get - sound like Captain Quarantine, though he's got to look like somebody who's going to open the economy up but do it safely and responsibly whereas Trump wants to open it up irresponsibly. But there are people out there hurting and if Biden focuses on that, he's going to have a great night. Ignore Donald Trump, focus on the people.</s>COOPER: Senator?</s>RICK SANTORUM, CNN SENIOR POLITICAL COMMENTATOR: Yes. So I what I think is going to happen, Anderson, if you remember the last debate, we were together, I said that Trump would come out and be very, very aggressive. I don't think he's going to do that this time. If you just look at his comment the other day where he was saying, I'm going to win this race. Now, I wouldn't have said that three weeks ago. That's what he said. And the reason he wouldn't have said that three weeks ago, it was shortly after the debate and he saw just like everybody else that he cratered. I mean, you talk to people in all of the swing states and they say the race got away from me three weeks ago and - but it is coming back ...</s>BORGBER: How?</s>SANTORUM: ... and I think there is enthusiasm. I can tell you, I mean, I talked to conservatives, there's a lot of enthusiasm, races are closing, for statehouse, state Senate, Congress in a lot of these swing states and there's a momentum out there that Trump feels. Now he may be angry and I get that, but I'm telling you, he thinks he is on - the momentum is on his side and I think he's going to be very positive tonight.</s>JONES: Senator, it would be great if - listen, if he would just be quiet and let Biden talk, I think it's actually a ...</s>SANTORUM: I think you're going to see more of that.</s>JONES: ... look, it's a better strategy for Trump. In other words ...</s>SANTORUM: It is.</s>JONES: ... Trump's worst enemy is Trump.</s>SANTORUM: No.</s>JONES: If Trump would just shut up and let Biden talk, then he could actually make his own point and he's a much better performer than Biden, but the reality is what he's going to do he's going to talk about Hunter Biden, he's going to talk about a bunch of stuff nobody cares about and Biden is going to talk about the real stuff.</s>SANTORUM: That's a very key point in this and this is up to the moderator is when they're going to bring up the foreign policy part. Because to me, that's the time he's going to bring up Joe Biden selling his office to foreign folks. And if she decides we're going to bring this up first, I think that's bad for Trump, because he's going to level that charge when they talk about that subject. If he waits til the end, then I think Trump may actually be benefited by that by not actually going there and sort of setting the tone for the debate too early.</s>ANDERSON COOPER, CNN HOST: Do you think he'll wait -- you think he'll wait for that to bring up --</s>SANTORUM: I think he will. I think he will.</s>COOPER: David?</s>GLORIA BORGER, CNN CHIEF POLITICAL ANALYST: No, I don't think he will.</s>DAVID AXELROD, CNN SENIOR POLITICAL COMMENTATOR: I don't know. But let me tell you this, if I were Joe Biden, I would say go ahead and take the mute off, because I don't think Donald Trump is helped by what he did in the last debate. The mute is maybe beneficial to him to keep him from being Donald Trump. And so, by the way, Van, I was -- I'm relieved to hear that you think one of these candidates is going to give a concession speech. I'm not sure that the president will ever give a concession speech. But go ahead.</s>BORGER: Can I just say this?</s>COOPER: Yeah, Gloria, go ahead.</s>BORGER: I think that the public would benefit, and we would all benefit from hearing some more on the issues tonight, which we didn't hear in the first debate, obviously. And for example, in the "60 Minutes" interview, the president of the United States said that he hopes the Supreme Court overturns Obamacare. Well, I guarantee you that that is something that either we'll be asked about, or that Joe Biden is going to raise, and then the president will have to talk about his plan for health care in the middle of a pandemic for over 200,000 people have died.</s>COOPER: Yeah, but there is no plan, and he's refused to talk about whatever he says there is a plan.</s>BORGER: That's right.</s>COOPER: Much more ahead on tonight's debate and an unanswered question about the coronavirus pandemic. We have new details on President Trump's recovery from COVID-19, next.
Campaigns Consulted With Dr. Fauci on Removing Plexiglass
BURNETT: It is debate night in America. And President Trump will be taking the stage you see on your screen in about 90 minutes from now, as a recovering COVID-19 patient. So I want to go back to Jim Acosta in the debate hall. And, Jim, there are a lot of questions about the president's illness that could come up tonight, right? I mean, a lot of things that we have never been told, even now. What are you learning?</s>JIM ACOSTA, CNN CHIEF WHITE HOUSE CORRESPONDENT: That's right. And perhaps Joe Biden will ask some of those questions. We'll wait and see. But in the meantime, one of the biggest developments heading into tonight's debate is that these plexiglass dividers were removed by the debate commission after the commission consulted with Dr. Anthony Fauci, who spoke with a physician associated with the debate commission earlier this afternoon. The dividers deemed not necessary because both candidates have tested negative for the coronavirus. But it's yet another example of why this virus hangs over everything, even a debate, in our lives now.</s>ACOSTA (voice-over): President Trump landed in Nashville for his final debate with Joe Biden, sounding more obsessed with perhaps his biggest election obstacle standing in his way of a second term, the coronavirus.</s>DONALD TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: All you hear is</s>COVID, COVID, COVID, COVID, COVID, COVID, COVID, COVID, COVID, COVID. ACOSTA: Even after his bout with COVID-19, there are constant reminders, White House officials say the president tested negative for the virus en route to the debate hall. Biden is all but certain to challenge Mr. Trump's efforts to downplay the pandemic.</s>TRUMP: That pandemic is rounding the corner. The vaccine will end the pandemic. But it's ending any way. I look fine, don't I?</s>ACOSTA: CNN has learned, Mr. Trump spoke with Dr. Anthony Fauci during his recovery. Advisers had hoped the president would use his battle as a campaign reset. But instead he's dug in, blaming Fauci, even after relying on his advice.</s>TRUMP: Fauci is a disaster. People are tired of hearing Fauci and all these idiots.</s>ACOSTA: It's been just 17 days since the president returned to the White House after being hospitalized, ripping off his mask and proclaiming himself cured.</s>TRUMP: And now, they call them therapeutic, but to me, it wasn't therapeutic. It just made me better, okay? I call that a cure.</s>ACOSTA: The next four days, president Trump remained out of sight, doing friendly interviews by phone.</s>TRUMP: I will say this, absentee is okay, because absentee ballots -- excuse me.</s>ACOSTA: The president was given a mix of treatments at Walter Reed, including an experimental antibody therapy cocktail and a five-day course of remdesivir. He also received steroid dexamethasone after his oxygen level dipped, along with several other medications.</s>TRUMP: I woke up and I felt good. I said, get me out of here. Boom, superman.</s>ACOSTA: With an all clear from his doctor, Sean Conley, Mr. Trump hit the trail, while the president always travels with the physician from the White House medical unit, Conley personally accompanied the president for his first rally after his diagnosis, where he said this --</s>TRUMP: I'll kiss everyone in that audience. I'll kiss the guys and the beautiful women and everybody. I'll just give you a big fat kiss.</s>ACOSTA: Still, much of the president's illness remains a mystery, with Mr. Trump and his doctors repeatedly dodging request for more details.</s>SAVANNAH GUTHRIE, NBC NEWS ANCHOR: Did the doctors say they saw pneumonia on your lungs?</s>TRUMP: No, but they said the lungs are, you know, a little bit different, a little bit -- perhaps infected.</s>GUTHRIE: Infected with?</s>TRUMP: I don't know. I mean, I didn't do too much asking.</s>ACOSTA: The president also won't divulge when he last tested negative for the virus, prior to his first debate with Biden.</s>TRUMP: Is that very important to you? You seem to be so intent. But if it's so important to you, why is it so important to you?</s>ACOSTA: Ahead of tonight's debate, Mr. Trump has now attended 15 in- person events and rallies, plus two town halls, three fund-raisers and one church service since his diagnosis. Today was First Lady Melania Trump's first appearance after she backed out of a rally earlier this week due to a persistent cough. The president has been quick to show off his recovered White House staff.</s>UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: We can share a microphone now.</s>TRUMP: She just recovered from</s>COVID. ACOSTA: But some advisers aren't so pleased.</s>CHRIS CHRISTIE (R), FORMER NEW JERSEY GOVERNOR: I was led to believe that, you know, all the people I was interacting with at the White House had been tested. And it gave you a false sense of security, and it was a mistake.</s>ACOSTA: Former New Jersey Governor Chris Christie who tested positive after helping with President Trump's debate prep sessions is now encouraging Americans to wear a mask, writing in an op-ed Wednesday, wear it or you may regret it, as I did.</s>ACOSTA: And the president's campaign advisers are planning as many as five rallies between now and Election Day, which means tonight's debate are with all of the precautions that are being taken may, in fact, be the safest event for the president over the next 11 or 12 days -- Erin.</s>BURNETT: All right. Absolutely. Thank you very much, Jim. And since President Trump had coronavirus, we have now seen that dreaded fall wave of coronavirus emerge. It's growing worse by the day. You've got record hospitalizations in some states and deaths rising. John King has more on the pandemic. And what you have seen so far, Jim, of its impact on this presidential race.</s>JOHN KING, CNN CHIEF NATIONAL CORRESPONDENT: Erin, when the president says we're rounding the corner, he's simply not telling the truth. The numbers don't lie, as you know. We are heading up toward another peak. Let's go through it. We'll go through number by number. This map just tells you all you need to know. Red and orange are bad. You see a lot of red and orange. That means cases reporting more new COVID infections now compared to a week ago. New Mexico, bright red. More than 50 percent, more cases this week compared to last week. New Mexico is in crisis right now. But 30 other states reporting more new COVID infections this week than last week. That is not running the turn, that is heading up the hill yet again, 18 states holding steady. Only one, only one of the 50 states, Hawaii, reporting fewer cases right now than a week ago. The country is trending in the wrong direction. If you look at the case line, remember, we've been through this for eight months. We went up the hill in March. We came down, and the president said here it would disappear in April. It didn't. The vice president said it would be behind us by Memorial Day. Not true. The president said at the peak of the summer surge in late July, the virus will disappear. Look what has happened since. We came down some but only to a baseline of about 40,000. Now we are heading back up with 60,000 new infections a day. The president said in July it would disappear. Since then, more than half of the cases in the United States. 53 percent of the cases since the president said that,.36 percent of the deaths in the United States since the president said in July. It wasn't the first time, but at the peak of the summer surge, he said it would disappear. We're going back up. We're close to the peak of the summer surge, and everybody says we're going higher. Where are we right now? This trend line, it's a tough line to use, this is the trend line of American deaths from the coronavirus. And we went way up early on. It was new. The hospitals were overwhelmed. You do see, because of new treatments and because the vulnerable are protecting themselves, this has been down a little bit. But look in recent days, 1,000 American deaths in the last couple of deaths. That trend line starting to inch back up. You see the curve right there. This is the map of a crisis, plain and simple, the deeper the blue, the higher the positivity rate. Meaning, more new infections today because people are testing positive. And the more people who test positive, the more risk of spread. Look at this, 55 percent in Iowa, 40 percent Wisconsin, 35 percent in South Dakota, 31 percent in Wyoming, 33 percent Idaho, Nevada in double digits, Kansas in double digits. This is more infections today, and it means more tomorrow, plain and simple. We have not rounded the corner. Now, the ten states right now per capita reporting the most new COVID cases, here there are. a lot of them are smaller case. So, the case numbers might be trailing a bit, but these are the ten states with the most new cases per capital right now. Who do they have in common? They all voted for president Trump in 2016. All but one of them have Republican governors. Wisconsin has a Democratic governor. It is going up right now. I don't like to mention that. We're all Americans going through this together, but watching the debate tonight, the president likes to make the point, the blue states are the problem. The blue states he says are staying closed to hurt him, to hurt the economy and to hurt him. Well, if that comes up, we should look at this, look at this trend. Yes, the blue states, California, Washington state, New York in the Northeast did go up the hill first. They have come down, stayed down, back up a little bit in the summer surge. Everyone is going up right now. Look at the red states, look at the red states. These are states with Republican governors. They were down at first. They drove the summer surge. Look at high this went. It did come down some. But right now, in America, states with Republican governors have a bigger problem than states with Democratic governors. One thing, Erin, you might hear tonight, he president will say, everyone is going through this. The world is going through this. He's right, the world is going through this. In Europe at the moment, actually, has more cases per capita, that's the yellow line, more cases per capita than the United States. The United States is the green line. But this is what scares public health experts. If you look at the history, Europe went up the hill first, right, Europe went up the hill before the United States. Then it did a remarkable job of flattening the curve, look at that. And now as we go back up, Europe is shooting up. New restrictions in Ireland, new restrictions in Germany, new restrictions in France, new restrictions really across the continent as they see this. The worry of public health experts here, Erin, especially because the president thinks we don't need to do anything, we're rounding the corner, just wait for a vaccine, is the United States went up that curve behind Europe, stayed higher than Europe the entire thing, now starting to go back up again. If Europe is going up like that, what is ahead for us? Is it going to be when you look at the cases as we go up here, are we going to hit the summer surge and keep going? That's the worry, Erin, as we get closer to the election. We have not rounded the corner. We're in a mess.</s>BURNETT: All right, John, thank you very much. Sobering but incredible thorough analysis. I'm joined by our chief medical correspondent, Dr. Sanjay Gupta, and our medical analyst, Dr. Jonathan Reiner. So, Sanjay, let me start with you, in terms of this room that we're going to see tonight and this will be front and center, not just in terms of the substance and the policy, but physically, right? We know that both President Trump and Joe Biden tested negative today. A plexiglass barrier that was going to be between them has been removed, right? But yet, we're going to see the coronavirus in that room, right? There are going to be 12'8" apart. The moderator 16 feet apart, everyone wearing masks, people with wrist bands because they were tested. But all of that puts the coronavirus in this debate. Does it mean, though, that the virus isn't in the room?</s>DR. SANJAY GUPTA, CNN CHIEF MEDICAL CORRESPONDENT: No, it doesn't. And I think this is a fundamental point. I mean, all those protections you mentioned, that's good. Good for them that they're doing that stuff. But I think to your point, we're still talking about gathering a large group of people indoors, in the middle of a pandemic. Two people who would be considered vulnerable by virtue of their edge will be unmasked, speaking loudly. Again, it's good that they're tested. But Erin, they're trying to do the best they can, but this is a bad idea. I mean, somebody has to say that. Call it for what it is. We're still in the middle of a pandemic. And everything that we've heard would suggest that you don't gather a large group of people indoors in a situation like this.</s>BURNETT: Yeah, I mean, you know, as Chris Christie said, it was a serious failure to go maskless at the White House, you know? And he almost paid for it with his life. You know, Reiner, President Trump said in an interview this week, probably more of what we will hear tonight, not much he could have done differently on coronavirus, rounding the corner, reopen. Is that a winning argument to make in the context of what we just saw with John King? The surge in cases, the surge in hospitalizations, the red Republican states right now leading on those counts?</s>JONATHAN REINER, CNN MEDICAL ANALYST: No, that's capitulation. And I don't think capitulation is a winning strategy. We have lived with this pandemic now for about 270 days. And the toll has been awful. And if you look on average, we're losing basically five fully loaded 737s every single day during this pandemic. And all the president can say, if he could do things over again, there's not much he would do. Look, if your -- if you fail a test, and then you go through your performance, and at the end, you say there's not much I would do differently, what you're really saying is that you've been overmatched by that test. And that's what the president is saying. I think if you ask the people that work for him, if you ask Dr. Birx, and Dr. Fauci, and Dr. Redfield, what they would go back and do if they could do it differently, they would get testing online quicker, they would shut down sooner, they would keep states shutdown longer, there's a lot they can do. But, you know, we're making the same mistakes over and over again. When you make mistakes over and over again, they cease to become mistakes, they become decisions. And the president has doubled down on his decisions and he has to live with that.</s>BURNETT: And, Sanjay, he has things to answer for tonight, right? This could come up on that debate stage. A new Columbia University study, which says 130,000 to 210,000 coronavirus deaths could have been prevented in this country with earlier policy interventions and more robust federal coordination and leadership. Now, I will grant you that is a huge range, OK? Right? There's a lot of uncertainty in those numbers. I just want to point out that 210,000 deaths is 94 percent of the people who have died in this country would not be dead. It is a pretty stunning thing to address for this president.</s>GUPTA: This was a thorough analysis, Erin. They looked at these countries, and they basically said if we had implemented the policies in X country, what would that have translated to in the United States? So South Korea, for example, we bring it up because patients were diagnosed on the same day, the first patients in the United States and South Korea, 2,799, that number represents the number of people that would have died in the United States if we adopted South Korea's policy. Not the number of people who would have been saved. So, 220,000 versus 2,000 is essentially what they're saying. I mean, that's staggering, Erin. Japan, 4,315. Australia. You see the numbers there. By the way, South Korea initially, they didn't shut down. They had robust testing. They had kiosk testing. They did really, really robust tracing. It made a difference. They had to do it early and it made a huge difference. By the way, some of those same things, those same strategies that worked in the other countries, they can still make a difference in this country. This isn't about the rear-view mirror. We're, by no means, through this yet. So, hopefully, we look at that and say it's horrifying, but also, you know, inspiring us to actually do more than we're doing.</s>BURNETT: And putting the onus on Trump and Biden tonight to say what could be done, especially for Biden specifically right now, to turn this around. Thank you so very much. And as we get ready for those questions at that debate stage, there are some minds, of course, that can't be changed tonight -- not just because they're set in their ways, but because tens of millions in this country have already actually cast their ballots. We're going to break down those huge voting numbers in some crucial battlegrounds next.
The F.B.I. Says Iran and Russia are Trying to Influence U.S. Voters; Tesla Reports a Fifth Straight Quarter of Profit.
JULIA CHATTERLEY, CNN BUSINESS ANCHOR, FIRST MOVE: Live from New York, I'm Julia Chatterley. This is FIRST MOVE and here is your need to know. Meddling mystery. The F.B.I. says Iran and Russia are trying to influence U.S. voters. Debate day. Joe Biden and Donald Trump in their final face-off tonight. And electric earnings. Tesla reports a fifth straight quarter of profit. It's Thursday. Let's make a move. Welcome once again to FIRST MOVE wherever you are in the world. You join us on the countdown to another debate night here in the U.S.A. From the immortal words of anchorman, Ron Burgundy, we hope things stay classy this time around. We will do debate prep this hour with 2016 Republican presidential candidate, Carly Fiorina. That's coming up in the show. In the meantime, emergency aid talks continue in Washington. The problem is, there is no sense of emergency at least from Senate Republicans and that makes a deal look all but impossible at this stage, combine that when what I mentioned there, election interference fears and you have a recipe for global stock market weakness and that's what you see in front of you right now. Former presidential candidate, Andrew Yang said to us yesterday if you remember, unless a deal on this financial aid comes soon, struggling Americans will have to wait until February at the earliest. And we keep saying, help is needed now. A further 787,000 Americans filed for first-time benefits last week. That's actually the lowest number since March, but it is still historic numbers and still more than 23 million people collecting some form of unemployment benefits in the U.S. at this moment. The Federal Reserve warned yesterday that consumer spending is now leveling off in parts of the U.S., a worrisome sign that household savings that built up during the summer may now be depleted or at least being depleted. On the brighter side, however, better than expected earnings are lending some support to stock markets at least. Tesla up to four percent premarket after posting record sales and they doubled down on their delivery numbers guidance. All the details on that coming up. In the meantime, PayPal hit a record high Wednesday, too. This, after announcing it will support cryptocurrencies on its platforms including payments on Venmo. We can now Venmo, which are the Bitcoins. Bitcoin hitting 2020 highs on the news yesterday, but it is ticking back some of that slightly today. And from crypto to cryptic. U.S. officials confirming that foreign powers are once again meddling in the U.S. elections. Let's begin the drivers there. Federal Intelligence agencies say Russia and Iran have acquired U.S. voter data in an effort to influence the election. The evidence suggests Iran was behind a campaign of threatening e-mails sent to voters, allegedly from the far right group, the Proud Boys. Alex Marquardt joins us now. Alex, great to have you on the show. Sadly, we have to separate the politics here from the Intelligence, and that's what I want you to do first. What exactly did the Intelligence Agencies tell us yesterday?</s>ALEX MARQUARDT, CNN SENIOR NATIONAL SECURITY CORRESPONDENT: Well, Julia, this was a remarkable press conference last night at 7:30 here on the East Coast, in part because it was so hastily assembled, but then also, the cast of characters who showed up. These are the most senior National Security officials in the country when it comes to safeguarding the elections. This was led by the Director of National Intelligence, John Ratcliffe, as well as the F.B.I. Director Christopher Wray and what they laid out for the first time was attributing to Iran and Russia essentially the stealing of voter registration data. This is the first time that they have announced anything like this in the 2020 election. So Russia and Iran have gotten a hold of some voter registration data. There had been a reported intrusion on election support systems around two weeks ago. We believe some of that data came from there and Iran used some of this voter registration data according to these officials to send out e- mails, threatening e-mails to voters. We've already reported that they were in Alaska and Florida threatening them, that if they don't vote for Trump, there will be consequences. One of them that we saw says, "Vote for Trump or we will come after you." Here's a little bit more of what the Director of the National Intelligence, John Ratcliffe had to say last night.</s>JOHN RATCLIFFE, DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL INTELLIGENCE: We would like to alert the public that we have identified that two foreign actors: Iran and Russia, have taken specific actions to influence public opinion relating to our elections. We have already seen Iran sending spoofed e-mails designed to intimidate voters, incite social unrest, and damage President Trump.</s>MARQUARDT: So there, Ratcliffe saying that the e-mails were meant to sow chaos, to infuse the process with more division. It should be noted, Julia that none of these officials have said any votes were changed or that there was any meddling on that front. It is rather problematic in the eyes of some, particularly Democrats that Trump's name was mentioned there. The argument among some Democrats is, how does this favor Trump when -- how is this against Trump, rather, when these votes are clearly threatening that if you don't vote for Trump, there will be consequences? The argument from Ratcliffe there seems to be that because these e-mails are meant to look like they are coming from this pro-Trump far right group, the Proud Boys, that that will work against Trump's favor. Now, the Intelligence Community said for a long time that Iran is looking to undermine Trump in this election and this appears to be the first concrete evidence that they are offering that this is the case. But again, no votes changed according to the officials and when it came time for Christopher Wray of the F.B.I. to speak, he did tell voters they should be confident that their votes will be counted -- Julia.</s>CHATTERLEY: Yes, and voters of both candidates targeted too, potentially as well. Alex, some important points there as well. Thank you so much for that. All right, tonight, American voters will get their last chance to see President Trump and Joe Biden face off before the November 3rd election. They'll meet on the debate stage in Nashville, Tennessee 12 hours from now. John Harwood is in Washington for us. John, it is President Trump versus former Vice President Joe Biden versus the mute button. What are we expecting tonight?</s>JOHN HARWOOD, CNN WHITE HOUSE CORRESPONDENT: Well, I think President Trump may actually benefit from that mute button if it tempers his performance. His last performance was disastrous for him politically and his advisers have been trying to get him to tone it down. But President Trump's personality is not likely to change. He is bristling to go after Joe Biden through the means of tarring his son, Hunter, which right-wing media has been doing as well. So I'd expect him to be, if not as raucous as last time, significantly raucous and the question is, is there anything he could do at this stage to change the trajectory of this race? It's been remarkably stable. Joe Biden has got a 10-point lead nationally. He leads in enough states to win the Electoral College. Joe Biden doesn't really need to do anything tonight except avoid a major mistake and try to run out the clock. We've got less than two weeks until the election. Joe Biden is on a glide path. The question is, can President Trump change that?</s>CHATTERLEY: Yes, you make a great point, I think, with the mute button, perhaps President Trump will allow Joe Biden to speak and perhaps then gaffes appear, but then, you're asking to change habits of a lifetime perhaps. John, talk to me about stimulus. What are we thinking here? There seems very little room to maneuver here from some of the Senate Republicans and the leadership there who perhaps are going to scotch this deal even if we get to the end.</s>HARWOOD: Well, I think Andrew Yang, who you quoted before as saying, I believe that if not now, then likely February, is pretty much on target. I think at this stage, it is extremely unlikely that a deal will be struck before the election. I think what Nancy Pelosi is doing is making clear by trying to strike a deal with Steve Mnuchin and then having it stopped by Mitch McConnell then it is Senate Republicans who do not want to be a big deal. That has been true for months. The House passed a bill in May. The Senate did nothing and hoped the issue would go away. So did the Trump administration, frankly, but when the economy stalled because the COVID virus was resurging, interest picked up, but the Senate Republicans who are now expecting Joe Biden to win are not eager to send a lifeline to the economy that Joe Biden is going to inherit. There is some small chance that something could be done in the lame duck, but nothing on the scale that Pelosi and Mnuchin are talking about, I don't think.</s>CHATTERLEY: John Harwood in Washington there for us. Thank you so much for that. And our special coverage of the final presidential debate begins at 12:00 midnight, if you're in London, 3:00 a.m. in Abu Dhabi and 7:00 a.m. in Hong Kong. All right, let's move on. Tesla results electrify despite the pandemic. The company has reported its best quarterly profit yet and reconfirmed a high target for this year's sales, or at least deliveries. Shares are up premarket. Paul La Monica joins us now. Paul, a fifth straight quarter of profits and oh, boy, it's a tough delivery target, 500,000 cars, but they say they can meet it. Talk us through with the numbers. What do you think?</s>PAUL LA MONICA, CNN BUSINESS REPORTER: Yes, I mean, Elon Musk, obviously, has been accused in the past of sometimes putting out targets for Tesla that may not really be achievable, too pie in the sky, but to Musk's credit, the sales have been sizzling so far this year and it is possible they could hit that ambitious delivery goal. The key question, I think, for Tesla investors though, is how sustainable will the company's profits be on a long-term basis? It's great that they are now generating net income for five consecutive quarters, but a big chunk of that is coming from that 400 million or so in credits that they are selling to other auto makers or compliance with various carbon emission standards. So that is something that I think investors are a little skeptical that Tesla's core sales -- you know, core auto business can be consistently profitable.</s>CHATTERLEY: Yes, it's interesting, isn't it? The regulatory card here is a big part of the -- which is what everyone seems to be saying here as well. What do we think, going forward, Paul? Do we think this ultimately means inclusion into the S&P 500 because there's a lot of people here are saying irrespective of what the contributing factor here is in terms of the profit, some level of consistency here, at least, is what they need, at some point in the future?</s>LA MONICA: Yes. To Tesla's credit, this is a company that has clearly shown that it is a leader in the electric car market, which is obviously growing very rapidly. The revenue growth is there. They are diversifying because of other businesses that they are in. Obviously, remember, the big Solar City deal that they did. So I think that sooner or later, given the massive market value of this company, it would be foolish for S&P not to include it in the S&P 500. I mean, it is already -- what -- how many times the size of the market value of the entire major U.S. automotive industry, it seems kind of silly to not have it in this blue chip index.</s>CHATTERLEY: Yes, I mean, those regulatory credits are all part of the game here. You can purchase this, it pays you the money and Tesla takes the money and then invests in factories in what -- its factories in Berlin and in Texas. That's the way it works.</s>LA MONICA: That's clear revenue.</s>CHATTERLEY: Yes. And they are up 400 percent year-to-date, that stock. Paul La Monica, thank you so much for that. All right, the most ant-ticipated IPO of the year. Could it be the biggest ever, too? Jack Ma's Ant Group has won regulatory approval for a dual listing in Shanghai and Hong Kong. It is expected to raise as much as $35 billion giving the financial giant a valuation of around $250 billion. Sherisse Pham joins us now. Sherisse, did you see what I did there? The most ant-ticipated. Yes, I have to repeat it. The great thing about this as well is that we get a sense of the numbers here. Talk us through what we know about this huge</s>IPO. SHERISSE PHAM, CNN BUSINESS REPORTER: That's right. That's right. And it might be named after a tiny bug, but this is really a huge company. And we learned a couple little interesting things in the updated regulatory filings today. One is that they'll be splitting this IPO evenly between Hong Kong and Shanghai. Each of those exchanges will be getting about 1.67 billion shares to sell and that amounts to about 11 percent of Ant's total shares, post-IPO. Now, we know that an Alibaba wholly owned subsidiary will be buying 730 million of the shares on offer in the domestic market, so about nearly half of the shares that will be offered in Shanghai. And Alibaba will also have the right to subscribe to additional shares so it can hold equity, equaling no more than 33 percent of the company. I want to make sure I got that right. So they've got the right to pretty much own a third of Ant, is what we're looking at from that perspective. Now, but let's just take a look at some of the key dates that are coming up ahead for this, I do say, really highly anticipated IPO. We've got October 22nd and 23rd, that's today and tomorrow. Those dates are bookmarked for initial pricing, and then the offering announcement coming hard and fast next week on Tuesday, October 27th. Share subscription happening next Thursday, October 29th. Payment for subscribed shares following on Monday, November 2nd. And then the key date we all want to know, when will the IPO happen? Basically Ant is saying, TBD. Ant saying that the company will be listed on the Star Market as soon as it finishes issuing shares, presumably, it will list the same day here in Hong Kong as well.</s>CHATTERLEY: Wow. Can't wait for that. It's going to be fascinating to watch and a hot ticket for the Hong Kong Stock Exchange and of course, the one-year-old Star Market in Shanghai as well. Sherisse Pham, thank you so much for joining us on that. All right, still to come here on FIRST MOVE, backing Biden, 2016, Republican presidential candidate, Carly Fiorina and why she is crossing party lines and what it is like to share a debate stage with Donald Trump. And Southwest's earnings head south. The airline reports its biggest ever quarterly loss. We've got the CEO and we'll get the scoop. Stay with us.
Joe Biden and Donald Trump in Their Final Face-Off Tonight
CHATTERLEY: Welcome back to FIRST MOVE. You're looking at the opening bell there at the New York Stock Exchange and muted open for stock markets this Thursday, appropriate perhaps as we head into tonight's presidential debate where we will have muted mics when necessary, too. Stocks hanging in there overall, despite the uncertain outlook for fresh stimulus, and word that an additional 787,000 people filed for fresh jobless claims last week. New jobless claims. The NASDAQ and the S&P still less than five percent from record highs. I mean, they are tilting into positive territory in the early minutes of trade, too. Hard hit airlines continue, though, to bleed cash in the third quarter. British Airways owner AIG reporting a more than $1.5 billion loss. It is slashing flight schedule by a further 10 percent for the rest of the year. That takes it down to just 30 percent of last year's levels to give you some context. In the United States, too, American airlines reporting a $2.8 million loss. In the meantime, Southwest lost $1.2 billion. The CEO of Southwest, Gary Kelly will join us later in this hour to talk about what they are seeing. In the meantime, let me give you a look at live pictures of the inside of the Senate Judiciary Committee. They have just approved Amy Coney Barrett's nomination to the Supreme Court. The committee voted 12 to zero, setting her up for a full Senate confirmation vote for Monday. Ten Democratic senators on the panel boycotted that vote as expected. Now, a few hours from now, President Trump and Joe Biden meet for their final debate before the U.S. presidential election with 12 days to go until Election Day. More than 40 million Americans have already voted. That's equal to around 30 percent of the total votes cast in 2016. Campaigns for Biden on Wednesday -- campaigning for Biden on Wednesday, former President Barack Obama delivered a blistering rebuke of President Trump's handling of the pandemic.</s>BARACK OBAMA, FORMER PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: Look, I get that this President wants full credit for the economy he inherited and zero blame for the pandemic that he ignored. But you know what? The job doesn't work that way. Tweeting at the television doesn't fix things. Making stuff up doesn't make people's lives better. You've got to have a plan. You've got to put in the work.</s>CHATTERLEY: Joining us now, Carly Fiorina, she is founder and chairman of Carly Fiorina Enterprises, former CEO of HP and 2016 Republican presidential candidate. Carly, fantastic to have you on the show. Thank you for joining us.</s>CARLY FIORINA, FOUNDER AND CHAIRMAN OF CARLY FIORINA ENTERPRISES: Great to be with you, Julia.</s>CHATTERLEY: I think we should start with the debate tonight. You know what it's like to be on the debate stage with president trump without mute buttons, let's be clear. What's your advice for Joe Biden tonight?</s>FIORINA: Joe Biden cannot respond to everything that Trump says or does. Trump will be Trump, which is not helping him, I will say, these days. Biden needs to be focused on what he wants to communicate and I think what he wants and needs to communicate most of all is his character and how he will problem solve as a leader. It's very easy to get distracted by Donald Trump. There are things that Biden will need to respond to, but not everything. The more the American people take a look at Donald Trump, the polls suggest the less they like him.</s>CHATTERLEY: You know, it is interesting. That's a decision that you've made and as I mentioned, Republican background, former Republican presidential candidate. I vividly remember reading the article in "The Atlantic" where you said, look, I'm going to vote for Joe Biden. Carly, talk to me about that. What was it? Does it come more down to the person rather than the politics and the policy?</s>FIORINA: Let me say that I believe and have always believed that leadership matters. That character counts, particularly in a President of the United States, and Donald Trump has failed every test of leadership during his tenure, and his character has become crystal clear. And so my vote for Joe Biden is not only a vote for a leader and a man of character, humility and empathy, but also a vote for the soul of the nation and the direction of the nation. Let me also quickly say that I don't agree with all the Democratic Party's policies, but neither do I agree with all of the Republican Party's policies, immigration to cite one example. But what I believe in is leaders collaborate to solve problems and Joe Biden has demonstrated his willingness to collaborate with all sides to actually make progress and solve problems and that's what we need our President to do now. Joe Biden needs to unite this nation and then work to solve our very serious problems and address our opportunities and that can only be done if we are united and collaborating in a bipartisan way.</s>CHATTERLEY: Yes, you being united has to be considered a policy choice as well, I think at this moment. And Carly to your point, but we are three months on from when you made that decision and the difference I think between then and now, is that we do have a greater sense of what those policies look like. And you mentioned, there are policies on both sides here that you don't agree with. Can you hand on heart say when you look at some of the policies particularly for the business sector and perhaps the impact on smaller businesses in particular, if you're raising personal tax rates, for example, that the economy will be stronger under Joe Biden than perhaps it would be under a continuation of President Trump?</s>FIORINA: Well, yes. I think the answer to that question is yes, because let's just start with the fact that the coronavirus epidemic is not under control. In fact, as you well know, we are entering a very difficult and dangerous period. And so, businesses of all sizes, but particularly, small businesses and working families are getting crushed, and Donald Trump seems to just want it to all disappear. In fact, he has told us it will just disappear. We know it won't. So we'll just start with that. Secondly, however, I do thing that both parties have not paid sufficient attention to small business. Small business is the engine of growth in this economy. There are 100,000 small businesses that have closed their doors permanently since this pandemic began, and I do believe, based on what he has said, that the relief packages and the economic policies that Joe Biden will pursue will be more helpful to small businesses. And finally, if I can just add, Julia, you know, lack of access to quality education is an economic issue. Lack of access to infrastructure is an economic issue, and those problems need to be addressed as well.</s>CHATTERLEY: Carly, that's such a great point and it is something I am also incredibly passionate about. Do you trust a Democratic-led government and Congress to fix some of the blatant problems in the education system state by state? Because one could argue that those problems have been around for a really long time and successive Democratic-led governments have not fixed these problems either?</s>FIORINA: Exactly. Well, look, let's be frank, Julia. Politics and politicians have failed over and over again on both sides of both parties. It is partially why Donald Trump was elected in the first place because people were sick of the failures of the political class. I will say, honestly, I think split government is usually more productive; and so if it were me, I would say a Democratic-led House and a Republican Majority in the Senate and a Biden presidency would be ideal, however, I think it is possible that Donald Trump has become such a drag on the ticket that Republicans will lose their majority. And I think it is why you see Mitch McConnell racing the Supreme Court nominee through. I hope, I very much hope that Joe Biden as President of the United States will understand that his job is not to be the leader of his party. His job is to be the leader of this nation and in that role, he needs to tackle festering problems of education, of social justice, of the environment and yes, of the economy as well.</s>CHATTERLEY: Yes, you're the President of the people that didn't vote for you as well as the President of the people that did. Carly, great to have you with us. Thank you. Carly Fiorina, the founder and chairman of Carly Fiorina Enterprises.</s>FIORINA: Thank you, Julia.</s>CHATTERLEY: Thank you. Former CEO of HP and Republican presidential candidate. Great to have you with us. All right, Trump versus Biden, oil versus renewables. The choice Americans face will shape the U.S. and the global energy industry for the future and that's next.
U.S. Officials Link Iran to Threatening Emails Sent to Voters; Trump & Biden to Face off in Final Presidential Debate Tonight; Obama Delivers Blistering Rebuke of Trump; Nearly 63,000 New Cases, 1,124 New Deaths Reported Overnight.
ANNOUNCER: This is CNN breaking news.</s>ALISYN CAMEROTA, CNN ANCHOR: We want to welcome our viewers in the United States and all around the world. This is NEW DAY. It is Thursday, October 22, 6 a.m. here in New York. And we do begin with breaking news. On the eve of the final presidential debate, the country's top national security officials announcing that Russia and Iran have both obtained voter registration information that could be used to influence the election. The timing of this announcement raises some questions. It came just minutes after former President Obama delivered a strong rebuke of President Trump. The director of national intelligence, John Ratcliffe, says Iran's efforts are intended to damage President Trump, but intelligence experts are skeptical of that claim, since the disinformation seems to support President Trump. Overnight, Google confirming to CNN that thousands of these suspicious e-mails were sent, but only about 2,500 made it to voters' inboxes.</s>JOHN BERMAN, CNN ANCHOR: So I have some math for you this morning. Nearly 41 million Americans have voted already. That's 89 percent of the early vote in 2016.</s>CAMEROTA: I love these homemade graphics.</s>BERMAN: It's 89 percent.</s>CAMEROTA: I see that!</s>BERMAN: Are you ready for another one?</s>CAMEROTA: Yes.</s>BERMAN: That's 30 percent of the total vote from 2016. That's a lot. And there's still 12 days left. And tonight, the final debate, this might be the last, best chance for either candidate to change the trajectory of this race. We know how it went the first time. We have new details about how both campaigns are preparing. The major focus, we imagine, will be the coronavirus pandemic. It certainly should be. It is now in the midst of this dangerous new wave. Overnight, the U.S. reported nearly 63,000 new cases. More than 40,000 Americans are now hospitalized. That is the highest number in two months. One thousand, one hundred, twenty-four new deaths were reported overnight. That's the highest total in more than a month. And this morning, 11 states are seeing deaths increase by 50 percent or more. We're going to begin, though, with the breaking news on this alleged foreign election interference. CNN's Alex Marquardt joins us now with the details. Alex, what have you learned?</s>ALEX MARQUARDT, CNN CORRESPONDENT: Good morning, John. Well, this was a rather remarkable and sudden press conference that we saw last night. We heard from the director of national intelligence, John Ratcliffe, as well as the FBI director, Chris Wray. They were joined by other election officials. These are the officials charged with safeguarding the election. And they said for the first time, they attributed for the first time, attacks in this election cycle to specific countries, saying that Iran and Russia have obtained voter registration data. Now, that doesn't necessarily mean that voter registration rolls have been hacked. But those countries have obtained that. And they said that Iran has used some of that data to email threatening e-mails to voters. Now, we've already reported that threatening e-mails have gone out to voters in Alaska and Florida, calling on voters to vote for Trump or else. And these e-mails appear to come from the far-right Trump-supporting group, the Proud Boys. One of them did read, "Vote for Trump or we will come after you." Now, here is how the director of national intelligence, John Ratcliffe, characterized this development. Take a listen.</s>JOHN RATCLIFFE, DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL INTELLIGENCE: We would like to alert the public that we have identified that two foreign actors, Iran and Russia, have taken specific actions to influence public opinion relating to our elections. We have already seen Iran sending spoofed e-mails, designed to intimidate voters, incite social unrest, and damage President Trump.</s>MARQUARDT: So Ratcliffe saying there that these e-mails were designed to support President Trump, even though they said that -- in the e- mails "vote for Trump." It seems that his argument is that, because they're coming from a threatening group, that that hurts Trump. Now, there is no evidence that any votes have been changed or that there has been any dramatic meddling when it comes to the votes. But this is in line with what the intelligence community has already assessed, that Iran would work in this election against President Trump, and this does appear to be the first evidence of that, that they are coming out publicly with. Now, the director of the FBI, Chris Wray, he struck a bit more of a confident and somber tone, telling voters that they can be confident that their votes will be counted. Take a listen.</s>CHRISTOPHER WRAY, FBI DIRECTOR: You should be confident that your vote counts. Early, unverified claims to the contrary should be viewed with a healthy dose of skepticism.</s>MARQUARDT: Now, this does come under two weeks, of course, before the election. Everyone is very much on edge. What was not emphasized here is the role of Russia, which according to Wray a couple of weeks ago, and others, has been playing a very active role in this campaign, trying to influence Americans' votes. Democrats did look at this with a real dose of skepticism because of the way that Ratcliffe has -- has been acting over the past few weeks, in a very political way, in favor of President Trump. There is a very aggressive tweet from the House Democratic -- from the House Democrats on the -- on the House Homeland Security Committee. They wrote, "DO NOT listen to Ratcliffe. Partisan hack." But then, Alisyn and John, that tweet was deleted later.</s>BERMAN: All right, Alex. Alex Marquardt for us. Thank you very much for all of that.</s>CAMEROTA: So John, tonight is the final debate between President Trump and Joe Biden. What can we expect? CNN's Jessica Dean is live in Nashville with a preview. Is there a way to predict what's going to happen tonight?</s>JESSICA DEAN, CNN CORRESPONDENT: Alisyn, I think that's probably a little bit impossible. We can do our best, though. We know that President Trump's advisers have told him that this is really his last chance to turn around negative impressions of his behavior, especially with seniors and women voters. They've advised him to really cool it down, turn down the temperature, and he's said that he's going to do that. But he's also said he is going to push back and push back hard if he thinks he's being treated unfairly.</s>DEAN (voice-over): While the rules may be different for the second and final presidential debate, the pressure is still on for former Vice President Joe Biden and President Donald Trump with just 12 days to go before the election. The Commission on Presidential Debates is now giving each candidate two minutes of uninterrupted time to speak and muting microphones, in a move to prevent the chaos that unfolded in the first debate.</s>JOE BIDEN (D), PRESIDENTIAL NOMINEE: You've already fired most of them because they did a good job.</s>DONALD TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: Some -- some people don't do their job.</s>BIDEN: Well, here's --</s>TRUMP: With you --</s>CHRIS WALLACE, FOX NEWS ANCHOR: Go ahead. Wait a minute. You get the final word in this.</s>BIDEN: Well, it's hard to get any word in with this clown -- excuse me, this -- this person.</s>TRUMP: And let me say --</s>DEAN: Trump complained about the debate rule change in an interview Wednesday.</s>TRUMP: Well, that's not fair. Plus, they changed the topics, which is unfair, just happened.</s>DEAN: But Biden says the new format is a step in the right direction.</s>BIDEN: I think it's a good idea. I think there should be more -- more limitations on us not interrupting one another.</s>DEAN: And while the Democratic nominee stayed off the trail to prepare for the debate, President Barack Obama traveled to Philadelphia on behalf of his former running mate, unloading one of his most direct attacks of Trump during a drive-in rally.</s>BARACK OBAMA, FORMER PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: He hasn't shown any interest in doing any of the work, or helping anybody but himself and his friends, or treating the presidency like a reality show that he can use to get attention. And by the way, even then, his TV ratings are down, so you know that upsets him. But the thing is, this is not a reality show; this is reality.</s>DEAN: Meantime in North Carolina, Trump bashing Obama for campaigning for Biden, to a crowd with few masks and no social distancing.</s>TRUMP: President Obama's campaigning for Sleepy Joe Biden. And I said, Huh, that's good news or bad news, tell me? Are you saying it's good or it's bad? Well, I guess it's bad. No, it's good. There was nobody that campaigned harder for Crooked Hillary Clinton than Obama, right?</s>DEAN: The former president also slamming Trump's handling of the coronavirus.</s>OBAMA: When asked if he'd do anything differently, Trump said, Not much. Really?! Not much? Nothing you can think of that could have helped some people keep their loved ones alive?</s>DEAN: And it wasn't only about Trump. Obama urging Americans to get out and vote.</s>OBAMA: There were a whole bunch of polls last time. Didn't work out. Because a whole bunch of folks stayed at home and got lazy and complacent. Not this time. Not in this election.</s>DEAN: President Obama will go to Miami on Saturday to continue campaigning for the Biden/Harris ticket. In the meantime, Vice President Biden, President Trump both headed here to Nashville for tonight's final debate, John. That starts at 9 p.m. Eastern.</s>BERMAN: Obviously, we'll be watching that debate very, very closely. Jessica Dean, thank you so much. As we said, the pandemic should be topic No. 1, two, and three at the debate tonight. And breaking news, a new report just published out of Columbia University says that between 130,000 and 210,000 deaths could have been prevented if there had been stronger leadership from this White House. That is a staggering number. Nearly 63,000 new coronavirus cases were reported overnight. More than 40,000 Americans now hospitalized. That's the highest amount in two months. One thousand, one hundred and twenty-four new deaths reported overnight. That's the highest total in five weeks. You can see the direction this is headed. CNN's Adrienne Broaddus live in Chicago with the latest on these troubling numbers -- Adrienne.</s>ADRIENNE BROADDUS, CNN CORRESPONDENT: Good morning to you, John. The numbers are spiking. Hospitalizations are up across the country, and Illinois is an example of one dynamic surge. The CDC reporting that Illinois has seen the second highest number of total cases within the last week, just behind Texas. The state's health department rolling out some numbers last night, numbers nobody wanted to see. As of last night, more than 2,300 people were in the hospital with COVID-19. Among the 2,300, more than 500 people in the ICU and 194 people on ventilators. Look, we know what happens when people go to the hospital after they've been diagnosed with COVID. Some of those folks, thousands, have not come home. And the governor here in Illinois does not want that to continue to happen. That's why he's rolling out some new restrictions. Many of them take effect tomorrow. In the southern region of Illinois, for example, indoor dining and bar service will be banned once again. Gatherings will be limited to 25 people or less. The governor is determined to stop the spread of this virus. The only thing constant or the only -- yes, the only thing constant about this virus is change. It's constantly changing. And now the CDC is updating its guidelines about close contact. Now, before we were told close contact would be 15 minutes of continuous exposure. We're now learning it could be 15 minutes of total exposure. You could have interactions with people for brief moments. The bigger question, John, is what does this all mean? It goes back to what we've been tell our viewers for weeks and months now, and it bears repeating. Mask wearing is important. A new study out says that if people wear masks, it could save about 100,000 lives -- John.</s>BERMAN: Is it important, ever. Chris Christie just published an op-ed pleading with Americans to wear masks. He spent a week in the hospital. He is pleading with Americans to wear masks and pleading to political leaders, including no doubt, President Trump, to send better messages about this. Adrienne Broaddus, thanks so much for being with us. The final presidential debate is just hours away now. So what is the one thing that each candidate needs to do when they take this debate stage? That's next.
Trump and Biden Face Off in Final Presidential Debate Tonight; Report Shows Faulty Trump Response Led to 130,000 to 210,000 Avoidable Deaths.
BARACK OBAMA, FORMER U.S. PRESIDENT: Doesn't fix things. Making stuff up doesn't make people's lives better. You've got to have a plan. You've go to put in the work.</s>ALISYN CAMEROTA, CNN NEW DAY: Then minutes after Obama's blistering takedown, America's top security officials announcing that Russia and Iran are actively working to interfere in this election. The director of National Intelligence, John Ratcliffe, accusing Iran of sending threatening emails to voters and spreading disinformation. Ratcliffe claims Iran's efforts are intended to damage President Trump, but intelligence experts are skeptical, since the disinformation seems to support President Trump.</s>JOHN BERMAN, CNN NEW DAY: Let's begin with the stakes in tonight's debate. Joining us now, CNN Political Analyst Alex Burns, a National Political Correspondent for The New York Times, Margaret Talev, a Politics and White House Editor for Axios, and Seung Min Kim, she is a White House Reporter for The Washington Post. We have the best in American print journalism here with us this morning. Alex Burns, to quote the famous Lyndon Johnson ad, these are the stakes. What are the stakes in the debate tonight?</s>ALEX BURNS, CNN POLITICAL ANALYST: Look, John, I think you put it well. This is the last best chance for either of them to change the course of the race. And, frankly, only one of them wants to change the course of the race and that's President Trump. The burden on him is heavy going into the debate tonight, as he continues to trail Joe Biden in national polls, in nearly every swing state poll we have seen. A New York Times poll this week found that on the issue of coronavirus pandemic, voters prefer Biden as a leader over the sitting president by 12 percentage points. I think that's the biggest thing for the incumbent tonight. Can he put a dent in those numbers? Can he say something to the country about the pandemic and the public health crisis and economic recession it has caused that causes some people who are currently writing off the president and actively leaning towards Joe Biden, because, remember, we are past the point where there are enough purely undecided voters to swing this thing to the president. Can he say something on COVID that actually pulls people away from the Biden camp?</s>CAMEROTA: So, Margaret, what's your reporting on what's the strategies are that each candidate will use tonight?</s>MARGARET TALEV, CNN POLITICAL ANALYST: Well, Alisyn, we know that President Trump's team has advised him to be a little bit less aggressive than in the first debate, be hard to not be less aggressive towards Joe Biden, and to kind of take the temperature down a notch. There's no indication that the president actually thinks that that is the right strategy toward this. He did a lot of prep last time, then Chris Christie got sick, plus he overtorqued in the prep. So the prep is largely out the window. But the president has made clear that he thinks he has to do more than just make himself more likable to people who might still be undecided. And that he thinks that what he really needs to do is knock Joe Biden off of his pedestal. So he's not just signaled, but basically said he's going to use this debate to try to go after Biden on his son, Hunter, and try to tie Hunter's problems and questionable business practices and relationships and such to the vice president directly. That's a dangerous territory for the president to be in. He may be successful or it may end up backfiring. So there's some consternation inside the campaign in the White House, because until you see what that looks like, you really don't know how it's going to land. And there are new dynamics, of course, in the debate tonight, with the microphone's ability to be muted. Can the president use that to his advantage or, again, will that backfire on him? But he wants to knock Biden off his game, not just try to give himself a second chance in debate world.</s>BERMAN: I will tell you, if your strategy for a 73-year-old man is to be different than you've ever been in your life, to reinvent yourself for this one night after 73 years, that's a tall order. And if that's what they're asking President Trump to do and if that's what they think he needs to be, that might be a tall order. Seung Min, what do you think the Biden campaign wants from its candidate tonight?</s>SEUNG MIN KIM, CNN POLITICAL ANALYST: Clearly, he wants the campaign's focus to clearly stay on the coronavirus pandemic and the president's handling. I mean, you've seen the Biden campaign and Vice President Biden himself be pretty low key this week. He's been primarily doing debate prep. He hasn't been on the campaign trail and relying primarily on key surrogates, including the biggest surrogate of all, former President Obama, to do the campaigning on his behalf. But once that's done, obviously, Biden has come under some criticism for not being out there, less than two weeks from Election Day, but that also has meant that a lot of the focus has been on the president and his, for example, outbursts against Dr. Fauci, several of them earlier this week, and the focus has remained on this growing pandemic, and the president's handling of it. So I think the Biden campaign wants that to remain the focus tonight. He wants to do what they can to protect the lead, basically do no harm and keep the focus where they want it to be.</s>CAMEROTA: Alex, let's talk about the Obama factor. So President Obama came out and gave this quite animated, for Obama, speech in Philadelphia yesterday. And he just went right at all of the, what he considers many failings of President Trump, including, I mean, let's just start with what he was referring to as his behavior. So listen to this moment.</s>OBAMA: You might be to have a Thanksgiving dinner without having an argument. You'll be able to go about your lives knowing that the president is not going to re-tweet conspiracy theories about secret cabals running the world or that Navy SEALS didn't actually kill bin Laden. Think about that. The president of the United States re-tweeted that. Imagine, what -- what?</s>CAMEROTA: Alex, your thoughts?</s>BURNS: Look, Alisyn, I think that cuts to sort of the fundamental factors around this election, that predate even the coronavirus pandemic, which is that even when the economy was good, and even when a lot of Americans were willing to give President Trump at least a measure of credit for that, he was still something of an underdog in his campaign, because so many people just detest his personal conduct. And one thing we saw throughout the Democratic primary is that one of Joe Biden's core assets is that people have seen him standing in the Rose Garden, sitting in the Oval Office. They see him as someone who can behave like a president and with the dignity and respect that they expect out of a president. And who better to deliver that message in the close of this campaign than somebody who has been the president. Barack Obama is the most popular living former president in the country. And he can speak both just as a political performer in terms of the way he delivers his rhetoric and then just culturally in terms of who listens to him, particularly younger voters. He can speak to that issue in a way that Joe Biden himself may not be able to. And I think it's important to see that he went to Pennsylvania, which is a state where turnout among young voters and black voters, especially, are so important to closing the deal for his party.</s>BERMAN: And he was on the attack, like a running mate is often on the attack, and to an extent, I mean, look, Barack Obama and Joe Biden have been running mates before. This is an inverse of the traditional relationship. But he was deliberately on the attack on, I think, President Trump's sore spots, including this new report in The New York Times that President Trump has business dealings and a bank account in China. Listen to this.</s>OBAMA: He's got a secret Chinese bank account. How is that possible? How is that possible? A secret Chinese bank account, listen, can you imagine if I had had a secret Chinese bank account when I was running for re-election? You think -- you think Fox News might have been a little concerned about that? They would have called me Beijing Barry.</s>BERMAN: By the way, I think Beijing Barry is actually trending right now, Margaret. But it shows you what the former president is trying to do.</s>TALEV: Yes. He's trying to attack Trump on everything from the notion of reality T.V. versus a reality presidency to foreign dealings, taxes, everything in between. But as Alex said, this really is about turnout and targeting two audiences, young voters and voters of color. There have been two elections in modern American history, in American history where the African-American vote exceeded the white vote and it was President Obama's two elections, 2008, 2012. If he could deliver that for Joe Biden, it would transform the map. It would be crucial in what we think of as battleground state and it could potentially be crucial in states that have never really been battleground states before, only aspirationally. We have new pollsing this morning with our Survey Monkey partners that show that there are literally five states in the entire country where young voters. And I'm not talking like 18-year-olds. I'm talking anywhere under 35 --</s>BERMAN: Young to me.</s>TALEV: -- states in the country that support President Trump among that group of young voters.</s>CAMEROTA: Not me. Seung Min, in terms of voters of color, again, President Obama went right at the questions of racism and the tone of the president and the country. So here is that moment.</s>OBAMA: Why are folks making excuses for that? Well, that's just him. No, it's -- no. There are consequences to these actions. They embolden other people to be cruel and divisive and racist.</s>CAMEROTA: What did you think, Seung Min?</s>KIM: Well, I think, obviously, the former president has a big platform to discuss his views and he really brought the issue that had dominated so much of the headlines this summer, the issue of racial justice, so what happened across the summer in the protests. And he's trying to fuel that fire, fuel that activism and translate that into votes this summer. And if you look kind of at the speech writ large, I mean, Margaret and Alex touched on it early, but it almost kind of seemed almost like a venting session or a therapy session for the former president, who has been such a target of President Trump throughout Trump's presidency, with the baseless accusations of the Obama campaign spying on him, the accusations, again, that they were ill prepared, or that the Trump administration had been ill prepared by the pandemic because of the Obama administration. You saw President Obama refute that last night, saying he literally left him a pandemic playbook that he ignored. The former president mocked President Trump's repeated claims that a health care was coming in two weeks. So you saw I think President Obama had a lot that he wanted to get off his chest yesterday.</s>BERMAN: Yes. He went right at him on the things that are most important to the president, including his T.V. ratings and his Twitter habits. Watch this.</s>OBAMA: I never thought Donald Trump would embrace my vision or continue my policies, but I did hope for the sake of the country that he might show some interest in taking the job seriously. But it hasn't happened. He hasn't shown any interest in doing the work or helping anybody but himself and his friends or treating the presidency like a reality show that he can use to get attention.</s>BERMAN: Reality show. Alex, talk to me about the geography again. Former President Obama in Philadelphia, we learned he sent to, where, Miami over the weekend. How will the Biden campaign deploy him and what's the targeted goal?</s>BURNS: Well, I think it's sort of as simple as it looks on its face, and that Pennsylvania and Florida are the two biggest swing states on the map right now, unless we sort of take Texas into the picture, which is still kind of a question mark. Among the traditional swing state, he is going to the real big one. And if Joe Biden wins those two states, it's very, very difficult or impossible for President Trump to mount a comeback in this election. And I do think that in addition to speaking to the groups within the Democratic base that are so important for Joe Biden to mobilize right now, you do hear, including in that clip that we just heard, the former president really trying to make a persuasion argument to people who may still be undecided. People don't necessarily remember how much time and effort and energy and money the two Obama campaigns put into reassuring and peeling away a suburban white voters and rural white voters, including a white man without college degrees. He's peeling some of them away from the Republican Party in order to bring down Republican margins in areas that are never really going to go blue. And what you hear him doing there, and we heard this in several of the clips, is trying to take away some of the excuses that voters make to themselves for why it's actually okay and it's not all that serious if you vote for President Trump, the idea that the tweets fundamentally don't really matter, or that they aren't necessarily specific consequences for these kinds of character arguments. And that argument, I think, specifically, John, the president is not interested in doing his job is one that has pretty broad appeal. There are people who like President Trump personally but feel that he has not measured up to the task at hand.</s>BERMAN: Alex, Margaret, Seung Min, great to have you on this morning. Thank you so much. Enjoy the debate tonight.</s>CAMEROTA: And tonight, Joe Biden and Donald Trump face off one last time before Election Day. CNN's special live coverage of the final presidential debate begins at 7:00 P.M. Eastern. Okay, a brand-new report says that hundreds of thousands of American lives could have been saved if the Trump administration had a response, a more coherent plan to respond to the pandemic. We have the details for you, next.
Thousands of Poll Waters to be Deployed
CAMEROTA: Election Day is still 12 days away, but already nearly 41 million Americans have cast their votes. That is close to surpassing the total early votes cast in 2016. It's also almost one-third of the total votes cast in that 2016 election. So, this morning, CNN has learned details about how the Trump and Biden campaigns plan to deploy thousands of poll watchers on Election Day. And CNN's Kristen Holmes is live in Washington with more. What have you learned, Kristen?</s>KRISTEN HOLMES, CNN NATIONAL CORRESPONDENT: Good morning, Alisyn. Well, the poll watchers are going to serve as the backbone to both the Biden and Trump campaign legal strategy on and after Election Day. We've learned that both of these campaigns are doing meticulous training with these poll watchers in the law so that they know exactly what to look out for. And they expect the poll watchers to report any anomalies in real- time. By anomalies I mean long lines, broken machines, issues with voter rolls. And we should keep in mind that actually poll watchers in some states can watch people counting the mail-in ballots. So that's something else that they are expected to report back on. Now, both sides have a different strategy for reporting it. One, Democrats are launching a new app that will put the incidents in real- time, send them out to a virtual boiler room for the campaign and volunteers to decide how to act. Now, Republicans, they are setting up command centers in person in various key swing states in order to deal with this in real-time. And this is really the largest involvement of poll watchers we've seen in decades. In part because of a 1982 decree that severely limited what Republicans could do with poll monitoring. And that expired this year. So all of this is to say that you should expect more lawsuits and, in an election that really has already been so rife with lawsuits and litigation. And only that note, we do want to point out that the Supreme Court, last night, did grant a request by the state of Alabama in order to ban curbside voting. The state had said that this would lead to mass logistical problems. And voter rights groups had said that this was actually very helpful during a pandemic because it helped elderly or disabled people who wanted to vote in person, but couldn't wait in those long lines. And the three more liberal-leaning justices agreed with those voter advocates. So interesting to watch, particularly if you think about the Supreme Court makeup as we head into today.</s>CAMEROTA: Kristen, thank you very much for all of that reporting. So new polls give Joe Biden plenty of reasons to be optimistic heading into Election Day, but some Democratic operatives see reasons for concern in key battleground states. And Ron Brownstein is up early to explain it all to us, next.
Report on Trump's Pandemic Response; Biden's Shortest Path to the White House
BERMAN: So just 12 days left to vote. And thanks to the founding fathers, this is not really about who gets the most votes, but where they get them. The Electoral College. Our friend, Ron Brownstein, has this fascinating new piece on Joe Biden's shortest path to the presidency and Dr. Ron Brownstein joins us now. Ron, thanks so much for being with us.</s>RON BROWNSTEIN, CNN SENIOR POLITICAL ANALYST: Hey, John. Good to see you.</s>BERMAN: Look, I'm going to cut to the chase here. The shortest path is to flip the three rust belt states that Donald Trump won from the Democrats basically.</s>BROWNSTEIN: Right.</s>BERMAN: Pennsylvania, Wisconsin and Michigan. We can put that up. If -- if Joe Biden does that and nothing else, he ends up with 278 electoral votes and wins. And maybe Joe Biden and his campaign are especially well suited for just this task, you write.</s>BROWNSTEIN: Yes.</s>BERMAN: Why?</s>BROWNSTEIN: Well, look, this isn't what you might have expected, right, right after 2016? I mean Donald Trump's breakthrough in the rust belt among non-college whites was so profound and those voters are still about half of the electorate or more in 2020. Many Democrats might have thought they had a better chance in the sun belt for 2020. But two things happened in the interim. One is that we saw in the rust belt in 2018 a pullback from the Republicans, not only among the non- college -- not only among the college whites who were retreating from Trump everywhere, but also significantly among some of those blue collar whites, particularly the women. And the second thing that changed is they nominated Joe Biden. If you were going to draw up a candidate in the lab to solve the Democrat's long-standing problem of turning out more younger, non-white voters across the sun belt in states like Arizona or Texas or Georgia, it would not be a 77-year-old white guy who's been in politics for 50 years. On the other hand, if you're going to draw up a candidate to try to win back some of those blue collar, you know, historically Democratic voters who broke towards Trump, that might be Biden. And both of those things combined have made this -- the rust belt somewhat surprisingly a better bet for him right now than the sun belt.</s>CAMEROTA: But, Ron, I did zero in on one graph in your recent piece about how the support for Trump may also be more energized than it was.</s>BROWNSTEIN: Yes.</s>CAMEROTA: You talked to a Wisconsin-based Republican strategist, who ran George W. Bush's campaign there in 2004 --</s>BROWNSTEIN: Yes.</s>CAMEROTA: Who is, quote -- you quote as saying, my sense of what I see, particularly in rural parts of the state and smaller cities, is that the Trump vote is more energized now than it was four years ago. So explain that.</s>BROWNSTEIN: Well, look, I mean, you know, the way Donald Trump won those states, Alisyn, four years ago, was that he turned out more rural and non-college white voters than the pollsters expected. And there are some Democrats who are nervous that in the early voting, they see signs of, again, tremendous engagement among those voters, particularly in the rust belt states. But Trump faces a couple of challenges in replicating what he did last time. First of all, it's unlikely that turnout will be as depressed in the large metro centers that include a lot of black voters along the rust belt, whether it's Detroit or Philadelphia or Milwaukee or Cleveland. And, also, he's losing ground significantly in most of these white collar suburbs. Places like Oakland County, Michigan, or Montgomery County, Pennsylvania, or Franklin County, Ohio, or Polk, which is Des Moines. He is not going to run as well. So the challenge is that even -- oh, and I guess the third thing is that matching the margin among the blue collar whites is going to be hard for him because of the retreat that he's seeing among seniors, many of whom are whites without a college education. So while there is the potential for him to turn out more of those voters than the pollsters expect, again, because he does -- you know, if there's nothing else that Donald Trump can do, it's turn out his voters. The problem he's got, even if he increases the numerator, the denominator is getting bigger. Everybody is voting at a higher rate. And it's harder to have a turnout differential benefiting your side if the entire pool is getting that much bigger.</s>BERMAN: I just want to put up P-114, and this gets to something you were saying there, that the president's margin among non-college whites --</s>BROWNSTEIN: Yes.</s>BERMAN: Right now, according to the polls, is a lot less. It's a lot smaller in Michigan and Pennsylvania than it was in 2016.</s>BROWNSTEIN: Yes.</s>BERMAN: Half in Michigan --</s>BROWNSTEIN: Yes. Yes.</s>BERMAN: And two-thirds of what it was in Pennsylvania. And then coupled with, Ron, what is Joe Biden or how is Joe Biden or what are the Democrats doing or what evidence have you seen about them trying to pull in more urban voters or more suburban votes?</s>BROWNSTEIN: Yes. Well, first, I mean, John, I am struck, if you look at the polling across all of these states that are, you know, within any degree of competitiveness across the rust belt. So the big three, Michigan, Wisconsin, Pennsylvania, and then kind of the next tier, where Trump is hoping to contest Minnesota and the Democrats are within reach now in Iowa and Ohio, Biden's coalition looks extraordinarily similar across those states. Where there are large African-American populations, he's winning about 80 to 85 percent of them. He's winning 55 percent or more of college whites in all of those states, except maybe Ohio. And that is an improvement from 2016. And then, most significantly, he's coming in right around 40 percent among non-college whites in all of those states. And we look at the polls that came out yesterday, it was 41, 41, 44, 42. That doesn't sound like great shakes (ph), but it is a significantly improvement over Hillary Clinton, who did not get above 37 percent, I believe, in any of those states among the blue collar whites in 2016. So, in a way, Joe Biden is doing the job that he was hired to do by the Democratic Party. I mean you don't -- as I said, you don't nominate Joe Biden to be the one to solve the problem of energizing more younger, non-white voters. His calling card from the beginning was that he could win back some of those folks that we've all been interviewing in diners in the rust belt since 2016, and the evidence is that he's doing just enough of it, particularly among the women.</s>CAMEROTA: Ron Brownstein, thank you very much for giving us your analysis of where we are at this moment in time. Always great to talk to you.</s>BROWNSTEIN: Good to see you guys.</s>CAMEROTA: OK, so Pope Francis making a seismic shift, endorsing civil unions for same-sex couples. How are Catholics responding? A live report from the Vatican, next.
Pope Endorses Same-Sex Civil Unions.
BERMAN: Reverberations around the world this morning after Pope Francis chose to speak out in support of legalizing same-sex civil unions. This is a major departure from his predecessors and a departure from catholic dogma. CNN's Delia Gallagher live in Rome. And this really has caused quite a stir, Delia.</s>DELIA GALLAGHER, CNN VATICAN CORRESPONDENT: Well, that's right, John, we've heard from both sides, both in praise and criticism for the pope's comments. Let's take a look first at what the pope actually said. These were comments made during a documentary film, which premiered last night in Rome. According to the catholic news agency, the pope said homosexual people have a right to be in a family. They're children of God and have a right to a family. What we have to create is a civil union law. That way they are legally covered. So we've heard praise, but we've also heard criticism from some catholic circles because this does represent a change from the position of the pope's predecessors. John Paul II and Benedict XVI were against the legalization of same-sex unions. We have to say that Francis, however, has, in interviews in the past, shown an openness to legal protections for same-sex couples, but he's made the distinction between that and marriage, which he says should be between a man and a woman. But, nonetheless, important comments from the pope because it is the first time that he has directly supported the legalization of same-sex unions. We should also add, John, of course, these were comments made in a film. We do not yet have anything official from the pope or the Vatican in terms of a document or official change in teaching on this. So we'll have to wait and see how it develops. John.</s>BERMAN: Yes, I understand it was in a film and it may not have been this year, but, still, it seems very clear and very deliberate what he said. Delia Gallagher, thank you so much for being with us. NEW DAY continues right now.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: We are not going to tolerate foreign interference in our elections that threatens the sanctity of your vote.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: We have already seen Iran sending spoofed e-mails designed to intimidate voters and damage President Trump.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: Just given the track record of DNI Ratcliffe, you have to address what he says with some skepticism.</s>BARACK OBAMA, FORMER U.S. PRESIDENT: We literally left this White House a pandemic playbook. They probably you'd it to, I don't know, problem up a wobbly table somewhere.</s>DONALD TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: Look, it's all over the world. It came out of China.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: That was the most at-once blistering and at-once mocking assessment President Obama has ever delivered on his successor.</s>ANNOUNCER: This is NEW DAY with Alisyn Camerota and John Berman. Welcome to our viewers in the United States and all around the world. This is NEW DAY. And we're just hours away from the final debate between President Trump and former Vice President Joe Biden. The last, best chance for either candidate to change the course of this election, if that's possible. Nearly 41 million Americans have already cast their votes. That's 89 percent -- 89 percent of the total early vote cast in 2016, 30 percent of the total vote cast four years ago. A lot of people voting already. So much interest in the future of this country. Why? No doubt the coronavirus pandemic playing a central role. And that will be the focus and should be the focus of tonight's debate. A new study from Columbia University states at least 130,000 deaths and perhaps as many as 210,000 could have been avoided with earlier policy interventions and more robust, federal coordination and leadership. Better leadership could have saved lives. Overnight, 1,124 new deaths were reported in the United States. Nearly 63,000 new cases. That's the high -- no, former President Barack Obama delivered a blistering rebuke of President Trump's handling of the pandemic during a campaign stop last night.</s>BARACK OBAMA, FORMER U.S. PRESIDENT: Look, I get that this president wants full credit for the economy he inherited and zero blame for the pandemic that he ignored. But you know what? The job doesn't work that way. Tweeting at the television doesn't fix things. Making stuff up doesn't make people's lives better. You've got to have a plan.
New Reports Suggests over 100,000 American Lives Could Possibly have been Saved by Better Federal Response to Coronavirus Pandemic; President Trump and Democratic Presidential Candidate Joe Biden to have Final Presidential Debate; Joe Biden Responds to Questions about Adding Justices to Supreme Court; Former President Barack Obama Campaigns for Joe Biden
ALISYN CAMEROTA, CNN ANCHOR: That was cast in 2016. Of course, the coronavirus pandemic is sure to be a major focus of tonight's debate. A report out just this morning from Columbia University says this about the failed pandemic response, quote, "at least 130,000 deaths, perhaps as many as 210,000, could have been avoided with earlier policy interventions and more robust federal coordination and leadership," end quote. Overnight 1,124 new deaths were reported, and nearly 63,000 new cases. Former President Barack Obama delivered a blistering rebuke of President Trump's handling of the pandemic during a campaign stop last night.</s>BARACK OBAMA, FORMER U.S. PRESIDENT: We literally left this White House a pandemic playbook that would have shown them how to respond before the virus reached our shores. They probably used it to, I don't know, prop up a wobbly table somewhere. We don't know where that playbook went. Eight months into this pandemic, cases are rising again across this country. Donald Trump isn't suddenly going to protect all of us. He can't even take the basic steps to protect himself.</s>JOHN BERMAN, CNN ANCHOR: All right, and breaking news, we just heard for the first time a new answer from former vice president Joe Biden on the question of whether or not he supports adding to the number of Supreme Court justices. It comes in this just released clip from his "60 Minutes" interview. Listen.</s>JOE BIDEN, (D) PRESIDENTIAL NOMINEE: If elected, what I will do is I will put together a national commission of, bipartisan commission of scholars, constitutional scholars, Democrats, Republicans, liberal, conservative, and I will ask them to, over 180 days, come back to me with recommendations as to how to reform the court system, because it's getting out of whack, the way in which it's being handled. And it's not about court packing, there is a number of other things that are constitutional scholars have debated, and I would like to see what recommendations that commission might make. The last thing we need to do is turn the Supreme Court into just a political football, whoever has the most votes gets whatever they want. Presidents come and go. Supreme Court justices stay for generations.</s>CAMEROTA: Joining us now to talk about this and so much more, we have CNN political commentator Ana Navarro, she is supporting Joe Biden, and CNN political commentator Scott Jennings, he's a former special assistant to President George W. Bush. Great to have both of you here this morning. I should mention, "60 Minutes" also put out a clip of President Trump's response to some of Lesley Stahl's questions, and we don't have time to play it at the moment, but basically you will hear that in terms of her questions and her tone, they are hardly gotcha. They are just the standard sort of respectful Lesley Stahl way, at least the clip that they have released. Scott, now to what Joe Biden just said, does that answer Republicans or voters, I guess, all voters, questions about Joe Biden's vision for the court, that he wants court reform?</s>SCOTT JENNINGS, CNN POLITICAL COMMENTATOR: Well, he lied. He told us a few days ago he was going to have an answer to this question before Election Day. He doesn't have an answer.</s>CAMEROTA: Why isn't that an answer. Hold on, Scott. Why isn't that -- I'm going to set up a commission for 180 days and they're going to look at how to reform the court.</s>JENNINGS: He's been asked directly dozens of times, his running mate, his campaign, do you favor packing the court? I don't know, I don't want to talk about it because it will become a news headline. And then he finally said, well, I will get you an answer before the election. And the answer is punting it down the road 180 days. We're still in the same place. You have to vote for me to find out what I'm going to do. The reality is he will never be able to withstand the left flank of his party on this, and he said the court is out of whack. He clearly has ideas about fundamentally changing this institution, the Supreme Court. So if you care about courts, if you care about nine justices, if you care about the sanctity of this branch of government, Joe Biden is telling you he is looking at radical changes, and that's what his party wants, but I'm not sure it's what the American people want.</s>BERMAN: And I don't know, I think if Joe Biden had been giving this answer for the last month this would not have been the issue it has become. It may not be an answer that satisfies Republicans, who may not have been satisfied with any answer from Joe Biden on this. It may not be the answer Scott wants, but for the first time it is an answer.</s>ANA NAVARRO, CNN POLITICAL COMMENTATOR: Yes, I don't understand why Joe has let this become such an issue. First of all, let's just go back to remembering that the people who set the number of court justices in a Supreme Court and in the federal courts is Congress. It's not the president. They are decided by congressional acts. It's been changed seven times in history. I think that maybe you hear Joe Biden's answer, it's the Joe Biden we have all known for decades. This guy is an institutionalist. He respects the institutions, he served in the Senate for six terms, and I think he sees the Supreme Court, as he just said, something that should not be a political football. Look, people forget when they are in the majority or when they have the White House that there will come a day when they won't, and they often do things that then comes back to haunt them when they are in the minority or when they are out of power. And I think Joe Biden in his years of experience has seen that time and again. I find that answer to be the answer of an institutionalist, but I wish he would add to that it's Congress's decision. It is up to Congress to decide the number of the justices. I don't think there's the votes in Congress to change the Supreme Court Constitution. And I think you're hearing he is an institutionalist. And a lot of people, a lot of people on the left don't like that answer, him saying don't turn it into a political football. A lot of people on the right want to portray it as a radical answer. Believe me, as the radical left, if they think that's a radical answer, and their answer will be no. They're not content with it. I think it's Joe Biden's answer. He is an institutionalist, like it or not.</s>CAMEROTA: Scott, let's talk about tonight. So the final debate of the election, the reporting suggests that President Trump's advisers have told him to take it down a notch, tone it down, be less aggressive, somehow be more likeable.</s>BERMAN: Be different. Just be different. Everything you've done up until this point for 73 years, be different.</s>CAMEROTA: And President Trump doesn't like that advice according to the reporting. What do you expect to see tonight?</s>JENNINGS: Well, whether he likes it or not, the debate commission is going to give him a spoonful of castor oil because they're going to mute his microphone. So he's going to get some medicine whether he wants it or not. And that may actually help him, because if he lets Joe Biden talk a little bit and let's Joe Biden talk around some of these issues that he has had trouble with on taxes or the Green New Deal or on courts or what have you, that it might give Donald Trump a chance to show off a real contrast. I'm not one who believes there is that many undecideds left. If you are still undecided, welcome to earth. We hope you're landing last night in middle America, wherever you landed your spaceship was comfortable, and you need to remember where you parked. This is about convincing people to vote. You have to get out the vote. You have got to tell your people don't sit it out. And so I expect Trump and Biden, frankly, to sort of forget about the persuasion game tonight and just talk about getting your people out to vote. Trump has a whole bunch of people, millions of people who lean his way on issues, low political engagers, didn't turn out in 2016. If there's any of them that might hear a soundbite from tonight's debate, that's who he is really talking to. The odds of per persuading a Biden voter tonight to switch sides are very low. So this is about get out the vote messaging in my opinion.</s>BERMAN: Ana, percentage chance that it could be a different Donald Trump tonight? And what do you want to see from Joe Biden?</s>NAVARRO: I want to see from Joe Biden the Joe Biden that we all know, the presidential Joe Biden, the Joe Biden that's empathetic, that's giving complete answers and articulating them in complete sentences, unlike Donald Trump. I agree with Scott, I think the mute button -- just think of that, wrap your head around that, OK, that we have to have a mute button rule because the president of the United States just won't shut up, and acts like a school yard bully on red bull anytime he is on a debate or a town hall. We saw how unhinged he was in that first debate. We saw how unhinged he was in the NBC town hall last week here in Miami. So I think the one that benefits from the mute button most is Donald Trump. And I agree with Scott, I don't think this is about changing voters' minds anymore. I think it is about turnout. I think it's about enthusiasm. I have to tell you, I'm here in Miami, early voting started on Monday. We have had big blickelrays (ph). It feels like we are living in Macondo from "100 Years of Solitude." And yet I see lines around the block in the libraries, which is an early voting site every time I go. And to me that is so inspirational. But those people that are still deciding whether to not vote or vote, I think a debate like this can make a difference. As frankly, look, we've been, as voters, we have been jilted, we have been stiffed out of a civic, substantive policy debate. We certainly didn't get it with the first debate. We didn't get a second debate. So this is the last chance for the American people, the American voters who want to see democracy in action, want to see a civil debate, to hear it tonight from the two candidates.</s>CAMEROTA: Ana, one more question to you. Former President Obama is heading to Florida. He spoke --</s>NAVARRO: To Miami.</s>CAMEROTA: Yes. He spoke yesterday in Philadelphia, and he went, it was a much more vociferous Obama than, obviously, we have heard in the past four years about what he thinks the case against Donald Trump is. So here is a portion where he's talking about how tweeting at the TV does not fix anything. Listen.</s>BARACK OBAMA, FORMER U.S. PRESIDENT: Look, I get that this president wants full credit for the economy he inherited and zero blame for the pandemic that he ignored. But do you know what, the job doesn't work that way. Tweeting at the television doesn't fix things. Making stuff up doesn't make people's lives better. You've got to have a plan. You've got to put in the work.</s>CAMEROTA: OK, 10 seconds, Ana. What's the Obama factor here?</s>NAVARRO: Listen, his ability to articulate attacks on Trump and do it almost in a comical way and bring back memories of the things that have happened to him, and he's talking about the place of experience of just how much character matters, I thought it was a brilliant skewering of the current occupant of the White House from the former occupant of the White House. I thought it was -- honestly, I thought it was funny, and it was satirical, and it was brilliantly done. And it's not an easy thing to do when you are talking to a bunch of parked cars as opposed to a stadium full of people. So looking forward to having him in Florida. Bring an umbrella or a raincoat.</s>BERMAN: Ana Navarro, Scott Jennings, I mentioned "Road House" twice in two days, Scott, and not once was I able to talk to it about with you. So America loses. See the excitement?</s>JENNINGS: We both solve all of our problems by kicking things. And so I applaud your --</s>BERMAN: Life lessons from "Road House." Scott, Ana, thank you. Tonight, Joe Biden and Donald Trump face off one last time. CNN's special live coverage of the final presidential debate begins tonight at 7:00 p.m. eastern time. Obviously, a central focus of the debate tonight really has to be the coronavirus pandemic, and a brand-new report says that thousands of American lives could have been saved if the Trump administration had a better response. The details next.
Trump and Biden Face Off Tonight
ALISYN CAMEROTA, CNN ANCHOR: But, Axe, what advice would you give Joe Biden for when President Trump invariably brings up Hunter Biden. I mean I know that Joe Biden, obviously, feels very personal about that, but what I think President Trump tries to do is make it seem like he's bringing up corruption and that somehow Joe Biden himself is smeared to that. How's he supposed to respond to that?</s>DAVID AXELROD, CNN SENIOR POLITICAL COMMENTATOR: It's a really good question, Alisyn, because this is a very tender spot for Biden, not because there are real vulnerabilities there, but because he feels so strongly about his kids. We saw it in the last debate. He handled it very well there, partly because the president chose to make it about drug use and Biden, I think, really turned that on him. But he can't be so reactive that it throws him off his game. He needs to dismiss the charges, which are, you know, based on dubious information that even Fox News turned down. And if the president keeps returning to it, I think the president's going to miss his opportunity to push issues that may actually benefit him. So -- but if Biden overreacts, if he becomes unsettled by it, then it could be a better night for the president.</s>JOHN BERMAN, CNN ANCHOR: It may be that what Joe Biden should do, as you're saying, is try to portray himself as the grown up, as this return to normalcy, which was, to an extent, the very same message we heard from former President Obama last night. Listen to one more part of what he said.</s>BARACK OBAMA, FORMER U.S. PRESIDENT: You might be able to have a Thanksgiving dinner without having an argument. You'll be able to go about your lives knowing that the president is not going to retweet conspiracy theories about secret cabals running the world or that Navy SEALs didn't actually kill bin Laden. Think about that. The president of the United States retweeted that. Imagine. What -- what?</s>BERMAN: So the former president was into this last night. There's just no question.</s>AXELROD: Yes, he was feeling it.</s>BERMAN: He absolutely was. And, Axe, you look at this and one of the things that jumps out to you is the timing of it all.</s>AXELROD: Yes.</s>BERMAN: Why now and how will he be used the next 12 days?</s>AXELROD: Yes, I think that he and the Biden campaign were very smart to wait until 12 days out to roll him out because what you didn't want to make this was a kind of extended surrogate battle between the former president and the president. You didn't want him to take center stage and you wanted Biden to establish himself as a solid front runner, not a guy who was calling his buddy in to bail him out. And so last night was the right time for him to appear. But he has a specific mission. And a lot of the subtext of his speech was aimed at younger voters, voters of color, because, as you remember, these were the constituencies that did not turn out for Hillary Clinton in 2016 and it made a critical difference in that election. Barack Obama has a connection to these voters. He's a motivating factor for these voters. And I think he's going to spend the next 12 or 11 days now speaking directly to those young people. And not just in these public appearances, but he's been a heavy presence in digital on social media in -- on channels that are -- that speak directly to these constituencies. That is his best value to Joe Biden right now, get out young people, get out people of color, make sure that that turnout is what Joe Biden needs.</s>CAMEROTA: You know, David, what was very interesting is that minutes after President Obama spoke, the top intel chiefs of the country came out with an announcement. So it was the DNI, it was FBI director and they came out to announce that Iran and Russia were once again trying to interfere with all of this disinformation. They're already seeing evidence of it. And what the DNI started the -- his speech with was he -- that basically he was there at the behest of President Trump. President Trump wanted him to do this. And, you know, President Trump is a master counter programmer, as we have seen for the past four years. And so every time President Obama speaks, should we expect -- I mean you know nothing gets his goat, nothing gets President Trump's goat like President Obama. And so the Biden camp -- should they be prepared for what team Trump will do to counter Obama?</s>AXELROD: Yes, well, first of all, let me say, Obama also gets -- knows how to get his goat and ratings was one of the ways that he did it, bringing up ratings. Yes, look, I think that Trump will -- I think we're going to see, like the grand finale of a fireworks show, we're going to see a lot of that stuff in the next 11 days. Let me just say one thing about that, though, about Ratcliffe coming out with the FBI director, making the point that he made. This is the reason why it's important not to politicize intelligent and not to appoint political apparatchiks into intelligence positions because there is a real question as to the emphasis that Ratcliffe put on whether Iran was trying to go after President Trump. And Trump, I should point out, retweeted a headline from "Breitbart" about that moments after Ratcliffe spoke. And it just makes the whole exercise seem political. President Obama was attacked after the fact in 2016 because he didn't make more of what Russia was doing. And one of the reasons that he didn't was because he was worried about seeming as if he, as president of the United States, was putting his finger on the scale politically. He had a sensitivity to that. Trump has no such inhibition. And Ratcliffe is an instrument for that, or could be. And it's -- and that is very dangerous for the country because I have no doubt Iran is trying to unsettle our electorate, I have no doubt Russia is trying to sow chaos. And just as with health and everything else, you want straight information, you want to give the American people the facts they need. And if they can't trust the source, it becomes a very dangerous situation.</s>CAMEROTA: David Axelrod, thank you. Great to talk to you.</s>AXELROD: Good to see you guys.</s>CAMEROTA: OK. We're getting a snapshot, a new snapshot, of America's unemployment crisis. So we have the breaking details for you, next.
Jobless Claims Drop; Restaurants in Dire Straits as Pandemic Worsens
CAMEROTA: New this morning, historically high layoffs continue 31 weeks into this pandemic, but fewer people were laid off last week than the week before. CNN's chief business correspondent Christine Romans joins us now with the breaking news. What do you have, Christine?</s>CHRISTINE ROMANS, CNN CHIEF BUSINESS CORRESPONDENT: So every Thursday morning we get this look of the last -- you know, the last week of unemployment benefits, the first time people file for jobless benefits at their state unemployment offices. And we see 787,000 new filings for unemployment benefits. Look very carefully at that curve. It's more a plateau than a curve, but at least these are not above a million anymore. When you look at continuing claim, 8.3 million people continuing to get a jobless check from the state, that's down by a million. You want to see these numbers going in that direction. But we do have these pandemic unemployment benefits that people keep filing for, 342,000, 345,000 people filed for pandemic relief programs. It just still paints a picture of a lot of people hurting every single people and a lot of people still out of work. And it's interesting, you know, in the "60 Minutes" interview that the president had with Lesley Stahl, he continues to paint this false picture that he created the best economy in the history of the world before the pandemic. Listen.</s>DONALD TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: We created the greatest economy in the history of our country. And the other side was coming in --</s>LESLEY STAHL, "60 MINUTES": You know that -- you know that's not true.</s>TRUMP: It is totally true.</s>STAHL: No.</s>TRUMP: Virtually every number was the best. We had the best economy ever.</s>ROMANS: It's not true now, obviously. He's down 3.9 million jobs as president. That's never happened for a presidency before. And it wasn't true before the pandemic. In fact, before the pandemic even hit, Alisyn and John, we know that jobs growth was slower in the first 44 months of the -- the first months of the Trump administration than it was in the Obama administration and he never got that super charged economic growth that he had promised because the tax cuts and deregulation. It just never happened.</s>BERMAN: You have kept us on the facts this entire time, Christine Romans, so, thank you so much for that and thanks for being with us this morning. So as the pandemic worsens fall and winter, small restaurants face this troubling future. CNN's Vanessa Yurkevich has that story.</s>VANESSA YURKEVICH, CNN BUSINESS AND POLITICS CORRESPONDENT (voice over): It's been seven long, grueling months for restaurants in the U.S. More than 100,000 have already closed. Thousands more will likely face that same fate.</s>JOHN DOHERTY, OWNER, PLAYWRIGHTS IRISH PUB: We are back where we started in March. We really are.</s>YURKEVICH: John Doherty owns the Playwright Irish Pub in midtown Manhattan. His PPP loan is used up. And even with outdoor and 25 percent indoor dining, it's simply not enough.</s>DOHERTY: There's nobody here. There's no --</s>YURKEVICH (on camera): Is this typical?</s>DOHERTY: Well, yes (ph).</s>YURKEVICH (voice over): This area, normally bustling with tourists and after work crowds, is deserted. Without new federal aid, Doherty says he will be forced to close his doors next month.</s>DOHERTY: We're begging for help. We really need help. We feel like that we're at the bottom of the mountain and we're trying to climb. There's no rope to help us.</s>YURKEVICH: And 2.3 million restaurant workers remain out of work. Doherty laid off nearly all of his 25 employees, the most painful part.</s>DOHERTY: They've all families. They have kids. My staff is probably 29 to like 40 years old. And I feel sorry for them.</s>YURKEVICH: Nearly half of the 660,000 U.S. restaurants say they won't make it another six months. While some big chains are even turning profits during the pandemic, many independent restaurants don't have the money to survive.</s>DOHERTY: What people are used to is the mom and pops</s>YURKEVICH: One restaurant closure has a domino effect. Ivan Mendez, who used to print menus and signs for the Playwright and 30 other restaurants, now has just three clients. He was forced to lay off half his staff.</s>IVAN MENDEZ, OWNER, NAVI PRINTING: If they're not open, I have no work. I had to actually dig into my 401(k) savings and take money out to keep up with the rent.</s>YURKEVICH: Mendez applied for a PPP loan, twice, and didn't get it. He will now almost certainly close his doors.</s>MENDEZ: They said, we're going to bounce back and it's just taking a little too long and it's not there. It's going to hurt because this is my baby.</s>YURKEVICH: The Midwest is seeing a surge of COVID-19 cases, so many Chicago area restaurants plan to roll back indoor dining, yet another setback for Kevin O'Brien, an out of work executive pastry chef behind on his bills.</s>KEVIN O'BRIEN, FURLOUGHED PASTRY CHEF: I have tried looking for jobs and since March I have not seen one job posting for an executive pastry chef in the city of Chicago. Not one. This has absolutely been the worst time in my life.</s>YURKEVICH: Yet despite the bleak outlook, John Doherty takes on another day, serving the few patrons he has.</s>YURKEVICH (on camera): You're investing thousands of dollars in enclosing this space for winter, but you don't think you'll have any business. So why are you doing that?</s>DOHERTY: Because I think tomorrow has to be a better day than today. I want to show that I have done everything I possibly could to make my business successful. And if I -- if I've exhausted all of my energy and failed, I tried my best.</s>YURKEVICH: Now, there is no question that the PPP loans from the federal government did help many small restaurants survive this, but as they're looking towards their future, they really need more. They're looking at a six month, one-year recovery, John. And they're paying very close attention to these stimulus talks. They're hearing that something might not get passed until after the election. John, some restaurants don't have these two weeks to survive until after the election. John.</s>BERMAN: You know, Vanessa, I know I speak for a lot of people, I would love -- I would love to be able to go back into a bar like that right now and I hope they're there when this is all over. Thanks so much for this report. Appreciate it. SO right now hundreds of children separated from their families at the border remain without their parents. The latest on the search for them, next.
U.S. Officials Link Iran to Threatening E-mails Sent to Voters
JOHN BERMAN, CNN ANCHOR: So top intelligence officials now say two foreign adversaries have obtained U.S. voter registration information in an effort to interfere in the U.S. election.</s>JOHN RATCLIFFE, DIRECTOR, NATIONAL INTELLIGENCE: We would like to alert the public that we have identified that two foreign actors, Iran and Russia, have taken specific actions to influence public opinion relating to our elections. We have already seen Iran sending spoofed e-mails designed to intimidate voters, incite social unrest and damage President Trump.</s>BERMAN: All right, joining us now, CNN national security analyst James Clapper. He is the former director of National Intelligence under President Obama. Director Clapper, in a perfect world, I would like to be able to separate the politics from the intelligence here. It's hard. It's hard because of now the Director of National Intelligence John Ratcliffe, and what we know about him and things that he has done in the past. But in so far -- let's try to talk about the intelligence first, briefly. What was suggested is that they have evidence that Iran and Russia -- they didn't tell us how Russia is doing it right now, but that Iran is sending e-mails, purporting to be from the Proud Boys, to directly intimidate Democratic voters, and say they're at risk if they go vote against Donald Trump. What's your take-away from just that claim?</s>JAMES CLAPPER, CNN NATIONAL SECURITY ANALYST: Well, I guess first, I have to acknowledge that it's always a good thing if law enforcement and intelligence are out informing the public about potential threats to our election. So that -- you know, check that off, so that's a good thing. You know, the statement kind of caused me to be skeptical for a couple of reasons. One, of course, the timing, coming on the heels of the scathing indictment of the speech by former President Obama. And DNI Ratcliffe kind of glossed over Russia and went right to Iran, which I found a little curious, because Russia has been interfering in the run-up to our election already. And from my part, at least, is the far more serious threat than Iran. And then the other thing that I found curious is sort of that this was done to hurt President Trump. Well, I could argue just the opposite. I mean, these e-mails purportedly simulated by Iran are designed to intimidate Democrats who vote -- who either have voted or contemplating voting for Vice President Biden. So, it's kind of a sad commentary that we can't just take it at face value when a statement like that is made.</s>BERMAN: He did specifically note that the e-mails that he now connects between Iran and this Proud Boys group, allegedly faked under the Proud Boys name. But then he added that extra line which you just pointed out, he claimed -- and he didn't present any evidence, did he? That this was done by Iran to help President Trump.</s>CLAPPER: No, there's no evidence or context at all. And of course, he mentions Russia second, and then kind of never mentions it again. And the other thing I would note is that it seemed like director -- FBI Director Wray and DNI Ratcliffe, all on the same platform were really content-wise on -- you know, two different pages. And in fact, I thought Director Wray made some reassuring statements which were great. He's a truth teller, a straight shooter, but could be applied to the president as well.</s>BERMAN: Let's listen to what Director Wray said, because that was very interesting. He was talking about the entire system here, so listen.</s>CHRISTOPHER WRAY, DIRECTOR, FBI: You should be confident that your vote counts. Early, unverified claims to the contrary should be viewed with a healthy dose of skepticism. We encourage everyone to seek election and voting information from reliable sources, namely your state election officials.</s>BERMAN: So what's interesting about that is, he could very well have been talking about what Iran and Russia are doing, but he could also have been talking about what President Trump has very publicly, out loud been doing for days. Maybe this is why both "The Washington Post" and "The New York Times" reported overnight that the president is considering firing Director Wray after the election.</s>CLAPPER: You know, it's -- probably, you know, there's long been speculation about this, and you know, this could be yet another nail in the coffin, so to speak. You know, I've come to consider Director Wray as kind of the Dr. Fauci of intelligence and law enforcement. You know, he speaks the truth. And you're quite right, you know, there was a statement he made directly to the American voters about the sanctity and security of the voter system, was both appropriate, welcome, and as you indicate --</s>BERMAN: Yes --</s>CLAPPER: Could certainly indicate -- include the president.</s>BERMAN: Director, let me ask one thing here, because look, I don't think there's any question that foreign actors are trying to mess with the U.S. election. David Sanger talks about what is a perception hack, that foreign actors, maybe Iran, maybe Russia, are trying to create the perception that they're inside the system, and sow distrust. What do they get out of that?</s>CLAPPER: Well, I think that's -- I think he's right. And we -- you know, we made that point, our first key judgment in 2016 about the Russians. The initial objective was to sow doubt, discord and discontent in this country and Russians unfortunately have been eminently successful principally because we're such a right target for. So they exploit and amplify the polarization and divisiveness in this country.</s>BERMAN: And that is something we have to guard against, period, no doubt. Director Clapper, thanks for trying to put this in context, really appreciate it.</s>CLAPPER: Thanks, John.</s>BERMAN: So a group of anti-Trump Republicans is now trying to court men, targeting men who voted for President Trump in 2016. That's next.
Trump, Biden to Face Off Tonight in Last Presidential Debate Before Election; Anti-Trump Group Appeals to Male Voters in New Ad.
ALISYN CAMEROTA, CNN ANCHOR: In less than two weeks until election day, and a new ad from the Lincoln Project, that's the political action committee created by Republicans who want to oust Trump. This ad is being shown here on NEW DAY for the first time, and it is designed for President Trump's most loyal supporters, men. Here's a portion of it.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: Our dads weren't perfect, but they did their best to raise us to be good. They taught us to own up to it when we did something wrong.</s>DONALD TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: No, I don't take responsibility at all.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: We may have thought we were doing the right thing in 2016. But it's clear, this isn't the America we voted for. We made a mistake. Vote for change. Vote for our son. Vote for Joe.</s>CAMEROTA: OK, joining us now is Rick Wilson, he's a co-founder of the Lincoln Project. Rick, great to see you.</s>RICK WILSON, CO-FOUNDER, LINCOLN PROJECT: Great to see you, good morning.</s>CAMEROTA: Good morning. OK, so, is this designed to appeal to that demographic that we hear so much about the non-college, rural male voters who support President Trump?</s>WILSON: It is, in part, but it is also meant to appeal to a slightly higher profile or slightly higher propensity demographic group of independently-leaning men and college-aged men. Those were also previously very strong groups for Donald Trump. We've seen erosion there in the last six to eight weeks, and it's increasing right now especially in the suburbs and targeted swing states, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Michigan, Wisconsin, Florida, Arizona and others, and even Texas at this point. And so, we saw tremendous success in moving the vote with our ad- testing and with our analytics. On the previous ad, we just released called "Girl in the Mirror". And we realized that this was an underserved market for persuasion in this race. And we've tested this very thoroughly and we are very confident it's going to move some numbers and make a big difference. And it is something where, you know, if you don't talk to someone, you can't persuade them at all. So we're going to talk to them. And this is a group we feel, if we can take one more piece off the chess board for Donald Trump, it's going to make November 3rd a much more -- a much more smooth sail.</s>BERMAN: A couple of questions, how much money do you have behind this add? And also, the voice of Sam Elliot which was on a Biden campaign ad the other day, it seems like I'm always interested in why certain things were chosen for ads and what the messaging is there. I mean, that voice obviously appeals to both the Biden campaign and you guys for a reason. I know him as the guy -- the other guy besides Patrick Swayze from "Road House", but what's the appeal?</s>WILSON: Well, he's also from "Big Lebowski". So, look, Sam Elliot has an iconic American tone and voice, and we were honored to work with him on this spot. And this spot will have several million dollars worth of national, digital and broad -- national, digital and cable push in the next few weeks -- in the next two weeks. We feel like it's a real -- it's a real burner as we say in this business, it's going to make a big difference. So, you know, working with Sam on this was a -- was a -- was a delight, and we feel like it's an ad that's going to be very persuasive and very impactful.</s>CAMEROTA: Rick, obviously, you're a long-time Florida, "Politico" consultant. And so tell us about the data that you're seeing in terms of the Hispanic support for President Trump, which appears to be growing --</s>WILSON: Sure --</s>CAMEROTA: And how concerned the Lincoln Project is about that.</s>WILSON: Well, we also have a bunch of ads up in Florida in both the Puerto Rican community and the Orlando metropolitan area, to push those folks into a position where that fairly unaddressed group of 200,000-plus voters is going to get talked to about, you know, who Trump is and the contempt he has shown for Puerto Rico. You know, he's a guy who wanted to trade Puerto Rico for Greenland, and you know, they're not even joking about it. We're also advertising in the Miami community, in the Cuban community right now. We've got an ad that basically compares Donald Trump to Castro, because look, they've been trying to compare Joe Biden to some socialist revolutionary. You know, last time I checked, Joe Biden wasn't going to show up with a black beret on and seize the means of production. But you know, it's an absurdity. So we're going to punch back against that pretty hard. That is a concern in Florida, Cubans make up about 8 percent of the voting population in the state of Florida, Hispanics about 23 percent. The fear of socialism is something they're flogging very heavily right now. We'll also be communicating in the next two weeks in Florida on another key message that's profoundly affecting the Hispanic community, which is the mishandling of COVID and the rising death rate of COVID in Florida. Florida is going to be Florida, no matter what we do and no matter what other allied groups of the Biden campaign do. It is always going to be close in the state of Florida. If you go back to the last 20 years and take every Republican vote cast and every Democratic vote cast for president, the difference is about 20,000 votes. So it's going to be a close run in Florida. The Hispanic community will be a hotly contested group in the state of Florida, but we feel like there's going to be a message that gets out beyond just the realm of the socialism versus freedom message.</s>CAMEROTA: Rick Wilson, thank you very much. Great to have you on</s>NEW DAY -- WILSON: Thanks so much --</s>CAMEROTA: Thanks so much for previewing the ad with us.</s>WILSON: I'll talk to you again soon.</s>CAMEROTA: You too, John?</s>BERMAN: All right, this morning, the Czech Republic going back into lockdown as coronavirus cases skyrocket across Europe. We have reporters all around the world bringing you the latest developments.</s>SCOTT MCLEAN, CNN CORRESPONDENT: I'm Scott McLean in Berlin where the German Health Minister has tested positive for the coronavirus, just as his country records a record high daily case count. Yesterday, France and Spain both surpassed 1 million confirmed coronavirus cases. Meanwhile, the Czech Republic has shattered its previous one-day record by almost 25 percent. After an emergency session of parliament yesterday, the Czech Prime Minister announced that his country would be going back into something you might describe as a lockdown. Starting today, only essential stores will be allowed to stay open and movement will be severely restricted.</s>NIC ROBERTSON, CNN INTERNATIONAL DIPLOMATIC EDITOR: I'm Nic Robertson in London, where in nearby island last night, the new, tough lockdown came into place. CNN spoke to revelers in Dublin, bars last night, their numbers were up. A last hurrah as one taxi driver put it before there are six weeks of takeaway service, only from bars and restaurants. People telling CNN that they're frustrated and uncertain, and they think that the government restrictions are in some cases unfair. They fear that they are now heading into a cycle of lockdowns. This one due to last six weeks, they're not sure what comes next.</s>FREDERIK PLEITGEN, CNN SENIOR INTERNATIONAL CORRESPONDENT: I'm Fred Pleitgen in Moscow. As Russia's efforts to create a vaccine against the novel coronavirus seem to be going somewhat slower than many people might have thought. In an exclusive interview with CNN, the head of the Gamaleya Institute which is responsible for the Sputnik-V vaccine acknowledged that so far only about 6,000 participants of a phase 3 trial have received both doses of the vaccine, which are necessary to achieve full immunization and get any sort of reliable data from those participants. That puts Russia well behind many of the western large vaccine makers. And while some prominent Russians have taken the vaccine so far, Vladimir Putin has not and remains in a bubble.</s>BERMAN: So, it should be one of the easiest questions to answer when you're running for president. What are you going to do? Why do you want the job? It's been a challenging question though, for some. A reality check, next.
Biden, Trump Set For Final Debate.
FREDERIK PLEITGEN, CNN CORRESPONDENT: But one notable exception remains the Russian president, Vladimir Putin, who, for months, has remained in isolation, essentially inside a bubble -- Brianna.</s>BRIANNA KEILAR, CNN HOST: All right, Fred, thank you for that report. And our special coverage continues now with Jake Tapper.</s>JAKE TAPPER, CNN HOST: Welcome to THE LEAD. I'm Jake Tapper. And we begin today with our 2020 lead. In a matter of just hours, we're going to see the final presidential debate of this presidential election, just 12 days ahead of Election Day. It's one of the last opportunities for President Donald Trump and Democratic nominee Joe Biden to make their closing arguments to American voters. And while Biden has been off the trail, we're told, preparing for the debate, President Trump has been holding big rallies across the country, potential coronavirus super-spreader events, health officials say, and shunning formal debate prep. We're learning key new details of the candidates' strategies. After the president's frequent interruptions in the first debate, a performance a renowned psychiatrist called emotionally abusive, Trump advisers are pleading with President Trump to be less combative this time. The nonpartisan Debate Commission says it will mute candidates microphones during some portions of the debate tonight. Team Biden officials say they're preparing the Democratic nominee for all sorts of Trump tactics, from frequent interruptions to once again going after members of the Biden family. Even if a theoretically muted mic means that those outside the arena at Belmont University in Nashville cannot hear what the president is saying, advisers are telling President Trump if he's able to lower the temperature and appear less angry, he may come across more likable and be able to win over women voters and seniors. Let's get right to CNN's Jeremy Diamond. He's live outside the White House for us. So, Jeremy, so far, the president does not seem to be lowering the temperature in any way. He's been out there attacking Lesley Stahl from "60 Minutes," pushing forward whatever right-wing media folks are pushing today.</s>JEREMY DIAMOND, CNN WHITE HOUSE CORRESPONDENT: That's right, Jake. And all the while the president is being encouraged to avoid much of the angry bulldozer-like behavior that we saw from presidents in that first presidential debate. And we already know from the polls that much of that behavior was turning off some potential undecided voters, which is why the president's advisers are urging him to try and lower the temperature. Now, we know that the Debate Commission has already taken care of part of the problem, which was the constant interruptions, by muting the microphones during the candidates' uninterrupted talk time. But the president's aides are also making clear that a lot of this is going to be on the president himself. And what they are urging him to do, besides trying to lower the temperature, is to use self- deprecating humor, which they think is one of the ways that the president kind of comes off the best to voters. Of course, the president has seemed receptive to some of that, Jake, in these private sessions. But it's not being reflected in the hours ahead of the debate. What we have seen from the president is these constant attacks against the debate moderator, Kristen Welker, from NBC News. He has been on this very strange, constant barrage of attacks against "60 Minutes." And he's also complaining about the debate rules being unfair, when he's talking about the microphones being muted. But, ultimately, it seems the president has a trump card, according to his communications director, Alyssa Farah, who said that the president, if he doesn't like the questions, ultimately, he's just going to answer the question that he would have liked to have received.</s>TAPPER: What better way to win over women voters than by attacking two women journalists who are held in very high esteem, Kristen Welker and Lesley Stahl? We also got a preview of what President Trump will likely say about the economy, which is an issue where his advisers, his aides want him to focus on. How is that going to hold up?</s>DIAMOND: Well, look, Jake, much of the president's closing message so far has been counterfactual, has been about denying the reality of the surge of coronavirus cases that we are seeing across the country, holding these rallies with thousands of people, despite what we are seeing in terms of case numbers rising, more than 1,100 people dead yesterday -- just yesterday. And the president is also trying to claim that, if it were not for the coronavirus, the U.S. would have the best economy in its history. Listen to what he told "60 Minutes."</s>LESLEY STAHL, CBS NEWS ANCHOR: Let me ask you what you think your biggest domestic priority is for you right now.</s>DONALD TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: Well, ultimately, let me -- and I will tell you, it was happening. We created the greatest economy in the history of our country. And the other side was coming in--</s>STAHL: You know that -- you know that's not true.</s>TRUMP: It is totally true.</s>STAHL: No.</s>TRUMP: Virtually every number was the best.</s>DIAMOND: And Lesley Stahl is correct to point out that that is simply not true. While the economy was in a strong position before the coronavirus hit the United States and the rest of the world, it was not the best economy in history by a number of metrics, whether you look at GDP growth, or whether you look at wage growth. This was not the best economy in history. But I think you can expect, Jake, that the president will continue to make that claim. The question is, will he be fact-checked or will he be confronted by former Vice President Joe Biden when he makes those kinds of claims tonight, Jake?</s>TAPPER: Yes, I mean, the economy was strong before coronavirus, but now we're living with coronavirus. It's almost irrelevant. Jeremy Diamond, thanks so much. Moments ago, we heard from Joe Biden as he boarded the plane to head to tonight's debate.</s>JOE BIDEN (D), PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATE: Hopefully, he's going to play by the rules. Hopefully, everybody's been tested. Hopefully, it's all worked out, the way the rules are. I'm looking forward to this. Thank you.</s>TAPPER: The Biden campaign says that the candidate's strategy tonight is simple, to speak directly to the American people and highlight his plans for getting the nation through the coronavirus pandemic. CNN's Arlette Saenz is live for us outside the debate site in Nashville. Arlette, walk us through exactly how the Biden team is approaching this debate.</s>ARLETTE SAENZ, CNN POLITICAL REPORTER: Well, Jake, Joe Biden is expected tonight to keep his focus on the issues that are top of mind for American voters. The campaign says that he will be talking about COVID-19 and the economy. But he is also fully bracing for those personal attacks from President Trump, as we saw play out during that first debate. They have been preparing the former vice president for the possibility that the president once again goes after his son Hunter Biden, as Republicans have tried to do over the course of the past few days, as this election nears its end. And deputy campaign manager Kate Bedingfield just a short while ago said that, if the president does bring up some of these attacks against Hunter Biden, that this is essentially amplifying Russian disinformation. They don't believe that Biden will take the bait and go after the president's own children during these types of exchanges, instead trying to shift the focus back to the American family and those issues relating to COVID-19 and the economy. Now, one area that President Trump could try to take issue with, with Biden is this question about expanding the Supreme Court. It's a question that Biden has dodged for several weeks, but he did offer a bit of a new answer in an interview with "60 Minutes." Take a listen to that clip.</s>BIDEN: If elected, what I will do is, I will put together a national commission of -- bipartisan commission of scholars, constitutional scholars, Democrats, Republicans, liberal, conservative, and I will ask them to over 180 days come back to me with recommendations as to how to reform the court system, because it's getting out of whack, the way in which it's being handled.</s>SAENZ: And Biden said that that commission won't just focus on the issue of expanding the Supreme Court, but also other reforms to the court system. Now, on that debate stage tonight, there will be moments where the microphone is muted, but the Biden campaign is fully prepared for the president to continue on with his interruptions, the possibility that the former vice president might be hearing the president when speaking when people at home might not hear those interruptions. They have been preparing him for those moments trying to ensure that he is not entirely distracted by the president. You heard the former vice president, as he was leaving, saying he hopes that the president adheres to the rules. He also talked about adhering to the rules when it comes to testing. One thing that we know is that Joe Biden tested negative for COVID-19 this morning. We have yet to hear if that has actually happened on the president's side just yet. But this is going to be that last opportunity on the debate stage for voters to get their glimpse, to fully gauge these two candidates up against each other 12 days out to the election.</s>TAPPER: We still haven't heard if President Trump tested negative before the first debate, Arlette. Forget today's debate.</s>TAPPER: All right, thanks so much appreciate it. In a hastily scheduled announcement, the country's top national security said that Russia and Iran have both obtained voter registration information that could be used to try and influence the U.S. election. Here's FBI Director Christopher Wray.</s>CHRISTOPHER WRAY, FBI DIRECTOR: We have been working for years as a community to build resilience in our election infrastructure, and, today, that infrastructure remains resilient. You should be confident that your vote counts. Early unverified claims to the contrary should be viewed with a healthy dose of skepticism.</s>TAPPER: And Alex Marquardt has more on all this. Alex, what were the specific warnings from these top national security officials?</s>ALEX MARQUARDT, CNN SENIOR NATIONAL SECURITY CORRESPONDENT: Well, Jake, you're right. It goes beyond Russia and Iran just trying to meddle in this election to sow discord and spread disinformation. It's about specifically what they are doing. And this is the first time that the intelligence community and the FBI have said that voter registration information has been obtained by these countries. And it's less about just obtaining that data. That's actually not that difficult. It's what they're doing with it. And what the officials said last night is that Iran has been sending out thousands of e-mails to voters, threatening e-mails to voters that make them look like they're coming from the far right pro-Trump group the Proud Boys. I just want to show you one example of one of these e-mails that's been sent out just to show you what voters are receiving. The subject line: "Vote for Trump, or else." And then: "We are in possession of all of your information, e-mail, address, telephone, everything. You will vote for Trump on Election Day, or we will come after you." So some very threatening e-mails there, Jake. Listen to what John Ratcliffe, the director of national intelligence, had to say about what he called these spoofed e-mails from Iran.</s>JOHN RATCLIFFE, U.S. DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL INTELLIGENCE: We would like to alert the public that we have identified that two foreign actors, Iran and Russia, have taken specific actions to influence public opinion relating to our elections. We have already seen Iran sending spoofed e-mails designed to intimidate voters, incite social unrest, and damage President Trump.</s>MARQUARDT: And, Jake, it is that last part about damaging President Trump that's raising a lot of eyebrows. The intelligence community has said that Iran would work to undermine President Trump in this election. It is unclear how these e-mails do that, because they are going after people who would be voting presumably against President Trump. And then, when you listen to the press conference in its entirety, there's very little emphasis on Russia, when experts and officials say that Russia is really the primary actor when it comes to meddling in this election in terms of impact, trying to denigrate the former Vice President Joe Biden in favor of President Trump -- Jake.</s>TAPPER: Yes, all right. Alex Marquardt, thanks so much. There's a new timeline for the release of a coronavirus vaccine, when it could be available to all Americans -- that story next. And just-released polls on the presidential race, do they change the potential paths to 270 for either candidate? Stick around.
U.S. Tops 1,000 Daily COVID-19 Deaths
TAPPER: In our national lead today: Every state in the continental United States is trending in the wrong direction, as the coronavirus continues to wreak havoc across the country. This is not just with new cases, unfortunately. It's hospitalizations and deaths which are climbing as well. Yesterday, more than 1,100 deaths were reported. That's the first day since mid-September when the death toll hit more than 1,000. Four states, Ohio, Kansas, New Mexico, and Wyoming, all saw their highest number of single-day cases since the pandemic began. And as CNN's Erica Hill reports for us now, an alarming new study finds that hundreds of thousands of deaths could have been avoided if the Trump administration had handled things differently.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: It seems like, every day, the numbers keep increasing.</s>ERICA HILL, CNN NATIONAL CORRESPONDENT (voice-over): It's not just an increase at this El Paso funeral home. The average daily number of COVID-related deaths is rising in half the states across the country, 1,124 reported nationwide on Wednesday, the first time deaths have topped 1,000 in more than a month.</s>DR. ALI KHAN, FORMER CDC OFFICIAL: There's a whole lot of people who are dead in America that -- completely preventable, would not have been dead if we had used science and good public health tools.</s>HILL: That's the finding from a new Columbia University study, which faults the administration's anemic response for as many as 210,000 COVID deaths. And experts warn there is more pain ahead.</s>DR. LEANA WEN, CNN MEDICAL ANALYST: We don't just have one or two hot spots. We actually have virus hot spots surging all across the country.</s>HILL: New cases rising in 31 states, only Hawaii showing a meaningful decline. North Dakota, which continues to have more cases per capita than any other state, just suspended contact tracing because it can't keep up. Florida just reported its highest daily case count since mid-August, no more indoor dining or bar service in Southern Illinois starting today, gatherings capped at 25 people.</s>GOV. J.B. PRITZKER (D-IL): Things have changed. Every region of the state has started to move in the wrong direction.</s>HILL: In Boston, rising positivity rates forcing a return to fully remote learning for the city's public schools.</s>MARTY WALSH (D), MAYOR OF BOSTON, MASSACHUSETTS: Putting that many people in a building at this particular moment is not the smart thing -- smartest thing to do.</s>HILL: Several states reporting record numbers of COVID-related hospitalizations, including New Jersey, where the former Governor Chris Christie is now urging Americans to mask up in a new op-ed, admitting he was wrong not to wear one when prepping President Trump for the first debate. Christie decries the polarization of masks, writing: "It's not a partisan or cultural symbol, not a sign of weakness or virtue," calling out the politics, but not the man who led that charge.</s>DR. EZEKIEL EMANUEL, FORMER WHITE HOUSE SPECIAL ADVISER: We have a president who made fun of wearing masks, who didn't let the scientists run this process and the task force. And that has been the problem.</s>HILL: Jake, we're continuing to see records shattered, Ohio just a short time ago announcing its highest single day for new cases. That was originally yesterday, now that new number, with today's cases, more than 2,400. And the governor had this to say: "It seems like we're not even starting to get to a plateau," he said Jake. "It just goes up and up." And, of course, that is the concern. This country never got low enough to get to a manageable plateau. And now we're seeing consistent increases.</s>TAPPER: And everyone says it's because people are not abiding by basic regulations, wearing masks, avoiding crowds, et cetera, et cetera. Erica Hill, thank you so much. So dispiriting. Joining me now, Dr. Rochelle Walensky, CNN medical analyst and chief of the Division of Infectious Diseases at Mass General. Dr. Walensky, good to see you again. A new report out from Columbia University found that the Trump administration's faltering response to the pandemic led to between 130,00 and 210,000 COVID deaths that, according to Colombia, could have been prevented. Do you agree with those findings? And as long as the Trump administration is in charge and handling things the way they're handling it, is there any way to turn this around?</s>DR. ROCHELLE WALENSKY, CNN MEDICAL ANALYST: Good afternoon, Jake. It's a pretty scathing report. And what they basically say is, there were deficiencies in testing, in mask guidance, and in the mitigation efforts, in shutting things down. When they compare, for example, the testing rates, the per capita testing rates that were happening in South Korea, it took us about three or four weeks for us to get to those per capita testing rates. And, in fact, as a result, they claim that 215,000 deaths could have been averted if we had tested at rates that South Korea tested.</s>TAPPER: Do you -- I mean, do you buy it? That's basically saying that we would only have 5,000 or 6,000 deaths right now. I mean, that's pretty stark.</s>WALENSKY: Well, we do know that, in other countries, they do not have the death rates that we have had. Our death rates were at around 500 per million, those in China three per million. So we do know that, certainly, during a pandemic, we should expect that there would be some excess deaths in this country. But the question is how many. There's been a report from the CDC just this week that demonstrated about 300,000 excess deaths, more deaths than were expected. And looking at it by age group, only two-thirds of those were related to COVID. Even a third of those were related to lack of access to hospitalizations and care, what we have been talking about, flattening the curve. We still need to continue those efforts, because now, again, we're in a really bad place in many, many places across the country.</s>TAPPER: So, the CDC redefined what they call close contact with somebody who was infected, to include cumulative exposure over time. It used to be 15 minutes within six feet of a person, but now they're saying it could be 15 minutes in one-minute, 30-second, two-minute chunks. Does that change how people should be interacting with one another?</s>WALENSKY: You know, this was a report out of the CDC. It was a prison guard who actually developed infection after sort of intermittent, staccato exposures. And it's not entirely clear -- well, it's entirely clear that he got infected through this mechanism. I don't necessarily think that this is going to change much. I think, if you're wearing a mask, if you're practicing these mitigation efforts, it might increase the number of people that we need to contact trace, because the definition is a little bit more liberal. But I would say we can't have a fatalistic attitude here. We have -- certainly, the cases are going up. There's tragedy among us and tragedy, much tragedy ahead. But there is a lot we can do. We are entirely empowered to make this better. And it's just a matter of whether the American people will do so and whether the leadership will create a strategy to allow it.</s>TAPPER: So Trump adviser and former New Jersey Governor Chris Christie wrote an op-ed for "The Wall Street Journal" and said of masks -- quote -- "Wear it or regret it, as I did." Christie does not mention in his op-ed that the leading underminer of mask-wearing in the United States is President Trump. Do you think that that would have helped him make his case? Or is it better for him to not do so, so as to convince more Trump supporters of the need to wear masks?</s>WALENSKY: I think we communicate by the words we speak and by the actions that we take. And I think that we need to communicate to this country that they need to be wearing masks, and that we should do so both through our leadership in our word and our action.</s>TAPPER: Health and Human Services Secretary Alex Azar reiterated on CBS this morning that a vaccine -- quote -- "could" be available to all Americans by April, April 2021. What information and statistics will you be looking for to ensure a vaccine is safe?</s>WALENSKY: That seems like an aggressive timeline to me. Certainly, I would love to see that that happens. I will be looking to the scientific evidence, to data from the FDA that has been reviewed by the scientists, reviewed by the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices. And so, certainly, I would like it quickly, but to all Americans by April seems rather ambitious. The first thing I'd like to see is that we have a safe vaccine that has some efficacy. The next thing I would like to see is to follow the National Academy's guidance on how it's going to get rolled out. But to claim all Americans are going to have it by April, I think, is aggressive.</s>TAPPER: Dr. Rochelle Walensky, thank you so much. Good to see you, as always. Former President Barack Obama not showing any ring rust when it comes to giving a stump speech, but does the former president's blistering attack play right into Donald Trump's hands? Stay with us.
Trump, Biden Set For Final Debate
JAKE TAPPER, CNN HOST: And there will also be Plexiglas barriers separating the candidates, following the president's coronavirus infection. First lady Melania Trump is making her first public appearance today following her coronavirus battle as well. Trump advisers have been, we're told, pleading with the president to try a different strategy than his frequent interruptions during the first debate. And Trump sources tell CNN they want him to stay on message, touting his accomplishments and avoiding attacking Dr. Anthony Fauci, as the president has been doing in recent days. Team Biden, meantime, is preparing the Democratic nominee for the president's personal attacks on his son Hunter Biden. We have our correspondents covering both Trump and Biden's debate preps. First, CNN's Jeremy Diamond filed this report on the advice that President Trump is getting.</s>JEREMY DIAMOND, CNN WHITE HOUSE CORRESPONDENT (voice-over): Before the final presidential debate, President Trump isn't holed up in debate prep. Instead, he's focused on denying the reality of a coronavirus surge that is gripping the country.</s>DONALD TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: That pandemic is rounding the corner.</s>DIAMOND: And complaining...</s>TRUMP: Well, I think the mute is very unfair.</s>DIAMOND: ... about the debate rules, the moderator, and a recent interview he did with "60 Minutes."</s>TRUMP: I go through these interviews, every question is a total kill, right, every question? They're going for the kill.</s>DIAMOND: Trump spent part of his morning attacking CBS News' flagship "60 Minutes" program, accusing host Lesley Stahl of constant interruptions and anger and calling his answers magnificently brilliant, after "60 Minutes" released this clip:</s>TRUMP: We created the greatest economy in the history of our country. And the other side was coming in...</s>LESLEY STAHL, CBS NEWS ANCHOR: You know that -- you know that's not true.</s>TRUMP: It is totally true.</s>STAHL: No.</s>TRUMP: Virtually every number was the best. We had the best economy ever for the period of time.</s>STAHL: I asked you, what's a priority? I mean, those are all the good things. What do you have to solve?</s>TRUMP: The priority now is to get back to normal, get back to where we were.</s>DIAMOND: Trump abruptly ended that interview. And today, before heading to Nashville for the debate, he broke an agreement with CBS and released a 38-minute clip of the interview ahead of Sunday's airdate.</s>JOE BIDEN (D), PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATE: Would you shut up, man?</s>DIAMOND: After turning the first debate into a fiasco with his constant interruptions, President Trump now faces his last, best chance to change the race. This time, Trump is being advised to lower the temperature, to appear less angry, and deploy self-deprecating humor, sources telling CNN Trump has appeared somewhat receptive to that advice, even as he has shunned more formal debate prep.</s>TRUMP: What am I doing to prepare? I'm doing this.</s>DIAMOND: And if he doesn't like the questions, a White House official says he will -- quote -- "answer the questions he wants to."</s>DIAMOND: And, Jake, as President Trump landed in Nashville, the White House chief of Staff, Mark Meadows, said that the president was tested for the coronavirus in flight and that he tested negative. Of course, we still don't know whether President Trump tested negative for coronavirus before the last debate. He said that he couldn't remember, leaving us with the distinct impression that he was not tested for coronavirus on the day of that first debate -- Jake.</s>TAPPER: Yes, they have the information. They just refuse to share it with the public. Jeremy Diamond, thanks so much. For the Biden team, tonight is all about ignoring any interruptions or personal attacks by President Trump. Instead, the campaign says that Joe Biden will be focused on speaking directly to the American people about their concerns, as CNN's Arlette Saenz reports.</s>ARLETTE SAENZ, CNN POLITICAL REPORTER (voice-over): With the election just 12 days away, Joe Biden is facing a final test on the debate stage tonight, as he looks to protect his lead over President Trump.</s>BIDEN: It's go time. It's the most important election in our lifetimes.</s>SAENZ: Biden spending the past three days off the campaign trail, preparing to again make his case before an audience of millions. Biden's advisers say he will speak to issues that are top of mind for American families, like COVID-19 and the economy.</s>BIDEN: Hopefully, he's going to play by the rules. Hopefully, everybody's been tested. Hopefully, it's all worked out, the way the rules are. I'm looking forward to this. Thank you.</s>SAENZ: But the former vice president is also bracing for President Trump to repeat a strategy from the first debate.</s>TRUMP: Hunter got thrown out of the military for cocaine use.</s>BIDEN: That's not true. He wasn't dishonorably...</s>SAENZ: Launching personal attacks on him and his family.</s>REP. CEDRIC RICHMOND (D-LA): I think the vice president will look straight past Donald Trump and his theatrics. What he won't do is get in the mud and start talking about the president's kids.</s>BIDEN: Would you shut up, man?</s>TRUMP: Who is on your list, Joe?</s>SAENZ: Biden has welcomed the debate commission's decision on muting microphones, but Biden's advisers have prepared him for the possibility Trump proceeds with his interruptions, even if they're not caught on mic.</s>KATE BEDINGFIELD, BIDEN DEPUTY CAMPAIGN MANAGER: Is he going to be there lobbying personal attacks and interrupting and trying to create chaos? Either way, Joe Biden is going to be there ready. He's going to be ready to talk about his plans.</s>SAENZ: Ahead of the debate, Biden offering a new answer on a question he's dodged for weeks, expanding the Supreme Court, the Democratic nominee telling "60 Minutes" he would form a bipartisan commission to study possible changes to the courts.</s>BIDEN: I will ask them to over 180 days come back to me with recommendations as to how to reform the court system, because it's getting out of whack.</s>BARACK OBAMA, FORMER PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: Hello, Philadelphia!</s>SAENZ: While Biden was off the campaign trail, he leaned on some help from his old boss.</s>OBAMA: I am back here tonight to ask you to deliver the White House for Joe Biden and Kamala Harris.</s>SAENZ: At a drive-in rally in Philadelphia, former President Barack Obama tore into President Trump.</s>OBAMA: He hasn't shown any interest in doing the work or helping anybody but himself and his friends or treating the presidency like a reality show that he can use to get attention. And, by the way, even then, his TV ratings are down. So you know that upsets him.</s>SAENZ: And President Obama will continue his road show, campaigning for Joe Biden in Miami on Saturday. And over the next few days, you will see a slate of Democratic surrogates hitting the campaign trail for Joe Biden, from seasoned politicians like Bernie Sanders and Julian Castro to celebrities like Cher and Lizzo. For Biden's part, he will be back in Delaware tomorrow delivering remarks on COVID-19 and the economy, after his final face-off against the president here in Nashville tonight -- Jake.</s>TAPPER: All right. Arlette Saenz, thanks so much. Here to discuss, CNN political commentators Bakari Sellers and Scott Jennings. Bakari, let me start with you. President Trump already complaining that muting the mics is unfair. But if he does interrupt Biden on stage, even if we won't be able to hear it, Biden will still be able to hear it. Are you worried about Biden getting thrown off his game tonight?</s>BAKARI SELLERS, CNN CONTRIBUTOR: I mean, I think the president will do it intentionally. I think that when you have an individual with a stutter who has to focus on every single word, one of the tactics that we saw the president employ in the first debate was attempting to talk over him and make it difficult to focus on those words as they were coming out. And, yes, that could pose somewhat of an issue. You know, I think that Cedric Richmond in the clip you played earlier is actually going to -- he actually spoke very highly and spoke to what Joe Biden will be doing, which is trying to look past Donald Trump. There's a saying that you never wrestle with a pig because you both getting muddy, but the pig likes it. And so he's going to try to stay out of the mud with Donald Trump, but it's going to be very, very difficult.</s>TAPPER: Scott, what do you want to see from Donald Trump this evening? I mean, we have already heard that he's going to bring up Joe Biden's son Hunter. He's going to -- obviously, based on how aggressive he was a lot of his last debate, a lot of his advisers are worried he's going to do that. What would you like to see if he was listening to you?</s>SCOTT JENNINGS, CNN POLITICAL COMMENTATOR: Well, I'm not opposed to being aggressive. What I am opposed to is not aggressively prosecuting the case that would convince people to vote for you. So, on the economy, you have to have a contrast. Here's what I would do. Here's what Biden would do, on taxes, on Green New Deal, on the courts. You know, there's a whole number of issues where I actually think Trump has a pretty good story to tell, and an opportunity to lay out why his agenda would be better for the future. But you got to let it unspool. I actually think muting the microphones might work to Trump's benefit a little bit tonight, because it lets Biden talk a little, and then Trump can respond on policy. I think he needs to mention his foreign policy successes. He's had some really good success in the Middle East lately. It hasn't come up yet. So that's a good opportunity. And then, finally, it's just -- it's time to get out the vote. There's not a ton of persuasion going on. So reminding people who are leaning your way, but are low political engagers, maybe they didn't vote in 2016, don't miss your chance to vote for me.</s>TAPPER: Bakari, the right wing is going crazy with all sorts of allegations about Biden and his family, too disgusting to even repeat here. I mean, some of the ones I have seen from the president's son and the president -- some of the president's supporters are just wildly unhinged. If Trump goes there tonight, what should Biden do?</s>SELLERS: I mean, that's a tough one. If it's me or you, Jake, somebody goes after our kids, you want to go back at them just as hard as they're going after your children.</s>TAPPER: And that's Biden's record. I mean, he gets passionate about defending his kids.</s>SELLERS: Yes. I mean, I have three children. If somebody attacks my kids, you just come out of your shell, out of your normal demeanor, and you want to fight back and attack. I don't see Joe Biden doing that, though. I see Joe Biden trying -- the country is sick and tired of that nastiness. They're sick and tired of that mud. They're sick and tired of the childish behavior of the president today. And so he's going to put forth that contrast. That restraint is going to be extremely difficult. And you know what I would say? I would say, it's Donald Trump Jr. and Eric Trump that are robbing the American public blind. Your daughter's on the White House payroll. Bill Barr's family works for the federal government. I mean, you guys have been pillaging and plundering government for your own benefit. That would be my response. But I think that Joe Biden is going to show us what a leader looks like. And he's going to be more dignified and focus on the needs of the American public. I would walk across the stage. Joe Biden won't do that.</s>TAPPER: Scott, one of the reasons why President Trump is, at least according to polls, in a rough shape right now in his reelection is because of his handling of the coronavirus pandemic. Chris Christie wrote an op-ed today in "The Wall Street Journal," telling people to wear masks. A lot of Trump's advisers were hoping that Trump would assume such a leadership role after he contracted the virus. He obviously did not. He's been out there undermining the wearing of masks. What do you want to hear from him on the coronavirus pandemic tonight?</s>JENNINGS: Well, same thing I have always wanted, which is for him to say that we're -- it's all of our responsibility to take care of each other. That's number one. Number two, wear a mask. Number three, socially distance. Number four, the rules apply equally to all of us. Number five, there's no special immunity based on your politics or your causes. And, number six, if we all do these things, I'm handling the vaccine. We got Warp Speed going on. And we're going to get to a vaccine as soon as possible. And those things are going to converge as soon as possible. But we're all in this together. I know because I got it. That right there would solve a lot of issues. He hasn't really done that yet. I actually thought Mike Pence in the vice presidential debate, too, did something very smart, Jake, thanked the American people for all of the sacrifices that the American people have done during this coronavirus pandemic. If Trump would do that tonight too, it would also be very helpful.</s>TAPPER: Bakari, we assume that Biden is going to have to ask -- answer questions about the Democrats' push -- it's not official policy yet, but there is a push by Democrats to expand the number of justices on the Supreme Court. Biden said, if elected, he told "60 Minutes" he'd set up a bipartisan commission to recommend all sorts of changes, including looking at that issue. Does that really answer the question, though?</s>SELLERS: I mean, it answers the question well enough to get to Election Day. This is going to be an issue that he's going to deal with in his first 100 days or 180 days, as he set forth. I'm someone who will tell you that, as a Democrat, I want to increase the number of federal court judges we have. We haven't increased or expanded the federal events since Jimmy Carter was president. I think that's necessary. I'm somebody who's in favor of adding justices. I don't think Joe Biden wants to go there. And so he's placating his base by doing this. And I think that it's a -- it's a well-reasoned answer. It's an answer that flies in the face of people trying to call Joe Biden some socialist or flaming liberal. It's a very moderate position to take. We will just have to see what comes from this reform commission. I think it's a good enough answer to get to November 4, but we have a serious problem with our federal bench. And I look forward to us delving into that deeper.</s>TAPPER: Blue-ribbon panels are what I tell my kids when they say they want a new toy that's too expensive. I just say, I'm going to set up a blue-ribbon panel to discuss. Your mother and I are going to...</s>SELLERS: I'm going to use that. I'm going to use that for the twins, then.</s>TAPPER: Yes, your mother and I are going to set up a bipartisan blue- ribbon panel in discussing whether or not we're going to get you that new toy. Bakari Sellers, Scott Jennings, thank you so much. Appreciate it. A new study finds 130,000 coronavirus deaths could have been avoided and puts the blame right on the White House. Let's just -- we will discuss that too. And new efforts to interfere in our election from Russia and Iran, but what's the truth about which candidate was the target and how? Stay with us.
U.S. Tops 1,000 Daily COVID- 19 Deaths.
TAPPER: Now to our health lead. A new report finds that, if the current administration would have instituted widespread COVID testing and advocated policies such as a mask mandate, between 130,000, and 210,000 lives could have been saved. And, still, this second wave is getting worse in the country, nearly 63,000 new cases just yesterday, with 31 states going in the wrong direction. Only one state, Hawaii, is reporting any positive trends. Deaths are climbing as well. More than 1,100 Americans died yesterday, the most in a single day since September 15. Joining us now to discuss, CNN chief medical correspondent Dr. Sanjay Gupta. And, Sanjay, we are getting some breaking news right now. The antiviral remdesivir just got approval from the FDA for the treatment of patients hospitalized with coronavirus. Explain how significant this is. And correct me if I'm wrong. I thought that there was a different study, maybe from the World Health Organization, saying that it was not effective.</s>DR. SANJAY GUPTA, CNN SENIOR MEDICAL CORRESPONDENT: Right. Yes. So this is going to be a little confusing for people. So let me try and clarify. I think what's happening here, first of all, it is significant news, in that this is the first and only drug that's now been approved for the treatment of this disease, COVID-19,SARS-CoV-2. Remember, this -- remdesivir had been authorized before, but now this is an FDA approval. I think the confusion a little bit is that you're absolutely right. The World Health Organization, as part of its trial known as a solidarity trial, they released some results just last week basically saying they could not find evidence that this medication reduced mortality, that it actually decreased the overall mortality rates or increased survival. There was a previous study that basically showed, for people who were hospitalized with this disease, that remdesivir could shorten the course of their illness from about 15 days to 10 days, so two different things. Could this be a medication that could still have some effect in terms of reducing severity of illness, duration of illness, while not necessarily reducing mortality? That seems to be where this medication sort of fits in.</s>TAPPER: OK.</s>GUPTA: It's, again, big, because it's the only approved drug. But it's not sort of the home run, I think, that a lot of people wanted in terms of actually increasing survival, Jake.</s>TAPPER: OK, that makes sense. Very nuanced, though. Sanjay, I want to ask you about this report from Columbia University that estimates that at least 130,000 deaths, and possibly as many as 210,000 deaths, could have been avoided with earlier policy interventions from the Trump administration and far more robust federal coordination. I mean, they're basically saying we would only have about 10,000 or so deaths right now if the Trump administration had done its job better.</s>GUPTA: Yes, I mean, Jake, this -- we have been following this Columbia modeling for some time. And the numbers are really quite striking to look at. Let me show you a few examples, because what they did is, they looked at this at a country-by-country sort of basis and basically said, look, if we had adopted this country's policies, where would we be? So, South Korea, for example, 2,799, Jake, that's not the number of lives saved, they say, with South Korean policies. That's the number of people they think would have died total here in the United States if the same policies had been implemented in this country as were implemented in South Korea. I mean, think about that. Again, South Korea is a good example because their first patient was diagnosed, confirmed on the same day a patient was diagnosed, confirmed in this country. They didn't really ever go into lockdown, remember Jake. Their philosophy really was all about very robust testing. You may remember Ivan Watson doing these pieces showing these testing kiosks all over Seoul, people able to get that testing, isolate quickly, contact trace, all that stuff. I mean, Jake, I mean, this Columbia port really shows now, eight months into this, how much of an impact that would have had. And you see that in several countries, Australia, Japan, in terms of trying to really apply those policies here. And maybe, Jake, I think the point is that they can still be applied here. They could still make a difference going forward, even if we have lost all this time so far.</s>TAPPER: And what's so upsetting about this study, other than what it suggests, is that, just yesterday, President Trump was asked, if he had a mulligan, if you could do it over, what would he do differently about coronavirus? And he said -- quote -- "Not much." Well, here's a study from Columbia University saying, if you had done much different, you would have saved hundreds of thousands of American lives.</s>GUPTA: Yes, I mean, it is very upsetting, Jake. And I don't know. I mean, you and I have been talking about this stuff for so many months now. I try to keep my head looking forward, as opposed to in the rearview mirror, because it's just too upsetting to look backwards. And, sometimes, I wonder if we have just been shouting into the abyss. But, Jake, I mean, there's examples around the world of just how different this could have gone. Those examples, those lessons can still be applied. There's also examples right here in the United States. Arizona, I have been looking at some of this data from several states, trying to understand the policies they put in place, because they were forced to many times, how much of a difference it would make. If you look at Arizona, they were sort of in stay-at-home mode until the end of May, beginning of June. As soon as they came out of stay- at-home mode, the numbers went up. That wasn't surprising, June 1 to June 15. But I think what was surprising and worth remembering for people, as we go into the colder weather, that they were able to significantly, by 75 percent, bring down the new case numbers by masking, by physical distancing, and by basically avoiding closely clustered indoor settings. And that shouldn't surprise anybody at this point. But I think the idea that it can make such a huge impact, even now, I think, is really worth remembering. Everyone's focused on the vaccine, understandably, but these public health measures can still make a huge difference.</s>TAPPER: Oh, I mean, the soonest we're going to get the vaccine -- and I don't buy it -- is April. I mean, we still have months and months to go before then. Chris Christie has a new op-ed out in which he basically apologizes for not wearing a mask. He says in the op-ed in "The Journal": "Those who deny the scientific realities of the pandemic undermine conditions that allow for rapid and complete reopening. They encourage behavior that invites personal tragedy and social regulation. People need encouragement to do the right thing, not excuses not to." Well, it's great to hear that from Governor Christie. And we're all, of course, so thankful that he is feeling better. He doesn't mention the fact that President Trump is the number one underminer of the imperative to wear masks whenever people go out. Do you think the op-ed would be stronger if he acknowledged that?</s>GUPTA: Yes, a hundred percent. I mean, he's one of the few people that could probably really make that point personally, because he likely became infected in that setting at the White House, either during debate prep or at one of these events. I mean, that's where this happened. The White House itself was a hotbed of viral activity. Jake, I don't know what gets through to people at this point. We're still around 65 percent of people who say they wear masks regularly. Every day, I think of new ways to sort of present this in a way that makes sense. And if you look at states in terms of states that put in mask mandates, there were 15 of them, and Washington, D.C., and see what happened, what the trajectory was of the new case counts, you see that it decreased a couple of percent initially, and then started to build and build over time. Keep in mind, a small percentage decrease in the face of what we have, almost exponential increase, is significant. You're able to really break the cycle of that transmission. Sometimes, people understand that. How about this example of those two hairstylists in Missouri, I believe?</s>TAPPER: Right.</s>GUPTA: They had COVID. They wore masks.</s>TAPPER: But they wore masks.</s>GUPTA: They should have stayed home.</s>TAPPER: Right.</s>GUPTA: They should have stayed home. Admit that. But they wore masks. They took care of 139 clients. None of them got sick. None of them got sick. Why? Because of the masks. I mean, there was no other therapeutic or any other magical thing that was happening. Can you imagine? Does this get across to people that, if you wear masks in an indoor setting, you can dramatically reduce the spread of this virus?</s>TAPPER: Yes.</s>GUPTA: And that's a good example of that.</s>TAPPER: The president, of course, is out there having rallies and not requiring his attendees to wear masks. He is inviting super-spreader events all over the country. If you wrote this as a screenplay, you would get laughed out of Hollywood. Nobody would buy it. Nobody would believe that the White House became a super-spreader den of the virus, but it happened. Sanjay Gupta, thank you so much. Always good to see you, my friend. Hopes for a pre-election stimulus deal are fading fast, and both parties might be to blame. I will talk to Senator Kirsten Gillibrand about what should happen now. Stay with us.
Trump Tests Negative for COVID Ahead of Final Debate; Trump Says He May Change Strategy from Last Debate; Potential Paths to Victory for Trump and Biden.
JAKE TAPPER, CNN HOST: And he's also suggesting that the entire debate commission and process in unfair. Here to discuss CNN's Jeff Zeleny and "Politico's" Laura Barron-Lopez. Jeff, Trump advisers are telling him loud and clear, lower the temperature, don't seem so angry. I have not seen much evidence of that yet.</s>JEFF ZELENY, CNN SENIOR WHITE HOUSE CORRESPONDENT: Jake, if the President decided to do that, that would certainly be a change in approach and a change in course. We have rarely seen him do that. Look, the big question hanging over the debate tonight, which President Trump is going to show up, is it going to be the grievance laced President Trump or is it going to be the one that Republicans really across the board have been clamoring for. Someone to talk about the economy. Someone to talk about the Supreme Court. Someone to talk about the issues that they believe are more winnable issues. So far President Trump has really decided to pick a fight with virtually everyone every day this week, from Lesley Stahl to Kristen Welker to people that the American people really are not that focused on. But the reality is the President going into this debate is trying to gain the ref series trying to say, look, this is an unfair process. This is the last, best opportunity for the President to get some of those people back on board who may be wavering. I think that's a small slice of the electorate. No question about it. But there are people who like the Republican policies, they just don't necessarily like the Republican President's attitude and conduct. So perhaps he can attract those tonight. But Jake, we have not seen any indication he has a second act here. We'll see.</s>TAPPER: Yes, I mean, it's become so cliche now, almost as much as infrastructure week. People in the media saying well, will the President have a new tone. There might be like a moment of relative normalcy. But like even if he has a relatively normal debate, we know, you know, who will be back on the campaign trail the next morning. Laura, there will be plexiglass barriers between Trump and Biden tonight and their microphones will be muted during portions of the debate. I mean there are some really extraordinary steps being taken here because of the pandemic and because of President Trump's behavior last time.</s>LAURA BARRON-LOPEZ, NATIONAL POLITICAL REPORTER, POLITICO: Yes, that's right. I mean coronavirus is going to be on everyone's minds because of those plexiglass barriers, similar with vice presidential debate. And then on top of it, yes, because of the way the first debate went and the President's behavior and the back and forth between the two, the commission decided to take extra measures so that way there could be a more -- there could be more from each of the candidates that the voters can hear from. Because a lot of the voters that I spoke to after the first debate said that they barely really heard much from Biden. They described -- this was undecided voters to me, described Trump's performance as unhinged. They described it as not presidential, but they still had questions that they wanted answers about Biden's policy proposals. And so hopefully tonight's debate we'll see a bit more of that. Although, of course, who knows if actually it will work given that the President could lash out based on what he's done this week.</s>TAPPER: Yes, and Jeff, Trump has already said muting microphones, quote, is very unfair. Of course, they will be muted both for Biden and for him. Theoretically he'll still be able to interrupt Biden and knock Biden off his game even if we at home or at work won't be able to hear it, Biden will still be able to hear it. What do you think Biden needs to do tonight?</s>ZELENY: Sure, they are standing on the same stage. So of course, the former Vice President will be able to hear exactly what the President is saying whether it's muted or not. So, we'll see how all that plays out on a technical basis. But the reality is I'm told that Joe Biden has been planning in his debate practice sessions all week long for those interruptions. He's planning for this exact moment. So, I think it would be more of a surprise if they didn't come. But look, Joe Biden I'm told is going to try and do one thing, first and foremost, again try and focus this discussion on how he believes the President and the Trump administration has let down America on coronavirus, has simply been asleep at the switch and not recognizing the truly challenges here. Something that Joe Biden will have to do, and this can be tricky for him, Jake, as you well know. His family is very personal to him. And he knows that President Trump is almost certainly to go after Hunter Biden, his son. So that is going to be something that Joe Biden will have to deal with. I'm told again in those practice sessions all week long they were pretty brutal at times going after Hunter Biden in very personal terms. So that's what we will see. It's hard to imagine at this point in the campaign any new information would come forward here. We've pretty much heard it all, especially with the President, you know, tweeting out so much of his own internal thinking here. But that is what I'm told that Joe Biden is planning to do, trying to keep his cool over questions even Hunter Biden. But at the first event you'll remember it was actually an empathetic moment when the President raised him because it gave Joe Biden a chance to talk about his son, challenges and all.</s>TAPPER: And Laura, we know at tonight's debate or we suspect anyway, that President Trump is going to say he created the greatest economy ever. It certainly was strong before the pandemic struck. But 700 economists including seven Nobel winners wrote an open letter opposing Trump's re-election. They say his handling of the pandemic has been selfish and reckless and that he's been a chaotic and ineffective negotiator when it comes to trade. How do you think President Trump should respond if Joe Biden brings that up?</s>BARRON-LOPEZ: Well, how I think he should respond is probably not how he's going to respond, Jake, given that he will likely refute the premise of the question and repeat the same claim that you just said. So, he will likely say that he did create the greatest economy. And a fact check by us as reporters and the fact check by economists is likely not going to change anything that he says, and he won't believe it. Now what his advisers want him to say, as Jeff was saying, is that they want him to focus on what he'll do to make the economy better, what he'll do to try to bring back the country after the coronavirus pandemic. But so far across his rallies, across the first debate and across his tweets, there's no indication that he plans on doing that.</s>TAPPER: Yes, and no indication that he has a plan to get us out of this coronavirus pandemic. Jeff Zeleny, Laura Barron-Lopez thank you so much. You can see the final presidential debate between Donald Trump and Joe Biden right here on CNN. Our special coverage starts at 7:00 P.M. Eastern. A medical milestone in the search for a coronavirus vaccine, 300,000 Americans are taking part in one clinical trial. What that could mean for when a safe vaccine, or if, is ready for you?
Republicans Advance Supreme Court Nominee Despite Boycott by Democrats
TAPPER: Back to our HEALTH LEAD, the FDA holding a special meeting today to focus on the effort to develop a successful coronavirus vaccine. The agency hoping that this daylong event will increase public confidence in the FDA approval process resulting in more people taking the vaccine when and if it becomes available. CNN senior medical correspondent Elizabeth Cohen joins us now. Elizabeth, have we learned anything new at this meeting about the development of a coronavirus vaccine?</s>ELIZABETH COHEN, CNN SENIOR MEDICAL CORRESPONDENT: Jake, what we've learned actually is something that the CDC plans to do once the vaccine comes out on the market. They've planned for this cell phone-based application where people who get the vaccine will be followed. They will get text messages, they will get e-mails saying, hey, how are you doing post vaccine? So, they would get a text or an e-mail every day for a week and then every week for six weeks after that asking them are you having any side effects, et cetera. And I think this is really aimed at further increasing the -- or doing anything really that they can to increase the public confidence in a vaccine. If we know that they're following up on this first group, which will mostly be essential workers, hopefully that means that we'll get more information about whether this vaccine is as safe as they want it to be.</s>TAPPER: Also, on the vaccine front Moderna just reported hitting a major milestone in its Phase III clinical trials, it has enrolled 30,000 participants. Explain the significance of this.</s>COHEN: Right, the significance is that the very first trial that started in the United States for a COVID vaccine has enrolled all of its people. They've given them all their first shots. They've given nearly all of them their second shots. That tells us that things are moving. However, it does not tell us that we will have a vaccine on the market any time soon, because just because they gave these people their shots, it doesn't mean that the vaccine actually works. So, let's take a look at some of the details here. So as of this morning, Moderna enrolled all 30,000 of its participants. Half of them got the vaccine, half of them got the placebo. Nobody knows at this point who got what, the participants don't know, the doctors don't know, Moderna doesn't know. But once 53 participants get sick with COVID, then a safety board will unblind it. And they'll see of those 53 if fewer than 14 received the vaccine, in other words, if 25 percent or fewer received the vaccine, then Moderna will ask the FDA for an Emergency Use Authorization -- Jake.</s>TAPPER: So that's 53 participants getting coronavirus on their own. It's not that they'll be infected with it --</s>COHEN: Right, of course.</s>TAPPER: -- like they're doing in that experiment in London. OK, Elizabeth Cohen, thank you so much. Appreciate it.</s>COHEN: Thanks.</s>TAPPER: In the POLITICS LEAD, despite a boycott from Democrats today Republicans on Senate Judiciary Committee voted to advance Judge Amy Coney Barrett to the U.S. Supreme Court. This sets up a full Senate vote early next Monday just days before the election. CNN's Manu Raju is live for us on Capitol Hill. And Manu, the final vote will give President Trump his third Supreme Court justice. And at this point I can't see anything Democrats can really do about it.</s>MANU RAJU, CNN SENIOR CONGRESSIONAL CORRESPONDENT: No, they can't. She will get the spot, she'll get it on Monday, she will be on the seat for life, for as long as she wants to serve. And this despite the Democratic protest about the process, this being one of the quickest confirmation proceedings in modern time, happening in just over a month period. Typically takes two to three months to get a nomination through. This happened in over a month. And despite the Republicans refusal to move on Barack Obama's nominee in 2016 eight months before the election that year. But nevertheless, Democrats tried to register their objection today by not showing up to a Judiciary Committee vote that actually advanced the nomination to the floor. None of the Democrats showed up, in place they had pictures of people affected by the Affordable Care Act in their seats instead. And Republicans ignored that, disregarded the Democratic concerns and plowed right ahead.</s>SEN. LINDSEY GRAHAM (R-SC) CHAIRMAN, JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: This is a groundbreaking, historic moment for American legal community and really politically. We did the right thing. It would have been wrong to deny her a vote. In my view, if you're a Republican, it would have been crazy not to vote for her.</s>RAJU: Now Democrats themselves have come under criticism from their own base, Jake, for not going harder at Amy Coney Barrett at last week's confirmation hearings. Dianne Feinstein for one praised the handling of those hearings, a lot of Democrats were critical of her. But today nothing they could do even if she had criticized the proceedings, they don't have the votes to stop her -- Jake.</s>TAPPER: And Manu, Republicans may have been unanimous in their committee vote today but it might not be the case for Republicans for the full Senate vote next week.</s>RAJU: Yes, that's right. They expect to lose probably two Senate Republicans, Susan Collins of Maine in a difficult re-election race. She said that it's too close to an election to move ahead. She has already indicated that she would vote no. Also, Lisa Murkowski of Alaska had a similar concern that she has raised. Now just today she told reporters that she also is likely to vote no. She has not said that outright but that is the expectation. But this will be one the closest confirmation votes for any Supreme Court Justice, but she will get the votes, with those two votes defecting, Jake, still a 51-49 vote she'll get confirmed by Monday night -- Jake.</s>TAPPER: Still a W, that's right, OK, Manu Raju, thank you so much. With just 12 days left to vote, a reality check on the road to victory. What President Trump and Joe Biden have to stay focused on during tonight's final debate. Stay with us.
Republicans Advance Supreme Court Nominee Amy Coney Barrett Despite Boycott From Democrats; Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand (D-NY) is Interviewed About Supreme Court Nomination and Stimulus Deal; New Debate Details: Candidates Will Be 12+ Feet Apart, Trump Will Get First Question.
JAKE TAPPER, CNN HOST: In the politics lead, President Trump is one step closer to getting his third Supreme Court justice on the Supreme Court. Although Democrats boycotted today's vote in protest, Senate Republicans, nonetheless, advanced the nomination of Judge Amy Coney Barrett out of the Judiciary Committee, setting up a full Senate vote on the floor on Monday. CNN's Manu Raju is live for us on Capitol Hill. Manu, committee chairman Lindsey Graham celebrated today's vote. He called it ground breaking and that is fact check true. No justice has ever been confirmed so close to Election Day, but that's exactly why Democrats are so mad.</s>MANU RAJU, CNN SENIOR CONGRESSIONAL CORRESPONDENT: Yeah, actually after July of a presidential election year, no Supreme Court justice has been confirmed. This is going to happen now eight days before the election, on Monday. That's when the ultimate confirmation vote is expected to happen on the Senate floor. And no Democrats are expected to vote for Amy Coney Barrett after today. You mentioned they boycotted today's committee vote. Republicans didn't bother them. They still moved straight ahead with this committee vote and approved their nomination advanced to the Senate floor by a 12-0 vote. And now on the Senate floor, two Republican senators have raised concerns about moving so close to the election. Susan Collins of Maine is in a difficult race has indicated she's a no vote. Lisa Murkowski of Alaska today suggested she also might vote no because of concerns about this process. She was the lone Republican who voted against Brett Kavanaugh. But even those two Republican votes not enough for Democrats to block the nomination of the vote. She'll be confirmed likely by a 51-49 vote on Monday night, Jake.</s>TAPPER: By many of the same Republican senators who in 2016 said that eight months before the election was too close to the election to even have a hearing for President Obama's nominee, Merrick Garland. Stunning. Manu, the on-again, off-again stimulus talks appear to be on again, gratefully. House Speaker Pelosi sounds as if a deal could actually happen before Election Day. So, what's changed in the last 24 hours?</s>RAJU: Well, both sides really have an incentive to get a deal. The president wants something before Election Day so he could say he's cut a deal with Democrats. And lot of Democrats in difficult districts, swing districts in particular, have been pressuring the speaker to get a deal. But, Jake, they are still a ways away on a number of key issues, hot button issues including funding for state and local government has been a big sticking point for some time. Liability protection for businesses and others that Republicans have been pushing. Those are two of the many issues outstanding. So, even if they get a deal, maybe they can get it through the House before election day, but the Senate a complete different situation as Republicans there are lining up in opposition to what the president is proposing -- Jake.</s>TAPPER: All right. Manu Raju on Capitol Hill for us, thank you so much. Joining us now to discuss, Democratic Senator Kirsten Gillibrand of New York. Senator, good to see you. Let me ask you, if there is a deal struck, do you think that Majority Leader McConnell will allow a vote on that, and if so -- I'm giving a lot of hypotheticals -- are there enough Republicans to join with Democrats to pass it?</s>SEN. KIRSTEN GILLIBRAND (D-NY): I think if we had a vote on a common sense bipartisan bill that didn't have poison pills, yes, we could pass it. But Mitch McConnell has been unwilling to even allow the conversations to let that happen. He's had the House bill since May. He's not negotiated any package with Senator Schumer, and he's been absent from these ones with the White House. So, he's not interested in the vote, but I do believe if we could bring it to the floor, we could get immediate relief to so many New Yorkers and so many Americans that are in desperate need right now.</s>TAPPER: Well, let's talk about that, because the reality is, as you know, millions of Americans are unemployed because of this pandemic. Businesses are struggling, bars can't open. Music venues can't open. People need relief, and they can't. Now, most Americans probably don't follow the machinations of, well, Mitch McConnell has $500 billion and he has a poison bill. They don't know. They see Republicans and Democrats fighting. Do you think that Democrats share any of the blame for nothing passing yet?</s>GILLIBRAND: I don't, and I'll tell you why. We've been clear from the beginning that we need money for food stamps and housing relief. We need money for states and city governments. We need money for unemployment and we need money for first responders and small businesses. Unfortunately, Mitch McConnell, the one thing he wants in there is the one thing that is a poison pill, liability protection for large companies, and for companies that aren't making sure their employees are safe. We know what that looks like, Jake. If you remember, we saw the meatpacking plants where people had to stand shoulder to shoulder with no masks, no PPE and COVID spread like wildfire in those places. If you don't have liability -- if you have liability protection then those employees can't sue and say, listen, we'll come to work, but you have to keep us safe. There's no incentive. And so, that is the poison pill. And Mitch has no interest in doing anything unless he can actually deliver that for his donors.</s>TAPPER: There's a new study out today from Columbia University that says if the Trump administration had taken leadership and more assertive testing that somewhere between 130,000 and 210,000 lives would not have been lost. There was a previous one, a previous study by Columbia saying that if the U.S. had enacted social distancing measures one week sooner than it did in March, 36,000 lives would have been saved. Now, Democrats have been very tough on President Trump for enacting those measures, but don't some -- don't some of these -- doesn't some of the blame also lie with New York Governor Andrew Cuomo who could have put in place some of these measures as well as mayors and city leaders? Are they not also responsible?</s>GILLIBRAND: I don't think so, and I'll tell you why. What President Trump first did is he did not disclose the seriousness of the COVID epidemic when it started. He had information that it was airborne, that's how it would be transmitted, and that it was deadly for everyone including children. And he did not tell the American people that. In fact, he kept down-playing it saying, it's just like a flu. He refused to wear a mask for a very long time, and even most recently where the White House was the vector for the virus, where spread was all over. He wasn't wearing masks, the people around him weren't wearing masks -- again, flying in the face of what his scientists and experts have been telling him. So, President Trump hadn't used his office in the way he could of. He could have used the Defense Production Act to start in January developing vaccines, developing the personal protective equipment, making sure he has all the testing manufacturers here in the United States, making sure we wouldn't run out of reagents and swabs like we have.</s>TAPPER: Yeah.</s>GILLIBRAND: And so, today, Jake, we still don't have universal testing. You have kids who can't go back to school because it's not easy to get a test, they're not taken very often, and they take too long to get results back and so you can't do proper contact tracing. So, I really -- I leave the blame at President Trump's feet --</s>TAPPER: OK.</s>GILLIBRAND: -- because the things he could have done, he chose not to do.</s>TAPPER: Senator, I'm sorry to interrupt but I do want to ask you about the Senate Judiciary Committee advancing Judge Amy Coney Barrett's nomination to the support today. The vote was unanimous because Democrats on the committee boycotted the vote. They filled their seats with photographs of people who defend on the Affordable Care Act. Republican Senator John Cornyn criticized the move. He said doing that made it look like a sporting event. What's your response to what Cornyn had to say?</s>GILLIBRAND: Well, Cornyn has not provided leadership at a time when our country desperately needs it, and I don't think he's served the people of Texas well at all. In fact, I think this whole process has been a sham. It was Mitch McConnell who denied Barack Obama his final Supreme Court justice, and he said that it was too close to the election. That was in March. He denied even a hearing to Merrick Garland. Now, his duplicitousness and hypocrisy is here for everyone to see, not only is he jamming through a justice weeks before an election, but he's refusing to put on the floor a COVID relief package that is bipartisan in the House and that could make a difference and help save peoples' lives.</s>TAPPER: All right. Democratic Senator Kirsten Gillibrand of New York, thanks so much. Good to see you again.</s>GILLIBRAND: Thanks, Jake.</s>TAPPER: The U.S. is blaming Iran for threatening e-mails sent to Democratic voters. But why is there debate about which presidential candidate they were trying to hurt? Stay with us.
Feds: Iran & Russia Interfered in 2020 Election
TAPPER: Continuing on our 2020 lead today, only 12 days until the presidential election. Today, there is a troubling new concern about election interference by foreign actors. As CNN's Pamela Brown reports in our latest installment of "Making It Count."</s>UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: This debate will cover six major topics.</s>PAMELA BROWN, CNN SENIOR WHITE HOUSE CORRESPONDENT (voice-over): On the night of the final debate, the spotlight is on threats to America's election. The federal government announcing both Iran and Russia have obtained U.S. voter registration information.</s>JOHN RATCLIFFE, DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL INTELLIGENCE: This data can be used by foreign actors to attempt to communicate false information to registered voters.</s>BROWN: That's already happened. The intelligence director says Iran was responsible for e-mail threats sent to thousands of voters urging them to, quote, vote for Trump or else. Many of the e-mails were made to look like they came from the proud boys, a far right extremist group. Director John Ratcliffe sparked outrage when he politicized the attack saying without explanation the e-mails were designed to hurt the president. Democrats pounced on that.</s>REP. NANCY PELOSI (D-CA): Elections are sacred. It should be treated with respect. I don't know what the DNI is up to.</s>BROWN: The Senate Intelligence Committee issued a joint statement saying, quote: Republicans and Democrats are united when we say that continued attempts to sow dissent, cast doubt on election results or disrupt our election systems or infrastructure will necessitate a severe response. It's unclear what Russia will do with the data officials say it has. But Democrats fear it will be for Trump's benefit.</s>REP. ERIC SWALWELL (D-CA): Russia has done this before. They had preference to tear down Hillary Clinton, help Donald Trump. We know right now they have a preference to help Donald Trump and to tear down Joe Biden.</s>BROWN: And there are also fears of in-person voter intimidation after the president's rhetoric at the last debate.</s>DONALD TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: I'm urging my supporters to go into the polls and watch very carefully.</s>BROWN: Both parties will be sending out poll watchers who will gather signs of not just intimidation but all voting issues. A rule that limited the RNC's ability to work with the party nominee to recruit poll workers has expired, allowing closer coordination with the Trump campaign. And Democrats have a new app that allows poll watchers to quickly report issues back to the campaign and its lawyers. Meanwhile tens of millions of Americans have already voted, up more than 100 percent from this time in 2016. This despite many voters nationwide reporting not receiving their mail-in ballots yet. Printing errors, mail delivery delays and sheer volume have left many states struggling to keep up. In the battleground state of Michigan, 3 million absently ballots were requested, 20,000 voters are still waiting.</s>UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: This kind of thing just can't happen. Obviously, there's a kink in the system.</s>BROWN: And, Jake, now, with less than two weeks to go until election day, the Supreme Court is still weighing in on these election issues in different states. In Alabama, in reinstated the ban on curbside voting. There are still cases about North Carolina and Wisconsin on ballot receipt deadlines in front of the court. And Republican sources tell me that Republicans will likely appeal on that Pennsylvania case on the merits that extended the deadline by three days to receive mail-in ballots if they were mailed by-election day. And it's worth reiterating, Jake, election experts are saying given all that's going on, given how close we are to election day, the best thing you could do if you haven't mailed in your ballot, that's what you're planning to do, is to go in person and vote and vote early -- Jake.</s>TAPPER: All right. Pamela Brown, thank you so much. Joining us now to discuss all the latest in election security headlines, Admiral James Stavridis. He's a retired U.S. Navy supreme allied commander and he's author of the book "Sailing True North." Admiral Stavridis, thanks so much for joining us. Just yesterday, you warned in a piece in "The Economist" that some, quote, un-neighborly countries might be tempted to take advantage of our divided nation. Is what we heard officials lay out last night what you were concerned about?</s>ADM. JAMESA STAVRIDIS (RET.), FORMER U.S. NAVY SUPREME ALLIED COMMANDER AT NATO: It really is, Jake. And let's face it, we've heard a lot about Iran. We've heard a fair amount about Russia. The dog that hasn't barked yet that I worry about, if you will, is China. So we've got a spread of concerns here, but let's kind of put them into perspective. If you want to put it in baseball terms, the Iranians are not like a tee ball team, but they're probably like a good high school baseball team. The Russians in this zone are the L.A. Dodgers. They're coming right at you like they would for the World Series. The Chinese are even better. We haven't seen publicly discussions of what China is doing, but our elections are front and center for all of these entities, and what they want is to sow disruption and continue the division that we've lived with for the last four years.</s>TAPPER: That's right. A lot of the divisions were there for them to exploit, but it's our fault that we have the divisions. Do you agree with the Director of National Intelligence Ratcliffe when he made this assessment that these e-mails they were talking about, that were purportedly sent by this far right neo-fascist group, the Proud Boys, threatening Democratic voters if they don't vote for Trump? Ratcliffe said that these were made to hurt President Trump. And I guess following his logic, it was an attempt to show some sort of alliance between President Trump and the Proud Boys, but I don't know that we can assert with any certainty who these were trying to help our hurt. What do you think?</s>STAVRIDIS: I agree with you. And more importantly the intelligence community agrees with you. The intelligence community looks at what has come out of the Iranian efforts, and they were using publicly available data. They weren't even hacking to get this stuff. And if they were the ones sending them, it's entirely unclear even what the effect would be. I could see where some Democratic voters might be intimidated in that setting, for example. That would help President Trump. I think what's much more clear and we saw that the briefing yesterday from FBI Director Wray is that Russia is deeply involved here hacking and clearly trying to support President Trump. And that's just not in the real moment. We know from 2016 that's exactly what they did. That's all been validated in a bipartisan way by the intelligence community and Senate investigations.</s>TAPPER: A lot of the officials that were up there on that stage last night I think are patriots who really have the best interest of the United States at heart. Chris Krebs who's in charge of cybersecurity, Chris Wray who's in charge of FBI. Do you have faith in the Director of National Intelligence John Ratcliffe?</s>STAVRIDIS: I do not. I think he was unqualified for the job to begin with, he was turned down once for exaggerating his national security credentials. There's nothing in either his background or his comportment thus far that give me confidence. I would pose much more confidence, for example, in the director of the CIA, Gina Haspel, who's a career intelligence officer, or FBI Director Wray. Those are the two voices I'm looking to hear from.</s>TAPPER: We know that foreign adversaries try to exploit social media platforms. This time, Google is saying approximately 25,000 e-mails were sent to Gmail users. What do you want tech companies to do to prevent this kind of malice we saw in these fake e-mails from the Proud Boys?</s>STAVRIDIS: This is a tricky one. Let's face it, if we didn't like the things that were coming out of the printing presses that Gutenberg invented we might have said, well, let's burn all the printing presses. We don't want to just shutdown the social networks. They're powerful engines, but we need Google, Facebook, all of the social nets, LinkedIn, all of them to monitor content. And when they see hate speech that should come down as surely as child pornography should. I think they can find their way to this. Jake, it's not an on and off switch of total free speech or shutdown the Internet. We got to dial that</s>TAPPER: And quickly if you could, when it comes to spreading false or sketchy or scurrilous information, I don't know if any foreign actors with ill intent can outmatch what we're seeing with homegrown American actors doing in this election cycle to be frank.</s>STAVRIDIS: It's absolutely true, but what we ought to consider is that they can build off each other and they can create the sum of the parts is greater than the individual parts. We ought to be concerned about both halves of that noxious brew.</s>TAPPER: All right. Admiral James Stavridis, thank you so much. Good to see you as always, sir. The new details just being revealed about tonight's presidential debate. That's next.
Biden, Trump Set for Final Debate; Florida, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, Michigan and Arizona Front and Center with Just 12 Days Left.
ANNOUNCER: This is CNN breaking news.</s>WOLF BLITZER, CNN HOST: Welcome to our viewers here in the United States, and around the world. I'm Wolf Blitzer in THE SITUATION ROOM. We are closing in on a crucial moment in the race for the White House, live coverage of the final debate between President Trump and Joe Biden now just -- our coverage will begin one hour from now. Also tonight, we have new details about what to expect on the debate stage, including who gets the first question, as well as coronavirus safety protocols that are now being enforced by the commission. Both candidates are certainly trying to chart a path to 270 electoral votes, with five key battleground states right at the center of the fight. We're talking about Florida, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, Michigan, and Arizona. And, as of this moment -- get this -- more than 46 million Americans have already voted. We're tracking all of the worsening coronavirus pandemic developments in the United States as well. It has now killed more than 220,000 Americans, with at least 8.3 million confirmed cases. More than 1,100 Americans died just yesterday. But there is, there is a glimmer-of-hope news tonight. The FDA just approved remdesivir to treat hospitalized COVID-19 patients. That's the drug -- the drug is the first therapeutic drug to receive approval to fight the virus here in the United States. Let's begin our coverage this hour with CNN's chief White House correspondent, Jim Acosta. He is inside the debate hall in Nashville. Jim, the president has just tested negative for the coronavirus, just ahead of tonight's face off with Joe Biden.</s>JIM ACOSTA, CNN CHIEF WHITE HOUSE CORRESPONDENT: That's right, Wolf. We are inside this debate hall in Nashville, Tennessee, where the president did his walk-through just a couple hours ago. And White House officials say President Trump did test negative for coronavirus on board Air Force One as he was en route to Nashville just hours before this final debate with Joe Biden. The president appears to be doing more complaining about this debate than he is preparing for one. The president is also claiming he's created the greatest U.S. economy in history, but that's not the case, as the U.S. is still in the grips of a recession, the worst recession in decades. Mr. Trump is blaming all of this on the coronavirus tonight, complaining the media only wants to talk about COVID-19, as the death toll from this pandemic keeps climbing.</s>ACOSTA (voice-over): Joined by the first lady, President Trump left for his final debate with Democrat Joe Biden sounding combative as ever, arguing in an interview with "60 Minutes" that he created the best economy in U.S. history, even as the nation is still reeling from the pandemic.</s>DONALD TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: We created the greatest economy in the history of our country. And the other side was coming in...</s>LESLEY STAHL, CBS NEWS ANCHOR: You know that -- you know that's not true.</s>TRUMP: It is totally true.</s>STAHL: No.</s>ACOSTA: Aides say the president hasn't done much preparation for his face-off with Biden, but Mr. Trump complained to Sinclair television about a new rule put in place to mute the microphones at times during the debate...</s>JOE BIDEN (D), PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATE: Would you shut up, man?</s>ACOSTA: ... to avoid a repeat of the constant interruptions during their last encounter.</s>TRUMP: Well, that's not fair. Plus, they changed the topics, which isn't fair. Just happened.</s>ACOSTA: White House officials say the president may simply disregard some questions at the debate and attack Biden's record on China, even though that might resurrect a recent revelation in "The New York Times" that Mr. Trump has had a secret Chinese bank account.</s>ALYSSA FARAH, WHITE HOUSE DIRECTOR OF STRATEGIC COMMUNICATIONS: I'd say he's going to answer those topics, but he's also going to, frankly, answer the questions he wants to. If we don't get to China, he is prepared to bring up China and Joe Biden's disastrous record on it.</s>ACOSTA: The president is also ranting about media coverage of the coronavirus, claiming it's yet another conspiracy against him.</s>TRUMP: All you hear is COVID, COVID, COVID, COVID, COVID, COVID, COVID, COVID, COVID, COVID, COVID. That's all they put on, because they want to scare the hell out of everyone.</s>ACOSTA: Former President Barack Obama, who is campaigning for Biden as he has been doing debate prep this week, said Mr. Trump is incapable of ending the pandemic.</s>BARACK OBAMA, FORMER PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: Donald Trump isn't suddenly going to protect all of us. He can't even take the basic steps to protect himself.</s>ACOSTA: During his own "60 Minutes" interview, Biden answered a nagging question about whether he would seek to expand the Supreme Court, promising to create a commission to study the issue.</s>BIDEN: Bipartisan commission of scholars, constitutional scholars, Democrats, Republicans, liberal, conservative. And I will ask them to, over 180 days, come back to me with recommendations as to how to reform the court system, because it's getting out of whack, the way in which it's being handled, and it's not about court packing.</s>JOHN RATCLIFFE, U.S. DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL INTELLIGENCE: Foreign interference in our elections.</s>ACOSTA: Democrats are also raising questions about a warning from the director of national intelligence, who said Iran is trying to interfere in the election to damage the president's chances.</s>REP. NANCY PELOSI (D-CA): I think we have to be very careful about any statements coming out about the election from the intelligence community at this time.</s>ACOSTA: The top two lawmakers on the Senate Intelligence Committee released a statement cautioning to the American people and the media: "We reiterate the need to be skeptical of sensationalist last-minute claims about election infrastructure." National Security Adviser Robert O'Brien said the foreign interference efforts detected so far appear limited in scope.</s>ROBERT O'BRIEN, U.S. NATIONAL SECURITY ADVISER: A very small number, two or three in different parts of the United States.</s>ACOSTA: And now that we are inside the debate hall, we can show you how the stage has been set. We understand that there will be Plexiglas dividers between the candidates separating the candidates, and that Biden and the president will stand about 12 feet apart. And the president, as we're told tonight, is set to receive the first question. And, Wolf, we should note, at this moment, those Plexiglas dividers are not on the stage. You can see they appear to have been removed. We're trying to find out whether or not there's anything to that. Perhaps they're just wiping off some smudges before these candidates take the stage -- Wolf.</s>BLITZER: All right, Jim Acosta, reporting for us, we will get back to you. Thank you. Now let's go to CNN's Arlette Saenz. She is also in Nashville. She is tracking the Biden campaign for us. Arlette, Biden has been off the campaign trail now for the past few days while preparing for tonight's debate. How is he expected to handle a potential repeat of the last debate, with interruptions and personal attacks from the president?</s>ARLETTE SAENZ, CNN POLITICAL REPORTER: Well, Wolf, Joe Biden's advisers say that he is going to focus on the issues of importance to American voters, that being the COVID-19 pandemic and the economy. Biden has spent the last three days off the campaign trail preparing for every possibility that President Trump can throw his way. Now, while Biden wants to keep the focus on the coronavirus and the economy, key issues that they believe will define this election, he is also fully prepared for the president to launch those personal attacks not just on him, but on his family. You have seen Republicans and the president in recent days really try to push a little bit more of a narrative about his son Hunter Biden. Now, one thing, we don't expect that Biden is going to kind of turn the tables on the president and go after his own children, but, instead, he is going to speak to the issues that are of concern to American families. Now, Biden, as he traveled here to Nashville, spoke to reporters a little bit about what he is expecting tonight. Take a listen.</s>BIDEN: Hopefully, he's going to play by the rules. Hopefully, everybody's been tested. Hopefully, it's all worked out, just the way the rules are. I'm looking forward to this. Thank you.</s>SAENZ: Now, Biden's advisers have, also, prepared him for the possibility of interruptions. Even though the microphones will be muted for periods during this debate, there is still the possibility that the president could try to interrupt or distract Biden while he's on stage. That may not be relayed on television, but they have run through scenarios to ensure that the former vice president can focus on making his case with just 12 days to go until the election.</s>BLITZER: Very interesting. Arlette, stick around. We got more questions for you. I want to bring in Abby Phillip right now and others. Abby, first of all, what's at stake, from your perspective, for the candidates in this, the final debate, tonight?</s>ABBY PHILLIP, CNN WHITE HOUSE CORRESPONDENT: This is the last impression, Wolf. This is the last opportunity all these candidates are going to have to have millions of people tuning in to their closing argument. And President Trump, I think, has a lot more work to do tonight than he -- than Joe Biden, in part because of how the first debate went. It's been about two weeks -- or, I'm sorry, even longer than two weeks, almost a month since the last debate. And the president, in that time, hasn't really done much to change voters' impressions of him in this final stretch. And while a lot of people argue, at this stage, it's not about converting new people, it's about turnout, the president has to make sure he doesn't depress his own potential voters by turning in a very similar performance as the first debate. Meanwhile, I think Joe Biden needs to get pretty specific. He's going to focus on the coronavirus. But one of the pieces of feedback that I think some voters had for him after the debate, the first debate, was, what specifically would you do differently? I think voters need more meat on those bones, especially if it's going to be the bulk of his argument for the presidency.</s>BLITZER: Governor Kasich, what do you expect? Do you expect any significant change in strategy from the president, tonight?</s>JOHN KASICH, CNN SENIOR POLITICAL COMMENTATOR: Well, Wolf, he can't double down on what he did last time. It just turned off too many people, including a lot of those suburban voters who are really critical for him. I do think he will try to really rattle Biden, and probably bring up Biden's family and those kinds of things. In terms of Joe Biden, I have heard what Abby said in terms of specifics and all that. And there's -- I think that that's somewhat right. But what I really think Joe Biden needs to do is, he needs to project strength, you know, that he's in charge, he will do a good job if he's president of the United States, he's not going to let anybody bully him, that he's capable. And I think he did a good job being able to pass the test as to whether he could handle this the last time. But he needs to reemphasize it. And he needs to be pleasant. You know, he's got a way about him that is likability, which he has used effectively. You know, he's not Hillary Clinton, where he can be attacked. And I think don't lose composure, don't try to interrupt, and just do your, because he is ahead right now in all these battleground states. And so that's what I think you will see. He's not going to -- but I think, probably, Donald Trump will probably try to throw some -- maybe some Hail Mary passes, but probably not with the same degree of aggressiveness in the last -- I just don't think that's possible.</s>BLITZER: Yes. Well, we will soon find out. Arlette, the White House, as you know, is hinting that, regardless what the questions are, the president may simply pivot to the attacks he wants to make. How do you expect the former vice president to handle that?</s>SAENZ: Well, that's one of the challenges that Joe Biden faces tonight, not getting bogged down in the direction that President Trump is looking to take this debate. You know, Biden is a meticulous debate preparer. So they have gone through a lot of these scenarios of different directions that the president could take as they face off on that stage tonight. And one tactic that you saw Joe Biden employ in the last debate that he is likely to do again tonight is that when he would stare directly into the camera, speaking to the American people. That was a tactic that his campaign said was very intentional in that first debate. And they really felt that that was -- those were moments where Biden was able to succinctly get his message across with emphasis. And that's something that he likely will turn to tonight, especially as the president tries to take this debate in many different directions.</s>BLITZER: Abby, the president, as we all know, has a long history of attacking women, particularly women of color, specifically journalists out there, and, of course, some politicians. How do you think he will respond to questions from the moderator, Kristen Welker?</s>PHILLIP: Well, the president has already signaled that he is going to go after Kristen Welker as if she is a candidate on that stage, which she is not, and accuse her of bias. And as someone who's worked with her and knows her and knows that she's covered this president fairly for many years, she's not biased. And the president is going to have to figure out how to do that without seeming like he's trying to find a scapegoat. Look, this is the third female reporter in just about a week that the president has decided to attack. He attacked Savannah Guthrie of NBC at the town hall. He attacked Lesley Stahl after that CBS interview. And now he will try to attack Kristen Welker. I think people will see through that. It's a real risk for the president to continue illustrating a pattern that is extremely damaging to him with women and with women who care about how he behaves towards people of color.</s>BLITZER: Yes. He tweeted, earlier in the day Governor Kasich, let me get your response. "Look at the bias, hatred, and rudeness on behalf of '60 Minutes' and CBS. Tonight's anchor, Kristen Welker, is far worse." What do you make of that?</s>KASICH: Well, it's ridiculous. I mean, look, the guy has got to expand his base. I mean, he -- yes, he may be firing up his own people, and they're going to those rallies. And they're doing "YMCA" and all this other stuff. But there's not enough of them. So, I agree completely with Abby when she says this idea that he can just go ahead and attack these women is going is going to somehow pay off for him. It's a turnoff.</s>BLITZER: Yes.</s>KASICH: And it's also mean. And it's very interesting that Billy Graham's granddaughter came out and said we can't support somebody that has this kind of behavior. It's really, really amazing that she did that, a counter to some of the evangelicals. Very interesting.</s>BLITZER: Yes. I know Kristen Welker. She is, first of all, very, very nice. But she is an excellent journalist. Lesley Stahl is as well. So is Savannah Guthrie. It's really sad to see the president of the United States lash out against these journalists. They are excellent journalists, indeed. Everyone, stick around. There is more we need to report on. There's more breaking news we're following. The FDA has just approved remdesivir to treat hospitalized coronavirus patients. It's the first approval for a drug to treat COVID-19 here in the United States. And the news comes as the pandemic is clearly worsening here in the U.S., with more than 1,000 deaths just yesterday. We will be right back.
Interview with Former BARDA Director Dr. Rick Bright
BLITZER: CNN's live coverage of the final debate between President Trump and Joe Biden is just under an hour away. Stand by. We're going to have much more on that in just a moment. But we are also following new developments in the coronavirus pandemic. CNN's Brian Todd is on the story for us. Brian, we are getting word the FDA has just issued its first approval for a coronavirus treatment here in the United States. What can you tell us?</s>BRIAN TODD, CNN CORRESPONDENT: That's right, Wolf. The antiviral drug remdesivir has just been approved by the FDA for the treatment of patients hospitalized with COVID-19, that word coming from Gilead Sciences. It's the first drug in the U.S. to be approved for the use of therapeutic treatment for patients with COVID. A study in the U.S. found that the drug could shorten recovery time for some patients by about a third, but a World Health Organization study does dispute that. Now, this comes as more states are reporting even more cases.</s>GOV. TONY EVERS (D-WI): One thousand, six hundred and eighty-one Wisconsinites have lost the battle against this virus.</s>TODD (voice-over): Coming off his state's highest single-day coronavirus death count, Wisconsin's governor says he's saddened to announce that this facility is taking in its first patients, a field hospital for overflow patients at a state fair park near Milwaukee.</s>EVERS: Make no mistake about this. This is an urgent crisis.</s>TODD: The surge in cases in Wisconsin is overwhelming health officials in the state's second most populous county.</s>JANEL HEINRICH, DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC HEALTH, MADISON AND DANE COUNTIES, WISCONSIN: Right now, we cannot keep up. With the sustained rise in cases, we cannot quickly contact trace cases and let the people they came in contact with know that they should quarantine. We are struggling with the constant and unending rise in cases, just as everyone else in the state is.</s>TODD: Wisconsin is one of 31 states where the reporting of new daily coronavirus cases is still going up. Only one state, Hawaii, has cases on the decline. Hospitalizations are on the rise, with around 40,000 reported across the U.S. on Wednesday. And deaths are climbing. Yesterday, with more than 1,100, America reported its highest number of deaths in one day in more than a month.</s>DR. ROCHELLE WALENSKY, CNN MEDICAL ANALYST: We're gathering inside and doing more to promote these numbers, and it's only October. It really worries me to think about where we are going to be in December and January in this country.</s>TODD: This comes as an ally of President Trump's, former New Jersey Governor Chris Christie, issued a sobering admission. In an op-ed in "The Wall Street Journal," Christie, who spent a week in the ICU after contracting COVID, wrote that he let his guard down when he helped the president with debate prep and attended the Amy Coney Barrett nomination ceremony at the White House, without wearing a mask either time. Quote: "Wear it or you may regret it, as I did." Meantime, a team of disaster preparedness experts at Columbia university is skewering President Trump in a new report, which says the administration's uneven response to the pandemic has led to between 130,000 and 210,000 deaths which could have been prevented.</s>JEFFREY SACHS, COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY: The president never took this seriously, from the first day, lied repeatedly, to the public, acted as if something as straightforward as wearing a face mask was some act of betrayal, and never communicated honestly or with the information being provided by our wonderful, knowledgeable public health community in this country.</s>TODD: Jeffrey Sachs of Columbia University also accuses the president of -- quote -- "beating down" the Centers for Disease Control, having what he calls political hacks oversee the CDC and preventing the professionals at the agency from speaking freely. The president, of course, has always defended his handling of the pandemic, saying recently that, with the treatments his administration has advanced, they have actually been able to reduce, in his mind, the fatality rate since April. And he said recently that the country is -- quote -- "turning a corner" -- Wolf.</s>BLITZER: Ryan Todd reporting for us, thank you very much. I want to bring in a top vaccine expert who resigned from the federal government back on October 6, several months after filing a whistle- blower complaint accusing the Trump administration of mishandling the coronavirus pandemic from the very start. Rick Bright is joining us right now. Director Bright, thank you so much for joining us. Thanks for all your critically important work over the years as well. As you know, this new study from the World Health Organization that came out earlier this month found remdesivir did not help patients survive coronavirus. But the Trump administration is now pointing to its approval to treat hospitalized patients as potentially great news. Are you encouraged by this development? Specifically, where do you stand on remdesivir as an approved treatment in hospitals for coronavirus patients?</s>DR. RICK BRIGHT, FORMER DIRECTOR, BIOMEDICAL ADVANCED RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY: Well, Wolf, thanks for having me on. I mean, the FDA clearly has reviewed all of the data that they have available to them from the company to review the efficacy and safety of that drug, for the approval of that drug now for hospitalized patients. It's important to note that even the data that we saw in the United States from that drug show that the benefit was modest. It wasn't a home run. It wasn't a remarkable improvement in terms of mortality or even the lengthening or shortening the length of the hospital stay. But it did show marginal benefit. And that is all the data probably the FDA has. So, it's not too surprising that another, perhaps even larger, well-controlled study from the WHO would refute that database that we have on remdesivir, again, probably showing that this marginal benefit probably becomes even more marginal depending on the population of people that uses that drugs or gets that drug. So, when you have rather weak data, it can still be beneficial in some people, but some studies are also going to show that it's probably not too beneficial at all.</s>BLITZER: Well, let's hope it is. You have said, Director, that President Trump's failure to tell the truth about this virus has allowed more Americans to die. There is a new report from a team of disaster preparedness experts at Columbia University that certainly supports your assertion. They are suggesting that between 130,000 to 210,000 deaths could have been prevented here in the U.S. if the Trump administration had responded sufficiently. What do you say to that?</s>BRIGHT: I think they're spot on, Wolf. It's really important to know that we have not had leadership through this pandemic from day one. There has been no plan, and there is still no national plan on how we will end this pandemic. The only plan and strategy that I have seen from President Trump...</s>BLITZER: I think we have just lost our connection with Director Bright. We will see if we can fix that. But we will get back to him. He's got some important things to say. In the meantime, let's take a quick break. Just ahead, we will have much more on tonight's crucial final debate between President Trump and Joe Biden. I'll discuss that and more with the Democratic governor of Michigan, Gretchen Whitmer. She is standing by live. We have lots to talk about. We will when we come back.
Gov. Gretchen Whitmer (D-MI) Reacts to Kidnapping Plot
BLITZER: We are closing in on tonight's crucial, final debate between President Trump and Joe Biden. In a sudden last-minute development, the debate commission is now removing plexiglass barriers that were supposed to separate the two candidates on the stage. We haven't been given any explanation for that decision. But we'll get one, at some point. In the meantime, let's continue the discussion with the Governor of Michigan, Gretchen Whitmer. Governor, thank you so much for joining us. I know you have a lot going on, and I want to discuss tonight's debate with you. But, first, as you well know better than anyone, 14 people in your state have now been charged in a plot to kidnap you. How are you and your family doing in the wake of this truly scary, awful threat?</s>GOV. GRETCHEN WHITMER (D-MI): Well, I mean, challenging doesn't quite describe it. But we are fine. And the Michigan State police keep us safe, and we've never had an ounce of worry about our personal safety. But I do think in this moment, it's really important that we have leaders who denounce this kind of radical, violent planning and the rhetoric that feeds it. I think it's critical that we have leaders that can bring this county together and fight COVID and get us back on track. And that's what I am looking forward to in tonight's debate. I believe Joe Biden will show America that he has got the temperament and the character and the empathy to lead our nation out of these really tough times.</s>BLITZER: You know, what is really, really sad and very awful, I must say, the president has publicly called you a dictator. He previously tweeted that he wanted your state liberated. Liberate Michigan, he tweeted. Do you believe these very serious threats against you, that you faced, 14 people have now been arrested, do you believe they were a result at least in part of the president's very divisive, angry rhetoric toward you?</s>WHITMER: Well, listen, Wolf. I can tell you that, since April, every time that the president identifies me or my state, we see an increase in terms of the threats, in terms of the online hate that is sent my way, in terms of death threats against me and my family. This is a moment where we, as a nation, have seen the character of two people that are vying to be our leader. The things that we have seen, over the course of the last eight months, whether it is directed at me or directed at Dr. Fauci or some of the incredible, public health experts across this country, who have taken so much heat because of this kind of rhetoric that you just described, it is wrong. It's dangerous. It's unacceptable. And people of goodwill on both sides of the aisle need to come together and -- and demand better from our government and hold one another accountable and set a higher standard in this nation.</s>BLITZER: Yes. What's so sad is that Dr. Fauci needs to walk around, now, he and his family, protected by federal law enforcement security agents at a time when, for decades, he's been saving American lives. And now, he needs that kind of protection. As you well know, you're a supporter of the former vice president. We're about to watch this debate. The final square off before this election is over in, what, 12 days. You're supporting Biden. He's heading in tonight's debate with a lead in your critical battleground state of Michigan. Let me put some of the numbers from the most recent polling up there. What does the former vice president need to do tonight to make sure it stays that way right now in this poll of polls as we have at CNN? Biden is at 51 percent. Trump is at 43percent.</s>WHITMER: So, first, I'll just acknowledge, I think the race is always tighter than what the polls lead us to believe. And I think Joe Biden and Kamala Harris believe that as well. And that's why they're spending so much time in states all across the country. But certainly, they're spending a lot of time here in Michigan. I think Joe Biden needs to be Joe Biden. He is a deeply decent human being who cares about his fellow Americans, who will bring us together in a way that we've been so split apart. I worry about after this election. Of course, Joe Biden's plan around COVID and reengaging our economy is critical. But he is also a unique person, who I think can bring us together as a country because the rhetoric that has been feeding so much hate over the last four years will have long-term consequences. And I know that Joe Biden gets it. And when he shows up and he is himself, people love him. People believe in him. They trust him and they know that he is the kind of leader we need right now.</s>BLITZER: The Biden campaign says it fully anticipated that the president will personally attack Joe Biden's son, Hunter Biden, tonight, going after the family. How would you like to see the former vice president respond to those attacks?</s>WHITMER: Like a dad, you know? I am a mom. If someone attacked my child, I -- you know, I would have a strong reaction, but it would be out of love. And I think that people see that when Joe Biden talks about his family. He is a family man. He is a true American leader who sees the humanity in others. He doesn't think he's better than anyone else. He respects people and wants the best for everyone. And I think that when President Trump attacks him for his son, I think it will backfire because parents everywhere see the genuine concern of a parent. And anyone who has a loved one who's had addiction issues, which is the vast majority of us, including me, knows that it is support and it is love that helps keep families together and supports our dear ones.</s>BLITZER: Yes. So we're going to see how far this unfolds in the next few hours. Unlike in the previous debate, Governor, as you know, the candidates' microphones will be muted during portions of tonight's event in order to not let them interrupt each other during their two-minute opening statements on new subjects. Do you hope this will lead to a more productive debate? What are you bracing for?</s>WHITMER: I hope so. That first debate was just horrendous, the way that the president overtalked and it was hard to understand what the candidates were saying because of the president's continuous talking. And so I am glad that they will be muting mics. I was trying to think what should they use, an air horn? But muting is better because it will give the person who is talking the ability to be heard. That's what American people want and that's what we deserve. We should know what the candidates are responding, not watch one person try to dominate another and be a bully on stage. So, I do think that this will be good thing. I'll be looking forward to this debate and I'm glad we're here. I just want them to be safe. And I've got the same questions you have about what is happening with those partitions coming down.</s>BLITZER: Yes. At least 70 million, 80 million, maybe 90 million Americans are going to be watching this debate. So there is really a lot at stake and we will see why they decided to bring down the plexiglass. All right, Governor, good luck to you. Stay safe out there. We'll stay in close touch with you. I appreciate it very much.</s>WHITMER: Thank you, Wolf.</s>BLITZER: Just ahead, there is more breaking news we are following. The federal government is fighting back against election interference by Iranian entities with brand new sanctions. We have new information just coming into The Situation Room.
Both Campaigns Consulted with Fauci to Remove Plexiglass
BLITZER: As we await the start of the final presidential debate, we are learning new information right now about pandemic precautions up on the stage. Let's go back to our Chief White House Correspondent Jim Acosta. He is inside the auditorium there. Jim, so what are you hearing, what are you hearing from your sources?</s>JIM ACOSTA, CNN CHIEF WHITE HOUSE CORRESPONDENT: Wolf, as we were telling you earlier this hour, the plexiglass dividers that we were expecting to be on stage for this debate tonight were removed. There were, in fact, two dividers between where President Trump and Vice President Biden would be standing. But we understand that both campaigns consulted with Dr. Anthony Fauci, yes, Dr. Anthony Fauci, about whether or not it was necessary to have the dividers there. Dr. Fauci said, no, because both candidates tested negative for the virus, that those dividers were not going to be necessary tonight. And this is a fairly late-breaking development, Wolf. I am told by a source who is involved in the situation that these conversations took place this afternoon. And so it just goes to show you things can change minute by minute as these debates get closer, Wolf.</s>BLITZER: I take it there's going to be a limited socially distanced audience there. Can you set the scene a little bit for us, Jim?</s>ACOSTA: That's right, a limited audience here, as we have seen at other debates involved in this campaign. And one thing we should point out, Wolf, and I am wearing one of these wristbands as well, everybody who is going to be coming into the debate hall, they were tested for the coronavirus. There are lines coming into this debate hall, where you have to stand and be tested for your temperature to make sure you're not running a fever before coming inside this debate hall. So, lots of precautions besides just these dividers that were removed to make sure that people are staying safe. But it is fascinating to see Dr. Anthony Fauci. He's been involved in so much throughout this entire pandemic, even when it comes to a presidential debate, the experts, the campaigns consult with Dr. Anthony Fauci even on something like a presidential debate, Wolf.</s>BLITZER: And all the guests that were invited by the president and the former vice president for that matter, they have to be inside wearing masks, all the time, is that right?</s>ACOSTA: That is our understanding, Wolf. And, of course, this was an issue during the last debate. There were some people who were not wearing masks, while others were. We understand that is going to be a requirement this evening. I can tell you, right now, I'm not wearing a mask when I'm doing a live shot. But as soon as my live shot is over, I put my mask back on. But you can see, as we're seeing, some of the crew people who are down close to the stage, they're wearing their masks. And so, it is expected everybody's going to be on board with this, later on this evening. But, of course, we're going to have to wait to find out to see exactly how it plays out. As we know, Wolf, not every -- not every candidate and certainly not both sides of this campaign are fully onboard with wearing masks. And so, you might see some people inside the Trump campaign, Trump advisers, friends of the president, and so on, who may not be wearing masks. That is something we will be looking out for, obviously, as the night develops. But so far, you know, that has been mentioned to us and stressed to us, urged to us, over and over again by debate officials. People who are onsite at Belmont University in Nashville, they want everybody to stay safe, wear a mask, socially distance. We see evidence of that, everywhere you go. Everywhere you go, there are markers on sidewalks saying please, stay six feet apart. There are plexiglass, dividers in the dining hall where people are dining this evening before this debate gets started. So, I mean, this is a pandemic debate, no question about it. And perhaps, the biggest evidence of that is that Dr. Anthony Fauci has been involved in the planning of tonight's debate as well, Wolf.</s>BLITZER: Yes, who would have thought? All right. Jim Acosta on the scene for us. Put the mask on now.</s>ACOSTA: Yes.</s>BLITZER: We'll be in touch with you throughout the night, of course. Just ahead, we are going to take a closer look at the key battleground states and the battle to win enough Electoral College votes to claim victory. Plus, as we count down to this, the final presidential debate. What President Trump and former Vice President Joe Biden need to do, tonight, to win over those undecided voters. We'll be right back.
Soon: Final Face-Off between Trump, Biden; W.H.: Trump May Disregard Some Questions and Attack Biden's Record on China; New: Lecterns are 12 Plus Feet Apart, First Question will go to Trump; FDA Approves Remdesivir To Treat Hospitalized COVID-19 Patients
WOLF BLITZER, CNN HOST: Welcome to our viewers here in the United States and around the world. I'm Wolf Blitzer in the Situation Room, we're following breaking news. We're just hours away from the final debate between President Trump and former Vice President Joe Biden, the most critical moment yet with just 12 days left in the race for the White House. Tonight, we'll break down what's at stake for both candidates and what we're expecting to see on stage. We're also tracking the very critical path the 270 electoral votes with five key battleground states front and center right now, Florida, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, Michigan, and Arizona. As of now, more than 46 million Americans have already voted. Their votes have been cast nationwide. All of this as the coronavirus pandemic is sadly surging once again. The U.S. death till now topic 222,000 Americans with more than 8.3 million cases. More than 1,100 Americans died of COVID-19 just yesterday. And we've just learned that the FDA has approved the drug Remdesivir to treat hospitalized COVID-19 patients making it the first to approved COVID treatment in the U.S. Lots going on. Let's start our coverage up with the scene of tonight's debate. CNN's Chief White House Correspondent Jim Acosta is in Nashville for us. Jim, we're learning that the President was actually tested for the coronavirus on his way there.</s>JIM ACOSTA, CNN CHIEF WHITE HOUSE CORRESPONDENT: That's right, Wolf, President Trump was tested onboard Air Force One as he was enroute to Nashville. White House officials say he tested negative for the coronavirus just hours before his final debate with Joe Biden. The President, in the meantime appears to be doing more complaining about the debate than he is preparing for one. The President is also claiming he's created the greatest economy in U.S. history. But that's not true. As the U.S. is in the grips of the worst recession in decades. Mr. Trump is blaming it all on the virus clip, complaining the media only wants to talk about COVID-19 as the death toll from the pandemic keeps climbing.</s>ACOSTA (voice-over): Joined by the First Lady, President Trump left for his final debate with democrat Joe Biden sounding combative as ever arguing in an interview with "60 Minutes" that he's created the best economy in U.S. history. Even as the nation is still reeling from the pandemic.</s>DONALD TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: We created the greatest economy in the history of our country and the other side was coming in -</s>LESLEY STAHL, CBS HOST, "60 MINUTES": You know that's not true.</s>TRUMP: It is totally true.</s>STAHL: No.</s>ACOSTA: Aides say the President hasn't done much preparation for his face off with Biden. But Mr. Trump complained to Sinclair television about a new rule put in place to mute the microphones at times during the debate.</s>JOE BIDEN (D), PRESIDENTIAL NOMINEE: Would you shut up man.</s>ACOSTA: To avoid a repeat of the constant interruptions during their last encounter?</s>TRUMP: That's not fair. Plus, they change the topics which isn't fair, just happened.</s>ACOSTA: White House officials say the President may simply disregard some questions at the debate and attack Biden's record on China even though that might resurrect a recent revelation in the "New York Times" that Mr. Trump has had a secret Chinese bank account.</s>ALYSSA FARAH, WHITE HOUSE COMMUNICATIONS DIRECTOR: I'd say he's going to answer those topics, but he's also going to frankly answer the questions he wants to. If we don't get to China, he's prepared to bring up China and Joe Biden's disastrous record on it.</s>ACOSTA: President is also ranting about media coverage of the Coronavirus, claiming it's yet another conspiracy against him. All you hear is COVID, COVID, COVID, COVID, COVID, COVID, COVID, COVID, COVID, COVID, COVID. That's all they put on because they want to scare the hell out of everyone.</s>ACOSTA: Former President Barack Obama, who's campaigning for Biden, as he has been doing debate prep this week, said Mr. Trump isn't capable of ending the pandemic.</s>BARACK OBAMA, FORMER PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: Donald Trump isn't suddenly going to protect all of us. He can't even take the basic steps to protect himself.</s>ACOSTA: During his own "60 Minutes" interview, Biden answered a nagging question about whether he would seek to expand the Supreme Court promising to create a commission to study the issue.</s>BIDEN: Bipartisan commission of scholars, constitutional scholars, Democrats, Republicans, liberal conservative, and I will ask them to over 180 days come back to me with recommendations as to how to reform the court system because it's getting out of whack the way which is being handled. And it's not about court packing.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: Foreign interference in our elections.</s>ACOSTA: Democrats are also raising questions about a warning from the Director of National Intelligence who said Iran is trying to interfere in the election to damage the President's chances.</s>REP. NANCY PELOSI (D-CA): I think we have to be very careful about any statements coming out about the election for the Intelligence Community at this time.</s>ACOSTA: The top two lawmakers on the Senate Intelligence Committee released a statement cautioning "To the American people and the media, we reiterate the need to be skeptical of sensationalist last minute claims about election infrastructure." National Security Adviser Robert O'Brien said the foreign interference efforts detected so far appear limited in scope.</s>ROBERT O'BRIEN, WHITE HOUSE NATIONAL ADVISOR: A very small number two or three across -- in different parts of the United States.</s>ACOSTA: And the President is signaling he will be leveling more personal attacks at Joe Biden and his family, something the Biden campaign says it is ready for an ace to the President, are hoping he will interrupt Biden last during tonight's debate, not only because that turned off voters who thought Biden won the debate last time around but also because Trump advisors are desperate for the former vice president to have some kind of gaffe that will shake up this race. As we know, Wolf, the President is running out of time for some kind of big change to the dynamic of this race. Wolf.</s>BLITZER: Yes, only 12 days to go. Jim Acosta in Nashville for us. We'll get back to you. Let's get some more on all that's going on. The former presidential advisor and CNN Senior Political Analyst David Gergen is with us. Our Chief Political Correspondent, Dana Bash is with us. And our special correspondent, Jamie Gangel is with us as well. Dana, this is the final debate, what's at stake from your perspective for the candidates tonight?</s>DANA BASH, CNN CHIEF POLITICAL CORRESPONDENT: A lot. A lot. Because look, we are in the final stretch. And yes, we have seen, you know, 10s of millions of people already voting. So, for them, this debate won't matter. But there are still 10s of millions, if not more of people, probably just 10s of millions, who have yet to vote. And this could matter to the very, very slim sector of the electorate that has not decided. Now, we don't know if those people have not decided who they're going to vote for or at this point, whether they're going to vote at all. But regardless, a debate like these matters. And all we need to do is look at the negative effect that the first debate had in not just public polls, I'm told, internal polls from the President and also down ballot Republicans, a very negative effect. And so that is why the stakes are so high for both the President and the former vice president tonight. Will it dramatically change the shape of the race? Maybe not. But that's not where we are right now. We are at a place where the margins matter. That's why tonight is going to be so critical.</s>BLITZER: And 10s of millions and many 10s of millions of Americans will be watching. You know, David, the White House is hinting that regardless of what questions are actually asked by the moderator, the President may simply pivot to the attacks he wants to make not necessarily even answering the questions, but just make points he wants to make attacking Joe Biden. So, are you expecting any real change in strategy, as far as the President is concerned from the previous debate?</s>DAVID GERGEN, CNN SENIOR POLITICAL ANALYST: Well, so far, I haven't been able to figure out what their strategy has been. It's hard to know what they're going to change from. The -- but I have to say, I think that Dana is absolutely right, this is a critical moment. They are coming down the homestretch. And Biden is about two links ahead. And unless, you know, Donald Trump can find some way to turn this around, I think he's going to stay pretty close to that. The -- and one of the things that's really striking to me, Wolf, is I think it's best -- I think it's fair to say that President Trump has had more airtime than any other candidate in history coming out of the White House. Just all the times he's been in the rallies and everything else, with the sickness and everything and on all the crises human face, he's had a huge amount of airtime. And yet over 14 rallies, he still has not had gotten that message across the American people about what his next term would be like. And they're not rallying to him in the way they did in -- when he first was elected.</s>BLITZER: Yes, so much at stake tonight. You know, Jamie, the President's reaction to Lesley Stahl of "60 Minutes," I suspect it provides some clues about how he's going to handle questions from another woman tonight, the moderator, Kristen Welker, both, both of them are excellent, solid, very respected journalists.</s>JAMIE GANGEL, CNN SPECIAL CORRESPONDENT: Absolutely. And as we like to say, Wolf, there is a tweet for everything. With Donald Trump, and sure enough, this morning he tweeted a "Look at the bias, hatred and rudeness on behalf of "60 Minutes" and CBS. Tonight's anchor, Kristen Welker, is far worse." So, you know, Donald Trump is sometimes very transparent. I think that sets the stage. I think also, Wolf, when you see a tweet like that, you have to remember, that's what sends those down ballot Republicans that Dana was talking about. It sends them running for cover. A senior Republican said to me that between remarks like that attacking women, and his attacks on Dr. Fauci, the strategy that David was looking for is just politically insane. It makes no sense at all, Wolff.</s>BLITZER: You're absolutely right. Dana, you want to make a point?</s>BASH: Yes. The point is that this is -- not only is it completely inappropriate, it's false. Kristen Welker -- I don't know Lesley Stahl, but obviously I've respected her for many years, I do know Kristen Welker and she is a Class A journalist straight down the middle as a reporter at conscientious human being. And the fact that the President is trying to kind of work the ref and rattle her, bully her, frankly, it is ridiculous on its face. But it's also really, as Jamie was saying, really bad politics. I've not talked to any of the President's advisors who say, this is a great idea. Why don't you go after a woman of color who's going to be sitting in a very prominent role tonight while you have a huge gender gap right now? It makes absolutely no sense. And it's Exhibit A of his lack of impulse control.</s>BLITZER: Yes, it's really, really sad to hear that. David, you want to make a point?</s>GERGEN: Yes, I do. Yes, we talk a lot about how much that means to Trump. It also means a great deal to Joe Biden tonight. You know, he has to lead. But he needs to hold on to it, he needs to solidify it. And if anything, Wolf, if he can extend his lead a little bit, he would be so much better off after election. With a big margin of big victory, he'll have much more power and authority to get things done. So he has a lot at stake in this too.</s>BLITZER: They both have a lot at stake. You know, Jamie, we just got some details from the presidential debate condition, the candidates will be exactly 12 feet eight inches apart on the stage. The President will be getting the first question. How do you think that potentially could shape the debate?</s>GANGEL: So one of the things we've heard about is the mute button. And I think the thing that is important to remember is, the audience at home may not hear if Donald Trump interrupts or tries to speak while Joe Biden is speaking. But former Vice President Biden will be able likely to hear that on the stage. And our understanding is that in preparing for tonight, one of the big things that they've worked on is don't get distracted by that man who is 12 feet and eight inches away from him. The other thing I think is worth mentioning is, you know, there's been -- we've heard a lot about the advice that aides have been giving Donald Trump. At the end of the day, there's one thing that we've seen in the last four years, Donald Trump trusts his own instincts for better or for worse. And he didn't think he was going to win in 2016. One of his aides said to me, and he can't quite believe he's not going to win in 2020 despite the polls. So, I think tonight, maybe we'll see a little self-deprecating humor, maybe a moment of discipline. But I think it's a real question, how long that lasts, Wolf.</s>BLITZER: Yes, that's an important point as well. You know, Dana, the -- Joe Biden has actually been off the campaign trail for, what, the last three or four or five days basically preparing for the debate tonight. What does that say about how he views the stakes in this final debate? Because he's largely been, yesterday, we saw the former president out there on the campaign trail, delivering a very powerful 35-minute speech in his favor, but he's sort of been invisible these last several days.</s>BASH: That's right. He's been hunkered down. He has been doing a lot of debate prep, some interviews, but mostly debate prep. And, you know, it's -- the Republicans, particularly people who are close to Trumper are throwing him some shade saying, you know, what's he doing, he's making the same mistake that Hillary Clinton may have made and going off the trail instead of going to some of those key battleground states that she ended up losing by just, you know, a handful of votes, you know, metaphorically speaking. But having said that, he is taking it seriously. He understands the stakes. Jamie mentioned part of this, I was told that what he's been doing is he's been in his house in Wilmington, doing prep with his advisors. But there have been times where the veteran democratic lawyer Bob Bauer, who plays Donald Trump, in his debate, prep just goes after the former vice president, interrupts him constantly, incessantly in order to get him prepared for what Jamie just described, which is, you might not be able to hear Donald Trump's microphone if you're in the audience. But if you're Joe Biden standing 12 feet away, you certainly can. So he's trying to practice not getting rattled if Donald Trump, even a little bit act like it did in the first debate.</s>BLITZER: Yes. All right, guys, everybody standby. There's a lot more we're following. We're going to take a quick break. But up next, we're going to go back to Nashville and talk about tonight's high stakes contest with the mayor of Atlanta, there you see her, Keisha Lance Bottoms. She's there. And later this hour, I'll go one on one with the White House Chief of Staff, Mark Meadows. He's standing by live as well. Lots going on. We'll be right back.
U.S. Coronavirus Death Toll Tops 222,000 And 8.3 Million Cases With More Than 1,000 Deaths Just In The Last Day; Feds: Russian State Sponsored Hackers Successfully Stole Data From State & Local Govts No Indication Election Systems Compromised.
BLITZER: All eyes are on tonight's final presidential debate. Our special coverage continues here in "The Situation Room". But first, there's breaking pandemic news we're also following. The FDA has just approved the drug remdesivir to treat hospitalized coronavirus patients, making it the first approved COVID-19 treatment in the United States, that comes as the U.S. death toll now tops 222,000 people with more than 8.3 million confirmed coronavirus cases. More than 1,100 Americans died of COVID-19 just yesterday. Our National Correspondent Erica Hill has more.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: It seems like every day the numbers keep increasing.</s>ERICA HILL, CNN NATIONAL CORRESPONDENT (voice-over): It's not just an increase at this El Paso funeral home. The average daily number of COVID-related deaths is rising in half the states across the country. 1,124 reported nationwide on Wednesday. The first-time deaths have topped 1,000 in more than a month.</s>DR. ALI KHAN, DEAN, UNIVERSITY OF NEBRASKA MEDICAL CENTER COLLEGE OF PUBLIC HEALTH: There's a whole lot of people who are dead in America that completely preventable would not have been dead if we had use science and good public health tools.</s>HILL (voice-over): That's the findings from a new Columbia University study, which faults the administration's anemic response for as many as 210,000 COVID deaths. And experts warn there is more pain ahead.</s>UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: We don't just have one or two hotspots. We actually have virus hotspots surging all across the country.</s>HILL (voice-over): New cases rising in 31 states. Only Hawaii showing a meaningful decline. North Dakota which continues to have more cases per capita than any other state just suspended contact tracing because it can't keep up. This overflow hospital in Wisconsin now treating its first COVID patient.</s>GOV. TONY EVERS (D), WISCONSIN: Make no mistake about this. This is an urgent crisis.</s>HILL (voice-over): Florida just reported its highest daily case count since mid-August. Ohio repeatedly shattering its own records.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: It does not seem like we're even starting to get to a plateau.</s>HILL (voice-over): Several states reporting record numbers of COVID- related hospitalizations, including New Jersey. But the former Governor Chris Christie is now urging Americans to mask up in a new op-ed admitting he was wrong not to wear one when prepping President Trump for the first debate. Christie decries the polarization of masks, writing, "It's not a partisan or cultural symbol, not a sign of weakness or virtue". Calling out the politics, but not the man who led that charge.</s>DR. ZEKE EMANUEL, FORMER WHITE HOUSE HEALTH POLICY ADVISER: We have a President who'd made fun of wearing masks, who didn't let the scientists run this process and the task force. And that has been the problem.</s>HILL (voice-over): And just one more note on El Paso, for the second time in 10 days, Texas Governor Greg Abbott has announced he is sending additional medical personnel and equipment to help deal with the surge in cases El Paso County today, reporting a record daily high for new cases. They're just 18 ICU beds available in the area, Wolf.</s>BLITZER: That's also heartbreaking indeed. Erica Hill in New York for us, thank you very much. Joining us now to talk about this and a whole lot more, including tonight's debate is the White House Chief of Staff Mark Meadows. Mark, thank you so much for joining us. I know you're there in Nashville at the debate hall. We're going to get to that in just a few moments. But let's talk about this pandemic first. The President keeps saying that we're, quote, rounding the corner, but you look at -- you just heard the numbers. Just yesterday, there were more than 60,000 new confirmed coronavirus infections and more than 1,100 deaths just in one day. Just yesterday, only one state's case numbers right now we're heading in the right direction. And as you can also see, we'll show our viewers, hospitalizations are also on the rise as well. So, how can the President say we're rounding the corner when all of these indicators are showing we're potentially, and I hope it's not going to happen, entering a very dangerous new surge?</s>MARK MEADOWS, WHITE HOUSE CHIEF OF STAFF: Well, hopefully we're not entering a dangerous new surge. But I think it's three different things. You lead out the segment, Wolf, with a great announcement from the FDA approving remdesivir for those that are hospitalized. Hopefully, we'll have some of the therapeutics that the President was able to actually use in and have available to him at Walter Reed under Emergency Use Authorization for those that are not hospitalized is a therapeutic going in. And then as we look to the vaccine development that hopefully is more like weeks away then months away, those are all good news. But I think when we look at this, where we know that we're entering into the fall, we have additional cases rising. Part of that is due to a very robust testing regimen that we have. I know that we've provided over 150 million tests, trying to make sure that tests are available to everybody. And when you test more, you're going to get more cases, the hospitalization -- you hit a key point, what we want to make sure of is that hospital facilities are not overrun. And if they're going into an additional area, the President stands ready, along with FEMA to make sure that we can provide emergency provisions there. But when we look at it, we're seeing and comparing us to Europe and to a number of other nations right now. You know, the picture there is more bleak than it is here in the United States. So, as we start to look it, I do believe we're rounding the corner, mainly because we know how to deal with this virus. We know also, hopefully, how to keep the contagion down. And we're going to be all hands-on deck until we get that done.</s>BLITZER: We certainly hope the therapeutics are going to slow these -- the deaths certainly down. We certainly hope we're rounding the corner.</s>MEADOWS: Right.</s>BLITZER: But it's so depressing when we see these numbers. These are real people, mothers and fathers, sons and daughters, brothers and sisters. It's so sad to see what's going on. I don't know if you saw this study, Mark.</s>MEADOWS: It is.</s>BLITZER: That --</s>MEADOWS: You know, and I -- no, I didn't, I didn't see this study.</s>BLITZER: There's a study from Columbia University.</s>MEADOWS: Yes, I saw you reference it, yes.</s>BLITZER: It found that anywhere from 130,000 to 210,000 lives potentially could have been saved over these past eight, nine, 10 months with a more robust federal response. So, why did the President say, you know, just this week, when he was asked what he would have done differently, he said not much?</s>MEADOWS: Well, I can tell you that if your study says that they can save 210,000 lives, I haven't read it, but it would be very, very difficult to imagine that scenario. So they're saying that 98 percent of the deaths that have occurred today could have been saved, just by taking different action. I don't know that any scientist or any doctor would agree with that particular analysis. Again, I haven't read the study. I'll be glad to do that tonight. As you're breaking that news here. But I think probably the bigger thing that we look at, Wolf, is that we have got to figure a way that not only we can keep our government, our households, our schools open, but we can do it in a safe way. And that's what the President has not only encouraged us to do but demanded us to do. And yet, sometimes we see what we have here is a clock that keeps talking about the number of cases that we have, that really doesn't talk about the advances that we need to make on the therapeutics, vaccines and treatments side of things.</s>BLITZER: We only hope those will work. We would appreciate -- tell the President we would also appreciate if he would say what the former New Jersey Governor Chris Christie said today and he had COVID too, as you know, wear a mask. I don't think this is a political statement or anything.</s>MEADOWS: And the President --</s>BLITZER: Just go ahead and do it. And don't have these rallies where people are just so close together, not wearing masks, it's potentially a super spreader. It's so dangerous. You know that Mark?</s>MEADOWS: Well, with all due respect, the President has talked about wearing masks, they do pass out the mask. But here's the other thing --</s>BLITZER: But he should be an example. He should be an example.</s>MEADOWS: Hold on, hold on. Let me -- Wolf, let me finish my statement and then you can -- we'll go back and forth. Here's the other thing that we need to make sure of. You know, we've got CNN reporters, other reporters that wear masks religiously, and yet they're coming down with this. They're actually -- so the mask is not the panacea to make sure that this doesn't spread. Will it help in confined spaces? Certainly, it helps. I've got my mask. I've had it on. It'll go back on here in just a second.</s>BLITZER: Good.</s>MEADOWS: The minute that I finished speaking to you. But at the same time is we need to make sure that we do follow the science, the President's encouraging us to do that. I encourage all Americans to do that. But we also need to understand that wearing a mask, if we could say we mandate mask and everybody can go back to work, then that would be something to consider. But even the doctors, even the most -- even Dr. Fauci would say that that is not something that would protect all Americans.</s>BLITZER: No, but he does say wear a mask. That's -- and do engage in social distancing. That is so, so critical. Let's talk about the debate. You're in Nashville right now. The President has said --</s>MEADOWS: Sure.</s>BLITZER: -- he may actually change his strategy tonight and interrupt Joe Biden less. So will we actually see a shift from him on the stage tonight during those 90 minutes?</s>MEADOWS: Yes, I don't know that the President has said exactly what you said. I think those are other people talking about what the President said. But certainly, as he is prepped and gotten ready for this debate, looking at the way that he interacts with Joe Biden, hopefully Joe Biden won't interrupt him. I can also say that he wants to take the case to the American people. He's got accomplishments to do that. The contrast tonight will be the accomplishments of President Donald J. Trump versus the rhetoric of Vice President Biden. And so, if we're going to compare record to record, we welcome that challenge.</s>BLITZER: Earlier today, your White House Director of Strategic Communications, Alyssa Farah, said that the President will, quote, answer the questions he wants to answer. So, what is that been, Mark, will he answer the moderator's questions? Or does he plan to bring up the issues he wants to discuss?</s>MEADOWS: Well, I think he plans to -- in fact, I know he plans to answer the moderator's question and continue to answer those questions. Hopefully, the moderator will bring up questions that a lot of people want to know about, want to hear about. You know, for example, some of the late breaking news that has come up with regards to potential corruption with Joe Biden. I think that's a valid question that the American voting populace would want to know out. I'm not sure that the question will get asked, but hopefully, if not, the President will give Joe a chance to answer that.</s>BLITZER: I'm sure the former Vice President will have some questions he wants to ask of the President as well. Some members of the Trump and Pence families as you know, Mark, did not follow the debate Commission's rule to wear a mask throughout the previous presidential and vice-presidential debates for that matter. Can you assure us that you and the others will certainly wear mask this time, because as we all know, it's so important?</s>MEADOWS: Yes. We've all been tested. I've actually already been over at the debate hall behind us to look at the venue wearing a mask, they're wearing inside. It's mandatory, that's part of the rules this time. Was not mandatory last time, I want to stress that, Wolf. And so, as we look at that, it's mandatory for anyone in the audience to wear a mask. And so, we'll comply with that. And I've already been over there, full mask in tow, and we'll have those discussions. But really, this is not about mask, it's not about really even a debate, it's really about a vision for America and who's willing to lead us for the next four years. And most Americans believe that they're better off today, in spite of the pandemic, knowing that this pandemic was not the fault of President Donald J. Trump. They're still better off than they were four or eight years ago, under a Bide-Obama administration.</s>BLITZER: Yes. I will point out that nearly 800,000 Americans just last week, according to the Department of Labor, had to file initial first- time unemployment benefits. So, those 800,000 are now unemployed Americans joining the millions of others who are unemployed.</s>MEADOWS: I agree.</s>BLITZER: They're certainly not better off than they were four years ago when they had jobs.</s>MEADOWS: I agree. And so, here's something that you and I can agree on, Wolf. We're going to call, you and I together, are going to call on Speaker Pelosi right now to get real about negotiations. We've come up four different times in terms of stimulus, Wolf, and Nancy Pelosi continues to say no, to a yes answer, which she'll give us something --</s>BLITZER: Where does it stand -- where does -- this is -- I agree with you. This is so critical right now.</s>MEADOWS: I know you do.</s>BLITZER: Millions of Americans are suffering right now. They need help, small business owners in North Carolina, your home state all over the country. So, where does it stand? I know you and the Treasury Secretary, Steve Mnuchin, have been involved very closely in this, is there going to be a deal in the next day or so that the House of Representatives can pass and then send it to the Senate. And let's see what the Majority Leader Mitch McConnell does. What's your assessment?</s>MEADOWS: Well, I certainly hope so. I can tell you it's entered a new phase, Wolf, where we're having the chairman and chairwoman of each individual committee, both on the Democrat and Republican side talking to one another, looking at technical language. I've actually exchanged some technical language back and forth with some of the Speaker Pelosi staff to actually try to look at the text of what we're talking about. But I must say that I've been here before and when we agree to something, it seems like the goalposts gets moved back and it gets moved back again, it changes each and every time. And so, it's incumbent upon your viewers to call their members of Congress and say, enough is enough, put politics aside, let's agree on something and let's get it done. I mean, we saw the Democrats in the Senate vote down at least $500 billion worth of stimulus and support for small businesses just this week. And so it's time to do that, but I'm hopeful that we can do it. We'll stay engaged until Nancy Pelosi says no or walks away.</s>BLITZER: Is the President ready to accept a $2 trillion deal?</s>MEADOWS: Yes. I think really the President has been very clear he's willing to go bigger. I mean, it really depends on what that is. If we want to increase the amount of money and direct payments to those hurting families, he's all in. We'll increase it. If he wants to increase the amount of money to small businesses, hotels, airlines, people in the restaurant and lodging business, were willing to increase it. What happens is, some of the demands that the Speaker has made, actually are not based on real facts or real losses. She's looking at this particular travesty as an opportunity to get a liberal wish list passed through Congress and that's just not acceptable.</s>BLITZER: So, it looks like -- it's not -- there's not going to be a deal. Because as you and I know, millions and millions of Americans --</s>MEADOWS: Yes.</s>BLITZER: -- are juggling right now. They're unable to pay their rent, they're waiting in food lines. It's so heartbreaking. I see them waiting in food lines.</s>MEADOWS: It is.</s>BLITZER: And as I said to the Speaker the other day, Nancy Pelosi, in Washington, you got to compromise. You can't let the perfect be the enemy of the good.</s>MEADOWS: Wolf, you and I agree, we've gone exactly here on this particular issue. And we see the hurting people, I see it back home in North Carolina, you see it all over the country. And what we have to do is, say, now is the time. You know, right now we're at $1.9 trillion. To give you an perspective, when we had the financial meltdown, the housing meltdown, we're two -- more than two times the amount of money that we're willing to pass right now to help the American people and she's saying no to it. It just defies logic, and even her rank and file Democrats, whether they're moderates, or more on the progressive side, understand how unreasonable she's being. And so, it's time that we get a bipartisan deal. The President stands ready, I stand ready. I'm encouraging us to go ahead and get this done.</s>BLITZER: So, if there's a $1.9 trillion deal, that you work out with Nancy Pelosi, and we all hope you can, does the President have the leverage to get Mitch McConnell and the Senate Republicans to approve it?</s>MEADOWS: Yes, I think at this particular point, the leverage that the President has, as the sitting President, and the ability to make phone calls and get enough votes to get it across the finish line is undeniable. Leader McConnell has been willing to say that if we've got a bipartisan agreement, where we have some of his Republican senators and some Republican House members, along with the vast majority of Democrat House members and senators, that he's willing to allow it to come to the floor for a vote. And, so I don't know how we can set the table better for Speaker Pelosi than what we have. Now it's time for her to say, OK, take yes for an answer. Let's get help on the way. You know, listen, she didn't want checks going to Americans with Donald Trump's name on it or a letter that was going out prior to the election. We couldn't even do that, if we passed it today to do that. So it's not going to affect the election. Let's get a deal. Let's announce it and make sure that help is on the way to the vast majority of American people.</s>BLITZER: Yes, because they need help, they need help desperately. Let's get through another a quick subject before I let you go, Mark. We've just received these official warnings from both the FBI, the U.S. intelligence community, that Russian hackers have targeted state and local governments in at least two instances, they successfully actually stole election data. This comes after the Director of National Intelligence last night issued a very stark warning focusing in on Iran's election interference here in the United States. At this point, which country poses a greater threat as far as election ballots are concerned? Are we talking about Russia or Iran?</s>MEADOWS: Yes. So let me make sure that I clear up two things right now in terms of ballots. There's a difference between really changing ballots, which neither the Russians nor the Iranians or the Chinese have done. So, I want the American people to know that. When they came out yesterday, and I want to I want to emphasize within 27 hours actually, it was less than that. Within the last 24 hours, we -- as you know, we've actually had someone actually come up, tell the American people, inform the Gang of Eight. Last night's threat, honestly was more from the Iranians trying to target President Donald J. Trump. There was some Russian involvement in a minimum way that we identified yesterday as well. But the real alarm bells went off with the Iranians. Now, that's not to diminish whether it's the Iranians' ability, Russians or the Chinese ability to interfere. But I can't say -- I left a briefing early this morning, the Department of Homeland Security, the President, and all of his team are on 24/7 alert to make sure that we stop it as we did here, and if we find anything else, we'll be coming to the American people and make sure that they're fully informed as quickly as possible.</s>BLITZER: Yes. I will say this. I've spoken to a senior U.S. intelligence official, they say the Russians, they know what they're doing. They've got a lot of experience. They want to foment as much political dissent here in the United States, create political chaos to weaken the U.S. around the world. That's their goal. That's what they're trying to do. The Iranians, they're newcomers, they're minor league, they don't have the capability that the Russians clearly have. The Russians represent a much bigger threat to the U.S. than the Iranians do.</s>MEADOWS: Well -- But both of those pales in comparison to what China is trying to do right now. And so let's just be clear about it.</s>BLITZER: Do the Chinese under a threat when it comes to election interference?</s>MEADOWS: I do without a doubt. So, you go back to your intelligence official that you talked to. And if he didn't give you the same -- or she didn't give you the same answer, let's get together.</s>BLITZER: Well, I noticed last night that Christopher Wray, the head of the FBI, John Ratcliffe, the Director of National Intelligence, they spoke about Russia and Iran, they never mentioned China.</s>MEADOWS: Well, that was because this specific address, this -- and threat last night, was predominantly Iran, and to a very small degree, Russia, so China was not involved in. So, we were talking last night about a specific threat. And to really less than 10,000 people, you know, and when we look at it, every person and every vote counts, but there's no balance that are being manipulated, no tallies that are being manipulated. This was all about trying to sow discord, as you were talking about and pretend like it's an ally of the President, to try to infer that he was doing something improperly.</s>BLITZER: All right, let's talk, before I let you go --</s>MEADOWS: And, by the way, I hit one other thing is, is because of that particular issue, Secretary Mnuchin has -- is about to or has already issued additional sanctions that are going towards Iran. We're taking very decisive action immediately. And we're not going to tolerate people of any country interfering in our election. And there's decisive action that's taking place today.</s>BLITZER: That's really important. We don't want that whether it's Russia or China, or Iran or any other country interfering in the U.S. democracy trying to weaken the United States around the world. You're very generous with your time. Mark Meadows, the White House Chief of Staff, thanks very much. We're all looking forward to the debate tonight.</s>MEADOWS: Thanks, Wolf. Good to be with you.</s>BLITZER: Thank you. As we await the start of tonight's, the final presidential debate, we want to take a closer look right now at the path to the 270 electoral college votes. Each candidate needs to claim victory. Our Political Director David Chalian is joining us right now. David, the path to 270 will almost certainly involve the key battleground state of Florida. Take us inside this very close contest.</s>DAVID CHALIAN, CNN POLITICAL DIRECTOR: It always does, Wolf. If you saw that brand-new Florida poll, we have out. It shows a margin of error race between Biden and Trump. Let's dig inside those numbers. What's making it so close? Well, look here. Among independent voters in our poll, Joe Biden's winning them 51 percent to 41 percent. This is a group that Donald Trump won in Florida in 2016 by four points, he is down 10, OK? Take a look at seniors, also part of his 2016 coalition. Joe Biden is winning them by points here. 52 percent to 44 percent. In 2016, Donald Trump won this group by 17 points. He's now down eight. So that is a key difference and why this race continues to be so close. One warning sign, of course, for Joe Biden is among Hispanic voters, Latino voters. In Florida 52 percent to 45 percent, Joe Biden is ahead you see here. But look at this, Donald Trump is 10 points higher here than he was in 2016. Joe Biden is 10 points below what Hillary Clinton did in Florida, among Latinos in 2016. So that's one bit of work he has to do. And it will not surprise you that Florida has seen the most advertising on television of any state this entire cycle. Take a look at the numbers, and you see the huge democratic advantage. The Biden campaign versus the Trump campaign and in the Democratic outside groups $186 million on the Democratic side to $117 million on the Republican side. Democrats clearly outspending Republicans in the critical battleground state of Florida, Wolf.</s>BLITZER: Florida, Florida, Florida, as they say. Thank you very much, David Chalian. We'll get back to you. Coming up, we're getting some new details of tonight's debate including coronavirus precautions. We'll be right back.
Tonight or Tomorrow, U.S. will Likely Record an All-Time High Number of New COVID Cases in One Day. Trump Fires Back After Biden Says U.S. Should Transition from Oil
ANDERSON COOPER, CNN HOST: Hey, good evening. We are now poised on a precipice. Tonight or tomorrow, we'll likely record an all-time high number of new COVID cases in one day. The previous high was 77,000 new cases in a day. That was back in July. As of right now, the data people at Johns Hopkins have recorded nearly 72,000 new infections today. Today is the fourth highest toll. But that number will almost certainly grow throughout the evening. Yesterday, there were more than 71,000 new cases and the trend line is rising and that trend line is followed by increased hospitalizations, of course, and then sadly, increased deaths. We saw the same thing this summer and it is happening again. It's grim stuff. The President talked about it today.</s>DONALD TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: We're rounding the corner beautifully. We're going to quickly end this pandemic, this horrible plague that came in from China.</s>TRUMP: That's how he talks about it. We're rounding the corner beautifully, he said. That would be accurate if he means that around the corner, there was a cliff or a fast-moving truck heading toward us. We're on the cusp of breaking the record for cases in the single day. The President was speaking at the giant Florida retirement community, The Villages and here's the President speaking to tens of millions of Americans at last night's debate.</s>TRUMP: It will go away and as I say, we're rounding the turn, we're rounding the corner. It's going away.</s>COOPER: He has now said that or words to that effect dozens of times since the pandemic arrived. This is nothing new. He has been saying it from the very beginning of the pandemic, it's going to magically disappear or gone by Easter. He said it knowing it wasn't true then, knowing how deadly the virus was. He admitted as much to Bob Woodward back in early February then told Woodward in March that he always preferred to, you know, play the pandemic down. Well keeping them honest, the pandemic doesn't care about the President's preferences, and even as we speak, the President is at another one of his potential super spreader events. This one in Pensacola, Florida, where as usual, the people behind him will be told to wear masks for the cameras but virtually no one else will be doing that. Why does it matter? Well, just today, researchers at the University of Washington's Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation published a new study in "The Journal of Nature Medicine." It says 100,000 lives could be saved in this country by February 28th if mask wearing became widespread across the country. Now, right now, only about 49 percent of Americans wear masks regularly, which is pretty stunning. If it was 95 percent of us, 100,000 people's lives could be saved by the end of February. Scientifically, it's that simple. But the President has single handedly made it impossibly complex. He's made mask wearing political, and he has shown in his own behavior, that it's perfectly acceptable to endanger other people by not wearing a mask. But in reality, it is that simple. If virtually everyone wears a mask in this country, 100,000 more people will live, will survive this pandemic by the end of February. They won't die. Now, even with near universal mask wearing, the study's death figure is still heartbreaking, 381,000 people, but it could be more than half a million if we just keep doing what we're doing with 49 percent of the country wearing masks, we will see nearly 400,000 people dead according to the latest projection by the end of February. So given how simple the life-saving answer is, given that it literally costs next to nothing other than saying the right words and modeling the right behavior, what do you suppose the President is doing about it?</s>TRUMP: This is Jeff Mason. He's got a mask on. It's a largest mask, I think I have ever seen. So, I don't know if you can hear him.</s>COOPER: That's the President's today mocking a reporter, Jeff Mason for wearing a mask indoors in the Oval Office, not a big space, surrounded by people not wearing masks, all of whom work for the President and they all know the President doesn't like mask wearing, not wearing a mask himself, and he makes fun of someone who is. If he were the CEO of a public company, mocking someone in the company for wearing a mask, pressuring everyone around him not to wear one, he would be removed as CEO. There would be lawsuits by employees, HR complaints. He wouldn't last long at all as CEO. But this President, he isn't a CEO. I mean, I know he has a company or had a company, but he is not really a CEO. He is the President and he is Donald Trump. If only he would wear a mask and encourage all of us to wear them as well. This is a President who said last night if only briefly before quickly shifting the blame elsewhere that yes, he does take responsibility for how this country has handled the pandemic. Listen.</s>JOE BIDEN (D), PRESIDENTIAL NOMINEE: And you say I take no responsibility.</s>KRISTEN WELKER, MODERATOR: Let me talk about your --</s>TRUMP: Excuse me, take full -- I take full responsibility. It's not my fault that it came here. It's China's fault. And you know what, it's not Joe's fault that it came here either, it's China's fault.</s>COOPER: OK, so his moment of accountability and self-awareness had the lifespan of a fruit fly last night. "I take full responsibility," of course, it's China's fault. That's Leadership 101. But just for argument's sake, imagine if he said exactly the same thing last night, merely adding a few words. What if you said, I take responsibility, but it's China's fault, but now that the virus is here, the simplest, cheapest and most effective way of defeating it is to put on a mask and that's what I'm going to do. But of course, he didn't do that. Because it seems he simply cannot. And today, he made fun of a reporter for wearing a mask. But imagine if the President had said that. Imagine if he decided to say that today because his supporters listen to him. Many of them would listen to him, and the power of him setting the wrong example, that is real, and it is costing real lives. It will cost 100,000 lives by the end of February. South Dakota Governor Kristi Noem is one of his staunchest supporters and like him, she too, doesn't want to wear a mask. Here's what she said in a recent op-ed, "If folks want to wear a mask, they should be free to do so. Similarly, those who don't want to wear a mask shouldn't be shamed into wearing one and government should not mandate it." South Dakota is now second only to North Dakota in cases per 100,000 and today set a new record for daily cases with the positivity rate now approaching 22 percent. Meantime, in North Dakota contact tracing is so overburdened by all the new cases officials are asking the infected to do it themselves. Let that sink in a moment. You're infected with COVID. Hey, can you do us a solid and trace all the people you came in contact with and call them up? And you know, in between your coughing? All these months into a pandemic and contact tracing still -- it varies state by state. Yes, some states devoted resources to it. Some haven't. There's no coordinated federal effort at all. A strong message on mask wearing from the President would lighten the load on those contact tracers by lowering the case count. It would save 100,000 lives. Not only can the President not bring himself to do that simple thing, he still can't even tell the truth about where we stand right now.</s>TRUMP: We're entering the final turn and approaching the light at the end of the tunnel. That's the way I look at it.</s>COOPER: He keeps using that phrase. That was a phrase that some generals and others used to describe the Vietnam War in the late 60s, they did it. I think it was 1968 people started talking about oh, yes, I see the light at the end of the tunnel. It turned out to be a very long and very deadly tunnel. Again, the virus clearly does not care what the President says. It doesn't care that we're all tired of this. It is spreading now at a rate not seen since July, heading toward a third peak higher than the first two. That is what is in this tunnel that we are in right now. By the end of the weekend, 225,000 Americans will have died in this country in this pandemic. By the end of February, according to the new I.H.M.E. study, 381,000 Americans will be dead; 150,000 more Americans will die in the span of three more months. Almost as many as that have already died. That's how bad it's going to be the next three months. And that is assuming that we all start wearing masks. If we don't, but if states begin shutting down when death rates exceed a certain level, that number climbs to more than 511,000. If states continue removing social distancing mandates, the new I.H.M.E. study projects about a million people will be dead of COVID by February 28. That's not rounding the corner, no matter how you describe it. Joining us now is doctor and I.H.M.E. Director Chris Murray. Dr. Murray, thanks for being with us. I know and it feels like deja vu, this persistent line though that the President peddles about rounding the corner. Are we in any way rounding a corner?</s>DR. CHRIS MURRAY, DIRECTOR, INSTITUTE FOR HEALTH METRICS AND EVALUATION, UNIVERSITY OF WASHINGTON: Well, I think we've rounded the wrong corner, Anderson, which is you know, this week, we're really seeing for the first time, as you mentioned, not only cases going up, but deaths going up. So, we think that the fall-winter surge is kicking off. It's already kicked off about a month ago in Canada, so it should be no surprise it's happening here. And it is, you know, roaring in Europe. And so that's exactly what's going to happen to us. We're going to go into that nearly exponential growth in cases and deaths over the next weeks and months.</s>COOPER: Your latest projections on fatalities predict more than 385,000 deaths in this country by February 1st. That assumes that some states will re-impose social distancing mandates. Do you have -- do you know which states in particular you think may have to do that? And then I guess the flip side of that is what if they don't, if they don't implement more precautions?</s>MURRAY: Well, it's the ones that are farther along. You talked about North Dakota, South Dakota, some of the states in the Midwest will have to put on the social distancing mandates sooner because the epidemic -- there's more virus out in the community. And as the winter comes in, it's going to spread faster and faster. And then some of the other states where it's not, you know, growing at the same rate will be a month behind that. But absolutely, we're going to have to see what's happened in Europe, re-imposition of the mandates, to avoid hospitals being overwhelmed, or we're going to face you know, a really large death toll.</s>COOPER: I noted, the study in mask wearing is to me just astonishing that more than 100,000 lives could be saved. What are you hoping government leaders on the Federal, state and local levels take away from the study? Because the very fact that tonight you can say, oh, yes, in this state and this state, it is likely there are going to be -- you know, you're going to have to institute you know, more, I don't know if lockdown is too severe a word, but more social distancing mandates in some of those states, not so that hospitals aren't overwhelmed. The fact that, you know, that now, it's not clear that the people who are in charge in those states are listening.</s>MURRAY: Well, you know, I think what we what we hope is that there will be clear guidance, leadership from governors, from the Federal government to have a mask mandate, to have penalties if you don't wear a mask, and also to start helping hospitals plan for what's coming. We're really back to March with the onslaught of the cases coming. And we should be better prepared this time.</s>COOPER: How do you know? I mean, how can you say, we know hospitals are going to be challenged like that and that we are going to see that large numbers of people like it was in March going to the hospital?</s>MURRAY: So fundamentally, what we've learned, and you know, we've been seeing this in the data for many months, actually, is that COVID is seasonal, and you know, you saw big epidemics in the Southern Hemisphere in the summer. We are now -- if you just look at a map where COVID is transmitting around the world, all the northern latitudes are, you know, essentially erupting. And it's just, it's the seasonal pattern that we expected to see, and now it's occurring. You just look at the absolute enormous wave in France and Britain, you know, in Belgium, Italy, Spain, and also in Quebec and Ontario, in Canada, same story. They're well above their April peak. And that's now what's happening in the northern states in the U.S., and it'll sweep through the rest of the country as the winter goes on.</s>COOPER: Dr. Chris Murray, I appreciate you being with us. Thank you very much. We welcome your expertise, even though the news is grim. More now in the politics of this, specifically the presidential politics. Joining us is CNN's senior political commentator, former top Obama adviser, David Axelrod. Also, our CNN chief political correspondent, Dana Bash. David, President Trump obviously continues to lie about the pandemic, rounding the turn, saying, you know, again, today that we're rounding the curve. It is going to end quickly. What does it say? I mean, he has said repeatedly that when there's a vaccine, it's going to go away. That's going to end the pandemic. That is just not the case. You know, I don't know what we do as a country when the President is just out and out lying about what lies ahead even in the time he will still be in office, even if he is voted out of office.</s>DAVID AXELROD, CNN SENIOR POLITICAL COMMENTATOR: Yes, you know, last night during the debate, Anderson, he was asked about this and the predictions of scientists about the time it will take for the vaccine to take hold in the country and for us to move through the virus and the President dismissed it, and he said, I know better than they do. Well, he was the one who said that this was going to be gone by Easter. The Vice President said it would be gone by Memorial Day. They have been consistently wrong, and the scientists have been consistently right, including predicting this fall surge. So it is disturbing. It's dangerous, because the President continues to believe that he can spin this virus, but people are experiencing it. And this, of course, is his political problem. The reality that people are living in their lives, the reality on the ground is different than the one that he shares with the American people.</s>COOPER: Dana, it was kind of remarkable, President Trump criticized Vice President Biden today saying all Biden wants to talk about is the pandemic. It's like say, you know, the President likes to call himself or used to like to call himself a Wartime President, it is as if during World War II, you know, you're attacking the President for talking about the war a lot. I mean, this is 23,000 Americans who are dead, and another hundred and fifty or more are going to die -- 150,000 are going to die in the next three months.</s>DANA BASH, CNN CHIEF POLITICAL CORRESPONDENT: And those are the facts, the grim facts, as you put it. He believes that this is something even though, as David said, it is unfortunately something that every American in some way, shape or form is experiencing. But he has not been disabused of the fact that this is not one of the things that he has, through his lifetime been able to spin away to charm away to convince people that they're not seeing and feeling the effects of it before their eyes. And, you know, I've had Trump advisers say to me, every single time he plays doctor on television, it hurts him. It hurts him more and more and more, but it's crunch time for him. And he understands fundamentally, that the more the discussion is about the coronavirus, and not other things, the worse it is for him because of his leadership of this and because it is a referendum on him, his presidency, but most importantly, on how he has handled what we're all going through right now as a country.</s>COOPER: Yes. And David, you know, the President continues to say you know that because of his actions, he prevented an estimated two million deaths in this country. That estimate is based on the government doing nothing, as if the government just stood by and watched people die. If the government did nothing, the estimate was two million people would die. That's hardly something to take credit for, you know, two million deaths that if yes, if he had done nothing, yes, you've done better than doing nothing, but 223,000 Americans dead with more than 150,000 dying in the next couple of months. That's -- I mean, it's unthinkable.</s>AXELROD: Well, and you know, look, the facts are harsh, and they are immutable. The fact is that we have four percent of the world's population, and we've had about 20 percent of the world's deaths and that is a terrible indictment of what we as a country have done. Other countries -- the whole world is suffering through this, and he is absolutely right about that. But other countries have been much more methodical and guided by science, and they as a result have had a much lower mortality than we have here. And you know, what's interesting about this is the President himself gets the virus and instead of using that as a teaching moment for the country, he is using it to once again do what he did from the beginning, which is to minimize the virus and you know, the country pays a price for his lack of leadership.</s>COOPER: Yes. Dana and David, stay with us. I want to get your take on the rest of the bigger campaign picture. John King joins us as well. The maps break down that will be driving these final days of the election. Later, Mary Trump on what she saw in her uncle's behavior on the debate stage last night.
In Final Stretch, What Changes The Race?; Debate Influence on Florida's Early Voting.
COOPER: The President sounding pleased about his debate performance last night. He is also seizing on what he sees as a gaffe by Joe Biden, though he was not quite accurate in how he characterized it. To be accurate, Biden said he quote, "Would transition from the oil industry" unquote, to cleaner sources of energy. In any case, here was the President today.</s>TRUMP: One of the most stunning moments last night was when Joe Biden admitted that he wants to abolish the oil industry. That wasn't too good. Did you see him this morning? This morning? I didn't really mean that. I didn't mean that. That was the last question. They talked about that. I said, whoa, this is the big point of the evening. Remember, I said well, you want to get rid of oil and gas. Is that -- yes, well, we want to phase it out. I said, thank you. Texas, are you watching? Pennsylvania? Oklahoma? Ohio, are you watching?</s>COOPER: These of course are all key states; with more Ohio and Pennsylvania are swing states. The question tonight has it or anything materially changed the direction of this race. For that we turn to CNN chief national correspondent, John King -- John.</s>JOHN KING, CNN CHIEF NATIONAL CORRESPONDENT: Anderson, now, we wait. We wait to see if the voters have the same view of the debate as the two campaigns do. The Biden campaign thinks nothing big changed. They think the map stays like this. They have the advantage. They have money. They have momentum heading into the final days. The Trump campaign thinks something different, especially on the issue of energy and fracking. They think the Vice President made a mistake. Mr. Biden made a mistake in the debate. Trump campaign says that's going to help in Pennsylvania. That's going to help in Ohio. That's going to help in Texas. The President said so himself during the debate. If that were the case, it's in if, but if it were the case that would help the President get back into play. If he could get Pennsylvania, and if he could return Ohio to the Republican fold that would get him back into play. But he would still have a ton more to do. So, let's switch maps as we get into the challenges of the final week. Who knows if that's the case, polling will tell us in a few days? But now we watch because the campaigns know. They have polling, they have data, they have interactions with their voters. So, let's watch this. How will this play out in the final days? Number one watch the ad spending. Not just where they are spending, but if the ad rotation changes. If the message in those ads change, if the strategy changes. Right now, the former Vice President is spending more money than the current President. Joe Biden's big spending is in Florida, North Carolina, Arizona, Pennsylvania, Texas, Michigan, and Wisconsin, all states carried by the President four years ago. The President, look here, Minnesota, New Hampshire, he did not win those four years ago. He knows the map is not as good to him, he is trying to find some new opportunities; so far, it hasn't turned up. Watch if this strategy holds. That's one way to look at it. Another way to look at it is even if the Biden campaign did have some missteps in the debate, it doesn't believe it did. But even if the numbers turn up that way, look at the advantage Joe Biden has heading in to the final 10 days of this campaign $162 million in his campaign coffers, compared to $43.6 million for the President. This is to the F.E.C. some more money will come in, but that is lopsided. So is if you add up Biden and his friendly committees, the President and his friendly committees, the Democrats have money not only to put up more ads, but to try to expand the map even if the candidates don't go there. One more thing to watch. Again, the candidates see the data before we see the data. So where do they go? That tells you a lot about what they think. Right now. Joe Biden: Delaware and Pennsylvania, two stops in Pennsylvania on the weekend. The fracking debate. Let's see how he handles it in that state and then watch what he does next week.</s>KING: Senator Harris: Georgia, Ohio, Michigan, again, trying to change the map in Georgia, trying to get the Midwest back in the Democratic fold. The Vice President and the President they know they're trailing. They're more busy. Watch where they go. Florida twice for the President, but he is going to New Hampshire. Again, that's a steady loss. The Vice President is supposed to go to Minnesota, a state they lost four years ago. So watch the money, watch the candidates. By early next week, we'll get to watch the polling to have any idea whether the debate puts the map something like this or if it still stays lopsided in Joe Biden's favor -- Anderson.</s>COOPER: John, thanks very much. We are back with CNN's David Axelrod and Dana Bash. David, do you think the Vice President's comments in oil and gas and fracking going to hurt him in states like Pennsylvania, Ohio, and Texas?</s>AXELROD: You know, I'm sure that he has supporters in those states and organizers in those states who may have winced with the way he answered that question. But the position that he has taken is very clear. It's in his platform, and that is to phase out fossil fuel fuels over the next 30 years. He could have worded it more artfully. And yes, in western Pennsylvania, there are tens of thousands of people who are employed in the fracking industry, and they were potentially listening and certainly the President may turn this into ads very quickly. He's had a steady lead there, Biden. He is from the neighboring state. He's a native of Scranton. They are relatively confident about that state. But this, you know, is potentially a little bit of turbulence that they don't watch. Overall, I think he feels good about where he is.</s>COOPER: Dana, it wasn't clear, I mean, whether or not -- sorry, go ahead, Dana.</s>BASH: No, I just want to add one sort of anecdote about western Pennsylvania. I was just there a couple of weeks ago, in the very part of the state that Republicans that the Trump campaign, they're hoping to get even more voters on their side than they did four years ago. For example, Westmoreland County is where we were. Donald Trump got more than 16,000 more votes in that county alone than Mitt Romney did four years before him. That was about a third of the overall number of votes that he won Pennsylvania by. And so that is why Democrats -- I also was communicating with some of the Democrats I met there last night. They more than winced in hearing how the former Vice President phrased his position. And it's not so much because they thought it was different or bad, but it's because they are completely ready for it to be used against Biden in ads that may not be entirely accurate, but it will probably be political fair game.</s>COOPER: Yes. I mean, it's one thing to say, well, you know, it's in his policy platform and stuff, but to hear him emphasize and as David said, Dana, you know, the way he said it, it was clearly a gift to President Trump.</s>BASH: That's certainly -- I mean, if you look at the way that the President reacted immediately, real time, he heard it. He knew exactly what Joe Biden said, and the fact that before the debate was over the Trump campaign, they were already, you know, putting out videos of what Joe Biden had said not just during the debate, but before that, absolutely. But the key is, is that the Democrats do have a lot of energy, as David said, in Pennsylvania and elsewhere. So if they, you know, get the numbers up in cities like Philadelphia and the suburbs, then it might not matter in other parts of the state, which is a crucial part of the puzzle for Joe Biden and his path to 270 electoral votes.</s>COOPER: David, if you were part of the Biden campaign, where would you be focusing your time and your resources in the candidate?</s>AXELROD: Well, look, the Pennsylvania, Michigan and Wisconsin are the -- you know, they used to call it the blue wall for Democrats. They're trying to reconstruct the blue wall. One of the appeals of Biden as a candidate for the Democrats is that he is particularly -- has particular kinship to the states, his profile, his history is good for those states. And I think they want to defend those states. But they see, obviously Florida is a huge battleground, they could end this race on Election Night if Florida comes in for Biden, and they see some opportunities in states like Georgia, North Carolina and Arizona in particular, 60 percent of the state is one big suburban area in the Maricopa County there around Phoenix, very promising for them. Those are the places that I'd be concentrating on right now.</s>COOPER: Dana, I mean, compared to previous elections, you know, more than 50 million people have already voted. Do we know how that affects things one way or another?</s>BASH: Not really, Anderson. These are unchartered waters that we're in right now. In some key states, what they are seeing right now with regard to early voting absentee is maybe more than half of the overall vote that they saw in 2016. We don't know how that is going to add up when we see the final votes counted. I mean, the Republicans absolutely assume for lots of reasons that most of their voters are going to go out and vote on Election Day. First of all, because that's kind of their tradition, it's cultural. But second of all, because the guy at the top of the ticket has been talking down the notion of early voting much to the chagrin of many Republican operatives I've talked to. So, we really don't know which is -- what makes election night, election day, election week, whatever you're going to call it. Really interesting, exciting and nail biting, to say the least.</s>COOPER: Yes. Dana -- yes --</s>AXELROD: One of the questions about the Election Day is if this coronavirus peaks in the next 10 days, as we're hearing from some of the scientists. What effect does that have on those voters who were planning to vote on Election Day?</s>COOPER: Yes, that's another good point. David Axelrod. Thank you, Dana Bash, as well. We're going to continue the conversation I had with someone who knows the president very well. Can tell us how long he can keep this change of tone he debuted last night. His niece Mary Trump joins us next.
Mary Trump On Pres. Trump's Debate Performance
COOPER: We started out in the crucial battleground state of Florida and that's where we end the hour. President Trump's rally in Pensacola is still going on. He's been campaigning in the state all day. It's a must win for the President and Joe Biden. The question is did their final debate last night influence any early voting there today? Randi Kaye spoke with some of those early voters and joins us now from Lake Worth in Palm Beach County. What did you find out Randi?</s>RANDI KAYE, CNN NATIONAL CORRESPONDENT: Anderson, the polls here closed a couple of hours ago. But we were out here earlier when the sun was out. It was pretty hot. And there was a line wrapped all the way around this building. Floridians very determined to vote today and cast their ballots. We wanted to know what they thought about the debate last night. Did it move the needle for them? Did it change their vote at all in terms of who they were casting a ballot for today? We spoke to voters here both supporters of Donald Trump and supporters of Joe Biden. And here's some of what they told us.</s>KAYE (on-camera): What was it about Biden at the debate that that assured you that you were voting the right way</s>JULIE STERN, BIDEN SUPPORTER: It just slight just demeanor. I felt like he came off more presidential, which kind of helped me believe that he's the one who can bring this country back together.</s>LANITA SANDERS, BIDEN SUPPORTER: I guess I was trying to see if Trump was acting the same way he did from the first one.</s>KAYE (on-camera): Were you considering voting for him?</s>SANDERS: Oh, never. No.</s>KAYE (on-camera): Your mind was made up before the debate and if they didn't change anything?</s>SANDERS: Oh, yes, no. Nothing would change my mind. I'm looking for who I think will support all people. And, in this country, we know that, you know, African Americans have suffered for hundreds of years and I want someone who's going to help turn that around.</s>KAYE (on-camera): So, when Trump said that he's the least racist person in the room, that didn't get you. He didn't get your vote.</s>SANDERS: He must have been in the room by himself.</s>KAYE (on-camera): Were you sold on Joe Biden before the debate or?</s>RODNEY ELLIS, BIDEN SUPPORTER: Yes, I will.</s>KAYE (on-camera): OK, so it didn't change your mind?</s>ELLIS: No.</s>KAYE (on-camera): Donald Trump went after Joe Biden on the 1994 crime bill. Joe Biden said it was a mistake. Was that something that was an issue for you or not?</s>ELLIS: Listen, honestly, I was a law enforcement officer. Joe Biden didn't put anybody in prison. When you commit crimes, you go to jail. He did what politicians do. He said it was a mistake. I believe him. I'm not going to fault him for what he did over 20 years ago.</s>KAYE (on-camera): What do you think of Trump's performance at the debate?</s>THERESA HOFFMAN, TRUMP SUPPORTER: He was honest. He behaved himself.</s>KAYE (on-camera): Why didn't the debate change your mind about voting for Trump?</s>HOFFMAN: Because I know about Trump. I believe he's a businessperson, not a politician. And go Trump.</s>KAYE (on-camera): Did you watch the debate?</s>UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: Yes.</s>KAYE (on-camera): You were impressed with Trump's performance at the debate.</s>UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: Very impressed. I love him. He's a great president.</s>KAYE (on-camera): Did you hear any plans from Trump for what he plans to do for a second term?</s>UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: Yes, I did. I did.</s>KAYE (on-camera): Did you hear health care plan?</s>UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: Pardon?</s>KAYE (on-camera): Did you hear a health care plan?</s>UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: Yes, I did.</s>KAYE (on-camera): You did?</s>UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: Yes. I heard that. He'll protect, he'll protect us.</s>KAYE (on-camera): But how?</s>UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: Because he's going to get -- he's going to protect us. He's, he has a plan and everything.</s>KAYE (on-camera): But he's been promising a plan for years.</s>UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: I'm sorry, I don't want to chat.</s>KAYE (on-camera): I'm just --</s>COOPER: I guess she just kind of ended the interview.</s>KAYE: Yes, she sure did. Anderson, as soon as I started to tell her and press her and the fact that the President still has not delivered a health care plan, despite all his promises, still isn't saying how he's going to protect those people with pre-existing conditions. She had had enough she was out she didn't want to talk to me anymore. And that's the thing. People here are so dug in, just like they are elsewhere that once you challenge them about the candidate, they don't want to talk to you anymore. And among the 25 or 30 people that I spoke to out here, not a single one of them Anderson said that that debate changed their mind at all. In fact, many of them said that they didn't care about all the talk about the candidates' business dealings about China and the Ukraine. That didn't matter to them. And when you talk to the Trump supporters, they're quick to point out they think Biden is a career politician. And when you talk to the Biden supporters, they call Trump a monster and a liar. Anderson, back to you.</s>COOPER: All right, Randi, appreciate it. Thanks very much. Randi's been traveling all over Florida talking to voters see how one state can be so divided about this election. What that indicates to the rest of the nation. Don't miss her special report, "DIVIDED WE STAND INSIDE AMERICA'S ANGER," tomorrow night 10:00 p.m. Eastern right here on CNN. The news continues tonight, want to hand it over Chris for "CUOMO PRIMETIME". Chris.</s>CHRIS CUOMO, CNN HOST: Have a good weekend my friend. I am Chris Cuomo and welcome to "Primetime."
Discussion on the Second And Final Debate For The President With The Election Days Away.
CARL AZUZ, CNN ANCHOR: Welcome to another edition of "CNN 10". My name is Carl Azuz. It`s always good to see you. First story we`re reporting on this October 23rd, the second and final U.S. presidential debate between incumbent Republican President Donald Trump and Democratic presidential nominee Joe Biden. It was held at Belmont University in Nashville, Tennessee. It`s a major event in the U.S. election process. And the night before the debate, the Director of National Intelligence and the Director of the Federal Bureau of Investigation held a news conference. They said the nations of Iran and Russia had taken steps to interfere with the election and spread false information about it. So the U.S. government warned Americans to be on guard concerning the stories they read on e-mail and social media. The planned debate topics were titled "Fighting COVID-19," "American Families," "Race in America," "Climate Change," "National Security," and "Leadership." They were chosen by debate moderator Kristen Welker, an anchor and correspondent for NBC News. And while CNN.com will have full coverage of the debate, we`re going to focus on the first topic today because it`s affected so many people around the world. Here`s an idea of how the two major party candidates addressed the coronavirus pandemic.</s>DONALD TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: So, as you know, 2.2 million people modeled out were expected to die. We closed up the greatest economy in the world in order to fight this horrible disease that came from China. It`s a worldwide pandemic. It`s all over the world. You see the spikes in Europe and many other places right now. If you notice, the mortality rate is down 85%. The excess mortality rate is way down and much lower than almost any other country. And we`re fighting it and we`re fighting it hard. We have a vaccine that`s coming. It`s ready. It`s going to be announced within weeks and it`s going to be delivered. We have Operation Warp Speed, which is -- the military is going to distribute the vaccine. I can tell you from personal experience that I was in the hospital, I had it, and I got better, and I will tell you that had something that they gave me, a therapeutic I guess they would call it. Some people could say it was a cure. But I was in for a short period of time and I got better very fast or I wouldn`t be here tonight. And now they say I`m immune, whether it`s four months or a lifetime nobody`s been able to say that. But I`m immune.</s>JOE BIDEN, PRESIDENTIAL NOMINEE: And we`re in a circumstance where the president thus far and still has no plan. No comprehensive plan. What I would do is make sure we have everyone encouraged to wear a mask all the time. I would make sure we move in the direction of rapid testing, investing in rapid testing. I would make sure that we set up national standards as to how to open up schools and open up businesses so they can be safe and give them the wherewithal, the financial resources, to be able to do that.</s>TRUMP: We have to open our country. We`re not going to have a country. You can`t do this. We can`t keep this country closed. This is a massive country with a massive economy. We have to open our country. You know I`ve said it often, the cure cannot be worse than the problem itself. And that`s what`s happening. And he wants to close down -- he`ll close down the country if one person in our massive bureaucracy says we should close it down.</s>BIDEN: I`m not shutting down today (ph) but there are -- look, we need standards. A standard is if you have a reproduction rate in a community that`s above a certain level, everybody says slow up, more social distancing, do not open bars and do not open gymnasiums, do not open until you get this under control -- under more control. But when you do open, give the people the capacity to be able to open and have the capacity to do it safely. We ought to be able to walk and chew gum at the same time. We ought to be able to safely open. But they (ph) need resources to open. You need to be able to, for example, if you`re going to open a business, have social distancing within the business. You need to have -- if you have a restaurant, you need to have plexiglass dividers so people cannot infect one another. You need to be in a position where you can take testing rapidly and know whether a person is in fact infected. You need to be able to trace. You need to be able to provide all the resources that are needed to do this.</s>AZUZ: Ten second trivia. In metric units, which of these prefixes means billion? Kilo, mega, giga, or tera. These prefixes are in order of thousand, million, billion, and trillion with giga denoting billion. But when it comes to wildfires, the term giga is used a little differently. A gigafire denotes a value of 1 million as opposed to 1 billion. The term has been around for a few years now and it`s been applied to several massive blazes throughout history, including one burning in California right now. It`s called the August Complex fire. It`s mostly contained, meaning it`s mostly blocked from spreading further, but the damage has already been done. It`s part of a highly active fire season across the United States. This isn`t the worse in national history, at least not at this point. The National Interagency Fire Center says since 1983 there have been two years when wildfires burned more than 10 million acres and 2020 hasn`t seen that yet. It`s also possible that decades of fires before 1953 were much worse, but the NIFC says data from them isn`t as reliable. Lightening strikes are responsible for igniting many wildfires. So are people. Through everything from campfires to fireworks to arson. For the more recent blazes, especially the ones in California, some experts and politicians have blamed a warming climate for higher temperatures and more severe droughts, which makes severe fires more likely. Some experts and politicians have blamed bad land management, not doing enough to remove dense forest vegetation which helps fires spread more easily. Whatever the causes are, "CNN 10" contributor Tyler Mauldin explains the effects across the Golden State. Tyler?</s>TYLER MAULDIN, CNN 10 CONTRIBUTOR: Carl, California`s largest wildfire ever recently became a gigafire. It`s a term that U.S. hasn`t had to use in more than a decade. I`m referring to the August Complex fire in Northern California. It`s taken the top spot for the largest fire in California history and has now burned more than 1 million acres. Once a wildfire burns 1 million acres or more, it gets coined as a gigafire. This is one notch above a megafire, which experts use when, as you may have guessed, a fire has scorched 100,000 acres or more. The country`s most recent gigafire was the 2004 Taylor Complex fire in Alaska. Before that, it was the Yellow Stone fires in 1988. So this is yet another unfortunate superlative for an already record- breaking fire season. The U.S. has had tens of thousands of fires this year. Many of these have been large wildfires, leading to more than 8.3 million acres burned. Way more than we`d see in a normal year. Half of that 8.3 million has occurred in California alone, making this year the state`s worst year on record according to Cal Fire. And speaking of the history books, this fire seasons has not only given way to the largest fire ever in California, it`s also produced five of the six largest fires on record for the state.</s>AZUZ: Probably seems like something called a diabolical ironclad beetle would be pretty tough. Well, it is. So tough you can run over it with a car and the beetle is still ticking. Scientists wanted to find out why. And in a new study published in "The Journal of Nature", they credit two interlocking lids over the beetle`s back for protecting it. These things fit together like a jigsaw puzzle and that helps the beetle spread any force that`s applied to it across it`s body. Researchers are hopeful that studying this beetle will allow them to invent new and stronger materials for better engineering in the things we build. It`s back is strong, it`s name is bad, and it walks to the beetle of a different drum. Some try to crush it but it`s ironclad, withstanding weight thousands of times its own. Unlike the beetles, it wanting help (ph) if the lower man (ph) gives it a hard day`s night, its lids to come together to save its hide, it`s ticket to survive makes it feel alright. I`m Carl Azuz and Friday`s are awesome, especially for the students of Wentzville, Missouri who get today`s shout-out at Timberland High School. Have a great weekend from all of us at CNN. END END
Trump, Biden Face off in Final Presidential Debate.
WOLF BLITZER, CNN ANCHOR: Welcome back to CNN's debate night in America. It's now midnight here on the East Coast. That means it's 11 days until election day here in the United States. And we're breaking down the final presidential debate of 2020, a very different exchange than the first chaotic Trump Biden face-off. There was far less interrupting by the president, and there was actually more debating. Both candidates scoring points and taking shots. Voters got a better opportunity to compare the stark divisions in their policies. Let's check in with CNN's Arlette Saenz. Arlette, first of all, what are you hearing from the Biden campaign about the former vice president's performance tonight?</s>ARLETTE SAENZ, CNN CORRESPONDENT: Well, Wolf, Joe Biden's advisers, not surprisingly, feel that the former vice president won this debate and that President Trump did little to change the trajectory of the race. Senior adviser Symone Sanders argued that this is an election that is a referendum on Donald Trump. Now, a few of the moments that they thought were shining moments for the former vice president in this debate were his response when it came to the coronavirus pandemic. And also that message that Biden would be a president for all Americans. That's just one of those unifying messages that we've heard Biden consistently deliver out on the campaign trail that they thought he forcefully delivered tonight. Now, Biden's advisers did acknowledge that the president had a bit of a calmer tone. He didn't interrupt as much. But they still felt the president was on the attack and had lies throughout the debate. Now, one area that the Biden campaign did have to clarify a little bit is when Biden talked about the oil industry. They said that he was talking about oil subsidies. This is something that we have seen the Biden campaign sometimes do after these debates, explaining what the vice president meant to say when he was on that debate stage. Now, as for where Joe Biden goes in the coming days, tomorrow he will be in Delaware giving a speech about the coronavirus pandemic and the economy. Those two issues that they really believe will be the defining issues in these waning days of the election. On Saturday, he heads to Pennsylvania to campaign with his wife. We'll also be seeing President Obama returning to the campaign trail, potentially delivering one of those forceful rebukes, again, of President Trump when he campaigns down in Miami on Saturday. The Biden campaign insists that he -- that the former vice president will aggressively campaign in these final days in a way that is safe to do so as the coronavirus pandemic continues to play out across the country. But Biden will continue to make this case on those issues, coronavirus and the economy, in these closing days of the election -- Wolf.</s>BLITZER: The former vice president clearly on the offense when it came to coronavirus. The president pretty much on defense and defending his policies. All right. Arlette, we'll get back to you. Jeff Zeleny is watching all of this very closely, as well. Jeff, some Republicans were very anxious about how the president would do tonight. What are you hearing?</s>JEFF ZELENY, CNN SENIOR WASHINGTON CORRESPONDENT: Wolf, they certainly were. Across the board of this Republican Party, they were very anxious about the president's performance at the debate tonight. And I can tell you, after contacting many Republicans since the debate has ended, they are breathing a sigh of relief tonight. In the words of one senior Republican official I spoke to, he said the word "finally" at the end of this debate. So giving a sense of approval at the president's change in demeanor, being less combative, you know, making his case in a more affirmative way. But there also are some questions I got from several Republican officials saying why didn't he do this sooner? Why did they cancel the second debate? So there is a sense of, you know, a missed opportunity here as time is ticking away, as it is here now, after midnight in the East Coast. We are at 11 days until election day. So in the words of another senior Republican adviser I spoke with, Wolf, he said this. Is it too late? It could be. The Trump campaign is planning on campaigning aggressively for the next several days. The president heading directly to Florida for two rallies on Friday, one in The Villages, of course, going after senior voters, and in Pensacola, as well. These are key parts of his base. And then over the weekend, he'll be campaigning on Saturday in North Carolina, in Ohio, and in Wisconsin. Again, all of these states are states that he won four years ago, is trying to hold onto again. So Wolf, it's an unknown factor if he changed the trajectory of this race here. Republicans are certainly more optimistic than they have been in weeks. But Wolf, again, 11 days and so many people have voted. Some almost 46 million Americans. That, of course, those votes cannot be changed.</s>BLITZER: Yes. Forty-six million Americans already have voted. Huge, huge --</s>ZELENY: Indeed.</s>BLITZER: -- early voter turnout. Amazing what's going on. All right, Jeff, thank you very much. We also are getting some more results from our instant poll of debate watchers. And David Chalian is joining us once again. So tell us what have -- what else you've discovered, David.</s>DAVID CHALIAN, CNN POLITICAL DIRECTOR: Well, Wolf, just take a look again. The straight-up question to these debate watchers in our poll, who won the debate? Joe Biden, 53 percent to 39 percent. Not as big a a victory as the debate No. 1, but still a substantial victory in the minds of these debate watchers in our poll. What's behind that victory? Take a look. Who directly answered the questions more? Who directly did that? Sixty-two percent said Joe Biden directly answered the questions more than Donald Trump did, 31 percent. That's a 2 to 1 margin on that score of answering the questions. How about on solving the country's problems? Fifty-four percent say Joe Biden had a better plan for solving the country's problems compared to 42 percent who say that about Donald Trump. This next one, who is a strong leader? Look at this. Who seemed to be the stronger leader? Tied, 49 percent Joe Biden, 49 percent Donald Trump. Clearly, that is a battle -- battleground where Donald Trump may want to lean into that, because it's where he's actually tied with Joe Biden. And then finally, take a look at this. Whose performance raised concerns for you about that person, about him as president? Fifty-five percent said Donald Trump's performance raised questions about his -- his performing the job as president. Forty-one percent said that about Joe Biden, Wolf.</s>BLITZER: Very interesting indeed. All right. David Chalian now with those numbers. I know you're getting more. We'll get back to you. In the meantime, let's check in with Anderson.</s>ANDERSON COOPER, CNN ANCHOR: Yes, Wolf. Thanks very much. We're joined by a new team: Andrew Yang, Kirsten Powers and Scott Jennings. Let's get some quick takes. Andrew Yang, what did you think?</s>ANDREW YANG, CNN POLITICAL COMMENTATOR: America, the last presidential debate is in the books, this cycle maybe --</s>COOPER: Woo!</s>YANG: -- coming to a close. Yes. I think it was a great night for Joe, because the race is continuing in his direction. But what the debate made me think of was the first debate 23 days ago. That had Super-Bowl-like ratings; 100 million Americans tuned in, and Trump, by all accounts, gave a disastrous performance and has not really recovered. After that, he got COVID. The second debate was canceled. So this debate was better for Trump, but it has not reversed the dynamics of this race, which makes it a tremendous night for Joe and the Democrats. But I think many Americans are just happy that this race is coming to a close. And we're getting votes in now. I already voted. You should vote, too.</s>COOPER: Kirsten.</s>KIRSTEN POWERS, CNN POLITICAL ANALYST: Well, I think that --</s>COOPER: You can try -- you don't have to match Andrew Yang's enthusiasm, by the way. That's not expected of anybody else, other than Andrew Yang.</s>POWERS: Yes. OK, that's a relief. No, I -- look, I think that Joe Biden had a very strong night and that there's a temptation to say that Trump had a strong night because he wasn't as out of control as he was in the first debate. But I think by any objective measure, the way that Donald Trump behaved is not really consistent the way -- with the way any other president would behave in a debate or, really, in any situation. I mean, if you look at how he handled the question regarding the children who, you know -- who have not been reunited with their parents. There was -- there was just zero empathy and just -- just really moving into, like, attack dog mode towards Joe Biden for something that he has no responsibility for. And not really showing any empathy for that. And I think Joe Biden, on the other hand, you know, if you watch him, he seems like somebody who really cares. And that is something that really came through tonight, I felt, on so many answers, was that he really sincerely cares and is passionate about the issues and the people that he's talking about, whereas Donald Trump just kept trying to redirect towards things that -- that he was claiming Joe Biden did that weren't really even his responsibility. They were Donald Trump's responsibility.</s>COOPER: Scott, what did you think?</s>SCOTT JENNINGS, CNN POLITICAL COMMENTATOR: Well, I can confirm what Jeff Zeleny said a few minutes ago, which is that Republicans are very happy with what Donald Trump did tonight. I sort of wonder, if he had turned in this performance on the first debate, would this race look different today? I mean, at this point, millions have voted. Most everyone else has made up their minds. So I think people will evaluate these instant polls through the lens of who they've already voted for or who they've already decided to vote for. But look, this was a 180-degree different Donald Trump than we saw in the first debate, which was widely panned, including by me. He came out tonight. He had a great stage presence. He didn't try to violate the muted mics. He let Joe Biden talk. He set up the policy choices. That is what Trump's always needed, a race about policy choices, not a referendum on him personally. He finally did that tonight. And on a number of issues -- energy, taxes, you know, on and on -- he actually set up debates where he could win on policy. Final thing, Joe Biden, I think, had two interesting moments. On health care, he sort of mocked the left flank of the Democratic Party. On their views on health care versus his, and at the end of the debate, his comments on changing energy industry in America, getting rid of the oil industry, I think that probably resonate heavily in Texas, which I know Democrats want to contest. But what he said about oil, I'm sure the folks in Texas were listening.</s>COOPER: But aren't -- I mean, aren't most, you know, car companies, I mean, wasn't Biden talking about transitioning to off fossil fuels in, you know, 2030 something or whatever is in -- in his plan? He's not talking about eliminating oil.</s>JENNINGS: I believe I heard him say 2025 zero emissions, unless I misunderstood, which would be a pretty substantial and radical thing to do over the next, essentially, one presidential term. But here's the deal, to borrow a phrase. Biden on energy tonight had to talk about fracking. He had to talk about his views on fossil fuels. Trump contrasted those views. Biden invited Trump, Show the tape. Show the tape on fracking. And immediately after the debate, the Trump campaign and Trump himself put out the video of Donald Trump showing different positions on fracking. So I think on the whole energy issue, Anderson, I think Trump actually finally scored some points on him.</s>COOPER: Yes. Daniel Dale showed the tape of Biden at the debate, as well. Andrew Yang, did you think that was a big -- a big loss for Biden on that?</s>YANG: Joe already released a very ambitious climate change plan that most Americans agree with. I mean, we can see the wildfires out west, that climate change is ravaging our communities here and now, not 10 or 20 years from now. But there were three times Donald Trump actually made me laugh out loud. No. 1 was when he compared himself to Abraham Lincoln in terms of his impact for black Americans. I have a feeling black Americans do not have Abe Lincoln No. 1 and then Donald Trump No. 2. The second time was when he said that his accountant is keeping him from releasing his taxes. This is Donald Trump. He runs around saying, I can do whatever I want, but his accountant, like, is keeping, the client, from releasing his taxes? It just seems so ridiculous to any American who's ever employed an accountant. And the third time is when he invoked the mythical GOP health care plan that can apparently do everything under the sun. We've all heard about it, but no one's actually seen it. And those three times, to me, were some of the -- the examples of Trump kind of crafting his own reality. And happily, I think many Americans can see right through it at this point.</s>COOPER: You know, Kirsten, Jake Tapper was saying earlier, you know, pointing out that in 2016, you know, a lot happened in the last 11 days of the race. The -- James Comey made the announcement that he was reopening investigations into Hillary Clinton. Clearly, President Biden -- President Trump is trying to get his attorney general to open an investigation into Joe Biden, sort of reusing the same playbook. I mean, again, it's 11 -- you know, 11, 12 days. A lot can still happen.</s>POWERS: Yes, a lot can still happen. But I think something is obviously very different between now in 2016. And that's that we're in the middle of a pandemic. And so that is what really is hanging over the entire race, and it is something -- that is the thing that, when you look at polls where Donald Trump is bleeding senior citizens, it's because of the pandemic. And so, you know, I think that that that is going to -- nothing in the next, you know, 10 or 11 days is probably going to change radically on that front. That is still going to be something that people are going to be voting on and that people are mostly pretty unhappy with the way the president has handled it. And I don't think he did anything tonight, really, to convince anybody, you know, to feel differently about it. And I do think, on the issue of the way he was talking about the children who were separated from their parents, that is an issue, actually, that I don't think the way he was handling it is going to go over very well with suburban women. And that's the other group of people that he needs to be concerned about. So I don't think that -- that President Trump did anything to change the trajectory for him tonight. I do agree with Scott, though, about you know, what he said about Biden and his comments about the oil industry. I don't think -- you know, is that going to make or break the entire election? Probably not. But could it be used against him in Pennsylvania? Could it be used against him in Texas? Absolutely.</s>COOPER: Yes. I want to go back to Jake -- Jake.</s>JAKE TAPPER, CNN ANCHOR: It's been yet another busy night for our fact checker, Daniel Dale. And we're bringing him back again. Daniel, President Trump talked about his push to get members of NATO to pay more to support the alliance. Let's listen to that.</s>DONALD TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: Between the sanctions, between all of what I've done with NATO -- you know, I've got the NATO countries to put up an extra 130 billion, going to $420 billion a year. That's to go against Russia. I sold, while he was selling pillows and sheets, I sold tank busters to Ukraine. There has been nobody tougher on Russia than Donald Trump.</s>TAPPER: Daniel, did any of that ring true?</s>DANIEL DALE, CNN FACT CHECKER: There's a lot wrong there, Jake. I'm going to start with the end, selling pillows and sheets. That was a vague reference to Trump's usual claim that the Obama administration merely sent Ukraine pillows and sheets in military aid. Now, that's not true. It is not true that Obama declined to authorize lethal military aid, weapons to Ukraine, but it sent things like drones, armored Humvees, counter-mortar radars, night-vision supplies, medical devices, so no, it was not just pillows and sheets. Now, on these figures for NATO, yes, NATO and its leaders do give Trump's credit -- do give Trump credit for pressuring members into and increasing spending, but it was not as much as Trump claims. So that $130 billion is not 130 billion a year. It's 130 billion, total, between 2016, and the end of 2020. Now, that $400 billion figure, he said 420 billion, was an estimated total increase as of 2024, so between 2016 and 2024. Not per year. And NATO told me, in an August email, that that estimate is now in doubt because of COVID-related budget challenges. So very much on certain, Jake.</s>TAPPER: That is an example of Trump actually having good facts on his side to share, but, instead, he just makes stuff up.</s>DALE: Yes, it's like the truth is never -- never good enough.</s>TAPPER: I know. Just tell the truth on this one. Those are actually good things to say. Let's listen to an exchange on immigration from earlier tonight. Former Vice President Biden, talking about the Trump administration's border policy. Detaining and separating families.</s>JOE BIDEN (D), PRESIDENTIAL NOMINEE: These 500-plus kids came with parents. They separated them at the border, to make it a disincentive to come to begin with. They were really tough. We're really strong, and guess what? They cannot -- it's not -- coyotes didn't brought them over. Their parents were with them. They got separated from their parents. And it makes us a laughing stock and violates every notion of who we are as a nation.</s>KRISTEN WELKER, NBC NEWS: Let me ask you a follow-up question --</s>TRUMP: Kristen, they did it. We change the policy.</s>WELKER: Your response to that?</s>TRUMP: They did it, we changed --</s>BIDEN: We did not.</s>TRUMP: They built the cages.</s>BIDEN: They --</s>TRUMP: Who built the cages, Joe?</s>TAPPER: I mean, this is a policy that the Trump administration trotted out. Jeff Sessions, the attorney general at the time, introduced the official family separation policy. But there you have President Trump trying to blame the Obama administration.</s>DALE: Yes, Trump has claimed, for a long time -- I've been fact- checking this for years -- that he inherited the separation policy from Obama. You know, he did it tonight, a bit more vaguely, than in previous occasions, but he did say they did it. We changed it. And that's at least highly misleading. Now, separations did occur, Jake, under Obama, but occasionally. Trump made them, as you said, routine deliberately. So under Obama, as CNN's Priscilla Alvarez has explained, separation occurred in exceptional cases, for example, where the parent was being criminally prosecuted for carrying drugs across the border, or other serious crimes, aside from the legal crossing. Or cases where human trafficking was suspected, or cases where the authorities couldn't confirm the connection between the child and the adult. So the separations happened, but not as a result of a blanket policy. As you said, Trump imposed a policy of routinely criminally prosecuting all suspected illegal border crossers for the crime of illegal entry, which forced separation from the children. So it was not just in cases of serious suspected crime, suspected trafficking. It is no comparison. Now, I have to say, as for the cages, there is some truth to what Trump said. A border processing center, with chain link fencing -- you can call them cages -- was set up during the Obama administration in 2014, in the wake of an unaccompanied minor crisis. They were getting huge numbers of children crossing the border. They didn't feel they were equipped to handle the situation. So, yes, those cages are built, at least some of them, under Obama. But again, that does not mean the two administrations, Jake, had the same policy.</s>TAPPER: That's right. I mean, if people are going to be outraged by kids in cages, it's fair to criticize the Obama administration because there were kids in cages. But the differences is these were kids who came across the border in these caravans without their parents. And I'm not justifying putting them in cages, but that's different than having a policy in which you are saying, we're going to separate kids from their parents and still not being able to find the parents of more than 500 of these kids.</s>DALE: Precisely. That's exactly correct. So Trump is seizing on images of cages under Obama, which is, frankly, a helpful image to him. And it's fair for him to point that out. But as you said, this is just absolutely apples and oranges in terms of separation policy.</s>TAPPER: All right. Daniel Dale, thanks so much. And I have to say, Abby, I think the president had an opportunity to sound more empathetic, and, instead, what he decided to do was just chum the waters, and make it like, Well, you did it, too. You did it, too. And you know, I got texts from friends saying, Is that true? Did the Obama people do it, too? Because you know, they're nit up on all these policy details like we are. But it's just -- as Daniel says, apples and oranges.</s>ABBY PHILLIP, CNN WHITE HOUSE CORRESPONDENT: Yes, and he even suggested, at one point, that the children are being well taken care of. He repeatedly said, falsely, that they were being -- they were all being brought over by coyotes and that they were being trafficked, essentially, when, the reality is, based on the information that we have, the administration had a policy of separating children from their families as a deterrent. That's what happened. And now they are trying to deal with the consequences of that. But the president doesn't want to acknowledge that, but also doesn't want to acknowledge the humanity of people who are trying to come to the United States, with their children, to give them a better life, to give them access to the American dream. They're fleeing something. The president never talks about it in that way. And I get why he doesn't do it. It's politically not his cup of tea. But in this moment, when Biden is trying to -- to basically say to the American people, literally, Biden said tonight -- I was a little surprised to hear him say that -- he's repeatedly said it's criminal. It's criminal what they were doing with those children. The president had an opportunity to turn that around with a little empathy, and he didn't take it.</s>DANA BASH, CNN CHIEF POLITICAL CORRESPONDENT: There's one moment that we haven't talked about but Arlette brought up, and I think she brought it up because the former vice president is playing cleanup on this -- this issue. And that is about energy. And I'm hearing from a lot of Republicans, and frankly, some Democrats, about this, that it might be something that plays in Texas, which, you know, who knows if it's real, how tight it is there. But much more importantly, where I was in the western part of your home commonwealth.</s>TAPPER: Pennsylvania.</s>BASH: Pennsylvania.</s>TAPPER: Absolutely.</s>BASH: Which is -- it's very rich in oil and fossil fuels. Fracking is big there. And specifically on the oil industry, when Joe Biden said, I would transition from the oil industry, yes. And then the president jumped on it, saying, that's a big statement. Now, tonight, the former vice president is saying, what I meant was, I will transition when it comes to federal subsidies. He's not saying that he would transition people out of their jobs, which, I guarantee you, is going to be what the Trump campaign, and people who are on his side, in these parts of Pennsylvania, in particular, are going to hit on big time. And it could have an impact. And on this, just to kind of show you how concerned some of -- some of the Democrats in those areas are, some candidates, for the House, are already on Twitter separating themselves.</s>TAPPER: Who?</s>BASH: From -- You're going to ask. Oh, I knew you were going to ask.</s>TAPPER: Oh, sorry.</s>BASH: That's OK, keep talking, and I'll get to it for you.</s>TAPPER: I thought you knew. I thought you knew off the top of your head.</s>BASH: I do. I have it here. Keep talking, and I'll get it for you.</s>PHILLIP: What's interesting about this is that this is something Joe Biden repeatedly flubs. He keeps mixing up his position on fracking. And then, his campaign has to turn around and say, Well, his position is that fracking is banned on federal land. It's something that he's clearly not -- he is not able to articulate clearly what is actual position is. Because it's threading a very narrow needle here. They're trying to say, we want to move away from fossil fuels, but also, not wanting to ban fossil fuels.</s>BASH: By the way, Kendra Horn from -- running for Oklahoma 5, but you're exactly right.</s>PHILLIP: Yes.</s>BASH: That -- and it's difficult. How many Democrats have we seen covering politics fall into this -- I wouldn't even call it a trap; it's a very fine line? Because they do want to not make people who are very worried, understandably so, about losing their jobs, even more worried and say, Forget it. I'm going to vote for the other guy.</s>TAPPER: And this underlines something that is interesting in this race, which is, Joe Biden is not a great candidate. I mean, like, in terms of his speaking style. He flubs a lot of stuff. There are a lot of gaffes. We haven't really seen it because of the coronavirus pandemic. He hasn't been out there on the stump. He hasn't been pressing the flesh. There haven't been as many voters challenging him. He gets hot under the collar. I mean, this happens. I've covered -- This is his second presidential race that I've covered, and there was one when I was a freshman in college that -- when he ran. He's not necessarily the strongest candidate. But this is a race against Donald Trump, and as Joe Biden always says, Don't compare me to the almighty. Compare me to the alternative. And the alternative is Donald Trump, and as an incumbent, it's really largely a referendum on him this race.</s>PHILLIP: Yes. And Donald Trump is also guilty of not being very articulate about, A, the truth, and, B, even his own policies. The president often misstates his own policies and inflates them, or misstates them, for political purposes. So, again, Joe Biden, if he were running against -- you know, even if he were running against --</s>TAPPER: Mitt Romney.</s>PHILLIP: Mitt Romney, or you know, or you know, a lot of other people, he wouldn't have -- this would be a much bigger problem.</s>TAPPER: Yes, but it is a referendum on Donald Trump, and David Chalian has -- I'm throwing to Anderson. OK. Anderson, back to you.</s>COOPER: Jake, thanks so much. You could have done it. It's not a big deal.</s>TAPPER: Well --</s>COOPER: I'll introduce David.</s>TAPPER: They put you up. They put you up.</s>COOPER: Yes, you know.</s>TAPPER: So there you go. Sorry.</s>COOPER: I've got to make the donuts. David Chalian has more results from our instant poll of debate watchers. David, what else -- what else do you see?</s>CHALIAN: I just -- I just had Anderson Cooper and Jake Tapper fighting over me. It was kind of amazing. Anderson, remember, our big poll finding of debate watchers, Joe Biden won this debate. He won it 53 percent to 39 percent. That's the basic question. Who won the debate? But now, I want to show you the gender gap. Because this is what we see in this race everywhere, how women are powering Joe Biden's position in this race. Look among the female debate watchers: 60 percent say that Joe Biden won; only 35 percent say Trump won. When you look at the male debate watchers, it splits almost evenly. Forty-seven percent said Biden won; 44 percent said Trump won. But again, that mirrors part of Joe Biden's strength we see nationally and in these battleground states. Look at the issue set that got discussed tonight. Biden wins on climate change, 67 to 29. Race and equality, 62 percent to 35 percent Biden. Coronavirus, a Biden strength, 57 percent to 41 percent. Foreign policy, near even, 50 percent Biden, 48 percent Trump. And look at the economy. Donald Trump has a huge lead among these debate watchers about who would better handle the economy. Fifty-six percent say Trump, 44 percent say Biden. I imagine that's tied to some of the conversation you just heard Dana, and Abby, and Jake having about that oil answer that the Biden campaign is trying to clean up. But that is a Trump strength in this race, and even more so in this debate tonight. And then, finally, just the bread and butter question: Did this debate make you more likely to vote for Biden or Trump? Twenty-one percent of debate watchers said yes, more likely to vote for Biden. Fourteen percent said more likely to vote for Trump. But, nearly two-thirds thirds of the debate watchers say neither. It didn't really alter their feeling about where they were in this race, prior to the debate. Again, I think getting at, there probably is not a huge change to the fundamental dynamics in this race from this debate. But, because Donald Trump was able to do some work, some positive work here, we could see a little bit of impact. But I don't think we're seeing an upending of the dynamics, as they exist.</s>COOPER: David Chalian, it's so interesting on the economy issue, favoring Trump so -- so heavily. It's the thing we've heard from supporters of the president, working with the president on the campaign, wishing he would focus, you know, on the issues that he does well on, with voters, as opposed to going down these rabbit holes and these conspiracy theory, you know, kind of swamps.</s>CHALIAN: Exactly. It's like politics one-on-one, Anderson. When you see numbers like that, any politician, normally, they would look at that and say, lean into that. That's a strength, let's play it up. That's -- you could bring people along, you could actually add to your coalition from this. You're doing better in this area than you're doing overall. So lean into it. But you're right: He chooses grievance politics and those rabbit holes time and again, no matter how many times people around him say, Please get out there every day and just talk about the economy. He has not proven disciplined enough to do that yet.</s>COOPER: Yes. Let's go to our team, check in. Scott Jennings, I'm sure, as a Republican, you wish the president would focus on the economy.</s>JENNINGS: Yes, it's his best issue, and people think that before COVID, we had a good economy. And I think they believe Trump is better geared towards getting the policies that would get it back. The race hasn't exactly been about the economy. So obviously, that's hurt Trump. I do think one thing about what David Chalian just said that dawns on me is, if Trump did enough tonight to, say, shore up some wobbly Republicans who care about the economy -- maybe some senior citizens thought, Hey, that's the kind of Republican that I recognize -- you wonder if this debate, even if not a ton of minds were changed, it might have staved off the possibility that the bottom could fall out. Say, you know, in the center-right suburbs, where you do have some -- some Republicans out there who, perhaps, thinking, I just don't know if I want to do this again. So I think that is -- that is something that could have happened. I think for Biden, the one thing you brought up in the earlier panel, Anderson, about the last 11 days, could something happen? The one thing he's got going for him that Hillary Clinton never had is that people don't hate him. Look at his image. His favorable/unfavorable rating is over water. In 2016, Hillary Clinton was so far underwater, nobody ever gave her the benefit of the doubt about anything. So if you're Biden, whether it's a debate, or something else happening at the end of a race, you have a reservoir of goodwill that is sort of like a Cancun. It's like a bit of a shield against bad things that could happen to you. People will give you the benefit of the doubt. So that's why I think a debate, or some other last-minute issue, won't be as impactful on Biden the way the Comey letter was impactful on Hillary Clinton.</s>COOPER: That's interesting. Kirsten, do you agree with that? Because in -- you know, John King earlier tonight was showing us in key battleground states, compared to 2016, Biden's not all that ahead of where Hillary Clinton was. And in fact, in some states, he's actually behind where Hillary Clinton was at this stage in the race.</s>POWERS: Right, yes. Well, so yes, I mean, I think that -- that it's unlikely that -- look, we're probably not going to have another, God willing, situation like, you know, a Comey coming out, you know, right before the election and changing the dynamic in that serious kind of way. So you know, what I think is fascinating is that Donald Trump, you know, based on what we just heard, you know, more people trust him in terms of how to handle the economy. And yet, under any normal circumstances, a president who is trusted on the economy would be running away with the race. That is -- that is typically the thing that people vote on. If you were to say give me one number, and it's how the president doing on the economy, that would all but guarantee that -- that they're going to be reelected. And yet, he's -- he's not even remotely running away with the race, if we believe the polls. He's quite far behind, at least nationally, and in some very key states, and with people who had supported him. Again, so what does -- what does that say about Donald Trump?</s>YANG: Well, the problem for Trump is that the economy and COVID are the same thing right now. Where you have Disney World reopened its doors, and then no one showed up; and then Disney just announced that they're laying off thousands of workers. So you can't be strong on the economy and be completely mistrusted on COVID, because one, unfortunately for all of us, leads into the other. This is why Trump can benefit from a Republican and an inaccurate association of him as the businessman, and it's not affecting his overall numbers. Sometimes the numbers tell the truth. And we're all somewhat traumatized by 2016, but if you look at the numbers around the country, Joe's ahead in many of the swing states that he needs to win, and he's competitive in places like Georgia, and North Carolina, Texas, Arizona. Trump had a rally in Georgia a number of days ago, which is the last place he wants to be at this stage in the race. So I think at some point, we have to start listening to the numbers, because they're telling a very consistent and clear story.</s>COOPER: All right. Coming up, we're going to find out if any of the undecided voters we're talking with in North Carolina are decided now who they'll vote for after watching tonight's debate. That and another debate fact check, ahead.</s>BLITZER: All right. We're getting more reaction coming in from the undecided voters who watched tonight's final presidential debate. Gary Tuchman is with undecided voters in the key battleground state of North Carolina. Gary, those voters gave the highest mark of the night to Joe Biden when he talked about election security. Watch this.</s>BIDEN: That any country, no matter who it, that interferes in American elections, will pay a price. They will pay a price. It has been overwhelmingly clear this election -- I won't even get into the last one -- this election, that Russia has been involved. China has been involved to some degree. And now we learn that -- that Iran is involved. They will pay a price if I'm elected.</s>BLITZER: So Gary, what are the voters telling you about why that answer resonated with them?</s>GARY TUCHMAN, CNN CORRESPONDENT: Wolf, personally, let me just tell you this, that the exhales you hear are the sighs of relief here at Davidson College, north of Charlotte, that this was a far more substantive debate. They were very alarmed at what happened three weeks ago, so people are happy they heard more. And that's an important point I want to bring up right away. Regarding this issue, we talked to you about election security. You guys pressed that button and raised it high, because it was such an important issue for you. Tell me why it's so important to you when you heard Joe Biden talk about how election interference from foreign countries is a problem.</s>UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: I think unless there's a strong disincentive, it's going to continue and get worse, and it threatens free elections, which is important to this country.</s>TUCHMAN: Same question to you. Were you -- are you concerned that Mr. Trump isn't talking about that so much?</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: Yes, I feel that, if a country gets involved in the election, then they have leverage over that particular leader when they bring to light that, Hey, I got you this election. Now you owe me.</s>TUCHMAN: How concerned are you about other countries interfering in our presidential election?</s>UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: Very concerned. And also concerned about the role that our leader takes in working with these countries, either in the past or moving forward.</s>TUCHMAN: Nathan, same question to you. You did tell me earlier that you were leaning towards President Trump. All of you -- almost all of you are leaning towards somebody. A couple of you were not sure at all. But you're all willing to be swayed based on what you saw during this debate. That's an important point to bring up. You were leaning towards Trump. Were you troubled by the fact that President Trump hasn't talked much about foreign interference?</s>NATHAN, UNDECIDED VOTER: You know, I guess not. I think he's got -- he's got a team that does that for him. And I know that the question was posed, and he went off on some tangent, just like he does with a lot of other things.</s>TUCHMAN: Did you like the fact that Joe Biden made a point of it?</s>NATHAN: I did. I did. I mean, I'm glad he came out and said it. It's an important issue.</s>TUCHMAN: Another important issue that you talked about with me was the discussion about pre-existing condition coverage. Joe Biden has talked about that with Obamacare. Are you confident that Joe Biden will keep coverage for pre-existing conditions? Anyone worried about that? No. Is anyone worried, when Donald Trump keeps that promise, that he's not going to keep that promise? Let me ask you that question. Does that concern you that he's not going to be able to keep that promise, because he's not giving any substance about it?</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: Yes, man, I think that he hasn't really shown that that's really any of his priorities. And I think that he's basically focused on getting rid of anything that Obama and Biden did.</s>TUCHMAN: But he does say that he will keep pre-existing condition coverage. Do you believe that?</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: If you can take him at face value, then yes.</s>TUCHMAN: Well, do you? That's the question. It doesn't matter what I think. It matters what you think as an undecided voter.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: I -- no, I don't think I can trust that.</s>TUCHMAN: How do you feel about that, Linda?</s>LINDA, UNDECIDED VOTER: I don't think I can trust him about that, and that matters to me. I have health issues, so I really want the pre- existing conditions not to be taken away.</s>TUCHMAN: Thank you for your response. One thing I want to point out, everyone here absolutely loved the idea of the mute button, and they're laughing about it, but they liked it. And I suspect that, if we hear a lot of argument in future years, that mute button will be back.</s>BLITZER: Yes. It was a much more civil debate, thanks to that mute button. Gary, the big question: Did tonight's debate help any of them decide who they will vote for?</s>TUCHMAN: OK. And that is the big question. You all came here undecided. You said you were willing to be swayed. I've been saying all night, I talked to people at home, how can anyone be undecided? These 11 people were undecided when they walked in today. My question is, of the 11 of you, after watching this debate, how many of you are ready to cast a vote for president of the United States? Raise your hands, please. One, two, three, four, five, six seven. Most of you are ready to vote. Of the seven of you, how many are ready to vote for President Trump? Zero. How many of you are ready to vote for President -- for Vice President Biden for president? One, two, three, four, five, six, seven. OK. So that's a good day for Joe Biden, according to this group. What I'm very interested in is those of you who aren't ready. Very quickly, why aren't you ready to vote for president?</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: Probably for fear of missing out. So you could find the one piece of information that, if I were to vote tomorrow and Donald Trump does, or Joe Biden does something on Friday, or Saturday, I'd be, like, Well, I shouldn't have voted.</s>TUCHMAN: All right. So you're still waiting for more. OK. As I mentioned, you were leaning towards Donald Trump. You're not ready yet?</s>UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: I want to see what happens over the next week and a half.</s>TUCHMAN: What could happen?</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: Who knows?</s>TUCHMAN: OK.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: Who knows?</s>TUCHMAN: Who was the third person who said they weren't ready to vote? You. OK, let me ask you the question, too. Do you --</s>UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: I want to see evidence that the Democrats won't tank the economy.</s>TUCHMAN: You think you'll get that evidence in the next 12 days?</s>UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: I think I can do some research and see what I think about it. I mean, is there assurance? Never.</s>TUCHMAN: OK. Final person right over here. Tell me why you are not ready to cast your vote yet. What are you waiting for?</s>MATT, UNDECIDED VOTER: Well, I'm pro-life. So I'd like to see, you know, whether Judge Barrett gets on the court.</s>TUCHMAN: If she gets on the court, what does that mean?</s>MATT: I'll probably vote for Biden.</s>TUCHMAN: You'll vote for Biden if she gets on the court? And why is that?</s>MATT: Well, I think that he is a stronger leader who is more willing to support fair elections and lead both parties more back toward the center and away from extremism.</s>TUCHMAN: So you're saying if the justice you want gets on the court and you no longer have to worry about her not getting on the court, then you could select Biden? But if she didn't get selected, you might vote for Trump, because you want her to get selected?</s>MATT: Right. Or someone like that.</s>TUCHMAN: Matt, it sounds confusing. But that's interesting.</s>MATT: Yes. It's hard. It's a hard position.</s>TUCHMAN: All right. We try to make television interesting when we do stories like this, and you're a bunch of very interesting people. Thanks for watching the debate with us. Great Americans. Great North Carolinians. These are the voters who represent all of us in the United States of America. Wolf, back to you.</s>BLITZER: Yes. Please thank all of them for spending so much time with us, Gary. Thank you very, very much. Jake, over to you.</s>TAPPER: All right, Wolf. Thanks so much. Such an interesting --</s>PHILLIP: That was very interesting.</s>TAPPER: -- voter, the young man who is very concerned about -- is very anti-abortion. It's very important to him. And yet, at the same time, he clearly, with the exception of that issue, far prefers Joe Biden. If Judge Barrett becomes Justice Barrett, he's like, I don't have to worry about that any more. I'm going with Joe Biden. I mean, fascinating.</s>PHILLIP: It is fascinating. I really -- it makes me wonder how many other people might be thinking similar things. I mean, it can't be --</s>TAPPER: I never even occurred to me that anyone would think that.</s>PHILLIP: It didn't even really occur to me. And it's probably a non- zero number of other people, but it's an interesting dynamic. And I also thought it was interesting that so many of the people who seemed to be maybe inclined to want to vote for Trump or skeptical of Biden were the ones who came out of this debate still feeling like they hadn't made a decision. I think that's pretty telling. It means that the president did not close the sale for those people who are already inclined to be interested in voting for him.</s>BASH: He didn't. But Joe Biden did --</s>PHILLIP: Yes.</s>BASH: -- with -- with the majority of the people who said that they have made up their mind. They were -- you know, I think all of them were -- were for Joe Biden. Obviously, this is a focus group. This is not necessarily representative of what we're going to see even more broadly in North Carolina, but it is very, very telling. And to hear these voters talk about what they heard and why they did or didn't change their mind. The other dynamic that we are reminded of is that people have voted and are voting. Like, they will wake up tomorrow morning and go vote.</s>TAPPER: Forty-seven million have already voted.</s>BASH: Right. And -- and in North Carolina, in Pennsylvania, in Wisconsin, in so many of these really important states, Florida, they could just take what they saw tonight, digest it, and go do it, as opposed to waiting the 11 days that we were talking about, going back four days, four years with the Comey decision.</s>PHILLIP: And just to note, we've surpassed the entire 2016 early vote already at this point.</s>TAPPER: Incredible.</s>PHILLIP: Eleven days left. I mean, it's an extraordinary amount of time we have left, and millions, millions, millions more people are going to vote.</s>TAPPER: Two parts of the debate that I think we will definitely see in targeted advertising. One, Joe Biden and his flub, gaffe, whatever you want to call it, about fossil fuel energy. We already have, you noted, the congresswoman from Oklahoma distancing. We already see a congresswoman from New Mexico --</s>BASH: New Mexico, yes.</s>TAPPER: Democratic congresswoman, New Mexico, distancing. That's going to be, I think, carried forward by the Trump campaign, a message based in reality, at least, in terms of what Joe Biden actually said. And then, Joe Biden is not doing as well, according to polls, with Latino voters as Hillary Clinton was at this point. He's doing better with other groups but not with Latinos. Donald Trump has made inroads. I would be surprised if the Biden campaign didn't take two comments that Trump made: one just the lack of humanity when talking about the child separation policy. And, two, again, I am still stunned at his comment about the Latinos that come into the country after being deported are low I.Q. I mean, it's just a stunningly racist remark. Not out of character. We've seen it before. But shocking to hear on a debate stage.</s>PHILLIP: Yes. I mean, I think those two comments for President Trump, he didn't do himself any favors. But one thing we should keep in mind is that Joe Biden is struggling, particularly with Latino men. And he's really struggling with Latino people of Cuban descent in Florida in particular. And they might be less swayed on some of these immigration-related issues and more swayed on economy-related issues. So it's a little bit of a tricky situation with Joe Biden with Latino voters, because in some ways, it's actually completely -- it might be completely divorced from his policies on immigration versus Trump's policies on immigration.</s>TAPPER: All right. We're going to take another quick break. On the other side, the bottom line on tonight's debate.</s>COOPER: Eleven days to go, let's take one more look at where the race stands in the Electoral College map, where Joe Biden is leading. Will that change? Let's take a look. That's the road for -- for 270. Let's go with our panel is here. Andrew, when you look at that map there, what do you -- do you think the race changes tomorrow? I mean, based on what we saw tonight, does -- does anybody have more momentum that they might have not -- or that they didn't have yesterday?</s>YANG: The fact is, one side needed a game changer tonight, and that's Donald Trump. And they did not get it. This map looks very much the same tomorrow as it does right now. And one thing we haven't talked about, Anderson, is that Joe Biden's campaign has built a fundraising juggernaut. They have a nine-figure cash advantage that they're deploying in the form of advertising, both nationally and in the swing states. Dems are in a great position. To me, a lot of it's going to be around trying to establish a margin of victory in swing districts in Pennsylvania and around the country. But Joe has to be thrilled about tonight.</s>COOPER: Kirsten?</s>POWERS: Yes, I do think that Donald Trump needed to do something different. If he -- if he made a few people feel better about voting for him, I think Scott was sort of making that -- that case earlier, I think they're people who were already voting for him. I don't think he did anything to help himself with people who -- who have voted for him before and were thinking of voting for Joe Biden. And I think Joe Biden just has to continue with the same argument that he's been making, that he is, you know, going to be the president for all people. I think there is a real fatigue around the division and the polarization that even tonight you didn't see the president trying to tamp down.</s>COOPER: Yes, Scott, I mean, do you think the president won over anybody who was on the fence or -- or you know, reached out to any new voters tonight?</s>JENNINGS: I do. I mean, I'll take that one. I think there were some Republicans, Anderson, who you know, probably approve of a lot of what the president has done from a policy perspective, but they're fatigued. You know, they have anxiety over what he's going to do. They're just -- you know, they're worn out from the guy. But tonight, they saw a Donald Trump that they could possibly live with for another four years. I got a text message from a Republican consultant who said he's going to sleep a little easier tonight. He's working on a big Senate race. In the first debate, basically, you know, everybody was fretting, because they knew the poll numbers were going to tank, and they did. This time around, nobody has that fear. If I may just take a quick moment, Anderson, to look at the next few days, you showed the map earlier. If I were Donald Trump, I would be doing a couple of things. No. 1, Florida. He's got to hold onto Florida. No. 2, that whole sort of Florida, Georgia, North Carolina, working my way north, you get up to Ohio. If he holds Florida, Georgia, North Carolina, and Ohio, and can figure out a way to hold one of those three states in the upper Midwest, he is really in the ball game. He could be in the ball game on election night. But on election night, if Florida falls, that's a huge problem. And how do you win Florida? How do you win some of these states? You find voters who fit your demos, who lean your way on issues but didn't vote in 2016. Maybe they weren't even registered. And you use your massive field program, which the Trump campaign has invested in, and you've got to turn them out. So there's not a ton of persuasion going on out there. There is turnout going on out there, to try to alter the composition of the electorate. Obama did it in '12. Bush-Cheney did it in '04. And could Trump be the next incumbent president to do it? That's his task over the next two weeks.</s>COOPER: Andrew, does Scott's math worry you?</s>YANG: Well, you'd much rather be Joe, according to this map. And the great thing about Joe's position is he has multiple paths to 270. And Trump, essentially, has to pull an inside straight, which would be a very, very difficult task, because it's not like the Dems can't see this coming. We could invest in a lot of the same battlegrounds. And at this point, the Biden campaign has meaningful resources to invest just about everywhere. So Scott's not wrong that that is Trump's best path to victory, but you would much rather be the other side on this one.</s>COOPER: Yes. CNN's coverage of debate night in America continues with Chris Cuomo and Don Lemon after a break. We'll be right back.</s>CHRIS CUOMO, CNN ANCHOR: Hello, everybody. I'm Chris Cuomo, along with my man D. Lemon, Don Lemon.
CNN Debate Night In America: Cuomo & Lemon; CNN Fact Checker: Trump's Denial Of The Pandemic His Greatest Lie Ever
CHRIS CUOMO, CNN ANCHOR: Hello, everybody. I'm Chris Cuomo along with my man, D. Lemon, Don Lemon. Our final post-debate extravaganza --</s>DON LEMON, CNN ANCHOR: Final.</s>CUOMO: -- of 2020.</s>LEMON: Final.</s>CUOMO: Well, I'll say this. Well, this was the last debate, right? And you did get to see both of these men for who they are. And Don and I both believe that the teams have pretty much been decided.</s>LEMON: Yes.</s>CUOMO: And it is time to play the game.</s>LEMON: Yes.</s>CUOMO: But you did get to see the best version of Donald Trump that you've seen in a debate.</s>LEMON: Low bar. Good morning to you. Good morning, Honest Abe.</s>CUOMO: "Who you calling Abe Lincoln? I never said I'm Abraham Lincoln, I didn't say that." Of all the things that he said --</s>LEMON: You said that he won't own, to that.</s>CUOMO: That was too much.</s>LEMON: I was like he was offended by that? Honest Abe. That was a good line, though. Don't you think?</s>CUOMO: I thought for Biden, it was a pretty good line.</s>LEMON: Purdy -- pretty.</s>CUOMO: And I thought that you saw the president --</s>LEMON: Wait, wait, wait. As you say, uncurb your enthusiasm. Pretty good --</s>CUOMO: Pretty.</s>LEMON: Pretty good.</s>CUOMO: Pretty good. I thought that it was good, that the format worked.</s>LEMON: Yes.</s>CUOMO: It worked well. And you got to see points of contrast between the two men. And it is very clear --</s>LEMON: Mm-hmm.</s>CUOMO: -- that this country will go in very different directions --</s>LEMON: Yes.</s>CUOMO: -- based on who wins. I do think that Joe Biden had to deal with a very well thought out line of attack by the president about his son and him making money.</s>LEMON: Yes.</s>CUOMO: The vice president kept saying no, no, no.</s>LEMON: But I've got something about that.</s>CUOMO: I'm sure you do.</s>LEMON: OK.</s>CUOMO: And the president was plagued by one single word tonight.</s>LEMON: What?</s>CUOMO: How?</s>LEMON: How. Oh, yes. We'll talk about that -- keep that word in mind.</s>CUOMO: Got it.</s>LEMON: But I thought the attack on the president's -- the vice president's family -- well, it's weird. Because you would have thought in this debate that Joe Biden was the president and Donald Trump was the vice president because Joe Biden was on the offense more, right? Like don't you think it was -- it seemed like role reversal, if you weren't actually -- if you didn't know? But the other thing is that I think that you need like a secret code book to know what -- like a decoder book, sort of like definition -- like urban --</s>CUOMO: Like that Dakota ring --</s>LEMON: Yes.</s>CUOMO: -- that would never come no matter how many comics you sent back?</s>LEMON: Or the sea horses that wouldn't work when you -- even (inaudible) sprinkled in there? No, but like urban dictionary, you needed like a conspiracy theory dictionary to figure out what Donald Trump was talking about. Because it was a sort of a wink and a nod to the conspiracies that "Fox News" and that the Trump Campaign are making up or are talking about. But most Americans are like what is he talking about? And they really didn't care what he's talking about. So I thought that part fell really flat. And I think it was good for the American people that it fell really fat -- flat. Because they were concerned with, as you said, the "how," which this president didn't really have any good answers for. How is going to find the 545 families, right? How is he going to fix health care, repeal and replace, as he's saying? You got the repeal part but what are you going to replace it with, right? How are you going to fix the economy? And other "hows" like that we talked about before. How are you going to do a lot of things? Didn't really have an answer for it, did he?</s>CUOMO: Intentionally so. This president is your outrage personified. In the movie, "Snatch," they had a very famous character in it who talked about being a nemesis. And he says, "Do you know what nemesis means? It is a righteous retribution of revenge manifested in the appropriate agent." In this case, Donald Trump. He is making a lot of good points of what people are angry about.</s>LEMON: Right.</s>CUOMO: What they don't like, what they don't like about the system. What they don't like about the people in the system, what they don't like about what's happening with this country. His problem is he's in a position of solving, he is not an animus advocate. And that's why "how" is a hard thing for him.</s>LEMON: Well, that's why I said the role reversal.</s>CUOMO: Especially with the pandemic.</s>LEMON: If you didn't know who was president, right? If you just sort of popped in here.</s>CUOMO: Right.</s>LEMON: Popped in, that's what -- go on, sorry.</s>CUOMO: Especially on the pandemic. Now I think on the personal attacks, this is just a battle of dissatisfaction. Because Joe Biden's saying to you, "Hey, it's not about his family, it's not about my family, it's about your family." Great line. Problem is it comes off like a dog.</s>LEMON: Yes.</s>CUOMO: Because Biden -- but to hear criticism about your family and making money you shouldn't and being corrupt from Donald Trump, it's like well, no matter how true it is about Joe Biden, you can't be trading down in terms of corruption.</s>LEMON: Yes. A good answer is like, Chris -- if you were Trump and I were Biden. Chris -- this way, let me see.</s>CUOMO: Now it works.</s>LEMON: Chris, really? You're giving me lessons or are talking to me about corruption? Have you looked in the mirror?</s>CUOMO: Right.</s>LEMON: Have you looked in the mirror? And you want to talk about kids; your kids are making money off of your companies around the world.</s>CUOMO: Right.</s>LEMON: Your daughter got patents and trademarks. You really want to go there, I don't think you want to go there. I think you probably should just shut up right now when your point comes to that.</s>CUOMO: But that's not who Biden is.</s>LEMON: Yes.</s>CUOMO: Obvious, look. We deal with people who are trying to --</s>LEMON: Then maybe it's better he didn't take the bait.</s>CUOMO: -- get things --</s>CUOMO: -- (inaudible) on a regular basis.</s>LEMON: But -- sorry.</s>CUOMO: I don't know that he could take the bait any better, he doesn't have that particular skill set of quick one liners. I think Trump is better at that. The question is how useful a skill is that when you're going to be president of the United States? But I will tell you this. In politics, axiomatically, if you're in the lead which presumptively the former V.P. is in national polls --</s>LEMON: Do no harm.</s>CUOMO: Well, do no harm, you want a tie. He definitely got a tie tonight. But look, as you and I both agree, I think the teams have been decided.</s>LEMON: Yes.</s>CUOMO: And it's time to play the game.</s>LEMON: I do. As I've been saying to you for months now, who's not decided by now? But maybe there's some people in the middle that are shaky like I don't know if I want Trump, I know what he is; I don't know if I want Biden, I know who he is.. I don't know if that's undecided or I don't know. I don't even know who at this point would actually be (inaudible) --</s>CUOMO: I don't think the president hurt himself tonight. He lied a lot. So what?</s>LEMON: Well -- well, well, well.</s>CUOMO: He didn't express empathy about --</s>LEMON: I disagree with you.</s>CUOMO: -- the people separated from their kids. Of course he didn't.</s>LEMON: No.</s>CUOMO: I don't know that he did anything unusual tonight that might upset his base.</s>LEMON: The only thing I watched -- and I was like OK, great, he got him there, he got him there, he got him there. But the one thing I thought that really hurt him is when he said well, you know, that's because it's in cities that are run by Democrats and it's blue states and blue -- and I said oh, that isn't going to go over well. Because what people want right now, quite frankly -- most people -- I'm not talking about the diehards, really far right and really far left. People want unity in the country. They're tired of fighting with each other, they're are tired of looking upon each other with suspicion about who do you support? What do you think about this, what do you think -- they're tired of the lying. They're tired of all of the vitriol. They are tired of people calling them names like libtard or trumptard. People are sick of that. So when he said that, I said if Biden doesn't come back and say I'm the president for all people then he's lost this debate. Sure enough he came back and said that. And I turned to my fiancee and said that was not good because people want someone who's going to be the president, most people, the president for all people. Not just people who live in red states, not just the people who voted for this president. And I thought he did himself some real damage there last night. Not with his people but with the people he may be trying to win over --</s>CUOMO: Right.</s>LEMON: -- if that is possible. Or people who are on the fence or may have been thinking about voting for him. I think that really hurt him.</s>CUOMO: Yes, look, we agree. I'm saying if you are sick of it and you want unity, you're not voting for Trump anyway.</s>LEMON: You don't want it? Don't you want unity?</s>CUOMO: I'm saying if somebody wants unit.</s>LEMON: And I got -- I want unity but sense with it. Like I know that people are not all of a sudden going to come together. But at least there should be someone who is the president of the United States -- shouldn't the president at least be trying, Chris?</s>CUOMO: No, he's "us" and "them." This is definitional. This is more about culture than it is about policy in this country.</s>LEMON: You're right.</s>CUOMO: And he is "us" and "them."</s>LEMON: Yes, you're right.</s>CUOMO: Everything he talks about is in terms of "us" and "them."</s>LEMON: Yes.</s>CUOMO: And if you're a "we" person, if you want more "we," it doesn't make any sense for you to be for him. Because that's what he speaks to. What do you think? Should we throw some people some sound about what's going on?</s>LEMON: If they want to hear. I think they like hearing us, they heard enough from those two guys tonight. They know what's going on. But no, OK. I'm kidding.</s>CUOMO: Oh.</s>LEMON: Well, let's talk about COVID. Because I think COVID is the big thing right now. People don't know if they're going to be able to put food on the table because of this. People don't know if they're going to have a job.</s>CUOMO: COVID is the truth.</s>LEMON: And COVID is the truth. So if we can talk about when Biden talked about -- and it's S-100 on our sheet. About the number of people dead by the end of the year and then the president's response to that. Let's listen.</s>JOE BIDEN, FMR. VICE PRESIDENT AND DEMOCRATIC PRESIDENTIAL NOMINEE: 220,000 Americans dead. If you hear nothing else I say tonight, hear this. Anyone who is responsible for not taking control, in fact, not saying I'm -- I take no responsibility initially. Anyone who is responsible for that many deaths should not remain as president of the United States of America. We're in a situation where there are a thousand deaths a day now, a thousand deaths a day. And there are over 70,000 new cases per day. The expectation is we'll have another 200,000 Americans dead between now and the end of the year. He says that we're learning to live with it. People are learning to die with it. You folks home who have an empty chair at the kitchen table this morning, that man or wife going to bed tonight and reaching over to try to touch their -- out of habit -- where their wife or husband was is gone. Learning to live with it? C'mon. We're dying with it. Because he's never said -- you see, he said it's dangerous. When's the last time -- is it really dangerous still, are we dangerous? You tell the people it's dangerous now, what should they do about the danger? And you say "I take no responsibility."</s>DONALD TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: I take full responsibility. It's not my fault that it came here, it's China's fault. And you know what, it's not Joe's fault that it came here either. It's China's fault. They kept it from going into the rest of China for the most part but they didn't keep it from coming out to the world, including Europe and ourselves.</s>BIDEN: What happened, what did the president say? He said don't worry it's going to go away. It'll be gone by Easter, don't worry, the warm weather. Don't worry, maybe inject bleach. He said he was kidding when he said that but a lot of people thought it was serious. A whole range of things the president has said. Even today. He thinks we are in control. We're about to lose 200,000 more people.</s>TRUMP: When I closed, he said I shouldn't have closed and that went on for months. Nancy Pelosi said the same thing. She was dancing on the streets in Chinatown in San Francisco. But when I closed, he said this is a terrible thing, you're xenophobic, I think he called me racist even because I was closing it to China. Now he says I should have closed it earlier. It just -- Joe, it doesn't work.</s>BIDEN: I didn't say either of those things.</s>LEMON: That is true. He didn't say that. He didn't say that he shouldn't have closed it. He did talk about xenophobia but not in terms of he shouldn't have done it. He said this xenophobic president, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. It's all context. But still, I don't think this president had a good answer besides I did the best, I had a shut down. Because we know it wasn't a complete shutdown from people coming in -- a ban, or whatever he calls it. The China ban. But I thought that was -- that part as well, the president did not do well on.</s>CUOMO: Him closing down China was the best thing that he's done to this point. And that is not a compliment. Because we've needed a lot of things, a lot more, than what happened with the travel restrictions in China and in Europe than has happened since. What we've needed since has been worse. And those things were late and incomplete. To your point. If this election is about the response to the pandemic, the president has big, big problems. Because he did say he takes no responsibility.</s>LEMON: None.</s>CUOMO: He said tonight I take full responsibility. No, you never have. And there are two reasons for that. One, the question at the time -- to your point of context -- was for what was happening in the country in terms of response. And he said I take no responsibility. You have to own it. He talks about when he shut down this country. He never shut down the country, he was against shutting it down. He didn't want states to shut it down. And that's why certain red states lagged to their own detriment. If you want to play the "us and them" game. His inability to own the response other than calling himself a wartime president, huge mistake that is plaguing us to this day. This is a virus, not a plague. But it is still here. And he didn't say anything tonight, not one word, about what more or better he would do to help us get through this.</s>LEMON: Well, that's a problem though. But if you look at -- I was looking for the whole -- the xenophobic thing to give you the context of what he said. But --</s>CUOMO: Well, he didn't explain it well either. Biden.</s>LEMON: That's the thing. That's why I was looking for the exact same thing. But yes, you're right. But you will -- here's the defense from Trump supporters. That they will say anyone who says that they would know -- this is Monday morning quarterbacking. Anyone who says that they would do something differently when it comes to the coronavirus, it's just Monday morning quarterbacking, it's not true, they wouldn't know. Well, that simply is false. Because people have said in real-time what we should be doing --</s>CUOMO: Right.</s>LEMON: They've been talking about testing. What restrictions we should be placing on -- what protocol we should have in place. They had been saying it at the time, in real-time. And as everyone is saying it, this president is saying -- is refuting it and not doing anything about it.</s>CUOMO: Because they were all wrong too.</s>LEMON: Yes.</s>CUOMO: Anthony Fauci -- which no one calls him by the way.</s>LEMON: Right.</s>CUOMO: It'd be like calling my brother Andy.</s>LEMON: Yes.</s>CUOMO: Nobody does it if they know the person.</s>LEMON: Right.</s>CUOMO: "Well, Anthony Fauci was wrong then too, he said this was going to be gone." False.</s>LEMON: He didn't say that.</s>CUOMO: He said based on the current case flow --</s>LEMON: Right.</s>CUOMO: -- we'll be fine. See, this is something the president doesn't get. And by the way, he's right not to get it. If you want to play politics, pure and simple, what I'm about to say is lost on everybody who wants to vote for him. Not because they're stupid, because they're sick of him.</s>LEMON: Right.</s>CUOMO: They're sick of his subtlety. But the idea of well, when Fauci said you didn't need masks, he was wrong and then he changed his position and he was right. People are sick of that because it sounds like doublespeak. But it happens to be the truth. Tony Fauci realized this wasn't a virus that you get from contact, by touching things and then touching yourself, and that there was a scarcity issue with masks. So it was better off not to mess with them, leave them for the people who need them most. He adjusted that. See, the president is right to question that because it looks weak.</s>LEMON: Right.</s>CUOMO: But long after Fauci and all the others knew this was going to be bad --</s>LEMON: But also, he wanted --</s>CUOMO: -- this president refused to change.</s>LEMON: -- to save masks for frontline workers.</s>CUOMO: Right. But as soon as you have to explain it --</s>LEMON: Yes.</s>CUOMO: -- you lose it.</s>LEMON: Yes. When you're explaining it. I will give you that.</s>CUOMO: And what the president has to face on that same score -- he's right. It looks bad for Fauci and the other people. But we all know the situation's changed and we know that he knew it changed too. Because he told Bob Woodward on tape.</s>LEMON: Right.</s>CUOMO: He told him things that he was telling us weren't true at the same time. And that's his problem.</s>LEMON: OK. So listen -- and I know what you're going to say as I was thinking about it. He says that New York City's a ghost town. I tried to get a cab the other day -- it wasn't for the reasons that you're going to say, so stop it.</s>CUOMO: I was going to say that.</s>LEMON: I knew what you're going to say. I couldn't. I'm like wait a minute, every cab that went by had someone in it. We tried -- we want to go to dinner, tables were full, people were out having dinner. People are shopping in New York City. Is it the same New York as it was before? No, no. No city is. And New York City is thriving right now, it's humming along. Has New York city been hurt? Yes. Every city in the country has been hurt as well. But for him to say in the city I love so much -- he doesn't love the city so much, he moved to Florida. Because New Yorkers didn't even vote for him, he lost his home town. So for him to say that New York City's a ghost town, I was just waiting -- maybe Joe Biden is not here and he doesn't know. But New York city people, not a ghost town. Doing A-OK.</s>CUOMO: But know what? That works too. Fear sells.</s>LEMON: Yes.</s>CUOMO: Things are bad, things are bad in this country. Things are bad in New York; my brother's the governor of New York, he'll tell you himself. He's going to have big budget problems for years. One of the things that gets too in the weeds too fast is -- and Joe Biden actually I think gave this answer better than any other answer in terms of policy. He said certain things in contacting and connecting with people who are in pain.</s>LEMON: Yes.</s>CUOMO: I think that shows who he is. But the states are dying and the federal government doesn't want to give them money to balance their budgets.</s>LEMON: Can we talk about -- can we play some sound on that?</s>CUOMO: Yes.</s>LEMON: Let's play some sound. So let's play, if we can, S-106 and S- 107.</s>CUOMO: I love code.</s>LEMON: Yes. Code. Code.</s>TRUMP: All he does is talk about shutdowns. But forget about him. His Democrat governors, Cuomo in New York -- you look at what's going on in California. You look at Pennsylvania, North Carolina; Democrats, Democrats all. They're shut down so tight and they're dying. They're dying. And he supports all these people. All he talks about is shutdowns. No, we're not going to shut down and we have to open our schools. And it's like -- as an example, I have a young son. He also tested positive. By the time I spoke to the doctor the second time, he was fine. It just went away.</s>BIDEN: I don't look at this in terms the way he does, blue states and red states. They're all the United States. And look at the states that are having such a spike in the coronavirus. They're the red states, they're the states in the Midwest, they're the states in the upper Midwest. That's where the spike is occurring significantly. But they're all Americans, they're all Americans. And what we have to do is say wear these masks, number one. Make sure we get the help that the businesses need that has -- money's already been passed to do that. It's been out there since the beginning of the summer and nothing's happened.</s>LEMON: Listen, as I said everyone is hurting. But -- and listen, who doesn't want everything to open back up? Schools, the economy, every single business. But we've got to do it and we've got to be safe about it. And whoever is the president can't only look out for red states if they're a Republican president or blue states if they're a Democratic president, they have to look out for all states meaning all citizens regardless of their ideology or political affiliation.</s>CUOMO: Yes. And look, again, it is unsatisfying for people to hear answers about how hey, it's not as bad as it seems. Look, that's politics. The president wants to say Joe Biden's the politician. He was every bit the politician on that stage tonight as Joe Biden. He has all of the skills, plus and minus, that people ascribe to politicians. But look, here is the fatal flaw, OK. On this issue of pandemic, we have never seen a crisis handled like this one. Which is to say that the person in charge denied we were in crisis. The president says he closed down the whole economy and that's what helped then he says now we're not going to shut down, we'll never shut down, I'm anti shut down. He can't have it both ways because he is in charge. All of those arguments and doublespeak work well when you are an insurgent when you're on the outside, when you're criticizing, when you're "us."</s>LEMON: Yes.</s>CUOMO: But when you're in charge, you have to live by what you did and did not do. And there's no question that we're still suffering in ways that other countries didn't for one simple reason. Lack of adjustment and lack of aggression toward the problem.</s>LEMON: "I wouldn't change anything."</s>CUOMO: And he refuses to do it.</s>LEMON: "I wouldn't change anything." And, "I have a plan."</s>CUOMO: That's the same thing as the no responsibility thing.</s>LEMON: Yes.</s>CUOMO: That's who he is. You'll take it as strength, I don't see arrogance as strength.</s>LEMON: Yes.</s>CUOMO: I see it as living in denial of your own weakness, is arrogance. And when you get the cross section of arrogance and ignorance that he has, you get yourself a problem. On this issue. If this election is decided by this issue, he's in real trouble. Now the open question is obvious. Will it be about that?</s>LEMON: Yes.</s>CUOMO: I don't know.</s>LEMON: And if it's decided on the facts, he's also in trouble. And you've got some facts to talk about.</s>CUOMO: Good segue.</s>LEMON: Yes.</s>CUOMO: CNN's fact-checker in chief, Daniel Dale, joins us now. Overall assessment of truthiness on both sides.</s>DANIEL DALE, CNN REPORTER: Well, Chris, we have a president who is running for reelection on a strategy of serial, deliberate dishonesty. And it's getting worse. This debate, the version of Trump we got in this debate, was worse from a fact check perspective, from an honesty perspective than the Trump we got in that first debate even though he was more belligerent in the first debate. His rallies are also getting more dishonest. And it's just a bombardment. Literally, his first sentence tonight was inaccurate. I don't know if I've ever seen that before in a debate. It takes work. And, as you said, I think the most important piece of dishonesty we're getting from either candidate is Trump's repeated insistence that the pandemic is going away or rounding some sort of turn or corner. This is getting worse and worse. And the president keeps saying it's getting better and it's about to vanish. This is just -- the magnitude, the importance, of this piece of dishonesty is just staggering to me. Now, I will add that Biden was far from perfect. He had some false claims, he had some misleading claims and some claims lacking in context. So he shouldn't be absolved for any of that. But, again, it's just -- apples and oranges, no comparison in the frequency and generally in the magnitude of the false claims from these two candidates.</s>CUOMO: Let's play a little sound as an example. I think one of big issues in terms of testing this president on what he's done, hasn't done. We'll start with immigration. And the president's position on the 500-plus children who are separated from their families. Those family members were sent back and now they're having trouble finding them. Here.</s>TRUMP: Catch and release is a disaster. A murderer would come in, a rapist would come in, a very bad person would come in. We would take their name, we have to release them into our country. And then you say they come back. Less than one percent of the people come back.</s>BIDEN: Not true.</s>TRUMP: We have to send ICE out and Border Patrol out to find them. We would say come back in two years, three years, we're going to give you a court case, you need Perry Mason. We're going to give you a court case. When you say they come back, they don't come back, Joe.</s>BIDEN: They do.</s>TRUMP: They never come back. Only the really -- I hate to say this but those with the lowest IQ, they might come back.</s>KRISTEN WELKER, "NBC" WHITE HOUSE CORRESPONDENT, MODERATOR: OK.</s>CUOMO: First fact check is he doesn't hate to say anything. If anybody learned anything tonight -- I had so many people, Daniel -- this isn't in your bailiwick but just as an aside. Many people said tonight well, the president was much differently behaved tonight. He was much more cogent and he was calmer than he was. Yes, that's because it's all intentional, my brothers and sisters. Of course he could be like this all the time if he wants to. All the bombast, all the cruelty, all the personal slights. It's not style, it's not that he doesn't get politics. This is who he wants to be. When he wants to be somebody else, he can be. He does what suits him in the moment. Back to the facts. Where does that stand in terms of catch of release?</s>DALE: So that claim is wrong. Trump has been claiming for years now that basically nobody shows up for their immigration court hearings after their release pending a hearing. In fact, as of the latest data we have for 2018, it was 25 percent of cases were decided in absentia which means the person was not present to hear the decision. Which means that 75 percent were in court to hear the decision. Now you can argue that 25 percent absent is too much. But that's not what the president says. He says it's 99 percent absent and Chris, that's not even close to true.</s>CUOMO: All right. Let's score both sides though. Biggest miss by Biden when it comes to the facts.</s>DALE: I think it was his claim about fracking. He accused Trump of lying for saying that he had opposed -- for saying that he opposed fracking. He said I never said I opposed fracking. In fact, although Biden's actual written campaign policy position is not a ban on fracking, it's a ban specifically on new leases for oil and gas on public lands only, he did say during the Democratic Primary in 2019 and early 2020 that he was generally opposed to fracking. I think we have a clip of what he said to our Dana Bash in 2019, is that right?</s>CUOMO: Yes, here it is.</s>DALE: We don't have the clip?</s>CUOMO: Oh, we don't?</s>DALE: We don't have the clip. I'm sorry.</s>CUOMO: I'll read it to you.</s>DALE: It's my fault. Yes, OK. Go ahead.</s>CUOMO: You want to read it to me. You have a nicer voice.</s>DALE: Yes. So we have it here. So Dana Bash said, "Thank you. Mr. Vice President, just to clarify. Would there be any place for fossil fuels including coal and fracking in a Biden Administration?" And Biden said, "No, we would work it out. We would make sure it's eliminated and no more subsidies for either of those either, any fossil fuel." And so he was talking about a few different things there, it was kind of vague. But he did strongly suggest that he was generally anti- fracking forcing his campaign to come out and clarify over and over that in fact he's not proposing a full ban.</s>CUOMO: Look, it's on him to explain his answers clearly, fully and consistently. And if he doesn't, it will be held against him. Thank you, Daniel Dale. You got a heck of a job on your hands when it comes to fact-checking.</s>DALE: Thanks, Chris.</s>CUOMO: But you know what, nothing matters more. Appreciate it, brother. You'll be back later on.</s>DALE: Thank you.</s>CUOMO: First, let's take a little break here. And when we come back, more analysis of what worked and where does it leave us? This was it. Now you've got to make your decision. Are you ready? Next.
Biden Rejects Trump's Comparison To Bernie Sanders "He Thinks He's Running Against Somebody Else"; Trump And Biden Battle Over Russia Claims; Trump And Biden Clash, In Tense, But Calmer Final Debate
DON LEMON, CNN HOST: Welcome back. What -- you're trying to steal my lines. What does it say right there?</s>CHRIS CUOMO, CNN ANCHOR: It wasn't me.</s>LEMON: Who was it?</s>CUOMO: It wasn't me.</s>CUOMO: Who was that? I can't hear anything. Are you talking? It's not working.</s>LEMON: Go on. You want to be going.</s>CUOMO: No, no. I'm sorry. I didn't say it wasn't me. But, go ahead.</s>LEMON: See? I have to save him all the time.</s>CUOMO: From myself.</s>LEMON: This is our special post-debate coverage here on CNN, the final one of 2020. Hello. I'm Don Lemon. And you know that guy right there. What's your name again?</s>CUOMO: Huh? Franklin.</s>CUOMO: Abraham Lincoln.</s>LEMON: That's Abe Lincoln right there. I got to say, though --</s>CUOMO: I never said I'm Abraham Lincoln.</s>LEMON: Oh, really? Is that what you take offense to?</s>CUOMO: I can't believe you said I said I'm Abraham Lincoln. I didn't say that.</s>LEMON: Well, you -- you said that you've done more than possibly Abraham Lincoln.</s>CUOMO: Don't eyeball me when we're on</s>TV. LEMON: No, I'll put you on Abraham Lincoln.</s>CUOMO: Stick to your own box. Don't eyeball me. This isn't "The Brady Bunch."</s>LEMON: Here's a story.</s>LEMON: What a night, though, seriously. I -- all -- I mean, all in all, considering we had the debate that was -- wasn't a debate, it was just a yell fest, and then we had the debate that wasn't, and then turned into two town halls, competing, and then we had this tonight. And so, actually, I thought we got some information out of it tonight. I like the format. I thought it was good. I thought them muting the mics, whatever, they didn't have to do much of that, I think it kept Trump in check, definitely, and it offered people a chance to hear from both sides. No?</s>CUOMO: Absolutely. And brava to the moderator, Kristen -- Kristen Welker.</s>LEMON: I don't think she did a good job.</s>CUOMO: I thought she did a good job.</s>LEMON: No, I think she did a great job.</s>CUOMO: Oh.</s>LEMON: See where I'm going with that? I thought -- I though she did a great job.</s>CUOMO: I thought she did a great job. It would have been shocking if we disagree.</s>CUOMO: And also, you know, I had Karen Finney in the last block say, you know, and it does matter that it is an African-American woman --</s>LEMON: Mm-hmm.</s>CUOMO: -- you know, respects and remembrances to Gwen Ifill --</s>LEMON: Yeah.</s>CUOMO: -- doing the job masterfully, as well.</s>LEMON: Well, I think she -- for me, this is -- and this is all positive, don't take it the wrong way when you write about it, she is a woman of color, a black woman. She is African-American and Native American. And how much more American do you get than being Native American and whatever else there is, right?</s>CUOMO: Mm-hmm.</s>LEMON: So I'm very proud of her. I don't know if she is watching. Kristen, if you are watching or if anybody in her family, I thought she did a great job.</s>CUOMO: How much more disadvantaged an American do you get than African-American and Native American? You know, I mean --</s>LEMON: Yeah.</s>CUOMO: -- it's two representative samples of things that haven't been done right by this country. But she did a good job tonight and that is a really hard job. And I was wrong not to say it sooner. Usually, I don't want to talk about the moderator because let's keep it about them --</s>LEMON: Yeah.</s>CUOMO: -- but you should remember it when it matters and this was one of those times. Now, couple other things I think people got introduced to tonight. Third time was a charm, in terms of these debates. You got to see both men for who they are. And when analyzing that in terms of the president, people know who Joe Biden is. This president tonight showed you something very, very important, that I hope resonates. He was this way tonight because he wanted to be.</s>LEMON: Right.</s>CUOMO: The bombast, the cruelty, the interrupting, the nonsensical statements. That's because he wants to be that way. It's not that it's his style. It's not that he doesn't know. It's what he chooses to be in a moment. Tonight, he was more poised because that's what they told him he needed to be, Don.</s>LEMON: OK. OK. The second time, you were right. Not that he wanted to be that. He had to be.</s>CUOMO: Ah.</s>LEMON: Right? The other thing, I think that -- that's just who he is. I think tonight he had to be this or he would have lost.</s>CUOMO: But that means, those other occasions, he chooses not to be.</s>LEMON: Yeah. I don't disagree with you on that part.</s>CUOMO: He could always be civil. He could always be civil. He could always wait for you to finish, you know.</s>LEMON: But he doesn't.</s>CUOMO: He doesn't. Why? Because he knows it works better for him the other way.</s>LEMON: But I -- but I also think when -- when you're just talking to him and he is unguarded, he shows you who he is.</s>LEMON: You know, when you're sitting down in an interview and you ask him if he's racist, he knows -- I am the least racist -- well, I played it in the last hour -- I am the least racist person. That is his refrain. That's his go-to when it comes to racism. Not an introspective, well, I'm sure, you know, growing up in America and living in America, there is -- there may be some</s>CUOMO: You've never heard him admit a weakness.</s>LEMON: No, never. No. And even when he says, you know, we're the -- we're the best, do you remember when someone asked him about testing negative, and he said --</s>CUOMO: Yeah.</s>LEMON: -- I tested positive --</s>CUOMO: Yeah, for not having it.</s>LEMON: -- and he could get it -- positively negative.</s>CUOMO: Yeah. He can't say bad things about himself.</s>LEMON: Sometimes, I wonder if --</s>CUOMO: He'd never cut it as a Catholic.</s>CUOMO: He can't say anything bad about himself. He's got absolutely no shame in his game.</s>LEMON: Well, he sure held that bible up. Remember, the bible he held up and you're like, wait, what side is that bible?</s>CUOMO: He needs -- he needs to open it.</s>CUOMO: But, you know, what was interesting is he did what he needed to do tonight. What will it mean ultimately? You and I are of the same school of thought on this. Yes, a lot of people make their decision in the last two weeks of an election. I don't think this election.</s>LEMON: No.</s>CUOMO: I think we know who is on which side and now it's which side wants it more.</s>LEMON: And imagine, think about this. You don't have to imagine it. This is the truth. This is what's happening to millions and millions of people in this country. Tonight's debate didn't matter because they have -- they have already cast their votes.</s>CUOMO: Right.</s>LEMON: The ballots are already in. So, the people, you know, the people who needed convincing or where they needed to perform really well for, that was a shrinking -- it's a shrinking pie, right?</s>CUOMO: It is small, but though against my own point, there are people who could have watched tonight and said, you know what, I wasn't going to vote for Biden but, or I wasn't going to vote for Trump but, so it was good for both of them to come out strong. You know, presumptively, you say, when you're ahead in the polls, all you want is a tie. I think Biden certainly got a tie. You know, he's strong where he's strong and he's weak where he's weak and people know that. I don't think this changed that much tonight. But it was because you got such a good sample representative of both men, you got the contrast, as well.</s>LEMON: Mm-hmm.</s>CUOMO: And I think that will be helpful to both their causes.</s>LEMON: You know what's interesting? This is a little bit off but not really off topic.</s>CUOMO: Mm-hmm.</s>LEMON: I was talking to someone the other day and they were talking about Joe Biden. They said, you know, well, you know, sometimes, he has to think about what -- and I said, you know, he's like -- he has -- he overcame a stutter. And then, the person had no idea. And I couldn't imagine at this point in time, as Joe Biden has been on the stage for as long as he's been on the stage and he's been running now for, what, about two years or so, a year and a half or so, that someone would not have that information and think something otherwise about Joe Biden, that he -- they don't realize it. Yes, he's overcome a stutter, but he still has some of the things that go along with that.</s>CUOMO: He still stutters.</s>LEMON: He still stutters, right.</s>CUOMO: Yeah. He doesn't get stuck --</s>LEMON: He doesn't get stuck.</s>CUOMO: -- the way some stutterers do. But look, let's be honest, telling somebody that you're a stutterer isn't the first thing you think to say about yourself. This is a society based on shame, all too often. You know, on judgment, all too often.</s>LEMON: But --</s>CUOMO: And there is stigma attached to it.</s>LEMON: It's also to a part of what's been going on in the country for the last seven or eight months. That people have been trying to figure out what do with their lives, trying to figure out how to feed their families, trying to figure out, you know, how they are going to stretch the meals and stretch the money that's not coming in. And I think they've been -- it's been so -- it's been really hard for many people to pay attention because maybe if things were going OK and you just, you know, you had the luxury of having the job that you had or the income that you had coming in or not a relative who was sick or dying, that you may have been able to pay attention. Usually, people don't pay attention till the end. But I found it fascinating that this person who was extremely informed had -- had no idea. Looked at me and said, what are you talking about? I said, well, he's a stutterer. He overcame a stutter. He said, well, that changes my -- the whole --</s>CUOMO: Right. And we also -- we also -- not you so much, you're actually pretty good at this. I have a tendency to assume much more intensity of interest about this stuff. Most people are passive when it comes to their politics. This is an unusually intense period. But, you know, people live their lives. They do other things. They don't watch us, you know, 24/7. Some do. Most -- they watch you more, but they, you know, most don't do that. You know what I thought was interesting tonight?</s>LEMON: What?</s>CUOMO: A juxtaposition between the president being able to identify all the different tolls that the pandemic is putting on people's lives, to the point you were just making.</s>LEMON: Mm-hmm.</s>CUOMO: Increase in abusive behavior.</s>LEMON: Right.</s>CUOMO: Domestic abuse, abuse of substances, mental health problems, different health problems that aren't being attended to because of the strain on the health care system. And yet, he doesn't --</s>LEMON: Alcoholism, addiction.</s>CUOMO: Sure. Substance abuse is up and understandably so. But, he does not make a connection to that and the need for him to get off his ass and get more aggressive in taking on this pandemic. I thought that was interesting. And it was tied up with a bow for me with what we started off with tonight, just so you think that Don and I didn't randomly decide to make fun of Abraham Lincoln. It came up in the debate tonight. And of all the things Biden accused Trump of, this is what he reacted to most indignantly.</s>DONALD TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: Nobody has done more for the black community than Donald Trump. And if you look, with the exception of Abraham Lincoln, possible exception, but the exception of Abraham Lincoln, nobody has done what I've done.</s>JOE BIDEN (D) PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATE: Abraham Lincoln here is one of the most racist presidents we've had in modern history. He pours fuel on every single racist fire, every single one. Started off his campaign coming down the escalator saying he's going to get rid of those Mexican rapists. He's banned Muslims because they're Muslims. He has moved around and made everything worse across the board. He says to -- about the poor boys, last time we were on stage here, he said, I told them to stand down and stand ready. Come on. This guy is a dog whistle about as big as a foghorn.</s>TRUMP: You made a reference to Abraham Lincoln. Where did that come in? I mean --</s>BIDEN: You said you're Abraham Lincoln.</s>TRUMP: No, where did that -- no, no.</s>BIDEN: You said --</s>TRUMP: I said not since Abraham Lincoln has anybody done what I've done for the black community.</s>BIDEN: And --</s>TRUMP: I didn't say I'm Abraham Lincoln. I said, not since Abraham Lincoln has anybody done what I've done for the black community.</s>LEMON: Look at captain accuracy over here, all of a sudden.</s>LEMON: No one has done for the blacks.</s>CUOMO: With the possible exception of Abraham Lincoln. Imagine you saying --</s>LEMON: Wait, wait, wait</s>LEMON: Say, what?</s>CUOMO: Can you imagine? It's like Don Lemon saying, maybe, with the exception of Martin Luther King, possibly --</s>CUOMO: -- nobody has communicated, as an African-American, the way I have.</s>CUOMO: And, you know, he can -- he can say that, you know. And then he gets indignant. I never said I was Abraham Lincoln.</s>CUOMO: Of all the things that he lies about and gets called out about, this is the one he needed to correct.</s>LEMON: This is what I'll say. Everyone -- when he does that, everyone is like</s>LEMON: Has anyone ever told him -- seriously, shouldn't someone in his campaign say --</s>LEMON: -- you need to stop? Like, don't do that.</s>CUOMO: They only tell him more. You know, we've heard all these stories about people who try to keep him on the right track. Look, I have, again, you know, this weird time we're living on, paradoxically, while I am demonized, very often, by this president specifically, I have never had better access to a White House than I have to this one in terms of understanding what's going on around him from people who know him well.</s>LEMON: Because they call you and they tell you.</s>CUOMO: And they do not push him. He doesn't want to hear it. He doesn't trust them. And he believes his gut is better. And he then listens to people who are telling him he is doing well. He is focused 100 percent right now on the people who are telling him, we're doing better in Florida in early voting than we were doing last time.</s>LEMON: Yeah.</s>CUOMO: You're going -- you're going to do well. Arizona, we're a little worried about, but here in North Carolina, this is going to lead us to Pennsylvania. That's all he hears. And the messaging they tell him goes with it is all he'll follow today.</s>LEMON: Well, it's so easily provable about, you know, when he says he's done more for African-Americans. I mean, this is -- it's just -- you know it's ridiculous because when you think about it he likes to say, well, you know Joe Biden and Barack Obama didn't do anything. Well, if you look at actually what is in the Affordable Care Act and pre-existing conditions, all you have to do is compare that to what's happening now with the pandemic, and look at the people who are contracting it and dying or coming in contact with this disease and dying proportionately higher than other people. It is African-Americans. It is minorities and people who are on the front lines, people who don't have an access, as much access to the health care system. That is certainly something that is a positive for African-Americans. And if you actually look at the unemployment rate, the trajectory of the unemployment rate, up or down, the longest decline in unemployment was under President Barack Obama. This president simply kept it on track. For him to say that, I think that's why African-Americans get so annoyed when he says things like that because we know the truth. He is not pulling the wool over our eyes.</s>CUOMO: True.</s>LEMON: We know what happened under the last administration.</s>LEMON: Who happened to come out -- listen, under a Republican president, pulled us out of the -- the biggest recession since the great recession, since the depression, and then to have that sort of job growth and then the rate go down, and then you want to take away something, an accomplishment, of the first black person who looks like me or every other black person around the country --</s>CUOMO: Desperately.</s>CUOMO: Yeah, they're not going to --</s>CUOMO: He wants to --</s>LEMON: Yeah, but they're not --</s>CUOMO: He wants to take Obama down desperately.</s>LEMON: We are not going to buy it. We are not going to buy it because we know the truth.</s>CUOMO: Well --</s>LEMON: You can sell that to your sycophants but you can't sell that to --</s>CUOMO: We'll see what happens with African-American men, specifically. With African-American women over 45, which is a big base for the Democrats, I don't know how much purchase he'll get there.</s>LEMON: I think that's -- listen. I am not buying that.</s>CUOMO: You don't buy it, either. You think it is talk but that at the polls, they won't do it.</s>LEMON: Listen, there -- look --</s>LEMON: No, no, there are outliers everywhere. We're looking at like three -- two rappers who are gazillionaires, right, and some</s>LEMON: Let me sit you down here. Our moms are going to be, like, boy, if you go and vote for -- don't come in this house because I'm going to disown you. You're not doing this. I don't believe it. I'm sure there are going to be some bamboozled who may go out and do that. But for the most part, it is not gonna happen, ain't gonna happen. Sorry. It's a good story. It is a good, you know, to write a copy and for people to talk about on TV, like me and you. But in the real world --</s>LEMON: -- in the real world, it ain't happening.</s>CUOMO: Well, I'll tell you what will be interesting to me.</s>LEMON: And let me just say one other thing.</s>CUOMO: OK.</s>LEMON: Before -- all those people that you hear on all of those channels, the conservative people and all of them, like, I'll find out. You know what that is? You know what that is?</s>CUOMO: What is it?</s>LEMON: That is the shortest line to the front. OK? Those are people who are sitting there on Fox News and everybody else, black -- oh, Donald Trump has done this. They don't believe that themselves. They're there because it is the shortest line to the front and it's a paycheck. OK? And they probably could not make it on some other channel that -- where people live in reality and people live in facts. So, they say, well, guess what? I'm going to go over here because they need a black person who's going to say what the conservatives want, who's going to give me a paycheck and have me on their show, I'm going to be famous, and people are going to know who I am. That is exactly what that is, even if they are not conscious of it. Because if they really, really sat down and looked in the mirror, they would see that they are being used.</s>CUOMO: Well, 11 days. Anthony Scaramucci, with the line of the night, he called it. We're in the last Scaramucci of the race. The last 11 days. Remember, he lasted 11 days as (inaudible) the White House. We're going to see. And again, I know that people always tell you, this election matters the most. Hype aside --</s>LEMON: This one does.</s>CUOMO: This is an unusually definitional election because the proposition is just about, look, the idea of whether or not this country really is going to suffer each other's differences for the sake of diversity or not and see each other as us and them and have policy along those lines. The president made it very clear to you tonight, he is not a uniter. He doesn't believe it. He wants to punish states that are run by Democrats because he doesn't like the job they're doing.</s>LEMON: It's terrible.</s>CUOMO: He named my brother by name.</s>LEMON: Terrible.</s>CUOMO: He talks about red and blue and us and them and Muslims and Christians and brown and white. That's what he does. And we'll see what wins.</s>LEMON: And very fine people on both sides, and you know, let's jail the Central Park Five and President Barack Obama was not born in this country and what do you have to lose and where is my African-American and -- all kinds of things. And that's why I say, if you want to be bamboozled and think that --</s>CUOMO: Led astray? Run amok?</s>LEMON: If you want to believe that a person who did and said all of these things, who is trying to take away your health care, the pre- existing conditions, all those things, if you believe that, then I got a bridge to sell you --</s>CUOMO: You've been had.</s>LEMON: -- or I'm going to get the license plate --</s>CUOMO: You've been took.</s>LEMON: -- of the turnip truck that --</s>CUOMO: Bamboozled.</s>LEMON: -- you just fell off, so that I can report them --</s>CUOMO: Led astray.</s>LEMON: -- to the authorities.</s>CUOMO: Run amok.</s>CUOMO: It's from Malcolm</s>X. LEMON: Fooled. Crazy.</s>CUOMO: You've been had. You've been took.</s>CUOMO: Led astray. Run amok. Best I can do. Vis-a-vis Denzel Washington.</s>LEMON: I will tell you something after this --</s>LEMON: -- that I want to tell you, that you will be happy that I didn't say it. OK.</s>CUOMO: Go ahead.</s>LEMON: And that's a fact. And here is a fact checker in chief, Daniel Dale, to get Chris Cuomo out of trouble.</s>LEMON: He's back with us.</s>LEMON: Hey, Daniel. How you doing? Are you hoarse yet? Do you have laryngitis from all of this?</s>DANIEL DALE, CNN REPORTER: No, I'm good to talk to you for at least like two to three more minutes.</s>LEMON: OK. So, here is -- this is something that was really -- that is really serious, an awful story that I reported earlier this week. I think it was last night that we reported this. In the midst of all of this that we are finding out, that there were these -- there are these 545 migrant children who still aren't returned or reunited with their families. The president dodged the question, suggested that they weren't actually brought over by their parents. And then, the moderator had to keep asking him. How are you going to reunite these families? Here it is. Check this out.</s>BIDEN: These 500-plus kids came with parents. They separated them at the border to make it a disincentive to come, to begin with. They -- real tough, were really strong. And guess what? They cannot -- it's not -- coyotes didn't bring them over. Their parents were with them. They got separated from their parents. And it makes us a laughing stock and violates every notion of who we are as a nation.</s>KRISTEN WELKER, NBC NEWS WHITE HOUSE CORRESPONDENT (voice-over): Let me ask you a follow-up question.</s>TRUMP: Kristen, they did it. We changed the policy.</s>WELKER: Your response to that?</s>TRUMP: They did it. We changed --</s>BIDEN: We did not --</s>TRUMP: They built the cages. They -- who built the cages, Joe?</s>BIDEN: Let's talk about --</s>TRUMP: Who built the cages, Joe?</s>BIDEN: Let's talk about what we're talking about. What happened? Parents were -- the kids were ripped from their arms and separated. And now, they cannot find over 500 sets of those parents and those kids are alone. Nowhere to go. Nowhere to go. It's criminal. It's criminal.</s>LEMON: OK, Daniel. Just the facts.</s>DALE: So, Biden was right here and Trump was wrong. These particular children were not brought to the United States by so-called coyotes, who are people who are paid by parents or paid by people in other countries to illegally bring others across the border. Biden was right. These children were brought by their parents. They were separated. And now, the parents and children remain separated. They can't find the parents. Now, there are -- Trump also claimed, during the debate, that the administration is working hard to find these parents. Experts say that's not actually true. They've been very reluctant to hand over information about the situation. Now, the part of this that was true, as Trump said, you know, there were cages built under the Obama administration, in a very different situation. During influx of undocumented -- unaccompanied minors, they did build these facilities with chain-link fences -- you can call them cages -- to house some of these young people. But Trump's suggestion, elsewhere in this debate, that he simply inherited the separation policy, he said, they did it, we just took it and we changed it, is wrong. It happened, occasionally, under Obama, under specific circumstances, like parents charged with serious crimes. Trump's administration is the one that made it routine. They implemented a routine policy of routinely separating --</s>LEMON: Separating, right.</s>DALE: -- children and parents at the border. And so, it's very much apples and oranges. Trump's suggestion is just not right.</s>LEMON: Yeah. Well, he likes to say, well, you built the cages but it doesn't explain the difference between what is going on now. They are wilfully and doing it systematically or had bee, now they changed their policy, of separating children from their parents. And the evidence of it, if one plus one equals two, well, this now equals 545 families that they cannot find the parents -- they cannot find families for. Those are the facts. So, listen. Daniel, Trump also tried to hit Biden with Russia. He claimed Biden received $3.5 million from Russia and that it's meddling to defeat him. And then Biden hit back. Listen to this.</s>TRUMP: Joe got three and a half million dollars from Russia. And it came through Putin because he was very friendly with the former mayor of Moscow. And it was the mayor of Moscow's wife. And you got three and a half million dollars.</s>BIDEN: I have not taken a penny from any foreign source, ever, in my life. We learned that this president paid 50 times the tax in China, has a secret bank account with China, does business in China, and in fact, he is talking about me taking money? I have not taken a single penny from any country, whatsoever, ever.</s>LEMON: So what's the truth about Biden and Russia?</s>DALE: So, Don, this is an example of what I think of as Trump- flation. It is how he takes a previous claim, often false, and inflates it, you know, beyond the original recognition. So the initial allegation, which has denied by Hunter Biden, this allegation made by Senate Republicans, is that Hunter Biden, Joe Biden's son, received 3.5 million in a business deal/consulting deal with the wife of the late mayor of Moscow. Now, again, Hunter Biden said he didn't get this money, not affiliated with the firm and didn't get the money. But regardless, that's not what Trump said. Trump said that Joe Biden got the money and it came through Putin. There is no allegation from Senate Republicans.</s>DALE: There is no allegation from anyone, as far as I know, until tonight, that Joe Biden received this payment. So this is, again, the president taking a kernel of something and turning it into something much bigger and more dramatic that's just not true.</s>LEMON: This is going to get worse over the next 11 days, Daniel. And I think that we are going to have to be dealing with -- actually, you may need a helper. And I'm serious with that.</s>DALE: We have a team.</s>LEMON: But this is going to get worse over the next 11 days because there are so many things out there. I think Jake Tapper pointed to this earlier, about sort of the -- the conspiracy theories that are being propagated on the right that weren't necessarily talked about in this debate, not necessarily being talked about in legitimate media, but they are certainly doing it in conservative media because the president is behind.</s>DALE: Yeah. It's getting worse and worse, Don. I mean, the president himself is getting worse. I counted 66 separate -- not even counting the repeats -- separate false claims from the president alone between Friday and Sunday. That's one of the most dishonest periods of his entire presidency. Social media like Twitter is just a disaster zone right now with misleading clips and images. Just total bad-faith tweets. And so, yeah, the information climate is just absolutely terrible. And frankly, a lot of it comes from the president himself.</s>LEMON: Daniel Dale, thank you, sir. Really appreciate it. There's more to come as our special coverage of the final presidential debate continues right here on CNN late night, after dark.
Trump: "I'd Like To Terminate Obamacare" Vows To Protect Those With Pre-Existing Conditions.
TRUMP: What we'd like to do is terminate it. We have the individual mandate, done. I don't know that it's going to work. If we don't win, we will have to run it and we'll have Obamacare but it'll be better run. But it no longer is Obamacare, because without the individual mandate it's much different. Preexisting conditions will always stay. What I would like to do is a much better healthcare - much better, we'll always protect people with preexisting. So I'd like to terminate Obamacare, come up with a brand new beautiful healthcare always protecting people with preexisting conditions.</s>DON LEMON, CNN HOST: All right, well let's get some thoughts on all that. Jennifer Granholm is here Amanda Carpenter, Mike Shields as well. Good evening. Good morning. OK, Amanda, seriously, did you understand what he was saying there?</s>AMANDA CARPENTER, FORMER COMMUNICATIONS DIRECTOR FOR SENATOR TED CRUZ: Sort of, but you know we could talk about the policy this debate but this debate wasn't about policy.</s>CARPENTER: This debate marked the complete utter total collapse of President Trump's strategy against Joe Biden, which was to smear him with all this nonsense about Hunter Biden's finances. That collapsed tonight, OK? He's been trying this for years. It's what he got impeached for. And he couldn't land a single argument on Biden about it. So yes, his campaign is going to keep pushing this, but I think everyone that was on this train needed to look at what Donald Trump did tonight, and he just made a mess of it. And so I think we need to stick that come conspiracy into the ground on Halloween, put a headstone on it, and dance all over it.</s>LEMON: Amanda! Well, Mr. Shields, Amanda came in hard. What do you think of that? She's not even talking about the health care, she came in hot and she is got her at own agenda.</s>MIKE SHIELDS, CNN POLITICAL COMMENTATOR: The fact that she led off with that means that it may have served some purpose because up until three days ago, a lot of people in the media weren't even talking about this story. And now she wants to talk about it so much - Hunter Biden.</s>CARPENTER: I've written about, I have watched this conspiracy theory. It is so much junk and you know it, Mike, you know it.</s>SHIELDS: Keep talking about it. I mean, you are talking about Hunter Biden. That's what the president wanted you to be doing. So that's exactly.</s>LEMON: People don't really know what it is.</s>CARPENTER: You can't explain it Mike, you wouldn't touch it with a 10 football.</s>LEMON: That's what I said earlier tonight that people you needed a decoder book to try to figure it out. Jennifer, let me bring you in here. What do you think of tonight? I started off with health care, because and I think it's important to talk about it, but look, you and Amanda Carpenter, talk about whatever you want. I think thought it's important to talk about it especially we are dealing with, we're in the middle of a pandemic right now.</s>JENNIFER GRANHOLM, CNN SENIOR POLITICAL COMMENTATOR: Of course. Of course and of course, yet again, the president does not have a plan. Now he's going to wait until after the Supreme Court knocks Obamacare out. But in the meantime, what happens to all these people who would be losing their health care in the middle of a pandemic? I thought that Joe Biden on this health care series, whether it was COVID or health care in general, was so clear. He came out of the box. There are 220,000 people who have - who have died. We have got now 1000 people a day. We've got now who are dying, almost 70,000 people. He had all of these numbers that were right on the money, and the whole point about the economy which Donald Trump keeps coming back to. First of all, Donald Trump had no empathy for any of the 220,000 people who were dying. And to me, if you step back and you look at this whole debate and who expressed a desire to come through this and an understanding of where real people were, it was obviously Joe Biden. And Donald Trump had no shred of empathy. And Don, you and I have talked about our mothers. So I call my mom, who is to let people know, she is 85-year-old, lives in the suburbs, a Former Republican I said, I didn't even have to - I call her mom, did you locked. He's a horrible person! Those were the only words. And what do you mean, mom? She said like, he is horrible! She's talking about Trump. And she cannot stand him, because he does not have a single shred of empathy. And that's what I think a lot of people who are not in the way who - she did not know what the heck he was talking about laptops and China and Russia and all that. She didn't even understand what they were talking about, she did get that he had no empathy.</s>LEMON: I didn't quite understand when he said - when he talked about, well, you know, I'm going to the pre-existing but the individual mandate but then I'm going to coming up with a beautiful health plan. Mike, listen. I know you're straight shooter OK. He has been saying he is going to come up with the health care plan since 2015. He's been saying, it's going to be shortly, it's going to be two weeks, it's going to be a month, it's going to be soon, it's going to be - come on, where the lie? I'm not lying here Mike. Especially now during a pandemic, does that ring even more hollow, because people want to know, what's the plan? And so far he has no plan.</s>SHIELDS: Yes, look. I don't think Republicans have done a great job of coming up with an alternative to Obamacare. That has been a huge problem for them. We ran on getting rid of Obamacare and replacing it and the replacing part was very difficult. I think the president's better message on health care is to talk about the Biden health care plan, which would get rid of private health insurance and is closer to single payer Medicare for all healthcare plans.</s>LEMON: I'm going to have to mute your mic Jennifer.</s>GRANHOLM: Sorry, sorry. You're just doing the same thing the president is doing.</s>LEMON: --I'll give you time to respond. Mike, go on, finish yours.</s>SHIELDS: I respectfully - interrupt you. I must have hit something that you don't want me to say if you interrupt me like that because that to me what I'm trying to tell you is that would be a better message for the president than - what he said, so I'm sure you might agree with it at least part of that.</s>LEMON: Go ahead, Jennifer.</s>GRANHOLM: Can I?</s>LEMON: Yes, yes you can. Your mic is un-muted.</s>GRANHOLM: Mike, I don't understand why you are repeating the lie. Joe Biden's plan is not to eliminate private health insurance. As he said repeatedly tonight, I ran against that idea, and I want it in the primary. He wants to allow people to keep the private sector plans. But he also wants to be able to create an option. So I don't - I mean, I don't understand why this continual emphasis on a doubling down on a lie. He hasn't say that.</s>SHIELDS: Well, I can answer that; I can answer that for you. I can answer that for you. Nancy Pelosi said it. She said, improving Obamacare which is the Biden plan is a step two Medicare for all and single payer health care. And she is the Speaker of the House.</s>LEMON: But Joe Biden did say tonight. Joe Biden did say tonight. Mike, Mike, Mike let me in so I helped you with the mute mic thing. But Joe Biden did say tonight, all of those things that you are talking about, you are running against Joe Biden. I've never said that. You are talking about everybody else is health care plan. What they want to do with it, what their interpretation of it. What he is saying, his health care plan won't do that.</s>SHIELDS: Yes, I'm sure - of course, you're bashing the president for not giving specifics. Joe Biden is saying this health care plan won't do that and yet he is for improving Obamacare, which Nancy Pelosi said is basically a step to single pair. We all know, in fact I'll make a bet with you Governor. If Democrats win the presidency, the White House - excuse me, the Senate and the House, then by the spring there will be a single payer health care bill on the floor and the left wing of the party will demand that it becomes law and be put on Joe Biden's desk.</s>CARPENTER: That won't happen because Republicans haven't done anything since Obamacare was made into law in 2010. So congratulations, Republicans, you had 10 years.</s>LEMON: Great. Keep going Amanda?</s>SHIELDS: I actually don't disagree with you on that.</s>GRANHOLM: Amanda you're on a roll.</s>CARPENTER: I was in the Senate, I try to re-appeal it and get a plan to replace it. I was part of that. How long do expect people to wait? Because I am in the camp of someone on the private market that really wants a strong private health care market. So I can get affordable health care. Where have the Republicans been? I have been waiting for that plan to show up, and I am fearful to Mike of what may happen that the Democrats have a socialist health care system, but who can I turn to for help? It sure is heck has not been the Trump Administration.</s>LEMON: Well I was just going to say when you said that, well let's imagine if the Democrats win the presidency, the House, and the Senate, there are conservatives who are watching, going no, Mike, don't say that! And Amanda is really is vocalizing that right now. So I mean, what happens? She's right, it has been a decade, and Republicans still have not come up with a plan. And this president, honestly, hasn't come up with a plan. I know you are criticizing Joe Biden, for you know, the president saying, OK, it's going to be two weeks, it's going to be whatever - but Joe Biden - there is a actual plan there that people can read, whether you agree with it or not. But there isn't one for this administration. There's not one.</s>SHIELDS: Is that question to me?</s>LEMON: Yes.</s>SHIELDS: You know look, I mean, if you hear what the president said, he says we administer Obamacare better. And in fact, under President Trump, Obamacare premiums have gone down. He's in a place where he can't - if you guys would let me talk, I may actually agree with you for a month. OK.</s>CARPENTER: Well, we may have comment about what you're saying.</s>SHIELDS: What I'm saying is that he can't say you know what? We didn't get a replacement done, we just didn't get it done, and so now I'm left in saying, we will protect pre-existing condition coverage and we're going to administer Obamacare better. That's a part of what his message is because as Amanda said, Republicans drop the bomb and we didn't get a replacement bill done. And I think a better message from the president has to talk about what will happen because to bring voters like Amanda back to the president, all they need to know is you're going to get socialized medicine when the left takes over and that will bring them back to the camp that's what he should be saying in the debate.</s>CARPENTER: Yes, good luck with that. I can't leave my house or send my kids to school because of how he has handled the health care system.</s>LEMON: Jennifer I got it wrong.</s>CARPENTER: You are so desperate for anything that will take a plan over no plan.</s>LEMON: Can you do it in 10 seconds, Jennifer?</s>GRANHOLM: I was just going to say, there's one other tabletop issue that I think - kitchen table issues that people really care about that I thought Joe Biden handled really well which is raising the minimum wage which is at $7.25 an hour, on the federal level, which no one can live on. Add I think that strikes a chord across America.</s>LEMON: That's a whole another show but I - listen, just someone here, I remember I think it was 3.35 an hour for me, when I started out, and I think I remember when it was lower.</s>GRANHOLM: OK, grandpa.</s>LEMON: I know, you guys, you don't remember 3.35? I was like, well, - minimum wage. Thank you guys I appreciate it. See you soon. So Chris, are you there?</s>CUOMO: I'm listening.</s>LEMON: OK, so here's the thing. The reason I talked so much about the health care plan is obviously because we're in the middle of a pandemic right now.</s>LEMON: And people are relying - people need medical health and medical attention and they need access to the health care system. And so by saying, you know, I'm going to do this, I'm going to do this, and I'm going to do this that does not help people who are right now entangled in the health care system in America.</s>CUOMO: First of all, the issue decided the midterm elections. Health care matters. We need to do better. What's the complete truth? The ACA, Obamacare, was never done a done deal. It was supposed to be worked on overtime. The Republicans wouldn't do it. Mitch McConnell specifically said we are never going to do anything to get rid of it. That never happened. So there's nothing better, it hasn't been perfected, and the problem keeps getting worse, especially for the pandemic. We have real problems. Which direction will this country take to solve them?</s>LEMON: We'll see in the next 11 days maybe will no, we don't know. I always enjoy hanging out with you my friend.</s>CUOMO: I'll tell you what, it's nice to do it on TV, it's nice to do it off. I wouldn't want to do it with these hours, with anyone else. Take us home brother. Take us home.</s>LEMON: Thanks for, watching everyone. A special encore presentation of the Final Presidential Debate is next. Right here on CNN. We'll see you tomorrow.
Six States See Highest Case Count
HARLOW: So, look at this, more than 71,000 new COVID cases were confirmed in the country just yesterday.</s>SCIUTTO: Yes, sadly, the fourth worst day since the pandemic began. Thirty-two states sadly seeing a spike, six of them had their worst day of new infections ever. Goodness. CNN's senior medical correspondent Elizabeth Cohen is here. Elizabeth, what's behind this combination, rather, of factors, fatigue, people being indoors more? Why are we seeing this?</s>ELIZABETH COHEN, CNN MEDICAL CORRESPONDENT: I think you just named the two big ones, Jim, that people are having fatigue. It is tough to keep up these measures, although it is so, so important. And also, as the weather gets colder, more people are going indoors. So what used to be a picnic or a barbecue where you could be outside and spaced apart, now those people are all in one person's living room and that is not good, even if you are wearing a mask. That is problematic. Let's take a look at these trends. So if you look at this map, you can see, 32 states are in orange or dark red. I mean they really -- that's a lot of states in orange. And that means that those states are going up, the cases are going up, more last week than the previous week. The yellow ones, the numbers are stable. There's only one state headed in the right direction, only one state where the numbers are going down, and that's Oregon. Now, let's take a look, six states are showing their highest daily case count ever. Six states, Ohio, Indiana, Illinois, Oklahoma, Montana and Utah, more cases than they've ever had during this pandemic. And it's not just a matter of cases, it's also, sadly, a matter of deaths. If you take a look, 28 states, they -- their death rates are going up. Ten of those states, they're going up by more than 50 percent. Deaths are going up by more than 50 percent in ten states. The yellow states, the death rates are holding steady. The green states that they -- the deaths are, thank goodness, going down. Jim. Poppy.</s>HARLOW: Elizabeth, a major move by the FDA yesterday, and that is authorizing the use of Remdesivir for patients hospitalized with coronavirus. People may know this because the president took it. How big is that authorization, but also, is there enough supply for anyone who needs it in the country right now and how expensive is it? Like can everyone afford it?</s>COHEN: Those are great questions because I'll tell you, this approval from the FDA in many ways is technicality. It got an emergency approval back in May and now it's getting sort of the full regular FDA approval. However, there are a couple of questions here. One is about efficacy. In the meantime, the World Health Organization came out with a study that was bigger than the original study that was done that got Remdesivir its approval. The new one says it doesn't work. The old one said, oh, it cuts a few days off of a hospital stay. This new World Health Organization one says it just doesn't work. Now, Gilead, the company that makes Remdesivir, says, oh, that WHO study, and they sort of poke holes in it. But, still, a concern that this drug is too pricey. Also concerns that there isn't enough of this drug to go around for everybody. Poppy. Jim.</s>HARLOW: Yes, I mean, those are two big issues for folks who might rely on it.</s>SCIUTTO: Yes.</s>HARLOW: Elizabeth, thanks a lot for the reporting. Have a good weekend.</s>COHEN: Thanks.</s>HARLOW: So in an hour, we're going to be joined by a very important guest, Health and Human Services Secretary Alex Azar will be with us, obviously leading the country's charge on handling</s>COVID. SCIUTTO: Yes, what are they going to do about this surge going forward? Another story in hour, North Carolina, of course a critical state at play in this election, but some voters there, they remained undivided, some of the few, you might say. We spoke with a group of them to see if last night's debate changed their minds.
North Carolina Voters React to Debate
HARLOW: All right, the battleground state of North Carolina, where more than 2.4 million voters in that state alone have already cast their ballots.</s>SCIUTTO: I mean it's amazing. And we're seeing this across the country.</s>HARLOW: Yes.</s>SCIUTTO: Well, polls in North Carolina show Democrats maintaining a narrow lead in early voting across that state, but were the undecideds, the few remaining undecideds swayed by last night's debate? CNN's Gary Tuchman, he asked undecideds.</s>GARY TUCHMAN, CNN CORRESPONDENT (voice over): Four of them identify as Democrats, three as Republicans, four as independents, all of these North Carolinians still not sure which candidate they want to be president. We watched the final debate with them. The group leaving no doubt who they think did best.</s>TUCHMAN (on camera): Who do you think won the debate? How many of you think Donald Trump won this debate? OK, no hands being raised for that. How many of you think Joe Biden won the debate? One, two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight, nine. How many of you feel it was a draw? Two. Two for a draw. Zero for Trump. Nine for Biden.</s>TUCHMAN (voice over): So why did this group feel Joe Biden did so well? James voted for Donald Trump in 2016 but is now concerned about the nation's lack of unity.</s>TUCHMAN (on camera): What do you think the most important moment of this debate was?</s>JAMES, NORTH CAROLINA VOTER: Definitely when Joe Biden was talking about that he's going to be an American president because Donald Trump has made it clear that he doesn't support the blue states.</s>TUCHMAN (voice over): John also voted for President Trump in 2016. Joe Biden's debate comments about American families around the dinner table meant quite a bit to him.</s>JOHN, NORTH CAROLINA VOTER: And Trump responded with some mockery of that and I think for me politics are about relationships and people. And this is all about the American family. So that was quite revealing and disturbing for me to hear.</s>TUCHMAN: Teri (ph) voted for Hillary Clinton four years ago but has been undecided because she did not like Joe Biden's role in the 1994 crime bill. But after the debate, she feels differently.</s>TERI, NORTH CAROLINA VOTER: So what resonated with me was the fact that Joe Biden owned the crime bill and his role in the crime bill, and that he owned the fact that they made a mistake.</s>TUCHMAN: Nathan voted for Donald Trump in 2016 and is one of the two who feels the debate was a draw. He says the economy must continue opening.</s>NATHAN, NORTH CAROLINA VOTER: Both of them want to open it. I think we need to open faster than slower, not wait for the coronavirus to go away.</s>TUCHMAN (on camera): So that was an important point for you?</s>NATHAN: It is important, yes.</s>TUCHMAN: That the president made?</s>NATHAN: Yes.</s>TUCHMAN (voice over): When it comes to the major question, are any of the 11 now ready to make a decision on who should be president, no response was more interesting than this one from Harrison.</s>HARRISON, NORTH CAROLINA VOTER: Well, I'd like to vote for Joe Biden, almost totally, except for the fact that he is going to increase abortion access in America. And so if, you know -- I'll feel a little bit safer about that not happening if Amy Barrett is on the Supreme Court.</s>TUCHMAN (on camera): So if she is confirmed, you'll vote for Biden most likely?</s>HARRISON: Yes.</s>TUCHMAN (voice over): So how many of these 11 voters are now ready to cast their votes following this debate? The answer is seven.</s>TUCHMAN (on camera): Of the seven of you who say you're ready to cast your votes, how many are ready to vote for Donald Trump? Zero. How many are ready to vote for Joe Biden? All seven.</s>TUCHMAN (voice over): As far as the other four, the debates are over, but their indecisiveness is not. Gary Tuchman, CNN, Davidson, North Carolina.</s>HARLOW: What a fascinating piece by Gary. Thank you for that reporting. So ahead for us, there are Republicans that are pointing to one particular moment in the debate last night that they think could hurt Joe Biden in certain states. We'll tell you what that is, next.
Trump and Biden Spar over Oil Industry.
HARLOW: Welcome back. So there are some Republicans really pointing to this moment in last night's debate, let' play the tape, and we'll explain why after.</s>DONALD TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: The oil industry.</s>UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: It falls (ph) --</s>JOE BIDEN (D), PRESIDENTIAL NOMINEE: By the way, I have a transition from the oil industry, yes. I will transition --</s>TRUMP: Oh, that's a big statement.</s>BIDEN: That is a big statement. Because the oil industry pollutes significantly.</s>TRUMP: Oh, I see.</s>BIDEN: And here's the deal.</s>TRUMP: That's a big statement.</s>BIDEN: You can't do that -- well, if you let me finish the statement, because it has to be replaced by renewable energy, over time, over time. And I'd stop giving to the oil industry. I'd stop giving them federal subsidies.</s>TRUMP: Oh.</s>BIDEN: He won't give federal --</s>SCIUTTO: Joe Biden later clarified his stance, but this could impact him with voters in key states that rely on the oil and gas industry. CNN correspondent Bill Weir joins us now. Bill, listen to that comment there. I mean you're deep into the climate change issue here. Tell us about the political implications.</s>BILL WEIR, CNN CLIMATE CHANGE CORRESPONDENT: Well, it's interesting, Jim. Yes, ever since Hillary Clinton lost coal country and was sort of tagged as a warrior against those workers, the Biden campaign has been very careful not to scare away Pennsylvania frackers. Now, for anybody who remotely cares about land and water and animals and climates, this is an obvious choice. They live in two different planets. In planet Trump, there are no gigi (ph) fires out west, Miami is not flooding, there are no experts telling us that this is just the beginning of a new normal. And the reality is, back here on planet earth, that a renewable energy company just last week was more valuable than Exxon Mobil. The International Energy Association just put out their report that says solar projects are now perhaps the cheapest form of energy ever invented. So we're on a tipping point right now and the Biden campaign is trying to temper any -- any big, seismic changes that might scare people away saying it will take time, but there's not a lot of time. He wants to decarbonize the electricity sector in just the next 15 years, be net zero for the whole country. And just for perspective, it took this county about 100 years to lay out its energy grid. By some estimates, that will have to be done two and a half times over to make it a smart grid. So it was just a clear choice last night between Biden, who calls this an existential threat and tempers the nightmare with the dream of all these green jobs, and Donald Trump, who continues to just hit it gusher after gusher of lies and misinformation and insistence that we stay on these old, dirty fuels.</s>HARLOW: Bill, the president also made a claim last night that I've heard the vice president, Mike Pence, make before that is just not true. He said again that the U.S. has the cleanest air and water. I think it's actually like 16th on the list, right?</s>WEIR: Exactly. And it's getting worse since this administration completely dismantled the enforcement arm of the Environmental Protection Agency, rolled back dozens of clean air and water provisions. And as a point of comparison, he said, look at India, look at China, look at Russia, they're filthy, without any sort of self-awareness that the reason our environment is clear here is a result of the Clean Air and Water Act and the EPA, created by Richard Nixon. So it would be much worse if it wasn't for those sorts of things. But it's been the Republican platform for a long time that all environmental regulation is bad. But you're seeing it, especially in communities of color. And that was what brought up the sort of real candid moment about Joe Biden transitioning away from fossil fuel, which everybody is saying, but the fact that he would say it out loud as a president debate is news.</s>SCIUTTO: Yes.</s>WEIR: But he talked about growing up, you know, near these big oil refineries in Delaware and having oil on the windshield. That's when Trump pounced. That's when Biden says, we have to get off these fuels.</s>SCIUTTO: Yes. Remarkable what the public statement means about where the debate has moved in the country. Bill Weir, thanks very much. Well, on the same day that the U.S. saw its greatest number of new coronavirus infections in several months, President Trump again says we, as a country, are turning the corner and that the virus will go away. What do the facts say?
Interview with HHS Secretary Alex Azar
ALEX AZAR, SECRETARY OF HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES: And in particular, being careful in household gatherings. This has become a major vector of disease spread.</s>JIM SCIUTTO, CNN ANCHOR: Would it help, then -- would it not help if the president spoke honestly and said, listen, this is serious, it's not getting better. We need you as Americans to take this seriously, to keep those masks on -- as you say -- to not do the opposite, which is to kind of give up on the protections that are necessary.</s>AZAR: Well, nobody's giving up on those protections. I'm here as his secretary of Health, speaking for him and I'm saying to the American people, this is the time, more than ever, to be vigilant. We're in so much of a better place than we were just months ago. You know, in April, if you were 70 and above and you got infected with COVID, you had a 30 percent-plus chance of perishing. Now, thanks to Operation Warp Speed under the president, thanks to Remdesivir, steroids, convalescent plasma, better treatment protocols, that has been reduced to well under 10 percent. And we literally are weeks to months away from next-generation monoclonal antibody therapies that'll treat and prevent disease, and vaccines that will eventually get us out of this.</s>SCIUTTO: And you're right, and we've talked about a lot of those developments on this broadcast. Because we are making progress as a country, and the health community is making progress. I do, for a moment, though, want to look back here, just about taking responsibility. Not to emphasize the negative, but to look back at -- there's a study, one of these models out there that has looked back and said, listen, if the U.S. had been more aggressive from the beginning, if the president had been more honest from the beginning -- adopted, for instance, the South Korea strategy with very aggressive testing and contact tracing -- that fewer than 3,000 Americans would have died as opposed the more than 223,000. And I know these models, it's hard to get the numbers exact. But you get the point here, that if the president has been more aggressive, if the country had been more aggressive, we could have saved lives as a country. And I wonder if you agree with that.</s>AZAR: I don't agree, actually. That kind of analysis is frankly just facially (ph) absurd. I was with the president throughout all of this, and I was there with him, taking these aggressive, unprecedented, historic steps -- for which we were criticized every step of the way for being too aggressive at the time, whether it was shutting down travel with China, shutting down travel with Europe or actually having 45 days of essentially sheltering the economy in place to try to prevent the spread of this disease. At every step, we were attacked. And here's the issue, Jim, that people have to focus on. We in public health focus on what's called mitigation fatigue. You can only ask a population to take stringent measures -- like sheltering in place for instance, or shutting an economy down -- for so long, and you've got to hit that disease curve just right. And when you look back, we actually hit that curve at just about the right point to achieve the core strategic objective, which was --</s>SCIUTTO: Secretary Azar --</s>AZAR: -- to flatten and delay that curve to keep within health care resources, and we're seeing the impacts now here and in Europe, from mitigation fatigue.</s>SCIUTTO: But still, to this day -- to this day -- the president, one of his senior advisors shared information -- Scott Atlas -- questioning the value of masks, which you just, moments ago, said people have to wear. I mean, the president admitted, in his interview to Bob Woodward in February, that he knew this was deadlier than the flu, and yet he said to the American people, no. At that time, when it was clear the science was that masks helped, the president continued not to wear one. I'm just asking if you're willing to take some responsibility here for the administration to say, yes, we should have been more aggressive earlier and yes ,by the way, the U.S. and South Korea had the first infection on the same day, and South Korea's had a far different course of this disease than the</s>U.S. AZAR: Well, Jim, first, let's talk about South Korea. They had a radically different type of case profile. They had an explosion of cases at one megachurch, and then they used their military and police powers to lock down that church, arrest everybody who was in contact with individuals in that church. And through a single testing site, using the same testing capabilities that we had at the CDC, during that same period of time, ran tests on the individuals in there through their significant lockdown efforts, things that fit them within their cultural and legal context but would likely not fly here in the United States. In terms of our messaging around mitigation, it's clear, it's been clear. As we learn about this virus, wash your hands, watch your distance, wear your face coverings when you can't watch your distance and stay out of settings where you can't do those things. We're saying that to people over and over again.</s>SCIUTTO: I know --</s>AZAR: And look, Jim, compare us to Europe --</s>SCIUTTO: -- but Secretary Azar, you're saying it but the president's not modeling it.</s>AZAR: -- compare us to Europe. Europe now -- no, Jim.</s>SCIUTTO: He's not modeling it.</s>AZAR: No, Jim. Let's look at -- Jim.</s>SCIUTTO: I mean, he's holding indoor rallies.</s>AZAR: Jim, we've got to look at the results, Jim. No, Jim.</s>SCIUTTO: He's holding indoor rallies without social distancing.</s>AZAR: You know, your proposition is just false. Europe has, right now, 30 percent more active cases per day being diagnosed than here in the United States, and you're not saying the same things about European leaders. I'm sorry, you're just -- you're not using valid comparisons here.</s>SCIUTTO: European leaders are not --</s>AZAR: Europe is facing this because of individual behaviors.</s>SCIUTTO: -- they're not holding -- they're not -- you have said, not just on this broadcast, you said it on Sunday. You're asking Americans over Thanksgiving not to hold family gatherings indoors. The president continues to hold indoor events. And we saw, with an event that proved to be a superspreader event at the White House. I'm asking you, why isn't the president modeling the very advice you're giving on this broadcast?</s>AZAR: Jim --</s>SCIUTTO: Why isn't he modeling it?</s>AZAR: -- you know, you're the one reinforcing that. Europe has 31 percent more cases today being diagnosed with a less aggressive testing system. Our message is clear. But the more important thing we ought to be talking about --</s>SCIUTTO: Talking about America (ph) here.</s>AZAR: -- for the American people, the more important thing we ought to talk about right now is, thanks to President Trump's leadership of Operation Warp Speed, which "The New York Times" has called "remarkably efficient, the "Washington Post" today quoted an opponent of the president, saying that it has been staggeringly impressive. "The New York Times" says our efforts will actually --</s>SCIUTTO: OK.</s>AZAR: -- reduce the duration --</s>SCIUTTO: Listen --</s>AZAR: -- of this pandemic beyond anybody's expectations. That's what we ought to also be talking about.</s>SCIUTTO: We've talked on this broadcast about vaccine progress every day, and certainly highlighted it (ph). I asked what the president is modeling here, you didn't answer the question. I do want to ask about what is going to be covered for average Americans, because if Obamacare is repealed, even perhaps after the election, there are questions about whether individual insurers will treat COVID as a pre-existing condition. And I'm curious, what would the Trump administration do to guarantee that COVID infection would not be treated as a pre-existing condition, prevent people being covered for that, their treatment being covered.</s>AZAR: Well, there are so many hypotheticals in there of things that would have to occur to get to that point. And what the president's made clear is under no circumstance will he permit insurance companies to actually harm individuals who have pre-existing conditions. We'll work with Congress under all circumstances if that day every comes that the Supreme Court strikes down all or a large part of Obamacare, to make sure there's real coverage for pre-existing conditions. But look what's happening now. This Obamacare that you talk about as if it's the land of milk and honey, it's not providing real protection for people who have pre-existing conditions. If you're a couple making $70,000 a year in Missouri, you're going to be spending -- and you're 58 years old -- you're going to be spending $30,000 a year in premiums, $12,000 a year in out-of-pockets, that's not real protection for COVID or any other pre-existing condition coverage. So that's what we would work to deliver if there's the opportunity to actually fix Obamacare with something that delivers a better solution. But in the interim, we have to work with Congress to make sure the uninsured are covered. We've worked to make sure people don't have out-of-pockets for their COVID treatments, we've worked to make sure the vaccines will be free to individuals. That's what we've been doing.</s>SCIUTTO: OK, we'll hold you to that and I hope you'll come back on this broadcast to say what the plan would be to guarantee that coverage if there were a replacement. Secretary Azar, you're always welcome on this broadcast.</s>AZAR: Thank you.</s>SCIUTTO: And we'll be right back.
Biden and Trump Supporters Happy with Final Debate
POPPY HARLOW, CNN ANCHOR, NEWSROOM: Well, loyal Trump and Biden supporters, they gathered for watch parties as their candidates hit the debate stage last night.</s>SCIUTTO: CNN correspondent Elle Reeve, she watched with Trump supporters. What did you hear?</s>ELLE REEVE, CNN CORRESPONDENT: Well, before the debate, they told us they wanted it to be more civil. But during the debate, they cheered like it was a professional wrestling match.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: Trump 2020, baby, Trump 2020.</s>REEVE (voice-over): We're in a baseball stadium called the The Corn Crib in a town called Normal, Illinois, where hundreds of Trump supporters have gathered to watch the debate at an event hosted by the local Republican Party.</s>CONNIE BEARD, CHAIRMAN, MCLEAN COUNTY REPUBLICAN PARTY: This event has sort of snowballed. We have our McLean County Republican tent (ph), of course, and our little Trump store.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: There you go.</s>BEARD: We have a raffle for a semiautomatic shotgun that is apparently very popular.</s>KENNY MOREAU, TRUMP SUPPORTER: I just like the no-bullshit attitude of, hey, I want to make America great. I don't understand what the problem is of trying to bring everyone up in America to do good things.</s>REEVE: But is it no bullshit to have only paid, like, $750 in taxes?</s>MOREAU: And here's the deal, is that I would love to be able to comment on that. I don't know. And it's one of those situations where you and I can both sit here and say if we made that kind of money, you know that you're going to play the tax game. It's set there for millionaires to be able to play this game.</s>REEVE: But would you want him to change it so that millionaires couldn't play that game?</s>MOREAU: Yes. In the grand scheme of things, it would be great.</s>REEVE: How do you think it's going so far?</s>PAUL BROWN, TRUMP SUPPORTER: As I expected it to go. Mr. Joe Biden is talking a lot of trash and lies, he's not being truthful with the American people.</s>REEVE: Well like, what made you cheer? Do you remember a moment?</s>BROWN: I guess when President Trump was talking about bringing out the details with the Biden crime family.</s>REEVE: So like when Trump was hitting him hard?</s>BROWN: Yes, oh yes.</s>REEVE: Have you ever watched a debate in a crowd like this before?</s>BROWN: Not like this, no. It's pretty cool (ph).</s>REEVE: Well, what do you think about it?</s>BROWN: I love it.</s>REEVE: Is there a moment that made you cheer?</s>UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: Yes. Everything that's coming out about how -- about Hunter Biden's computer, that was the -- I saw that as a grand slam.</s>REEVE: How do you think the debate went tonight?</s>JEANIE QUIRAM, TRUMP SUPPORTER: Great, he's absolutely wonderful, Trump nailed him.</s>REEVE: Well, what was your favorite moment?</s>QUIRAM: Just all of it. I thought it was absolute -- the best debate by far, and it was great. Trump 2020, look at this baby, there he is.</s>DAWN NOWLIN, TRUMP SUPPORTER: I was really glad he brought up all the Biden, Hunter e-mails.</s>REEVE: OK.</s>NOWLIN: Or the -- excuse me, Hunter Biden e-mails, let's --</s>REEVE: Yes.</s>NOWLIN: -- get that right. Honestly, I wish he would have been slightly more aggressive.</s>JOHN T. GRIFFIN, TRUMP SUPPORTER: oh, John (ph), I saw my number, way up in the middle of the air. Amen. Right?</s>REEVE: Yes, that was pretty good.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: Four more years! Four more years!</s>UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: Four more years! Four more years!</s>REEVE: And now to CNN's Jason Carroll, with a view from the Biden side.</s>JASON CARROLL, CNN NATIONAL CORRESPONDENT (voice-over): Minutes after the debate ended, a group of Democratic supporters who had gathered for a socially distanced, backyard watch party in the Mount Airy section of Philadelphia, were ready to weigh in with their verdict.</s>CARROLL: Who felt as though Vice President Joe Biden met or exceeded your expectation during the debate? Show of hands.</s>DAMON WALKER, BIDEN SUPPORTER: Four more years of Trump is not going to work in America.</s>CARROLL (voice-over): Damon Walker, a correctional officer and father of four, agrees with Jasmine Schley, who says some of Vice President Biden's best moments came when he addressed the COVID-19 pandemic.</s>JASMINE SCHLEY, BIDEN SUPPORTER: When he talked about the families who have died because of coronavirus, it shows his humanity. And that's one thing that you never hear President Trump mention. He talks about the economy, he talks about his poll numbers but he never takes the time to acknowledge the suffering of Americans.</s>WALKER: I believe he did what he needed to do. He answered all the questions, and he stated the facts. He didn't veer off-point.</s>MACK DUNCAN, BIDEN SUPPORTER: He answered the questions, he had a plan, he explained it. That's it.</s>CARROLL (voice-over): In this predominantly African-American middle- class community, residents such as Billie Jo McKinney, a mom of five including a young son, says Biden's answer on race in America made an impact.</s>BILLIE JO MCKINNEY, BIDEN SUPPORTER: He showed compassion for all races. And the story about him saying that he's never had to teach his daughter about putting her hands on the wheel, that's a big deal for me because I'm going to have to teach my 6-year-old that. And that's painful.</s>CARROLL (voice-over): Also important for people like McKinney and Walker -- who, again, is a correctional officer -- was to hear Biden's response to his past support of crime bills that resulted in high rates of incarcerating African-Americans for petty drug offenses.</s>JOE BIDEN (D), PRESIDENTIAL NOMINEE: It was a mistake.</s>WALKER: He answered the question by first apologizing.</s>MCKINNEY: He took accountability and he apologized immediately, something we have not seen from our current administration.</s>CARROLL (voice-over): Biden scored points on character and integrity with the group after hearing what he would say to those who do not support him.</s>BRIAN CLINTON, PHILADELPHIA MAYOR'S OFFICE: Joe Biden, when he said it's human decency, American values are on the ballot in November. I thought that really spoke to me.</s>UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: Trump didn't answer that at all.</s>CARROLL (voice-over): The watch party organized by City Councilwoman Cherelle Parker, a Democrat who says beyond tonight's performance, it's Biden the candidate who will ultimately drive supporters to the polls.</s>CHERELLE PARKER, PHILADELPHIA COUNCILWOMAN: One of the things that I like about Joe Biden the most is what you see is what you get. And people from all walks of life know that they want a steady leader.</s>CARROLL: so a couple of quick points, a number of folks that we talked to said that they had already voted, so it shows you just how much interest there is here in this state. It's very clear from the folks that we spoke to that Biden did what he needed to do to energize urban voters. Tomorrow, Biden's going to be out on the campaign in places like Bucks County, Pennsylvania, trying to energize suburban voters. Again, this is a state that Democrats lost in 2016. They don't want to see a repeat this go-around -- Poppy, Jim.</s>SCIUTTO: Yes, the battle there for Democrats is all about building a big lead in those urban, suburban areas to counteract the disadvantage in the rural areas. Jason Carroll, also Elle Reeve, thanks very much. Thanks to you, we'll be right back.
Over 50 Million Americans Have Already Voted.
SCIUTTO: Well, these numbers are just incredible, more than 50 million Americans have already voted in this election with a week and a half to go until November 3rd.</s>HARLOW: That's amazing. Kristen Holmes joins us again this morning from Washington. Good morning, Kristen, we made it to Friday, it's been a big of news but also a huge week of early voting.</s>KRISTEN HOLMES, CNN NATIONAL CORRESPONDENT: That's right, Poppy and Jim. I mean, it's really incredible here, and we are starting to learn more about the landscape, meaning who exactly is voting. So we'd started to see a pattern of Democrats far outpacing Republicans when it came to early voting, but now that gap is starting to close, particularly in the critical swing states of Florida and North Carolina, where we've seen that ramped-up early in-person voting. And just to give you an example here, from last Monday to where we are now, in North Carolina, that margin was cut in half by 50 percent. So you're really seeing Republicans eke up here. Now, there is another headline out of North Carolina that I want us all to pay attention to because we have talked about it before. You might have thought it was over, this idea that you can count ballots up to nine days after the election. We know an appeals court ruled in favor of that; now Republicans are bringing that to the Supreme Court. The reason to watch this is, the Supreme Court is generally hesitant to change these kinds of rules this close to the election. It could potentially disenfranchise thousands of voters if they choose to do this, so keeping our eyes on that. Now, I do want to talk about one other case, and that is the Texas Supreme Court allowing drive-through voting to continue. This is important because the U.S. Supreme Court just blocked that in Alabama.</s>HARLOW: The courts are making huge, huge moves here --</s>SCIUTTO: Yes.</s>HARLOW: -- since Shelby v. Holder, that make huge differences state to state, and it seems like it's happening right up to Election Day. Thanks, Kristen, we appreciate it. OK, so all the information, let us point you here, CNN.com/vote if you want to find your polling station, voter registration status or information on absentee or early voting, everything for your state is here, CNN.com/vote. Thank you for being with us, we wish you a restful weekend because a big two weeks are ahead. I'm Poppy Harlow.</s>SCIUTTO: No question. I'm Jim Sciutto, NEWSROOM with John King will start right after a short break.
Trump and Biden Clash in Final Presidential Debate; U.S. Says, Russian Hackers Have Stolen Data From State and Local Governments; 71,000+ Coronavirus Cases Reported in U.S. Thursday.
JIM SCIUTTO, CNN ANCHOR: A very good Friday morning to you. It's Friday. I'm Jim Sciutto.</s>POPPY HARLOW, CNN ANCHOR: What a week it has been. I'm Poppy Harlow. We're so glad you're here. So we do have breaking news this morning. More than 50 million of you have voted already. And today, both candidates are on the trail. They are trying to win over any holdouts and undecided voters. This just hours after Americans saw two different versions of what these men see as the future of the country. On the debate stage last night, the president said we are rounding the corner on coronavirus.</s>SCIUTTO: The numbers belie that. They prove otherwise. The president's own task force even warning that several regions of the country are showing, quote, early signs of deterioration heading into winter, six states seeing their most new infections ever on Thursday. Those are the states there.</s>HARLOW: Yes. And those are the facts. With us now, our political experts. Good morning to you guys, Seung Min Kim, Errol Louis. Thank you for being here after everyone was up very late last night watching the debate. Errol, if I can begin with you on -- I mean, the president knows what the numbers are, every person who interviews him says it, Kristen Welker did a great presenting him with the facts again last night. Does he actually believe that Americans think that all the data out there is false and that he is the only one who is telling them the truth?</s>ERROL LOUIS, CNN POLITICAL COMMENTATOR: Well, the president's view of reality is that the case numbers are only going up because we test so much and test more than anywhere else in the world. Now, those things are not true, but that is what he believes, or at least that's what he repeats over and over again. He says it on the stump, he said it in that 60 Minutes interview that he walked out of, he said it last night during the debate. He seems to think that if he repeats these things enough and he has enough of an echo chamber both inside the White House, inside his campaign and also, of course, from Fox News, that he'll convince a lot of people to believe it. As I said before, he is running not just against Joe Biden but against reality. I think most people understand that these numbers are real, that their local public health authorities are not scheming politicians who are trying to make the president look bad. They're just telling the truth. They're just reflecting the science. They're just trying to warn the public about a very serious problem. The president is running up solidly against that this. And, look, there's a natural human tendency to want to avoid bad news beyond a certain point. And the inconveniences, the serious inconveniences that come with trying living with COVID, he is trying to, I guess, politicize that and use that to his benefit. It's a shocking tactic. I don't know why he thinks it's going to succeed. My guess is that it probably won't, but that is what the president is doing.</s>SCIUTTO: Seung Min, another focus, the president and his team going into this debate was drawing attention to the business dealings of Joe Biden's son, Hunter Biden. Biden's pushback on this, when the president without foundation accused him of taking $3.5 million from Russia, listen to his and I want to get your reaction.</s>DONALD TRUMP, U.S. PRESIDENT: That's a typical political statement, let's get off this China thing and then he looks the family, around the table, everything, just a typical politician when I see that.</s>KRISTEN WELKER, MSNBC HOST: Let's talk about North Korea then/</s>TRUMP: I'm not a typical politician. That's why I got elected. That was -- let's get off the subject of China, let's talk around sitting around the table. Come on, Joe, you could do better than that.</s>JOE BIDEN (D), PRESIDENTIAL NOMINEE: You have not released a single solitary (ph) year of your tax return. What are you hiding? Why are you unwilling?</s>SCIUTTO: Seung Min, the president, again, hiding behind this, they're under audit, which, of course, does not prevent him from releasing them, as the vice president has. Does the Trump team view that as a missed opportunity here? They were looking to strike a blow. Did they?</s>SEUNG MIN KIM, CNN POLITICAL ANALYST: Well, I mean, certainly, they tried, but then you heard the former vice president come back with his questions about his own business dealings and his own refusal over the last several years to release his tax returns. And we heard some actually new excuses from the president last night when it comes to the issue of his taxes, saying the $750 that have been reported as the number, as the amount of the federal income tax he had paid back in 2016 and 2017, he called that a filing fee. But tax experts say there's no such filing fee. And it just leaves us with more questions about his actual financial picture, the financial situation of his properties. And I thought the vice president was able to kind of effectively turn that argument against him. If you're -- if the president is trying to paint the Biden family as engaged in some sort of corrupt dealings, I think that was a way for -- to turn it back on the -- turn it back on President Trump with his tax returns. That was the way the Biden campaign hoped that he would respond and he certainly did.</s>HARLOW: You know, Errol, I'm glad we actually ran that sound bite before the one on taxes, because I wanted you to address that. And that is, you know, the key question, especially in the closing days of an election to folks in so many polls is, do you think the candidate cares about people like you. And the president's flip response to kitchen table issues last night, I wonder how important you thought that was?</s>LOUIS: I thought it was extremely important. My jaw dropped. I couldn't believe the president said that. In part because of that question you just said, the reality is you want to connect with voters, you want to make sure that they know that you understand their lives and so forth. Not only did President Trump, candidate Trump, show that he doesn't understand it, he was scornful of the idea of even trying to connect with it. He seemed to be so disgusted with the idea that somebody like Joe Biden would actually care about the fact that people don't have the money to replace their tires on their car or to pay the tuition for somebody to go to community college or to handle the basic needs that so many people are grappling with. This president not only doesn't know about it, doesn't want to hear about it but he's disgusted at the very thought that somebody would try and make that the subject of a political conversation. He could not be more out of touch with where people are coming from. Does that mean his followers are going to walk away from him? Not necessarily. But to the extent there are still undecided voters out there, and more importantly to the extent that there are working people out there who maybe necessarily going to vote or didn't know if this election was all that important to them, I think he solidified in that exchange why if they want any kind real attention to their issues. They're going to have a really clear choice between two candidates this time.</s>SCIUTTO: Seung Min, I had to admit, I had a little bit of deja vu last night with this final debate, it reminded me of the final debate in 2016 where there was a calmer Trump, and he got kudos for that. But the majority of people said that Hillary Clinton won the debate, as CNN's polling showed and other polling has showed, scientific polling, not online polling. And yet, of course, Trump won the election. I just wonder, do -- who won or who's perceived to have won these debates matter in the minds of voters? I mean, is it fair to compare to 2016.</s>KIM: It's a hard comparison, because also the kind of the electoral dynamics are different now. And in terms of talking about more than 47 million voters actually having voted already in this election because of the availability of mail-in balloting, of the early voting sites, obviously, pandemic playing a huge factor here. But we can't forget that Republican voters tend to be the ones who come out on Election Day and vote. And so the Trump campaign is really not only trying to drive out those voters with get out the voter campaigns, obviously, and try to get his base to energize by campaigning, having large, not socially distanced rallies all over the place. But if you are someone who is inclined to vote Republican but the president has given you pause, maybe this debate performance was a way for you to kind of get off your couch and say like maybe this guy can, you know, behave for a bit. And I do like his policies and he was able to tone down a bit. So maybe in that respect, it may have been effective. But, look, the -- like you said, how much does the last debate performance change matters, especially when so much of the population has already voted. It will be a really fascinating question that we won't be able to answer, at least for the next several days.</s>HARLOW: Thank you both, Errol Louis, Seung Min Kim. We appreciate you. Get a lot of rest this weekend, okay, because there's a big two weeks coming up for everyone here. Thank you so much. All right, let's go ahead and bring in our Chief Medical Correspondent, Dr. Sanjay Gupta. By the way, Dr. Gupta, is it your birthday today?</s>DR. SANJAY GUPTA, CNN CHIEF MEDICAL CORRESPONDENT: It is, Poppy, a birthday that I will never forget.</s>HARLOW: Oh, yes. It must feel good to be 30. Sanjay, thank you for being here. In all seriousness, there's so many important things that happened about COVID last night on the debate stage. So let's take a listen to the president again claiming that the virus is just going to go away while Joe Biden warns of a very tough next few months.</s>TRUMP: It will go away. And as I say, we're rounding the turn, we're rounding the corner. It's going away.</s>BIDEN: This is the same fellow who told you it was going to end by Easter last time. This is the same fellow who told you that, don't worry we're going to end this by the summer. We're about to go into a dark winter, a dark winter and he has no clear plan.</s>HARLOW: Is there any piece of data that says we're rounding the corner?</s>GUPTA: Unfortunately, no, Poppy. You know, we will get through this ultimately, but I think it's pretty clear when you look at the data, not only in terms of the numbers going up but the pace at which they're increasing, I mean, there's real concern here. We can show sort of what the trajectory of this pandemic has been in the United States over the last several months. And it's had these intermittent peaks. And we know sort of middle of July, we had the significant peak after July 4th weekend, people were really tired back then, they started getting together in large numbers. But even then, you could still be outside mostly. We're sort of having the same issue now but we're starting with a lot more viral transmission. People are still -- there's COVID fatigue and yet people are still getting together and that's really driving the numbers up and at a faster pace. So the number of people who are becoming infected is going up, the number of people who are hospitalized is going up. And that's probably the biggest concern, Poppy. I mean, there's hospital systems all over the country right now where planners are looking around their communities saying, could that building be a surge capacity building, do we need to put up field hospitals like they're doing in Wisconsin. Hopefully, we don't need that. But I think there's no question that things are going to get worse for a while before they get better.</s>SCIUTTO: Sanjay, Joe Biden, he made that point last night, specifically on the number of U.S. deaths going forward. Have a listen. I want to get your reaction.</s>TRUMP: We have a vaccine that's coming. It's ready. It's going to be announced within weeks and it's going to be delivered. We have Operation Warp Speed, which is the military is going to distribute the vaccine.</s>SCIUTTO: Actually, that's not the bite. Let me just quote it myself. JOE Biden said the expectation is we'll have another 200,000 Americans dead the time between now and the end of the year. Where does that data come from? And a putative president, either a president-elect Donald Trump in a second term or a new president-elect Joe Biden, if you had ten minutes with him after Election Day to say, what do you need to do to stop that from happening, what would you tell them?</s>GUPTA: Yes. Well, first of all, the data comes from these various models, as you know. And the models, as we have said for months now, models are all wrong but some of them are useful. But this IHME model does predict that there was going to be -- either by the end of the year or certainly by end of January, perhaps a couple hundred thousand more deaths. I think the good news, if there is any such thing here, Jim, is that --</s>SCIUTTO: Well --</s>HARLOW: It looks like we lost the feed.</s>SCIUTTO: We lost Sanjay Gupta. We'll get back to him and get an answer on the good news there. Always good to have Sanjay on. Still to come this hour, Health and Human Services Secretary Alex Azar, he is going to join us. Lots of questions on all these coronavirus developments.</s>HARLOW: Yes. That will be a great interview in just a few minutes, folks. Also, all signs point to Russia again, as the Kremlin prepares to cast doubt on the election results in favor of the president. That is now how the president sees it. We'll get into that critical issue. And how did each candidate do in the final debate? We ask you, the voter.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: Joe Biden is talking a lot of trash and lies. He's not being truthful with the American people.</s>UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: When he talked about the families who have died because of coronavirus, it shows his humanity. And that's one thing that you never hear President Trump mention.
Trump and Biden Clash in Final Presidential Debate; FDA Approves Remdesivir As First Drug to Treat Coronavirus; Trump, Biden Clash in Final Presidential Debate
POPPY HARLOW, CNN ANCHOR: Well, good morning. I'm Poppy Harlow and we've made it to Friday.</s>JIM SCIUTTO, CNN ANCHOR: We have indeed, a little coffee in tow.</s>HARLOW: Yes.</s>SCIUTTO: I'm Jim Sciutto. Listen, the sad news this morning and the numbers support it, the health crisis in this country, it's unfortunately getting worse and of course the election is getting closer. And on the same day that the U.S. reports 71,000 new coronavirus infections, that is, by the way, the fourth most since the pandemic began, the president again tells the American people that we somehow are rounding the corner. The facts just don't show that. Six states saw the highest number of new cases ever on Thursday. More than 41,000 Americans are now hospitalized and that is the most in two months.</s>SCIUTTO: And the White House task force is warning that several regions in the United States, in particular the Midwest and the sunbelt and a cluster of northern states, are showing what they are deeming, quote, "early signs of deterioration" heading into the winter. Today President Trump and former vice president Joe Biden are both on the campaign trail. This is after their debate last night that laid out very different visions for this country moving forward, 11 days from election day and more than 48 million of you have already voted. Were minds changed last night on that debate stage? So let's begin there with our Jessica Dean, she joins us from Nashville, Tennessee, at the site of last night's debate. Jess, not only did Kristen Welker just do a phenomenal job, we actually could hear their answers which matters.</s>JESSICA DEAN, CNN WHITE HOUSE CORRESPONDENT: Yes, it's amazing what a difference that makes, isn't it? You can actually hear them talk back and forth.</s>HARLOW: Yes.</s>DEAN: And so here we are 11 days out, as you mentioned, from election day. This was Biden and Trump's final pitch to voters from a debate stage and there was a lot fewer interruptions this time, but plenty of jabs. Take a listen.</s>DEAN (voice-over): In the second and final presidential debate, President Donald Trump and former vice president Joe Biden clashed over the major issues. With fewer interruptions, the two candidates offered their final pitches to voters, including how they will combat coronavirus on a day that saw one of the highest numbers of new U.S. cases since the crisis began. Still the president repeated lies about the pandemic.</s>DONALD TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: It will go away and, as I said, we're rounding the turn, we're rounding the corner. It's going away.</s>JOE BIDEN (D), PRESIDENTIAL NOMINEE: 220,000 Americans dead. You hear nothing else I say tonight, hear this, anyone who's responsible for not taking control, in fact, not saying I take no responsibility initially, anyone who is responsible for that many deaths should not remain as president of the United States of America.</s>DEAN: Trump also used his own recent coronavirus diagnosis to downplay the severity of the disease.</s>TRUMP: I was in for a short period of time and I got better very fast.</s>BIDEN: He had nothing -- he did virtually nothing and then he gets out of the hospital and he talks about this is -- don't worry, it's all going to be over soon. Come on. There's not another serious scientist in the world who thinks it's going to be over soon.</s>KRISTEN WELKER, DEBATE MODERATOR: President Trump, your reaction.</s>TRUMP: I didn't say over soon. I said we're learning to live with it. We have no choice. We can't lock ourselves up in a basement like Joe does.</s>DEAN: Biden condemning the Trump administration's coronavirus response and looked straight to camera speaking directly to voters impacted by the pandemic.</s>BIDEN: You folks home will have an empty chair at the kitchen table this morning, that man or wife going to bed tonight and reaching over try to touch their -- out of habit where their wife or husband was, is gone. Learning to live with it. Come on. We're dying with it.</s>DEAN: The president continued to paint himself as a Washington outsider and Biden as a career politician, while the Democratic nominee aimed to depict Trump as a failed first-term president.</s>BIDEN: Look, this isn't about -- there is a reason why he's bringing up all this malarkey. There is a reason for it. He doesn't want to talk about the substantive issues. It's not about his family and my family. It's about your family and your family is hurting badly.</s>WELKER: Ten seconds.</s>TRUMP: That's a typical political statement. Let's get off this China thing and then he looks, the family, around the table -- just a typical politician when I see that.</s>WELKER: Let's talk about North Korea --</s>TRUMP: I'm not a typical politician.</s>WELKER: OK.</s>TRUMP: That's why I got elected.</s>DEAN: Trump criticized Biden's stance on fossil fuels in a move aimed to hurt the former vice president in key swing states like Pennsylvania, Michigan and Ohio.</s>BIDEN: I would transition from the oil industry, yes. I would transition.</s>TRUMP: Oh, that's a big statement.</s>BIDEN: It is a big statement because the oil industry pollutes significantly.</s>TRUMP: I see.</s>BIDEN: Here's the deal.</s>TRUMP: That's a big statement.</s>BIDEN: Well, if you let me finish the statement because it has to be replaced by renewable energy over time. Over time. And I'd stop giving to the oil industry, I'd top giving them federal subsidies.</s>DEAN: On immigration Biden called out the president on the 545 migrant children who have been separated from their parents.</s>BIDEN: What happened? Parents were ripped -- their kids were ripped from their arms and separated, and now they cannot find over 500 sets of those parents and those kids are alone. Nowhere to go. Nowhere to go. It's criminal.</s>TRUMP: They are so well taken care of. They are in facilities that were so clean. They have gotten such good --</s>WELKER: But some of them haven't been reunited with their families.</s>TRUMP: But just ask one question. Who built the cages?</s>DEAN: And when pressed on his record on race, Trump made this claim.</s>TRUMP: I am the least racist person, I can't even see the audience, because it's so dark, but I don't care who's in the audience. I'm the least racist person in this room.</s>BIDEN: Abraham Lincoln here is one of the most racist presidents we've had in modern history. He pours fuel on every single racist fire. Every single one.</s>DEAN: All right. So the debates are now behind us. President Trump heads to Florida for a couple of rallies today. Vice President Biden is in Delaware where he's going to give remarks later this afternoon on the coronavirus pandemic and how he intends to respond to it. And, guys, of course, Biden's biggest surrogate, President Obama, also hitting the campaign trail this weekend. He'll be in Florida tomorrow.</s>SCIUTTO: Jessica Dean, good to have you run through all of it for us. A lot to get through. We've got a team of folks who know it pretty well to walk us through this. I want to start with you, if I can, Dr. Amy Compton Phillips, because we know the facts. The country is not rounding the corner. I mean, infections are going up, deaths are going up. So those are the facts. What difference does it make that the president is not speaking honestly about that to the American people, and granting, acknowledging, that this is getting worse not better?</s>DR. AMY COMPTON-PHILLIPS, CNN MEDICAL ANALYST: Well, unfortunately the way the president frames this is all about the book ends, right? That he talks about the beginning of the whole pandemic and about the end game, about the vaccine, and doesn't talk about anything in the middle. In fact, when he talks about the middle he said, you know, the choice is either I go out and continue our life or I have to live in the basement. And that's not the choice. What Vice President Biden talks about is what do we do in the middle, not just between the book ends, but what do we do in the middle? How do we actually fight during the middle of the pandemic and get the economy back going, and get schools going, and by the way, make sure people have PPE and make sure that we're controlling the spread. And so I think what the president is doing is actually a disservice because he makes it feel like it's an either/or, and Vice President Biden talks about how do we do both? How do we do and fight the virus and get our lives back?</s>HARLOW: Toluse, to you, Jeff Zeleny, our colleague, is reporting that a lot of Republicans, advisers, breathed a sigh of relief last night for sure that the president toned it down, but I mean, but his statements were still riddled with falsehoods and lies, but one Republican adviser told our Jeff Zeleny finally, right? Finally the president did this, but they also question, is it too late? Do you think the president did anything last night on the debate stage that actually increased his, you know -- broadened his tent, increased his base, whatever, got him more voters that he didn't already have?</s>TOLUSE OLORUNNIPA, CNN POLITICAL ANALYST: Well, the president was definitely more on message last night than he was a couple of weeks ago during the first debate which was widely seen as a debacle even among Republicans who didn't like how the president came across with this sort of angry and interrupting tone. This time he was a little bit more subdued, he focused more on his talking points. He did not interrupt Biden as much, and that may help him with some, you know, moderate Republicans who were on the fence about whether to vote for him again, who didn't like his tone but liked his policies. He was able to tick through a number of his policies and point out some differences he has with Joe Biden on policy areas. So he may have helped himself at the margins but in terms of, you know, this debate being a major game changer in the race, it didn't appear that that is the outcome in part because Joe Biden got in a large number of attacks on President Trump. President Trump was not able to reset the focus on to Biden's family and these allegations of corruption, which in many cases are unsubstantiated. Instead he found himself defending himself as to why he hasn't released his own taxes, why he had this secret bank account in China, and he had to defend and explain a number of different issues instead of being on the attack and allowing this Hunter Biden issue to become the main issue in the race. That was not the outcome of last night. And for that reason, the fact that he continues to be behind in the polls, I don't expect that to change very much over the next 10 days.</s>SCIUTTO: Laura, I wonder if you agree because the big issue following the first debate, right, was, it was not so much the issues and the questions and answers, it was the attitude, right, you know, that seemed to alarm Republicans. I wonder if in your view the president gave enough to at least skeptical Republicans last night that maybe I can live with another four years?</s>LAURA BARRON-LOPEZ, CNN POLITICAL ANALYST: Potentially, Jim, but we are talking about a very small piece of the electorate as Toluse was saying. And there are very few undecided voters left. We're seeing that we're about to hit about 50 million votes cast already and there's 11 days to go and Democrats have a substantial advantage. "Politico" were reporting that this morning. We have an analysis that shows they have a massive advantage in terms of who is casting early vote. Now, of course, Republicans are expecting that a lot of their voters are going to turn out the day due to the president's attacks on voting by mail, on casting their ballot that way, but I'm skeptical what impact this debate would have, also particularly with voters like college-educated white women and college-educated white men, which we've seen Trump has been losing substantially. I didn't hear any message that could potentially win them over based on my conversations with those voters over the last few weeks.</s>HARLOW: On the issue, the key issue right now, not only for the election but for the health of every American on coronavirus, Dr. Compton-Phillips, listen to this exchange when the moderator, Kristen Welker, pushed the president on a vaccine.</s>WELKER: You have said a vaccine is coming soon, within weeks now. Your own officials say it could take well into 2021 at the earliest for enough Americans to get vaccinated and even then they say the country will be wearing masks and distancing into 2022. Is your timeline realistic?</s>TRUMP: No, I think my timeline is going to be more accurate. I don't know that they are counting on the military the way I do, but we have our generals lined up. One in particular that's the head of logistics and this is a very easy distribution for him.</s>HARLOW: I mean, distribution is not going to be easy for a host of reasons we've gone over on this show, complicating it. The states are not ready, they don't have enough money, but he just said, Dr. Compton-Phillips, don't believe the CDC's timeline. They said second or third quarter next year. He said believe me. Who should the American people believe this morning?</s>COMPTON-PHILLIPS: The American people should believe the CDC. The CDC understands the complexities that it takes to actually do the logistics of getting the vaccine out, getting it approved, getting it distributed and, by the way, convincing all of those skeptical Americans that we have talked about previously to actually get the vaccine. So we need to believe the CDC and glossing over the complexity doesn't make it any better.</s>SCIUTTO: Toluse, looking ahead here, we've got 11 days to go, and let's put those figures back up on screen. More than 50 million Americans have already voted 11 days to election day. That's about a third of some of the projections as what the total and likely record breaking vote will be. What are the key moments between now and November 3rd that might still change this race?</s>OLORUNNIPA: In terms of a large national audience, this last night was the president's biggest chance to change the trajectory of the race. Tens of millions of people watching at once most likely. Now the president is going to be addressing much smaller audiences in a slew of campaign rallies over the next few days. He's going to be going to swing states including Ohio, New Hampshire, Florida, Wisconsin. He's holding multiple rallies a day trying to change the trajectory of the race. For Joe Biden, it's a slower campaign schedule but he's going to have a large number of surrogates also out on the campaign trail including former president Barack Obama who is going to be trying to target specific voters. So I would expect some of these events over the next couple of weeks to really impact the way people are approaching this race, the people who are still undecided. As Laura said, not that many people are undecided and haven't voted yet, but for those who are there, there's going to be a highly motivated targeting effort to try to go after those voters to try to get them to turn out. President Trump is going to be traveling across the country trying to do that as well. So I do expect last night to have been the biggest stage for both of these candidates to make their closing pitch but they're going to continue to make that pitch on a smaller stage over the next 10 days.</s>HARLOW: Laura, immigration was finally a topic in this debate and it's a really important issue and it comes at a critical time when we know that, you know, 545 children right now are without their parents, still from the zero tolerance policy. What is the most important thing you think voters heard on that, learned from both candidates on that last night?</s>BARRON-LOPEZ: Right. Well, as you said, it was the first time that we really heard them debate that topic, which is surprising given that it was one of the biggest issues in 2016 pushed by Trump when he talked about building a border wall. But last night, when Trump was asked about those 545 children, and what he would do to reunite them if he were re-elected, he didn't give an answer, he diverted and went to attacking Obama-era policies. Which Biden said was a mistake in terms of the mass deportations during the first part of Obama's administration, it was something that Biden was pushed on a lot during the primary, he had said it was a mistake during the primary, and a lot of those liberal groups that were pushing him on it are now ones that are working for him in states like Arizona to get out Latino voters. But again, I think one of the biggest takeaways from that exchange last night was the fact that the president didn't provide any forward- looking plan for how to handle these children and reuniting them, and was not apologetic at all about the family separation policy.</s>SCIUTTO: Yes --</s>HARLOW: And he is a father. I mean, can I just -- can you imagine if those were your children?</s>SCIUTTO: Yes.</s>HARLOW: Thank you guys very much. Dr. Amy Compton-Phillips, Barron- Lopez, Toluse, stay with us. We have a lot ahead this hour. Still to come, the FDA approves the drug remdesivir to treat patients hospitalized with COVID-19. President Trump himself received the drug, but the World Health Organization has cast doubt on just how effective it is on treating COVID. We'll have more details on that ahead.</s>SCIUTTO: And this, we watched the debate with voters from the key battleground state of North Carolina. Have a listen.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: Who do you think won the debate? How many of you think Donald Trump won this debate? No hands being raised for that.</s>SCIUTTO: Notable moment. What moments from the debate mattered to them most? Stay with us.
U.S. Embassy in Turkey Warns of Potential Terrorist Attacks and Kidnappings Against U.S. Citizens.
SCIUTTO: Welcome back. It was something that the former Vice President Joe Biden knew was coming, taking on claims from the president and his supporters that he took money from foreign interests and, again, with no evidence, President Trump attacked Joe Biden on just that. So here was the former vice president's response.</s>KRISTEN WELKER, MODERATOR: On the election security.</s>JOE BIDEN, DEMOCRATIC PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATE FOR 2020: I have not taken a penny from any foreign source ever in my life. Release your tax return and stop talking about corruption. You know his character, you know my character. You know our reputations for honor and telling the truth. I am anxious to have this --</s>HARLOW: All right. With us now is Mike Rogers; former Republican House Intelligence chairman. Good to have you here, Chairman Rogers, and Toluse Olorunnipa is back with us. OK, so, if I could begin with you, Chairman Rogers. I mean, I think it's important to note here that a month ago, we got the results of a Republican-led Senate investigation into a lot of this that found no evidence that Mr. Biden, former vice president engaged in -- cute dog, by the way, whoever's that is -- wrongdoing over his son's business dealings. And in fact, it said, quote, "the extent to which Hunter Biden's role on the Burisma board affected U.S. policy toward Ukraine is not clear." As the former Republican House Intel Chairman, how should all Republicans be responding to these repeated, unfounded attacks on the Biden family on this specific issue?</s>MIKE ROGERS, FORMER HOUSE INTELLIGENCE CHAIRMAN: Yes, I mean, candid, listen, in politics today, it's -- allegations seem to be all the lure. And what worries me is, listen, if you're going to make -- if you're going to challenge someone's character -- and I don't care if it's Donald Trump or Biden or any other political official, I think you're obligated to get it right. And so, people are just trying to create this air of something that isn't -- wasn't appropriate. And so, the odd thing about this is that having a bank account in China through a business- a legitimate business is not a crime. As the Democrats are saying about Trump. Having a business meeting about the possibility of doing business in China is not a crime, nor is it in and of itself inappropriate. And so I think it's really important as we go through this, and I know political operatives, you know, their heads would pop off over this, need to get it right. If you're going --</s>HARLOW: Yes --</s>ROGERS: To attack someone's character --</s>SCIUTTO: Yes --</s>ROGERS: Get it right. And I have seen no information that says that there is anything untoward in those conversations, at least as of today.</s>HARLOW: I would just note that the president didn't disclose in the financial disclosure forms the --</s>SCIUTTO: Yes --</s>HARLOW: Chinese bank account, right, so there maybe not criminal, but I mean, since we don't have his taxes, he points to the disclosure forms and it's not in there. But you are so right, I mean, it was interesting, Jim, in the Lesley Stahl interview that the president posted, he's like why aren't you guys talking more about, you know, the Obamas --</s>SCIUTTO: Yes --</s>HARLOW: And investigating more of this. She said because we're "60 Minutes" and we have to verify things, right?</s>SCIUTTO: Yes. Well, and Joe Biden noted he did release his tax returns which we know --</s>HARLOW: Yes --</s>SCIUTTO: If they were filed correctly have shown such income. Chairman Rogers, if I could go to you again before we go to you, Toluse, just on another false claim by the president last night. The president claimed that both Russia and Iran do not want him to be president, that their preference is Joe Biden. I will play those claims because it's important to hear them and then let's talk about what the truth is. Have a listen.</s>DONALD TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: John Ratcliffe who is fantastic, DNI, he said the one thing that's common to both of them, they both want you to lose because there has been nobody tougher to Russia with -- between the sanctions. Nobody tougher than me on Russia, between the sanctions, between all of what I've done with NATO.</s>SCIUTTO: That's false. The intelligence, in fact, shows, as released and detailed in August by the president's own appointee, leading the group that tracks this sort of thing, Bill Ervolino(ph), that Russia's intention primarily is to denigrate Vice President Biden. There is a deliberate effort by the president and his administration to play down the Russia threat again four years later, Mike Rogers. God knows why? But tell us why it's important that they won't confront this publicly as the facts show.</s>ROGERS: Yes, and it's really important that the intelligence community both under Obama and Trump also came out and said that the Russians at least had some preference. It is --</s>SCIUTTO: Yes --</s>ROGERS: Important to know, however, that believe me, the Russians aren't for -- listen, if they think that Trump gets elected and they continue the chaos, they're not going to get any better at this. They don't like --</s>SCIUTTO: Yes --</s>ROGERS: America, they don't like American politics, they're going to keep up their maligned activities. But this is important because you have to ask the question, are you doing everything you possibly can to push back the Russian interference? Remember, the FBI just came out recently, I think it was Director Wray in a speech himself and said, guess what? The Russians actually got into voting networks, took --</s>SCIUTTO: Yes --</s>ROGERS: Voter registration information. That's concerning because what they're going to try to do -- remember, this is what they call perception hacking. They want --</s>SCIUTTO: Yes --</s>ROGERS: To give Americans the perception that something isn't exactly as it appears in the election, and that sows chaos, that sows -- gets us, you know, at each other's throats. And what they really want to do, those -- the Russians, in this case, now the Iranians, Chinese are also engaged in this now, is get Americans not to like Americans, and one good way --</s>SCIUTTO: Yes --</s>ROGERS: To do that is in a very contentious election, make sure that people don't believe in the results. That's what I'm worried about in all of this.</s>SCIUTTO: Yes.</s>HARLOW: Toluse, let me just get you to weigh in on the North Korea conversation last night which I think was really important, and I'm really glad the issue came up because you had the moderator press Joe Biden on the fact that, look, North Korea conducted four nuclear tests during your administration and pressed Trump to -- you know, you say everything is rosy with Kim Jong-un essentially, but they did roll out their biggest ever intercontinental ballistic missile during your administration. What was the most important thing voters learned about either candidate on this key issue?</s>TOLUSE OLORUNNIPA, WHITE HOUSE REPORTER, WASHINGTON POST: Yes, I also thought it was important that, that came up. And it was important that Americans know that North Korea continues to pursue its nuclear program despite the love letters that have been traded between President Trump and Kim Jong-un. And even during the Obama-Biden administration, it was very clear that, that nuclear program was advancing and all of the various strategies that were put in place all the way going back to the Bush administration and the Clinton administration have not stopped North Korea from advancing. And so, I thought it was important that, that issue was brought forward to the American people. President Trump has tried to say that he is, you know, happy to meet with Kim Jong-un and they have a great relationship and that's kept us from war, but it hasn't kept the North Koreans from pursuing their nuclear ambitions and moving forward and advancing. So, it's not a win for President Trump to be able to say he's met with Kim Jong-un, a dictator and a brutal thug, multiple times. But it's also not a win for Biden to say that he would do something different because we do know that during his eight years in the White House, there was not the kind of progress that you might want out of a two- term president in curtailing North Korea's nuclear ambitions. So, I thought it was important that the American people got to see both candidates' vision with the knowledge that the man has had an opportunity to address this, and neither --</s>SCIUTTO: Yes --</s>OLORUNNIPA: Has been successful.</s>SCIUTTO: Listen, sad fact is successive administrations of both parties failed to curtail North Korea's nuclear programs. Those are the sad facts. Toluse Olorunnipa, Mike Rogers, thanks to both of you. And join us for a special live coverage the way only CNN can bring it to you from the first votes to the critical count. Understand what's happening in your state and across the country. Election night in America. Our special coverage starts Tuesday, November 3rd at 4:00 p.m. Eastern.</s>HARLOW: All right. We do have this breaking news this morning. The U.S. Embassy in Turkey is now warning of possible terrorist attacks and kidnappings against Americans.</s>SCIUTTO: Yes, listen to this, CNN senior international correspondent Arwa Damon joins us now from Istanbul. Arwa, how alarmed, how concerned are U.S. officials and do we know where or what group these threats are coming from?</s>ARWA DAMON, CNN SENIOR INTERNATIONAL CORRESPONDENT: We don't know that at this stage, Jim. We have asked the U.S. Embassy and consulate press officers here if this was somehow related to the more recent strikes that have been taking place by the U.S. in Idlib province against al Qaeda targets or against al Qaeda affiliates, but they would not comment on that. The only thing that they will do is refer us back to the statement that they put out that is urging not just U.S. nationals, but all foreigners to exercise caution. What the U.S. has done at this stage is shut down visa services and services for American nationals, temporarily suspending them in its embassy and also in all of its consulates. What is a bit more interesting about this particular statement, though, that the U.S. Embassy did put out is that, it says that they've received these credible reports of potential terrorist attacks and kidnappings against U.S.
More Than 71,000 New Cases in U.S. Thursday, Highest Since Summer
JOHN KING, CNN INSIDE POLITICS: If you watched the debate last night, you heard Joe Biden say there was a dark winter ahead when it comes to the coronavirus. The president said, no, he doesn't see it that way. He does not see a dark winter. You can choose your own term but if we look at the map and we look at the numbers, things are pretty bleak. Let's start with the map. If you look right now, 32 states heading in the wrong direction. That means more new infections right now compared to a week ago. Those are the states in orange and Rhode Island is in the dark red, that's more than 50 percent new infections this week than a week before. 32 states trending in the wrong direction, 17 holding steady, only one state trending down. You see Oregon the map there. This is what's troubling. If you look at the case count, as it starts to trickle up, number one, record getting high again yesterday, close to the record, 71,000. Only four times that we've been up 70,000 cases in this pandemic. You see that. Here is the other troubling sign to the public health experts. This is the peak of the summer surge. If you look at where the line is going right now, and let me try this again this way, take the other one out of the way, the 60,000 plus average right now heading up from where we were at the peak of the summer surge and that line is pointing up. That troubles public health experts. Hospitalizations with cases, you see it, also trending up. And the IHME model now, this is sad when you look at it. There are 223,000 deaths right now in the United States. The projection is, 100 days from now, 385,000 deaths. That is 162,000 more deaths in the next 100 days projected in this model as we have this fall case surge. Let's discuss this with our CNN Senior Medical Correspondent, Elizabeth Cohen. And, Elizabeth, you can look at the numbers and be numbed and then the question is what can we do about it. And as even more research out today, masks have become a flashpoint in the political campaigns but new research says they work, right?</s>ELIZABETH COHEN, CNN SENIOR MEDICAL CORRESPONDENT: Right, absolutely. And we've known this for so long. And this just reinforces it. And, John, I think you're right. Let's talk about what we can do. So let's take a look at this study. So what this study says is, look, let's start here, studies have shown that, currently, about 49 percent of Americans wear masks. And by wearing masks, we mean in public and always, reliably. If that 49 percent could go up to 85 percent, we could save more than 95,000 lives if we look at the time period from late September through the end of February. If we could move that up to 95,000, we could save more than 129,000 lives. It's very clear. Are masks perfect? No. Do they help save lives, absolutely. John?</s>KING: Elizabeth Cohen, thank you so much. Let's continue the conversation now with Dr. Jonathan Reiner. He is a CNN Medical Analyst and Professor of Medicine at George Washington University. Dr. Reiner, it's good to see you this morning. And I just want to go back first to the map and put the map up on the screen for people to see, when you see 32 states trending in the wrong direction right now. The president says he does not see a dark winter ahead. He says we are rounding the turn. He says, we are learning to live with this. I want you to listen to his surgeon general, surgeon general of the United States, this morning, who was actually speaking the truth. Listen.</s>JEROME ADAMS, U.S. SURGEON GENERAL: We are, in the United States, seeing cases go up. And this week, we will probably have our highest number of cases that we've ever had on a daily basis in the United States. We know that hospitalizations tend to lag several weeks behind cases. And we're starting to see hospitalizations go up in 75 percent of our jurisdictions across the country. And we are really concerned that in a few weeks we will see deaths start to increase in our country.</s>KING: One test of leadership, Dr. Reiner, is telling the truth. The surgeon general there is telling the truth. The president in the debate last night was avoiding the truth, right?</s>DR. JONATHAN REINER, CNN MEDICAL ANALYST: Right. Well, the president has always had an irresolvable conflict of interest, which was he has perceived dealing with the pandemic in a straightforward way as counter to his election chances. That was always a false dichotomy. The truth of the matter is that we're turning the corner into a tsunami. Yesterday there were 73,000 cases, one of the highest days we've ever had, 41,000 people hospitalized which is an increase of about 3,000 over a week, and things are likely to get worse. We saw over 1,000 deaths yesterday. So one way to think about the death rate is to take the case rate, the new case rate per day and multiply that by about 2.5 percent and you'll see that kind of death rate on a daily basis a couple of weeks from now. So we are likely to see a gigantic rise in the number of daily deaths. As worrisome, our hospitals would start to fill and we run the risk of overwhelming our hospital capacity in large parts of the country. The only way to reverse this is to do something very simple, which is to mask up. Mask up. It's a very small thing to do. It's really low tech. Mask up and we can turn this around.</s>KING: I want to go back a little bit to the debate last night too. You mentioned the president's</s>REINER: We're in a boat load of trouble. If you think about the northeast during the darkest days of the pandemic in the spring when we just about ran out of ventilators and we did run out of ICU capacity or hospitals all over the northeast were making O.R.s into ICUs, were making cafeterias into ICUs, hallways, that's the risk we run. The lowest we dropped after the first surge was about 20,000 cases per day. We didn't come down into the single digit thousands or less than that, which is what Europe did. They dropped to very, very low levels, almost negligible levels for month. So they rebuilt capacity, so they have capacity. We never rebuilt that. And when we surged during the summer, we never dropped below 30,000 to 40,000 cases per day and now we're on the way back up. The way to reverse this is, again, through wearing masks. Wearing masks is easier on the public than closing down. But you could get to the point where we would have to do targeted closures. I mean, lives are at stake.</s>KING: Lives are at stake. And we'll watch this play out again. The numbers, they way you lay it out, this is quite factual (ph), if you look at the graphs and that's the way it is headed. Dr. Reiner, grateful for your insights. We will pick up the conversation another day. Coming up for us, back to the campaign, early voting data from key swing states finds Democrats do have a turnout advantage, but, in recent days, it's narrowing.
CNN Reports, More Than 50 Million Americans Have Already Voted
KING: Early voting records are shattering. More than 50 million people, take a look, more than 50 million people have already cast their ballots more than a week before Election Day. And while Democrats are still seeing a lead in the number of early votes cast, you see some data here that shows 49 percent cast by Democrats, 28 percent early votes cast by Republicans, that lead is narrowing in some key states. That's according to the latest numbers from Catalyst, a company that provides data analytics and other services to Democrats, academics and non-profit issue (ph) advocacy organizations. It is giving us new insights into who's voting before November. Joining us now, CNN National Correspondent Kristen Holmes, who is keeping track of all this. And it can get pretty dizzying, Kristen, Democrats think they do have an early advantage but it is perhaps narrowing some as we get closer.</s>KRISTEN HOLMES, CNN NATIONAL CORRESPONDENT: That's right. Now, it's really dependent on what kind of voting you're talking about. We're talking about mail-in ballots that is still Democrats far outpacing Republicans but we've really seen that trend across all of early voting. And as you mentioned, it's no longer quite looking like that, particularly in the key states of North Carolina and Florida, where we're really seeing that ramped up in-person early voting. In North Carolina, for example, the margin there from last Monday to where we are now, it decreased 50 percent. So you can see that catching up there. It's likely to continue to rise because of that in- person voting element. Now, I do want to point out another headline for you, John. We've been talking about these court cases that are shaping the election also out of North Carolina, and this is about counting ballots. An appeals court said that they would allow ballots to be counted in North Carolina up to nine days after the election. Republicans are now challenging that. They brought it to the Supreme Court. Here is why it's important to watch. We are so close to the election, Generally, the Supreme Court does not like to weigh in on these kinds of matters this close to the election. Thousands of people, voters could be disenfranchised so we want to watch what they do. They did weigh in earlier this week on that case on Alabama, as we've talked about, on curbside voting. And here is an interesting fact for you, the latest case out of Texas, the Texas Supreme Court actually is allowing curb side voting. They have said that this is legal in Harris County, the largest, most populous county in Texas. So, really interesting to see here how all these cases from all different courts are shaping the way we vote when 50 million people have already cast a ballot.</s>KING: To count votes and track the legal cases all at the same time, grateful you're here to help us through that. Kristen Holmes, thank you so much. Up next for us, a global terror threat. The U.S. embassy in Turkey warns of terror attacks potentially targeting Americans.
Americans in Turkey Warned About Credible Threat.
KING: There's a heightened alert for American citizens in Turkey today. They are being warned about credible threat of possible terror attacks or kidnappings. CNN Senior International Correspondent Arwa Damon joins us now live from Istanbul. Arwa, what's this about?</s>ARWA DAMON, CNN SENIOR INTERNATIONAL CORRESPONDENT: We don't exactly know what sparked this but we do know as it would seem from the warning put out that the U.S. is taking it very seriously. They have suspended all of their visa services as well as all services to American nationals in their embassy and in all of their consulates in Turkey. Additionally, this warning, when it was put out, contained a bit more detail than other warnings in the past have in the sense that it specifically mentions Istanbul and it also mentions that the threat was against the U.S. consul general. Now, what the U.S. is telling people to do, again, not just Americans but foreign nationals as well, is to be extra vigilant, to avoid crowded areas, especially those that contain foreigners, such as malls or office areas. But the other thing, John, that's significant is that it has been quite some time since we have seen this kind of an alert, a warning being put out. Now, we did ask U.S. officials in Turkey as to whether or not this may be linked in some way to an increase in targeting that we have been seeing by the U.S. of terrorist organizations, such as Al Qaeda in Syria and its affiliates that have been taking place over the last week or so in the province Idlib Province. They would not respond to that. But it's worth noting as well that this is not necessarily the first time that the U.S. has taken these types of measures in Turkey. You'll remember back to the days of 2016, '17, when there was prevalence of attacks by ISIS and by the PKK in turkey, the U.S. did suspend operations and it did also end up evacuating the family members of its staff. But America is taking this very, very seriously right now, erring perhaps on the side of caution, John.</s>KING: Arwa Damon, grateful for the important live reporting. I know you'll stay on top of that. And we will circle back. Up next for us, debates are over and 11 day sprint now to Election Day. We'll go inside last night's big night. But, first, California is struggling with its worst wildfire season on record. For the thousands who have lost their homes, 2019 CNN Hero Woody Faircloth now working to provide them with R.Vs. until they can get back on their feet. With the help of his daughter, Luna, he is helping communities recover.</s>WOODY FAIRCLOTH, CNN HERO: Unfortunately, this fire has really affected a lot of first responders. Six of the seven volunteer firefighters in Berry Creek, California lost their homes, including the chief. And so Luna and I did what we do. We sourced a couple of donated R.V.s and we headed out to California. We delivered one to Chief Reed Rankin.</s>CHIEF REED RANKIN, BERRY CREEK VOLUNTEER FIREFIGHTER: I just can't say thank you enough, but thank you. I deeply appreciate this. We won't be coming on here another month-and-a-half, and at least we've got somewhere to be.</s>FAIRCLOTH: He loves his community.</s>RINKIN: It is huge. I mean, I just don't have enough words, but it's huge.</s>FAIRCLOTH: A couple thousand of his neighbors are left homeless. 15 people were killed in the fire. And they have been through a lot. But the chief is still out there every day on the line, fighting the fire.</s>RANKIN: I could start over somehow. I just have got to get everything done up here and get the fire to put out if people</s>KING: For this full story, go to cnnheroes.com. We'll be right back.
COVID-19 Cases Continue to Rise
BRIANNA KEILAR, CNN HOST, NEWSROOM: The president is still not modeling CDC guidelines even after contracting COVID, but his secretary of Health and Human Services is urging Americans to.</s>ALEX AZAR, SECRETARY OF HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES: This is being driven by individual behaviors at this point. The community spread is happening because we've got to keep focused on washing our hands, watching our distance and wearing our face coverings when we can't watch our distance. And in particular, being careful in household gatherings. This has become a major vector of disease spread.</s>KEILAR: Now, more than half of the U.S. -- that is 32 states -- are showing an upward trend in cases. There is only one state, Oregon, that is heading in the right direction. The number of deaths? Increasing. The seven-day average for deaths is 763, this is the highest that it's been in a month. Hospitalizations are soaring with more than 41,000 yesterday. That is a 33 percent jump since the beginning of the month. And an influential model of the coronavirus pandemic predicts more than 385,000 coronavirus deaths in the U.S. by February 1st. That projection is just that, it's a projection. So if we all work together and we wear masks and we do these other things we know we need to do -- washing our hands, socially distancing -- we can stop this from becoming a reality. The science backs that. The latest study shows more than 100,000 lives can still be saved if Americans just wear masks. Senior medical correspondent Elizabeth Cohen has been going over this data. Break this down for us, Elizabeth.</s>ELIZABETH COHEN, CNN SENIOR MEDICAL CORRESPONDENT: Brianna, this is so interesting, how these numbers work out. Let's take a look at how many Americans are currently wearing masks dependably, always when they're out in public? Only 49 percent. So what this study found is that if 85 percent -- if we could get that number up to 85 percent, we would save 95,000 lives from late September through the end of February. If we could get that number up even higher, to 95 percent, we would save more than 129,000 lives. Masks are not perfect, we are not going to mask our way out of this pandemic. But as you can see from these numbers, they help enormously -- Brianna.</s>KEILAR: And let's talk about remdesivir, which I think so many folks have been hopeful would be extremely wonderful, right? That it would very much help people. It just became the first COVID-19 treatment to receive FDA approval. Who is this going to be given to?</s>COHEN: So let's talk about sort of the technicality that's going on here. remdesivir received authorization, emergency authorization, back in May from the FDA. So people have been getting it since May, including President Trump. So lots of people have been getting it, not just the president. So now the fact that it has a full FDA approval, that doesn't really mean anything for patients. It was authorized before, now it's approved: It's all kind of the same for people who are sick with COVID-19. But that does bring up certain questions. When it was approved, it was proved based on a study that didn't say remdesivir saved lives. That study showed that it shaved a few days off the hospital stay. That's a good thing, it's better to be in the hospital for a shorter amount of time than a longer amount of time. But still, it didn't save lives. Since then, the World Health Organization has come out with a study that says, you know what, guys, we didn't see that remdesivir did anything. It didn't save lives, it didn't make for shorter hospital stays, they didn't see that it did anything. Now, you can poke holes in both studies. There are lots of things to say about both of those studies, but certainly it has given people pause when you have this large World Health Organization study coming out saying remdesivir doesn't do anything -- Brianna.</s>KEILAR: All right, Elizabeth, thank you for walking us through that.</s>COHEN: Thanks.</s>KEILAR: There is new data that shows students at the University of Michigan are responsible for 60 percent of the local coronavirus cases. Health officials have issued an emergency stay-in-place order to stop the spread. So what happened on campus? CNN correspondent Adrienne Broaddus has the details for us.</s>ADRIENNE BROADDUS, CNN CORRESPONDENT: Brianna, the University of Michigan is struggling to contain an outbreak. According to the university's president, 99 percent of COVID cases on campus are among undergraduate students. Earlier this week, we told you about an emergency stay-at-home order for undergraduate students. Just because those students are supposed to stay at home, it doesn't mean they can't leave. They can go to the grocery store, they can go to medical appointments, and they're also allowed to go for a walk with one other person. The president also says they've learned the virus isn't spreading in classrooms or on campus, but it's happening in small gatherings -- Brianna.</s>KEILAR: All right, Adrienne, thank you so much. And tonight at 7:00 Eastern, the nation's top infectious disease expert, Dr. Anthony Fauci, will be joining our Erin Burnett live. So you do not want to miss that, very important information that we'll be getting there. Moments from now, Democratic presidential hopeful Joe Biden is going to lay out his plan to defeat this pandemic and get millions of unemployed Americans back to work. CNN's MJ Lee is in Wilmington where the event is going to get started here shortly. So, MJ, what are you expecting that we'll hear from the former vice president?</s>MJ LEE, CNN POLITICAL CORRESPONDENT: Well, Brianna, the day after the debate, Joe Biden is back here in Wilmington, Delaware. And in just a few minutes, we are going to see him deliver a speech that is centered around COVID-19 and the economic recovery. This just goes to show, is another example that no matter what is sort of happening in the 2020 race and no matter what kinds of attacks President Trump is directing his way, this is a campaign that is very set on making sure that they continue to make the coronavirus pandemic central to the Biden campaign and his candidacy. And obviously, last night, we saw the two very different perspectives from the president and the former vice president when it comes to the pandemic and how things are going in the country when it comes to the virus. Obviously, the president, often almost painting a rosy picture of what we have seen, whereas the former vice president basically said, look, if you are a president who presided over more than 200,000 deaths when it comes to this virus, you do not deserve to be re-elected. And one other thing that was pretty clear was that they have very different predictions and outlooks when it comes to the coming colder months, as it is related to the virus. Take a listen.</s>JOE BIDEN (D), PRESIDENTIAL NOMINEE: We're about to go into a dark winter, a dark winter. And he has no clear plan, and there's no prospect that there's going to be a vaccine available for the majority of American people before the middle of next year.</s>KRISTEN WELKER, NBC HOST: President Trump, your reaction? He says you have no plan.</s>DONALD TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: I don't think we're going to have a dark winter, and -- at all.</s>LEE: And, Brianna, another central aspect of the Biden candidacy is that he is the candidate of decency. He is somebody who is empathetic. And we have seen him, over and over again, use COVID-19 to try to demonstrate that. We saw that last night, when he directly addressed American families who have suffered losses during this pandemic, including talking about wives and husbands who are reaching over at night in bed and realizing that their partners are no longer there. Also just want to note that when it comes to the final days of this election, the Biden campaign says that they do expect the former vice president to have a robust campaign schedule. Tomorrow we are going to see him campaigning in Pennsylvania. This, of course, is a critical state that President Trump won narrowly in 2016. But according to a new CNN poll out of the state, shows Joe Biden with a 10-point lead right now over the president -- Brianna.</s>KEILAR: All right, M.J. Lee, thank you so much for that report from Wilmington. And as Trump and Biden are looking to shore up support in these final days, CNN has learned a record-setting 50 million Americans have already cast their vote. CNN's Kristen Holmes is following the numbers for us. So, Kristen, what do we know about who is voting early and where are the numbers most striking here?</s>KRISTEN HOLMES, CNN NATIONAL CORRESPONDENT: Well, look, these numbers are incredible. This is 36 percent of the entire votes cast in 2016, we're still 11 days out from the election. And of course, we have Election Day. So let's take a look at the where first. We have this map for you, we'll pull up some of the big numbers. You see in Florida here, 4.7 million people. There are 6.3 million people voting in Texas, nearly 2 million in Michigan. The big one I really want to point out here is Georgia. You see it's about 2.4, 2 million. This is 125 percent increase in voter turnout compared to 2016, so huge numbers. We've seen those long lines in Georgia. Now, who is actually voting? And that is actually slightly changing in the last several days. The pattern we had seen before was that Democrats were really outpacing Republicans in terms of early voting. Now that gap is narrowing , particularly in the swing states of North Carolina and Florida, where we're seeing that in-person early voting ramp up. Now in North Carolina, for example, from last Monday to now, that margin between Democrats and Republicans, it was cut in half. So the one thing that Democrats still are far outpacing Republicans in is this. Take a look at these numbers here, these are ballots requested. Mail-in ballots are still exponentially higher among Democrats than Republicans, no surprise there, all the data, all the research we have shows that Republicans would prefer to vote in person on Election Day. But again, Brianna, these numbers are just absolutely incredible, and we still have 11 days left.</s>KEILAR: Yes, we still have a while. All right, Kristen, thank you so much. Still ahead, CNN gets the very different reactions of Biden and Trump supporters after the debate.</s>BRIAN CLINTON, PHILADELPHIA MAYOR'S OFFICE: Joe Biden, when he said it's human decency, American values are on the ballot in November, I thought that really spoke to me. [4:10:06]</s>UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: Trump didn't answer that at all.</s>PAUL BROWN, TRUMP SUPPORTER: Mr. Joe Biden is talking a lot of trash and lies, he's not being truthful with the American people.</s>JEANIE QUIRAM, TRUMP SUPPORTER: Trump nailed him.</s>ELLE REEVE, CNN CORRESPONDENT: What was your favorite moment?</s>QUIRAM: Just all of it, I thought it was absolutely the best debate by far.</s>KEILAR: Plus, a closer look at how Biden and Trump addressed race in this country. And just in to CNN, Delta Airlines announces it had to ban more than 400 people for not wearing masks on flights.
Trump Addressed Race at Debate
KEILAR: The final presidential debate is over, and thanks to a new muted mike policy and an admitted change in strategy from President Trump, Americans were treated to moments of substance and real policy discussion at long last.</s>TRUMP: You keep talking about all these things you're going to do and you're going to do this, but you were there just a short time ago and you guys did nothing.</s>BIDEN: We did --</s>TRUMP: You know, Joe, I ran because of you, I ran because of Barack Obama, because you did a poor job.</s>BIDEN: You know who I am, you know who he is. You know his character, you know my character. You know our reputations for honor and telling the truth. Character of the country is on the ballot, our character is on the ballot. Look at us closely.</s>KEILAR: All right, let's talk about how it went. We have CNN political commentator Angela Rye, she's the former executive director of the Congressional Black Caucus and CEO of Impact Strategies. And Sarah Isgur is with us, she's our CNN political analyst and she's also a staff writer for "The Dispatch." OK, so I wonder what you guys think. Sarah, you say that this race isn't actually about issues, it's about the candidates themselves. Do you see President Trump's apparent discipline that we saw last night, which stood in stark contrast to the first debate, really helping him over the next few days? Or is this just no more damage done?</s>SARAH ISGUR, CNN POLITICAL ANALYST: I think an interesting question is what would have happened if this had been his performance at the first debate? And maybe that could have made a difference. Because what we saw, especially on some of these down-ballot races and the Senate races around the country, is that all of a sudden their numbers fell out of the bottom and a lot of races like Alaska, Montana, Texas, races that had no business being competitive, suddenly are. I think having it this late in the game, we've already had 50 million people vote. And it's -- you know, compared to that first debate. So that first debate was so bad that this one being a little bit better, I think it might stem the bleeding but I don't think it's going to turn around some of the worst outcomes that we saw in that first debate, moving some of those Senate races into the competitive field.</s>KEILAR: Angela, what did you think?</s>ANGELA RYE, CNN POLITICAL COMMENTATOR: I thought last night's debate was rough. I still -- I posted an Instagram selfie last night, was like, what was that? So I appreciate the low bar, but I also have to say that in a crisis like the one we're experiencing right now, which in some communities is threefold -- it's not just COVID, it's economic injustice and racial injustice -- there wasn't a lot said that meets the needs of communities that are desperate for real leadership and change. And so I think what we really have to be analyzing is how someone who has had such a disastrous response to COVID, with now the United States topping 1,100 deaths daily, someone who says that he's the least racist person in the room -- not at all saying he's not racist -- and someone who, in the last debate, told the Proud Boys to stand back and stand by. No (ph), Joe Biden must have been hungry on the debate stage since he said "Po Boy," I wouldn't mind a fried shrimp po boy myself right now. But I think the reality that we have -- Sarah, I see you agreeing with that point --</s>KEILAR: So let's -- I mean, you mentioned racism, you mentioned racial injustice. Let's talk about this. There was one moment from the debate last night where President Trump was attempting to reach out to black voters -- or at least it seemed that way. Listen to what he said.</s>TRUMP: Nobody has done more for the black community than Donald Trump. And if you look -- with the exception of Abraham Lincoln, possible exception, but the exception of Abraham Lincoln -- nobody has done what I've done. I am the least racist person, I can't even see the audience because it's so dark. But I don't care who's in the audience, I'm the least racist person in this room.</s>KEILAR: Angela, what the --</s>RYE: Brianna. You can keep a straight face if you want to, but here's the reality --</s>KEILAR: I'm (ph) trying (ph).</s>RYE: -- the reality is, there's been a lot that's happened since the Emancipation was signed in 1863. And I think what that really tells us is the fact that Donald Trump comes from a party that doesn't appreciate the advancements of civil rights. Donald Trump comes from a party that really started undoing civil rights progress under Ronald Reagan and has not pivoted since then. Donald Trump comes from a party where, in their budgets, this year, they're zeroing out offices of civil rights all throughout the federal government. He's not done more for black people, he's actually caused more harm. And he wants Joe Biden to apologize for the crime bill, which I actually agree with, but he also should apologize for calling for the death penalty for five young men -- of course the Central Park Five -- and all that he said he would do that hasn't really meant the rubber meeting the road in this administration. There's been four years, and he's spent more time fighting a black man who's no longer in office. That black man is of course Barack Obama, who haunts him every day. He's busy undoing executive orders that actually would help the black community and have helped the black community. That's what he's been doing.</s>KEILAR: You know, Sarah, I wonder what you think. I've spoken to conservatives who feel like President Trump is doing a disservice to the party, right? That when it comes to how he speaks to black voters, they cringe when they hear these kinds of things.</s>ISGUR: So two things that are interesting coming out of this. One, I think there's this assumption that when he's saying things like that, he's trying to speak to black voters. I actually think there's a really decent chance that they're looking at their numbers among suburban white women that are just plummeting right now in double digits, a gender gap that may actually be larger than what we saw in 2016. And that what they're actually speaking to is trying to control those drops by making those white suburban women feel more comfortable voting for him, because those voters are giving feedback that they're not comfortable with his language around race. Second of all, speaking of gender, we've also seen something really interesting happening among communities of color, which is that the gender gap that Donald Trump has between men and women, who -- in general, is also reflected in communities of color, that he's actually winning a few more black men than black men, for instance. And quite a few more Latino men than Latino women. So you know, to some extent, I think he was trying to talk to communities of color, but I think that actually some of that was aimed at these suburban white women that he has got to do better with if he has any chance of winning in states like Florida and Pennsylvania.</s>KEILAR: And</s>I -- RYE: That's such a good point, Brianna --</s>KEILAR: -- Angela, yes.</s>RYE: Sorry, really quick. I was just going to say that's such a good point by Sarah. You know, I think that that is spot-on. And I had not considered that at all, but it makes a ton of sense. Because when you hear the rhetoric around "I'm the least racist person" instead of "I'm not racist," or you know, the people who are probably in all of our friend circles who say, "I have black friends"? Those folks that speak in those defensive terms, that language resonates with them a whole lot more. What we really need to be talking about is why communities of color, particularly in this instance -- black voters -- are used as a political football. Instead of trying to get points with whatever your language is, your policies at some point have to align with that language so people feel comfortable not only saying they will vote for you when the pollsters come around, but actually going out to exercise their right to vote on your behalf and to your benefit.</s>KEILAR: Thank you guys so much, I really enjoyed this conversation. Angela Rye, Sarah Isgur, it's great to see you. I know I'll be seeing a lot more of you in the coming days.</s>RYE: Thank you.</s>KEILAR: Any minute now, Joe Biden will be delivering a speech on his plan to fight the pandemic after hammering President Trump on his response at last night's debate. We're going to bring that to you, live from Delaware.
Hundreds Banned from Flying Delta.
KEILAR: Just in to CNN, Delta Airlines says it has had to ban hundreds of flyers for not following the company's mask policy. Pete Muntean is following this for us. So what is the airline saying? And you know, what does this ban mean? Is this a lifetime ban, is this something that's over once COVID is over? What is it?</s>PETE MUNTEAN, CNN CORRESPONDENT: Airlines are essentially saying that you can be banned at least until their pandemic policies change. The new number, Brianna, 460 people have been banned from flying on Delta for refusing to wear a mask on board its flights. The last time I got an update on this was about two months ago, when Delta's CEO, Ed Bastian, said about 270 people had been banned. It's so interesting here, when you do the math on this, it works out to an average of two people per day being banned from flying on Delta since its mask mandate went into effect on May 4th. What's so interesting here, other airlines requiring this. But this is also coming at a time when the CDC is saying, in its strongest language yet, that masks must be worn by travelers on every part of the trip. New studies show the risk of contracting coronavirus on board an airplane is actually not all that high because of the way the air is filtered through every few minutes. But the CDC says the risks are higher in places like terminals, where people can get bunched up and close together. Airlines have been requiring masks starting at check-in, but they do not get any help here from the federal government. So far, the FAA, the DOT has been silent. No new regulations from the federal government requiring that passengers wear masks on board flights.</s>KEILAR: All right, Pete, thank you so much for that. Now, besides suggesting that he would phase out the oil industry, Joe Biden's attempt to clarify his position on fracking put him on the defense during last night's debate. Here's what happened when he was pressed on this by President Trump.</s>TRUMP: It's all a pipe dream. But you know what we'll do? We're going to have the greatest economy in the world. But if you want to kill the economy, get rid of your oil industry. If you want -- and what about fracking?</s>WELKER: All right, let me --</s>TRUMP: Now we have to ask him about fracking.</s>WELKER: -- let me have -- let me allow Vice President Biden to respond.</s>BIDEN: I have never said I oppose fracking.</s>TRUMP: You said it on tape.</s>BIDEN: I did -- show the tape, put it on your website.</s>TRUMP: I'll put it on.</s>BIDEN: Put it on the website.
Trump Accusations about Fauci's Politics Don't Hold Up
BRIANNA KEILAR, CNN HOST: After calling Fauci a disaster, an idiot this week, the president has added Democrat to his resume. But Fauci says he is not one. He is not registered to a party. And he worked for presidents from both parties, six presidents in all. He has overseen response to HIV/AIDS, to Ebola, Zika and tuberculosis. He has run National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases since 1984 when Ronald Reagan was president. And Republicans and Democrats alike, with the exception, of Trump love the guy.</s>GEORGE H.W. BUSH, FORMER PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: I think of Dr. Fauci. Probably never heard of him. He is a very fine research, top doctor at National Institute of Health, working hard, doing something about research on this disease of</s>AIDS. GEORGE W. BUSH, FORMER PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: Three decades ago, a mysterious and terrifying plague began to take the lives of people across the world. Before the malady had a name, it had a fierce opponent in Dr. Anthony Fauci. For his determined and aggressive efforts to help others live longer and healthier lives, I'm proud to give the Presidential Medal of Freedom to Dr. Anthony S. Fauci.</s>BARACK OBAMA, FORMER PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: Thank you to Dr. Tony Fauci and Nancy Sullivan, incredible scientists at NIH who work long days, late nights, to develop a vaccine. All of you represent what is best about America and what's possible when we lead.</s>KEILAR: Anthony Fauci doesn't serve a party. He serves the nation's health. President Trump has repeatedly demonstrated that he serves himself at the expense of the nation's health. So it makes sense these two maybe don't see eye to eye. There's another megachurch seeing a coronavirus outbreak as more churches refuse to enforce mask use. Plus, see how Biden and Trump supporters reacted to the debate, including what surprised them most. And the president says, don't worry, the children separated from parents at the border are well taken care of.
Trump Claims Kids Separated from Parents at Border Are "Well Taken Care Of"
KEILAR: A key moment, Joe Biden slamming President Trump for separating families at the border. This week, court documents revealed the U.S. government has been unable to reunite 544 children with their parents whom they were separated from between 2017 and 2018. They can't locate the parents. Many of the parents thought to have been deported to home countries without their kids. Instead of explaining his administration's policy, Trump repeatedly tried to argue that the cages that some children were held in were built under the Obama administration. And he boasted how the children separated from their parents were being treated.</s>JOE BIDEN, DEMOCRATIC PRESIDENTIAL NOMINEE: What happened? Parents were ripped -- kids were ripped from their arms and separated. And now they cannot find over 500 sets of those parents and those kids are alone, nowhere to go, nowhere to go. It is criminal.</s>DONALD TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: They are so well taken care of. They're in facilities that were so clean.</s>KEILAR: Raul Reyes is an attorney, an immigration analyst, and he writes opinion pieces for CNN.com. Raul, I'm glad you're here to clear this up. You have written extensively about the conditions. But also talk about the conditions and also explain to us where the kids are. As we have understood from reporting, they're not actually being held in detention facilities, which brings up the question of would President Trump be OK if they had been for all these years. But tell us about the facilities and tell us where the kids are.</s>RAUL REYES, CNN CONTRIBUTOR: First of all, I want to start with that the government has not been involved in the process of locating and potentially reuniting the children. Our government hasn't done that. It is largely done by ACLU and other nonprofit groups. They've faced and enormous task, where they think the children are. They have been placed in shelters. They may be within foster care. To be honest, some of them may have been placed and adopted by other families, even though they do have parents, because under some U.S. state laws, adoptions can take place without parental consent. We have these children scattered across the country and going through multiple traumas. Remember, they came from Central America to the United States. That's one trauma. Separated from their parents, another one. At least three years apart from parents. And were they to be reunited, under the best scenario in the future, again, talking about trauma because whoever they are with now, even if it is just a shelter or foster family, they'll go through wrenching separation again, likely they have bonded with them and will be separated again. The whole situation is -- the reason the president deflected this is because it is indefensible. At best, this is some type of gross bureaucratic meltdown, malpractice. But at worst, it is government- sanctioned kidnapping.</s>KEILAR: So fact-check his claim about what the Obama administration did and did not do because there were some separations, but to be clear, under the Trump administration, this was actually a deterrent policy adopted that became widespread as we have seen by number of kids separated.</s>REYES: Right. One thing quickly before I get to that. The president talks about the facilities that children are well taken care of. We know from journalists and doctors, nurses, volunteers, there are horrific conditions in detention. Children died in detention. To the president's claim that basically he is saying Obama did it, that's not true. In 2014, the Obama administration did have a pilot program that they initiated, they kept migrant families in detention, but they were together. Children were only separated under instances where the government suspected they were perhaps trafficked by an adult they were not related to. To be clear, under the Obama administration there was no policy of family separations. It was not widespread. And it was certainly nothing on the scale of the so-called zero- tolerance policy of 2018 that Trump instituted, defended, and only walked back on after international and global bipartisan outrage. To make the comparison with the Obama administration is extremely misleading.</s>KEILAR: Raul Reyes, thank you for coming on.</s>REYES: Yes, ma'am. Thank you.</s>KEILAR: Up next, Joe Biden is playing cleanup after his debate comments on the oil industry. Plus, why Santa Claus won't be visiting Macy's stores for the first time in 159 years.
Update on Coronavirus Responses Around the Country; Joe Biden's Promise about Oil Is Raising Eyebrows; Fact-checking Trump Claim on Windmills and Birds; At Least 55 Million Watched Final Debate, on Par with 1st One.
KEILAR: President Trump and former Vice President Biden do not agree on much, but they certainly do not agree on how to handle climate change, or even if it's real. President Trump is adamant about keeping the fossil fuel industry going. And as Biden is pushing a big move toward clean energy, he made a statement that raised some eyebrows.</s>BIDEN: I would transition from the oil industry, yes. In a transition.</s>TRUMP: Oh, that's a big statement.</s>BIDEN: That is a big statement. Because I would stop --</s>KRISTEN WELKER, DEBATE MODERATOR: Why would you do that?</s>BIDEN: Because the oil industry pollutes significantly.</s>TRUMP: Oh, I see.</s>BIDEN: Here's the deal --</s>TRUMP: That's a big statement.</s>BIDEN: If you'd like me finish the statement. Because it has to be replaced by renewable energy over time. Over time. And I would stop giving -- to the oil industry, I would stop giving them federal subsidies.</s>KEILAR: Bill Weir is our CNN chief climate correspondent. He's with us to go through this. This is one of the needles that needs to be threaded, because the oil industry, Bill, is responsible for a lot of jobs. At the same time, it's a huge contributor to climate change. What did you think about Joe Biden's answer?</s>BILL WEIR, CNN CHIEF CLIMATE CORRESPONDENT: It was interesting. You could see his hesitation. And he's been this way since he won the primary. He was much more middle of the road, mushy on this issue until he absorbed a lot of Bernie Sanders' Sunrise movement, Jay Inslee folks, and came out with a $2 trillion plan that's 20 times more ambition than what Barack Obama put forward. But at the same time, he remembers 2016, and the so-called War on Coal turned off voters in West Virginia and other places to Hillary Clinton. So in Pennsylvania, fracking is not exactly a slam dunk there, either. It's been around for a while. Some people got rich. Some people got sick. In some of those western counties, there's no chance they'll go for Joe Biden anyway. So maybe that's the calculation he's making right there. But if we step back, Brianna, just to appreciate this from 40,000 feet, only in America is it controversial for a debate candidate to say this. While the rest of the world, given the giga-fires that won't go out or the flooding that won't stop in low-lying areas, they're moving on because of the market forces and morality. Just last week, a renewable energy company was briefly more valuable than ExxonMobil. The international energy folks, who are hardly tree-hugging lefties, put out a report this week that solar power is the cheapest form of energy ever invented by humans.</s>KEILAR: I think that's why we heard Biden saying he would take away subsidies.</s>WEIR: Right.</s>KEILAR: He was focusing on why to give an advantage to the oil industry. But I want your perspective that Trump was saying he knows more about wind than Biden. Let's listen to this moment.</s>TRUMP: We don't need all of these countries that we had to fight war over because we needed their energy. We are energy independent. I know more about wind than you do. It's extremely expensive, kills all the birds. It's very intermittent. Got a lot of problems. And they happen to make the windmills in both Germany and China. The fumes coming up -- if you're a believer in carbon emissions, the fumes coming up to make these massive windmills is more than anything we're talking about with natural gas.</s>KEILAR: All right. Bill, fact-check that for us. I know windmills have killed birds. But there's a lot of things that kill way more birds than windmills.</s>WEIR: Exactly. Windmills kill a couple -- 250,000 birds. Feral cats kill 2.5 billion. Winds on office buildings kill way more than windmills. And that number is going down because the Norwegians figured out, if you paint one blade of the windmill black, it decreases bird kills by 70 percent. And as far as it's intermittent or whatever, the U.S. is late to an off-shore wind explosion. They opened a first windward on the east coast recently. And it's laying groundwork for what's happened here on Europe. As I wrote on CNN.com, it was like watching two different candidates from two different planets. Planet Trump, where the fires aren't burning and the scientists aren't saying this is just the beginning, it's hell and high water and we've got to get ready, and then here on planet earth where we have to deal with it.</s>KEILAR: Planet reality, which we are all facing, whether we want to admit it or not. Bill Weir, thank you so much for joining us. Just in, the ratings for the final presidential debate. Brian Stelter, our CNN chief media correspondent, the host of "RELIABLE SOURCES," is here with us to tell us how it shaped up. OK, what's the word?</s>BRIAN STELTER, CNN CHIEF MEDIA CORRESPONDENT & CNN HOST, "RELIABLE SOURCES": And this matters because this was, by far, the biggest TV event remaining in the election cycle. These candidates will not have a big audience like this again. The early preliminary numbers just in from Nielsen, show that at least 55 million people watched the debate on the six biggest channels in the country. That compares to 63 million who watched on the same six-channel group for the first debate in September. Ultimately this number will end up being higher. Ultimately it was 73 in September. So the ultimate tomorrow will probably by 65 to 70 million people. That's a massive number in this fragmented country where none of us watch the same thing anymore. So it just speaks to how important these debates are, Brianna, in this polarized age. The country stopped and watched this debate and consumed it. And we'll see who ultimately benefited from that fact. These are really, really impressive numbers, on par with 2016, ahead of 2012's debates. It shows that this country is plugged in for this election.</s>KEILAR: Yes, some kind of watch party there was last night.</s>STELTER: There was.</s>KEILAR: Brian Stelter, great to see you. Thank you.</s>STELTER: Thanks.</s>KEILAR: It is the top of the hour. I'm Brianna Keilar. The coronavirus pandemic in America is a disaster. The U.S. case count is above eight million, the highest in the world. Hospitalizations are overflowing and overwhelming in many states. And flu season only started. The president is still not modeling CDC guidelines even after contracting COVID, but his secretary of Health and Human Services is urging Americans to.
Trump: Israel And Sudan Agree to Normalize Relations.
JOHN KING, CNN HOST: Moments ago, in the Oval Office, the president taking questions.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: And you also said that the Palestinians want to do something. Can you give us an update on the status of those --</s>DONALD TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: No. I mean, they're both just statements that we have many countries wanting to come in and we're doing them one by one. We did Sudan. They wanted to do a deal. And that was in particular nice, because they've essentially been at war with Israel for a long time. I don't know if it was fighting. I don't know that, but probably there's been a little bit, but certainly it's been for many years, you've been officially at war with Sudan and now it's not only the deal was signed, but it's peace. So that's official and that's nice. Yes, we have at least five that want to come in and we'll have many more than that very soon.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: And when you say want to come in, you mean --</s>TRUMP: Want to come in to the deal. In other words, yes, part of the peace deal. And you know what it's costing the United States? Nothing, nothing. It's so nice. Isn't that nice? I say nothing. Why should we be paying? We're settling peace. It's like Kosovo and Serbia. You look at what's happened there. We're doing a trade deal, Bibi, two trade deals. And they were killing each other all the time for 25 years, right, much longer than that. I said, "Wait a minute, we're doing trade with each country, why don't we just settle it up, so you don't have to kill each other?" And they were so happy, you know. They were so happy. So we settled the deal. We do a lot of things that people don't know about fellas. Any other questions, for the Prime Minister?</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: Can you just walk us through what normalized relations means, like what now --</s>TRUMP: Yes. Sure. Bibi, do you want to give that? What normalized relationship, what it really means and what it means to you? Go ahead Bibi.</s>BENJAMIN NETANYAHU, ISRAELI PRIME MINISTER: Yes, well, I'll give you an example. I mean this is so -- it's really mind boggling, OK? A few days ago, I went into a port in Haifa. There was a ship, a huge ship, container ship that came in from the Emirates, second container ship. The first one was a week earlier. So these were the first container ships coming from the free trade area in Dubai, coming to Israel. They had consumer goods there. They had actually washing machines. OK. That's bringing down the price, the cost of living for the citizens of Israel right away. So first, it's trade, OK? Then Israelis could never fly east. I mean, we had to go around the Red Sea, really around the Arabian Peninsula. It would take us hours to get anywhere, let alone to get into the Arabian Peninsula because we didn't have any relations there. Now people are planning. There are now guide -- tourism offices from Israel, all these tourism agents, flocking to Abu Dhabi and Dubai and Bahrain. And they're now just loaded with requests from Israelis and believe it or not, the other way around, Bahrainis and Emiratis who want to come to Israel. So you have tourism, you have trade, tourism, technology, entrepreneurs, everything. I mean the same thing is going to happen with Sudan. We're going to have, you know, each of us has -- what it has to offer the other. It changes the lives of people. And exactly, as you said, Mr. President, we're not engaging in bloodshed. We're not engaging in antagonism. We're engaging in cooperation for the present and the future. And it's not a distant vision. It's not a distant dream. I mean, we're actually seeing the fruits of peace right now, in these days, days after signing these agreements. I think that -- we've never seen anything like this. And I want to say, one thing that I do see, an enthusiasm from most countries in the world, for most people in the world, across the political divide. Yes, Iran is unhappy. Hezbollah is unhappy. Hamas is unhappy. But most everybody else, is very happy and they should be because peace is a good thing. It's a very good thing. So if you ask me, what does it feel like? It's amazing and it's fast.</s>TRUMP: They're also poor. Iran is poor. Hamas is poor. They're all poor. And they weren't poor three years ago, they were blowing everything up. They're very poor. Do you think Sleepy Joe could have made this deal, Bibi, Sleepy Joe, I think -- do you think he would've made this deal somehow, I don't think so.</s>NETANYAHU: Well, Mr. President, one thing I can tell you, is we appreciate the help for peace from any one in America and we appreciate what you've done enormously.</s>TRUMP: Yes.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: Mr. President, can you follow up on the idea of what this means to (inaudible) the pressure --</s>NETANYAHU: And this will be registered in the books, history books. History registers who did what.</s>TRUMP: Yes.</s>NETANYAHU: I think it does. It's going to --</s>TRUMP: Yes. No, I think it's a terrific thing. And it should be completed pretty soon. Say?</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: Yes, I just wondered if you could expand a little bit about what this means to Iran, the pressure that these deals are now placing on --</s>TRUMP: Well, I think ultimately Iran maybe will become a member of this whole thing, if you want to really know the truth. Look in the end, you're going to have everybody together with the United States and beyond the United States, you'll have other major powers involved. And with it, not have to be signed into it, because it's a region, but they're with it. And I could see Iran, look, someday, I'd love to help Iran. I'd love to get Iran back on track. Their GDP went down 27 percent. They've gone from a rich country to a poor country in a period of three years, and I'd love to get them back on track. They just can't have nuclear weapons, that's all. And nuclear weapons and it's always death to Israel. That's all they shout, is death to Israel. So they can't have nuclear weapons, but they can have what they want. I mean, they should be a great nation. They're great people. I know so many Iranians. I have a lot of Iranian friends. It should be a great nation and we want it to be a great nation, but we can't have nuclear weapons. And I could see Iran ultimately, it sounds, right now, it doesn't sound like something that would happen, but I see it happening. Ultimately, they'll all be one unified family. It will be an amazing thing. Probably has never happened in the Middle East because the Middle East is known for conflict and fighting.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: Mr. President, is the full normalization -- when if it's a full normalization and do you and the prime minister want to say anything about the sale of F-35s to the UAE?</s>TRUMP: No, but I think that's moving along, that process is moving along. It's a good process. We've had an incredible relationship long- term. We've never had a dispute with UAE. They've always been on our side and that process is moving along, I think hopefully rapidly.</s>UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: Mr. President, you're also trying to remove Sudan from the state-sponsored list of terrorism. And can you speak a little bit about how that move or those plans are playing into the dynamics of the normalization deal with Israel?</s>TRUMP: Which plans?</s>UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: To remove Sudan from the state-sponsored of terrorism.</s>TRUMP: The dam, you said, the dam back is it?</s>UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: -- the state-sponsored list -- the list of state- sponsored of terrorism.</s>TRUMP: Oh, yeah. Why don't I have you answer that question?</s>MIKE POMPEO, SECRETARY OF STATE: So we've been working with Sudan for as long as I've been part of this administration to address this issue of state sponsor of terrorism. They did all of the things that they needed to do. These two leaders of Sudan did all the right things. We now have a civilian-led government inside of Sudan, and so the rationale for them being designated a state sponsor no longer made sense. We also wanted to make sure that victims of that terror had compensation. So we've now accounted for that; $335 million will go to the victims from those terror attacks. But now Sudan has fully complied with that, and their leaders have done great work. We want to support that civilian-led government. We want them to be successful. So, it's completely appropriate that we would lift this. This will also be something that will help the Sudanese people and the Sudanese government. And you'll see trade not only between Israel and Sudan, but between the United States and Sudan, as well.</s>UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: So, but can you explain --</s>TRUMP: Sudan has -- Sudan has great potential on trade and other things. I mean, they really -- they -- it could be a very, very successful, wonderful country. And I think it will be. It's been hampered by what's going on in the world.</s>UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: Can you explain though how that connects to the normalization deal with Israel, as well as negotiations --</s>POMPEO: Let me -- sure. They're connected in the sense that the Sudanese leadership made sense that this -- they both have one other thing in common. It made sense for the Sudanese people to build out their economy, to create democratic institutions, all the things that the Sudanese people have been demanding. They're connected in the sense of the Sudanese leadership is now driving towards a really good outcome and improved life for the people of Sudan, and we think for the broader region in North Africa, as well.</s>TRUMP: And with the leaders on the phone, they've been incredible leaders, I will say. They have been incredible leaders. You have great leadership now, which you haven't had in the past. Please?</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: Yes. Obviously, you're going to be hitting the road the next couple of days. Are you envisioning any sort of meeting here in Washington between the Sudanese as well as the Israelis? And then, I'm just curious, what's it like to try to do something like this while also campaigning? I mean, you're trying to -- I know you've got a big staff. But trying to do something like this --</s>TRUMP: It's my life. Do I have a choice? Do I have a choice? This is all things I've been working on and then the campaign.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: So, are they coming to D.C., Sir?</s>TRUMP: The campaign begins, and, you know, I think last night was very, very successful. We've gotten great reviews, great polls, great everything. And I had won 91 to -- 91 percent to 9, that's good. But, no, it was an exciting night. Tremendous audience, I understand. They had bigger than they even thought. And it was certainly an exciting night. But I have to, you know, this is my day job. I have to do this. This is very important.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: So, are they coming to D.C., Sir?</s>TRUMP: We will have them, along with some other countries that you will be hearing about, coming -- probably simultaneously. And then, ultimately, we're going to have a big reunion at the end, where everybody is here and everybody is going to be signed. And we expect that Saudi Arabia will be one of those countries. And highly respected, the King and the Crown Prince, they're all just highly respected in the Middle East, and Mohammed from UAE, highly, very highly respected, a warrior. He's really a great warrior. So they'll all come together. We're going to have a big, beautiful party at the end, OK? And you'll be there, OK? OK. Anybody else have a question?</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: Another question about the debate last night.</s>TRUMP: Yes.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: You know, I know, obviously, this is very important, but I think everybody was watching the debate last night. You seemed much more calm and measured at the podium. How much of that was you, kind of, trying to change your strategy or was that you wanting to play by the debate commission's rules? What were you kind of -- what's going through your mind? Because you didn't seem to jump out as you did in the first debate.</s>TRUMP: I think the other is more effective, in terms of business and life, the first one. I thought I did great. There are certain groups of very aggressive people that loved the first debate. But I think this was better. This is obviously a more popular way of doing it. And, no, I think, you know, I wanted to play by the rules. They felt very strongly about it. It's two different styles. I'm able to do different styles, you know, if you had to. But this seemed to be much more popular.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: Would you do another debate?</s>TRUMP: Yes, but I don't think there's any reason. I think we're leading in a lot of states that you don't know about. Your pollsters may be the worst there are, by the way.</s>UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: Do you stand by your statement that you take responsibility for the pandemic that you said last night, Sir?</s>TRUMP: I always take responsibility, and I've done a great job, and the people around me have done a great job, just like these people have done a great job. The pandemic people, what they've done for ventilators and for equipment and for stocking governors that had absolutely nothing, they had nothing on their shelves, and we stocked them. And those governors, if they're honest, they'll tell you we've done the best job they've ever seen. I've had governors say it's one of the best jobs they've ever seen anybody do on anything what we did. We made a lot of governors look good. And there are a lot of good governors, too, by the way. They did a good job. But they had nothing. They didn't have ventilators. They didn't have gowns. They didn't have masks or goggles or anything. And we got them. And think of it, ventilators are very tough, not one person with all of this going on, not one person who needed a ventilator didn't get it. And that's very untrue in other countries. In other countries, very few people were able to get it. We're now supplying ventilators to many other countries because they're very hard to make. You know, they're very complex and very hard to make, very expensive. So, no, I think we've done a great job.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: -- offer an update on stimulus talks with Speaker Pelosi?</s>TRUMP: I think we can. Sure. I think we can. Go ahead, Steve, real quick.</s>STEVEN MNUCHIN, SECRETARY OF THE TREASURY: The President has been very clear in his instructions to me that if we can get the right deal, we're going to do that. We've been speaking to the Speaker. I would say we've offered compromises. The Speaker, on a number of issues, is still dug in. If she wants to compromise, there will be a deal. But we've made lots of progress in lots of areas, but there's still some significant differences that we're working on.</s>TRUMP: I mean, one of the big differences that you, and I said it last night, loud and clear, she wants to bail out poorly run Democrat states. They're poorly run, both in terms of crime and in terms of economics. And we just don't want that. We want COVID-related. But she wants to bail out poorly run Democrat states, and that's a problem because you're talking about tremendous amounts of money. And we don't want to reward areas of our country who have not done a good job. And a lot of them, a lot of those areas have not done a good job on medical and COVID, frankly. If you look at New York, and if you look at some others, it's been, it's been a rough, it's been very rough. But we don't want to do that. Now, we're talking, and we'll see what happens. But at this moment, I would say that, I actually think Nancy would rather wait until after the election. She thinks it's a good point for the election, but I think it's against her because the American people know it's her that's stopping the money to going, going to her -- going to them. So, you know, I really believe it. I think she views it as a good election point, perhaps. She's, you know, good for November 3rd. I'd like to see the people get the money. I don't think she wants the people to get the money before the election. I don't think that's a good point for her, but we want the people to get the money. It wasn't their fault. It was China's fault. It was China's fault. The plague came in from China, OK? And that's about it.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: Mr. President, can you --</s>TRUMP: No, no, no. That's enough. That's enough. Thank you.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: Can we talk about --</s>TRUMP: Four questions is too many. Who else?</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: Armenia and Azerbaijan, are you going to play any role in that conflict?</s>TRUMP: Yes, we're talking, we're talking about it. We're working with Armenia. We have a very good relationship with Armenia. They're very good people. They're so dedicated. They're incredible people, and we'll see what happens.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: Have you spoken to either leader in the last month?</s>TRUMP: I don't want to say. But we will see what happens. I think really good progress is made -- being made with respect to that. Armenia is -- we have a lot of people living in this country from Armenia, originally from Armenia, and they're great people, and we're going to help them, OK?</s>JEFF MASON, WHITE HOUSE CORRESPONDENT, REUTERS: -- for the Prime Minister, Sir, you mentioned a potential scenario in which Iran would be part of a peace deal.</s>TRUMP: No, I think, at the very end, Iran will be, yes, I can see that. I can see that. Do you see that?</s>POMPEO: Sure. Absolutely.</s>MASON: Can we ask Prime Minister Netanyahu how he feels about that?</s>TRUMP: I would say that. Yes, sure. Go ahead.</s>MASON: Prime Minister Netanyahu, if you can hear me, Jeff Mason with Reuters.</s>TRUMP: This is Jeff Mason. He's got a mask on that's the largest mask I think I've seen. So I don't know if you can hear him. But he wants to know about what you think, what you, gentlemen, think about -- as I said, when it's all finished up and everybody is in the deal, I said that I wouldn't be surprised to see Iran be very friendly also. You have everybody unified, and I think that Iran will be in some way involved. And what do you think about that?</s>NETANYAHU: Well, I was beginning to say that when I spoke in the American Congress, I didn't say I was opposed to any deal. I said I was opposed to that deal because that deal lifted all sorts of restrictions from Iran and did not condition any change, any -- require any change in behavior from Iran. So Iran essentially increased its aggression after the deal, rather than reduce it. You know, with ballistic missiles, with enrichment of uranium for atomic bombs, with all sorts of terrorism in the region. So I think that if a new deal is offered, and that's what I actually said when I spoke to the U.S. Congress, a different deal was offered, it would be welcomed. I think that that will only happen if Iran faces, I would say faces strong opposition to its aggression of the kind that has been thwarted by you, Mr. President. If you're soft on Iran, you're not going to get peace with Iran. If you're strong against Iran and prevent it, as you just said, from achieving nuclear weapons, then I think they might come around to a better deal. A better deal, a real deal, I think, is something that no one will be opposed to, but so far, that's not been available.</s>TRUMP: When everybody is unified and this is all done, and it won't be in a long period of time, Iran will be, in some way, involved. If not part of the deal, they'll be very happy. And, you know what, they're tired of fighting, too. They're tired of what's going on. Those are great people, and they want an end to it. They want an end to it. In fact, if we win the election, they all want me to say "when," but I always say "if" because it's an election, right? If we win the election, one of the first calls I'll get will be from Iran, let's make a deal. One of the first calls I'll get. So, if they don't want me to win, and Russia doesn't want me to win either, you know, what's unique about those two countries, they both don't want me to win, and that's OK. But I think we're going to win. And I think if you start looking at what's happening in these states and the votes that are coming in, and the amount of votes that are coming in, and the great red wave hasn't hit yet, that hits in a few days. It's going to be a great red wave like you've never seen before. You're going to have a wave like you've never seen before. It's going to be all red, and it's going to be a thing of beauty. Have a good time, everybody. Thank you.</s>KING: The President of the United States in the Oval Office with his national security team. They're taking questions from reporters after announcing that he has been part, the United States has helped broker a normalization of relations between Sudan and the State of Israel. That is a big deal. The details scant though we'll see how it plays out with the Prime Minister of Israel joining the call by speakerphone answering a few of the questions from reporters. The President then talking about the debate last night he says he's confident he did a good job. He predicted a quote a red wave is coming even though the polls show Joe Biden with a big lead right now. The President says that will change in the days ahead, predicting a red wave. Let's discuss what we just heard. Joining me from the White House was CNN correspondent Boris Sanchez, Oren Liebermann is in Jerusalem for us. Boris, let me start with you at the White House. The President confident about the debate, talking about this normalization of relations as a building block toward Middle East and regional peace there, if you sum it all up trying to use his day job, the power of incumbency to make a statement in the closing days of this campaign.</s>BORIS SANCHEZ, CNN WHITE HOUSE CORRESPONDENT: Yes, that's right, John, the President injecting reelection politics into this brokered normalization of relations between Israel and Sudan. And it's a trend that we've seen from the White House lately and brokering these deals between Israel and the United Arab Emirates, Bahrain, and now Sudan. The President wants to show that he is working toward Middle East peace, this pet project of his son in law, Jared Kushner, at one point on the call, he asked Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu if he believed that Sleepy Joe Biden could have gotten this sort of deal done. Netanyahu sort of uncomfortably parried the question, but the President is clearly telegraphing his intention here. He also did so when speaking about Iran and saying that one of the first calls that he would get if he were reelected, would be from Iranian leadership, and that he would try to navigate the prospects of some potential deal with that government. He was also asked about the debate last night, as you noted, the President saying that he felt good about his performance, that he performed it in a style that was more popular and calm. The Trump campaign is certainly happy about his performance, the reporting of boost of $26 million in fundraising tied to that debate last night, John.</s>KING: And Oren, these events are always interesting. I want you to bring the significance to us. I just want to note at the top of it, the President of the United States said this was ending a war between Sudan and Israel. He said he didn't know if they were fighting. But this ended the war in Sudan and Israel obviously, are not fighting kind of stunning to hear the President of the United States say things like that, about the state of global affairs. But how significant is this Oren?</s>OREN LIEBERMANN, CNN CORRESPONDENT: It is very significant. Israel and Sudan have in the past been at a state of war in the 1948, Arab Israeli war, Israel's War of Independence, and in the 1967, Six-Day War. Did the two sides directly fight? No, but specifically in 1948, Sudan supported Egypt, which was very much at war with Israel. So there is a big difference here, these two countries have had a state of war in the past. And this will officially end that. And that makes it fundamentally different than the agreements between Israel and the UAE and Bahrain. Those countries have never been at war. And that was just essentially formalizing agreements that had essentially been under the table until that point. Sudan is famous for another reason when it comes to Israeli history. And that's the 1967 cartoon resolution. The three knows no to peace with Israel, no to recognition with Israel, and no to negotiations with Israel. So that the turning around of that that changing now with the normalization is a significant statement, certainly a foreign policy accomplishment by the White House, and a big one for Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who has pointed out this this is now the three yeses, three Arab states agreeing to normalize relations with Israel within just a few months here, John.</s>KING: Oren Liebermann in Jerusalem, Boris Sanchez in the White House, gentlemen, appreciate your insights after that event with the President. We'll see you back here on Monday. I'll also hope to see you Sunday morning at 8:00 a.m. Eastern for Inside Politics so you can get up and join us a very busy news day. Please stay with us. Brianna Keilar picks up our coverage after a quick break. Have a good day.</s>BRIANNA KEILAR, CNN HOST: Hello, I'm Brianna Keilar. And I want to welcome viewers here in the United States and around the world. The pandemic in America is a disaster. It already was, and now it's getting worse.
Instant Debate Reaction: Biden Won Nashville Confrontation; Biden Repeatedly Rebuts Trump's Attacks As "Not True"; Biden Enters Final Election Sprint With Clear Advantage; U.S. Averaging 763 Deaths Every Day, Highest Level In A Month
JOHN KING, CNN HOST: Hello, everybody. I am John King in Washington. Thank you so much for sharing your day with us. An important day it is, 11 days left now. The debates are done, the campaign trail is busy. Last hour, some debate day after cleanup. Joe Biden last night said he wants to transition away from the oil industry. That raised the eyebrows, even among some Democrats who say oil, gas and fracking are key to jobs. Biden immediately tried to amend his answer after the debate. Well, today, his running mate Senator Kamala Harris also did the damage control.</s>SEN. KAMALA HARRIS (D-CA), VICE PRESIDENTIAL NOMINEE: Joe Biden is not going to ban fracking. He is going to deal with the oil subsidies, but the president likes to put everything out of context. And let's be clear, what Joe was talking about was banning subsidies, but he will not ban fracking in America.</s>KING: This is an always an odd wait and see moment. We knew the state of the race when the candidates walked on stage in national last night. Joe Biden was the frontrunner and convincingly so if you study the numbers like that, or if you look at the map. And when the debate ended, the instant polls scored it a Biden win. The consensus instant analysis was that maybe President Trump helped his cause some but not enough. But America's take. Voters around the country, their takes often differ than Washington's take. So now we wait a few days to see how this final debate settles across our 50 state puzzles. We so know some things as we wait. More than 50 million ballots are already cast. The data tells us Democrats have an edge there. And we know the Coronavirus; already the defining 2020 issue is surging as the leaves change and as the election nears. Take a look. Thursday, 71,000 plus new cases. 71,000 is the fourth highest single day total of this pandemic. The daily average of new cases is now 61,000. 12 states hitting new highs for the daily average yesterday. COVID has 40,000 Americans in the hospital today. And the daily average of new deaths is ticking up again as well. Back to COVID and its impact on America in a minute, let's start with the debate, and whether or not it will impact this. Heading into the debate, we already had Joe Biden at 290 electoral votes. The deep blue states, solid Biden, the light blue states, lean Biden. It takes 270 to win. Joe Biden walked on stage last night knowing if nothing else changed, he could well be the next President of the United States. President Trump needs a comeback. He only had 163 electoral votes in our outlook as he walked on stage. The question is, did he turn in a strong enough debate performance to change the map. One key test in the days ahead, watch these states we have these toss ups, Iowa, Ohio, North Carolina, Georgia, Florida and Main Second Congressional district. The president carried them all four years ago. We will watch. Does the advertising mix change over the weekend, do polling numbers change as we come out of the weekend into next week? What Republicans are hoping for is the president's debate was strong enough to do this, to get these states back in the Republican fold. He won them four years ago. What the Democrats are hoping is that voters watched the debate last night and they said we were inclined to like Joe Biden coming in. Now if these states can lean Joe Biden's way, if they're competitive in the end, he has a money advantage, too, I think we could show you that, he has a cash on hand advantage as we head into the final weeks of the campaign. Joe Biden is saying, if I come out of the debate OK in a map that's already favorable to me, look, I have $162 million in my campaign account to $43 million, $44 million if you round up for the president Biden plus friendly committees, $331 million, $223 million for the president and his most friendly committees. So, the vice president, the former vice president, the Democrats in enormous advantage will see how the debate impacts the map. Then Biden has the money to try to whether its fix things or take advantage of opportunities in the days ahead. That is the challenge as we head into the final ten days of the campaign. In the debate last night, the president did press his case. It was normal. They actually talked. No interruptions. Big exchanges over energy, over healthcare, over taxes. Joe Biden spent a lot of time after the president, parried saying he is just wrong.</s>TRUMP: And he wants to close down. He'll close down the country if one person in our massive bureaucracy says we should close it down.</s>WELKER: Vice President Biden, your response.</s>BIDEN: Simply not true.</s>TRUMP: He is the vice-president of the United States and his son, his brother, and his other brother are getting rich. They're like a vacuum cleaner. They're sucking up money.</s>WELKER: OK. President Trump, thank you. We do need to move on.</s>BIDEN: Not true.</s>TRUMP: I just gave $28 billion to our farmers.</s>BIDEN: Taxpayer's money.</s>TRUMP: It's what?</s>BIDEN: Taxpayer's money. Didn't come from China.</s>TRUMP: No, no. You know who the taxpayer is? It's called China.</s>BIDEN: Not true.</s>TRUMP: China pays--</s>KING: Joining our conversation, CNN's Abby Phillip and Jonathan Martin of "The New York Times." Abby, I want to start with you in the sense that the Biden Campaign you could see from Kamala Harris doing cleanup there. They felt they had to fix something that morning after, make sure that people understood the vice president is not going to get rid of fracking tomorrow, not going to get rid of the oil industry tomorrow.</s>KING: But he did say he wants to eventually transition. Overall, do they feel good the morning after or are they a little worried?</s>ABBY PHILLIP, CNN POLITICAL CORRESPONDENT: Well, it does seem like the bidden Campaign feels like generally they did fine, but this fracking issue and the oil and gas and fossil fuel issue is one that Joe Biden keeps stumbling over, even going back to the primary. He keeps saying things that his campaign then later says actually, that's not our plan. That's not our policy. And we often talk about Joe Biden being someone who is a little bit prone to gaffes, this is one of those cases where he was clearly, I don't know what he intended to say. Obviously if you ask environmentalists, they'll say yes, we do need to transition away from oil and gas. But I do think Biden also knows that, that is at this point not his plan and that that is a statement that is going to put vulnerable Democrats in trouble in a lot of parts of this country, and even could affect his prospects in a key state for him, which is Pennsylvania.</s>KING: Well, Jonathan, it's one of the key pressures on Joe Biden because of the evolution of the Democratic Party. He is an older school Democrat who looks at Pennsylvania, who wants to go more slowly perhaps. And you know there are others who say let's move quickly as possible to the Green New Deal. Like you pointed this out last night, two Democratic House members, Horn of Oklahoma, Torrez Small of New Mexico, tweeting out after Joe Biden's remarks saying whoa whoa whoa, Kendra Horn's case, here's one of the places, this is one of the places Biden and I disagree. We must stand up for our oil and gas industry. The New Mexico tweet, I disagree with VP Biden's statement tonight. Energy is part of the backbone of New Mexico's economy. So, you see this in real time playing out, because we are ten days from Election Day. And there were some people again, Biden is the overall leader, I don't think any of us think there was anything last night that he did to really hurt himself. But maybe did he a little hurt himself here?</s>JONATHAN MARTIN, CNN POLITICAL ANALYST: He didn't help himself with the few undecided voters that exist still and sort of energy producing parts of the country. And I think he probably created more of an uncomfortable spot for members of congress and those kinds of seats that you mentioned, places like Oklahoma or Eastern New Mexico, which obviously are huge oil communities in America. So I think that will probably create more of a mess for down ticket Democrats. But John to your broader point, look, Joe Biden has had a blessing this campaign. The basement campaign has been a blessing for Democrats. And last night was a reminder of why it's been a blessing, because Joe Biden is given to say things that he or his staff later have to clean up. And the fact that he's never really had to have it sort of like four or five events along the day on a campaign trail and instead has run a campaign in the COVID year, which is totally understandable, he is following safety protocols, has been really convenient for he and his party. And I think this was always the risk with nominating Biden, he would have these gaffes that would have to be cleaned up after the fact. The larger issue though John is that this is a one issue campaign for all intents and purposes. And the issue is not Joe Biden's gaffs. Are they a pain, are they an irritant? Yes, they can be. But this is mostly about Donald Trump and his conduct and albeit last night change that in a serious way.</s>KING: Right, and back to that point. Joe Biden, number one, Coronavirus was the first topic. Number two, the president says, I don't see a dark winter. The facts tell you; Joe Biden says yes, we are heading into a dark winter. On the facts, you could pick a different adjective if you like; we are headed into a very sober challenging time if you look at the case count. And to your broader point, not only does Joe Biden prosecute the case Abby that he would do a better job with the pandemic, he tries to make the case look who this guy is, Joe Biden making an empathy argument. Let's listen.</s>BIDEN: You're sitting at the kitchen table this morning deciding, "Well, we can't get new tires. They're bald, because we have to wait another month or so." Or "Are we going to be able to pay the mortgage?" Or "Who's going to tell her she can't go back to community college?" They're the decisions you're making, and the middle-class families like I grew up in Scranton and Claymont, they're in trouble. We should be talking about your families, but that's the last thing he wants to talk about.</s>TRUMP: That is a typical statement.</s>BIDEN: I want to talk about North Korea.</s>TRUMP: Excuse me. Just for one second, please.</s>WELKER: 10 seconds, Mr. President. 10 seconds.</s>TRUMP: That's a typical political statement. Let's get off this China thing, and then he looks, "The family around the table, everything." Just a typical politician when I see that. I'm not a typical politician.</s>WELKER: Let's talk about North Korea now.</s>TRUMP: That's why I got elected. Let's get off the subject of China. Let's talk about sitting around the table. Come on, Joe. You could do better.</s>WELKER: Alright. We're going to -</s>KING: We're never quite sure as again as I said, the America's take is sometimes different than Washington's take. There Joe Biden tried to play to his strength which is that. I get you, I understand your pain and your trouble right now, and this guy doesn't. The president trying to say that's a cop out.</s>PHILLIP: Yes. It's an interesting strategy for President Trump to say that talking about what people are experiencing around their kitchen table is a typical politician talking point. I think that that is a challenging argument to make when the Coronavirus really has made literal kitchen table issues, a literal life and death, being perhaps the most important issue for American voters. So it's a bit of a risk for him to take that route.</s>PHILLIP: But I see what he was trying to do which is that, you know, the president knows and his advisers know that nobody is going to be convinced that Donald Trump is somehow the sort of paragon of the perfect politician. So he really has to lean into this. I am unconventional. You may not like my tone, you may not like my attitude, but you like the things that I'm doing and I'm actually thinking about the policies that are going to affect you. So that's what he is trying to do there. But again, I think it's a little bit of a risk to come across as dismissive about the real fact that we are approaching Thanksgiving and people are thinking about whether they can even have a Thanksgiving dinner with their families. That is a real thing that the president is going to have to contend with.</s>KING: And so, Jonathan on this day after, we're trying to figure out what is the impact. We do know Republicans have a sense of cheer, if only because the bar is so low for this president. But if only because Republican Senate candidates now, vulnerable Republicans and other races don't have to be asked today about interruptions and rudeness, and they can have a conversation about taxes and about health care and let the voters decide what people think about policy. Republicans like that. What about the bigger dynamic? Joe Biden walks in there last night as the frontrunner; he has more money in the bank. If you look at the state polling, he has a menu of opportunities, including the state you're sitting in Texas. So the argument is do you play it safe here? And just do Pennsylvania, Michigan, Wisconsin for the final ten days, put most of your time, most of your money into there or do you go bold? Do you think you can actually stretch the map? Flip Georgia, get Florida, maybe play in Texas.</s>MARTIN: Well, I think that their instinct internally is to be safe and to not put the ball in the air, but they get that probably or three yards in a cloud of dust. And I think both 2016 and Joe Biden's own instincts and that of his top aides wants them to sort of secure 270 first. That is their number one goal. But that said there is different ways to get the 270. And I think they see the data, and they know there are place like Georgia is changing dramatically. And in some respects, place like Georgia is not easier to get than Ohio perhaps even Iowa. And so, it does make more sense to be in Georgia on the ground, be there on TV, and perhaps yes, even give Texas a go. This is a numbers game. And I think the Biden Campaign is looking at the polling data and looking at the early votes so far. And looking at some of these big cities and numbers of folks who are flocking to the polls. John, and a lot of parts of America by Election Day, big cities have already surpassed their 2016 total vote. And you can be assured that the Biden Campaign, they see that, they know it, and they'll have to make some crucial decisions here in the final week of the campaign about where to spend their time and their money and what makes the most sense. What's the easiest way to get to 270 beyond just the sort of traditional states that we're also familiar with?</s>KING: And again, the time is running short, believe it or not with our voting. If you're going to change your plan in the chess game, you have to do it over this weekend heading into the final week. Abby Phillip, Jonathan Martin, grateful for the reporting and the insights there. Up next for us the country hits Coronavirus records. It has sadly not seen since the summer surge. We're going back up.
More Than 71,000 New Cases In U.S. Thursday, Highest Since Summer.
KING: Coronavirus trends at the moment are sober, if not depressing. Let's take a look at the 50-state map. And you can just tell if you have been here before, orange and red are bad. And you see a lot of orange, a little bit of red. Rhode Island is red. That means 50 percent plus more new infections right now compared to a week ago. Orange is somewhere between 10 percent higher infections this week, up to 50 percent more than the week before. 32 states. 32 of the 50 states right now trending in the wrong direction in terms of more new infections now than one week ago. 17 states are holding steady. Only one, Oregon, trending down at the moment. This is a bleak map when you look at it. And we've talked about this before. As this has trended worse in recent days, you wait two weeks, and sadly you get this. The death trends also heading up. 28 states now reporting more deaths right now compared to a week ago. And you see a lot of the deep red here, Ohio, Indiana, South Carolina out here, Idaho, Wyoming, Nebraska, Arizona. 50 percent more deaths this week or higher than one week ago. This is a trend that is troubling as you look ahead and watch the case trajectory. And this is the case trajectory. Why are public health experts so worried? From a baseline of about 18,000 new infections a day, the summer surge got us up above 70, now we dropped down or just shy of 40. Now we're heading back up again. Yesterday, 71,671 new infections reported here in the United States of America. This is what worries the public health experts. This was the summer peak. You draw the line out. Inevitable. The trajectory right now is going to surpass the summer peak as we head into the colder fall and winter months. And that is troubling. And this tells you all the more so about the challenge ahead and how it is not going to go away tomorrow. Again, look at some of these numbers here. You look at Pennsylvania, its 10 percent positivity rate. You look at Iowa, 55 percent positivity rate. Kansas is at 21. South Dakota is at 35. Wyoming 31, Idaho 33. All of those infections, people infected means the risk of spread when the digits are that high, 31 percent, 35 percent, 55 percent, 14 percent. That causes trouble. And then that causes hospitalizations. Hospitalizations trending back up again. 40,000 Americans in the hospital today with the Coronavirus. Again, the trend lines heading in the wrong direction. So much so that the model by the IHME out at Washington State, the University of Washington, excuse me, right now 223,000 Americans have died of the Coronavirus as of today. The projection is, one hundred days from now, February 1st, 385,000. That is more than 160,000 Americans to die in the next 100 days. Managing this is a public health challenge of enormous proportions anyway.</s>KING: Listen to the Surgeon General who says, the task of getting you to be more personally responsible, wear a mask, socially distance, gets more complicated because we're in an election year.</s>DR. JEROME ADAMS, U.S. SURGEON GENERAL: There's no chapter in the pandemic play book for an impeachment trial. And that is where this started in the United States. There's no chapter in the pandemic play book for a presidential election. There's no chapter in the pandemic play book for a social justice movement the likes of which we haven't seen since the '60s in our country. If I say Hydroxychloroquine, someone automatically puts you into a Trump or a Biden camp. And If I'd say wear a mask; someone puts you into a Democrat or a Republican camp. It's important to understand that context.</s>KING: With me to share his expertise and insights, CNN Chief Medical Correspondent Dr. Sanjay Gupta. Sanjay, it's good to see you. But I am seeing you at a time, if you just go through the numbers; you look at the trend lines, cases up dangerously. Hospitalizations heading up. The positivity rate especially in the Midwest and across the prairie states downright depressing.</s>DR. SANJAY GUPTA, CNN CHIEF MEDICAL CORRESPONDENT: Yes. I mean, there's no question, the numbers are increasing, John. And when you look even deeper at some of the numbers that you were just showing, you see that the pace at which they're increasing is faster as well. That's one of the big concerns. You have to look at both these things in parallel. And as you point out, compared to July when people were COVID fatigue is not a new thing, people are having that same COVID fatigue going into July 4th weekend. It was very predictable that there would be a significant increase in the overall number of people becoming infected after that. But people were still able to be outside largely John at that point. COVID fatigue now, people increasingly mobile, holidays coming up, people have to be inside. That's a huge concern, starting from a higher level and less sort of buffering from the weather and from outdoors is a real problem. We saw that 100 years ago. By the way John, this was the worst time of the 1918 pandemic as well. So human behavior over the last 100 years I guess really hasn't changed that much. John, one thing I want to point out, we've talked about this, we tell people to do preventative things all the time. And patients will say, well, how do I know that's going to work, those preventative measures you're talking about? Look at places around the country that have implemented some of these basic public health measures nothing super fancy with bells and vessels. Take a look at Arizona, for example, after they lifted their stay at home orders, first couple weeks of June, saw the numbers go way up. They were starting to red line. It was really, really concerning there, hospitals becoming full. Then they put in basically three things, this is in middle of July now. Mask requirements, limiting large public events, and certain businesses bars primarily closing. 75 percent reduction following those basic public health measures. John, this should inspire people. Because right now, we're going into exponential growth. To simply plateau right now would be a really good outcome in terms of where we are, if you could start to actually reliably bend that curve down going into these months that would be huge. There wasn't a vaccine, John, there wasn't any magic therapeutic, and there was just basic public health stuff.</s>KING: Right. And so, one of the questions as we look at the United States is remembering the history. And I know we've got the graphic and you can walk people through it when you look at the European Union. The president in the debate last night said this is everywhere. He is right, it's everywhere. But if you look at the history as it starts to go up in the European Union right now, if you remember at the beginning, again, the orange line is the United States. The green line is the European Union. Walk through, Sanjay, the fear that yes, the EU now, one million residents has passed the United States. So the president says that's proof that we're doing better than them. That's how he likes to characterize it. But remember we were about two and a half, three weeks behind them going up the first hill and that's the worry, right?</s>DR. GUPTA: That is absolutely the worry. I mean, this is maybe the closest thing you have to a crystal ball if you will. Back in March, remember John, we're looking at Italy saying it looks terrible, what's happening in Italy? That's not going to happen here. And then just as you said John a couple of weeks later, not only did that happen here, but our overall trend line increased. They were able to in the European Union, that continent, at least bring things down for a period of time. But John, contagious virus, reopening, starting to have COVID fatigue, not abiding by public health practices, they're in exponential growth right now in the European Union, and again, we are a couple of weeks behind over there. So that's the concern. We're trying to avoid it, it's not inevitable, but it is certainly looking more and more that way. John, I don't need to tell you that there is obviously places in the world that have very different sort of trend lines. South Korea, we bring it up, because they had the same - they have the first patient diagnosed in the same day as ours.</s>DR. GUPTA: If we had adopted what they did in South Korea in this country according to this new study out of Columbia, there'd be 2800 people total that would have died by this point in the pandemic in the United States, 2800 total as opposed to 220,000.</s>KING: Right. The key points there, the key pieces of that are A, consistent leadership from the top, political leadership, public health leadership, and then personal responsibility. We listened to the president at last night, he says we are rounding the corner, we've turned the bend, it's going to be over soon. Listen to his own Secretary of Health and Human Services saying something very, very different.</s>ALEX AZAR, HEALTH & HUMAN SERVICES SECRETARY: This is being driven by individual behaviors at this point. The community spread is happening because we've got to keep focused on washing our hands, watching our distance and wearing our face covering when we can't watch our distance, and in particular being careful in household gatherings. This is becoming a major vector of disease spread.</s>KING: The president had audience of millions last night. He could have said that. He didn't.</s>DR. GUPTA: No. He didn't. And frankly, Secretary Azar is talking about the public health strategies that we've known for a while, but these have not been implemented on a national scale. I mean, it makes a huge difference. We are the United States. People travel back and forth in the areas where you may have had better control; they were still affected by areas of the country that had poorer control. That's the problem. And now when you look at that map that you showed, the country is sort of coalescing around a sort of collective upward trend in this country. Before it was wave over here, wave over here, wave over here. And now it's all starting to turn into one large surge. By the way, the other thing is what about testing? Secretary Azar is talking about individual behavior and he is absolutely right. We just abandoned this idea of being able to test in a way that was meaningful. John, I could be with you onset right now, despite the fact that we don't have a vaccine if I can be tested regularly, you could be tested regularly, I'd have the confidence at least that I don't have it, I have the confidence that you don't have it likely, we'd still wear masks and do all those other things, but it would be a very different picture. We just abandoned that idea I think pretty early on and we've never caught up.</s>KING: That's sort of a sad statement in the United States of America. But it is where we are at the moment, and to your point about that national scale of this. That is what is troubling when you look at the numbers and you look at the map. Dr. Gupta, grateful for your insights, especially on what is this, your 27th birthday? 27 or 28 today?</s>DR. GUPTA: Yes, that's right. Almost 30 now, John, yes. Feels like a decade since my last birthday, I'll be honest with you.</s>KING: Happy birthday to our child prodigy, Dr. Sanjay Gupta, it has been a long year my friend, yes, it has.</s>DR. GUPTA: Thank you.</s>KING: Up next for us, well, President Trump supporters are saying about his very much dialed back debate performance.
Cases, Hospitalizations Soar as Pandemic in U.S Worsens
BRIANNA KEILAR, CNN RIGHT NOW: Hello. I'm Brianna Keilar and, I want to welcome viewers here in the United States and around the world. The pandemic in America is a disaster. It already was and now it's getting worse. The first coronavirus wave never really ended. Cases never dipped low enough for a true trough between waves and now the fall and winter surge is upon us. The president is still not modeling CDC guidelines, even after contracting COVID. But his secretary of Health and Human Services is urging Americans to.</s>ALEX AZAR, SECRETARY, HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES: This is being driven by individual behaviors at this point. The community spread is happening because we've got to keep focused on washing our hands, watching our distance and wearing face coverings when we can't watch distance, and then particularly being careful in household gatherings. This has become a major vector of disease spread.</s>KEILAR: More than half the U.S., 32 states, show upward trend in cases. Yesterday, there were more than 71,000 new cases reported. That's the highest one day count since July. Seven states saw the highest one day case totals, Pennsylvania, Indiana, Ohio, Oklahoma, Utah, Colorado and also Montana, seven states there. The number of deaths increasing, the seven-day average for deaths is 763. That is the highest that it has been in a month. Hospitalizations are soaring with more than 41,000 yesterday. That's 33 percent jump since the beginning of October. And an influential model of the coronavirus pandemic predicts that more than 385,000 deaths will occur in the U.S. by February 1st. That is a prediction. It doesn't have to be a fact. A new study projects more than 100,000 lives in the U.S. could be saved if we all just wore masks. CNN Health Reporter Jacqueline Howard has more on this. Jacqueline?</s>JACQUELINE HOWARD, CNN HEALTH REPORTER: That's right, Brianna. This new study finds that if 95 percent of Americans wear a mask in public, that could save lives. The studies from Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation, here is what the study found in September, some 49 percent of Americans reported that they always wore a mask in public. So, keeping that in mind, the institute says that if states issue social distancing mandates when the number of daily deaths reaches critical threshold but mask-wearing stays the same, the death toll from COVID-19 could exceed 500,000 total by the end of February. But if mask use increases to 95 percent and states issue mandates, the study projects about 380,000 deaths by the same day. So you see that's a difference of about 120,000 lives. Brianna?</s>KEILAR: Jacqueline Howard, thank you so much for that. And I want to talk about this study now with Dr. Saju Matthew. He is a primary care physician. He is public health specialist. Dr. Matthew, it's great to see you. And this is a study that says that, as of September 21st, only about 49 percent of U.S. residents reported that they always wore a mask in public. Do you see that that's something that could change for the better so lives can be spared, or do you think that's about where it is going to be for the future?</s>DR. SAJU MATTHEW, CNN MEDICAL ANALYST: Brianna, I want to be optimistic. I am a primary care physician. I'm the gate keeper. We're first point of contact when patients come in with COVID. And I'm telling you, there is still a lot of people out there that believe that this is a hoax, that I don't know of anybody that had COVID, Dr. Matthew, why should I wear a mask? And if we just look at these studies, if we look at other countries, look at South Korea, Brianna, we have the first case on the first day back in January of both U.S. and South Korea. Now, they have 444 deaths and we have over 220,000 deaths. Look at the number of cases total in Japan, that is a mask wearing society, total number of cases, 90,000. We could get to 90,000 cases per day in the U.S. All we have to do, look at our other countries, look at our neighbor, Canada. It is very simple. I just hope and pray that people will realize there is nothing political about this. Wear a mask. You'll save your mom. You'll save your dad and you'll save your life as well.</s>KEILAR: And I want to talk to you about another new study. We are always wondering which groups of people are at increased risk to serious complications or death with coronavirus. And this study found that people with down syndrome have ten times a risk of dying from COVID-19 compared to those who do not have down syndrome. Why is that?</s>MATTHEW: The reason for that is patients with down syndrome, it is a genetic malformation, if you will, in utero. And a lot of patients with down syndrome also have other chronic conditions. It can affect your heart, it can affect your liver, it can affect your neurological system. So, unfortunately, from day one, a lot of our down syndrome patients are dealing with chronic medical conditions. And we know that patients who have diabetes, hypertension, heart problems, they are also the patients who are being affected mostly with COVID-19.</s>KEILAR: And here we are, we are at a key place in this fight against coronavirus. There is so many grim predictions for the weeks ahead. What are you expecting?</s>MATTHEW: What I am expecting is if we don't hunker down, if I was a weatherman, this is where I would be sending out high alerts. We're going into the cold and flu season. Our cases already started at a very high level. And that's the difference. When people ask me, Dr. Matthew, why is it that the U.S. is so behind from the get-go, we never got into contact tracing, we never got into aggressive testing. And, really, one thing a lot of us should remember is our testing should be scaled on the size of the epidemic and not necessarily on the size of the population. But I want to be optimistic. I think that, moving forward, if every American just took this upon ourselves to fasten that seat belt, wear a mask, it's very simple, don't go into indoor gatherings, weddings, restaurants, try to stay away from gyms, wash your hands and socially distance, I think that we can definitely decrease the number of cases.</s>KEILAR: If only people would follow this advice. Hopefully, some people hear you, Dr. Saju Matthew, and they follow this. we appreciate having you on.</s>MATTHEW: Thank you, Brianna.</s>KEILAR: At last night's final debate, the president told a lot of lies, particularly when it came to coronavirus. Soon after taking the stage, President Trump downplayed the more than 223,000 American lives that have been lost to the disease.</s>DONALD TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: As you know, 2.2 million people modeled out were expected to die.</s>KEILAR: That 2.2 million number that he keeps repeating is a false benchmark. They weren't really expected to die. This is from a British report that said that many Americans would die if we took no precautions, whatsoever, as a country. So, eight months into the pandemic and the U.S. has the most cases and the most deaths of any other nation and the fact it isn't worse is really due to individual Americans and state and local leaders who are doing the things, the recommendations that the president will not.</s>TRUMP: It will go away. And as I say, we are rounding the turn, we're rounding the corner. It's going away.</s>KEILAR: It is not going away. It is going way up. It is about to hit the fan, according to experts, as they're watching the graphs that show fall, winter surge beginning. We're looking down the barrel of a gun that is about to go off as the temperature drops and more people head indoors to socialize. The president also made some extremely lofty claims about a COVID vaccine.</s>TRUMP: We have a vaccine that's coming. It's ready. It's going to be announced within weeks and it's going to be delivered.</s>KRISTEN WELKER, MSNBC HOST: You also said a vaccine will be coming within weeks? Is that a guarantee?</s>TRUMP: No, it is not a guarantee, but it will be by the end of the year. But I think it has a good chance.</s>KEILAR: He couldn't guarantee a vaccine because the FDA has not approved any vaccines yet. Most are still in active or paused trials. But who needs a vaccine if you believe another falsehood from the president?</s>TRUMP: 99.9 of young people recover. 99 percent of people recover. We have to recover. We can't close up our nation.</s>KEILAR: Young people may recover, but not before they spread it to people who are more likely to die. Young adults are the primary source of spread. And according to Johns Hopkins University, about 2.6 percent of people who test positive for coronavirus die from COVID-19. And many survivors are experiencing lingering symptoms and internal organ damage for long-term consequences. Now, the president and Joe Biden are hitting the trail after a fiery debate. Hear where they're setting up shop in the final 11 days. Plus, the debate ratings are in. See how it compared to the first one. And Biden trying to clean up comments that he made about moving on from oil. This is CNN special live coverage.
Trump, Biden Storm Trail with 50 Million Votes Already Cast; Trump's Accusation About Fauci's Politics Don't Hold Up.
KEILAR: Election Day is around the corner. We are just 11 days away now. And right now, President Trump and former Vice President Joe Biden are hitting the campaign trail, they are looking to connect with undecided voters and trying to energize their base. More than 50 million have cast their ballots. The president is flying to Florida this hour to convince America's senior citizens to back him a second term. Seniors are a key voting bloc to usher Trump into the White House in 2016 and could prove to be the tipping point in 2020. Biden is set to speak next hour in his home state of Delaware, where he will outline his plans to defeat the pandemic and get unemployed Americans back to work. We're going to take you there live once he gets under way. And this final sprint for both men is coming on the heels of last night's debate where they laid starkly different visions for the future of this country. Joining me now is CNN Political Analyst Carl Bernstein. And, Carl, President Trump and the former vice president facing off last night for the last time before Election Day. This was the last pitch that a lot of Americans were going to be paying attention to. What did you think? What was your takeaway from the debate?</s>CARL BERNSTEIN, CNN POLITICAL ANALYST: Trump, once again, is appealing to his base to get him close enough to winning that he can throw a monkey wrench into the electoral process if there is no win, which is very unlikely that he will win a majority of votes in the Electoral College demonstrably. But rather, and people I talk to in the White House and elsewhere say that his strategy is to undermine the electoral process to the point where he can draw this thing out through court challenges, through not accepting whatever the vote of the American people is and trying to cling to office through some other means. He's still in the ball game. He did not perform like he did in the first debate, which was almost fatal to him. He was much more coherent than he usually is. And his Republican supporters are happy with what he did. At the same time, the question is, is this election, as we have seen all along, really about the character of Donald Trump and the COVID crisis, the pandemic, his negligence in causing, through his negligence, the deaths of hundreds of thousands of Americans. He is trying to move the debate away from that. And meanwhile, to energize his base with a kind of repeal, we're going to see, I have been told by those who were around the president, in the next 11 days, we are going to see a scorched earth campaign the likes of which the filthiest of the campaign conducted by Donald Trump, unlike anything that we have seen in our history. So, get set is what I was told last night.</s>KEILAR: All right. We'll buckle up. We'll hold onto our hats and glasses because this is going to be wild ride, as they say. One of the things I think that we're hearing just from normal people who were watching this election, as they look back to 2016 is people who support say, Joe Biden or oppose President Trump are worried that even though polls may indicate positivity for Biden, they worry that it could be missing something. And then folks that support President Trump say, he defied expectations last time, he is going to defy expectations this time. Could we be surprised again?</s>BERNSTEIN: There's always room for surprise. Of course, that's a possibility. But a lot is going to depend, I think, on the media and how we focus on these next 11 days, particularly about the issue of Donald Trump, what he and his rhetoric and his actions and words have been all about for almost four years now, the pathological lying, the racism, the call to arms for his followers in the streets to almost provoke violence in our electoral process. We're dealing with a president of the United States whose level of irresponsibility, recklessness and lack of faith in the American democratic process as well as coming dangerously close to a new kind of authoritarianism that we have never seen advocated by a president, something close to some kind of peculiar Trumpian, American neo- fascism, those are the real issues in this campaign. And I think most voters are aware that the real issue is Donald Trump and his conduct. Can Trump energize his base enough to make this election close? And Republican senators particularly, who I've talked to, say that that's his real objective. Just get it close enough so that he cannot be forced to leave the White House with a clear victory for Biden. And if that is the case, then he goes into causing a constitutional crisis. And I think we need to look at his words and actions over the past month and into the next 11 days in terms of his willingness and enthusiasm for provoking a constitutional crisis if he can't get past 270 electoral votes, which seems unlikely, whatever happened in the debate last night. The trajectory does not seem to have been changed notably, but his strategy is to cause such chaos that we are going to be very troubled in terms of how our institutions, how the Electoral College, how Republicans in Congress, how our system handles a challenge to the orderly and legal electoral process such as we've never seen. And that also includes the kind of message that he is sending, as he did last night during parts of the debate to his followers, the kind of unfounded, vicious charges, the kind of language that we have seen in the past month appeals to racism. As Biden said last night, that much more than dog whistles, fog horns, toward racism, toward a kind of unacceptance of pluralistic America, the likes of which we have never seen. That's where we are and that's what we've got to look at, particularly in the media, along with the coronavirus pandemic and his failure to act, his homicidal negligence in failing to act to save lives of Americans. As he told to my colleague, Bob Woodward, he knew January 28th that we were facing the greatest national security crisis, as he was told by his national security advisers, that his presidency was going to see and he chose to not only ignore it in public but to pretend almost it didn't exist, as he said, to cause -- so that he would not cause panic in America.</s>KEILAR: And, Carl, we'll be watching the final days with you. It is wonderful to see you. Thank you so much for coming on.</s>BERNSTEIN: Thank you.</s>KEILAR: Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell responding to concerns about his health after photos show bruises and bandages on his body. Plus, the president once again attacked Dr. Fauci, calling him a Democrat. We're going to roll the tape on that false claim. And as Big 10 football returns this weekend, some college town mayors are terrified about super-spreader events. We're going to take you there.
Biden Falsely Claims He Never Opposed Fracking; Biden and Trump Supporters Happy with Final Debate; Biden Speaks on Coronavirus Response, Details His Plan.
DONALD TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: But if you want to kill the economy --</s>TRUMP: -- get rid of your oil industry. You want -- and what about fracking?</s>KRISTEN WELKER, DEBATE MODERATOR: Let me have -- let me allow Vice President Biden to respond.</s>JOE BIDEN (D), PRESIDENTIAL NOMINEE: I have never said I opposed fracking.</s>TRUMP: You said it on tape.</s>BIDEN: I did -- show the tape. Put it on the Web site.</s>TRUMP: I'll put it on.</s>BIDEN: Put in on the Web site. The fact of the matter is --</s>BIDEN: -- he's flat lying.</s>BRIANNA KEILAR, CNN HOST: And here is how Biden responded to questions about fracking in two previous Democratic debates.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MODERATOR: Just to clarify, would there be any place for fossil fuels, including coal and fracking, in a Biden administration?</s>BIDEN: No. We would work it out. We would make sure it's eliminated and no more subsidiaries for either one of those. Either -- any fossil fuel.</s>SEN. BERNIE SANDERS (I-VT): Tell the fossil fuel industry we're going to move aggressively to wind, solar, stainable energy --</s>UNIDENTIFIED MODERATOR: Thank you.</s>SANDERS: -- and energy efficiency.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MODERATOR: Thank you, Senator.</s>BIDEN: No more, no new fracking.</s>KEILAR: It's not clear if the fracking debate will turn off any potential Biden voters. CNN national correspondent, Jason Carroll, watched the debate with a group of Democratic voters in battleground Pennsylvania, and they were impressed with his performance.</s>BIDEN: Thank you.</s>JASON CARROLL, CNN NATIONAL CORRESPONDENT (voice-over): Minutes after the debate ended, a group of Democratic supporters who had gathered for a socially distanced, backyard watch party in the Mount Airy section of Philadelphia, were ready to weigh in with their verdict. (on camera): Who felt as though Vice President Joe Biden met or exceeded your expectation during the debate? Show of hands.</s>DAMON WALKER, BIDEN SUPPORTER: Four more years of Trump is not going to work in America.</s>CARROLL (voice-over): Damon Walker, a correctional officer and father of four, agrees with Jasmine Schley, who says some of Vice President Biden's best moments came when he addressed the COVID-19 pandemic.</s>JASMINE SCHLEY, BIDEN SUPPORTER: When he talked about the families who have died because of coronavirus, it shows his humanity. And that's one thing that you never hear President Trump mention. He talks about the economy, he talks about his poll numbers, but he never takes the time to acknowledge the suffering of Americans.</s>WALKER: I believe he did what he needed to do. He answered all the questions, and he stated the facts. He didn't veer off-point.</s>MACK DUNCAN, BIDEN SUPPORTER: He answered the questions, he had a plan, he explained it. That's it.</s>CARROLL: In this predominantly African American middle-class community, residents such as Billie Jo McKinney, a mom of five including a young son, says Biden's answer on race in America made an impact.</s>BILLIE JO MCKINNEY, BIDEN SUPPORTER: He showed compassion for all races. And the story about him saying that he's never had to teach his daughter about putting her hands on the wheel, that's a big deal for me because I'm going to have to teach my 6-year-old that. And that's painful.</s>CARROLL: Also important for people like McKinney and Walker -- who, again, is a correctional officer -- was to hear Biden's response to his past support of crime bills that resulted in high rates of incarcerating African-Americans for petty drug offenses.</s>BIDEN: It was a mistake.</s>WALKER: He answered the question by first apologizing.</s>MCKINNEY: He took accountability and he apologized immediately, something we have not seen from our current administration.</s>CARROLL (voice-over): Biden scored points on character and integrity with the group after hearing what he would say to those who do not support him.</s>BRIAN CLINTON, PHILADELPHIA MAYOR'S OFFICE: Joe Biden, when he said it's human decency, American values are on the ballot in November, I thought -- that really spoke to me.</s>UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: Trump didn't answer that at all.</s>CARROLL: The watch party organized by City Councilwoman Cherelle Parker, a Democrat, who says beyond tonight's performance, it's Biden the candidate who will ultimately drive supporters to the polls.</s>CHERELLE PARKER, PHILADELPHIA COUNCILWOMAN: One of the things that I like about Joe Biden the most is what you see is what you get. And people from all walks of life know that they want a steady leader.</s>CARROLL: Jason Carroll, CNN, Philadelphia.</s>KEILAR: CNN was also on the ground in Illinois, where Trump supporters gathered to watch the debate. Elle Reeve has that part of the story.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: Trump 2020, baby, Trump 2020.</s>ELLE REEVE, CNN CORRESPONDENT(voice-over): We're in a baseball stadium called the Corn Crib in a town called Normal, Illinois, where hundreds of Trump supporters have gathered to watch the debate, an event hosted by the local Republican Party.</s>CONNIE BEARD, CHAIRMAN, MCLEAN COUNTY REPUBLICAN PARTY: This event has sort of snowballed. We have our McLean County Republican tent, of course, and our little Trump store.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: There you go.</s>BEARD: We have a raffle for a semiautomatic shotgun that is apparently very popular.</s>KENNY MOREAU, TRUMP SUPPORTER: I just like the no-bullshit attitude of, hey, I want to make America great. I don't understand what the problem is of trying to bring everyone up in America to do good things.</s>REEVE (on camera): But is it no bullshit to have only paid, like, $750 in taxes?</s>MOREAU: And here's the deal, and that I would love to be able to comment on that. I don't know. And it's one of those situations where you and I can both sit here and say if we made that kind of money, you know that you're going to play the tax game. It's set there for millionaires to be able to play this game.</s>REEVE: But would you want him to change it so that millionaires couldn't play that game?</s>MOREAU: Yes. In the grand scheme of things, it would be great.</s>REEVE: How do you think it's going so far?</s>PAUL BROWN, TRUMP SUPPORTER: As I expected it to go. Mr. Joe Biden is talking a lot of trash and lies. He's not being truthful with the American people.</s>REEVE: Well, like, what made you cheer? Do you remember a moment?</s>BROWN: I guess when President Trump was talking about bringing out the details with the Biden crime family.</s>REEVE: So like when Trump was hitting him hard?</s>BROWN: Yes, oh, yes.</s>REEVE: Have you ever watched a debate in a crowd like this before?</s>BROWN: Not like this, no. It's pretty cool.</s>REEVE: Well, what do you think about it?</s>BROWN: I love it.</s>REEVE: Is there a moment that made you cheer?</s>UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: Yes. Everything that's coming out about how -- about Hunter Biden's computer. That was the -- I saw that as a grand slam.</s>REEVE: How do you think the debate went tonight?</s>JEANIE QUIRAM, TRUMP SUPPORTER: Great. He was absolutely wonderful. Trump nailed him.</s>REEVE: Well, what was your favorite moment?</s>QUIRAM: Just all of it. I thought it was absolute -- the best debate by far, and it was great.</s>REEVE: Trump 2020. Look at this baby. There he is.</s>DAWN NOWLIN, TRUMP SUPPORTER: I was really glad he brought up all the Biden Hunter e-mails.</s>REEVE: OK.</s>NOWLIN: Or the -- excuse me, Hunter Biden e-mails.</s>REEVE: OK.</s>NOWLIN: Let's get that right. Honestly, I wish he would have been slightly more aggressive.</s>JOHN T. GRIFFIN, TRUMP SUPPORTER: Oh, John, I saw my number, way up in the middle of the air. Amen. Right?</s>REEVE: Yes, that was pretty good.</s>KEILAR: Next, the Senate majority leader fielding questions after he appeared on Capitol Hill with visible bruises and bandages this week. Hear what Mitch McConnell had to say about it. Plus, we'll take you live to Delaware as soon as Joe Biden comes to the podium to detail his plan to fight COVID-19.
Pandemic Is Raising Fears of a Global Recession; Still No Health Care Plan from Trump 11 Days Before Election
KEILAR: As the number of coronavirus cases continues to surge across the U.S. and the rest of the world, the pandemic is raising fears of a global recession. CNN politics and business correspondent, Cristina Alesci, has more.</s>CRISTINA ALESCI, CNN POLITICAL & BUSINESS CORRESPONDENT: Brianna, as coronavirus cases grow in the U.S. and around the world, so does the risk of recession. Business activity has fallen back into decline in Europe, according to data that tracks the manufacturing and services sector. There's also signs the U.S. economy could be running into trouble. A survey of economists show they expect both manufacturing and service activity to remain roughly flat compared to the previous month. That means the recovery could look more like a "W," a double dip, than the "V" that Trumped promised, especially if there's any delay in vaccine roll-out and additional stimulus -- Brianna?</s>KEILAR: All right. Cristina, thank you so much. The president was once again asked last night about his mysterious health care plan, the one that doesn't exist. He's been teasing a plan to replace Obamacare, the law that he's trying to kill without replacing it. And with 12 days to go and millions of Americans having already voted.</s>TRUMP: I would like to do is a much better health care, much better. We'll always protect people with preexisting conditions. I would like to terminate Obamacare, come up with a brand-new beautiful health care. The Democrats will do it because there will be tremendous pressure on them. And we might even have the House by that time. And I think we're going to win the House. OK. You'll see. But I think we're going to win the House. But come up with a better health care, always protecting people with preexisting conditions.</s>KEILAR: Still no comprehensive plan to protect Americans with preexisting conditions. No plan that could actually be sent to Congress to become a law. No plan despite countless promises, countless timetables and countless missed deadlines.</s>TRUMP: I will ask Congress to convene a special session so we can repeal and replace. And it will be such an honor for me, for you, and for everybody in this country. But as soon as our secretary is approved and gets into the office, we'll be filing a plan. We have a really terrific, I believe, health care plan coming out. We're going to have a health care plan that's going to be second to none. It's going to be great. We have two plans coming out. Coming out in a very short period of time. We're going to come up with a health care plan. We're not going to vote on it until after the election. The plan is coming out over the next four weeks. We're going to produce phenomenal health care and we already have the concept of the plan. And it'll be --</s>GEORGE STEPHANOPOULOS, ABC NEWS ANCHOR: Do you mind telling me what the plan is?</s>TRUMP: Yes. We'll be announcing that in two months, maybe less. We have a great plan coming out. It's going to be -- if we can take back the House. We're signing a health care plan within two weeks, a full and complete health care plan. We're going to be doing a health care plan. We're going to be doing a very inclusive health care plan. I'll be signing it sometime very soon.</s>TRUMP: It might be Sunday, but it's going to be very soon. We're going to be introducing a tremendous health care plan sometime prior to -- hopefully, prior to the end of the month. It's just about completed now. We're going to be doing a health care plan very strongly.</s>STEPHANOPOULOS: You've been promising a new health care plan. I interviewed you in June of last year. You said the health care plan would be coming in two weeks. You told Chris Wallace this summer it would come in three weeks. You promised an executive order on preexisting --</s>TRUMP: I have it all ready.</s>KEILAR: His response on this has really become a joke at this point. But voters say health care is actually one of the most important issues they have. And in the middle of a pandemic, no one is laughing. Moments ago, Joe Biden arrived to the venue in Wilmington, Delaware, where he will be delivering a speech on coronavirus response. We'll bring you that live as soon as he comes to the podium. First, though, we have an update on one of our "CNN Heroes." Since 2018, Woody Faircloth has been providing R.V.s to families who lose their homes to wildfires, to floods and other disasters. He's even given front line medical workers a place to stay as they fight COVID-19. Most recently, he and his daughter, Luna, are giving shelter to people impacted by California's North Complex West Zone Fire.</s>WOODY FAIRCLOTH, CNN HERO: Unfortunately, this fire has really affected a lot of first responders. Six of the seven volunteer fighters in Berry Creek lost their homes, including the chief. So Luna and do what we do. We sourced a couple of donated R.V.s and we headed out to California and delivered one to Chief Reed Rankin. REED RANKIN, CHIEF, BERRY CREEK VOLUNTEER FIRE DEPARTMENT; I just can't say thank you enough. I deeply appreciate it because water will be coming on here in a month and a half. At least we have somewhere to be.</s>FAIRCLOTH: He loves his community.</s>RANKIN: It's huge. I mean --</s>RANKIN: It's huge.</s>FAIRCLOTH: A couple of thousands of his neighbors are left homeless. Fifteen people were killed in the fire. They've been through a lot. But the chief is still out there every day on the line fighting the fire.</s>RANKIN: I think we'll start over somehow. I just got to get everything done up here and get the fire completely out and get people back in to see the stuff and then I can figure out what I'm going to do. But I'm definitely staying in Berry Creek. I'm definitely going to somehow rebuild. Hopefully, FEMA will help us out.</s>KEILAR: And for Woody's full story, go to CNNheroes.com.
Candidates Blitz Battlegrounds in Final Election Sprint; Biden and Trump Spar over Future of Obamacare; Undecided Voters Pay Close Attention to Final 2020 Debate.
JOHN KING, CNN ANCHOR: Hello, everybody. I'm John King in Washington. Thank you so much for sharing this very important day with us. The debates are done. Today opens the final sprint to America's choice. The president is in Florida today. His vice president hits battleground Ohio and battleground Pennsylvania. Joe Biden plans a speech in the coronavirus at home in Delaware. Senator Kamala Harris heading to Georgia. The weekend is busy with campaign events too. Just 11 days left now. A state by state chess match now that the final debate is in the books. The instant polls after last night's final showdown gave the edge to Democrat Biden. The instant analysis was that the president maybe helped himself some by staying civil for a change and by drawing policy contrast on issues like taxes and energy. But no game changer in a race where the president needed one. Now, America's take is sometimes very different from Washington's take and it will take a few days to know for sure what you think. Biden's debate stage argument was the case for change. Arguing the incumbent does not have a plan. Not on healthcare, not on the pandemic. And Biden says the country needs a president who cares about you and who understands how to make government work. It is a low bar, yes, but just that the president wasn't rude and allowed policy conversations gave Republicans cheer. And if you watched, you heard the president's obsession with recreating his 2016 map. He called out Texas and Pennsylvania. Ohio, too. That as Biden outlined his views on fracking and fossil fuels. Being civil did not guarantee being truthful. Both candidates stretched or abandoned the facts at times, but in the president's case it was constant. The coronavirus pandemic is the defining November issue and was the night's first topic. The alternative facts from the president were many. He says vaccines are weeks from being ready, children are virtually immune, it's rounding the corner that's a direct quote, and it's going away. But the numbers don't lie. Thursday, 71,000 plus new infections. 71,000 is the fourth highest single day total of this pandemic. The daily average of new cases, 61,000. 12 states hitting new highs for their daily average. COVID-19 has 40,000 Americans in the hospital today. And the daily average of new deaths sadly is ticking up again as well. Let's go through some of these as we look at it. This is the pandemic election. And the virus is making a late campaign statement. No other way to say it. 32 states trending in the wrong direction. You see them here in the red and orange on the map. The red is Rhode Island. That means 50 percent more infections now than a week ago in Rhode Island. The orange means you have at least 10 percent more infections this week between 10 percent and 50 percent. And you just see it. It's everywhere, including the big states that drove the summer surge. Florida, Texas, Arizona and California all now trending up again. The big populous states joining a lot of these smaller states out in the plains and the prairie. That's a dangerous sign as we move forward. If you look at the cases, again, averaging 60,000 now. Went well up again yesterday. Remember, the president said this would disappear in April. Then the vice president said it would largely be behind us by Memorial Day. Again, in July, right at the peak of the summer surge, the president said the virus will disappear. President said that late July. Since then, more than 53 percent, 54 percent if you round up of the cases since the president said it will disappear. More than 36 percent or 36 percent of the deaths since the president said it would disappear. And the count of course continues. This is troubling. And it's sad statistics. We saw how high the death trend went early on when doctors were still trying to figure out how to deal with this virus, came down, went up a little bit in the summer surge, came down again, starting if you see the end there to trend back up. 1,000 deaths a day. The positivity rate is what is so alarming. Positivity right now means more infections today but also more infections tomorrow because a lot of people are infecting others. Look at the deep colors. Double digits Florida. Alabama and Mississippi, high double digits, 55 percent this week. Positivity rate in Iowa, 21 percent in Kansas. 35 percent, South Dakota. 31 percent, Wyoming. 33 percent, Idaho. That's just a bad map. It tells you the coronavirus is rampant in some of these places which means the new infections will continue. If you look at the states with the highest rates per capita right now, these are the 10. These are the 10 states that this week have the highest per capita rate of new infections. If you're looking at it in a political context, nine of these 10 voted for Trump in 2016. Three of them, Illinois, Montana and Wisconsin have Democratic governors. With this, the Trump map, if you will, right now is dealing with coronavirus in a big way. The president talked about blue states, blue states. He blames blue states governors for the coronavirus. It is true that the states ran by Democratic governors went up the hill early, the West Coast, New England, New York, they came down. We're up in the summer surge but nowhere near as much as there were states with the Republican governors. Everybody is going back up right now. We should treat it as an American problem, not a red state or blue state problem. But if the president wants to make a political argument, the states with Republican governors, have a bigger problem at the moment than the states with Democratic governors but everybody is trending up. This was a giant flashpoint in the debate last night. The president of the United States saying, we got this. We're turning the corner. Things are getting better. Joe Biden saying that is simply untrue.</s>JOE BIDEN (D), PRESIDENTIAL NOMINEE: We're about to go into a dark winter. A dark winter. And he has no clear plans.</s>DONALD TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: I don't think we're going to have a dark winter at all.</s>BIDEN: He talks about this is -- don't worry, it's all going to be over soon.</s>TRUMP: I say we're learning to live with it. We have no choice.</s>BIDEN: Learning to live with it? Come on. We're dying with it because he's never said - you see he said it's dangerous. When's the last time, is it really dangerous still? We're dangerous, you tell the people it's dangerous now, what should they do about the danger? And you say I take no responsibility.</s>KRISTEN WELKER, PRESIDENTIAL DEBATE MODERATOR: Let me talk about your --</s>TRUMP: Excuse me, I take -- I take full responsibility. It's not my fault that it came here. It's China's fault.</s>KING: Let's breakdown last night and what it might mean looking forward. Joining me right now, Dan Balz with "The Washington Post," CNN's MJ Lee and CNN's Jeff Zeleny. Dan, I want to start with you because as I noted at the top, the instant analysis was the poll show Biden wins the debate. The instant analysis was the president did OK. He wasn't rude. Republicans are cheerful they're not being asked questions today about a rude and interrupting president. The question is does it change the dynamic of the race, you write this, this morning. "If, at worse, the debate was judged a draw, that alone would be less than the president needed politically. Trump stuck to a more traditional game plan in the hope that he could begin to win over or win back voters he needs to secure a second term. If the latest polls are accurate, the president has considerable ground to make up, but a path still exists for him to win another electoral college majority, one essentially identical to the narrow path he followed to victory four years ago." And that is the question. Did he do enough? He pressed Biden on taxes. He pressed Biden on energy. You could hear the words out of his mouth, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Oklahoma, Texas, did he do enough?</s>DAN BALZ, CHIEF CORRESPONDENT, "THE WASHINGTON POST": Hard to say, John, probably not. I think for a number of reasons. One, the - which was the top of this whole program, which is the state of the coronavirus pandemic. I think that we all wondered back in late July and August what this would look like in the final weeks of the campaign. Would it be going down? Would it look like it is being contained or would it not? We certainly have the answer at this point and it's not. And that's not good news for the president because it's the one big issue that continues to be a drag on him and the way people are judging his -- his presidency and the way he has handled his presidency. I think the other big factor is that more than 47 million people have already voted. It's quite an astonishing number. Now, we're expecting record turn out and it may be another 100 million who are going to vote between now and Election Day. But there is a dwindling pool of people from whom Trump can get votes. Most of his voters or many of his voters still have not voted. He needs an enormous turnout from his supporters and people who didn't vote in 2016 from him but are like minded of his supporters. And so, I think those are the main obstacles that he faces. I think he did what he came to do last night at the debate. And certainly, the Republicans and people around the president are quite happy with that. But it's a -- it's a high hurdle that he has to get over in order to change what has been a movement away from him for a long time. And MJ, the frontrunner Joe Biden knows that coming in. He knows he's in command. So, his strategy was clearly more cautious. He clearly knew just don't make a mistake here. But he also knew number one the coronavirus pandemic. He wants to make it a test of leadership, the president has failed. We need a new president. That is the Biden argument. But then he links into at the issue of health care. He says this president is arguing before the Supreme Court as early as a week after the election to try to take away Obamacare. Biden trying to make the point that in the middle of a pandemic this president simply doesn't get an issue that is critical to most Americans. Listen to the health care exchange.</s>TRUMP: But it no longer is Obamacare, because without the individual mandate it's much different. Preexisting conditions will always stay.</s>BIDEN: He's been talking about this for a long time. There is no -- he's never come up with a plan. What I'm going to do is pass Obamacare with a public option, become Bidencare.</s>TRUMP: When he says public option, he's talking about socialized medicine.</s>BIDEN: He thinks he's running against somebody else. He's running against Joe Biden. I beat all those other people because I disagreed with them.</s>KING: It was an interesting take. It was nice to actually have a policy debate last night, whether you're Democrat or Republican or in between to see that merit out. But Biden's position was number one, the president wants to take away Obamacare. And number two, I'm not Bernie Sanders.</s>MJ LEE, CNN POLITICAL CORRESPONDENT: Yes. And you know, I think it's fascinating when you take the issue of healthcare. I think this is a great example of an area where we didn't actually see the president make a successful affirmative case for what his second term in the White House would look like. And he actually badly needed to do that last night, right? It wasn't enough for President Trump to just have a night with less interruptions and be a little bit you know more in control of his behavior. He really needed to use this sort of last opportunity to talk to the nation about why people should actually vote for him again and give him another four years. And on the issue of health care this has been an ongoing issue for the president, he wasn't actually able to say what he would actually replace Obamacare with. He has been saying for a while, I have a plan, I have a plan coming, but we've not actually seen a full wholesome detail of whatever that plan is. And I think Biden really seized on that. It's also the reason that we're going to see him back here in Wilmington making another speech that has to do with COVID-19 and the economy. I'm kind of losing count at this point on how many speeches, how many remarks, how many campaign events have been centered around this issue. Clearly, he has decided this is the issue that most Americans care about the most and nothing else matters as much as this issue and how the country is going to come out of this pandemic.</s>KING: And Jeff Zeleny, that gets to the challenge for the president because the cases are surging, the president's record is on the public record. And most Americans do not think he has handled this virus correctly. So, he was trying to have a bit of a reboot last night. You write this morning about how Republicans are at least cheered about the fact that it was not an insult fest and it was a policy debate. One of the big policy arguments the president wanted to make, and Republicans were grateful for this. Was this elect Joe Biden, the president says, he will raise your taxes and he will hurt the economy. Listen.</s>TRUMP: I'm cutting taxes and he wants to raise everybody's taxes and he wants to put new regulations on everything. He will kill it. If he gets in you will have a depression the likes of which you've never seen. Your 401(k)s will go to hell and it'll be a very, very sad day for this country.</s>KING: Biden's counter argument is that's not true. That you know, if you even look at the market - market has factored in a Biden victory. And he's not that worried. But the president was making a Republican economic argument there, instead of throwing insults which left Republicans happy.</s>JEFF ZELENY, CNN SENIOR WASHINGTON CORRESPONDENT: Absolutely was. And that is something that was music to the ears of Republican Senate candidates in particular. The big reason, John, I was talking to an adviser to a key Senate race just a short time ago. They said they're not spending the morning answering questions about the debate last night. They're not spending the day or worried about spending the day defending the president or saying are you with him on whatever outlandish thing he may have said. So, the reality is the policy debate, it was a normal debate. It was - you know it seemed like one of the most normal things we've seen in this campaign, was actually just that. But there are those policy disagreements out there. And it is one thing that Republicans believe that, in particular, in states like Pennsylvania and in Florida, they will keep some, either moderates or Republicans who are frustrated with Trump, from voting for Joe Biden by that economic argument. So, that is something that is going to playout over the next several days or so. There hasn't been all that much of a discussion about the Biden -- a tax plan, of course, he says that he will only raise taxes on households for more than $400,000, but Democrats believe that that is sort of a barrier to getting some of the college educated men to vote for him because they're worried about the direction of the Democratic Party. That was one of the discussions that were happening there. But John, I agree with Dan, it is hard to imagine that this is going to upset the trajectory of this race. Because it has not changed the fundamental elephant in the room and that is coronavirus. This is not going to change how people are living this every day in their lives, seeing the cases rise, the schools close, et cetera. So that is something that President Trump could not do last night.</s>KING: And so, Dan, you have this. You could see the different strategies. Joe Biden knows he's in the lead. He's talking big picture. He's talking coronavirus. He's talking leadership. I know how to make government work. Joe Biden also talking an issue that is important to him. Essentially, pointing to the president and saying think of who you want as a president, let's talk about character. Listen.</s>BIDEN: You know who I am. You know who he is. You know his character. You know my character. You know our reputations for honor and telling the truth. I am anxious to have this race. I am anxious to see this take place. I am -- the character of the country is on the ballot. Our character is on the ballot. Look at us closely.</s>KING: The president then tried to turn the tables listen to this piece where he essentially says Joe Biden has been around forever, what has he gotten done. Listen.</s>WELKER: President Trump, your response?</s>TRUMP: Excuse me. He was there for 47 years. He didn't do it. It was just a little while ago, right? Less than four years ago. He didn't do anything. He had eight years he was vice president. He did nothing. You guys did nothing.</s>BIDEN: We did.</s>TRUMP: You know, Joe. I ran because of you. You're all talk and no action, Joe.</s>WELKER: Your response.</s>BIDEN: We got a lot of it done. We released 38,000 ...</s>TRUMP: You didn't get anything done.</s>KING: Biden has the edge, Dan. If you look at the polling when it comes to questions of character and honesty. So, that's a card he wanted to play. Can the president play that outside, a card that did work against Hillary Clinton four years ago? But he's the incumbent now. So, a little different. Isn't it?</s>BALZ: It's a lot harder today. Certainly, Joe Biden has a very long record in public service and there's a lot that the president can pick apart on that, as he did last night and as they've done through the campaign. But the idea that because he's been in office for 47 years does not seem to have been a great impediment to a lot of voters. They seem to at this point continue to trust Joe Biden more, certainly on the pandemic and on healthcare generally, on economic issues, most of the polls now show that there's kind of an even split on something that was a presidential advantage. So, the president, I think, will continue to make this argument about him. But I don't know how far it will go. Certainly, on the character question, the vice president - the former vice president wants to keep that front and center because he knows that on that issue in particular, he has an advantage. So, to some extent what we heard last night was a repetition of arguments on both sides that have been made for quite some time. What was different was it was done in a calmer way. And so, I think viewers got a better sense of both the differences between the two men in terms of who they are but also what they would like to do and the disagreements they have with one another over policy.</s>KING: Oh, actually we got to heard -- we got to hear what they wanted to say which I guess that is unusual I guess as part of our new normal. But it was. It was a normal debate. It was refreshing. Dan Balz, MJ, Jeff Zeleny, thank you all so much for joining us with your reporting and incites. Up next for us, we continue the conversation. Undecided voters share their takes on the candidates' debate performances and whether the needle moved. First, quick glimpse in a few of the catch races from last night.</s>BIDEN: Come on, there's not another serious scientist in the world who thinks it's going to be over soon.</s>WELKER: President Trump, your response?</s>TRUMP: Excuse me. He was there for 47 years. He didn't do it.</s>BIDEN: Come on. Come on, folks.</s>WELKER: President Trump --</s>TRUMP: Excuse me.</s>WELKER: -- please respond, and then I have some follow-ups.</s>TRUMP: We are energy -- we are energy independent for the first time.</s>BIDEN: Come on. What's the matter with these guys?</s>TRUMP: The bill that was passed --
Joe Biden to mandate Use of Masks; President Trump Sees the Pandemic Differently
CHRIS CUOMO, CNN HOST: Give me time. Give me time.</s>DON LEMON, CNN HOST: You're only supposed to sing that song with me. What happened?</s>CUOMO: It's too instructive. He is wrong in terms of which Republican president passed to compare himself to. It's not Lincoln. We know why he does it. It's Herbert Hoover. He denied the extent of the depression, he wasn't with the people and it wound up costing him that election. I don't know that will happen here, but FDR came in with the big ideas about going big. I don't know why he didn't do that. The wall mentality is what everybody needs right now. Throw everything at it.</s>LEMON: We should have him talk to Margaret? Hoover. She works with us.</s>CUOMO: Yes, I know.</s>LEMON: It's her great grandfather.</s>CUOMO: I know. I know both halves of the Hoovalons, Margaret Hoover and John Avlon.</s>LEMON: I thought -- I thought corned them the Hoovalons. Yes, it is very instructive. I mean if you watch Archie Bunker from Queens, right, then you get an idea of who's actually sitting in the White House right now. It's that kind of mentality or you think he may represent that sort of, what do you think?</s>CUOMO: Here's what I think. I think that this election is tough to call because it should be all pandemic.</s>LEMON: Yes.</s>CUOMO: However, however, there is a parallel dynamic of this president seen as an agent of people's animus, their fear, their outrage, their humiliation, their distaste for the elites and the system. And I coin the phrase from the movie "Snatch" when one of the characters says, do you know what nemesis means? The righteous infliction of retribution manifested in the appropriate agent. That's what Trump is. He is their animus. He is their virus. Inserted into the political corpus --</s>LEMON: He's a virus?</s>CUOMO: -- to make it sick and change.</s>LEMON: That part is true. But listen, I think that elite word, I wouldn't give too much for that elite word. What is elite? I mean, you know, he's out there saying that they are --</s>CUOMO: The rich. The Limousine liberals.</s>LEMON: Yes.</s>CUOMO: The people who run universities and institutions who look down on the working class.</s>LEMON: He's --</s>CUOMO: Who look down on the faithful.</s>LEMON: He's like Sean Hannity, like Tucker Carlson, they're all rich, like Donald Trump.</s>CUOMO: Tucker Carlson --</s>LEMON: They're all rich.</s>CUOMO: -- is absolutely --</s>LEMON: They're all.</s>CUOMO: -- checks every box of elitism. Hannity has that working man vibe he just made a lot of money.</s>LEMON: Yes. Well, still, that's rich. It doesn't matter. They're still rich.</s>CUOMO: Elite deals with looking down on others.</s>LEMON: Yes, but do you actually --</s>CUOMO: Hannity never wore a bow tie.</s>LEMON: But I'm saying, don't just -- don't just give people that because I don't really believe that liberals are looking down on others. I don't think that -- I think that word elite --</s>CUOMO: Well, it's not just liberals. There are a lot of elites on the right.</s>LEMON: -- they're looking down to a lot of people. Right. That's my point.</s>CUOMO: Yes.</s>LEMON: That's my whole point.</s>CUOMO: But I see, do you remember --</s>LEMON: Donald Trump is one of them.</s>CUOMO: -- Trump bashes Republicans too.</s>LEMON: Yes.</s>CUOMO: He bashes Republicans and Democrats. He's his own animal. He's his own thing.</s>LEMON: Yes.</s>CUOMO: You know, he talks about Republicans being weak all the time.</s>LEMON: Yes.</s>CUOMO: You know, his people aren't necessarily for him because he's a Republican. You hear very few Trump folks say, well, he's a Republican, so I'm going with him. Those flags say Trump.</s>LEMON: Yes.</s>CUOMO: They don't say</s>GOP. LEMON: He gives them --</s>CUOMO: They don't say Republicans.</s>LEMON: He gives them license to do and say a lot of things, let's just put it that way.</s>CUOMO: GOP is grand ole party. His is a rave.</s>LEMON: Well, we can go a lot of places with that, but I'll just get started with the show.</s>CUOMO: That was good, you can have it. I love you, D. Lemon. I'll see you tomorrow.</s>LEMON: I'll see you tomorrow. Have a good one. This is CNN Tonight. I'm Don Lemon. You know what? It's hard. I didn't get myself in trouble on that one. Normally I would, but it's been a long week, I'm not going to do it. You know why? Because as I sit here tonight, believe it or not, talking to you, there is just one full week left between now and election day. Can you believe it? And here's the fact. The fact is election day is already happening right now. Fifty-two million people have already voted, 52 million. That's 52 million ballots already cast. Thirty-six percent of people who voted in 2016 have already voted 11 days before election day right now. But there is one issue that overshadowing everything. You know what that is, don't you? I don't have to tell you. It's the coronavirus. What it's done to this country. What it's done to our economy, and what it's done to all of us. Our lives up ended because of a failure of leadership.</s>JOE BIDEN (D), PRESIDENTIAL NOMINEE: Tonight, we saw the President of the United States lie to the American people, repeatedly lie about the state of this pandemic. We saw him refuse to take responsibility for the crisis that should have been met with real presidential leadership. Instead, it has cost hundreds of thousands of Americans' lives, pushed millions into poverty. We saw him diminish the pain felt by so many Americans. President Trump said we're rounding the corner. It's going away. We're learning to live with it. There are quotes. But as I told him last night, we're not learning to live with it. We're learning to die with it.</s>LEMON: The former vice president not just laying the responsibility for the pandemic at the door of the White House, but also laying out his plan to actually do something, do something, imagine that, about the virus.</s>BIDEN: I'll go to every governor, to mandate mask wearing in those states. And if they refuse, I'll go to the mayors and county executives and get local mask wearing requirements in place nationwide. As president, I'll mandate mask wearing at all federal buildings and all interstate transportation because masks save lives, period.</s>LEMON: So, here's what is really remarkable about all of this. You know who agrees with Joe Biden? The man running against President Trump on this. President Trump's own top health official, Dr. Anthony Fauci, this country's top infectious disease expert. The man America trusts on this virus. Dr. Fauci saying that there should be a mask mandate, which is what Joe Biden is calling for.</s>DR. ANTHONY FAUCI, DIRECTOR, NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF ALLERGY AND INFECTIOUS DISEASES: If everyone agrees that this is something that's important and they mandated it, everybody pulls together and say, you know, we're going to mandate it, but let's just do it, I think that would be a great idea to have everybody do it uniformly. One of the issues though, I get the argument, if you mandate a mask, then you're going to have to enforce it and that will create more of a problem. Well, if people are not wearing masks, then maybe we should be mandating it.</s>LEMON: There you go. So, it's not, listen, this is not, this shouldn't be political to wear a piece of cloth, should not. But you know who's made it political, right? The president, on the other hand, spent all week trashing Dr. Fauci, telling you, America, turn the corner. He's lying to you. How do you know he's lying to you? Well, for one, because it's a safe bet, right? But also know because of what you're about to hear. This is from the president's own surgeon general.</s>JEROME ADAMS, U.S. SURGEON GENERAL: This week, we will probably have our highest number of cases we've ever had on a daily basis in the United States and we're really concerned that in a few weeks, we will see hospital -- we'll see deaths start to increase in our country.</s>LEMON: The worst week we have ever had, the worst, the highest number of cases we have ever had on a daily basis. Those are the facts. That's the truth. That is not rounding the corner but the president is still insisting that we're rounding the corner, even though that we can all see that it is not true even though every state but one is trending in the wrong direction.</s>DONALD TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: -- talk about is COVID, COVID, COVID. Because they want to scare people and we've done so well with it. Now it's 99.8 percent. I mean, you look at what's going on, and we're rounding the turn, we're rounding the corner, we're rounding the corner beautifully.</s>LEMON: Gees. Do you really believe that? Come on. The numbers are here, the numbers are just, go look up the numbers. Rounding the corner beautifully? Usually when someone says you're rounding the corner. They don't mean you're about to run right smack into a truck. But the president just keeps on with the super spreader tour. Like his rally today at the village's retirement community in Florida with a packed crowd of seniors, hardly any of them wearing masks, seniors, the most vulnerable. This is absolutely crazy. All those people crowded together, virtually mask-free to see the president so sick with the virus that he ended up in Walter Reed, OK? Ended up in Walter Reed, he got the virus by continuing to put himself in the position of being around a bunch of people without masks. It wasn't a sacrifice, it was stupid. He says it was a sacrifice, no, it was stupid. He didn't want to get that virus, but it was just going to go away, it wasn't real, right? And it wasn't just him, remember? He ended up in Walter Reed. The first lady was sick. Their son has the virus. Multiple people in the president's inner circle got sick, again, this is evidence and logic that I'm speaking right now. You may not agree with it, but it is the truth. The White House went into a quarantine. Chris Christie was in an ICU for seven days. Yet the president keeps doing these rallies. It defies logic because there is no logic to it. He just keeps refusing to wear a mask, encouraging his own supporters to risk their own health and their lives. So, it's interesting to hear him say this today.</s>TRUMP: You got to lead your life. And you know what? Some people want to stay in and that's good, do it, do it. You know, I'm sort of like, lead your life, right? And some people agree with me, some people, but if you want to stay in, if you want to do what you're doing, do it. If you want to get out, you want to be careful, and socially distance and all of the things, you could wear a mask if you can't socially distance, there's a lot of things you can do. But some people want to stay in and that's OK.</s>LEMON: That would be what you would call, what we call do as I say, not as I do. Before we go, there's a pivot, right? He's got a new tone. Let me play you what the same man said just a few hours earlier in the Oval Office making fun of Reuters' Jeff Mason for wearing a mask.</s>TRUMP: This is Jeff Mason. He's got a mask on. That's the largest mask I think I've seen, so I don't know if you can hear him.</s>LEMON: You know this president never changes, there's never a pivot, there's no new tone, no moment he grows into the presidency or rises to meet the level of the office. You know, President Barack Obama talked about that. We have waited for that for four years. Well, some of you, I mean, I never thought it was going to happen, but maybe you did, I don't know. He is still the man who said this about the virus six months ago today.</s>TRUMP: I said supposing you brought the light inside the body in which you can do either through the skin or in some other way. And I think you said you're going to test that too? It sounds interesting.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: We'll get the right folks who could.</s>TRUMP: Right. And then I see the disinfectant where it knocks it out in a minute. One minute. And is there a way we can do something like that by injection inside or almost a cleaning. Because you see it gets in the lungs. And it does a tremendous number. So, it would be interesting to check that.</s>LEMON: That's the president. I can't believe it's been six months, I mean, that's been six months. That's crazy. Seems like yesterday when we had the ole disinfectant bleach comment from the podium in the press briefing room. Does a number on the lungs, knock it out in a minute, one minute, inside the body? The president of the United States. He claimed during the debate that he was kidding when he said that, right? Doesn't really sound like he was kidding, does it? Because he kept going on and on. There was no smile. Like he knew, I know what I'm talking about. It's going to put it in the body. And there was something else that he said in last night's debate that shows you that he never changes.</s>TRUMP: I am the least racist person, I can't even see the audience because it's so dark, but I don't care who's in the audience, I'm the least racist person in this room.</s>LEMON: Wow. Almost sounds like that was practiced, a rehearsed or like, pulled it out of like, you know, response box or something. Because I'm wondering, where have we heard that before?</s>LEMON: Are you racist? I am the least racist person that you have ever met. I am the least racist person.</s>LEMON: Are you bigoted in any way?</s>TRUMP: I don't think so. No, I don't think so. I am a person --</s>LEMON: Islamophobic?</s>TRUMP: No, not at all.</s>LEMON: That was almost five years ago. Boy, time flies when the country is miserable, doesn't matter how many times -- that was sarcasm, by the way, the flying part at least, doesn't matter how many times that he says that. Not as a candidate last time, not as a president this time, because we know what else he said. We know what he said about deadly white supremacist violence in Charlottesville. We know he just wouldn't give a straight answer to the question of whether he disavowed David Duke, the former head of the Ku Klux Klan. We know he called African nations sending immigrants to this country, quote, and I quote, "shit hole countries." About Baltimore being infested, I don't know how anyone would want to live there. It was infested. We know what he said about black athletes who dare to protest police brutality and racial injustice. We know. Sons of bitches, remember that? Just in case you forgot. Words matter. President's words matter, but I've said it before. You have the last word, and you know what that word is? Your vote. All roads are leading now to a must-win Florida tonight. Former President Barack Obama stumping there tomorrow for Joe Biden. President Trump holding two rallies there today and our latest CNN polls shows no clear leader in that state. The man who ran Barack Obama's campaign and the man who worked on five GOP campaigns both weigh in. They are next.
GOP Lost a Battle in Penn. State Supreme Court.
LEMON: We are just 11 days away from election day and with Americans turning out by the millions to cast their ballots for the nation's next president, you need to focus on protecting your vote. And today, in the commonwealth of Pennsylvania, another major victory for voting rights. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court unanimously deciding that county elections officials cannot throw out absentee or mail-in ballots with signatures they claim don't match versions of those signatures on file. The same ruling comes after U.S. Supreme Court decision earlier this week allowing mail-in ballots to be counted if they are received within three days of election day, even if they do not have a legible postmark. But this latest ruling is really important in this election. Nearly half of the mail-in ballots approved in Pennsylvania have already been returned according to data from the secretary of state's office. So, joining me now is Pennsylvania Attorney General Josh Shapiro. Good to see you again, sir. Down to the wire, are you ready for this?</s>JOSH SHAPIRO (D), PENNSYLVANIA ATTORNEY GENERAL: We're almost there. Ten days and a wake-up, Don. We're almost there.</s>LEMON: I like the way you put that. Listen, a lot of folks would just like to wake up on November 4th, right, and having it already been decided, but we won't be that lucky. So, the ruling eliminates the challenge that could potentially have been used to disqualify a large number of votes. What exactly does this mean in terms of getting these mail-in votes counted?</s>SHAPIRO: Well, you've got to understand what we've been dealing with here, Don, in Pennsylvania. You know, Donald Trump and his enablers are just trying to chip, chip away at our laws to make it harder for people to vote and make it easier for ballots to be tossed out. You know, with this win today, we're actually 5 and O in court against Donald Trump. We're actually keeping up with the Steelers over in Pittsburgh, and what this ruling, and what this ruling I know you're a Philly guy, but I got to get that in there for the Steelers, but what this ruling means is that if your signature on the back of the envelope that you send your mail-in ballot back in doesn't exactly match the signature on file, they're not going to toss your ballot out. There's a presumption of inclusion in our election as opposed to what Donald Trump wants which is to exclude more ballots. You know, 2.9 million Pennsylvanians have requested their mail-in ballots, 1.4 million have already responded. We've got half of the electorate already in. We've got to have an election now and we've got to stop, you know, this meddling by Donald Trump and just focus on people voting.</s>LEMON: I think that's your phone. Your emergency? I do that all the time, when I have a lot of stuff in my hands. I press the emergency thing. Am I right? Was that right? I was right. Right?</s>SHAPIRO: We're good. Yes, I'm doing good.</s>LEMON: This is an emergency though, so.</s>SHAPIRO: Don, I got four kids running around the house, so I'm just try to make it through this.</s>LEMON: I understand. You know, a lot of kids make appearances now on Zoom videos and even in these television appearances. But listen, back to -- back to what we were talking about. Are you expecting, Rosh, Republicans to appeal the ruling to the Supreme Court and do you think that it will happen before or after the vote of Amy Coney Barrett's confirmation on Monday?</s>SHAPIRO: Yes. The United States Supreme Court ruled that ballots could be counted after election day, provided they were postmarked by election day. It was a four-four decision. Frankly, Don, it probably should have been an 8-nothing decision, based on the Purcell principle. The Purcell principle of course that the federal courts should not meddle in state election law matters, particularly as we get close to having an election. Obviously, if justice -- if Judge Barrett becomes Justice Barrett, she could be a deciding vote in that matter. Late tonight, the Republicans in Pennsylvania seemingly on behalf of Donald Trump asked for sure -- asked the Penn -- asked the United States Supreme Court, pardon me, to consider this issue, again, and we'll see, ultimately, what the United States Supreme Court decides to do. I would hope they would honor the Purcell principle and allow the top court in Pennsylvania, our state Supreme Court, to just do what they do best which is to interpret matters of state law and just let us have an election. Let's move forward and let's have these votes be counted.</s>LEMON: Mr. Attorney General, I'll let you get back to your four kids now and your wife. It's Friday night, so enjoy. Thank you so much for appearing. I appreciate it.</s>SHAPIRO: Good to be with you, Don. Thanks so much.</s>LEMON: Yes. Joe Biden has got an all- star group of campaign surrogates hitting must-win states. President Barack Obama is hitting Florida tomorrow. Lizzo stumping in Michigan today and there's a whole lot more. I'm going to speak with the co-chair of Biden's campaign that's Congressman Cedric Richmond. He's next.</s>LIZZO, ARTIST: I want to say, they out there trying to make America great again, but we need to finally bring America together because I don't want to go back to the way it was.
Trump Don't Deserve Support from African Americans
LEMON: Can you believe, 11 days, 11, count them, days until election day. And the Democratic vice-presidential nominee Senator Kamala Harris making the case against President Trump's efforts to court black voters.</s>SEN. KAMALA HARRIS (D-CA), VICE PRESIDENTIAL NOMINEE: You have to know the other side is spinning it.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: Yes.</s>HARRIS: Donald Trump has this goal to turn 20 percent of black men in favor of him. Donald Trump who pushed as part of his popularity, the theme that the first black man to be president of the United States was illegitimately there. Donald Trump, who, when it came to Charlottesville, on the other side peaceful protests, on the other side neo-Nazis --</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: Yes.</s>HARRIS: -- with Swastikas who were hurling racial epithet, he said fine people on each side.</s>LEMON: Well, President Trump making a last-ditch appeal to black voters, repeating his claim that no one else has done more for black Americans except possibly Lincoln.</s>TRUMP: Nobody has done more for the black community than Donald Trump, and if you look, with the exception of Abraham Lincoln, possible exception, but the exception of Abraham Lincoln, nobody has done what I've done.</s>BIDEN: Abraham Lincoln here is one of the most racist presidents we've had in modern history.</s>LEMON: Boy. Here to discuss co-chair of the Biden campaign, Congressman Cedric Richmond. Good evening, Congressman. I mean, before I get to this black vote, what did you think about that when he said that?</s>REP. CEDRIC RICHMOND (D-LA): You know, Donald Trump he is who he is. He is a pathological liar and I don't think he lets the truth get in the way of the argument he's trying to put forth. Remember, he started with the exonerated five in Central Park and (Inaudible) death penalty to them and never back off of it. When African American athletes were trying to take a social position to improve the lives of black families and protect black men. He called them sons of bitches, and that goes to show you how he thought about those athletes and their cause and about their mothers. And so, this guy is exactly who he is. He is a blatant racist, he doesn't use a dog whistle. I think Vice President Biden last night said he uses a foghorn, and so, let's just stop pretending about it. He wants to see if he can get 10 or 12 percent of black males to either stay at home and not go vote for Vice President Biden, but it's not going to work.</s>LEMON: Well, I was just going to ask you that. So, you heard Senator Kamala Harris there saying, she's not having it with the president's goal to turn out 20 percent of black men, as you said, and she said. But, I mean, if he does manage to get the support, how much of a problem could that be for Joe Biden when you look at the overall electorate?</s>RICHMOND: Look, I think our numbers are solid. I think that we're doing very well with African American men, and of course, all African American men don't think the same way.</s>LEMON: You don't think he's going to get 20 percent, right?</s>RICHMOND: Absolutely not. I don't. I think it is somewhere around 10 percent. And so, our African American agenda is the most robust agenda for African American empowerment that's ever been promoted by a presidential candidate. So, as long as we keep talking about it and pushing it, I think both black men and women will see that our plan allows them to be the architects of their own future and empower them to accumulate wealth and all those things that go with it.</s>LEMON: Well, there are some pages, I think it's 21, 22, but maybe -- I forget, but somewhere in the 20s on, for Joe Biden's plan, I think it's like two pages for Trump's plan. So, I mean, there is a difference there. So, at his rally tonight President Trump claimed that Biden disrespected former President Barack Obama at the debate. Watch.</s>TRUMP: Joe Biden was very disrespectful last night to President Barack Hussein Obama. You saw that. Barack Hussein Obama. Remember Rush Limbaugh would always do that. He's doing Barack Hussein Obama.</s>LEMON: Congressman?</s>RICHMOND: Do you really want me to respond that on a Friday night --</s>LEMON: Yes, I actually do. Go on.</s>RICHMOND: I don't think they have enough sensors on TV for me to adequately describe the foolishness that just came out of his mouth. He was making fun of President Obama by, you know, drawing out his middle name, the same way with Senator Kamala Harris, and Vice President Biden, if you, according to Barack Obama who said that the best decision of his presidency was picking Joe Biden to be his vice president and then gave him the Presidential Medal of Freedom. And so, that relationship is thick as blood and Vice President Biden holds former President Barack Obama in the highest regard. But President Trump, his whole purpose on life in his little mind is to discredit and dismantle anything that President Obama did. That's why he's in court right now trying to repeal the Affordable Care Act, take health insurance from 20 million people in the middle of a pandemic and then the seven or eight million people that have been affected, God bless them enough so that they would survive and now he will allow them to be treated with preexisting conditions and discriminated against. But this guy is exactly who we think he is. He's a fraud, he's a con man and at some point, 11 days away, I think America is going to send him a clear message that we are better than this and we're going to unify this country and we're going to uplift the country. So, it's just hard to watch the things that come from him because on one hand, you get mad but two, you're just astonished that so many people fall for it.</s>LEMON: Well you read my mind in a sense, because if that crowd didn't buy it or eat it up, he wouldn't say it. It wouldn't come out of his mouth because it wouldn't be politically expedient for him. So, the people there listening, or they like it at some level. We have to keep that in mind. Interesting. Thank you so much, Congressman. We'll see you soon. Be well.</s>RICHMOND: Thank you, Don. Thanks for having me.</s>LEMON: So, I want to make sure you know about my podcast. We talk about all these difficult issues. It's called Silence is Not an Option. And I'm taking on the hard conversations about being black in America. In these weeks before the election, we're looking at voting and social justice, OK, and we're talking about people who are trying to steal your vote, why vote, so you've got -- you've got to listen to these podcasts. They're very interesting, very informative. So, find an Apple podcast or your favorite podcast app. Meantime, the coronavirus cases rising to near record numbers. Over -- more than 77,000 cases reported today. That is the second worst day this country s seen since the pandemic began. Stay with us for the very latest.
Mass Gatherings Worsen the Pandemic
LEMON: So, we have some breaking news in to CNN, and it involves the pandemic. Today, and this is just in. Today the United States reached the highest single day of coronavirus cases, 80,005. Yet this president is continuing to claim the United States is rounding the corner when it comes to the coronavirus. But the data is telling a different story. Look at this map. Cases are surging across the country. Forty-nine states trending in the wrong direction or holding steady. Today we have seen more than 80,000 Americans diagnosed with the virus. Michael Osterholm is here -- Osterholm is here. He is the director for the Center for Infectious Disease Research and Policy. Dr. Osterholm, good to see you. Eighty thousand today.</s>MICHAEL OSTERHOLM, DIRECTOR, CENTER FOR INFECTIOUS DISEASE RESEARCH AND POLICIES: Good to see you.</s>LEMON: Thank you. Eight thousand and five cases the highest alone today, a record setting number. What does it say to you?</s>OSTERHOLM: Well, first of all, we have to just put it in perspective. Just think at Labor Day we were at 32,000 cases in this country a day, now at 80,000 and we are going to continue to shoot straight up. These numbers are going to grow much, much larger. It's the confluence of a number of factors. And you know, as I've said over the past several weeks, we were just entering the darkest days of this pandemic.</s>LEMON: Boy, is there any doubt that the fall and the winter surge that experts warned about that it is here that is upon us?</s>OSTERHOLM: Well, actually it's a combination of things, Don, as we discussed. First of all, it's pandemic fatigue.</s>LEMON: Yes.</s>OSTERHOLM: People are just tired of dealing with the virus even though the virus is not tired of dealing with them. And so, when you look at people who are going to bars and restaurants, going to weddings and funerals, going to church, going to family gatherings, all these things are really facilitating transmission. And then you have about a third of the population unfortunately that are what I called pandemic anger. They are actually believing that this pandemic doesn't exist and that in fact, once the election is held, it will be over with. They are not going to do anything to help public health. Then you put that mix all together, and indoor air, and that's what you are talking about with the fall and winter. We know the virus transmits much, much more easily in the indoor environment. The virus concentrates there as opposed to outside. So with that mix, you know, we easily will hit six figure numbers in terms of the number of cases and the deaths are going to go up precipitously in the next three to four weeks, following usually new cases by about two or three weeks.</s>LEMON: Boy. Listen, I think you can also add, you are talking about bars and restaurants and churches and gatherings. You can add political rallies into that.</s>OSTERHOLM: Yes.</s>LEMON: And I'm wondering since we are in the season, if the leadership is even more important now, considering where we are now and where we are headed?</s>OSTERHOLM: Well, you know, at this point, it's not just about the science. The people have heard that. What we need right now is FDR moments. We need fireside chats. We need to bring people together to understand that these are going to be some of the darkest days in this country's history, at least modern history. And right now, we need leadership than can help people to understand why do we want you to stay apart. We're not asking forever. We're asking until we get a vaccine or vaccines which we will have in the second and third quarter of next year. But between now and then, it's us against the virus. And if you look at the Asian countries. Look what they have done. They have basically beaten the virus back by doing the kind of things that we recommended. So, it can be done. It's just whether or not we can convince the American public it needs to be done. The leadership is critical to do that.</s>LEMON: You are the perfect person to have on this breaking news. Thank you, Dr. Osterhom. I really appreciate it.</s>OSTERHOLM: Thank you.</s>LEMON: More than 80 --</s>OSTERHOLM: Thanks a lot.</s>LEMON: More than 80 -- yes, we'll see you soon. More than 80,000 cases today, the highest so far. There have been 80,005 coronavirus cases. This is per Johns Hopkins University. This is the highest single day reporting since the pandemic began. Over 52 million people voting already this year and we are still 11 days out to election day. What could the path to victory be? What is it? John King is at the magic wall right after this.
More Than 80,000 COVID-19 Cases Recorded Today; The Path to 270 for Biden and Trump; Changing Demographics Show the Trump Coalition is Declining; GOP Voter Registration in Key States Surpassing Democrats; Will Biden's Comment About Oil Industry Hurt Him.
DON LEMON, CNN HOST: So, it's 11 days until Election Day, and we have some breaking news. The U.S. reporting more than 80,000 new COVID-19 cases today. The single highest day since the outbreak of the pandemic. The surge in pandemic playing a key role on the road to 270. President Trump holding two packed rallies today in Florida, where cases are on the rise. No social distancing. Few people wearing masks. Falsely telling Americans that the virus is going away. Joe Biden, saying Trump has given up on fighting COVID and calling on Governors to mandate the wearing of masks as one way to get the virus under control. So, I want to get right to the candidates' paths to 270 electoral votes. 270 electoral votes, John King is at the magic wall to lay it all out for us. John, what do you have?</s>JOHN KING, CNN CHIEF NATIONAL CORRESPONDENT: Don, here we go into the final sprint the debates are behind us. The big question, did that final debate change this map in any way, a map that right now leans overwhelmingly in Joe Biden's favor. The Trump's campaign says it did. Well, you know, we'll see polling a few days ago with the Trump campaign thinks what the former vice president said about fracking, about phasing out the oil industry. The president thinks that helps him in Pennsylvania. He thinks it helps him in Ohio. He thinks it helps him secure Texas. You heard him, he said so himself during the debate. He is obsessed with this map and he thinks he got some help there. What if that were the case? We will see in the next few days. But what if that were the case? Ohio came back into the fold, the president wins Pennsylvania. He keeps Texas that certainly would get him back in to play. We get Joe Biden down to 270, because Pennsylvania's twenty are so important. But it wouldn't be not enough, even that wouldn't be enough for the president. So, let's switch maps to talk about the things we need to look for in the final days. Number one, the campaigns are polling all the time, they have data operations. They are in contact. They are watching social media. They have ways to track voters. So, one thing to watch is this. Not just where they spend their ad money, but what they say in those ads. Do they switch the rotations to adopt to something that happen in the last debate? The former vice president is spending more than President Trump. I will show in a minute why. But watch where these are all states the president won last time. He is looking to pick up Minnesota, New Hampshire. He couldn't carry those. President Trump knows that</s>LEMON: Mr. John King, thank you so much, I appreciate that sir. Another problem for the Trump campaign, the changing demographics in the U.S. Census data excuse me -- shows that the Trump coalition of white voters without a college degrees, well, it's declining while the Biden coalition of college educated whites and minority voters are on the rise. We are seeing a shift in states that were critical to Trump's 2016 victory. So, I want you to check out this chart. This is from The New York Times. In Pennsylvania, a state Trump won by less than 45,000 votes in 2016. The Trump coalition is down by 431,000. While the Biden coalition is up by 449,000. And in Wisconsin, where Trump won by less than 23,000 votes. His key voting block is down by 48,000 and Biden is up by 140,000. We are also seeing this this time, the same trend I should say, in Michigan, a state Trump won by just over 10,000 votes four years ago. So, let's break down all these numbers all right, with Mark McKinnon, the former adviser to George W. Bush and John McCain and also the executive producer of the Circus. CNN's senior political analyst, Ron Brownstein is here as well. Gentlemen, good evening. We could have dressed better for Mark, Ron, but you know --</s>RON BROWNSTEIN, CNN POLITICAL ANALYST: You know, hey, I feel like Rand Stoddard next to John Wayne in liberty valence.</s>LEMON: He wears it well. He is looking good. Thank you both. I appreciate you joining. Ron, I'm going to start with you. So just to give you an edge on his outfit. With just 11 days to go, what can we see about the impact of these changes in the electorate?</s>BROWNSTEIN: Look, the core strategy of President Trump from the beginning, when he was really sentencing the Republican Party to, is trying to squeeze bigger margins at a shrinking group that has always been his approach. To double down on whites without a college degree, Evangelical whites and rural whites. Even though all three of them are shrinking as a share of the electorate. Non-college whites, which has been his best group, decline two to three points as a share of eligible voter s every four years, going back as far as we can go and stretching forward as far as we can go. As you pointed out, what significant about this is that it's not any not surprising that it's happening in Texas, Arizona, and North Carolina. Where you have explosive growth in the young, non-white population. But it's happening even in Ohio, and Minnesota, and Michigan, and Wisconsin and Pennsylvania. And so, it's not to say there isn't a path for the president, because there are still in those Rust Belt states, Don, despite the decline, non-college whites will still pass about half of the votes this year.</s>LEMON: Right.</s>BROWNSTEIN: And many of the eligible non-voters, people who did not showed up, a majority in those states, are still non-college whites. But the problem he has got, as we talked about, is that because he has alienated everybody else to such an extent that he is going to lose college educated white where the biggest margin error ever. And despite maybe some small gains among men, he's going to lose people of color by enormous margins. He has to generate historic advantages among non-college whites every time. And Joe Biden is not Hillary Clinton. And he's picking up a few points among those voters. Especially in the Rust Belt. And it just makes it all so hard to make them add that up.</s>LEMON: OK. So, Mark, having said that on the other hand, right, we're also learning that new Republican voter registration have outnumbered new Democratic ones in key states like Pennsylvania, like North Carolina, even in Florida. Is that good news for the GOP? Because some people are saying that this is a red flag for the Biden campaign.</s>MARK MCKINNON, CNN POLITICAL COMMENTATOR: Well, it certainly a point of concern. Republicans have had very successful voter registration. In key places like Florida. Where they have out registered Democrats by 100,000 votes. And again, a close race and we know Florida is always close. So, if that can make a difference around the margins in a way that surrounds the margin at Florida is likely going to be. It's a dead heat right now. So, that can make a difference. I think that in states where, you know, you see a four or five-point advantage that may not be as big a deal. But it certainly -- the Republicans have shown that they are willing to grab knock on doors during COVID. And some of the Democratic registration happened more during the primary. But Republicans have hustled. And now registered Democrats in some key states. So, yes, that is a warning sign and problematic here. That frankly the polling doesn't capture.</s>LEMON: OK, so, it doesn't. Right? Say that again. Please.</s>BROWNSTEIN: That's right.</s>MCKINNON: Well, the polling looks at historical models. And so, looking at models from what the registration was in the last election, not what the registration numbers off a bit for the future election.</s>LEMON: Did you want to say something, Ron?</s>BROWNSTEIN: Well, to say, I mean look. I mean, you know, Trump won last time because he turned out more non-college and nonurban whites than people expected, the polls are expected. And he has a chance to win only because he's doing that again. And you know, you can see everything they do. I mean, why does he go out and hold rallies with no masks and social distancing? And you know, disdain for Dr. Fauci and talks the way he does about race. He is -- everything about him is about drilling drown. He's speaking to a minority of the country. But he's trying to reach more, convince more of those voters to come into the electorate.</s>LEMON: Fear.</s>BROWNSTEIN: And that is his one pathway. The challenge he has got, Don is that it's harder to kind of have a turnout surge in your favor when everybody else is voting in elevated rates as well. Look, Harris County in Houston past a million votes today. They had at 1.3 million in 2016. And it's indicative of what you are seeing in this kind of metro recoil from Trump's definition of the Republican Party. He lost. We talked about this before, he lost 87 of the hundred largest counties in America in 2016 by a combined 50 million votes. I'm betting he loses over 90 of them this time, by at least 18 million.</s>LEMON: And so, for states like Texas, you said Harris County, is it hard for the suburbs and for the rural areas to make up those urban, those city numbers, right?</s>BROWNSTEIN: Especially because the suburbs are now voting more like the urban areas. I mean, if you think about it, Beto O'Rourke won the four metros in Texas in 2018. The first Democrat since Johnson top to take it in all four of the metros. And Biden is going to win it as well. I mean, Richard Murray at the University of Houston projects that he can win the metros in Texas by including the suburbs by a million votes. And so the question is and when you add that to what's happening in the valley, can Trump overcome it with the rural, sure. Maybe he can. Because there are a lot of rural voters in Texas, he's going to win them 3-1. But you can see the writing on the wall, and this is what Trump has sentenced the Party to. He is exiling the Republican Party, from the fast-growing metros, that are adding populations that are driving economic growth. After this election, Republicans in the House may fewer, may have only have one fifth of all the seats with more college graduates than average. I mean, Trump is again making the party more and more dependent on places that are shrinking in population and constituencies that are shrinking. Can he make it work again? Maybe. But is a long-term proposition, I don't think any business would say write off the markets that are growing and double down on the ones that are shrinking.</s>LEMON: Very interesting. Mark, so listen. Let's talk about the enormous number of early votes already banked, 52 million so far. Do any of the models in polling or otherwise help us make sense of this, or is this totally unprecedented?</s>MCKINNON: Well, I talked to Dave Wasserman who will be on our show Sunday night, he's the guy who does all the House races for the</s>COVID. LEMON: Boy, a lot of unknowns there. Unprecedented times. Gentlemen, I can't wait to watch the show this week, ShowTime on circus -- the circus on ShowTime.</s>MCKINNON: There's a guy -- there's great voiceover for us.</s>LEMON: Yes, it's me kick it thank you. Good to see both of you. Be safe, have a great weekend.</s>BROWNSTEIN: Bye, guys.</s>LEMON: The president doubling down today on his lies about the coronavirus. Will voters by it? Plus, our breaking news tonight. This is the highest single day of new cases of the virus since the pandemic began.
President Trump Trashes Harris Mispronouncing her First Name
LEMON: Here's our breaking news. The U.S. reporting more than 80,000 new COVID-19 cases today. The single highest day since the outbreak of the pandemic and with only 11 days until Election Day. The worsening crisis is the key issue on voters' minds. President Trump holding two packed rallies today in Florida which recorded more than 5,500 cases yesterday, its highest daily increase in more than two months. There was no social distancing, very few people wore masks and the president repeating his false claim that the virus is going away, even though the fact is, it is getting worse. The science and the numbers show was us that in this moment right now. Let's discuss with two of our CNN political commentators, Mr. Mike Shields, and Mr. Bakari Sellers. Gentlemen, good evening, good to see both of you. Bakari, I have to ask you about what President Trump said earlier today about Vice President Biden's running mate Senator Kamala Harris. Here it is.</s>DONALD TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: Biden's running mate, the most liberal member of the United States Senator, and by the way Kamala will not be the first female president. She will not be your first female president. We're not supposed the socialist. Look, we're not going to be a socialist nation. We are not going to have the socialist president, especially a female socialist president. We are not going to have it. We're not going to put up with it.</s>LEMON: Especially a female and mispronouncing her name. What's up with that, Bakari?</s>BAKARI SELLERS, CNN POLITICAL COMMENTATOR: First of all, her name is Kama-la. It's very easy to pronounce. It's like comma and then la.</s>LEMON: I did that 101. I remember I did that on the air.</s>SELLERS: I wish, you know, I wish grown men like Senator Perdue and Donald Trump would simply learn how to pronounce a black person's name right. Funny story, my mom, she is probably watching right now -- Bakari is a funny name to pronounce too. I mean in elementary school she would tell teachers if you can't say Bakari just call him Mr. Sellers. So, I had teacher calling me Mr. Sellers in first and second grade.</s>LEMON: Ms. Harris is pretty easy pronounce but go on.</s>SELLERS: Actually, it is right. But when you see the disrespect and the disdain, I think that the president has these age-old tropes, where he goes out there and he tries to rile up and hit the base and hit the red meat by mispronouncing her name. That is not something that's done by accident. That is something that is done on purpose. But you know, more importantly, the socialist tags just simply are not sticking anymore. You know, these old, he is bringing out the hits from 2016 and they are just not working any more. And the president doesn't have anything new. What we saw in the debate and what we are seeing on the campaign trail is that this president speaks to 35 percent of the country and he has an inability to expand his base. And because he cannot expand his base, that is why he is down 10 points in a lot of the major polls.</s>LEMON: Mike, let me bring you in. Because you know, he needs women voters, right. I mean, you know that. Everyone wants as many voters as they can get. What was that?</s>MIKE SHIELDS, CNN POLITICAL COMMENTATOR: Look these rallies are base turn-out rallies. President Obama did a base turnout rally for Joe Biden that was really harsh partisan and really went after the president. Attack him pretty harshly. And that's what you do when you are talking to the base. When you are 10 days out from the election, the idea is to motivate base voters and make sure they show up and vote. And one of the things I'll tell you about the Trump rallies, and you can look this up, they capture data from all the people that shows up in these rallies and they are getting up to 20 percent of the people had never voter before. And a huge number of them are Democrats that are coming to the rallies. So, they are actually base rallies, but they are motivating people that had not taken part before they show up to these rallies. And so that's the point of the rally. That's what you do in a base rally. You charge up the base. And the president gets up there and sees himself as an entertainer. He is sort of riffing and he is trying get the base motivated just like President Obama did.</s>LEMON: You rally the base by saying misogynistic things? About not a female?</s>SHIELDS: Well, look. He comes up with nicknames for all of his opponents. We have talked about this. That is kind of his way of doing things, sleepy Joe, and you know, low energy Jeb. And you know --</s>LEMON: But he pronounces their names right. He pronounces Joe right. He pronounces Jeb correctly. It's not so hard, it's comma, like a period, an exclamation point, comma, just out a la, on it. Comma-la. It's so easy. It's really very, very easy.</s>SHIELDS: Yes, look. Don, I would posit that mispronouncing Kamala Harris' name is designed to make Democrats get mad at him for mispronouncing it and to the delight of the base, and that's the sort of thing that the politics are in right now. As you say things that make your base angry, then you guys come out and talk about it and they say, look, he is fighting the guys that I want to fight, and to him, that's the way to motivate the base.</s>LEMON: Does that make it Democrats angry, Bakari?</s>SELLERS: Well, yes. I mean, part of the reason it does, is because we still have PTSD from 2016 and I have not seen a more anxious group of individuals in the entire world ever at any point in history than Democrats in this election. I think that's why we are voting</s>LEMON: He never called Hillary Clinton, Hi-lary or hill-ary.</s>SELLERS: First of all, I mean, Donald Trump -- but Donald Trump has this history. This isn't anything new. I mean, I just on my podcast talked to Abby Philip. You know whether it's Abby Philip or whether or not it's Yamiche, you know, I'm surprised he didn't blow a gasket last night with Kristen Welker. But he really has a difficult time dealing with black women who have some level of authority. And I think that, you know, having Kamala Harris on the ticket is just driving him crazy, day in, day out. Now, yes, he does attack men, he attacks white folk. But he really, really, really just goes after black women. He goes after their intellect. As you see, he can't -- he apparently can't pronounce Kamala's name. He called Abby Philip basically stupid. April Ryan, Yamiche, I mean, it goes on and on and on. And you see this, this is, this is just something and I you know, I, my heart goes out for Mike and the rest of the Republican Party. Because one of the things we are realizing is that the racism and xenophobia and bigotry of Donald Trump is not a bug, it's a feature. And they won't be able to get rid of this after November 3rd. If Donald Trump loses this election, this is still Donald Trump's Party for the next decade plus.</s>LEMON: Let me ask you this. Listen, I am simply pointing out that he pronounces everyone's name correctly. Gives them a nickname, but he at least pronounces their name correctly and so there's something to be said about that. That was what I was pointing out. So, listen, Bakari, then Mike, I'm going to bring you in again. The vice president last night getting some flak for calling a transition from the oil industry. Is that going to hurt him?</s>SELLERS: Well, I'm glad that they came out and cleared it up. I mean, I think that one of the things that Vice President Biden sometimes does, is you know, stumble over his words and when he stumbles over his words. His campaign is then forced to come out and rectify this. I don't think that this is going to have some, as Jason Miller talks about. This is devastating in Pennsylvania, or this is devastating anywhere else. I don't find it that to be the case at all. In fact, I don't think last night's debate is going to move anybody anywhere.</s>LEMON: OK.</s>SELLERS: We are in the -- as Mike said, we are in a geo TV stage, we are not wooing voters any longer.</s>LEMON: Let me bring Mike in. Quickly, Mike, because I want to get your response, what do you think?</s>SHIELDS: It absolutely is going to hurt him. And that is why you saw members of Congress, like Torres small, in New Mexico, and horn in Oklahoma immediately cut Democrats who were in oil producing areas coming out and saying, oh, my god, I don't agree with Joe Biden on this. Because they know how devastating it is. These are exactly the types of things that Republicans are trying get through as a message to energy workers about what is going to happen to their industry and it really hurts them in western Pennsylvania.</s>LEMON: Mike, thank you. Bakari, thank you as well. I appreciate it. This is our breaking news, more than 80,000 coronavirus cases recorded today, the single highest day since the pandemic began. Plus, the FBI arresting a man for rioting during the George Floyd protest in Minneapolis. That man turns out is a self-described supporter of an extremist anti- government group.
2020 Final Presidential Debate; John Fetterman, Lieutenant Governor of Pennsylvania, and Sarah Longwell, Founder, Republican Voters Against Trump, Are Interviewed About the Final Presidential Debate; Mike Pompeo Meets with Azerbaijan and Armenia Ministers for Another Cease Fire; Zohrab Mnatsakanyan, Armenian Minister of Foreign Affairs; Presidential Polls.
CHRISTIANE AMANPOUR, CHIEF INTERNATIONAL CORRESPONDENT: Hello, everyone, and welcome to "Amanpour." Here's what's coming up.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: What they said last night really don't mean nothing to me. Because you're going to tell me what I want to hear anyway, just so I can vote for you.</s>AMANPOUR: So, how many swing votes were decided by that last debate? Pennsylvania's lieutenant governor, John Fetterman, joins us with Sarah Longwell of Republican Voters Against Trump. Then, a conflict with consequences, as a simmering row between Russia and Turkey erupts in that Cold War enclave, Nagorno-Karabakh. Why it matters for the region and why the U.S. has called both sides into emergency talks. Plus --</s>SEAN TRENDE, SENIOR ELECTIONS ANALYST, REALCLEARPOLITICS: Boy, if you haven't made your mind up about Donald Trump by now, I don't know what's going to help you choose.</s>AMANPOUR: Our Hari Sreenivasan digging deeper into the polls. What current opinions say about America, even after the election. Welcome to the program, everyone. I'm Christiane Amanpour in London, working from home this Friday. At the end of a long week, as the clock ticks down towards the most anticipated election in modern times, when the United States decides its own fate and the potential direction of the entire world for the next four years. Early voting has racked up record numbers. More than 50 million so far have cast ballots. National opinion polls clearly give challenger, Joe Biden, a lead over the incumbent Donald Trump. But unique to the United States, an electoral college decides the winner, and that means just a few key states hold a whole lot of power. And that is what happened in 2016, when President Trump lost the popular vote, but eked out an electoral college victory. Thanks to nearly 80,000 votes spread across three states, Michigan, Wisconsin, and Pennsylvania. So, who won the swing voters in the final debate as the candidates offered two starkly different visions of America? Pennsylvania was key back then. But this time, the Poll of Polls show Biden up seven points in the state. But let's take a closer look with Sarah Longwell, she's a Republican strategist and she's a Pennsylvania native who founded Republican Voters Against Trump. And we're also joined by the state's Democratic lieutenant governor, John Fetterman. Welcome to the program. So, we've heard all the noise, we've heard the reviews, we saw the debate. Apparently, it was more civil than the previous one. I want to know from your point of view what you think the biggest issue is still for American voters. First from your state, which is very important, Lieutenant Governor.</s>JOHN FETTERMAN, LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR OF PENNSYLVANIA: Well, I don't think it's a specific issue. I think it's just a referendum on the president. It's if you liked the last four years, you get a chance to vote and reup for four more or if you want to take a radically different direction, a more return to normalcy, so to speak, you're going to vote for the vice president. So, I don't know if that's an issue or just a whole bunch of issues put together. As we all know, I don't think anyone had the 2020 bingo card put together that would -- had anything looking like the way it worked out. But it's really a referendum, as I see it.</s>AMANPOUR: OK. So, that's interesting. A lot of people do see it like that, Sarah Longwell, a referendum on one man and the last four years. But what do you think about the health issue? The debate moderator raised that question first, COVID, and the response to it and these 220,000 deaths. Do you agree that it's just a referendum or that it's a big issue?</s>SARAH LONGWELL, FOUNDER, REPUBLICAN VOTERS AGAINST TRUMP: No, I think it is a referendum, but I also think that there is a dominant issue in this election, and that is the coronavirus. You know, I do focus groups all the time with 2016 Trump voters. And the fact is, his handling of the coronavirus has damaged him tremendously with his own people. Because the fact is, look, what people care about -- so, I always ask people, how do you think things are going in the country? And people say they're going really bad. Their lives have been upended by this virus. And so, they are looking for somebody to give them a plan to speak to their lives. And so, when Donald Trump goes on and on about Hunter Biden's hard drive, that's not talking to things that matter to real people. The things that they are experiencing in their lives. And it's not just the virus, it's the attending economic crisis. I mean, if you look at polls and you ask, what matters to you in this election? And people say two things, they say the economy and they say COVID. And on both of those issues, you know, Donald Trump is doing very badly going into the last 11 days of this election.</s>FETTERMAN: Yes, I don't know --</s>AMANPOUR: I want to play -- Lieutenant Governor, can I just play the soundbites and I'll get you to comment on it because it's specifically about COVID?</s>DONALD TRUMP, U.S. PRESIDENT: It will go away. And as I say, we're rounding the turn, we're rounding the corner. It's going away.</s>JOE BIDEN (D), PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATE: Anyone who's responsible for that many deaths should not remain as president of the United States of America.</s>AMANPOUR: So, Lieutenant Governor, you know, how do you think that sat with the voters in your state?</s>FETTERMAN: Yes. I think most voters are lumping it all in chaos. It's like, do you enjoy the daily churn and the chaos and the news cycle swaying on a single tweet in this kind of fatigue has set in? And if you want more of that, you have a vote to make. And if you reject that, off vote to make. But coronavirus, in many respects also, is not -- the way I would describe it is, is that the people that are voting for Donald Trump, they don't see that as the key defining issue. They see other things. So of course, the president's handling of the coronavirus has damaged him in some circles, but in Pennsylvania, he still remains popular. And I would not take anything for granted here in Pennsylvania with respects to it regardless of what the poll says because it's going to continue to tighten, I believe, over the next 10 days.</s>AMANPOUR: OK. So, that's really interesting. And I want -- and many people are making that point. And I want to just read you some figures. Everybody has been talking about the registration, the Republicans adding more than twice the number of new voters as Democrats, far outpacing the experience in 2016. This is in your state, that there are almost 2.5 million eligible white voters without college degrees who didn't vote last time. So, given this surge, you heard what the lieutenant governor said, Sarah Longwell, and you are Republicans against Trump. Given this surge of registration, what do you think the outlook is for Pennsylvania?</s>LONGWELL: Yes, look, I think you shouldn't take anything for granted in Pennsylvania. There are a lot of people, white working-class voters in Pennsylvania and that is the president's -- that's the demographic with whom he does the absolute best. And -- but I do wonder, though, about these registration numbers. I think there might be something going on there where it's actually an existing political realignment. And the thing is, one of the things I've been watching closely is women in this election. I do a lot of focus groups with women in Pennsylvania, and the last group that I did, they were all 2016 Trump voters, and I couldn't find a single one of them who was going to vote for Donald Trump again. They were somewhat undecided, but they weren't deciding between Joe Biden and third-party voters. And so, while these swing states are closer and nobody should take anything for granted, I do think it bodes poorly for the president that he's sort of fallen off cliff, certainly with college-educated women and with white working-class women. You know, if you look at Bucks County, OK, which is the suburbs outside of Pennsylvania, the polling shows that roughly 25 percent of the Republicans in that suburb are planning on voting for Joe Biden. So, even if they are sort of registering voters and they are registering as Republicans, they may have been people who were already voting for Trump and voted for him in 2016, but Trump is alienating all of these people that Republicans traditionally rely on in the suburbs, college-educated voters, and those are the people who are moving away from the president at a very fast pace. And you cannot win in a national election when you are at 33 percent with women. You just can't.</s>AMANPOUR: So, that's something that one should stop and think about. Let me ask you, Lieutenant Governor, because the last time we talked, fracking was on the table. And you pointed out, because there was this big debate, this was still during the primary, and you were saying that anybody who wants to ban fracking is not going to do well in Pennsylvania. You know, President Trump drilled down on it in the debate. Is fracking still an issue, the top issue, rather, for your state?</s>FETTERMAN: What I said about fracking is that Pennsylvania is a margin play, it needs to be treated as such. And a hardline stance that you're going to ban fracking on day one is not what I would call the smart political strategy. That being said, 2020 happened. We had a global pandemic. We're approaching a quarter of a million Americans dead. We had the George Floyd racial reconciliation. We had all kinds of other issues in 2020. So, fracking has receded out of the top five number of issues that it's going to -- I'm not aware of any significant bloc of Pennsylvania voters that are going to be facing that discussion or conversation on fracking on who they're going to vote for in 10 days here in Pennsylvania, truly. And that's what I get back to my point earlier, it's a referendum. This is, you know, more chaos and more of what we have or we are going to reject that and head in a different direction. And your guess -- the other point, the key to Pennsylvania is the margins and small counties. These small counties. And Donald Trump created unprecedented margins in these counties. He pulled down 75, 80 percent in some of these counties. And individually, that doesn't necessarily make the different. But when you win 60 of those counties, multiply that number by 60, that was the difference. And where Joe Biden is particularly well suited in Pennsylvania is that he appeals more to these kind of smaller county voters, and it doesn't take a lot. You're not going to turn the county blue, but if you blunt those margins, you suck all the oxygen out of the room and you eliminate Trump's path, the 270 by taking Pennsylvania out of the category.</s>AMANPOUR: OK. So, Pennsylvania has 20 electoral votes. You tweeted the other day on this subject. Tell me who wins Erie, Pennsylvania, and I'll tell you who wins Pennsylvania. That person is our next president. So, what is your call? Currently, the Poll of Polls says that Biden, 51, Trump, 44. So, Biden's up 7 in this one.</s>FETTERMAN: Yes. Well, I -- that's absolutely true. And I -- my first campaign manager is managing Pennsylvania for the vice president. And one of the things I said is, you've got to get the vice president to Erie. And thankfully, he did get him to Erie, and not a few days past before the president came to Erie and he famously announced, I don't want to be here, which I don't know why you would say that. But, you know, his Bulworth moment there aside, the -- in underscores the fact that Erie is critical and it such a critical bellwether. And I think the vice president will carry Erie and ultimately, carry Pennsylvania. That being said, I would never underestimate the strength and popularity and durability of President Trump's base here in Pennsylvania. And I run like I'm five points down, especially with a candidate that has this ability to pull margins that we had not previously observed from Republicans in the state before.</s>AMANPOUR: And that is very wise counsel. I want to ask you, Sarah Longwell, not just about Pennsylvania, but about the broader national picture, because, again, you are about the broader national picture. I don't know whether you saw, but some people are talking about the body language at the end of the debate last night, that President Trump didn't want to necessarily engage afterwards. He kind of walked off. He looked a little bit reticent and hesitant. I've heard -- I've watched and listened to a columnist in "The New York Times" talk about, you know, he's behaving like a loser. On the other hand -- like he's absorbing the idea of defeat. On the other hand, the president being told by his campaign, you just watched the next 11 days. It's going to be scorched earth. You've never seen anything like it. What do you anticipate from President Trump over the next 11 days?</s>LONGWELL: Well, I think that despite the fact that he had a somewhat more subdued performance last night, I mean, you know, we're all judging him by the bar that he set for himself in the first debate. And so, last night, since he wasn't, you know, shouting and acting crazy, everyone says, oh, well, you know, he was more substantiative. But the fact is, you know, Donald Trump can't change who he is. He just can't fundamentally be a different person. And if he was going to really make a play to win this thing, he would be talking about his plans for COVID relief for people. He would be talking about his plan for solving coronavirus. I mean, more of this bluster. Look, it was one thing in 2016 to run that playbook. It's really fun to own the libs when you can own your car and own your house. But like when there's a pandemic and an economic crisis, people want real answers. And he just -- that's not what he does. He's not substantiative in that way. He wants to go out and hold his rallies. He wants to yell about the press, he wants to talk about hunter Biden and re-run that 2016 playbook, because that's what's fun for him. But it's not fun for America anymore. People are exhausted. And they're hurting. I mean, the thing that I hear from these voters all the time is the tremendous amount of personal pain they are experiencing in their own lives. Maybe their parent died and they weren't able to see them because of the coronavirus or they're recovering from chemotherapy and they don't feel like they can go to the grocery store because people don't wear masks or their kids aren't in school or learning virtually and they're having to work from home or somebody in their family has been furloughed or laid off. I mean, people just want something better than what Donald Trump can offer. And, you know, I just saw a poll come out of "The New York Times" that had Trump is beating Joe Biden by six points in Montana. Now, Montana is the kind of ruby red state that Donald Trump won by over 20 points in 2016. If he's now only winning by six points, you are talking about a massive shift in people's support for him. And he only won -- going back to Pennsylvania, he only won Pennsylvania by 44,000 votes. So, the question is, is are there 100,000 votes that have either switched or that are people who didn't turn out last time who are willing to turn out this time because they are so frustrated? And I'm bullish on the idea that there are.</s>AMANPOUR: I wonder what your response to that, Lieutenant Governor. And also, just as part of it, the FBI has said, and we learned this yesterday, that Russia did hack into local and state computer networks. As far as you know, is the Pennsylvania voting infrastructure safe and secure?</s>FETTERMAN: It absolutely is. And like, it's -- you know what's really exhausting is, these freak-out stories that appear with daily regularly. Like, oh, my God, this. We found three ballots in the lunchroom and that suddenly becomes a national story or whatever. It's like, the fact is, is that over 1.5 million people have already voted in Pennsylvania. They're already banked. And there's going to be a lot more over this weekend. Voting in Pennsylvania is safe, secure and true and the result that we will deliver will reflect the true democratic will of our state. And I just tell people, just breathe, relax, trust the United States Postal Service. Vote by mail. If you have a ballot, use it immediately and get it in. And if you are going to go to the polls, just be prepared for longer lines and make sure you mask up and just make sure that you remember that it's going to be probably -- that there's some grand -- or whatever, it's just part of the chaos. And there is an agenda attached to that chaos -- all it's trying to do is get in the head of Democrats and to create some kind of grounds to challenge the legitimacy of an outcome that he may not like in Pennsylvania, but it will be absolutely true and we are absolutely on top of it.</s>AMANPOUR: I just want to pause here and say, for our viewers actually and for all of you, you're talking about the deliberate chaos. We try to get Trump supporters on our program, like officials, to have a rational debate about what that side believes and envisions. And all we get is chaos. We get total chaos. We get just incoherent conspiracy theories, and it's a real problem, because we cannot get to the heart of getting, you know, real interviews that make sense with some -- in that political -- right around President Trump. So, it's really, really difficult to get that perspective. But I want to ask you, because you said, take a deep breath -- yes, go ahead.</s>FETTERMAN: Yes, it's like -- that's the way they want it. They want these anecdotes. They want that -- my cousin's girlfriend, I saw on Facebook, that they found a suitcase full of -- I mean, all of these like anecdotes. Because when you try to pin them down, whether it's in court or on your program, as you pointed out, they're not going to come with -- and you know, that's like garlic and a cross to Dracula. They don't want to, you know, be near that sunlight. They just want to continue to foment this kind of online chaos, this kind of conspiracy theory, because all it does is create more and more sound and fury and that is part of their strategy. And I believe it's two points. It's, one, to question the legitimacy of the election and two, to confuse and diminish the trust that Democrats have in the voting system, voting by mail, for example, to create extra-long lines and disenfranchisement on the day of the election here.</s>AMANPOUR: Well, it's very good to hear that you have told everybody loud and clear that the system works. It's safe. It's secure. And just get out to vote. Sarah Longwell, I want to ask you. You know, is it -- you know, the lieutenant governor said breathe, take it easy, just, you know, concentrate on what's important. What about after the election. I want to play you this thing that went viral. Everybody's seen it, but the two gubernatorial candidates in Utah. Just a little snippet and I want to ask you about whether that's a real hope for the future or not.</s>CHRIS PETERSON (D-UT) GUBERNATORIAL CANDIDATE: I'm Chris Peterson.</s>SPENCER COX (R-UT) GUBERNATORIAL CANDIDATE: And I'm spencer cox.</s>PETERSON: We are currently in the final days of campaigning against each other to be your next governor.</s>COX: And well, I think you should vote for me.</s>PETERSON: Yes. But really, you should vote for me.</s>COX: There are some things we both agree on.</s>PETERSON: We can debate issues without degrading each other's character.</s>COX: We can disagree without hating each other.</s>PETERSON: And win or lose in Utah, we work together.</s>AMANPOUR: So, Sarah, what is your just quick view on that? Do you think it's possible? I mean, could these four years, everything you've been saying, the fact that it's a referendum on the disruption and the dislocation, could there be a move towards somewhat more civil political debate in the country or the opposite?</s>LONGWELL: Well, look, nobody is very bullish on the idea that things could get better or be more civil, but I am. And I'll tell you why. So, yes, I've been a Republican all my life, but I think that there is something about Joe Biden that is uniquely suited to this moment. He is old, but he's also old school. He's old school about being bipartisan. And his whole message of wanting to unite the country and bring people together, there are going to be lots of Republicans who are going to continue to be recalcitrant and not want to work on, whether it's his policy agenda or whatever. But the fact is, if Joe Biden wins, the first thing that's he's going to have to do is deal with this coronavirus. And Republicans know that we have to deal with it, too. And so, there is really opportunity there for bipartisan and there is going to be a segment of Republicans who, I think, maybe a Ben Sasse, certainly a Mitt Romney, who feel like, hey, we need to move past this really bleak moment in our history, and I think we'll be looking to with Joe Biden for the American to solve this coronavirus problem that's plaguing all of us. And so, I see a glimmer of hope here after so much darkness of the last four years.</s>AMANPOUR: Well, we like to end on an up note with some optimism. So, Sarah Longwell, thank you very much. And Lieutenant Governor John Fetterman, thank you so much for being with us.</s>FETTERMAN: My pleasure.</s>AMANPOUR: Now, foreign policy does not come up much in these debates. But it is a sure bet that every U.S. president will have to deal with crises overseas, like the current flare-up of violence between Armenia and Azerbaijan in Central Asia pitting their sponsors, Russia and Turkey, potentially, against each other. Now, it centers around this tiny enclave of Nagorno-Karabakh, which is officially a part of Azerbaijan, but it's also home to ethnic Armenians. The Soviet Union kept things quiet, but ever since the end of the Cold War, fighting has erupted periodically. And today, the foreign ministers of both countries met with the U.S. secretary of state, Mike Pompeo, in a bit to seal another cease fire. Well, joining me now, fresh from that meeting in an exclusive interview is the Armenian foreign minister, Zohrab Mnatsakanyan. Welcome to the program. Can I just ask you what message Mike Pompeo, the secretary of state, gave to you? Is there any hope that there will be a cease-fire?</s>ZOHRAB MNATSAKANYAN, ARMENIAN MINISTER OF FOREIGN AFFAIRS: Well, thank you very much for having me. The message from Secretary Pompeo is the message of the three co-chair countries, Russia, France and the United States, who have been the internationally recognized mediating foment to find a peaceful resolution to this conflict. And the message is, one, the war has to stop, the aggression has to stop. Cease-fire has to be established and then we move on. That was the message we share very much and we support very much.</s>AMANPOUR: OK. So, you say that. Your counterpart, who of course we did invite on this program wasn't able to join us, foreign minister of Azerbaijan, Jeyhun Bayramov, said the only pathway to peace is based on the U.N. Security Council resolutions and respect for international law. The illegal Armenian occupation must end and Azerbaijan's territorial integrity restored. Are you prepared to make that concession?</s>MNATSAKANYAN: We are not talking about concessions. We are talking about establishing cease-fire now and returning to the peace process. Now, when it comes to the future of Nagorno-Karabakh, this whole conflict is about people, is about our compatriots in Nagorno-Karabakh. The Armenians who have been resisting the subjugation to the domination to this -- to the domination of Azerbaijan. This has been the whole story. It is all about our people who are pounded with bones and rockets and missiles. Now, the existential physical security of our compatriots has been the core of this problem. Has been the core of the issue. And what we have been insisting upon is that we find the peaceful resolution to this conflict in which the security of our compatriots finds its expression and that the statutes of Nagorno-Karabakh, the right to self-determination of our compatriots is a very basic principle recognized by the international community and that has to be delivered now. Our people in Nagorno-Karabakh will live in freedom and dignity in safety and in security. That's the core issue of this conflict. It's about people. It's not the conflict. It's the real lives of people. As we were talking, when we were here in Washington, when we were trying to further reinforce the message of cease-fire, the message of going back to the peaceful resolution, I have been receiving now messages when coming out of the meetings, messages from Armenia, from Nagorno-Karabakh that the civilian settlements, the towns of Stepanakert, Hadrut, Martuni have again been the target of heavy shelling, of missile shelling by the Azerbaijani forces. The civilians are dying. The civilian -- the humanitarian situation is very dire. And this is not going to happen.</s>AMANPOUR: OK, Foreign Minister. I get it. I get it, because we've been watching it. That's why we're having you on. And it's always the people, isn't it? It's not the officials who sit in their palaces and walk the halls of power. It always the people.</s>MNATSAKANYAN: Exactly.</s>AMANPOUR: So, I want to ask you this. You know, you've just called Nagorno-Karabakh ethnically belonging to your people there. But the United Nations calls Armenians an occupation force. Look, in 1993, there were security council resolutions demanding the immediate withdrawal of those occupying forces, as they said. In 2008, the U.N. General Assembly adopted a resolution on the issue in which it called for the exactly the same thing. And the 2008 General Assembly reaffirmed Azerbaijan's territorial integrity. So, this obviously has to happen through negotiation. You can see it pointed out there in black and white and yet, you can also see that your people have a right to safety and to their own rights. Is there any way you -- because you're very firm about what you're saying, is there any way that you and the Azerbaijanis can get together and resolve this? Because all the cease-fires that have been put in so far have just collapsed after a day or so.</s>MNATSAKANYAN: Right. Now, excellent point you're making. As we are going back to '93, then that is an important point to make about that. Between '92 and '93, we had a very dangerous situation, when there was a narrow strip left to the Armenians in Nagorno-Karabakh with the rest of the territory occupied by the Azerbaijani forces. The population from those territories ethnically cleansed and driven out of their territories. The subsequent developments have been such that the Armenians were capable in Nagorno-Karabakh to defend themselves, very resolute to defend their lives and they have created a security belt, which today, has been basically, you know, a demonstration that unless there was a security power (ph), the Nagorno-Karabakh population might have been again facing this ethnic cleansing as it has always been, you know, looming over them. We are negotiating in good faith to find a way in which the right to self- determination of our compatriots in Nagorno-Karabakh will find its manifestation, its resolution. That's our commitment and we will continue to work towards achieving this objective.</s>AMANPOUR: OK. So, that's your commitment. You're telling us now in full international platform and full platform across the United States, but the problem is that your prime minister was there in, I believe, it was August, actually last year in August, and he was behaving in a very nationalistic way. He used -- perhaps it's his language, but he used the Armenian name for Nagorno-Karabakh and he repeatedly led crowds chanting, unification with Armenia. Is that your policy?</s>MNATSAKANYAN: Well, look, this is a twist we have been addressing and dealing with over the past year. A twist and a deceptive way of turning the words on their heads. The prime minister has been talking about the role of Armenia in securing, guaranteeing the security of our compatriots in Nagorno-Karabakh. There is no other force in this world who has been doing that. And the prime minister has been talking about the way in which Armenia is developing, Armenia is reforming, and he is reaffirming that Armenia will not be indifferent to the fate of its compatriots in Nagorno-Karabakh.</s>AMANPOUR: OK.</s>MNATSAKANYAN: The prime minister has been talking about -- he has been talking about the compromised peaceful resolution consistently over these two years and in that speech, as well. So, these words are taken out of context and there is disregard to the --</s>AMANPOUR: OK. So, just confirm for me --</s>MNATSAKANYAN: -- fundamental point that the solution is compromise-based and it is peaceful. And that's the message from Armenia that has been consistent over two years.</s>AMANPOUR: That is what people want to hear, peaceful compromise, diplomacy and not fighting as we see right now. So, are you telling me that the official position of Armenia is not to have Nagorno-Karabakh unify with Armenia?</s>MNATSAKANYAN: We are saying that the right to self-determination of the people of Nagorno-Karabakh, in which their free expression without limitations will be achieved. Now, today's situation shows that there is no way for subjugation. There is no way for domination. There is no way that we will have the risk of ethnic cleansing of our compatriots again looming over them. That the people will decide their fate and they will decide for their independence, and that has to be respected. That is the way to solve it. So far, as the compromises confirm, we have to be very clear, no concession, no maximalist approach that we have been hearing from Azerbaijan. They have to stop that.</s>AMANPOUR: Foreign Minister...</s>MNATSAKANYAN: So far as the compromise is confirmed, we have to be very clear, no concession, no maximalist approach that we very been hearing from as Azerbaijan. They have to stop that.</s>AMANPOUR: Foreign Minister, thank you very much for joining us.</s>MNATSAKANYAN: Thank you.</s>AMANPOUR: Again, I had hoped to have the Azerbaijani foreign minister as well. He wasn't able to join us today. We hope that this will calm down in your region. But joining me now to tell us more about why this matters is, in fact, Ivo Daalder. He is the former U.S. ambassador to NATO, and has been very involved in all these issues. So, first and foremost, Ivo Daalder, welcome to the program. But the Armenian foreign minister tells us that it's about self- determination for Armenians in Nagorno-Karabakh, that he says that the Azeris are dominating the Armenians there, ethnically cleansing them. What -- is there a role and a route to compromise over this?</s>IVO DAALDER, FORMER U.S. AMBASSADOR TO NATO: Well, there hasn't been a route to compromise, of course, for almost 30 years, since the conflict really started up again back in the early 1990s, when Armenia was able to take control of Nagorno-Karabakh and has kept control of that region ever since. Occasionally, we have had some diplomatic engagements, as we did in the late '90s, that was trying to get to a diplomatic settlement. But then war or conflict once again rises to the fore, as it did in 2016, as it is doing now again. Ultimately, unless and until the leadership in both Armenia and Azerbaijan is willing to compromise on this very difficult set of issues of both the self-determination that is involved, but also the territorial integrity and the non-use or threat of force, which are key principles, not only of the U.N. charter, but of the Helsinki Final Act, that guide and should guide behavior in Europe, until that is done, we're not going to get a diplomatic solution, nor, frankly, are we going to get a military solution. It's just a bloody mess when the fighting goes on, but nothing much changes in the status quo.</s>AMANPOUR: So, let me ask you this, then, because, clearly, people are worried. I mean, there's a reason why the United States has invited these two gentlemen to Washington, that the secretary of state has put his -- power of his office behind trying to get a cease-fire. Why is it so important? I mean, you were a NATO ambassador for years. Obviously, Turkey, which backs Azerbaijan, is a NATO member. And let me just see -- read you what President Erdogan has said just a couple of weeks ago. "We say again to our Azerbaijani brothers that we stand by them in their holy struggle until victory." In the meantime, Vladimir Putin, who backs Armenia, is much less robust in his defense. He says: "hit is deeply regrettable that the hostilities continue, but they are not taking place on Armenian territory." So, Putin is standing back, it seems. Erdogan is being very bullish on this. What could be the fallout?</s>DAALDER: Well, that is the big change. It's Turkey's direct support of the Azeri claims, but also the rapid supply of armaments and even the possible participation of Turkish forces, that has really changed the situation. Turkey is throwing its weight around. It is benefiting from the absence of the United States and others in the region. It is engaged in conflict with Russia in Syria and in Libya and now potentially over this area. That's why it matters. That's why we should be concerned, because there is the possibility -- it's not a likelihood -- but there's a possibility of an escalation of this conflict that would lead to a direct confrontation between Russia and Turkey. And, as you mentioned, Turkey is a NATO member. And under those circumstances, the question of whether NATO would get involved or not, whether it would risk a conflict with Russia over this particular issue or not, comes on the agenda. Much better to find a cease-fire quickly in order to de-escalate the situation, so you don't have to confront that very, very dangerous possibility.</s>AMANPOUR: I mean, it does look like they are still far apart. But we will wait to see whether the U.S. can bring them closer together. Just quickly, before I leave you, on a different issue, the United States has announced that, I believe, it's removed Sudan from its list of state sponsors of terrorism, and it's talking about Sudan very soon or now are normalizing relations with Israel. This would be another African, but Arab state doing so. What is the impact of that?</s>DAALDER: Well, there is the effort by President Trump and his administration to bring Israel closer to its relations with Arab countries. We saw a peace agreement, or at least an agreement towards the normalization, first with the UAE, then with Bahrain, now Sudan. And there is this idea that, if we can create the momentum of bringing Israel into better relations, and perhaps even normalized relations, with more and more Arab countries, that will be to the benefit of Israel. And, as the United States, as the diplomatic broker of these agreements, it will be seen as a victory for President Trump in his approach to this part of the world. That said, these are just commitments to have agreements. Whether they will actually be fully realized and whether the domestic politics in Sudan will support it is something we will have to wait and see.</s>AMANPOUR: And very quickly, it's great to rack up these normalizations. Obviously, peace is better than war, although none them have been at war with Israel. But is it still, would you say, a massively important goal to strive for the elusive prize of peace between Israel and the Palestinians?</s>DAALDER: Well, ultimately, of course, real stability and real peace in that part of the world does require a settlement between Israel and the Palestinians, a settlement that seems more distant each and every day, that has been put on the back burner by the Trump administration, nevertheless remains fundamental to ultimate peace and stability in this part of the world.</s>AMANPOUR: Ivo Daalder, former U.S. ambassador to NATO, thank you very much, indeed, for joining us. Now, we have spoken about the competing visions in the race for the White House. Donald Trump's 2016 victory shocked America and, in fact, the whole world, after polls consistently showed him trailing Hillary Clinton. Polls again, as we have been discussing, have the Democratic candidate with a comfortable lead, but will they get it right this time? Sean Trende is a senior analyst for RealClearPolitics who's been tracking the trends shaping 2020 and how polling has changed over the last four years. Here, he's talking to our Hari Sreenivasan about his key takeaways as the clock ticks down.</s>HARI SREENIVASAN, CNN INTERNATIONAL CORRESPONDENT: Christiane, thanks. Sean Trende, thanks for joining us. I'm not going to ask you about who's leading right now, because I know polls are just a snapshot, and people should go vote regardless of whether they're candidate is up or down. But I want to ask, do you think that last night's debate is going to have any impact on these?</s>SEAN TRENDE, SENIOR ELECTIONS ANALYST, REALCLEARPOLITICS: I think, if it does have an impact, it'll be pretty moderate. I think there are some conservative voters in the U.S. who were kind of looking for permission to vote for Donald Trump, if you will. They're inclined to vote for Republicans, but because of President Trump's behavior, having a normalish debate from him probably helps him. But, overall, I don't think we will see any major movement as a result.</s>SREENIVASAN: Is there a trend line that you have seen, not just about the about who's leading and who's not, but, say, for example, the rest of the questions in the poll, which I think are much more fascinating to me, about issues that seem persistent?</s>TRENDE: Yes, we look at the traditional question. People vote their pocketbooks. There's the line going back, Bill Clinton's 1992 campaign, "It's the economy, stupid," And look to see how people perform there traditionally. And then, actually, surprisingly, Donald Trump holds up fairly well. He typically leads Joe Biden on who's best for the economy. But this cycle is a little different. We want to see who leads on the handling of coronavirus. And, in that case, it's usually Joe Biden who's leading the president. There are other issues, like health care and things like that, that typically voters say don't matter as much. Typically, Joe Biden leads on these other issues as well.</s>SREENIVASAN: So, where were we in 2016 compared to now? I know it's a different landscape, because there was not a pandemic facing either Donald Trump or Hillary Clinton at that time.</s>TRENDE: Yes, I mean, I want to be cautious with the 2016 comparisons, especially given what I'm about to tell people. But, in 2016, Donald Trump was not an incumbent. And so the machinations of the functioning of the election was a little bit different. But the polls actually looked a lot in 2016 like they look right now, especially at the state polls. Clinton had blown up a big lead after the "Access Hollywood" tape dropped, and then it was just kind of like trending, gradually tightening, and that's what we're seeing right now. And if you look at the states, they're almost exactly where they were in 2016.</s>SREENIVASAN: So, that leads to a natural question. What did the polls get wrong last time ,and how are they different today?</s>TRENDE: We hope we know the answer to that. Part of it is easy. People convinced themselves that the Upper Midwest wasn't competitive. And they stopped polling. We didn't get a lot of polls from states like Wisconsin and Michigan and Minnesota in the closing days. We think the issue was that they weren't getting enough whites without college degrees in the sample. And so -- and that's a problem, because that was Donald Trump's strongest demographic group. And they are the most -- they're a massive demographic group in kind of -- in these key states of Michigan, Wisconsin, so forth. So, pollsters have been working really hard to try to get more of these voters in their sample. We're a little nervous, because, in 2018, the poll said we were supposed to have Democratic governors in Ohio and Iowa, and that didn't pan out. We were supposed to have Democratic senators in Missouri and Indiana, and that didn't pan out. So, there's some nervousness here. But I think at least some of the error in 2016 was fixed.</s>SREENIVASAN: So, how do pollsters correct for that? And how do we know? I mean, is -- do just try to make sure that you're including that many more people of whatever category in your phone survey? Because there's always the concern, well, the people who might support the president might not really like talking to pollsters.</s>TRENDE: And that's something that you can't do anything about that, that last scenario. And that's what makes us nervous. Donald Trump voters are characterized by low levels of social trust. And you can easily see how that could manifest, even with every demographic characteristic controlled for, not talking to pollsters. With that said, to answer the question more directly, you know what share the population white voters and whites without college degrees and African- American voters make. And so when you get your overall sample, you do what's called weighting the respondents. If you only have 8 percent African-Americans in your sample, and you know the population as a whole is 16 percent, you essentially count those African-American respondents twice. You wake them up to their population average.</s>SREENIVASAN: There's also the fact that there's the popular vote, which the polls might predict accurately, and then there's the Electoral College, which is a whole different beast.</s>TRENDE: Absolutely. And we know what happened in 2016. We know what happened in 2000. And if you look at the polls, it suggests that the split between the state that gives Joe Biden or Donald Trump electoral vote 270, and the popular vote is going to be about three or four points this time. So, when you see Joe Biden with a seven- or eight-point lead, I just always mentally subtract four points from it. And so it's really a three- or four- point lead right now. And that puts things in perspective.</s>SREENIVASAN: Is there still an undecided voter left in America? Because it seems like, if you like the president, you love him by now, if you didn't like the president in 2016, you really don't like him now.</s>TRENDE: Well, if you haven't made your mind up about Donald Trump by now, I don't know what's going to help you choose. I mean, the last four years have, if absolutely nothing else, been eventful I -- we look at the polls. And at this point in 2016, Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton accounted for about 85 percent of voters, and there were a large number of undecided. Some of those went to third parties. If you look at it today, it's more like 93 percent of voters are voting for Donald Trump or Joe Biden. So, we really are talking about a very small pool of undecided voters at this point.</s>SREENIVASAN: What do you think is the driving factor in the resiliency of the president? Because what's impressive, regardless of where you are politically, is how consistent his support has been. I mean, it's barely wavered lower, and then maybe back to where it was, over the four years.</s>TRENDE: Yes, during his first year of office, he saw it dip down into the high 30s. But it came back in 2018. He's been pretty much the most stable job approval president ever. It's tracked between 42 and 46 percent ever since. I think there are just -- there's people who just like Donald Trump. And I don't know how else to explain it. I think part of it is, we're in a very polarized time. So, if you're Republican, you start out liking Republicans, and if you're Democrat, you don't. Donald Trump famously had no what we call a honeymoon period. His job approval started at like 47 percent, kind of just outside his normal range, whereas most presidents will get up above 50 percent and even into the 60s for their first couple months in office. So it's just been an unusual presidency, but perhaps it's a sign of the times.</s>SREENIVASAN: Is there -- is it accurate when people say, oh, that poll comes out, well, that's a right-leaning poll, oh, this is a left-leaning poll? They're not really -- most people don't -- are not pollsters. They don't have to read the fine print on exactly who was surveyed. We don't know which 1,200 people were phoned, right? But is there implicit bias inside the polling systems that exist today?</s>TRENDE: There are some pollsters who, for whatever reason, when they take polls -- some of them, we know exactly why they take a poll and it has a Republican lean or Democratic lean, because they're companies that are affiliated with the Republican or Democratic Party, Trafalgar on the right and PPP on the left. For the most part, though, I think pollsters try to get it as right as they can, because they're putting their reputation on the line. And so whether it's the CNN poll, or the FOX poll, or the MSNBC poll, they're trying to inform their viewers. And I don't think you can dismiss any of those polls based on the label, unless it comes from an outfit that is particularly devoted to one party or the other.</s>SREENIVASAN: And if we also included cell phone numbers in this now? Because different markets, some people are cutting the cord, they don't have copper service lines that they're paying for anymore.</s>TRENDE: It is a huge problem, there's no doubt about it, that we have cell phone -- a lot of cell phone-only households now, because, under federal law, if you have you know the robo-dialing polls, where it's not a person, it's just a computer that asks you the questions and you punch it on, you can't do that with cell phones. It's something that goes back to the days when people paid by the minute, and so they passed a law to protect people from having to listen to robo- calls and waste their minutes. And now there's just no constituency for letting the robo-callers call your cell phone. Anyway, it's a problem. And there's no easy way around it. Live interview polls are very expensive, so, generally, only the big networks conduct them. You know, people do the best they can.</s>SREENIVASAN: You recently wrote a couple of articles, Donald Trump's path to victory and what a Biden win would look like. Just kind of summarize your main takeaways there.</s>TRENDE: Yes. So, a Biden win is the easy piece to write, because it's basically the polls are correct. And if you go back to like 1998, there's really not much of a bias to the polls. Now, in any given year, there can be a substantial bias one way or the other. But, overall, the polls are accurate. So, there's probably going to be some sort of house effect. In 2012, people don't remember it, but there was actually a bias in the polls. It was towards the Republicans. Barack Obama outperformed the polls by about two or three points. No one cared, because the polls that said Barack Obama would win. So, in that way, the 2016 error was typical. So you should expect the polls will be unbiased, but know that they can be off two or three points in either direction. So, Biden could outperform his already kind of substantial polling lead. For Donald Trump, it's a little bit trickier. When I wrote -- when I wrote the piece, his job approval was about 43 percent. And, typically, incumbent presidents get their job approval plus a point or two. And so I said, if he can get his job approval back up to 46 percent by Election Day, he'd actually have a pretty good shot. You would expect him to lose the popular vote by three or four points, which, for him, probably translates to an Electoral College victory. But we have seen his job approval stagnate about 44.5 percent, 45 percent. And I don't think that's enough for him to get it done, unless something happens over the next week or two -- I mean, we have got now, I think, 10 days to improve his job approval -- I think he's going to have a tough time winning.</s>SREENIVASAN: What -- you mentioned 2018. And what does that tell you about 2020, if the predictions were that there should have been more of a Democratic blue wave coming through?</s>TRENDE: It's something that makes us a little bit nervous. I mentioned the polls in the Upper Midwest, but also Florida, which is -- if you go back to 1992, and add up all the votes for Republican presidents and all the votes for Democratic presidents in the state of Florida, the gap is 10,000 votes. Like, it is that close. And so we kind of look to it as the kind of perennial swing state. But, in 2018, I don't think Ron DeSantis led in a single poll over Andrew Gillum, and yet he is now the governor. Rick Scott did lead in a couple polls over Bill Nelson, but it wasn't many, and he is now the senator. So there was a Democratic bias in the polls in 2018, no doubt about it. Will it repeat in 2020? We don't know. But we have to be aware of the possibility.</s>SREENIVASAN: I'm going to ask also, given the huge surge in not just interest, but in actual early voting and mail-in balloting, how do you capture that cross-section of the audience?</s>TRENDE: So, there's a couple ways you can do it. One way is that some states let you know who voted. And so some of these pollsters aren't randomly dialing. They are selecting people from a list, a published list of voters and sampling from that list. And so, in some of these states, you can match that with people who have voted early. And that's actually great, because you know these people have voted. You ask them who they voted for. You don't have to guess at what that electorate looks like. Other states, the data aren't quite as good. And that's where it becomes a little bit tricky. One of the interesting things is that there will typically be more people who say they have already voted than actually already voted. People aren't truthful. And so that's just one of those vagaries of polling you try to deal with.</s>SREENIVASAN: Do Biden supporters have reason to be concerned, considering -- or do Trump supporters have reason to say, you know what, this happened last time, he's sort of the comeback kid?</s>TRENDE: Yes, I mean, you can't dismiss what happened last time. And, like I said, you can't dismiss what happened in 2012, where the polls were actually off by two or three points, just in the different -- in the different direction. So you have to acknowledge the possibility that these things can happen. But, like I said, the error can be in either direction. We could have polls showing Joe Biden up by seven points and then, on Election Day, he wins by 10 or 11. You cannot predict which direction poll errors go.</s>SREENIVASAN: Let's talk a little bit about the Senate race, because, in a way, people have made up their minds about the president, and that's not going to have nearly as much of a margin of change as what could happen in the Senate in technically 50 different places, right? So, how do we -- heading in now to the election, what are the Senate races that you're most intrigued by?</s>TRENDE: There are a lot of interesting Senate races, but we can -- we can kind of clump -- put a clump in of seats we think are going to change. And they would give Democrats two seats, one short of a majority. Then there's a cluster of races that, if things get really bad for Republicans, they could lose, but they probably lost the majority before those seats flip. The majority-making seats are most likely Iowa and North Carolina, two very close Senate races. Right now, in our average, we have the Democrats ahead in each of them by two points. But they also have been closing in our averages. So...</s>SREENIVASAN: Is that within the margin of error?</s>TRENDE: Well within the margin of error, yes. So, control the Senate really could -- I mean, unless the polls have a systemic bias, and Joe Biden wins by 10 points, then I say, yes, Democrats could get 54, 55 seats. But if we're in this range of Joe Biden winning by six to eight points, those two seats are going to be very, very tight. So, in North Carolina, Thom Tillis and Cal Cunningham are neck and neck in a race. Thom Tillis is trying to get reelected for the first time. It's the same story in Iowa. Joni Ernst was elected in 2014 to replace Tom Harkin. She is in a very, very close race for that seat.</s>SREENIVASAN: And in North Carolina, this is after a sexting scandal with somebody who wasn't Mr. Cunningham's wife.</s>TRENDE: Yes, that's right. This was a race where it kind of looked like maybe like Cal Cunningham was getting some distance from Tillis, but ever since that scandal broke, there's been a hard break towards Tillis in the polls. He's still not leading in our averages, but it is much more competitive than it looked a few days -- a few weeks ago.</s>SREENIVASAN: What are you watching for in the last week?</s>TRENDE: I watch President Trump's job approval more than anything else, because if we do see a late break among a small number of undecided voters -- I think that's where it turns up first. People decide, OK, I like the job he's doing. Then they make the decision that they're going to vote for him or against him. I'm paying very close attention to those two Senate races in Iowa and North Carolina, because I do think they're the majority-makers, and just trying to keep my sanity, along with the rest of America. Sean Trende, RealClearPolitics, thanks so much.</s>TRENDE: Thank you.</s>AMANPOUR: And the rest of the world. And, finally, we kick off the weekend with something to celebrate. The one, the only Pele is 80 years old. No matter how old you are, or where you grew up, or who you grew up watching, few players have touched the game of soccer like this Brazilian superstar. From the moment he first burst onto the scene as a teenager to now, he ranks among one of the greatest sports people of all time, and he remains the only man in history to win three World Cups. So, good wishes are pouring in across his home country. And we have an exhibit launched in his honor at Sao Paulo's football stadium, football museum, to a mural that was designed by the street artist Kobra in Santos. He will forever be an international treasure as well. And that's it for now. Thank you for watching, and goodbye from London. END
World Reduced to "Friends," "Thugs" and "Filthy" Countries in Trump- Biden Debate
JOE BIDEN (D), PRESIDENTIAL NOMINEE: He embraces guys like these thugs in North Korea and the Chinese president and Putin. He's legitimized North Korea.</s>DONALD TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: I have a very good relationship with him. I was right.</s>BIDEN: I'm going to shut down the virus not the country.</s>TRUMP: This horrible disease that came from China.</s>BIDEN: He is xenophobic but not because he shut down access from China.</s>TRUMP: I'm the least racist person in this room.</s>BIDEN: His buddy, Rudy Giuliani, he's being used as a Russian pawn.</s>TRUMP: Joe got $3.5 million from Russia and it came through Putin. I am the least racist person in this room.</s>BIDEN: He pokes his finger in the eye of all of our friends, all of our allies.</s>UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: Joe Biden won this debate.</s>UNIDENTIFIED MALE: Eleven days until Election Day.</s>ANNOUNCER: Live from CNN Abu Dhabi, this is CONNECT THE WORLD with the Becky Anderson.</s>BECKY ANDERSON, CNN ANCHOR: And connecting this hour, a world that looks, well, rather nasty, at least, that is, if you are running to make it here to the White House, your home for the next four years. But no one set themselves on fire in the last presidential debate. There was much of the same as last time, just easier to understand to be honest. A lot more muted in tone and tenor. The world didn't feature all too heavily, but where it did it wasn't so much about successes but rather it was basically using the world as a giant prop for Donald Trump and Joe Biden to go after one another.</s>BIDEN: He pokes his finger in the eye of all of our friends, all of our allies. He's talked about his good buddy who is a thug. A thug.</s>ANDERSON: Well, he was, of course, referring to Kim Jong-un there. Mr. Trump defended his meetings with the North Korean leader saying he avoided war and the two had a good relationship, prompting this retort.</s>BIDEN: We had a good relationship with Hitler before he, in fact, invaded Europe.</s>ANDERSON: And when climate change came up which Mr. Trump hasn't exactly had a pristine record on, he had this to say about the rest of the world.</s>TRUMP: Look at China, how filthy it is. Look at Russia, look at India, it's filthy. The air is filthy.</s>ANDERSON: Speaking of China, both men used it as a punching bag. Joe Biden landing his blows saying he would force Beijing to abide by international law. He didn't, though, say how he would do that. The president defending his position on getting tough on China regarding trade and the coronavirus. So how did all the bluster in the debate play out around the world? Have a listen.</s>SELINA WANG, CNN CORRESPONDENT: I'm Selina Wang in Hong Kong. Trump and Biden sparked several times during the debate about their approaches and ties to China. Joe Biden said he would force China to play by the international rules if he were elected and said Trump embraces, quote, thugs, including the Chinese leader Xi Jinping. Trump repeated his tactic of claiming China for the coronavirus. He also attacked Biden over unsubstantiated claims about his son's business dealings in China. Biden then criticized Trump for having a secret bank account in China and for his business operations there. Trump also called the air in China, Russia and India filthy, while defending his administration's decision to withdraw from the Paris climate accord. In response, China's Ministry of Foreign Affairs pointed out that, quote, the sky is blue today, adding that China is not interested in the U.S. elections.</s>FREDERIK PLEITGEN, CNN SENIOR INTERNATIONAL CORRESPONDENT: I'm Fred Pleitgen in Moscow. As the Kremlin has shown themselves to be disappointed by last night's presidential debate. A spokesman for the Kremlin saying that he believed the debate was, quote, a competition of who dislikes Russia the most, the Kremlin especially took offense to the fact that President Trump called the air in China, India and Russia filthy. Dmitry Peskov saying, of course, there are dirty cities in Russia but Russia is working to try to protect the environment and also said that all of this can only be done on an international level, seeming to take a swipe at President Trump for leaving the Paris climate accords while Russia remains inside.</s>PAULA HANCOCKS, CNN CORRESPONDENT: I'm Paula Hancocks in Seoul. President Trump and former vice president Biden have very different views of the North Korean leader Kim Jong-un of the last presidential debate. Mr. Trump spoke of his good relationship with the North Korean leader whereas Mr. Biden called Kim Jong-un a thug. Now, we did hear once again from the president that if it weren't for him then the U.S. and North Korea would be at war. He also pointed out that having a good relationship is a good thing. Now, the vice president's countered that with, quote, we had a good relationship with Hitler before he invaded the rest of Europe.</s>ANDERSON: Paula, Fred and Selena for you. CNN's grantee of international diplomacy, Nic Robertson, is now standing by. Look, Nic, let's be quite clear, what we got here was certainly more political theater than a genuine opportunity to help us understand how candidates see America's role in the world going forward. What, if anything, did we learn?</s>NIC ROBERTSON, CNN INTERNATIONAL DIPLOMATIC EDITOR: Yeah, I don't think if you are a world leader watching it, you really learned anything new about either of them. And let's face it, you know, Donald Trump has got a four- year track record, he is being judged on that. Vice President Biden was in the Oval Office or next to the Oval Office in and out of it with President Obama over about eight years. So I think everyone has got a measure of both of them on their foreign policy and if you can call it that, you know, in both cases. I think one thing did jump out to me a little bit, but, again, not surprising that it came from President Trump when he said India's air was dirty. I mean, think back a few months ago before the -- well, just as the coronavirus pandemic was hitting the world, President Trump's last major overseas visit was to India. You know, an ally and a partner that is trying to build business relationships with and is seen as a strategic bulwark against China in this increasingly fractured U.S./China world. It was interesting to hear him call -- call out India as their air being dirty. Do you do that to a friend? That really plays to Biden's point that is Trump sticks his finger in the eye of his friends. So, no, I think the take away here is for international world leaders, it's how did this play in the U.S.? How is it going to affect the vote? Who is most likely to win? Because that's the big issue now. Who are we going to have to deal with as president going forward? That's what the real calculations were based on.</s>ANDERSON: Yeah, of course. And just to your point about India, I think back to the great state of Texas hosting the "Howdy, Modi!" gathering and that was -- much was made of that, great fanfare by the Trump administration as he once again feted his friend from India. As that example of how he has been tough on Russia, Donald Trump says he has persuaded NATO member nations to increase their contributions to fund the alliance, to guard against Russia. His position on NATO has been controversial at best. Nic, is what he said last night factually correct?</s>ROBERTSON: In terms of numbers, yes. Let's listen to him lay out what he thinks he got. Here it is.</s>TRUMP: There has been nobody tougher to Russia between the sanctions, nobody tougher than me on Russia, between the sanctions, between all of what I've done with NATO. You know, I got the NATO countries to put an extra $130 billion going to $420 billion a year. That's to guard against Russia.</s>ROBERTSON: So numbers, yes, but, no, he hasn't got them to do that. They've been pains to try to meet some of his demands that they should speed up getting their contributions to 2 percent of GDP. But, look, that was a deal struck at the Wales NATO Summit back in 2014 and guess who was closest to the White House then, yes, you're right, it's Vice President Biden. Guess what happens next, the deadline of everyone, all 29 nations not just nine as it stands now including the U.S., but making that 2 percent of GDP commitment agreed back in Wales this 2014, it would be 2024. So whoever gets into the White House this time wins this vote, they will see NATO making good on that commitment. So Trump right on the numbers, but not right on how it's all come about.</s>ANDERSON: You pointed out that we had some noteworthy you might say choice lines, comments, from Donald Trump when it comes to air quality in countries around the world and filthy -- just filthy is a term that he used. What do we hear from Joe Biden when it came to climate change?</s>ROBERTSON: Yeah, Biden's tone and he has spoken about this before was clear, that, you know, this is an issue and we have to deal with it. I'm going to invest in renewable energies domestically and he talked about transitioning oil industries away or sort of oil producers away over time from oil production. That was perhaps something that's going to impact him back home, particularly one thinks of Texas and Philadelphia as well. But, you know, on climate change Biden was quite sure this is something we have to do something about, this is what he said.</s>BIDEN: Climate change, climate warming, global warming is an existential threat to humanity. We have a moral obligation to deal with it. We're told by all the leading scientists in the world we don't have much time. We're going to pass the point of no return within the next eight to ten years. Four more years of this man eliminating all the regulations that were put in by us to clean up the climate, to clean up, to limit the -- limit emissions, will put us in a position where we are going to be in real trouble.</s>ROBERTSON: Yeah, and he went on to say that he would reengage with the international community on climate change. He will rejoin that Paris Accord from a few years ago. But I think, you know, the take away here is it's part of the narrative that Biden has been developing. You work with your allies and friends --</s>ANDERSON: Sure.</s>ROBERTSON: -- and you can use that work and working with them as leverage in other areas. He talked about dealing with North Korea as needing to involve Xi Jinping of China. He talks about, you know, dealing with Russia and other issues as needing European allies back on board. It is in essence Biden taking his finger out of the eye of his friends and putting it in the -- and putting his hand in their hands to work together. I think that is a narrative there, that's how he would expect to be able to win whack some of those countries that might have been distanced by President Trump.</s>ANDERSON: Yeah, it's fascinating. All the perspective from outside of the States and some indication of how world leaders may have perceived what happened last night. We are, what, just over ten days out at this point. So that's how both candidates see the rest of the world. Thank you, Nic. But what about their vision for America itself? Well, they ranged from dreams of a better future to nightmare visions on the pandemic, on health care, climate change and indeed the economy. My team wrapped all of that together for you. Here you go.</s>BIDEN: We're about to go into a dark winter, a dark winter, and he has no clear plan. We ought to be able to safely open, would they need resources to open. I'm going to shut down the virus, not the country. It's his ineptitude that caused the virus -- caused the country to have to shut down in large part.</s>TRUMP: We can't keep this country closed. It's a massive country, with a massive economy. People are losing their jobs. They're committing suicide, there's depression, alcohol, drugs.</s>BIDEN: What I'm going to do is pass Obamacare with a public option, to become Biden care. Not one single personal private insurers would lose their insurance under my plan, nor did they under Obamacare.</s>TRUMP: I'd like to terminate Obamacare, come up with a brand new, beautiful healthcare. The Democrats will do it because there'll be tremendous pressure in them and he might even have the House by that time.</s>BIDEN: Climate change, climate warming, global warming is an existential threat to humanity. We have a moral obligation to deal with it. I would transition from the oil industry, yes.</s>TRUMP: Transition.</s>BIDEN: That is a big statement because I would stop --</s>KRISTEN WELKER, DEBATE MODERATOR: Why would you do that?</s>BIDEN: Because the oil industry pollutes significantly.</s>TRUMP: I see.</s>BIDEN: And here's the deal --</s>TRUMP: But that's a big statement.</s>BIDEN: Well, if you'd let me finish the statement -- because it has to be replaced by renewable energy over time.</s>TRUMP: The Paris Accord, I took us out, because we were going to have to spend trillions of dollars and we were treated we unfairly. When they put us in there they did us a great disservice. They were going to take away our businesses. I will not sacrifice tens of millions of jobs, success is going to bring us together. We are on the road to success, but I'm cutting taxes and he wants to raise everybody's taxes and he wants to put new regulations on everything. He will kill it.</s>ANDERSON: Whose arguments did Americans buy into most? Well, according to a CNN instant poll of debate watchers overall just over half, 53 percent said Biden had the upper hand, 39 percent said President Trump had the better night. The margin of error a tad under 6 percentage points. Let's be clears, polls are all well and good but we are here to connect you to how it is. So, we sent our colleagues out to send time with both sides, CNN's Jason Carroll hung out with Biden supporters in Philly and Philadelphia, but first let's check in with CNN's Elle Reeve who watched the debate with supporters of President Trump in a small town in Illinois.</s>ELLE REEVE, CNN CORRESPONDENT: We're in a baseball stadium called the Corn Crib in a town called Normal, Illinois, where hundreds of Trump supporters have gathered to watch the debate that had been hosted by the local Republican Party.</s>CONNIE BEARD, CHAIRMAN, MCLEAN COUNTY REPUBLICAN PARTY: This event has sort of snowballed, we have our McLean County Republican tent, of course, and our little Trump store. We have a raffle for a semi-automatic shotgun that is apparently very popular.</s>KENNY MOREAU, TRUMP SUPPORTER: I just like the no bullshit attitude of, hey, I want to make America great. I don't understand what the problem is trying to bring everyone up in America to do good things.</s>REEVE: But is it no bullshit to only pay like $750 in taxes?</s>MOREAU: Here's the deal is that I would love to be able to comment on that. I don't know. And it's one of those situations where you and I can both sit and say if we made that kind of money, you know that you're going to play the tax game. It's set there for millionaires to be able to play this game.</s>REEVE: Would you want him to change it so that millionaires couldn't play that game?</s>MOREAU: Yeah, in the grand scheme of things it would be great.</s>REEVE: How do you think it's going so far?</s>PAUL BROWN, TRUMP SUPPORTER: As I expected it to go. Mr. Joe Biden is talking a lot of trash and lies. He's not being truthful with the American people.</s>REEVE: What made you cheer? Do you remember a moment?</s>BROWN: I guess when President Trump was talking about bringing out the details with the Biden crime family.</s>REEVE: So like when Trump was hitting him hard?</s>BROWN: Yeah.</s>REEVE: Have you ever watched a debate in a crowd like this before?</s>BROWN: Not like this, no.</s>REEVE: What do you think about it?</s>BROWN: It's pretty fun. I love it.</s>REEVE: Is there a moment that made you cheer?</s>JILL HENDRICKSON, TRUMP SUPPORTER: Yeah, everything that's coming out about how -- about Hunter Biden's computer. That was the best -- I saw that as a grand slam.</s>REEVE: How do you think the debate went tonight?</s>JEANIE QUIRAM, TRUMP SUPPORTER: Great. Absolutely wonderful. Trump nailed him.</s>REEVE: Well, what was your favorite moment?</s>QUIRAM: Just all of it. I thought it was absolutely the best debate by far and it was great. Trump 2020. Look at this baby, there he is.</s>DAWN NOWLIN, TRUMP SUPPORTER: I was really glad he brought up all the Biden/Hunter e-mails, or the -- excuse me, Hunter Biden emails. Let's get that right. I think he should have been more aggressive.</s>JOHN T. GRIFFIN, TRUMP SUPPORTER: John, I saw my number way up in the middle of the air, amen. Right?</s>REEVE: That was pretty good.</s>CROWD: Four more years! Four more years!</s>REEVE: And now to CNN's Jason Carroll with a view from the Biden side.</s>JASON CARROLL, CNN NATIONAL CORRESPONDENT (voice-over): Minutes after the debate ended, a group of Democratic supporters who were gathered for a socially distant backyard watch matter in a Mount Airy section of Philadelphia were ready to weigh in with their verdict. (on camera): Who felt as though vice president Joe Biden met or exceeded your expectations during the debate? Show of hands.</s>DAMON WALKER, BIDEN SUPPORTER: Four more years of Trump is not going to work in America.</s>CARROLL (voice-over): Damon Walker, a correctional officer and father of four, agrees with Jasmine Schley who says some of Vice President Biden's best moments came when he addressed the COVID-19 pandemic.</s>JASMINE SCHLEY, BIDEN SUPPORTER: When he talked about the families who have died because of coronavirus, it shows his humanity. And that's one thing that you never hear President Trump mention. He talks about the economy, he talks about his poll numbers, but he never takes the time to acknowledge the suffering of Americans.</s>WALKER: I believe he did what he needed to do, he answered all the questions and he stated the facts.</s>MACK DUNCAN, BIDEN SUPPORTER: He answered the questions, he had a plan. He explained it. That's it.</s>CARROLL: In this predominantly African-American middle class community, residents such as Billie Jo McKinney, a mom of five including a young son, says Biden's answer on race in America made an impact.</s>BILLIE JO MCKINNEY, BIDEN SUPPORTER: He shows compassion for all races and the story about him saying that he has never had to teach his daughter about holding her hands on the wheel, that's a big deal for me because I'm going to have to teach my six-year-old that and that's painful.</s>CARROLL: Also important for people like McKinney and Walker who, again, is a correctional officer, was to hear Biden's response to his past support of crime bills that resulted in high rates of incarcerating African-Americans for petty drug offenses.</s>BIDEN: It was a mistake.</s>WALKER: He answered the question by first apologizing.</s>MCKINNEY: He took accountability and he apologized immediately. Something we have not seen from our current administration.</s>CARROLL: Biden scored points on character and integrity with the group after hearing what he would say to those who do not support him.</s>BRIAN CLINTON, BIDEN SUPPORTER: Joe Biden when he said it's human decency, American values are on the ballot in November. I thought that -- that really spoke to me.</s>UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: Trump didn't answer that at all.</s>CARROLL: The watch party organized by city councilwoman, Cherelle Parker, a Democrat who says beyond tonight's performance, it's Biden the candidate who will ultimately drive supporters to the polls.</s>CHERELLE PARKER, PHILADELPHIA CITY COUNCILWOMAN: One of the things that I like about Joe Biden the most is what you see is what you get. And people from all walks of life know that they want a steady leader.</s>CARROLL: Jason Carroll, CNN, Philadelphia.</s>ANDERSON: We saw Elle in a town called Normal there in an election that is anything but, they. But hat's a look at the domestic front for you and we started on the international one. Well, next, we go super international as the International Space Station figures in this show, how this ties into the American election is up next. Plus, we are live in Istanbul where there are new warnings of potential terror attacks and kidnappings against Americans in Turkey. That is later here on CONNECT THE WORLD.
Marcus Rashford Promotes Grassroots Network to Feed Hungry.
ANDERSON: This week, we've been tracking Manchester's mayor going up against the British government and losing. But not so for Manchester United player Marcus Rashford. He is down but not out, dodging the government entirely to help feed kids in schools and promoting private companies like this cab company, who are willing to help feed them for free. Fair play to him on that. Christina Macfarlane is in the house for you. For those viewers who don't know the background to this story, just explain, if you will, Christina.</s>CHRISTINA MACFARLANE, CNN SPORTS CORRESPONDENT: I mean, this has been a long campaign for Marcus Rashford, hasn't it, Becky. We've seen him in the last three months pushing for food for underprivileged children in the U.K. I can tell you we've been watching his Twitter feed all morning and it's topping about 100 businesses now across the U.K. pledging their support to provide free meals during the school holidays. It's remarkable, Becky, that this young footballer just 22 has almost singlehandedly here started a movement and done what no politician in the U.K. has been able to do and he's done it with poise, dignity, a laser focus whilst being able to shine on the pitch for Manchester United. It is an incredible story and is still unfolding, this young player is quite exceptional.</s>ANDERSON: What a -- this is sort of a humanitarian we want to do more stories on, right? I know he wouldn't call himself a humanitarian, he's, you know, he would probably call himself just a really good lad and that is exactly what he is and an exceptional footballer to boot as well. I know you have a lot more on that coming up. We will be watching. We are going to take a short break. "WORLD SPORT" is up after that break. I will be back at the top of the hour for you with the second hour of CONNECT THE WORLD. Stay with us.
Biden, Trump Offer Starkly Different Visions In Final Debate; Trump: Coronavirus Pandemic Is China's Fault; Trump: The Air In Russia, China And India Is Filthy; Trump Mocks Biden For Empathy, Calls Him "Typical Politician"; Biden Slams Trump For Reaction To 1994 Crime Bill
ANNOUNCER: Live from CNN Abu Dhabi, this is "Connect the World" with Becky Anderson.</s>BECKY ANDERSON, CNN HOST: Good evening. A world of thugs and filthy countries, the final U.S. Presidential Debate reflecting little on America's place on the world stage. More so on Donald Trump's personal opinion of America's allies and foes. All this just 11 days away from one of the most consequential elections in U.S. history the outcome affecting not just Americans but all of us around the globe. While the final debate may have lacked the fire and theatrics of the first it did highlight a stark contrast in how Donald Trump and Joe Biden would handle major domestic and foreign affairs, whipping through toppings few from COVID to climate crisis it was a much more muted affair sort to speak with fewer interruptions allowing for a much more civilized discussion. As you would imagine, both Biden and Mr. Trump managed to land a couple punches. CNN's Jessica Dean wraps it all up for you.</s>JESSICA DEAN, CNN CORRESPONDENT: In the second and final presidential debate, President Donald Trump and Former Vice President Joe Biden clashed over the major issues. With fewer interruptions, the two candidates offered their final pitches to voters, including how they will combat Coronavirus on a day that saw one of the highest numbers of new U.S. cases since the crisis began. Still, the president repeated lies about the pandemic.</s>DONALD TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: It will go away. And as I say, we're rounding the turn. We're rounding the corner. It's going away.</s>JOE BIDEN (D), PRESIDENTIAL NOMINEE: 220,000 Americans dead. You hear nothing else I say tonight, hear this. Anyone who is responsible for not taking control. In fact, not saying I take no responsibility initially. Anyone who is responsible for that many deaths should not remain as President of the United States of America.</s>DEAN: Trump also used his own recent coronavirus diagnosis to downplay the severity of the disease.</s>TRUMP: I was in for a short period of time, and I got better very fast</s>BIDEN: He had nothing, he did virtually nothing. And then he gets out of the hospital and he talks about, "Don't worry. It's all going to be over soon." Come on. There's not another serious scientist in the world who thinks it's going to be over soon.</s>KRISTEN WELKER, NBC NEWS, CORRESPONDENT: President Trump, your reaction?</s>TRUMP: I didn't say over soon. I say we're learning to live with it. We have no choice. We can't lock ourselves up in a basement like Joe does.</s>DEAN: Biden condemning the Trump Administration's Coronavirus response and looked straight to camera, speaking directly to voters impacted by the pandemic.</s>BIDEN: You folks home will have an empty chair at the kitchen table this morning. That man or wife going to bed tonight and reaching over to try to touch there out of habit, where their wife or husband was, is gone. Learning to live with it? Come on, we're dying with it.</s>DEAN: The president continued to paint himself as a Washington outsider and Biden as a career politician while the Democratic Nominee aimed to depict Trump as a failed first-term president.</s>BIDEN: look, there's a reason why he's bringing up all this malarkey. There's a reason for it. He doesn't want to talk about the substantive issues. It's not about his family and my family. It's about your family, and your family's hurting badly.</s>WELKER: President, 10 seconds.</s>TRUMP: That's a typical political statement. Let's get off this China thing, and then he looks, "The family around the table, everything." Just a typical politician when I see that. I'm not a typical politician.</s>WELKER: Let's talk about North Korea now.</s>TRUMP: That's why I got elected.</s>DEAN: Trump criticized Biden's stands on fossil fuel in a move aim to hurt the former vice president in key swing states like Pennsylvania, Michigan and Ohio.</s>BIDEN: I have a transition from the old industry, yes.</s>TRUMP: Oh, that's a big statement.</s>BIDEN: I will transition. It is a big statement. Because the oil industry pollutes significantly.</s>TRUMP: Oh, I see.</s>BIDEN: Here's the deal-</s>TRUMP: That's a big statement.</s>BIDEN: Well if you let me finish the statement, because it has to be replaced by renewable energy over time, over time, and I'd stop giving to the oil industry, I'd stop giving them federal subsidies.</s>DEAN: On immigration, Biden called out the president on the 545 migrant children who have been separated from their parents.</s>BIDEN: What happened? Parents were ripped - their kids were ripped from their arms and separated, and now they cannot find over 500 of sets of those parents, and those kids are alone. Nowhere to go, nowhere to go. It's criminal.</s>TRUMP: They are so well taken care of. They're in facilities that were so clean.</s>WELKER: But some of them haven't been reunited with their families.</s>TRUMP: They have gotten such good - but just ask one question. Who built the cages?</s>DEAN: And when pressed on his record on race Trump made this claim.</s>TRUMP: I am the least racist person in this room. I can't even see the audience because it's so dark, but I don't care who's in the audience, I'm the least racist person in this room.</s>BIDEN: Abraham Lincoln here is one of the most racist presidents we've had in modern history. He pours fuel on every single racist fire, every single one.</s>ANDERSON: Well, that just some of what we heard last night. My next guest says he believes Mr. Trump delivered his best night of the entire campaign. Scott Jennings is in the house he is a Republican Strategist and CNN Political Commentator. It's a real pleasure to have you on, sir. According to the polls and I'd actually saw Biden as the clear winner. The debate, look, unlikely to move the needle not a lot anyway from the first debate the only difference was we could actually hear both of their answers this time. So I just wonder why you believe this was his best night in your opinion.</s>SCOTT JENNINGS, CNN POLITICAL COMMENTATOR: Well, as a first night of the campaign where we actually had a debate on actual issues. In the first debate the president had a disastrous performance because he never stopped talking. In this particular debate he had to stop, he had to listen, he had to think about who is going to prosecute the case on issues and time and again he did get Joe Biden on issues that I think play to the president's benefit. You mentioned energy earlier in the show just a second ago. That is going to help President Trump in Pennsylvania, Ohio, Texas which the Democrats are contesting so there were a lot of issues where we have actually get down to the nuts and bolts of who wants to do what it benefits Donald Trump. He didn't do that in the first debate. He did it last night. Hence, my idea that it was his best day.</s>ANDERSON: OK. He did revert to teeing up Hunter Biden and the scandal, failed arguably to make any impact with that. Do you believe we're still waiting for the so-called October surprise at this point?</s>JENNINGS: No. And the way we vote in the United States now over a month period makes it unlikely that an October surprise could dramatically change the election. Plus, one key thing that's different about this race, people don't hate Joe Biden. His image is pretty good. In the 2016 election, Hillary Clinton had a very negative image and so they weren't willing to give her the benefit of the doubt says when the Comey letter came out 11 days before the election. Biden has got more protection against that because people trust him and like him more than Hillary Clinton. So, an October surprise I think is unlikely to affect this race the way it did against Hillary in 2016.</s>ANDERSON: Coronavirus, though, is expected to affect or have affected this race because, of course, 50 million people have already voted. The first question from the moderator was how will you handle the next COVID phase, yet Donald Trump failed to lay out any policies, circling back to this old nugget. Have a listen.</s>TRUMP: I take full responsibility. It's not my fault that it came here. It's China's fault.</s>ANDERSON: Joe Biden did lay out policy including masks and restrictions. He didn't go so far as to suggest the nationwide lockdown. I wonder how you justify Trump as the winner of that exchange, if indeed you do.</s>JENNINGS: Well, I don't know that he won that exchange because his job approval on that particular topic was very low. But I do think it was the crispest defense of his administration's actions that he's given in the campaign so far and he mentioned vaccines which is central to the Trump plan.</s>JENNINGS: So I'm not under any illusion that Donald Trump is going to win on Coronavirus and people to think that's the top issue but for one night he actually did give I thought a crisp coherent defense on that particular topic.</s>ANDERSON: Yes, that's interesting, Scott. You say Republicans are reassured by this Trump performance. By which you mean what, I wonder?</s>JENNINGS: Well, in the public opinion polls here there's a difference between Donald Trump's job approval and what he is getting on the ballots and a lot of those voters are Republican suburban voters who like all of Donald Trump's policies but they don't like his style or his communication ways. Last night he reminded them why they voted for him in the first place because they know deep down even though he is not the kind of Republican they're used to -- he does executes the policies they like. I heard from a number of Republican consultants last night who were breathing a sigh of relief that he may have actually help to save a couple of Senate seats because he reminded voters that at its core the Republican Party is better on policy. So, I think for those Republican wobbly voters in the suburbs, reminding them on policy especially on economic policy was a good for Trump to do right here at the end.</s>ANDERSON: Yes. You made a really good point here because it is not just the president who is up for re-election if indeed that is what happens. There are an awful lot of congressmen out there who are also up for re-election. Perhaps that may be more consequential to some degree going forward but although with Donald Trump around. He is of consequence if indeed he is re- elected. Scott, it is a pleasure having you on. Come again. Thank you.</s>JENNINGS: Thank you.</s>ANDERSON: The Republican view there of last night's debate. Still ahead on the show, we'll get the take of one Democrat, a Strategist who worked on Hillary Clinton's 2016 campaign so do stick around for that. Let's talk through two other major topics that are affecting us around the world this hour COVID and climate. Both are linked and both on what happens in America does affect all of us. Have a listen to Mr. Trump and Joe Biden.</s>TRUMP: It will go away. And as I say, we're rounding the turn. We're rounding the corner. It's going away.</s>BIDEN: This is the same fellow who told you, "This is going to end by Easter" last time. This is the same fellow who told you that, "Don't worry, we're going to end this by the summer." We're about to go into a dark winter, a dark winter and he has no clear plan.</s>ANDERSON: And I think it is important to get a quick fact check hire. The U.S. is not rounding the corner at present not the only place is not rounding the corner because, of course, there is a second wave, particularly blighting Europe but that wasn't true when Donald Trump said that. The country's Coronavirus situation is measured by newly confirmed cases, hospitalizations and test positivity rate is getting worse, not better. Senior Medical Correspondent Elizabeth Cohen joining me now. Donald Trump once again teased a vaccine within weeks. This is what he said last night.</s>TRUMP: We have a vaccine that's coming. It's ready. It's going to be announced within weeks and it's going to be delivered. We have Operation Warp Speed, which is the military is going to distribute the vaccine.</s>ANDERSON: Elizabeth, you and I have discussed this headline many, many times over the past weeks and months, in fact. It seems to be that tomorrow that never comes but Donald Trump did list a few companies saying they're in good shape. What is the story on vaccines?</s>ELIZABETH COHEN, CNN SENIOR MEDICAL CORRESPONDENT: Well, let's take them one at a time. So he said that Johnson & Johnson is doing very well. Now Johnson & Johnson, their trial only on in the United States for about two and a half weeks before they went on a pause because of a participant became ill. So it is hard to say that trial - they have been going well for two and a half weeks but obviously needs to go on a lot longer. So they're not really close to getting any results because they were only up for two and a half weeks and now they're on a pause. Then he also mentioned Pfizer and Moderna, those trials are going better. Those trials are - have been going on since the end of July and those two companies say they're optimistic that they will have results late November, in December, depends which one you're talking to but there's and that may be true but there is a huge but here and I can't emphasize this enough Becky. Those results might not look good. They might have early trial results, but those results could say the vaccine doesn't work so we just have to wait and see. And I think Americans want this to be slower because people aren't trusting the vaccine so when he talks about how quickly it is going to happen I think that actually works to his own detriment, to everyone's determent it makes people nervous this is going too fast and that the vaccine won't be safe enough. Becky?</s>ANDERSON: The FDA has now given full approval for the drug Remdesivir. That is despite the W.H.O. saying it has little or no effect on mortality for hospitalized patients.</s>ANDERSON: When I saw this FDA approval. I was really quite surprised. We have been having this discussion with the W.H.O. on Remdesivir specifically for some time now. Why is there disconnect do you think, on this information?</s>COHEN: There is disconnect Becky because we are talking about different studies. So when the FDA gave an Emergency Use Authorization for Remdesivir back in May it was based on a study that showed not that it saves lives, no one have ever claimed really officially that it saves lives but that it saved a few days off of a hospital stay, like about four days off a hospital stay. But then a W.H.O. study came up that said, no, it doesn't. It doesn't save time off a hospital stay and it also doesn't cut down on mortality, it doesn't save lives. But the FDA says, look, we look at the data given that were given and they gave a full approval. So basically, you have sort of these dueling studies. Gilead which makes Remdesivir will tell you, oh, this W.H.O. study there are some things that should be looked at here. They will poke holes in it. Other people will say no, the W.H.O. study was well done. It was certainly larger than the original study. So, you really have sort of dueling epidemiologists here but that's why you have that disconnect.</s>ANDERSON: Elizabeth Cohen, thank you. Well, a pandemic is shown us how precariously we are perched here on earth and how we have to live in and with the natural world, isn't it? It's almost like the climate crisis at super speed. Yet another issue where the candidates as ever couldn't find common ground it's terrible, it is happening. We cannot wish it away Mr. Trump though still thinks his decision to pull out of the Paris Climate Accord was the right one to make. It will be no surprise to that Joe Biden disagrees but even his articulation of a different vision for getting out of the climate crisis didn't go over so well. Have a listen.</s>BIDEN: I have a transition from the old industry, yes.</s>TRUMP: Oh, that's a big statement.</s>BIDEN: I will transition. It is a big statement.</s>TRUMP: That's a big statement.</s>BIDEN: Because I would stop.</s>WELKER: Why would you do that?</s>BIDEN: Because the oil industry pollutes, significantly.</s>TRUMP: Oh, I see.</s>BIDEN: Here's the deal-</s>TRUMP: That's a big statement.</s>BIDEN: Well if you let me finish the statement, because it has to be replaced by renewable energy over time, over time, and I'd stop giving to the oil industry, I'd stop giving them federal subsidies.</s>ANDERSON: Well, that was Joe Biden last night. Those comments I have to say lit up social media. So, after the debate Mr. Biden took a bit of a back step.</s>BIDEN: Get rid of the subsidies for fossil fuels but we're not getting rid of fossil fuels for a long time.</s>ANDERSON: There you go. Let's bring in our Chief Climate Correspondent Bill Weir who's just written a piece for CNN Digital under the headline "How the debate on the climate crisis ricocheted from planet earth to planet Trump" by which you meant what? What did you make of that slight backtrack by Joe Biden, by the way?</s>BILL WEIR, CNN CHIEF CLIMATE CORRESPONDENT: Becky, only in America is this statement remotely controversial while the rest of the world is being pushed by market forces and mortality to reckon with our energy system and the damage it's now doing on real time. Only on planet Trump is it not happening and ever since Hillary Clinton lost coal mining communities four years ago. The Biden Campaign is very careful not to scare off frackers in Pennsylvania but it's much more controversial there. It is not this fracking wonderland that it's painted by some in that party. It is very divisive in that state. The bloom is off that rose for some people were very excited about it early on. And Methane as a heat-trapping gas is much more damaging in the short term than carbon dioxide. So when Joe Biden says he tries to ease the political fears that have been sort of infused in this country that it's going to take a lot of time. There is not a lot of time. He wants to de-carbonize the electrical grid in just 15 years in the whole country by 2050 and that means massive efforts starting yesterday.</s>ANDERSON: Yes, absolutely. Well, the president referred to many countries air quality as filthy last night. Have a listen.</s>TRUMP: Look at China, how filthy it is, look at Russia, look at India, it's filthy, the air is filthy.</s>ANDERSON: Clean air is the tag line of any or many discussions on climate by the president. He also makes claims last night. The U.S. has the cleanest air and water, is that true?</s>WEIR: No, I think we're ranked somewhere 15, 16 on the list and its going - it is getting worse since Trump's EPA was dismantled basically by former fossil fuel lobbyists there. He doesn't seem to realize that the reason the air and water in the United States is cleaner, it didn't used to be. It used to be the air in Los Angeles looked like Beijing and the rivers in the Midwest looked like those in India. But then the environmental protection agency and the "Clean Air and Water Act" all which is being gutted and rolled back under President Trump and he conflates pollution at ground level with the heat-trapping gases up there like a dog in a car on a hot summer day. We're the dog.</s>ANDERSON: Climate crisis is what Bill knows better than most. Bill, thank you for that, a bountiful green background behind you on such an important beat thank you for connecting us to it more from Bill on this show going forward, believe me. You are watching CONNECT THE WORLD. Still to come, the U.S. issues an emergency warning for Americans in Turkey. I'm going to get you the details on what's been called a credible threat and indeed we'll get you the reaction to it. And a prison fire in Lagos is the latest escalation of unrest in Nigeria.
U.S. Election Will Have Global Effects.
ANDERSON: This hour we have been looking at the state of America following the final presidential debate, specifically the politics of hope versus the politics of fire. From the outside looking in it can seem chaotic and for many at times quite frankly tiring. Imagine how it feels for those actually living through it. At the end of the day folks this election will send shockwaves across the globe. America, after of all, is the most powerful country in the world. Who wins the election could determine the future of its place in the world and how it leads on the global stage? While international issues such as North Korea and Russia were discussed at the last Presidential Debate, we saw next to no foreign policy actually laid out. Nic Robertson has covered effects of U.S. foreign policy in every part of the world. He joins us now from London. This is an important time, isn't it? I mean, there will be leaders around the world who will be interested or would have been interested to hear what both candidates' positions are when it comes to U.S. foreign policy. This is the last time both candidates came head to head. What did we learn?</s>NIC ROBERTSON, CNN INTERNATIONAL DIPLOMATIC EDITOR: You know, we have learned that President Trump still has the ability to as Vice President Biden said during the debate to put his finger in the eye of allies by describing India's air is dirty they were in the boat with the Indian Prime Minister is an important strategic ally of United States right now. Why, because the tensions are growing with China. So that was an oddity but again I think the sort of - when I say oddity, world leaders have been able to watch President Trump for four years. They know what he is like. I don't think there were any surprises today. And they know what Vice President Biden was like because he had eight years as vice president to Barack Obama particularly on foreign policy so perhaps no surprises there. I think where people will have been watching keenly, economy is important to everyone. Every world leader knows that how they handle COVID determines how well their economy and how quickly their economy can recover and how badly it is affected? So to hear Vice President Biden put forward an offer of a plan and an idea and a way out that's different to the way that President Trump is handling it with a high death rate that the United States is having would be indicative to some world leaders to be able to say. OK, look perhaps this guy Biden is going to be at a sort of - get out of this faster, get the U.S. economy back on track. And of course, that's so - because the U.S. economy is so important globally that's a key issue.</s>ANDERSON: Yes, Joe Biden accusing Trump of cozying up with thugs and poking his finger at friends when discussing the president's relationships with America's foes and allies, even going as far as to say this, Nic.</s>BIDEN: We had a good relationship with Hitler before he, in fact, invaded Europe.</s>ANDERSON: What do you make of those comments?</s>ROBERTSON: You know Vice President Biden is not above saying things that can sound you know, perhaps, perhaps off putting to some people. There are slips that he makes for sure. You know? I think the point that he was making there was, you know, President Trump's made a friend out of Kim Jong-un in North Korea. And you know is no good President Trump saying hey, we got along great. I mean, look, listen to what the U.S. defense expert said last week. They said that look at the new ballistic missile that North Korea is been able to develop. That's under President Trump. You know? There's a sense that President Trump has been played by Kim Jong- un. Kim Jong-un has played for time. Joe Biden said I'll only sit down with Kim Jong-un if he guarantees, you know, getting rid of his nuclear weapons. So they're very different positions but I think what he was trying to say there was President Trump, there's no point in saying that Kim Jong-un seems OK because you don't know what is going to happen around the corner.</s>ROBERTSON: And he is making every move at the moment under the Trump Administration to continue to develop nuclear weapons and to continue to develop ballistic missiles capable of reaching the United States carrying those weapons even to the point of putting them on public and international display at a big parade just last week so I think that's Biden's point there.</s>ANDERSON: Finally, Joe Biden not last night but in a town hall just a week or so ago was asked whether he would concede to agreeing and this was a member of the audience, agreeing with this member of the audience when they said that Donald Trump has had some foreign policy successes. And the normalization agreement between Israel, the UAE and Bahrain, for example, was one of the issues that this audience member brought up. And Joe Biden actually said, look, a little bit. You know? I would concede that he's had a little bit of success and I'm just being told as we speak that Sudan, in fact, has announced that it's just normalized with Israel. If anything, there is some success out there for Donald Trump, isn't there?</s>ROBERTSON: Yes. I think we have just heard from the State Department, as well, if I read the emails crossing just a couple minutes ago correctly. The State Department taking Sudan off the list of state sponsors of terror. So yes, you know? There have been some successes. There is no doubt about it. And I think you there's an understanding and view around the world particularly amongst the United States allies and particularly here in Europe that China's trade practices violate international norms. You know they want access to intellectual property, they want to have Chinese business partners and this is something that also Vice President Biden said that he wouldn't put up with either. So there's a sense that, yes, Trump's got it right on some issues is the way that he said about it that I think has made it hard for a lot of world leaders to stomach because there has been a lot - there has been consequential knock-on effects. It has been erratic and hasn't brought allies together. That's what Vice President Biden says there he will do. You know President Trump again was trumpeting he will what he's been able to get out of NATO over the past few years during this administration.</s>ANDERSON: I just want our viewers to get a little bit more of what you and I are discussing here. But specifically, what we have just broken on air while you and I have been discussing. Sudan and Israel agreed to normalize relations. This according to the White House, and let me just give you specifically what we have here? President Donald Trump announcing Friday that Sudan and Israel have agreed to normalize relations of foreign policy win for the incumbent president less than two weeks before the U.S. presidential election. This from the White House Spokesperson Judd Deere on Twitter, "President Donald Trump has announced that Sudan and Israel have agreed to normalize relations, another major step towards building peace in the Middle East with another nation joining the Abraham Accords". This announcement coming shortly after the White House said that he had informed congress of his intent to remove Sudan from the state sponsor of terrorism list. This is something that you confirmed that you saw from the State Department just before you and I started talking. The rescission of that 27-year-old designation was widely seen as being tied to this deal with Israel. And this deal with Israel, Sudan is brokered by the U.S., a classic case of transactional foreign policy by the U.S. President, Donald Trump, Nic.</s>ROBERTSON: Yes. And a lot of people actually in the region would say that Jared Kushner, his son-in-law, his Special Expert on the Middle East, has really played the major and significant role behind the scenes that President Trump has really only sort of got involved at the last minute. It certainly what Trump was looking for, he has been looking for international foreign policy win. And he'll certainly chalk this up as that and I think for some people you know they will see that President Trump has succeeded in the Middle East where other presidents have failed. Of course what he hasn't been able to do is to bring a lasting peaceful solution between Israel and the Palestinians and that's, you know, would have been the really big goal and the really big thing to achieve. But that's not to undermine what has been achieved now because whoever becomes president next, whether it's President Trump with another four years or Vice President Biden, what's been achieved will be built on in terms of that relationship between the United Arab Emirates and Israel, between Bahrain and Israel, between Sudan and Israel. This is this is going to change and reflect differently on how the Middle East is viewed? END